DBXIcoverI DB Launch - Doing Business€¦ · VWÙÚeÛ“”ÜÝÞfl‘ 11 ‚ßà ¡¢£⁄X`...
Transcript of DBXIcoverI DB Launch - Doing Business€¦ · VWÙÚeÛ“”ÜÝÞfl‘ 11 ‚ßà ¡¢£⁄X`...
© 2010 1818 H Street NW Washington, D.C. 20433
1 2 3 4 08 07 06 05
��������� ���������������������� !"#$%&'��(
)*+,-.�/012�34���"#56��������789:;<�
�����
��������=>?@�A�BCDEFGHI+JK�����LM+:LNOP&@Q4R���
STJU,VW���XYZ[\]^_FG�����LM`a�
b�cd^_ef+Ff�����ghLM`aXij��9k78�limnoCopyright Clearance Center Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USApqro978-750-8400pJso978-750-4470ptuowww.copyright.com�
�vwx�Ay`�@Q�A+EN��@,z{|Xi}{ Office of the Publisher, The World Bank, 1818 H Street NW, Washington, DC 20433, USApJso202-522-2422pq~��[email protected]�
�N������o�2011 �����VWo�������������2010 �����VWoy����������2009 �����VW���2008 �����VW���2007 �����VWobh�����2006 �����VWo�����[���2005 �����VWo���������2004 �����VWo �¡¢£¤�X��t¥owww.doingbusiness.org�
¦Cli§00[¨©ª���M«78�
§0f¬
�2011 �����VW��®¡¢£¤bh�¯+°G��±²�³��´VWµ�¶·¸VW�¹VWº»@Q��4£H¼A5½�®¾¿ÀXÁ¿
ÀNÃy�vÄÅÆÇÈÉÊËÌ� 183 ¸CÍÎÏÐ�ÑÒXÓ�Ôº»¿Ày$%�Ð`�Õ¾Ö×�Ø
VWÙÚeÛ��ÜÝÞ�` 11 ¸ßà�¡¢£¤XÁ 11 ¸ßà�oáâ���âãäåEN6�æçè¼�éê7ë�5½ìíî�ïð�ñ0òó�(Ø
ôÓ�Qõ���éêqöH÷øùå�,µéêqöH÷øùåúûü@�v
y�2011 �����VW����ýþ´��µ�Ø
�2011 �����VW�µ�úû��� 2010 � 6 ����úû�VWµ�¿Àø�M CÍ��Ã� ��Â��@��y����m� ��Ã��
��@��Ø
�2011 �����VW�µ÷øùå¿À����4@��Õ���úû���
v
1
12
18
2009 2010 42
52
http://www.doingbusiness.org
—— 1 183 http://www.doingbusiness.org/Rankings
2011 2004 http://www.doingbusiness.org/Reforms
2004 http://www.doingbusiness.org/Custom-Query
http://www.doingbusiness.org/Methodology http://www.doingbusiness.org/Research
http://www.doingbusiness.org/Reports
http://www.doingbusiness.org/ Subnational-Reports
http://www.doingbusiness.org/Law-libraryhttp://wbl.worldbank.org
183 8200 http://www.doingbusiness.org/Local-Partners/Doing-Business
(Business Planet)
http://rru.worldbank.org/businessplanet
v
y$¸��±ö���L�µX��[� ìíX�����["º!ܼöX
Á"���L�O#$�%�&'�m("�z)º»*+��[��,&�
-.����� �:��%�&'�34�/�$0��XyÁ0��
µ$� 18 1�23+45�6Á"�o789X:;<@=å/X��å/>�?d@��L�O#��AA"<5,&NÃMB���CDX�cdE
F$G¡¢��X@@Hö�@CI~�JKîXL z)�MN+GObhX
>O#�â��XÓ�@��O#�ìí"éê��XÄP��*+���[�Ø
�2011 �����VW��®¡¢£¤bh�¯+°G��±²�³��´VWµ�¶·¸�¹VWº»@Q��4£H¼A5½�®¾¿ÀXQÚ�vÄ
ÅÆÇÈÉÊËÌ� 183 ¸CÍÎ�VWµ�úû��� 2010 � 6 ����úû�Ø
�����VW��$¸R�º�XCͱ²dS@TC�£¤AA,UV
�oO#<FH�W¼A"XYZ[�\��pº!CÍ]K�N^_MX�ô
Ó`aº»<%M"bcAþ�dø�eÀ��G%�¡¢£¤f��@���
�@&>NÃ@ø�X"g�hiPý�jä�������VW�k$º»
ÒC¼AHìíî5½�ßànlÒ!�MúXÑbyQm�nó�78op
�q@*rs�dS�Ø
�����VW�td��0`µuv���34X®ÁÂ��ÜÝÞ�/¸
wx�yø�4£�VWyz¸ßà�4£R{|k/CÍÎ���XÁz¸
ßà�oáâ���âãäåEN6�æçè¼�éê7ë�5½ìíî�ïð�
ñ0òó�(ôÓHQõ���}~XVWÔº» ÷øùå4£�úûÃ�
$�@Qéêqö���M¿À�
�����VW�yQÚ��|@�°M�VW#Äk¸�[��´��4£�
��H��X�#®k��Hìíî@eÛ+kCÍÎ�Zö@eÛ����
���@�q�VW�e�������ß�&H1�G%$¸��\�
�*j�ûX"�����4£H��bheÛCÍ��º»á��úûXÁÂ
CÍ���vܼö�ìí��;��������H%���
Y�Á¿ÀX�����VW�����/���4£�Õ¾Xç�
� 2004 �ÃK� 1500 +0�d���y: ¡¢HCÍ£��¤¥�X:���1�G%k��¨q���4£���Xy©Âßà���]´ª�
ÑÃ*«�
Á¬§�ö$@&)º� $Â{|o��@�ÂeÛ®: ��4£@
�Â�Õ®ÁÂ�Õk��H/CÍί¼Ü ��eÛ®�2011 �����VW��°±ÁÂ{|º» ��úûHm²�²yy�Ðñ´*��úûR
{|X2011 ��VW³� $¸��®�4XK(´µ¸CÍÎ���¡¢����2006 �����VW�mËÃK� 5 ��Ð`@�¶k·¸|��Õ�¹®¿À���ýþ´¹��º» º�XJîÃ�����VW�
"�µ��@,zCÍÎ�R_®µ¸CÍÎy/0¿À|��»×�Ø
��´����þø *���Ðñ´X,µk¼§�½¾Hµ¿�À��4
£�����Á´ $ÂÂ&SÃ����ÄÁ���¸á[�ÅÆVW�Ð
vi 2011 �������
ñ´���XÃ�,zúû���²Xj@��&ùH1�G%îk��¡¢
µ�Â4£@��bh@�Ã����@�� �êÈǯXBK�å/jØ
Â&Ȳ�
�����VW�º»�úûHR_¿ÀO#É´Êy�ËÌX"ÍÎ\�î
�ÄhDNÃÏÐC�ÑÒXÓ}�Ä 2003 �8ÔmËÃK�Èm @Q1��Õ �� 2003 �ÃKX/012VW@ 270 +0��4£���yÖÈ�����VW��×m+Ø�J���ÙLM��x�*ÚÛ�ìí��
��ÜÝXÞy�¯CÍ�ZöXßbyàáÑ¿�âã¿HþÑä¿�
����/012�������G%���å�XZZ@ø+¸úûKæHØ
¿À���îcdk+¸þ�çQ�Hþ���/�°fXP�@ÁÂ�q>
y1�Õ µº� �d�{|Ã�z)�è�Qé�{|�����Ô
�ìí��{|ê/012(ákrXÞyST12^ëM�@øÁÂúûX
º!ëìOöXíîïð��ñ�º!�0y�����VW�µ���XØ
"ST���ìí���ÚÛ���
�����VW�� �å/êÈ 8200 +ò/0ó��Ùöô¬Xü@z)�ó�·�HõöÍÎX�#NO9�Á=VW�ÁÂó��vR÷���ø
}ù{�[Ü÷�úû-ã&�12üùÃ�,zó�&ýXz)yVWÙÚ
� 183 ¸CÍεCZþk�Q�4RH¡¢dSá(å/+º»ø}·���VW� ���dUN��º»úû�Ã�: /��o�ã0�R÷*�
�p �â�0�R÷*��p þR÷*��pIus Laboris �å�����þH��¡R÷*��m�p���[Ü÷*��p�s���4ýR÷Ø
�[pLex Mundi �FR÷*��m�p��¿R÷*��pÛ¿����p��� [Ü÷*��p��� 4R!�p"#$0�t%pSDV 0��&��pH Toboc Inc.�
�'$�KX��/012H\��·�HÍÎ�@�0eé�()�
VW� ���dUN��ËRï4*�àáÑ¿�+��,0��,-�Ø
./à�012H34512XÓ�z)º» @Q��4£���eÛ�q
�6Ü78X7~XÔd�� 60 +¸0��12º» 2009–2010 ���4£���8Î78�
�VW�����å/&ù���� ���������/�ÀL�
�/t%��@Ó*��VWº»�ÍÎ�
��AA0�¡¢9:
¡¢ê��L�m(t%t¢;�
<¼=U¼Ø $>
1
y: ¡¢HCÍ£�¤¥�X��
/��\�î)y�'$�µ?Ð@
äX������áâHC���*
�ýþ����Á$IA�d�td
B�!CDCÍÎ�¡¢£�XÅJ
EÕ�CÍ£�XFGÈ*+�0
��2009 �� 2010 �ÐX��/����!�ÖÈ ¡¢HCÍ£��e
Û�H¢@ÂCÍÎÖÈ�IJÑ,
zCÍÎ*ÙXÄáâHC����
�óK´Ã�4LHM¼KN�O�
!YXNO[eÛÈ��fk£��
Px�,QR��S�]´�Ø
2009 � 6 �� 2010 � 5 �ÐX117 ¸CÍÎ�12j 216 0��4£��X����áâHC��
T�´��¯Hè¼Aþ�ǯÃ�
��Z[�\HM¼KN�O�º!
�� ýþ����yÁÂ1�M�
�µXUúÃ|��!�áâ���
�òó�ïð�� *�ýþ���
VW�¨ 1.1X�ØYÎk 183 ¸CÍÎ�R_¾
M �¿ÀX�����VW�Z�
����t[\�Q4£áâHC
�µu����óK´�VWÃê�
��Q�Ó]��ûX�®"^�y
0`��Vtd�µu��X�_Ý
Þ�`�yø4£�Õ¾Ö×�VW�
ó` 1.1X��®H^���Èm Ø80 +¸CÍÎá(1�Ùa X@ê
*+��áBk/¸CÍε��¨
q�¡¢4£�bhÓCÍ���m
³�(á��1������VW��
b�º�oCͱ²cdT�g�
/��ã��TC£¤�Ø
�����VW�"#ÙÚÓ�
��Q��@d]Xßboc�#d
efgCÍh��R{iä��²Ø
jO+�:»×X�#dekl¡¢
»×+¡¢³6�jöXPÁmî
!�Qnd]X@Î�op: ¡¢
£��$Âb�qÓ�Ä�Xb�
��¡¢T�g!�XOrêÈ�[
�#sNOÐ\�Q³+UNtSX
;£CÍßà�@NOá(*+CÍ
±²XPCͱ²Or*+�á(�
^ 1.1
2009 2010
::::::::4_)`ab+,/0.1�cdefQ:gh(i�jk(lmnopqr�stuvw�xy*T2006 ������U=z&Q:
2005 2011 2011
0 20 40 60 80
T������Uef{Q|}9
~9
�� 1.19
keÛ��_ÝÞ�` 9 ¸ßà�4£�deHR_M �u¿À��v���
ýþ´¹Î����ûXÁ 9 ¸ßà�oáâ���âãäåEN6�æçè¼�
éê7ë�5½ìíî�ïð��ñ0òó�(ôÓÃ�Qõ���}~XØ
�����VW�Ô�w÷øùåHéêqöV$¸��E�|eX�qVmî!B
ïDv��¹Î��X�4£1�Ø
�����VW�C� x«úûH¿Ào$«�74RêM¿À?Xb@Qìí
î5½HYy&êëy&4RAþ�¿ÀX�©q4RH4£h�º» $G®Ø
À_�©Âßà�è¼AHìíî5½ö´*ÙXbkQm�nó�opdS*r
sX�����VW�n��Mú�z!p7$«�7�ÐHû¿À?Xb@Qá
â���æçè¼HâãäåEN6��¿À�Á¿ÀÄ��t��´Xç�bû
�Q¡¢£%9�${nó�c�KN��ÐH��X�P�®¡¢eÀj²�K�
�OHF|K´���ê~L�Q�qVÑb12��XÏÐ�gh}²>~/$¸
KN�yü�C�piyø�Ö×�X¤R�ÁÂpi�ç��~���@Q���
��VW����4���Z�XiW�úû���Ø
1. ���o�5��������������'�E�������Y�-Q������5��Z����5�Q���1 (¡¢d��5��£¤Q¥T2010 �������U=�¦�§�¨©O 10 Z�5�!ªf(«4¬®q¯�QO 9 Z°y!ªf�±��²�¨©�¯³¡¢´ 1.2(RSµq¢¶T������U·¸:¹http://www.doingbusiness.org):Q
2 2011 �������
NOÐ\�@þ�4£HðCG´�
� 2003 ������VW�0eײ
ÃKX:�� 75% Ã|CÍÎ�\�
î)�C�y;£L�áâ����
*�ýþ������á(�$0Ø
��@ø �'·�ÐÄ 100 ¸CÍ
Î��æçL�C��úû���m
²XE@!����æç³6�CÍ
ÎX�!P�,���DO*!X��
�´*Ù2�Ø
Á�q�bÈ�Ó&@Q³�CÍ
£��.�X����H�¬²@��
®ÑÃ]gh��>�d�2009 �X
:����&'5È 2 .12 �XÑ 2007 �£�áB��Ç 3400 �3�
;�b}X������ :��
\�îå/��µÏ��ÅÆ$�~
CÍ�È�åjäJ�9�^~��
�è1CD��X/012e��
dø*5�ô�9�*+�å/�Ó
}X��uv����y�����
q�Êö�Q�d�
µuv��<j8@�����
�ÙÊö�yCô��!CDCÍÎ
`Xµu������¹ú� 95%X,y��&úµ���Ñß� 60–70%XPy�þ�µ0���H�0�Á«
CÍεX,y��&úµ���Ñ
ߪ�5È 60%–80%4�Ó}X\�
î)@ã�Íεuv����XP
��,¡¢����ô¬c)���Ø
Ï$�Ø
Ãâã¿ï��k (Nakuru) �
� (Bedi) !�@°9:�ß5�y
$�U�СSÄ�0Ù�¢
£¤¥�¦Ï$Uó� (Tesco) éê§
¨ø©�ªiÏJX��' ÇD
,: »f«��[��¬|%�Ø
®�=nú¯�X�G% 9��
ÜÝXÄú�°±²y³'�ú��
·�=È5�0XÄ�Cs´ XØ
Ó���µ¨$¶å/�C�·�k
4£HKN�¸�O#@Î���
òó&Y�Ù��XÄPNÃ@¹b
�Á"�9:QR���[�
2009–2010
�'$�ÐXk�¡S����¡¢
���\�î)P�X,å/�IÓ
�À�#ÓP@�#Ó�Ø
: £�Øm/CÍÎ� 2009–2010 �
ÐÙöj 4RHG´���þkM
¼Hº�Z[ú®�#ì�ÇX16 ¸
CÍÎVÙLM�½¾Hµ¿�ÀØ
CÍÎÃ�Cô��!CDCÍÎXØ
�� ,M¼G´XÁÂCÍÎ�v
Ñþ��»�¼2þ�¯��,0�
"�ã¿�/�2��0H½"�¾
0�V. ¿À¿X6�CÍÁD��Ï�X
Â,cd!��4LHM¼KNXÃ
<5í¼\]êÈ��ÃÄXP#�
�°Åy4L�yÁ$ßà���+
úÆö�9�+ØD��KNXÃ<
5@ÜÆö���O#¦§C��Ø
ÃXÇ@M¼��È@ÜÆöXk
c)�º�pÉy½¾Hµ¿�E
+CÍεÊ��Ë�Ì4�bûØ
�����VW��Ü~��X��
À��!V#Tº�X°CO� 33%XÁ$I"#ÍÎ�Cô��!CDC
ÍÎ��!°CO� 69% �Ø?Ð\]²$Ï�½¾Hµ¿
�À�$ÙUI�bû�����Ø
VW��deX2004 �ÃKX��
À�\�î)yj��4£��
�q$Ï�±Ð��'$�KXÁ
�q�Ñb}X��À 25 ¸CÍÎ
µ@ 21 ¸V� 84%Xj ��4£���� 9�M¼KNX�áâ
��Hïð��*ýþ����ËÌ
4AA��ÀÒ�ÓMÏ$�CÍÎ
yÁx�q!j ���y7ë7
8³6�,c�qX��ö´�kd
uÂ�#�X�� 2004 �ÃKyÁ�qj Ø36 0��X7ë78³6�Õê*Ç9�X,y�&µ��!Q
ÚOÄ 3% º!È 30%�Ø
´ 1.1
2009–2010
|}9����:ef{Q
^ 1.2
2009–2010 75%
84
75
67
63
61
59
47
T������Uef{Q|}9
º» 3
�ÀV6 ¸CÍÎXá(��Àà$
ξ³² ,µLM��X$Â��
�Ô�L�Õ¾Qm��²@��á
(�½L�Õ�Àj�Ö�i$¢
G@äÇ« 345H×Ø5ÏÐ�
��]´�âã¿�ÙÚã¿H×Ø
5¾QL�Êy@ø#Ó�q~úû
³6XÄ@Q�q;ö�Á³6
EF6$�q�46 ¸ÛܼÃ��Õ
�ÀCÍε� 27 ¸�j 49 0
�������
µ½HÝ��À 18 ¸CÍε�Ø11 ¸�j 22 0��4£��X
Ô@ 6 ¸�� ¾QP§H³'iä
Ã�ýòóHÞô0�À_�dSX
ÁÂ0��vÊß�+�HÅmà�Ø
: /CÍÎAA# �ãòÄHC
Dá�bhX,\�î!?ø jâ
³6K������XXYnó��X
ºãT�´��'$�µX¼§HÇ
äÑ�À@ 47% �CÍÎj ��
4£��X25 0��µX23 0h¾ 1KN��h¾KNXA+CÍÎ
!ØD t|KNX+Y�q~³6
@#Ó�����5¬Óå�Y�Á
$�4XÊ/��þ�23+4H.
/àh¾ ��áâKNXàáÑ¿
�æ äåEN°GXãǼ3��
ñ0òó���Ø
�¿�À 8 ¸CÍε� 5 ¸j
��V� 7 0��XXf´¦§
9�,�E��q~æç³6XDE
��yt|ôçf ð�k¸½¾�
À!jä ¾�@QST@øq~³
6�£%XÄPØm $³�Õ¾X
b¼è�¿HFéê?ø q~¾Q
³6�Ø
Ä: 3XyCô��!CDCÍÎ
��aó�ÛܼÃ��Õ�ÀH
�¿�À���t����Xyv
��7��ýþ´?��ëµ���
�@ 9 ¸��¡¢ßàX,¼A�Ö
È�5½�ìíVW�¨ 1.3X���´X�Çîy7��ýþ´?
��µÊï8òXÅJ�µ0ð³
UN1À��/��f¹�§0�
ñ��Ç�Ù�ò��ó4�HôÙ
þ¿VW�. 1.2X�ÄÁÂ��õ�0�Êy���Xy��Ø25 ò�CÍεX@ 18 ¸y�'$�µ�� ������� 25 ò�CÍεX#ö�������ÙX,�
�Ķ 18 òã�¶ 14 ò�#öXY áâ���í��°dSXh¾
è¼æçKNXY��Çk��op
78�dSH£�k/þ��ÏÐn
ó�÷^Xǯ ìíî5½�Ø
k��P���ýþ�CÍÎY
Zi@9��q~1�³6�q~1
�øù�|�ú·û�-X?@9�
q~1�³6�CÍÎʦ§k,�
���2008 �Xµ0ð³UN1
ÀH�Çîj,$u�EüEN6â
ãý'ïDt|³6�ñ�þþ×ø
�����VW�mË 8 �ÃKX½¿Hs���ÀCÍÎ8Ô�D��
�������*ýþ���q.²
�±Ð�CÍÎ��24 ¸CÍÎ
µX18 ¸j ��4£HG´��X
Á$ú����Ï���å�� 2006 �ÃK�åÇ«X���@ÓM
Ï$�CÍÎj }«��XP�
'$�µÁ$Ñß� 75%V¨ 1.2X�Øf´ã/¿��K/¿Hz��
�øklCÍÎO9�µu���
áâ�EN�âãHè¼æç��
ýþ��X�O9ǯ 7ë78
�B�C� M¼liÄ 2007 ��Ø
10918 =�� 2009 �� 15784 =ÏJX
µ0ð³UN1Àe;yG%�
���KN�
¹�À�Á$¦NO[¬§�
�X¿sCô��ß�&mù $
0²XÞyY�ñCÍÎ�³6M
ÓÐ�}§�H�ÎX�µu��
��*�ýþ������¹²�
��XÁ$�À�CÓ�����
�PÖ��CÍβyNÃÓ,cC
ÍÎMBC� �ßbXû,0¾Q
¹�_~X��ú�P§âã�ÐN
Ã^_X³'Þ�«Xµ�NÃé
ê 20 �§�������Çî�E
��t|æç³6µ�N�����
� 4200 �§�ô�7�ÜÝL�bû
������<% ¿sCô��²
��¸�Ißàoáâ���éê7
ë��ñ0òó�(ôÓHâã
EN6�¹²��Þ�È 2015 �@�����VW�®�ÁÂßà�
¡¢��º! 25%�q�UNËÌ�s����u0�� Ä����l
iQnô¬�Ø
2009–2010 �Ðj�òóýþ¾�
�µX�Uú�yÛܼÃ��Õ
�ÀV9 ¸CÍÎXÃ�µ½HÝ�
^ 1.3
#1
183
1–183
30
72
8796
117
137
30
72
8796
117
137
T������Uef{Q|}9
4 2011 �������
2011 2010 2011
1 1 02 2 23 3 14 4 25 5 06 6 27 9 28 7 09 8 0
10 10 011 12 412 13 413 11 014 18 315 14 016 15 117 17 318 19 119 16 120 20 121 23 322 21 123 26 524 27 225 22 126 28 027 24 028 25 129 30 130 29 131 33 232 31 133 34 234 32 035 41 236 46 437 35 038 36 239 38 140 37 241 40 042 43 343 53 244 47 145 42 146 52 447 49 048 44 149 48 350 39 051 51 252 50 053 45 054 55 255 58 256 54 257 57 058 70 359 74 460 59 061 67 1
2011 2010 2011
62 61 163 82 264 56 065 60 066 65 367 77 268 64 469 68 070 73 171 66 172 62 273 63 074 69 075 72 076 84 377 71 078 88 379 78 180 76 181 79 182 81 183 75 184 89 285 96 186 80 087 83 088 85 089 90 190 87 191 86 092 98 393 91 094 99 295 92 196 106 197 95 098 94 299 93 0
100 101 3101 100 0102 102 0103 108 1104 103 1105 104 0106 105 1107 111 2108 123 1109 97 0110 110 2111 107 2112 117 3113 109 1114 114 1115 113 0116 112 0117 119 1118 126 2119 118 0120 120 0121 115 3122 129 2
2011 2010 2011
123 116 2124 122 1125 121 0126 130 1127 124 1128 125 0129 131 3130 127 1131 128 0132 142 3133 132 2134 135 2135 133 1136 136 0137 134 0138 137 0139 149 3140 138 2141 139 0142 140 1143 143 3144 144 3145 147 3146 141 0147 145 1148 146 2149 148 0150 150 0151 154 4152 151 0153 155 3154 153 0155 152 0156 158 0157 156 3158 157 0159 159 0160 162 0161 160 0162 163 1163 164 1164 161 0165 167 0166 166 0167 165 0168 173 1169 168 1170 172 1171 169 1172 170 1173 171 1174 174 1175 179 3176 175 1177 177 1178 176 1179 178 0180 180 0181 181 1182 182 0183 183 0
~9cd����¨©¼½ 2010 � 6 ¾()�¦*�'�´¿Q²����ÀEÁ¨©����* 9 Z°y¨©�ÃÄÅ�¢´ 1.1¥Q±��¨©�¢Æ�ÇÈÉ¥����-�(ÊËÌͶ 9 Z°y)7ef�ÎÏdcÐÑQ�ÒÓÔÕÖ�e×aØÙ���Ú��XÀE�cdÛnQ
|}9T������Uef{Q
´ 1.2
º» 5
��Ü~�¾��æç³6��0
�×ø ��4Lt|Æ�³6�Ø
��õ�CÍÎYZ�@øR
� !�³6Xj,íæ�Iø�
cd�ßàXÑbkR"uÀEi0
e�¡#�: 85 ¸CÍÎG%
uv��EüEN6«]li&KX
$0H�Çî��,µx¸�Ø
}~XÁÂCÍÎ$%�Y�R
����³6k9�ù�{&�ô
Ùþ¿��ÇîH§0Ä|�úzû
�-J�áB�k:4L����
�'�2009 �X�K/¿ØD þk
4ü���¿ú�eXå�âãO
�CêȺ!�Ø
�����VW�µ�!k|$�µ
��ýþ´º!�Á("y 3 ¸Ã
|�ßàj1���� 10 ¸CÍÎ
lÃ.)��'$�µÜ*+Ù,
ê¦-VW�. 1.3XXÁ¸0�¸� 9:4X?ø Oh¾��áâK
N�4£"jí��°dSX�qK
� 70%X7~XÜ*+Ù� 2009 �j .0��Eü4£XØD â
ã@QäåP§�$u�!�ý'X
"?Ð R� !�EN6÷^â
4X}JyÜ*+ÙâãäåEN
6�CÙÙ��ý ��²¾Q78
³6HR� !�³6���@òó
�é�()Xºúi�.Gòó��
²yNÃyt|ºnXú�5È�
NÃliVQ�Á«²-¾�ö�
C¢§� .�X,µÔ�v?ø
$¸ !¢ã³6K/Gú��ñ�
Hyêµ0�0�Q'ØD$¸²-
¾�1�³6 (TC-SCAN)X�'�c��ÐÓ}25 8 3X�'��Ð
25 9 3Xá(òócd���2
5 1 ¸�Ü*³6Ôy�Qþ�
�ÏÐnó�q�Ç �4op�d
S���¸� 9:4X9:²y�
�y�Vµk[��þ�I4�nó
lÃ���Ø
v��¿5�345X�Å,J
�@6��z��7ê��89Ø
+Ù�:Ñ¿�¼2þ�sßï5HØ
�;�Ø
µ����Ö×>[@Õ²XØ
ÁÄ$%K´|&' ©CÍÎ��
¡¢���Õ¾Ö×XÄÕ¾¹��
k��©CÍÎ���NO[��,
cCÍÎ�m(PmÜÕ¾�×gX
�´��Õ¾"#O&'©CÍ��
�¡¢��y$%��`�bhmÜ
վ��
� �������VW�de
�¡¢��y/CÍÎ`�bhÅÆ
���'Pm��Xv��V
WØD $G��®À<����
�Õ¾Múº»k 174 ¸CÍÎ��
¡¢��y��µmÜÕ¾�® 8�
bûR������VW�¿À�
®��X¹À<N&'©CÍÎ��Ø
¡¢����@Õ¾Ö×Xb��$
u�!�P�=���áâ�Ð�
>X+��j �$ådSopQ
m�nó78�6?nó�£¤P�
=�ìíî5½ö´ÇÙ�de��
Â&SÃo174 ¸CÍεÙ�@ 85% �CÍÎX,����e���*
�ýþVW�¨ 1.4X�y��¡¢���q��@´
Ù� 10 ¸CÍÎ�s�9¿�345�
ËRï4*�AUżB��ä�Ø
949+�"�¿�Ü*+ÙH
Çï��@ÁÂ0�y 5 ���Ðä
>j 12 0Ã|��������,µ.¸0�V�vs�9¿�345�
CD"+�ËRï4*�949+�Ø
"�¿HÜ*+ÙXy$��
´ 1.3
2009–2010 10
� � � �
� � �
� � � �
� � �
� � �
� � �
� � �
� � � �
� � �
� � �
~9�ÕÖ�e×�ÜÝ7��Þ�¨©Qßà(²�T������U=�§�¨©abY 9 Záâ(ã¿cäå����cæ��Õç�����ÕÖè�éê=½ë 3 ìáâ�¢�� 1.1¥Qêí(ã¿Ù�q¯³¨©(7ã�����7¶Â������Õç�îÁÞ�¨©QÕçîÁïð(¨©ï$Q
|}9T������Uef{Q
C����������ؿE�P
ÖÈ.)�Ø
Ã345�ßXÁ¸0�'�Ö
È .)XP�����Õ¾Mú
®��'��K�FÜ��.�Á"
�$ÔM�öXPgj�Õ��
�jGM���Ä 2005 �ÃKX34
5y�����VW�de�ßàµ
�Hj 22 0��4£�����
�CÁ´��Á����2005 ��X
y345áâ$���cd 9 ¸P
§X���&!CD� 223%�bvX��tNÃy 3 3`ñI$¸��
�XPôç�P§�����&!C
D� 8.9%�2008 �@ 3000 +��t
þøÁG@��KNáâ ��X!
�}�áâ�� 7 0 0 ���!á
��2005 ��Xè¼æçcd$�
+V371 3X��ÐX�J�¤��
�è¼KL� 9.8%�bvXÁ¸�K�cd 2 ¸�X�J��cè¼KL
� 0.4%�2009 �jä�$0�9:4
dS��FÙopX�Ç)*)�&
g"d@M½*ó�éÐ78X,�
��ìíî5½êÈ Ç¯�
ÇïH�ä�,z0�y.�`
�� �����Çïy 6 ¸ßà`?
Ð @äX¹0�E 8¸V7�X
j² ��ñI�Ü~�¾XÓ�k
,è¼æçÎG� N���XÄ
O�æçG�%¼AæçG�+��
����@êè¼�J�c��ÐÄ 24 ÞX� 5 Þ�eX�0�P5¼
A�,sjM��ä�¡¢����
K@�Ç]Xtd����vo¾Q
�������iF $u�!
�ý'�� 2009 �¸� @QQ*R
SKN�4£ÄPǯ k5úM½
�5½XÓ�Ôh¾ �\��Z[
�4TKNVH¢ÊÑ��U�X�
$ÂÙv�øklCÍÎ��å
jÙö��Xµ0ý�,µÏ$�
�'.�KXµ0j Þy���
���� 14 01���Xk���
��VW�ÙÚ� 9 ¸ßà>¼Ü
e�2005 ��V��9:4j$
´���|!�í��°dSÄ�
��&!CD� 1236% X� 118%�2006 �X��E�7ëæçL�áB���bvX64% ��&!@7ëç
��2007 �X�C 14 ���ÏJX
��¼A4áBäXk9�H�&
è¼nlÓ�5½X�FÙ Nø�
P5����
f´y 7 ¸ßàj 18 0�
�4£��X,µA+��!�Wj
âXÇj��q~æç�ð�q~
���P5q~æçÃ�t|ºn¾
Q.sHçy�G´�/���j
���Ó,cÙ0$"Xf´/X
H/k���4£�ÆyYZ����Ø
��VW�$�q[�CÍÎÙ�
��\kX7$�q�ø����Ø
º�,0�¿ÀXÃβ12kÁÂ
YZ�Qñ�bû�f´����Ø
VW�X2006 �� 2009 �ÐX��
�]��f´ 17 ^\kµX14 ^j ��X�áâ���âãäåEN
Ã��è¼æ纻 ýþ9�Ø
����ÚñÉe´ò]?óÒ'ôõ�ÓÔ��ÚñöÃ(÷� 5 �1����� 9 Z�5ø×Q]�Á�����ÚñÉeùú�û 0.1 ½ 0.54Q�¶����ÚñÉeüý�����þ�(
^ 1.4
5 85% 2006 �2011
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
~9
T������Uef{Q|}9
�¡¢�ef���ÈÉQ
6 2011 �������
Õ¾�K´#�Ð\���¡¢
���]´XÔÐ\����ùI�Ø
ßbo_�+�Çî���C?@@�
�q~1�³6H4Rkè¼A¯@ö
�5½XÓ},�å�`Ð#Ù�,z
0�XÑbo·Ùþ�Xy$Âßà
j ú0¡¢��XÄÁÂßàX
Ñbo:4+M¼ßà���Xcd
*���ÐaO3È�����Ø
eX��H��µFÜÕ¾¿ÀVÇ
����Õ¾MúXÊ��¿´M��
.bü&k25���cdP§eK�
CD@�fgXÄ���4£��Y�
hG��k����¼ÜeÛ�bhØ
³²��H��®zKz+�j6��
��y/CÍÎ��¡¢��HÕYØ
K´���H�����ÏÐEF Ø
m³10�25_DhikCÍ���*
ÚÛeÛÂ,êÈ jD���Ä�X
}¢M"#·kÆÓ�M�,c0Nd
]+Ó���,cÕ�VbfgCÍ
��XX�NO�Ñm� $%/ø�
:)l"aOm *Öy#j
¡¢���Ö×��r�CmÜ
Õ¾®Y���$00`y$%��
`mÜ�Õ¾XbàáÑ¿jh
¾ ��KN�M¼G´��Øm�
Õ¾X$Â��O#kÁ$I�_
����ÏJX@ÜÆOö���*
@NOêÈ��XP#��º�p
ÉXÓ����V#Tº�X°CO
�êÈ º!11�,c��¤k�e
Û ©Â��+���1����
���ÁÂ��?øBÖeÛ��
N/�W\Xm²�;£���Dà
áÑ¿�f´H./ົýþ��
�X�Ç �����Dú®X��
¯ �Z12���./à/k��ñI
KN�h¾XyÖÈeÛ��µX
�ñI���ú®�Ç 5%X��Oº! 2.8%�
,cNn���;y�²�Y�
?øK������o%"�úûXØ
����Á´X½¾Hµ¿�À��
�4£��eK �����º!13�
pÑfgCÍ���jâá��º!Ã
����UI�Ó]�NOkܼO¼
ÜeÛXÄ��ÊÑÂ&SÃ�
�'q�KX��ÀCÍÎy9
���4£�q�±ÐXÁ"Ì�
eÀ�� rf¹bÇD¾�+��
¡¢£�����V¨ 1.5X���ÀØ93% �CÍÎ�� ��áâ��XØ
20 ¸CÍÎEF $u�!�ý'�
eX��Àáâ���ýþ´s�
�Cô��!CDCÍÎ���êÈ
����YZ�����H��
��2009 �ys�9¿á(�$0�
�m²X�E��!�µtÍÎ��
������!�þu� 3.25%XPÁ���ñI!����v��¹µt
!���@��P�XÏsHÐs�
����!5 720 �§�14�
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
–0.1
º» 7
8 2011 �������
bû�����VW��ç�X2004 �ÃKX183 ¸CÍÎ�j 1500 0
��4£���eXm(µCÍÎ
���;zKz+�ĵ���'
$�µX� 66% �CÍÎ�� ��
��XP 6 ��Á$Ñß��Ø 34%�Ä345HÇï�Ö×3X���áB
ÐêÂ&7!���XPÁÂ��¯È
T ,z0��Ø
Á�$¸C�8XÓ��¡¢
����[ÊÑÆy�ÑPXYCD
HµYCDCÍÎ���tHìíî
q��üwP§Ê+�!CDCÍÎ
���tHìíîX,êÈ�¼A5
½�*í�ÑbXþ��H0�'�
dâã 11 =^�XP40�câã 2 =�ÛܼÃ��Õ�Àáâ��
�c��ÊÑ�Cô��!CDCÍ
Î� 18 xÏ+�Ó}Xm(µCÍ
Î�A+��NO�[yz{�;£
L�X²y�;£L��ÁÂ��|
5éê;£��7ëH�Dkl�}
X,÷ùéê�tSÒ5XPgê
#È5½�û_~X: �@ 18 �
&Ö÷��;£L�X12 �&Ö÷�
;£L�15�Ø
��cd�KN[~���±
²X|�N5½¼A�ºãT�´Ã
�56��t@�@ø,í¼���
+4£�[~���±²�b�4
L�P5æçL�HV7�����
OY�+|�Xü@Q³�P5H7
ëç��%,a�H��t¤@N
O�Ö��16�k��K�Ö×��
b}XÓ�V7�H²¼P54R�
��H4£"#ô¬��YZC��
��«vXÇ;£H�;£L�YØ
í���v��uv��VW�Ø
ó` 1.2X17�
²vXYCDCÍε�@ 1.3% ��&OéêV7��!��A+�
vHµuv��X,¹í¼� 95% YZ�²¼P�#²¼Xc)"#O�
ÁÂí¼ø�-�FÙ£��c�í
¡XÄ"#��@���Ö×>�Á
"�pÑ 35% �ÛܼÃ��Õ�À
CÍÎG% STj/«í¼ø/P
5�4RXĽ¿Hs���ÀCÍ
ÎHCô��!CDCÍÎ�Á$Ø
ÑßMN!5 71% H 68%�70 ¸YCDHµYCDCÍÎü@iFµ�P
5æçL�XÓPL4%ºA&Wm
�Qí¼�r�Céê 7$¸ºA
&�P5��@ÁÂ�á($���
��H�����º» �[�
2003 �ÃKX�����VW�Ä�
����´�w��¡¢Ö×X^�
#Ó���Õ¾��ײÃKXVW
0e�� 5 ¸|eX"y"�µ�
Ç 50 ¸CÍÎ��'$�KX¹0
ekx¸¿À�� ��o$¸�
Q�bhéêqö��¿ÀX7$¸
�C9��÷øùå¿À18�Ø
�������� �!��"#$%&�'()*+,-./0123456789:2008 �;<�=>?@�AB(CDE�FGHB(2010 ��IJ�FGKL>(2010 �=;�MN?@�OP�QRS(*T2006 �������UVT2011 �������UW0X&Y 15 Z���[!\]Q
^ 1.5
T������Uef{Q|}9
~9
48
35
46
63
7175
100
91
83
9196
8479
83
67
57
67 6773
58
39
50
59
4753
56 56
67
89
62
25
62
50
75
63
38
67
52
61 6359
48
35
46
63
7175
100
91
83
9196
8479
83
67
57
67 6773
58
39
50
59
4753
56 56
67
89
61 62
25
62
50
75
63
38
67
52
61 6359
100
80
60
40
20
0
DB2006
DB2007
DB2008
DB2009
DB2010
DB2011
º» 9
��á(�����Á´X108 ¸
CÍÎ���Cã��qö�Néê
MHNõM�,��±²�¶mÙG
�Ó]X¶$ÙG�Ó]�¢í}
����.�Xqö»f#öNk
��ܼO�,¼Oìí��#þe
Û 19�qö!�#�k���Q�dX
Pg�x�Cͱ²µÖ¡¢K´
!�ßàÏ$������VW��
w}«¡¢yYqJbhk��¼
ÜeÛ�Á�q�¿ÀNÃk@Qø
qá��úûV#�vy�����Ø
VW�µXÔ@»q!��NéêM
HNõMÃ���Ks��q�úû
ùȺ�/ø��úû�k/CÍ
Î�YqKN��ÐH����g
ÑÒº» h��$0���H�0
�$ÂCÍÎ���ACoqöcS
yµ���Ny 40 3`Yq�Ä»
¤NO�� 279 3X×���Ø309 3X949++Ù�� 337 3�Ø
w�µkYq�qúû��M
LMÉ´ 4£�����Há(
¡¢��krNO�ùI�176 ¸C
ÍεX@ 100 ¸CÍÎ�Yq��
T�´##20�9ø*�9:��J
º»���c)/�cd�ï��
øXP#��<£��í���Ü~
9�XÁXY º»QnCÍ!��
9ø*�9:�>X@�Jq�
dø�A�Êy��X"g@NOn
�M!��9ø*�����º»�
½�yA+CÍεX��JP�9
ø*�9:��dC���+¸12
L��÷^Á$F|�KXÓ�h
¾9ø*�9:H,z��Ð���
K��[�C�� �yA+µ�C
DCÍεX�JÔ[q�#�d
��F|��bH���:1�K
NXPÛܼÃ��Õ�ÀÃ�µ½
HÝ��À$Â0��12b�#d
S�}«1��
ÁÂ�,z$Âm².�XE+
12H¡¢L�NY�STjYq
KN�q��������Qn��
�{|�dSº!Dt%K�T�´
HSTL�Ð*C���NÃ/��
��ùI�Ø
�¬"�ÇܼM���òH��
ú®X�:��\�î�$0�Iå
/Xy�����b}�TC�
�� 1.29
:��¹&'µX��� 50% Ã|XÄy$ÂCÍÎX,��²ö�Ñ��#È 30%XÁ.���@ÆÈB���Êö�k�öZ
ºã��yCͱ²µ�Wê´�\�îP�X$¸C�ùI�<54RH��@þ���e�Ä*���±²Hå/�Ø
Ã7ë��ß�ÅÆ|�ú®û�-uv7ë����²X$Â0�H�À���8Ôéê 7ë�È 2006 �XÒ� 3330 ¸
uv7ë���� 1.33 ��Jº» !��ÁÂ�JµX9300 ��Jy�ȶ${ëy��%�&'XP 85% �%�&'�
���ÑPX:�� 128 ¸7ë�µX�@ 42 ¸i@uv7ë��XÁ°G ,Yy&YÐ7ë�Oö�����jä��
0e7�����ê4R?k¹b|�ÁÂYZÃ��<ÀMMN�4£��w1�Ø
��k²@����M ê�b�� o��¡¢���d]eÜk���r\%����tÃ�C�;£������� Â,
Ù�eÛ���yéê¢í�q���@NO@ê,�µ�Yí���v�XÓÁÂ�dS�í¡Ò5XÄ��Hm(�ÊöØ
Òu�$ÙNO���X��Oéê�j�H7-�?P5NOd5��M2�
b4R�ji +fC¡�²¼ø/ëyP5º»ýþX¤���NÃĵÖ��H¢��k@NOø/P5���+EüYZ|�
ô4AþXÄ,*@NO?@²¼�+ä�Å���Ë?@¡8¢X"Ó}P?@èÆ�Â&£¤��X�Nø¡8¢/ëyØ
P53�
��YZ@ø�;£7ëXÄ,nó��A!���yÇïá(�$0��Á´X���éê7ëP �Ù®�Ð�¬Ó�;£7ë
º»�EF�F|Q³t4�Ø
²�6�XY�$�������*C�ÃÄí¼Ã������Px����éê;£¢í�h�XNÃÐê��5�# ��
��X&&>f��
1. http://wbl.worldbank.org/.2. Klapper:� Parker�2010:�¥3. Pal�1997 �¥:4. Schindler�2010¥5. �����2008 �¥
10 2011 �������
�²4£NÃ¥#¦±�ÍÎeD
���»§+����;£L��&
)y;£L�éê�å/XÓ�ÔN
Ã��C¨Èå/�&)º»�M5
½XÁ"�#[©G,ܼO�¨È
ôy��"�ó*�Ø
�n\�îH��&ùº»78X
�����VW�0e;=ö�9�,
÷øùå¿À�4XFÙ¿À��bû
�ó�Hþ��Q������u�º
��·�HEX;yiÄ���°X
Ã[\0��å���Q9�h��<
Y5½á�XÇYåíá��eª
�«3úÃ�µÞ+å/3ú�Á"
ÌN��¿À�]ßà�å&5½H
��°Gº»¬�}~XQ��²4
£�q��úû;yC�ϵXúû
[\å/�°V9 ¸��1 ��5 �H 10 �XC��7÷øùå?w�®¯
�0å/� åm²�Ø
������ k�����VW�
ùº�/ø�R_¿À�Vó` 1.3X�� 2010 � 3 �³��7�����H4R?úû�X8Ôº» ®k#
ÓMNÀNktÖ×��gÀ<��
2010 � 7 �³��7ñ�ìí?úû�º» Ä~0ìíî��´®�
�4£�À<�B� 2004 ��������VW°± ÙCÍÎ`L�Õ
¾Ö×�����á(�,cå
/?ø#Ó��º» @KL�º�
úû�Ø
�������VW�²¬Ä�
�����´®H^�: ��4
£�Õ¾XÓ}|��,zúû�º
» $¸³´�R{X@ê\�îH
��&ùO#k��@ä@���ü
@�¦§�µ�X"º!z)k¸
µqÓ�ã��Ø
1.Ø yÓde�§â�¶|Ù�m. Ø656 ·�¸XPgY� Google Scholar (http://scholar.google.com) ¹*�rNèÈÙ� 2060 · ��
2. Klapper�Lewin HØ º»¼½¾¿¾Ø À¼Á¾¿ÃØ
V2009 �X��DO¿�ñI����@ñI���ÄMÑ����´�
%¸���ú®��@yÅ�²&'
V18–65 1X�ÄMÑ�
3.Ø 0��å���úû�Ø
4.Ø Cô��V2004 � bX�0��å��H SERCOTECV2010 �X¶ 12 ÆX���òóHå�LV2004 �X¶ 18 ÆX�µ00�å�1¢ã¹�tu http://www.saic.gov.cn/english/ Ã� Ayyagari�Beckv H Demirguc-KuntV2007 �X�Ø
5.Ø Bedi V2009 �X�Ø
6.Ø ßbo2009 ��0@ 19077 �9:� º�pÉXÑ|$��Ç 22.8% �Ø
7.Ø ��[X7�ÇîC�o:0M�ÕÐê�Ç�d]?X2009 � 9 � 30 ¯y�ÇîÈ�
8.Ø �����VW�^� 2005 �ÃKX174 ¸CÍÎj�k��ÄáâÈQõ�k¸_ÝÞ�`��eÛ
���¡¢���2003 �� 2005 �ÐX�����VW��� 5 ¸É|X,]��CÍÎú®Ä 133 ¸�ÇÈ 174 ¸� �@Q���³�����FÜ¿ÀVÇ����Õ¾
MúX�*+`aXiW����Ø
��VW�h®� �Á$�¿À�
bh���XiW�úû���Ø
9.Ø ��V2009 � aX�
10.Ø d:q �êܼOH���CÍ���Q���áâ4£��°ùX
iW� DjankovV2009 � bXÃ�ØMotta�OviedoØ HØ SantiniV2010 �X� (�ÔNW� Djankov�McLieshH RamalhoV2006 �X� (�*+��VWXiæÊ�����VW�
tuohttp://www.doingbusiness.org/�
11.Ø Giné HØLoveV2006 �X�Ø
12.Ø Ag h i on �&V2 0 0 8 �X�ËÌ»ÍÎV2008 �X�Kaplan�Piedra H SeiraV2007 �XÃ� Cardenas H RozoV2009 �X�
13.Ø Amin H RamalhoVÇj��X�Y�?øà 28 ¸CÍÎ�� 2100 ����o%"��úûX/îk� �
�Hü@����CÍÎ��²Ü
¼Oy$%��`�Õ¾Çà Ñ
Ò�Áx�CÍÎ�²Ü¼OÕ¾�
YZ�#È 5% �Õ¾@´P��C8@6ܧ·¸�
�� 1.39
���� ��(http://wbl.worldbank.org/)º»@Q 128 ¸CÍÎy4R|k#ÓMNÀNkt�úûX]� 6 ¸ßà�
�����(http://iab.worldbank.org/)Ø
º»]� 4 ¸ßà�eÛ 87 ¸CÍÎ~0Ïsìí�4RH4£úû�
����������(http://www.doingbusiness.org/Subnational/)º»kCÍÎ`�ÏHk�ÑÒ������VW�úûV]� 299 ^\k�
41 0��X�
���� �!"���(http://www.enterprisesurveys.org/)º»Q� 125 ¸CÍÎ� 10 �+����]�ÚÛ����É|���úûÃ�
bû$G#Ó���éê�ÐÑ�º�úû�ÁÂ>�vy�������Ø
VW�µ�
º» 11
14.Ø 0�¡¢9:X2010 � 9 � 20 ¯9Ë��0�¡¢9:ÍÎs�9¿h¾
��cdâã�P§Ã���ÐHØ
íæ�Xhttp://www.ifc.org/�
15.Ø 0��å��úû�Ø
16.Ø ��V2008 �X�
17.Ø Ò Í Í ¾ Ó Ì ¾V 2 0 0 3 �XH A m i n ÔV2010 �X�Ø
18.Øxî>#�vyv����ýþ´¹Î��µ�Ø
19.ØßboW� C a l d e r o n H S e r v e nV2 0 0 3 �X�D ol l ar�Ha l lward -Driemeier HØMengistaeV2005 �XX�Reinikka H Svens-sonV1999 �XÃ�ØEiffertV2007 �X� (�?ø��úûJXIimiV2008 �Xm²X½¾Hµ¿�ÀbO��Õq²ÖX,0`
ܼ¹LN�� 0.5–6%�
20.Ø yÁÂCÍεXo%qr���sY�ø�Ã9á�C���.��û
Ü~�X�¹sY�ø�#È 1%�
12 2011 �������
�@=ö��0CÍ�×M�;<�
�09Qº»�[�0�12#��
WfgCÍ»×XPgñ�eÛ¯Z
Cͱ²�4R�£¸H�����Ø
: ¡¢£�ØÔØù&)k×
:�£¤ê¡¢�Qñ�yCÍÙ{
��XY�@����¡¢G´H�
�X@Î�á(CÍ�kå/�Y�
º!���DH{�kl�ýþK
´��¯�kíæ@ø�¦±MXN
@��*aóÕcÄ*cS2í��
�XáBÄ*����Y��<è¼
Aþ�ǯklR{iäVßb7ø
78�P5©³6XX¤N@���
ECÍ�ìíîH��î�¯7t�Ø
ÑPXÏÈ�a�² ø�¡
#ÁÂ�gCͧd]HM ,eÛ
�: M¿À�1980 �-@&yÁ�q� �µ�X?øó��
�H����µC���Úúû�}
«��k� �CÍH1�»×@C
DXÄ,�Û��ÚXPgk,0�
��#9:XÓ}°G M ���
NøM�
z�mù������VW�
0e*� $å�Á¸0e��0`
µuv��X_®ÁÂ��ÜÝÞ�
/¸wx�yø�4£� yÜ�
ámH?ø������VW�HÀ
_���ve�E+0�ø�®
12£¤G%k��±²eÛ�Ý$
À_å81�Ø
¶$¸�����VW�m.
� 2003 �X�� 133 ¸CÍÎH 5 ¸¿À��v��VW�� 183 ¸CÍÎH 11 ¸¿À��y��ýþK´¹��µ�v 9 ¸É|��0eCÈ /012�§â��@Qßàå/&
ùH÷�&ù�&Þ·�2��0e�
�ÊÑ�o�ã�H����¡¢
��º»�g�bû�
�����VW�k�Ã��q�¡
¢£¤º»®¾úûoáâ���â
ãäåEN6�æçè¼�éê7
ë�5½ìíî�ïð��ñ0ò
ó�(ôÓ�Qõ��V�þk0
`µuv��X�¹VWÔ÷W @
Q÷øå&�¡¢£¤"�³� @
Qéêqö�úû�Ø
�����VW��b�º
�oCͱ²cdTC�£¤X,U
V�O#EFH�%è¼AX25�
\��ßà���Xº!CÍ]K�
N^_MX"�ôÓ`aº»Gc@
á��'t5½£¤�eÀ�o¡
¢£¤�G%d�ÆO#@ÏêÈ@
�Hj�O#º»n�@cd@ø
¡¢£¤�&X"gO#hiPý�
jä�âã�Ó}X$Â�����
VW�¿ÀkÒF|�¡¢£¤Vß
bk�Q�nó�78op£%Òr
sXnlÒ!�MúX7$¿À¤
køh¾�4(²@¡¢£¤Vß
by$¸7$u�?��âã�@á
â���P§XnlÒ!�Mú�
�����VW�0e��x
«úû�¶$«úûK�k4RH¡
¢£¤�äå�¶m«úû��ÐêØ
²/��úûX_®5È¡¢eÀ�
�OHF|MVßb%��æm4R
�çX��Ðê²/��úûµ�Ø
��eÜúûK�ü�j��QC
�.3������VW�Yè �4
�+ $*Ô�á�M����XP$*Ô¤Yè éä$ä �ä9@ø��Ðê²/���4Vûø
��U T vêë�ܼXÐê Ý�-��O4MX�$*Ô 1980 �-?ø¹�4Á´ y6�þ�ìÀEF
!�Çåí�q����4�Ø
� ������VW��v�Â
`aX���m ¹VW#�v�Â
`aX���yã�úû����<
,�°M�Ø
������ 13
����VW�j�IÄ� 11 ¸É|Xe��_®0`µuv��yÜ
ÝÞ��Kµq��¡¢»×Hc�
î��Ó}oØ
Ø �����VW�"#_®��Ø
��k��+ìíî@eÛ��@
�qX�#_®eÛ�Zö��@
�q�ßbX¹VW"#_®Ã�Ø
d]o�:�fgC�%M��
��ïQ��²jO����b�
×:M+R{iä�G®5�}~X
¹VW"#��þk~0ìí�8
Ρ¢£¤�
Ø �����VW�"#de¡¢G
´+¡¢kl¡¢£¤�ö´XP
Áx¸Ó]k�<%: ¡¢£�
�$Âbæ8@�d·¸�Ø
Ø �����VW�"#��$¸C
ÍÎ��@¡¢£¤H�@¡¢e
À�ÅÆCÍHjâ��åXÖ¡
¢�Cͱ²ßà¯��+�ß
bX¾Õm���ô4RV�ô4
RX�`a²���+5 14,500 ¸£¤�ô������VW�Y
� 11 ¸8Î�¿À��ÙÚ��ÜÝÞ�µ� 11 ¸�q�Á¿À�#��Qñßà��@¡¢�q�
ßbXáâ��¿ÀH5½ìíî
¿À#����4��@�qX÷
øùå¿À#�v�å4£��@
�q�ßbXe�¿À�#��
å/l��:��ÎïëAþ¡¢
£¤�q�úû�
�����VW�¿À�ûÀ_¾Ø
åßX@8Î�«iXßb«i��
ò�¹CÍÎÙ���\k�CÍ
¿À]]@ÁG°GM�«i�ßbX
Yúðñ6Üú�]]�û5ú\k
�À���î�K�Ø
Y�}««iXNÃk: »
×���XPg@þ�º!NÑ
MXÄ-K����v������Ø
VW� ����Ù��\kúû
��°MX$¸0�`/�Ày��
¡¢H¡¢(�qÆyYZXym
XG0�HÙvCÍÎ*�b}�Ø
}~X/0���\kV# �
f´�ò�Ô�Ê/�ó5"X�ô
Ç��Åõ4Ô�ÊÜ�ö��Ø
�÷X�Æy�ËÌH�[�Ñ�
@AÙYN�è�/012;< �
ÁGYNXÓ}�����VW�yº
»: M¿ÀÏ~XÔ� þkÃ
�/0���ø��oÊ/�µ0�Ø
àáÑ¿�żB+��H0�f´�Ø
f´ã/¿�âã¿�./à�õà�Ø
ã¯þ¿�ÊR+ÙHùRú6�ØØ
y¡¢F|MHYZMÒ!�
Ö×�X�cdk ������Ø
VW���?ø�À_¾åß�û
ü�%¸�y�d�XÀ_¾åß«
i$¸@°&g9:�?øÁ¸�4
�LMqÓ�bûC�o: Ù+ú
CÍÎZ����ý����&Ø
@°&g9:�Á¸�4Ôβ Ø
�����VW��$¸�Io�Ç
���[�:)Y�jÊy��°G�
í�ìDPSTìíî���ìí�
yG%¿À�qX�����VW�
«i��áâî �²@�:L¡¢
£¤"gÇÃþ��j�|X��á
âîNOd �A+�Ð �ÈhD
'âãP§Ã�cdºn�Â���
��áâîÔNOØ�íîâã4R
dS�P§XßbL��[�:Ø
æç�Ø
b�¡¢£¤UN�dXCÍÎ
��;�K´�[Ò!��;�M�
@-K�o�;�L����YZ�
�Ò�X#saóéê7ëX÷ø�
ùå&úÒ5VPg,ùå#Ö�²
4�5½X7������VW�_
®�d]@Î����;�MmÜ�
qÓXÍÎ\�î �cd���Ê
yßà�� *�M� ���ÒÚ
�����X"k¹ÎM1�ËÌ@
���XÔcdyäå�����V
W��Ó�W�,zKæ�úûXß
b��������8�
�����VW��/ø�k0`Ø
���¡¢���«���§|�
o_��o_�"#Á´:
)×���@�qXÄ�O#_®k
×�8@�d·¸�$¸�q�cO
º�:)Ä+�q�Õ�X#�O
#��o¿ÀXÔO��kÎØ
×��Ø
:)NÃY�$G �K_�Ø
�����VW�Or/�¹Î��
��H�Zö�-ã¿ÀXu��g
w�����VW��ÔH,ztd
CÍR_¿ÀÏÐ��QM�ê��
���VW��_®`as��¿
À��CÍô/êm(���¼©k
l¡¢¿À9XPxîÐ��Q³ú
� 0.72���CÍ ���: �Zö¿ú�H IMD �����Zö�è�pÑ��ÒÚXÄê����
�VW���Q³ú�A!VMN
� 0.79 H 0.64X10�Ø
$¸*�d�{|�o�����
VW��ñ��*0k�m(H2%
�r@�deۮ�����V
W�,&�-.�6}{:�� 6 �+�,&o���bhaO�è%�11®
�êÈ�±å�Z�<o# ��M
Ô��MX,&>�;<89�ÔyÄ
����éê�CD+Y�Ö÷�,
z��Péê�CD|�d$���Ø
V"<5,&O#éê���CDX�
cdEF$G��X@8@�HCt
·�JKîV# MNHQObhXO
#�F��X@C��O#�ìíH
éê��XÓ���*+���[�
14 2011 �������
µuv����Z���H�
����[�Qn²öVÂ,�y
m(µ0�XXÑPÁÂCÍÎ+
5 80% �Cͱ²>Æy��;�L����Ï�Ã#O�D;�L�X
qÓNO���P§H¡¢£¤��
�d�Ø
b�¡¢£¤eK���PXÓ
�|��ZXu�d�Ç�]]Ð\
�����&XP#�å/Ìêb
h��&Xb�¡¢£¤T�¾��
O!XPg?Ðhi��4(Xu
�8@�t���áâîV# @ü
@Q³X�*aóy4G��`�
�/XPg*aóéê4R�º»�
�[H5½�
Ó}X�����VW���T
C�£¤k�[�aM8@Qn�
/ø�¹VWÔNYÃ��¡¢£
¤�,fø�eK�eÛ�ßbX
�2004 �����VW�m²Xb�ôÓ4(]´Ò«X&)���4
R9�MÒ!X��b�(4]´�
�[M�(4��12�Ø
y: £��¤¥�X\�î�
Ñq�$Â8Î�ËÌ�m5CÍÎ
Hm(µCÍÎ�jÎCÍ$Ï�Ö
Æ¡¢£��eÛX��O|ãXC
D�X�E+12q��r�ËÌ
�bh������[HC�[�
ÄE+0��èö �@°XL4�
R{iäìí�9�íÎ�±²X
�L4º»9�íÎ��:tH�
[!��Y���K��ìí��Ø
V�v����¡¢XNéê.�q
�CD�Y�EF¦±�¡¢£¤H
@��¡¢��V�v!�O�áâ
��P§&KH!�O�Löɺ�
M¼G´XXj@þ���MÃ�²
öHí��P����EHáB��
�����[¤@Î��0��CÍ
F���R{�}~XY�âh¡¢
��H&K�º!,N@øMXj@
þ�y���E�KµXY�;�H
;�L�ÏÐ���XÄP�,&º
»*+�[�
�����VW�O#β¡¢G´
�©ÂQnUVX°��@Î�<%
R_¾M �R_¾M V# �þ
k¸&���Ô�CÍÎX�Ñ8@
�°Mob�@Î��¯ëìOöX
�@�øHÍÎ/øpÄ�b�øØ
cK-�ëìX�øHÍÎ/ø�[
XY�Ø
�����VW�øxG��º
»�?��úûo89º»µ¸CÍ
Î� 11 ¸¡¢t|�7¶k?¿ÀúûpÑJº»CÍÎy 9 ¸É||��ÔX�v/0¿À��ÔH¹Î�
Ô13�åîyã�VWµ8ÎCÍÎ�
_®úû�XÃ�y<%��H1�
|N������Xcd/���
�ëì�
b�i�'3�����VW�
���X�NO¼Ü·�#È����
@ÂCÍÎy©Â¿À|��ÔÏ!
NO�&·>X@ÂCÍÎpÑ��
\]+îÏØ Ù®ìíXÄ�Ô�
Y�7$�b�(��0��
k�=ö����12P�X�
�����D�¡¢�����Ñ�
Q��Ô!Y*�d�� @Î�k
��²����eÜXv��VW
º� $G��®À_X@êCÍ
ÎO#jc)bv�Ö×ê 5 ��Ö×ÇÃkÑ�ÁG��à 5 ��iò�FÜÕ¾¿À.� CÍÎy
$%�Ð`��¡¢�q���K´Ø
V�ÖW�úû��XXÁ¸¿À�
k�´��ýþ´���$Gº�X
JîyÓ$�ÐI|kCÍÎ�}
�ÑÒ�
ÅÆCÍÎ�m(X0�[�¯
H�Ç5½ìíîHè¼A�¡¢£
¤�ê}Ó�X12[¨È�O*!
��4K(²@¡¢£¤H���
��£¤������VW��$¸
����.�o�(ҫ���\]
�CÍÎ[#ì��H¸ª¡¢£¤
Ã�£¤(��XPE+,0�¡
¢G´ÊÑÕ²y 18 �úJ��
®¾úûHR_¾M O# pÊy
�ËÌX"OÍÎ\�î �ÄhD
ÏÐC�ÑÒXÓ}@Î�$�Q�
1��Õ �@Q�úûÔ@Î�M
#�1���V�#�1�
��@äXbh$��Zö���H
º!���CD�^�����Ø
@ ·�������VW�ú
ûX&)êÃ�zKz+���X
������VW�¿À|�.²
VÃ�ê¿À�Q���Xê^��
�[CÍ��@��Q³�Ód
§â¶�m. Ù� 656 ·�¸X7~Y� Google Scholar ÔNèÈÙ� 2060 ·å/��14�ÁÂ��
���M ���vo
Ø ����ÒYê�;�L��£�
Òu@Qm15�Ø
Ø b��D��ÒYX¤@þ����
º!��ܼOH25��²Ö16�Ø
Ø b��âP§ÒhiX¤N�ÇØ
���[17�Ø
Ø 0�(ôÓ�G®�òó��Ñ
Ò!�$¸Kæ�ôÓ(C�
0�ó�Ä*Q³vìí��d�
ò��18�Ø
Ø Y�V7�j²*ÙK´�78Ø
MBQ³Èþu�º!H !
�XY19�
/012bhûø�����Ø
VW�®$¸�Ó� �&f�kØ
�����VW�úû�G®Hyø
MÃ�VW����bhÜ~ê��
º�g{�ÑP@Q�Õ ]]m(
�*jD�a X"aúûk�CÍ
������ 15
Î�yøMÃ�y�Âßàá(��
¡¢��ÑÒôã�
Ù+ú��î$áB>d¡¨Ø
9ßXP�����VW�yÁ�qØ
VW�ó` 2.1X@ÍÎ/ø�ßbXAUżBj40���4/��
�Xk�0���4� ¸��Ø
�ÕE+0�>Yè#äS+V���
��VW�¿Ày�Õ0�µ��Ø
!Xy���q�9�C��àá
ѿ����$%LL� Luis Guillermo Plata �o
Á�*#&Ì'(u"@)*N+�
j�Ö×"�b}XÓ�/0>@#
ÓÏD�Ä:)NÃy©Â�qÏÐ
©Â�dC�X�øÁÂC�X3y
:0���@�����
�'·�KX/012y��0`�
�¡¢���q?Ð E+@ä�ê
�����VW�/0É|�Q�Ù
+ú��@ä>=ö�º!CÍ�Z
öXßbàáÑ¿�âã¿HþÑä
¿�Ö×��b}�/012yG%
Ã�������e�����å�
?ø +GúûKæH¿À���î
kE+þ��Q�Hþ���/�°
fXPÁÂþ��Q�Hþ���j
E+�d�*0H{|eD��Õ
�����ê/012Ð(á
�ìí��krÞySTkúû�
^ëM�@øXÃ�Çëì�,
-MXíî.q�Qñ�����Ø
VW�µ���"STO��ìí�
��ÚÛ����
�����VW����kÖ@ 183 ¸CÍÎX,µ�vuCÍÎH$Â,�0�V,zúû�µÁÂ
0��úûA5+îü@X����
��VW��úû�û/0�0`4
RH¡¢£¤Ã�1¢ã£%�Ø
V@Q�����VW��4���
��W�úûñ��XØ
Ù+ú¿À�û4RH¡¢£¤�Ø
}~XÙ+ú��¿À!�ûü�C
�.������VW���°fî
/� ©q��.X"gº» @Q
4R�¡¢£¤HC�.�*ØXØ
@Î� �î1�úûH56G®�Ø
k�©Â¿ÀVÑboâãäå
EN6�(ôÓHQõ��¿ÀXXØ
LM��Vü@C�.���XHØ
LM�Ð�ûj�Ì4P#�©qØ
4R�Á�cd/�$%K´�tg
ëì�Ó}X�����VW�?ø
��4�êCZÄ*@Qnó�4R
�&ý+ó�&ý�ô/����
��VW�þ+�Ðê²���À
_�4Xjµ¸&K+nóVßb�
F��Hy4R|C���XM�Ø
#Óå0XÄP��k�Ð�e~�
µ¸å0�e~�Ð!�y¹nóØ
�q8@³Æ¯ZC��&ýº»�Ø
·�KX183 ¸CÍÎ� 11000 +�ó�&ùyº»�����VW�
¿À�c�úû�qº» �Î�v
��VWW� 8200 +�ó�&ù�·��. 14.1 µ�� µ¸¿À����.°f&ú������VW�
tu¶æ µ¸CÍÎHµ¸¿À�
��.°f&ú�°f&ù�ó�&
ù+12üùXCZþk�����
VW�µ¸t|�]��4RH¡¢
£%á(å/+º»ø}�è��I
�y4RH¡¢G´�qXÓ}Ù+
ú��.°f&ù!�R÷�7ë7
8��.�°f&ù�7ëæçDH
7ø��üù�ú�mû���[Ü
�� 2.1:
� <5#ÓL�ÏÐ��å/���XàáÑ¿�345H1¼þ��C
ÍÎEF Ïs%¹62V���¡¢3ù[Xj�����VW�µ�¿
ÀØDc)�������£Ýµ�Ô@ 20 +¸0�EF �/LWê�Á«3ù[XÁÂ0��v½¿ê�¿�f´��K/¿�Vµ0XV4H
z�pµ½HÝ��żB+��H0�5õà�AUżB�6þ¿Å¼
B�H0�żBmôà�0H���H0p½¾Hµ¿�s�9¿�Ü*
+Ù�949+�H0�54+7H89+ÙpÛܼÃ��Õ�À�Ø
âã¿�þÑä¿��¼�H:Ñ¿pÃ�¼8§Õ�£��¼�./àH
6��
� CÍÎÏ~X¿sCô�� (APEC) �þø�����VW�9Ncd�¡¢���ßàXy�OÍÎ,zCÍκ!�!ZCÍÎÃ�<%N
î�eÀ�2009 �¿sCô��³� ���ýþ´²ÜÝ�X,eÀ�È 2015 ��@¹�À������X 25%���«»´Hýþ´º! 25%�Ã:j���R{|X£Ýî)<% 5 ¸!9ßàoáâ���éê7ë�(ôÓ��ñ0òóÃ�âãEN�s�K�x¸å0�o
¿sCô��/CÍÎj<%eÀîÐê���X7~X°y��!Z
CÍÎXÑb¯���/�H§0�jG%£ÝÃý�O#yÁÂßàHj
¡¢���Oö1�
1. >���"#_æ��� Muhamad Noor * 2010 � 3 ¾ 25 ¶��J�BJ���;����J ���m�����Â�´���(¢ http://www.apec.orgQ
16 2011 �������
÷�EüiÜ÷H,zó�&ù°±
@Qñ0òó�ð�HEüEN6
���{;�Ø
�����VW�yúûC�Ø
�q��4#���+9:��{
;��4XJî]]� ���yØ
©¸�<��ÚHÎ��µ�ñI 100–150 ������R÷k�¹&KÑ��áâî*=±XÓ���á
âîñI���Ôú�@$Ô+x
Ô�M¼4üµ��ëå�@.û
¸XÓ}k�M¼*�� �Ò�N
OâãM¼P§����
Ü~µ¸¿À��4>T�¾X8@
�gMXPgaó�F�(�§â�
&ýWê ¿À�G%å/XÄP5
6§â|�rûM�Q�¿À�··
¤¥ ��Cm.y(��Cͧ¶
�|�Ø
�����VW�?øhi�!
4kM«¿ÀÇAHÜ~���}~
Ô"a ,z�4X�v?øtd�
MHBgwÈ�M���m²X?ø
td�MHBgw�M���
êhi�!4���R��Ó�v�
���ýþ´¹��µ�v� 9 ¸¿À�kÉ|�QÚq¥#ÚÛXÓ
}X?ø hi�!4�Ø
VW��4+�K#��/��
Õ*td�bû/0º��E�ß
bXyôÓ4(�qXC�úû�
¶$�ÏJåß��µ�ßà¡vÄ
&!CD� 50% �ÇÈ 200%XÓ�m²úvÒu�ìR#sNO%4T
º��Ø
7$¸Õ*]�È�â���í
��°NOk��áâîý����
X�����VW�_® £%
�í��°X# �rdS^9ôç�
yE+CÍÎX�dS^9ôçí�
�°�$LM�� &'j����
��XÄ 2004 �ÃK?ø j�í��°úv�Ø
v��VWk$¸¿À�V÷ø
ùå¿À�X�'t�4/� �
��� kå&5½4H@þ���
���@�÷>¡¢£¤ÏÐ��
�®X�����VW�y�
' 3 �äV�vv��VWXk÷øùå¿À�� G�4� $³�
���yÁ¸�K��Ó�X��
Ä,�0�1����de�{
;µÐ� ÷øùå¿À�X"¿´
ùåyº»1�E+de0�m(
ÜÝ+�Î�?�#dØ@øÁ¸¿
À��2009 �%ùå�m�$=���v�Z� @ø¿À�_¤20�ØØ
�}Ï~X����Ôyê
$¸ø}u�ô/V�ù�v�²4
R÷�÷tê÷ù-.Ã�K�0�
�å���Cô���QÐ�ÎH�
&L��ó�XXk÷øùå¿À�
�'t�4�÷�""¡BK��
�ßà21��'$�äXÁ¸ø}u
�6@á�.Ô[X,º»�¿�
�'t�4y.¸�q���A%
R{X$ÂÕ*�Cyv��VWä
êÈHj���ø}�KH�f�Ø
�ÕÈB9�XÓ}Xv��VW#
º»CÍÎ�÷øùå¿À�ÔXy
��ýþ´¹Î��µ�#�vÁ¸
É|XÄ�º» �¹¿ÀC��Ø
úû�@Q�å¡¢£¤�v~úû
NÃy�����VW��tu|Ø
¨È22�Ø
Èe�cX÷øùå¿À�4
���kÞô0��å���Q�
�YK´5½H¡¢£¤µNOB
C������´5½>lÃD��
eª�«�µÞå/¯úHYåí
��q�|°H�°���å&5½
4H��¡¢£¤µ��´°GÏ
Ð��º» $¸¬VW�úûØ
��X�
�����VW��Ñê��Ó
~Lþ�çQ�X�vÓ0�ðCk
r�GWê0y@Q��å8H�4
�q�a �
y�4|/���@Õ²>yØ
�����VW�µHVWtu/�
���}~Xµ¸¿ÀHCÍÎ�
úû�ÐN�>¶æytu|Vù
¿À+¹CÍÎ8Ô�DVW��´
� B�´X�� º»8@NÑM
��г�/����ûXVWbû
�4�Õ*Húû¸;kúû��
&EÜ~�tuÔº» ø� �
¤¥����@qBúû��Ø
@Qúû¸;�78��yúû
ñ�µ"¶æyVWtu|�Y�?
øT�¾�ìRKNXgh&!Nk
úûº�Gg�b�C�úû�6&
KP6j@�EX�\]/�¸;�
1.Ø À_���v�<%¡¢£%k�����1¢ã�P�®¾M �4�
¹�4Nø�_®$¸4R�eÛX
�N_®©¸4Rßà�eÛXÔN
k$¸0���@4R�R�_®�Ø
2.Ø Á�q�v�����Fdeu���÷�V2008 �XXÃ�K�0�ðCkr ��·��Ø
3. µ�>k 183 ¸CÍÎ���ó����ÃC�H*�úû�µ¸CÍÎ�
��ó��i������VW�tu (http://www.doingbusiness.org)�
4.Ø De Soto V2000 �X�Ø
5.Ø @Qñ0�òóHEüEN6�¿À��$¸CÍÎR{iäÖ°G�Ø
Ó]X�v���`Êú�ûFHá
qGH»f���
������ 17
6.Ø http://www.doingbusiness.org/Subnational�ØØ
7.Ø SchneiderV2005 �X�Ø
8.Ø http://www.enterprisesurveys.org�Ø
9.Ø Cô��X7¼©kl¡¢¿ÀtÆ?Xhttp://www.oecd.org/�
10.Ø ��CÍ ���: �Zö¿ú�?ø �����VW�áâ���
÷øùå�5½ìíîHéê7ëØ
Vô4AþX�úû�µ�LMúû�
11. Narayan �&V2000 �X�Ø
12.Ø ��V2003 �X�Ø
13.Øv��VW#º»��I�éêqö¿À+÷øùå¿ÀXy��ýþ
´¹Î��µ�#�v|�É|�
¿4. http://scholar.google.com�
15.ØßboM a s a t l i o g l u H R i g o - l i n iV2008 �XXKaplan�Piedra H SeiraV 2 0 0 7 �XXA r d a g n H L u s a g iV2009 �XÃ� DjankovV2009 � bX�Ø
16.ØßboA l e s i n a �&V2 0 0 5 �XXP e r o t t i H Vo l p i nV 2 0 0 4 �XXKlapper�Laeven H RajanV2006 �XXF i s m a n H S a r r i a - A l l e n d eV2004 �XXAntunes H CavalcantiV2007 �XXBarseghyanV2008 �XXDjankovV2009 � bXXÃ� Klapper�Lewin H Quesada DelgadoV2009 �X�
17.ØßboFreund H BolakyV2008 �XXChang�Kaltani H LoayzaV2009 �XÃ� Helpman�Melitz HRubinsteinV2008 �X�
18.Ø NunnV2007 �X�
19.Ø Houston �&V2010 �X
20.Ø ��V2009 � eX�Ø
21.Øø}u���A��Ã���Ö×X���������VW÷øØ
ùå¿Àø}u��h t t p : / / w w w.doingbusiness.org/�
22.Ø www.doingbusiness.org�
18 2011 �������
�����VW�µº�"M �Ø
¿À®����¡¢£¸H¼AØ
5½AAÃ�c)k��XÂ,�µ
uv0`���eÛ�89X/¿À
ç�¡¢�K´XÑbdâã+5Ø
P§aOáâ��+îæç+�IØ
��è¼�¶mXc)®¡¢�Ø
��XÑbd �+5�ÐH��a
O(ôÓ�9�M¼KN+î�
ñ0òó�¶ÓXc)®kè¼�Ø
4R5½K´XÑb5½ìíîî�
��)*)�JK+î[\²¼P5
nó4��"�í¼NÃø/P5�
¶LX@$¸¿À�ç����ð��
JXÔ@$¸¿À�®��¡¢
�#Ó�q�
�2011 �����VW�µ�@¿À��úû��¯�� 2010 � 6 �=1�Ø
�����VW��úû�Y�À_
¾�4?���89X�����Ø
VW���H§âù{&ù$ùiÜ
$0���}��ø$¸hi�Ø
��åß<5CÍÎÏÐÃ�#Ó�
ÐxÏÐ�NÑMXÓ}k���Ø
4Rý��£�Ùu��y��,Ø
���MG>� $%�«i�Ø
���� 8200 +���ó�jä�X�vR÷���ø}ù{�[Ü÷�
úû-ã�12üùÃ��&4RØ
4£�q¯Z¢ã+ø}�ó�&ù
V. 14.1X�ÁÂó�ê�����VW���� úM}²X}²Ø
���qr[�7N]KH���
Ì�O{�� P��2011 �����VW�X���ù6O{� 33 ¸CÍÎXÃ�6úû"QR��k
Ö����êúû�NõMSC_
�XÄP@�?��78.C¸�+
F��Ø
�����VW�� G�4@
.¸!I�Á¸�4ûMT�X�ø
*j78��4R4£�`a"DE
+Ôê����kÖ�}²ÃTp
k{|�ÊyE��¨È��kÖ�
öv"�"#�$¸{|XÓ��C
k�Q4R4£���� C��
k±å�_<M�� 'j�Á¸
�4��#!PgaóFGXÓ}N
ÃÄÙ®�CÍÎ"�µC�úû�
Ó�yúûC�µ@ø À_¾�Ø
«iX/GÑÒHR_y¹CÍÎÏ
Ð>�@���JXÁÂúû#�
4� ��q��8Ρ¢���K
´XPgÔ¨� c)�bæ"¿�
N�����
�����VW�� G�4@�¸
�q��°Xy�åúû�fÇÃØ
ñ·�89XC��úû�ºÈ C
ÍÎÙ���\kä���XÓ}
�E#O-.,z���¡¢Ö×�
� �\Á¸{|Xy 2009–2010 �´X� 6 ¸CÍÎ�F ��ø������VW�¿ÀXÁ 6 ¸CÍÎ�oàáÑ¿�f´ã/¿�âã¿�
ã¯þ¿�ÊR+ÙHD"+2�y 2009–2010 �´�C�� Q�ÙÚã¿ÚnÊ4�$�\k�×�eX
$0��ø��;yùRú��Ø
}~X$¸\k�×0e;y�ñ�
L\kUÊ (Juba) ��$¸�ÀVW�Cy¾Õ½�LáBXQÚ 7 ¸CÍÎVÅ4Êã¿�½V�W*X�Ø
�,-�54+7�VYH14�¿X
� 16 ¸\k�zKz+Á"���VW#ì°%�*�Xî$%��
`�Ðê��(+îFÙ0e��ã
QÚ��ÄPj*+\k�v�K�
v�àáÑ¿�ã¯þ¿�ÊR+Ù
HùRú���ø��0eÃ�½�
¾��À����Á�Ì����ø
��0em²XyÓ$¸CÍÎ�µX
���]´H��ýþ´y#Ó�\k
ÏÐÙ#�Ó�
¶mXúûCZZ[�©$G8
Îý����X$\�¿%£��
@°&g9:V+4R|ê,�Ó�
jÎXX�Ã�E#O-.,z��
�4£¡¢Ö×XÑb¸Îå�J�
¶ÓXÀ_¾åßÖ¥µ]��*�
¿��$�8Î�{|X�E#O-
.$���SÈ��@{|�¶LX
�Ð�®Ð\�sÖ���ó��
ëì���²#Ó�ëì�X���
´ 14.1
1,406
605
1,128
1,127
874
891
1,279
984
852
602
862
ef�� 19
��VW�äq��пÀ¤?øØ
yÀ_¾åß�«iÏ��Ì°f�
µL�
JXÁ¸�4«i��?@Ø
cd�:L78PgyâP§�#^
�gh�Ð�yj_�µXb���
|�78+î^�##\]Xâ9$
0P§�E[ �*���Ð�7$
GNO�X���E\%#ã[©
Âcd�P§�Ó�Áx¸qÓX
�2011 �����VW�µ`²��ÐaEXNO[ê������
���+,z�ÖM��µ���)
�°b@�#Ó�
y$¸��Qó�Hþ�çQ���
�ø}u��¿��X÷øùå¿À
� G�4v�@�*�3�Á¸¿À
ü@��yv����ýþ´¹��
�µ�Ø
��VWmËϯX$=Ó·Ì
���Õb�oYåíÑO�Ü~
�4@Õ¾XÃ<5uÂü@gh
Yåí�CÍÎ�+î4RpÑ�
Yåíº» ¡¢�GÄ�#Oyj
_µêÈ(�CÍÎ�Ô@d��
@cßM�Yåíd�Yåí�
yø�9�L��CÍÎ>#[éê
!êM�iF eª�«��°H
µÞå/¯ú�|°XÃ<5ü@C
ÍÎÓ�yÁÂßà�M¦±Py�
M�Kµ�Èýd�JXÔÕ*
�ê�å/�ÐþM¿úP��e
ù��H�«��Ü~X#ØW�
20 �åÅå&X��W� 1 �åÅ�5 �åÅH 10 �åÅå&��!L�Ø
�����VW�úû�û�¶ÙØ
LM4R4£>NÃy�����
(GNI)
�2011 �����VW�äVW� 2009 �&!CDX����2010 ���m(¿À�m.�úû�CDøÅU¼+�4 (Atlas method) Ü~V§�²KX�k�Ã&!CD�ÄMÑK.´���
¿ÀK�X2009 �ç�Ü~�0Q¹CD�Mf�Ä��Ø
ü@��0� 2 0 0 9 ��0Q¹CDXÁÂ0��oÅÆÇ�ÊÜ
�ö��Êß�Bþg\�1hØ
�+�2FUä¿�i¿u�Ø
¾ � � ð ³ V µ 0 X � � 5
Ç+Ç��/��Åj�½+Ø
k/�Å84�AUżB�Ø
�ä��#ý�V4Vµ0X�
½lm�żBmôà�0�Ø
�no/pHÇA�eXÔ@É
ÊËÌ�yÁÂåß�µX:)
@ø&!0`ܼ¹L (GDP) +î&!0Qܼ¹L (GN P) Ã�
��OXÁÂúûK��0�úqR
¡������CÍ(<�úû�
H�Cͧ&�78L (Economist Intelligence Unit)�Ø
�����VW�@ø���
M«À_��ÀHCDM«XØ
�� http://www.worldbank.org/data/countryclass���k!CDCÍÎü@��ÀM«����
��VW�µXkCô��!CD
CÍÎrl ó��7�À?M«X
c)°��7Cô��!CD?Ø
$«�¨H.µ`²��À�!L
�vK��@CD«N�CÍÎØ
VY�µsY�µs!H!CDX�
�2011 �����VW�VW�&'X��2010 ���m(¿À�9Ë� 2 0 0 9 ��µ�&'6Üúû�
VW�tu|¨ÈX� ht t p://w w w.doingbusiness.org�/¸¿À�û��@t"��H���9ËyÁ¸tu
|�b�k�4@g{+îkúû@
ZXNY�tu|�7º{?ÇO
ºn�Ø
�����VW�µ�mË 8967 ¸¿À���FÁ¿ÀX���Ø
��VW���c® 52000 +¸úûIXµ¸úûI>Ny�����
VW�tu|¨È�µ¸¿ÀHCÍ
Î���úûXÄ¿À+CÍÎCD
VW�¶$�ùXtu|>@�� Ø
º»$¸NÑÒ��г����X
�����VW�tu|º»���
úû��C��k�X&' �4�
�ÕHúû�¸;�
� 2 0 1 1 �����VW�jØ�$0��K´¿ÀXøÃ���Ä
�2006 �����VW�m.ÃK����µXµ¸CÍÎ���¡¢Ø
��Ķk·¸|�mÜ ��"�
Õ¾��2011 �����VW�µ���ýþ´¹���v 9 ¸��¡¢ßàXb�êÁÂßà�f�úû
ü@Õ¾XÁ$�À_�[n$¸µ
MêMpb�Õ¾�=¿À���XØ
¤n$¸;êMpb�Õ¾k¿À¼
Ü#þeÛX¤n$¸�êM�Ø
¹¿Àk��ýþ´¹���$
Gº�XJîjµ$¸CÍÎ��
¿Àê�����VW�t"µ�@
20 2011 �������
,zCÍÎ�¿À�kÑ�Y�¿
�$%�Ðä�¶kÕ¾XÁ¸¿À
%µ$¸CÍÎ.�c����Ø
¡¢��ê���ÑmÜ +ÙÕ
¾X�'��µFÜmÜÕ¾Ù�
CÍÎêM!�Ø
Á¸�¿ÀML¸å0EFo
1.ض$åXêM�¶kYNX�����VW� 9 ¸É|�µ$¸��¿À>i�Ü~X� 28 0¿À�ÑbXáâ��@ 4 ¸¿ÀoP§��Ð���V&!0Q¹CD�Ø
ÄMÑXÃ�Yj�í�dSØ
V&!0Q¹CD�ÄMÑX�Ø
/CÍÎu$Ü~Á¿Àµµ¸
¿À��´¶kÕ¾�Ñb�X
�2006 �����VW�_�©¸CÍÎáâ���cd��Ð�
200 3Py�2007 �����VW�µ�ø 50 3XÁ¸CÍÎ�[@$¸ 150 3�Õ¾ç��ÑPXb��Ð�ÇÈ 350 3Xu�[@$¸� 150 (–150) 3�ç��
2.Ø� @�@¿À>@$¸¹��XY�jÕ¾L£�È 0–1 ���
`X@굸¿À���>8@
NÑMXÕ¾Lz!��©¸CÍ
Îy©¸¿À|�¶k��Ñ,z
CÍÎzÙ�¶måXØÔkÁÂ
Õ¾L���XÄP@©¸¿À
�XYY�$¸�MêÈ&'XØ
Pº!Y�$¸;MK&'�0 M.´ü@mÜghÕ¾4�Ø
3.Ø� ����¡¢�@ 9 ¸ßà��ÕX?ø#Ó¿À�@êM�Ø
hi�!LKÜ~µ¸CÍι�
�´Õ¾K´¿À�Y�@øhi
�!LXÁ¸�¿Àþ+��ýþ
´��?ø��4�
4.ØJX�µ¸CÍÎ��´Õ¾K´¿À�ÇXÃ��CÍÎ���
¡¢��y�'��µ�Õ¾�
[\��ýþ´¿úX/CÍÎ��
ÔNÄ 1 È 183�k�µ¸CÍÎP�Xcy¹¿ú|����� 9 ¸É|µµ¸É|ÄMÑ���hi�!
L��XÁ 9 ¸É|�vy�2011 �����VW�¿ú�µXc)�o
áâ���âãäåEN6�æçè
¼�éê7ë�5½ìíî�ïð�
ñ0òó�(ôÓHQõ���Ø
µ¸É|���X��,��¿ÀØ
ÄMÑ���hi�!LV. 14.2X�«b©¸CÍÎy©¸8Îßà
ü@4R4£�¡¢XÑbM¼XØ
Á¸CÍÎ�[@êÈ7ü@j_?
�Àv�ÓãXb�4R4£@�@X
Äyj_µü@êÈHjp+îÁG
j_�È7~êÏwx�4R4£�
ycX$¸CÍÎ[CÈ$¸7ü@
j_?+7#NO?�Àv�# �
�GÖ×X$¸7ü@j_?��
MÀv�[jÁ¸CÍÎÄ�¹¿ÀØ
����¨�
�qȸß~K���l"��
��y��Xáâ$¸��cdâ
5 GP§� � 5 3�ÐH���&!�CD 2.3% ��ø�Yí�dS�&!CD� 11.97%�Á 4 ¸¿ÀX���ÄMÑ��MN� 13%�4%�15% H 63%��ÃXyáâ��ýþ´¿À|X����!ÄMÑ�
�� 24%�cy5½ìíî¿À|�ÄMÑ��� 50%Xñ0òó¿À�
´ 14.2
ef�� 21
ÄMÑ��� 39%X(ôÓ¿À�ÄMÑ��� 10%XQõ��¿À�ÄMÑ��� 9%X��Ã}«³���z!.´¡¢zhi�kè¼A
�5½z@ö���y�@É||�
ÄMÑ���hi�!L� 25%��@CÍÎ>[\c)��!ÄMÑ
�Ô�N�rX���y¶ 15 ò�?ø*F|�zô�4XßbØ
td��¿ÀHBgw���¿ÀX
¼Ü�K���.b9:$"5�yz
zô�4k��.bü@��eÛX
Ó� 9 ¸¿À�y/¸É||�QÚq>¥#æÚ��ÃX�����Ø
VW�@øhi��4�
��ýþ´¿úXy��|�@
�°M��Á¸¿úü@����Ó
]oCÍÎ�rõ�Ùkl�,R
{iä!�V#�êñ0òó@Q�Ø
!�X�G®�¡¢Î³�jö�è¼Ø
��:MV#[�È{|HJKXXØ
Ã�CÍÎ�fgCÍh�+îb�
G´�ö´�y��"�£¸G´[
��G���Â��@ä�@���
CÍÎ�0Ö[kÁÂ{|¼Ü��
"�eÛ�{||Ôcd¦§ÌÙ®
���å/������VW��Ø
¿Àº» $}��C�úûX�E
NÃ��kÁÂ{|�ã��
�2011 �����VW�Ô?ø $Ghi��4KÜ~�ÂCÍ
Îy��ýþ´|��Ù�89X
VWy�uÂkv���ýþ´�
�ÙÚ� 9 ¸É|µ 3 ¸+ 3 ¸Ã|É|�����CÍÎX@ 25 ¸CÍÎÞôÁ$À_Xc)�oCDØ
"+��;�ËRï4*�7ê��
þ�Qt�H0�s�9¿�sßØ
ï5�i¿u�¼2þ�f´ã/¿�
~��Ü*+Ù�Féê��ä�Ø
VY�6��345�AUżB�Ø
1¼þ��+õ�ã¿�#ö�89
+Ù�×��z�H:Ñ¿�Ø
¶mX�����VW�þøNÑÒ
���XbûÁÂCÍÎ��ýþ´
��Ò$��º!K´Xkc)Ø
����
v����ýþ´¹Î��à 9 ¸¿À���ûXc)�oáâ���
âãäåEN6�æçè¼�éê7
ë�5½ìíî�ïð�ñ0òó�
(ôÓHQõ���
�����VW�ç�$ò���d
áâ";�û�$¸å�+����
�Xü�;�dS��@P§�ÁÂ
P§�véÐ�@�d�(\HEN
"9��@dS�YW��6+î�
��@�QAö���ùå�ñI�
áâ��ýþ´���,��¿ÀÄ
MÑ���hi�!LV¨ 14.1X�ØC���@Q��_D�4R�
£¸H9á78ÃJXG% $¸Ø
���P§piXÓ�w| y$\
Ö×�â㵸P§�cd��ÐH
��Ã�Yj�í�dS�ÑJX
�����ø}R÷H12üù9�
"�6ÁÂúû�
ÔC� @QâãP§�rNØ
Ã�P§�rNÃÓ�âã�78�
:)�«i�oghcd�78>N
Ã�ý�éêPgáâ���Kµ]
�È��@L�ym��O�>#Æ
y���b���ó�)�°±�²
YNXj[¦§���XÏÈúû
�ô�c�
� /¸CÍÎ�úû@NÑ
MXk��H�QP§� .¸Ø
«i�
¹��o
Ø �$¸@°&g9:�b�©¸C
Íε@.G«v�@°&g9:X
¤yz0`��ä&�$G«
v�Q�&�9:«v�78
K���ø}R÷+î6Ü���
Ø yCÍÎÙ���\kû��
Ø �Ø100% �0`9:"@ 5 ¸�tXü@$¸�t�4RjÎ�
Ø ×²í¡� 2009 ��&!CD� 10 xXø²¡ôç�Ø Ä*$\Må�+��±²Xßb
ܼ+%9�¶¥¼©+!��}
��#Ä*~òÄ�#C�cþ�
UNðCG´�¼©XÑb�â�
>+î���#?ø��r��Ü
¼�K�
Ø ����í�Hâ9�X#���¼
�@î�
Ø ü@ísBÖìíÈT@ä+îg
hUN�!��
Ø áBû�ÃJ�$¸�`X�5@ 10 ¸�+@ 50 ¸÷ùXÁÂ÷ù:L>��09Q�
Ø ��v�55È&!CD� 100 x�Ø @$¸ 10 Æ��9:¸K�
%
25% 25%
25%25%
^ 14.1
4
22 2011 �������
P§�%¸�o���B&ê~L�
*&Vßbo12���R÷�÷Ü
&ù+96&ùXÏÐ�gh}²�
���B&+��¢ã&ùêùåÏ
Ð�}²#~/P§���yÓ$¸
Eü�Äy#Óâ9�`9��P
§X~/#Ó�P§�b����B
&��O{Ó$¸â9�C.ÔXÃ
âã#ÓrN�P§Xu�µ$ÔO
{>di�Ü~�Áä«i�B&>
���âã�@�P§X#øµÐ
&�!���[Ü÷+R÷X��4
RdS��@øÁ"�¶Ó��b�
dSó�&ù�!�Xz)-.��
âã�P§dMNi�Ü~�µ$¸
q~P§>di�Ü~�b�x¸P
§NÃyÓ$¸tu9�XÄdSM
NliX¤~/x¸P§�Ø
���y;�û�$¸��ü
�dSâã�ñIHñIJP§>
°ç��KV. 14.3X�ü�7N+îê9����]K
�dS�P§�°ç��K�ÑbX
b���Vbïð-�X|dSÇÚ
���f¸Xu�éÐf¸�~/P
§�Ó"Xb�yæç��ð+�L
ðÏ����áF�JXu�
âãáJ�d~/$¸P§°�vy
`�»��@y�¥�� 4 ¸h��Ö×�aÜ~y`oô4��YÙ�
>NÃø�Ù+ú��>ø�íP#
øÁ»�[��jGMaE�
�@uÂ�@��>dSâã�
P§a�vy`�þk¸N��P
§°��y~�ÑbXþ��54£
�P§X�@yc)yø��@Ä*
$\Må�+��±²����a°
�vy`�9:âã�sYq�á�
HH��Dã!��/GP§X>ü
��y`�
�Ð�ø¯�3úç���¹¿ÀÐ
��ø}R÷)¿��9�$¸P
§�c�ÐVy9�P§cd�ê1
2��Ð�^�å/5Xg#cd
v~ç��Ö×�X�µL�Áä«
iµ¸P§dS�>�Ð� 1 3�H¢P§NÃÓ�mÜXÄ�c)#
NOyÓ$3áBV����XÓ�
��P§9Jy#Ó�¯�áBX�
$n��CÈ���XP§ý~9
�XÑb���Èc�ñI6©+î
ð����b�v~���O#Ç]
P§�âãXu�yz«�P§�
Áä«i���#[^��ÐPgy
9�P§�#�E�Ð����ø�
¹�78��Ð�?#Ü�Áä«i
���Ä$áB�m �@�_D4
£Ã�c)�9JrNXÄ����
*9"ü@Hghâ*üù�s�
m³�
��øCÍÎ&!CD�ÄMÑKØ
ç�X�v�@�ü��øXÃ�y
4RdS�Ö×�X4R+ó�&ý
�!���b�4RdS�rX¤9
:�����Hô4¾�ø�Ü~y
`�9:4���£�H8Î4£Ã
�C���.ø/��Ü~�Kæb
û�yü@C����Ö×�X12
üù�eÜ°�/$Gü��D�y
ü@12üùeÜ�Ö×�X¤?ø
��ø}R÷�eÜ�b�.¸��
ø}R÷º»#Ó�eÜX�?øµ
ÐúL�y�@Ö×�X��$R#
�v���
Yj�í��dS&' yæçñI
ÏÃ�9:�FJ 3 ¸�`���cdÆD+nn96&�yúXÃC
ÍÎ&!CD�ÄMÑKç��¹y0
�úv$\���£�+9:4£%�
A+CÍÎ>@Yí��dSXÄ
�DE��yæçñIÏNÃ�ç
,µ$LMX,�LMNÃyû�$
�ÃJôç�y·ÙþX2009 � 6 ��k@°&g9:�Yí�dS�
´ 14.3
%
%
ef{Q
ef�� 23
10000 ¾�XÄyñIÏ�5dôç,µ� 2500 ¾��Ó}X·Ùþ�Yj�í��� 2500 ¾�+î��&!CD� 10.1%�y./àXYí�dS� 50000 Ñ*XñIÏcdôç,µ��MÏ$XÓ}X./à�YØ
j�í��� 10000 Ñ*+î��&!CD� 9.2%�
d �µ¸CÍÎáâ�����ú
ûXiO{ http://www.doingbusiness.orgXy�¼�iäyzCÍÎ�N¨È�Á$¿À��4�� Djankov �&�ô(V2002 �Xµº��XÁä/ $Â���
�����VW�ç�Eü���
�Ei$¸À_¾��cdâ��@
P§�ÁÂP§�v%¢ãL�ºn
ê8Î0e�Q�:L��Vßbo
Eü¨H²l�¨Xpéê�@��
�^_�(\�EN6H6�p9�
�@�YWpÃ�sÖ$é���1
�������VW�Ôç�sY
q�á��áHo%Ê�qr��c
�P§�æçè¼Ãø/P5+�I
n7$¸jÎ�c�P§�Ü~y
`������VW������
Ei$¸����KM��<8Î�
P§"Ü~y;ZÖ×�j�9�µ
¸P§�c��ÐH���âãäå
EN6ýþ´���,��¿ÀÄM
Ñ���hi�!LV¨ 14.2X�78�ÄäåEN�q�ó�u
äC��X�vEü÷�Eüø}R
÷�Eü9:�9ø*�!�º»�Ã
�âãEü4£V�v÷^H1�X�
12üù��@úûyCÍÎÏÐ8@
NÑMXk�����Ei0eH9ø
iä�sY� .¸«i�
¹��VEü9:Xo
Ø �$¸@°&g9:�
Ø yCÍÎ�Ù���\kû��
Ø � 100% �0`�&�@�Ø @ 5 ¸�tX>#�4RjÎ�Ø @�M�ENH5!jäEü0eX
ÑbE����
Ø @ 60 �äå&ùH,z÷ùX>��09QX>8@éêäåENH÷
^�c�jâó�OöH��C��
Ø �5@$¸÷ù�¬6Eü÷"y
��Eü÷�[ñI�
Ø ��ï�@ðy"éê�@���
yø�9:$\��±²�5!Ø
VÑbEüå&·~5!H¶Ó�
&g5!X�
Ø ?@Ei������
¹��o
Ø j°ø�$\��Ʊ²XÑb©
�+�8��Æ�#ø��Ægh
cdU�h��ú�XÑb)©�
¾§©+��©�
Ø @x¨X>y�|X¹q��Ø
1300.6 ��=V1400 ���<XXµ¨! 3 =V9 �< 10 � X�
Ø @ �NYXò�CÍÎÙ�Ø
��\kkÀÞ�VÇy¹\k�
Ö¡XÄÊD�,;�Ö�à X̀�
Ø #yUNCÍ+å�Àäq��¥
��yÀ�dSXÇEyNÃ3È
«����Àà�
Ø �� 929 ��=V10000 ���<XXg���¢ 100% x�|�Eü9:"y���H0�æç�Q_<
ñI�
Ø �$¸�E0eVÏÁ¢�|Ø
ü@EüX�
Ø ?@�$�¬6Eü÷G%�9k
�äåHj⨣�
Ø j?@$édS�jâi XÃý
@��O#9:û/�
Ø j � 3 0 Þ�ÐEiV#�vÓ1H¡¢dSPmÜ��@Ø
aEX�
sYqöoØ
Ø ¤¥tqt 10 =V32 �< 10 � X�Ø �µ¦�3 ��4 � Y ¢s�140 §¨�
(kVA) ¢s�yäåÀ@ 3 �qæ!�Nø�
Ø jY�!!�FqX��yÁ¸
\kÖ¡�Àü@!!�iä�
Ø �cdhi¢sX��dS��$
¸óøÕquVÕ¦©X+îaª
t%�
Ø �dS��$¸q.�
«%¹Eü9:@$ò¬6qå
K9���`L�q�ËÄ�
»áH�á¢so
Ø ¥²@áæH�á s' 10 =«V32 �< 1 � X�Ø #dS�bøápP�@ø¬Ø
³6VØ�X�b�4RdS®�
�b³6XÁä«i�q£%�Ø
øácS����bøá�
%
^ 14.2
3
33.3%
33.3% 33.3%
24 2011 �������
Ø ¯�!øá® 662 9ãV175 Ç X̄X
¯�!�á&® 568 9ãV150 Ç X̄�
Ø !°¯øá®5È 1 3 2 5 9ãV350 ǯXX!°¯�á&®5È 1136 9ãV300 ǯX�Ø Z�@¬§�%�øá®H�áØ
&®�
qr¢so
Ø ¤¥trt 10 =V32 �< 10 � X�Ø �o%�Ê�qr��
P§�%¸�o9:�ùå+î¢ã
&ùê~L�*&ÏÐ�gh}²X
~L�*&�v12���96&ù�
��æçL����¢ã�Q�9ø
iä9:�9�H�&1�&ùÃ�
jâó�XÄ#�v��`L�Eü
÷HåK÷�9:ùåÏÐ�}²X
Ñb��¨£�G%Hùå�Ì�1
�X>#~/P§�9:�sYq�
á��áHqr!�Pâ�P§��
vy`��@4R|+j_µdS��
ÃE����e��P§>Ü~y
`XÇýy¸NÖ×�NÃíîÁÂ
P§V. 14.4X�
�Ð�[\¯�3úç���¹¿À
?ø ��ó�)¿��j��µâ
9P§�cd�Ð�µL�Áä«
iµ¸P§�c�5�Ð� 1 3�H¢P§NÃÓ�mÜXÄ�c)#
NOyÓ$3áBV����XÓ�Ø
��P§�9Jy#Ó¯�áB
�X�b�v~���O#Ç]P§
�âãXu�yz«�P§�Áä
«iÁ¸Eü9:#[^��ÐPg
y9�µ$¸tâP§�#�E�
Ð�¹Eü9:ø�¹�78��Ð
�?#Ü�Áä«i¹9:Ä$áB
�m �@�EüdSÃ�c)�Ø
9JrN�
��[\CÍÎ&!CD�ÄMÑç
���ç�;��ø��9�ê�4
Ei��@Q��@P§Pôç��
ø:L>dç�X�véê��@ø
÷^HäåiÜEN��øpäå
�äåµÐH±åJsÖ1���
øpsY9øiä��øÃ�æç�
�è¼��ø�9���Ei0e�
c��#�FmÜ�ðy�dç��
K�Eü£����ó�º»�78
H8Î4£Ã�C���°ø/Ü~
���Kæ�û�b���.¸ó�
º»�eÜ#ÓX¤?øµÐúL�
d �µ¸CÍÎâãEüEN���Ø
úûXiO{ http://www.doingbusiness.orgXy�¼�iµyzCÍÎ�N¨È�
�����VW��$���V�
�XÄ7$���V²�X��$G
è¼X"j}è¼A�³È���
�XÃý��NÃø��è¼KFÙ
���ø/ëyP5+îy�d�X
�è¼²n7$����k¸�KØ
rN�ç��K�Á¸�KÄéê�
Q��áBXÑbXycd�Ö×�
éê²�è¼A´6�;�XÃ�y
dS�Ö×�d�H�����Á
=è¼NÃ#Ö¶Ó�dS���Ø
Ã����NÃ@øc�jcø/
ëyP5+îNÃ�c²µ��
�Xâãæç��ý°���CØ
9��æçè¼ýþ´���,�
�¿ÀÄMÑ���hi�!LØ
V¨ 14.3X�4RdS�+îj��µcd�
µ$¸P§>�vy`X#¢�²�
Ô����&gX�#¢�#��¶
Ó�-â�P§����è¼R÷�
96&Hè¼æç��º»êP§Ã
�9�µ¸P§�c��ÐH���
Q�78�
� @/¸CÍÎ�úû8@N
ÑMXknó/���*&è¼HP
§� .¸«i�
´ 14.4
%
ef{Q
ef�� 25
nó/�V��H²�Xo
Ø �@°&g9:�
Ø ò�CÍÎÙ���\kÖ¡Ø
�À�
Ø � 100% �0`�&�@�Ø µ�>@ 50 �÷ùX:>��09Q�
Ø Ä*$\M��±²�
¹è¼o
Ø KL�&!CD� 50 x�¶¥Ks��,KL�
Ø 9:�²��@�
Ø ü°ø/¶·X� 10 �`$Ïx�Ó$¸�t�
Ø y��æç�Q+���+xî>
@æçñIXPg�@Aü@Z�
Ø ò�kÀÖ¡���ÀXü@��
yÀ�dS�
Ø ���HEü������q
� 557.4 ��=V6000 ���<X�$¸x¨� 929 ��=V10000 ���<X���¸HyÁ¢��|�
��@ 10 � �D�TC»§�
Þô�@��:À_�Eü£�H
,z4RdS�Á=��ÇEü�
è¼j:L9k�I�
Ø ��ÃJj#cd�E+FE�
Ø ü@¹º��Ñáæ��Ñ5½À
+î��ú»�Ï«�½/�
Ø j#°ø�U�e�pü@U�E
N�dSXÑbø�ïR�å�í��
¼�½Æ+î©Â¾�±²�
Ø ü@°�øVô4+�4XXü@
,z�y,µ?@4%A��
P§�%¸�o��+î²��c)
�-ã&Vb�4R|+îj��µ
dS@-ã&�rX+îè¼ê~L
�*&�gh}²X~L�*&�v
12���1�&ù�96&ùHR
÷�9:¢ã&ùH÷ùÏÐ�}²
#��y`�4R|+îj��µd
S�è¼æç��@P§X>°ç
�XÇýÁÂP§y¸NÖ×�NÃ
íîV. 14.5X�Áä«i��þ+«��ô4��Ù+úè¼�@î
>@ø��4�H¢cd���NÃ
yæç�Kµ÷øR÷+î,zó�
&ýXÁä«i��yæç�Kµ#
÷ø~L�ãX��4R|+îj�
�µ°dSÁ"Ì�
�Ð�ø¯�3úç���¹¿À?
øè¼R÷�96&ù+îæçüù
¿��9�$¸P§�cd�Ð�µ
L�Áä«iµ¸P§dS�>�
Ð� 1 3�H¢P§NÃÓ�mÜXÄ�c)#NOyÓ$3áB�Áä
«i��[#^��ÐPgy9�t
âP§�#�E�Ð�b�v~��
�O#Ç]P§�âãXu�yzÙ
+úè¼�@î@ø�«�ô4P
§�b�P§O#Ó�âãX�«i
Ö×�Á"��Áä«i�*/�Ä$
áB�m �@4£Ã�c)�9JØ
rN�ø�¹�78��Ð�?#Ü�Ø
��Ãè¼KL�ÄMÑKç�XØ
«i�&!CD� 50 x��ç�4RdS�ü��øX�v/G�ø��
Ið�f ðHgh,z|nnè¼
æçL��96&ù�9���+R
÷��ø�,z/GðyXÑbí�
þêð+î�LðXü@�vy��
33.3%
33.3% 33.3%
%,
^ 14.3
3
´ 14.5
%
ef{Q
26 2011 �������
äq����v��H²�¿�DP
����«b/�KæeÜ���@
�DX�еÐúL�Ø
d �µ¸CÍÎæçè¼���ú
ûXiO{ http://www.doingbusiness.orgXy�¼�i|yzCÍÎ�NèÈ�Ø
�����VW�Y�$�¿ÀØ
®P5nóµY�Hë��ô4Ø
AþXY�7$�¿À®7ë78
�MB�¶$�¿À]�P5HM¼
4l"@ëy*Çýþ�¶m�®
9�7ëæç��H��V7�º
»�7ë78�QÚq���Há
�K´�éê7ëýþ´���,
��¿ÀÄMÑ���hi�!LØ
V¨ 14.4X�@QY�Hë��ô4Aþ�ú
û�Y�k¡¢R÷�$0��C�
�X"Y�M 4RH4£Ã�@Q
P5HM¼4�9�78æÇÃ�
6�Q�7ë78MB�úû�Y
� 2 ¸wxEFùK��89Xk�&¡#����H9�78æ�
��XÃ'j9�7ëæç��+
î��V7��Æy�¶mXyyø
�Ö×�X�9�7ëæç��+�
�V7�����4RH�Q£¤�
�����¹jÎ����Y�ê
��kÖ.ÔJ§ÀYX�Y�m³
¶Ó�Ã�ø}9�78æXk��
CÈ�°f��6�Y�«Kqr
[+îy�@CÍÎ`�²lO
{X��úûêÃ<��
ô4Aþö´¿ú®P5HM¼4
5½Y�Hë�AþX�Ç�YëØ
º»ýþ�K´V. 14.6X�?ø 2 ¸åßÖ¥Våß A Håß BXK<%P5nóγ���X,µ]
�È$¸P5Y�XÇ ABC 9:pH$¸P5ë�XÇ BizBank �y©ÂCÍÎ�@QP5nó�4R
¬�X�@åß A +îåß B �Ö¥yøVP#�x¸>yøX�Áx
¸åß����@Q@ø²¼P5�Ø
Ó$�4R°G�
ÁäkP5Y�Hë�� .¸Ø
«io
Ø ABC �$�0`@°&g9:�Ø ABC 9:�¹L�Ý$û�R�iyCÍÎÙ���\k�
Ø � �¥FÙ���í¡cdXØ
ABC 9:Ä BizBank éê${ëyXv´5ÈÃ��úqÜK�
&!CD� 10 x�Ø ABC 9:H BizBank >� 100% �0`���
x¸åßÖ¥�cd«i�y
åß A �Ö¥µX/�ëyP5XABC 9:nl BizBank i$«N²¼���@P5A�XÑbc�
fC¡y+îc��Æ�ABC 9:�5¬kP5©��@A¯5¬k
P5©��@A�@ÂCÍÎ�4RØ
#DE²¼��@P5A��ÆyXØ
yÁGÖ×�XABC 9:H BizBank �@ø$GÖÔA��I��Ø
V+îê��@P5A��«��$
G�-X�
yåß B �Ö¥µXABC 9:nê BizBank $G��P5���P5�Á²P5+îghP5X
�dOI BizBank k ABC 9:��ô²¼V+îHNO+� ABC 9:�±²í¼X?@P5A���Ø
ABC 9:¤5¬kÁÂí¼��@AH�@A�
ô4Aþö´¿ú�vêP54
ä�ô4Aþ@Q� 8 ¸�qHM¼4ä� 2 ¸�q�4R���UIXµhêM>� 1oØØ gh��>NÃø²¼/P5XØ
Ó�5@kÁÂí¼��@ApØ
gh¡¢��>NÃsÖÁÂí¼
/P5�
Ø 4RDE���Ii$«N²¼�
��@P5A�VÑbfC¡y+
^ 14.4
2
33%
33% 33%
(0–10)
62.5%
(0–6)
37.5%
ø×Y����c�� ô��!"#$��� ô(~9%�¬&*¨©¿Q
´ 14.6
(0–10)
(0–6)
%
%
ef{Q
ef�� 27
î�ÆXXP#dSkP5��
8Î]��
Ø 4Rj�|DE���I�@²¼
���@P5A�XP#dSkP
5��8Î]��
Ø P5A�NÃaªÈjK+ÃJé
ê�í¼X"N�²aªÈqBØ
í¼¼Ü�¼©�C�+�-©�
Ø P5�Hæç��µDEkº�
Hçy¸��$\M]�oÇ/
Gº�Hçy¸�y¿�ÏÐ>O
êÈP5XPgP5�ÔNÃ�
vø/P5�í¼�Ùv´�
Ø @©¸P5æçD+æç��y;
ZûXbû�ãòÄ"[\í¼
«vÇÃ6$p8 $¸øº�&
&�/*Ø�q~úû��
Ø �º�&yM¼KNÏ~ÂÃ�X
@P5ºA&89êÈÄçVÑbX
y�YðyH÷ùdSÏX�
Ø ���°p~�X@P5ºA&8
9êÈÄçVÑbXy�YðyH
÷ùdSÏX�
Ø �º�&�D�4L¡#���K
N�X@P5ºA&#Ö�²Õc
+a�Éç�°G�
Ø 4RDE¿�yP5�µ5�$
=XÓ·ë�NÃyT~@c�
P5A��Ø
Á¸¿ú��Ä 0 È 10XêMz!��P5HM¼4G%êzCX
7ë�*Çó�éê�
7ë78j´¿ú®uÂeÛ7ë
78QÚq���Há�K´�£¤
HÌ4X# ÁÂ78��9�7
ëæç��Ô����V7�º»
��9�7ëæç��+��V7�Ø
V+xî$ùX�Ã� 6 ¸�qXµ¸�q�êM>� 1oØ ;q�7ë78VÑbXBÉëy
�ú®H_�Ôy�Ö×XH�q
�7ë78VÑbXÂÃÔy�Ã
ymÜ�ú®HÃyvXÔ@M¼
ú®X>mË�
Ø mË�úû@Q�9:��@Q
�¸&��
Ø K�¤¥�H9�*�9:�úû
Ã�K�¡¢���úû>mË�
Ø mË 2 �Ã|���úû�Ãy$nÔp�Å'�7ëæç��+
V7�yÁ¸¿À|êM� 0�Ø mËy&!CD 1% Ã��ëyvúû�ñ·X�5QÚ�&&' 1% �7ëæç��+V7�yÁ¸¿
À|aO�êÈ 1 M�Ø bû4RXY�@AþéÐc)y
CÍÎ`Ù�7ëæç��+�
�V7��úû�
}¿ú��Ä 0 È 6XúLz!��NÃéê�7ë78z+X#
ÁÂ78�Ä9�7ëæç��Ô�
Ä��V7�éê�XÁ@Î�ë
y\��b�9�7ëæç��+�
�V7�#��+îQÚ#È 1% ��&&'Xu�7ë78j´¿ú�
êM� 0�ÑbyFéêX@$¸9�7
ëæç��¯@$���V7�y�
��x�>�mË;q78¯mË
�q78VêM� 1X�x�>mËQ�9:�HQ�¸&�úûVêM
� 1X�H¢9�7ëæç��#mËK�¤¥�+9ø*��úûXÄ
���V7�mËÁÂúûVêM
� 1X�H¢��V7�#mË 2 �Ã|���úûXÄ�9�7ëæ
ç��mËÁÂúûVêM� 1X�H¢9�7ëæç���mËv´
� 50000 FUÃ|�ëyúûXÄ���V7�mËghv´�ëyúû
VêM� 1X�Y�@AþéÐc)yÁx¸���úûVêM� 1X�j/¿À�Çê�Féê�¹êM� 6�
9�7ëæç��QÚq¿Àβ
y9�7ëæç��æç�¸&H9
:�ú®X"w@z)� 5 ��Yë��78�ú®ø���&'�Ø
ÄMÑK.´Vbû�����
m(¿À�X�&¿��È 2009 ��Åy 15 1�Ã|�&X�9�7ëæç���%¸�o�9�L�VYZ
�µ�+¡¢��X¢ã�
$¸úû�X¹úû�C�¡¢³6
`Y�V¸&+9:X�7ø78"
$�ÐÃ�¡¢��Ð�7ë7
8n&�b�ü@9�7ëæç��
��XÁ$0�QÚL� 0�
��V7�QÚq¿Àβ y��
V7�æç�¸&H9:�ú®X"
w@z)� 5 ��Yë��78�ú®ø���&'�ÄMÑK.´Ø
Vbû�����m(¿À�X
�&¿��È 2009 �Åy� 15 1�Ã|�&X���V7��%¸�o
�¬$¸úû��$���9:+î
�Æþ��X}úû�C�¡¢³6
`�Y�V¸&+9:X�7ë7ø
78"$�ÐÃ�¡¢��ÐØ
�7ë78n&�7ë������
H7ëVW9:X#Ïs$�Ð
�,z¡¢��Ð7ë78n&�X
#��y`�b�ü@��V7�Ø
��XÁ$0�QÚL� 0�
d �@Qµ¸CÍÎéê7ë�Ø
��úûXiO{ h t t p : / / w w w .doingbusiness.orgXyz�¼�i|�CÍÎ�NèÈ�Á$¿À��4
�� Djankov�McLiesh H Shleifer y,ô(V2007 �Xµº��XyÁä?@�²�
28 2011 �������
�����VW�®� @uM½
#Ö)*)dø9:í¼���Çþ
��áPkz)�5½�ö´�Ø
¹¿Àj5½ìíîM�Ó¸�qo
Qm�nó�T�´VopK´¿
úX�k�:nó�{&V)*&g
K´¿úXÃ�M½Ó#;��P
ùR¢ã&ùH)*�OöVM½R
Sýþ´¿úX�úûK�k9:4
H6?4R÷���X"Ã6?¡¢
£¤�9:4Ã�4T�6û£¤�
�û�ìíî5½ö´¿ú����
,��¿ÀÄMÑ���hi�!L
V¨ 14.5X�� @/¸CÍÎ�úû8@N
ÑMXÁäk��Hnó?ø .¸
«i�
¹��V��Xo
Ø �$�yCÍÎ�d�MÈnó
�9á|k�9:�b�y¹¸n
ó�9á|k�9:#È 10 �X+î¹CÍÎü@MÈnó�X��
¤°«i�$�@+¸M½�Ùv
��9:�
Ø @$¸)*[H$�yDE�Ö×
�NÃ�4-.��9:�8É(
ü (CEO)XÇ@4RkÁ$Iü@�<�dS�
Ø �$�)©Ü¼���
Ø ?@���M¶t%�
Ø ÊËý���9:�/MM½X�
���9:)*[�ù�z?@�
�9: 60% �MÈX"³y ��9: 5 �)*[�ù�µ� 2 ò�
Ø ÊËýÔ?@²�9: 90% �MÈX²��$�Ì�¤¥¢£ÍX
"y��`Qõ Ù®�Íq�
Ø ÊËýº��9:��²�9:
#ø�Åëë�XÃFÙ�è�)©
ÃK���9:Ó· Á¸º�Ø
Ks�����9:� 10% "g!�klKL�
Ø º��Á0nó�9:;Z���$
LMX�ü@Ò�9:�ÎA���
Ø ��� nó���êÈ �@
dS�^_X� �@dS�o
pVÇÁ{nó#�ÏÐX�
Ø Á{nó�á ��9:�þ��
M½)kÊËý9ÜH^_}nó
�,z/�ºùRS�
opK´¿ú� 5 ¸`a��V. 14.7XoØØ ��"�4&tÎO#ô4^_}
nó�b��c8É(ü+î)
*¹Cã^_ÇNXÁ0êM� 0pb�)*[+îM½��ìÈ.\
gDEÊËýìÈX¤êM� 1pb�)*[��ìÈ.\Pg#D
EÊËýìÈX¤êM� 2pb�M½��ìÈ.\Pg#DEÊË
ýìÈX¤êM� 3�
Ø �rdSFÇ%9��¡¢L�+
îM½opnó6�b�ü@dSo
pXêM� 0pb�dSopnóh�XÄ#dSopÊËý�þ�
I4XêM� 1pb�dSopnóh�X¯dSopÊËý�þ
�I4XêM� 2�Ø �rdSy�´VWµ�op�
b��´VWµ#dSopnóX
êM� 0pb��´VWµdSopnóh�XÄ#dSopÊËý
�þ�I4XêM� 1pb��´VWµdSopnóh�X¯o
pÊËý�þ�I4XêM� 2�Ø �rdSÊËý%)*[op�#
dSXêM� 0pb��dS$\Mopþ�I4�ÆyP#dSg
h8Î`aXêM� 1pb�dS9:op�²¿�nóµ]�ÊË
ýþ���@8Î*jXêM� 2�Ø �rdS@~L��XÑb~L÷
Ü÷XynómÜÏ÷'nó�
#dSXêM� 0pdSXêM� 1�}¿ú��Ä 0 È 10XMLz
!X��opK´zÙ�Ñby½
�Xn�)*[^_XPg#
DÊËýìÈVêM� 2X���9:��FÇopeÛMÈKs��@
78X�vþ�I4VêM� 2X�y,�´VWµX��9:���o
pnó�h�Ã�ÊËýk�²¿�
��@AVêM� 2X�nóÏXÊËý��%,z)*op,þ�I
4XÄ#dSzº»I4�8Î`a
VêM� ¿X�½�#dSgh~L��K÷'nóVêM� EX�j|�ú��ÇXê�½��opK´¿
ú� 7�
)*&gK´¿ú� 7 ¸`a��7o
CEO
^ 14.5
3
33.3%
33.3% 33.3%
ef�� 29
Ø M½qW�rO#Ó}0�²nó
n9:eK��á��ÊËý�&
g�b�#OkÊËý��&g+
î�O��z�ÏÐ+#Ñj&gX
êM� 0pb��@yÊËýeÛ nó�^_+Ò����aO�
�,&gXêM� 1pb�nók,zM½#9+#þ���XO#
��ÊËý�&gXêM� 2�Ø M½qW�rO#Ó}0nón9
:eK��á��^_tÎV8É
(ü+)*[X�&g�b�#
O��&g+î�O��¹^_t
Î�ÏÐ+#Ñj&gXêM� 0pb�O#��^_tÎ�Ò���
&gXêM� 1pb�nók,zM½#9+î#þ���XO#�
�^_tÎ�&gXêM�Ø2�Ø yM½qW�Ç�j² AþdS
�Ö×�X4L�rO#ÓËnó
L��b�nó#O�¶+î�@
yÏÐ+#Ñj�Ö×�aO�
¶XêM� 0pb�ynók,zM½��¦G+#þ�Ö×�NÃ
�¶XêM� 1pb�ynó�#
9�+î[eKþ�I4�Ö×�
NÃ�¶XêM� 2�Ø yM½qW�Ç�j² AþdS
�Ö×�XÊËý�r�n9:�
���á�ÄÉ¡�rXêM� Ep�XêM�Ø¿�
Ø yM½qW�Ç�j² AþdS
�Ö×�XÊËý�r{ÔÄnóµ
êÈ�C��rXêM� 0p�XêM� 1�Ø ÔyH¡yOryø�ÊËý�
rXêM� 0p�XêM� 1�Ø M½qW�rO#Ónón9:�
���áºùÏs+ÕÜRS�b
�#O+î�@¬@9: 10% Ã|M=�M½aNúùRSXê
M� 0pb�¬@9: 10% +Ã�M=�M½NúùÏs+ÕÜØ
RSXêM� 1�¹¿ú��Ä 0 È 10XúLz
!X��)*��4R&gz�
«i#þnóêÈy��^_Ho
pXÃÊ���ßXd��ÊËý�
&gXqW��6jzeÛ ^_t
Î+îÒ���VêM� 1X�d�
�,z)*�&gXqW��6jz
)Ò���VêM� 1X�#þnó#O#°ÓËL�VêM� 0X�b�m²ÊËý<j�@&gXz�
�ôçÄÉ¡VêM� 1XXÄ#dSz{ÔêÈ�C�VêM� 0X�ÊËý#O°ÔyX�#O°¡
yVêM� 0X�¬@ 10% +Ã�M��M½NúùÏs+ÕÜRSØ
VêM� 1X�j|�ú��ÇXê�Ê���)*&gK´¿ú� 4�
M½RSýþ´¿ú@ 6 ¸���Mo
Ø ÷ã�ÐXM½qWNÃÄ°WH
6&uäéê���������
�/G���µXµéê$GXÇ
ê 1 Mo°W.´døK���Õ½�78�Ïs6jqWAþdS
µ8Î*j�78�êAþdS`
a@Q�gh78�NÃ�=m²
�Q78�gh78�
Ø ÷ã�ÐXqW�rNÃÏsG}
°WH6&�rXêM� 0p�XÄd{�{|c*9Vê4ü�Ó
·XêM� 1p�Xg#cd*9VêÓ·XêM� 2�Ø qW�rNÃÄ°Wuäéê©Â
«N��Q��P#cd8ο�
µ$¸���rXêM� 0p�XêM� 1�Ø ¬@9: 10% +Ã�M��M½�rNÃiS12¡wù��}Ô�
²nóPL�y4T|ºùRS�
rXêM� 0p�XêM� 1�Ø ¬@9: 10% +Ã�M��M½)�r@AþyºùRSÏ1�
}Ônó����rXêM� 0p�XêM� 1�Ø Q*RS�È6À_�rY�Ö*
RS�rXêM� 0p�XêM� 1�
´ 14.7
(0–10)
(0–10)
(0–10)
(0–10)
ef{Q
30 2011 �������
¹¿ú��Ä 0 È 10XúLz!��M½ËÌnó�AözÙ�Ñby
;×XqWO#éаW�~øK�
��Õ½PgOÏs6jqWAþd
Sµ*j���VêM� 2X�qWO#y÷ã�ÐG}°WH6&XH
¢�@y*9Ðê4T^_�º�Ø
VêM� 1X�qW���<¿�d¡S���VÑbX�²¿� 2006 � 6 � 15 ¯�?��XX#O��Ø6�dSéê©$«��VÑbX�
@ênó@Q���XVêM� 0X�$�¬@�� 5% MÈ�qWO#iS12¡wùkÊËýH8É(ü
¢ã#��Ùg�÷�XP#øy
4T|ºùRSVêM� 1X�y\%�rùRÏXghM½>O1�
nó��VêM� 1X�Q*RS�È6À_HÖ*À_$"VêM� 0X�jÁÂú��ÇXê�;×�M½R
Sýþ´¿ú� 5�
ìíî5½ö´¿ú�opK´¿
ú�)*&gK´¿úHM½RSØ
ýþ´¿ú��!L��¿ú��
Ä 0 È 10XúLz!��ìíîÖÈ�5½z+�
d �Q�/CÍÎìíî5½�Ø
��úûXiO{ h t t p : / / w w w .doingbusiness.orgXyz�¼�iµ�CÍÎ�NèÈ�Á$¿À��4
� Djankov, La Porta, López-de-Silanes H Shleifer y,ô(µV2008 �Xº���
�����VW�ç�$�µv��
y©$U%�=`���ï�/GØ
ð0H¯GMÕyX�®ÓïðH
ÕyP¼Ü�1�P�Á¸0e�
ê��� ô/ámHjä����
w�ð0HÕy�vþu+���ê
ð�÷t�ï��[ÕyH��ð�
è¼ð�è¼�Ið�Ú�ð�í�
C�ð�¡¢nóð���C�ð�
ëÛH �ðÃ�gh,zuv�ð
+��ïðýþ´���,��¿À
�ÄMÑ���hi�!LV¨ 14.6X������VW�®VmX�
Ï+���gh$øX12¯GVC
��yø�À_¾���gk,è�
V.¼ÜeÛ�/GðH»y��
ÌÈÁ$IX�����VW�Òz
ð�J6%¸�12�0Q¡Jk
ð��%�oð��vôçn12�
¯GM�ê#ȵÔ�y0����
��VW�Ï�ä¥Á$%¸X�
Ó�c®��uÂeÛ��¡JP
#�12�J��¯GV���ø�
xîÏÐ�tdYN]�È�²�
�������VW�®�`a�
v�÷t�ïnµÔv�&��R¡
+�å5!R¡�12¯GÕy�Ø
ßbo¹¿À��vôÙþ¿�¸�
{Ü¡5�H�åÄÉ5!���
ý�Ü~¹ðOV%¸���XX�
@���P�ð0a°�vy`XÑ
bo�LðYZ#�vy`V��c
)�L4µÔ�XXÓ�c)#[e
Û����qþuX����Xc)
yCDV.µ#[êÈ&'�ÑPXy
ô£¿ÀV�ÐH�ðÔúXµ��v
ÁÂð0XÓ�c)�<�Ç ��
ðCô£�1�P�
�����VW�ø$¸åßk
À_¾���ï�ð0HÕyÃ�C
ÍÎ�ð�ô£Î³�F|M�
�w�¹åß@ø $k}è�V.
Ã�k$�µ��/«nó�/�
«i�yµ¸CÍεXK�#Ó9
:VyE+CÍεX��� �Á
Â9:µ�$ùX�ð�ó�[bû
À_¾åß��ê��úûXk,!
���`�ð0H¯GMÕy�Ü
~�}~XÔkCÍÎ�lVH�ð
ÝOÃ�þ�ð4�c��Ð�78
�2 �� @/¸CÍÎ�úû
8@NÑMXk��Ã�ð0HÕy
Ì� .G«i�
¹��o
Ø �$�@°&g�fïð����
b�yCÍε@#c$G@°&
g9:X¤yz0`Z��@°
&g9:ý��Z��ý���
�ø}R÷+6ÜL�VW�
Ø � 2008 � 1 � 1 ̄ áBû��u�X9:?� í¼�º.µ�Á´�
�@í¼"÷ø �@�å�
Ø yCÍÎÙ���\kû��
Ø � 100% 0`9:p?@ 5 ¸�tX!��Ñ&�
Ø 2008 ���Xײí¡�&!CD� 102 x�Ø Ä*$\Må�+��±²�8Î
P�X¹��Ä*éÞ ß�ܼ
H¤¥�#Ä*k~òóVü@�
�'XPg#C�ÖUGðG�·
�¼©XÑb�«+����
33.3%
33.3% 33.3%
%
^ 14.6
3
ef�� 31
Ø 2009 � �?@�� 2 ¢�Eü� 1 ^��à�â9i �Ü~�H 1 ÛÅëX"�øØ1 ÛÅë�Ø � ê9:�°+£�@Q�!�
1�~XLísBÖìíÈT@ä
+,zgh!�1��
Ø ÷>ùå 60 �X,µ¢ã&ù 4��Îã&ù 8 ��å& 48 ���@ùå!��09Qg,µ 1 �¢ã&ù����tÏ$�¹9:Ô�
ùåôçv~��á5!V"�4
R¯G�X/�v~�þ��}Ï
~Xy©ÂCÍεY$�V¶H
�JQt�°W/v~�þ�y
yø�Ö×�X«i9:�ÁÂv
~�þô�ôçðy+îÁÂ�þ
Õ�ùå�fïðCD�åß��
«iü@�Eâ�nY�ÑãH,
z*0nùåôçv~�ªíXÓ
}XÇ@9:CZnlùåÁÂC
DXc)�#[ÜDfïðªí¹
v+îÄ,µä�XÄP��D
��ð+�²���Ü~µ�
Ø ��v�&!CD� 1,050 x�Ø ��¶$�mÜå��
Ø #þuOVðX� 20%VÇo¶¥v�¥�ú���� 120%X�Ø y¶m�æjçþu� 50% /�èþMÃn���@&�
Ø y¶m� j���?@�,µ$
¢��¥"éþ�
Ø Åë��éê���&!CD�Ø
xx�
Ø � @�åß�$åÀ_¾Xká
ôHnó�Ì�$³����«i
�yø�¹���è�V.µ��
@Õ®>Ã� 2005 �&!CD�ÑßK.´�ßbX«iè���
¢ã&ùÏ$�uò�t�9:
�9Y�áô�&!CD� 10%V¹�t� ¶µ 20% �Ú�&áô�20% ��JQt��60% �Y$�X�
Ø �@ç��ð0HÕy>�y��
¶m�V2009 ¯��X�ï��$¸ð0+Õyë�ç#Ó+�#
Ó��VCX¤°W�#Óðe�Ø
ð0HÕy��çHVC���ÓX
Äþk#Ó���VC�ðO#ÓX
¤°W��Ó�ð0+Õy�
Ø ��y$�µ�ðHôçÕy�Ø
Ôú�ð0+Õy�G«úìÃØ
µ¸ð0+Õy��ïV+^íX
ÝO��ïÝO�v^9�ïV+
^íXÃ�%��ïV+^íX�
ïð¿À�&'��¹À_¾åß�
��9:û�¶m��Ð��ï�ð
0HÕy�¹ú�ïð�4�ïðÝ
OÃ��]����ú®V. 14.8X�,µ�v����ï���ðXÑb
��ð+�Lð�J6|XÁÂð0
�Ä��îuä-í-���pÑÁ
Âð0#eÛ9:�CDV.XÄ�
[�ÇðCô£�1�PXÓ}°
��yïð¿Àµ�
�ðÔúµ�q~lV�Ôú�
b�:qjPgÙ+úµv��!
yzq~lVHïðXu�XÇý�
lVHïðÝO*!XïðÊ[$�
$ÔÜ~�k�Y�¶Ó����
ïXÑb¡¢���ï�þ8ð+é
êM¶��ï�éêðXÇ@�ïÝ
O*!X��[$ÔÜ~�
b�@ 2 G+ 2 GÃ|�ð0+ÕyøÓ$lV.ô"lVH�ïX
¤µÔmô�ðc[$ÔÜ~�ßbX
b�¯G×�5!ÕyH¯G��¡
Õyô"lVH�ïXu�X�ðÔ
úµ��v,µ$0Õy�
�Ð[µ��u�úç��¹¿À
®��_ �lVH�ï 3 Gtdð0HÕy�cd��ÐXÁ 3 GtdðH»y�o���êð��Lð+
��ðÃ���ðX,µ�våíð
H�[Õy�_ �Ð�vC�Ü~
fïðv�c�$é78Ã�Ü~f
�¡v�cd��Ð�b���5²
i��ð�[Ü��AA+î�i
��Ü~Xu�XêÁÂå/�Q�
�Ð�f�vy`�Á$v~�Ð�
@yZ£�[Üå/#O�¥ð�[
´ 14.8
3
%
ef{Q
32 2011 �������
ÜdS�Ö×��N��y`�lV
�Ð�v/��@�d�ïðlV.
sÃ�%ð��Qºn�QlV.s
��Ð��ð�пy��ð+yð
��Q�ð�cd�u�ú�î��
ðHôçÕy�XÔc�v���Ð
��E���
¹ðO�_®����yû�¶m�
��P�ð0H¯GMÕy�v´X
Ã���þu�=v.´��2011 �����VW�µVW�� 2009 ¯���¹ðO�����P�¹ðvXØ
�DE2îÃJ��@f�ðHÕy
�¹H�uÂ���-í�ðVb¸
&�êðX+���-CJ|�ð�
L�Ä#����P�ðVb�Lð�
��ð+ú�H!�ðX#�vy`�
�vy`�ðNM� 5 «oþuð+���êð�÷t�ï��[ÕyH
��ðV�v�@¯GMÕyXª�
�vnçnµÔv��¡Ï«���
jÎ�ÕyX�è¼ð�Þ�ðHØ
,zðVbk1iä�Ã�ëÛHØ
éêðX�
¹ðOÞyk���P��@�
ïð���:q_®�¹ðO#Ó
�4%ðOXJî�#��º»$¸
ðRyø³ú�¹ðO�øj�fï
ðv�Ã��þuÜ~�K���#
ö�úû´ßV. 14.9X���þujG|����ï�@
ðy�çþuXc#Ó�J6|y
è�V.µÁ´�ðþu�yÜ~
ðþu�X$¸9:��P�A+
ð0!�Ní��XPyÜ~��þ
u�XÁÂð0�#Ní���Ó}X
��þupW`² ��y$¸è�µ
�ïghðyÏ�j�þu�
j¶¥v2'�¶¥ú����X
2'ªí¹vX2'1¢ã�X2'
,záôX2'^ ¡XÇ|Vè¼Ø
¶¥�éê�Xí�C�X2'ôçþ
8XÇ|þ8CDXÑJØ2'��
ïð�XýÜ~���þu�Ü~�
�ïð��X?øÏ�ïð4X[ÃØ
�ïðO�Ü~o���ïðO�
0%�Eü�� 5%��ài � 10%�Ü~�� 33%�â9i � 20%�Åë� 20%���ámô�� 10%���þu�&!CD� 59.4 x�
Á$Ü~¹ðO��4ê��
� ám�¹Îð�¬ (Total Tax Contribution framework) R�$=XÓ��Þô[\Á$¬kð��
�Ü~�Ä�X��� �Ü~YZ
ÃCÍε٣�����º»�
úû��ûXP�����VW��
IQñ��kÀ_¾�µ�£�9:
��åß���
ê0�ðCkr (International Tax Dialogue) ��ù�a X@ïð¿À� G�4�$åé��a @��
å8µ@Qïð�пÀ�{|êÈ
ºñX"�= k@Q��ðùVq
Ó�Iúû�?�Xû�$å���
d �/CÍÎïð¿À���úûX
iO{ http://www.doingbusiness.orgX"Ä�¼�iµyzCÍÎ�Á$¿
À��4y Djankov �,z&�mô(/V2010 �Xµº��
´ 14.9
(r) (b) (a)
1
(c) (t)
a = r x b t = a/c
SKr SKr SKr
28% 10,330,966 2,892,670 17,619,223 16.4%
0.38% 26,103,545 97,888 17,619,223 0.6%
32.42% 19,880,222 6,445,168 17,619,223 36.6%
4.16 45,565 189,550 17,619,223 1.1%
9,625,276 54.6%
1. 'h(E)Q
~9Skr !*+B,Q�ÒE)-,!.Ä%&� 59.4 /Q
ef{Q
ef�� 33
�����VW�2 À_¾¾û
ú���'��QKNM£%Xç�
Ä¿�òªôÓÈú�nçÁ$�
K�ú���'ü�KNÃ�9�Á
$KN�cd��ÐH���}~X
�����VW�Ôç� òó�Ä
*ú���'�cd��@i6�ú
��'KN��Äú�y����
�Èú�¥á�'³�k¸�K�¾
û�ÐH��#�y`�?ø7ø6
çyX7ø6òm+Wm�c��
Ð���Hi6��y`�ñ0òó
ýþ´���,��¿ÀÄMÑ��
�hi�!LV¨ 14.7X���úû-ã�óû9:�VQ
�³'üùHº»@Q9�µ
}KN�c���������
78�� @#ÓCÍÎ�úû8@
NÑMXk���òóú�/� .
0«i�Ø
¹��o
Ø �5@ 60 �÷ù�Ø ò�¹CÍÎÙ���\k�
Ø ���@°&g9:X#y�'Ç
åÀ+BÖUN��'A�å�À
`û��
Ø �L~í�0`���
Ø �'�¶¥� 10% Ã|�
òó¼©?ø 20 �<��Øú��ôûFX�®� 10 õXKL 20,000 §��¹¼©o
Ø #x�£!ú�g#�5ø©�
Ø #cdö÷+gh,zU����Ø
�9��0�À_~X#cd�¥
ghU��ø�1ù+���:Ø
À_�
Ø �¹CÍÎtd��'+�'¼©
Ï$�Ø
��'µóú��cd��@i6!
ç��KV. 14.10X�«i¿��C5�"òªôÓ�/12L3�¾
Q�³'H��ô�¦t¢�Q�ú
Üêjâ/G�QHâã�P
§�c�i6>��y`���?ø
7ø6ôç��X�7ø6ò
m+P5�c�$éi6���y
`�µ���âã�Ã�#cdµó
��âã�i6VÑb�9ð6�X
#�y`�Ø
��'�Ðï�3úç��âãP
§�c��ÐÄP§×²áBÜ~$
ÏÈ9��c�b�©0P§NY�
ôçv~�ø���Ç«âã]´P
g�@òó9:!N@ø}�4X¤
yzâã]´«�ô4P§�yø
��'ÇåÀ���«]Y P§#
��y`XÓ�"��@òó9:!
N@ø�¾û�Ð#�y`�Áä«
i�'�H�'�!#^��ÐPg
!D�\]9�µ0tâP§�N"
9��P§X[ÓåP§_®�#
ÓP§Ð����ÐAAÑbú�û
ú�ÐAA��y}_®�Kµ�
��®��k$¸ 20 �<��ô�VC��øXç��iò�,µ�
�9�ú��'+�'/0P§��
@�Q�øX�vi6��YQHj
â/G¢ã��VQ-ã���¦�
û�H`ÊûF����µ#�vQ
ðÃ�ê¾û�Q�ðH�ø��ç
�ü����
Ø
d �/CÍÎñ0òó���úûX
iO{Øhttp://www.doingbusiness.orgX"Ä�¼�iµyz�QCÍÎ�Ø
Á$¿À��4y Djankov�Freund H Pham ô(����V2010 �Xµº�Xy}üÌ�²J?ø�Ø
20
^ 14.7
3
33.3%
33.3% 33.3%
´ 14.10
ef{Q
34 2011 �������
@Q(ôÓ�/¿À®��:Ø
4³6�\��ßà��O�ÁÂØ
úû�Y�^���¶¥ßày��
4L$å$å�m(EÕ�KPEF
ùK��úû�?��Y���Q*
RS4H,z4T£¸Kj²�XØ
úû�7$¸Kæ�k���RS
R÷H4ü9��������Ø
V¨ 14.8X�µ¸CÍÎ�Q4L��çAAØ
Çoò�CÍÎÙ��\k�Ø
@A÷ã]å¡v�&!CD 200% ���å��4LAA9ËyÃ�
t¥ohttp://www.doingbusiness.org/ExploreTopics/EnforcingContracts/�Ø
Ø *Äv�¹CÍÎ&!CD� 200%�Ø ßàQ³ÈØ2ظ��V²�H��XÏÐ�$0ô4nóXÁx¸��
�y��¹CÍÎÙ���\k�
²�%���¶¥ú��úL�¹
CÍÎ&!CD�Ø200%�²�jú�nç��JX��Ã�nçú�
G®#ôs��ý¶ôçúy�
Ø ²�VqWXùR��V°WXX
dSC°¶¥�µ£%�úy¡
vVǹCÍÎ&!CD�Ø200% X���k²��*ÄdS.´&kX
çú�G®#ôs�¿�k¹*Ä
dS���þÏÆyßà�
Ø }ßà�ò�¹CÍÎÙ���
\k�@A÷ã]å¡v�&!Ø
CD 200% ����4L�&e\�
Ø ÓPt��M¼X²�yéêë\
Ïí· ���&²í¼Vbâ
9i HëÛ�X�
Ø k�nçú��G®�C@ ó�
·��b�¹CÍÎ�À_Ì4�
�µ$�/�J����ó�6
&X¤¿�\}âã�b�¹CÍ
Î�À_Ì4��4ü¿%�Fó
�X¤4ü\}âã�yÁGÖ×
�X4ü#DEgh$�kó�6
�º�Z�
Ø ë\�� 100% @þ�²�o4üe%ú�G®ôsg����[�
%Ksôçúy�
Ø ��kë\��#ºù|R�ë\
���ë\�
Ø ²�� ë\OêÈFÇ(?Ð
$é�d�@ä�úyY�9á
�¥���&²í¼Vbâ9i
HëÛX�ÇC°�
�µ¸CÍÎ G�KNMå0pi
�[\�Q4L÷ã��ßà��Ð
rN G��KN¿��4R£%�
+j_µZø��ôÓ¿�ÏÐ+î
ôÓ¿�ê4ü+4L&ùÏÐ�g
h}²�,µ�vFåHK5å0�
å��÷ãHë\å0Ã�(ë\
��då0V. 14.11X�Ø}0��DE��kÖç�Q4
A°`Æy��Ä�c4A°`#Æ
y�KNX&Ï�Ñ�ßbXyj
Q4�0�X4üN¿%$ò�Fó
�XPyj�c4�0�X/�>
%4Lº»ó�6&�i�� β
¹Î�OXk�i@ó���4T�
CÍÎXÄ,KN¹úµ2' 1 ¸KNXk�DEÃq~��%4Lº�
Fåli�CÍÎX�Ä,KN¹ú
µ2' 1 ¸KN�$ÂÓ�mÜ�+î��y,zKNMå0µ�KNM
å0#ÜDKN¹úµ�Ø
�Ðï�3úç�XÄqW�\%
%4LºùRSÏ�ùÜ~XÈúy
ôç�cX,µ�v?в�c�
3úÃ�,Ð�����cç�ßà
�\�#Ówx��!¬§�ÐoØ
9�K5VFåliHK5�ÐX�
mËë\V÷ãHÌ�ë\��ÐX
Ã�ôç�<V(ë\��ÐX�
^ 14.8
3
33.3%
33.3% 33.3%
´ 14.11
%
ef{Q
ef�� 35
��[*Äv�ÄMÑç�X«%�
&!CD� 200%���#lç��cç�Ó«��o4T�ø�(�ø
H�!R÷��
4T�ø�v²�VqW�X�
�^9ôç4L��@4T�øHó
��X# ²��mÜ����+
5�ó��øXb�4RdS+j_
�µ�Ë@øX¤��y4T�ø
µ�(�ø�²�VqW�X��
^9ôç��� Y�9á�¥��
&²í¼K(ë\�$é��X#
²��mÜ����+5��!
R÷��²�VqW�X��^9ô
çn��-ãR÷��øXÃýR÷
yÀ_å�µ-.²��T�
d �/CÍÎ(ôÓ���úûX
iO{ http://www.doingbusiness.orgX"Ä�¼�iµyz�QCÍÎ�Á$
¿À��4y Djankov H,z&ô(����V2003 �Xµº�Xy}üÌ�²J?ø�
�����VW���0`jÎM¼
KN��Ð���H���úûê�
k��M¼Ä�iòk���±FX
"gY�k@QM¼G´�4R4£
�9�78���ÇÃ�6�QõØ
��ýþ´��ðCO�bûØ
V¨Ø14.9X�� @#ÓCÍÎ�úû8@N
ÑMXÁäk��Håß/� .0
«i�
¹��o
Ø �@°&g9:�
Ø y¹CÍÎÙ���\kû��
Ø � 100% `í��X�âî?@�� 51% �M=V,zM½¬M!
#Ò�¹M=� 5%X"Pg¡*[tÉ�
Ø ykµtÀ@#²¼X��yuä
C�$��ÍX�,tdí¼�Ø
¹�Í�eL�&!CD� 100 x+ 200,000 §�XÐxvÒÙî�
Ø �@$���¹Cã�
Ø �@ùå 201 &�»f� 50 �Xµ�»f�J$ÔnúJ�úy
!ÂÃBç�
Ø ê$�0`ò@ 10 ��ëy�X?ø:q��¶·G´Vb
Á²¶·G´XP5VyD�}«
P5�CÍÎ`X+Ã�Íè¼Ø
P5�b�}CÍÎ�4RB�Ø
:q��¶·G´Ì��<£%X
ÄôÓµZ@ø,z«��£%X
¤�yëy�µ�</�}«Ø
£%�
Ø Èe�cB�þ�ëy�Ôy£
%Ã��@,zê�Ôëy@Q�
h��
Ø @¶·�X¶·�¡�KLê�Í
�klKL9:���
¹��SÈ&²M{|�2009 ���å�X�=,í�çL���²y
�Ð� 2010 � 1 � 1 ¯���L²¡:vÉç�¶m3VÇ 1 � 2 ¯XÈ��ëyþ8+�¡���Ó
}jL4ÉÔëy���¢ã¨�
� 2010 �H 2011 ��>j�²å��ëy�µ�BÉÔ¡vê�Í
���klKL;C��XPg�9
:¹º�� 74%X,� 26% �º��LP5ºA&V»f��ùå�ð�
�Q�X¬@�
¹���ºA&s+XL4��
$¸�;��T~�\�åXÄ@Ã
�.G�\�åN»yzoY�:4
KNk9:��E+��X@ÏO
¦§û�pY�:4KNk9:�
p~+Õ�pÃT|V+Y�7$1
2�QX+T~VÑbY�¿%sC
&X(��k9:ײº�(+
¶·�üCKN�
;<HNO�ë�]´H
Y���XÙ°´�C°ëy�L
P5ºA&;<?Ðyø4R�DE
�gh@äíî��í¼�M��
¥�+úMM½�d¦§/G��"
5¬û��¢ã¨�d@��5¬û
�Ã5R���å/�/�!���
jÎ+9Qp#]�~0�*��
ºA&C°ëy��Ð[¯��úØ
ç��V. 14.12X�����VW��_®��ÐxÄ9:P�Ï�á
BXÏ�,ÂÃ�y0LM+:
LÉçÏ��·�/�NO?Ð�Â
aÌâXÑbº�Âa�Ð�lR+
a�li�X!��y`�
RS��[º�&#²¼KL�Ä
MÑç����Ü~Ã��±;��
ûX�v4T�øH12ð��M¼
¢ã���²��de�HR÷�Ã�Ø
,z$é�øH���°��
^ 14.9
1
100%
Þ�¨©/(/0Vý]¬É01&Q~9
36 2011 �������
��e~L�NÄÃ�y0µyzoØ
�#²¼KL� 2% Ã��2–5%�5–8%�8–11%�11–18%�18–25%�25–33%�33–50%�50–75% Ã� 75% Ã|�
ºA&�º�°CÖ×Ð\�4R
²9�J�Í���r[¦§û��
'+î���í¼�r[°M��
¥�b��Í��¦§û�X¤#[
mÜKL��Xt��ºAN9
:êÈ�¥XÇNC°�º��º�
v� 100%�b�í¼°M��¥X¤ÙNC°¡vj#Ò�t�
ºA� 70%XÇ�º�v� 70%�
°CO[ºA&Y����p~+º
�(V¶·�üCX�4R²C
°�º��º�v�ÄMÑKç��
Ü~�c����o4R²9�J
���[¦§û�Ô�[°M��
¥XÑJX�j4R²���í�
Vº�&#²¼KL�µ¸ÄMIÜ
� 1%XXJXí¡yM¼KN�а��¼Ü�KL��c��y
`X,µ�vÓ�Í�8ïðP¼Ü
�KL���ê0�[Ücß$=X
�8��ïðO[ 20% Ü~�Áä«i�8�í¼¹KL�LMÏ$�°
CO��CD�²LX�û�0�
úqR¡���0�è�6Üúû�
9Ë� 2009 �æ�ëyþOXÃ/0�H�Cͧ&�78L�úû�
º��Ø
b�$¸CÍÎy�'��µµ�@
#È 5 ¸å�]�:4���:4p~+º�(KNV¶·�üCXX
¤¹CÍÎ[êÈ$¸7Lj_?
���Á�·kÆXºA&#NOY
�;�4RKNVT|+T~XC°
,y0�7Lj_?CÍÎ�°COØ
�¤�
Á$¿À��4y Djankov�Hart�McLiesh H Shle i fer ô(����V2008 �Xµº�Xy}üÌ�²J?ø�
x¸#�vyv����ýþ´¹Î
��µ�¿À��oéêqö¿ÀX
Á�$¸�Iúû�pÔ@÷øùå
¿À�X¹¿À�� G�4�
�k�
�����VW�ç����$¸À
_¾��éê��Mqö¢sH»q
!���@P§X�v%qö��º
�li"òªôÓ�Ä,z��âã
$é�d�÷^P§XÃ�~L�H
��¢s/�V. 14.13X��Qúû�Ä9�Ãq9:?��XÑJ
C�qö¡¢��HqHåK÷��
Fó�jâ&ù�qöD��Häå
���9�H�6�����9�Ã
q9:������yÀົ!�
�Ãq9:�b�@+�Ãq9:N
»yzX¤yz�Jú®+�ÃqØ
9:�Ø
� @#ÓCÍÎÏÐ�úû8
@NÑMXÁäk��Hqö¢s/
� .¸«i�Ø
¹��o
Ø �©ò������@�
Ø ò�CÍÎÙ���\k�
Ø D�¹\k�ü��À`g¹Àà
`Ô@,z��V$¸�ïRÀX�
Ø #D�UNCÍÀ+ìíÀ`pÇ
qö¢s#BÖU�Q�Øí1�
�º +«»!��b�@+¸ò
ÄN»yzX¤}��ò�óÐ
q����
Ø @ �NY�q�¢s/�]�È
�z$h++h �Ve���
���!���«�/�XXÄ
�ÁÂåK/�!y9���|Ø
9�X����#[�D,z�@
�
Ø �DòÄL�ã°G�ÑbX#õ
����
Ø ø�Æ�ö÷ú��
Ø ��EiäVÇ���D�¢q9
LEü�XXx�8ÔsYqö�
Ø �@ 2 ¨X!y�|X¹q���1300.6 ��=V�ô 14000 ���<X�����q�� 929 ��=V10000 ���<X�
´ 14.12
%
%
ef{Q
ef�� 37
¹Yq��o
Ø ���M¢s���
Ø �Ó��4 � Y v¢s�140 §¨�Vli�a®X�qö¢s���
Ø ¹Y¦¢��� 150 =V��y�Jè¼|��@ÃqÕ¦©XyÁ
GÖ×�Y¦¢��´� 0X8�¹
��NO�!+����X�d
����yCÍÎH�yÀà*�
Z����ý�ÇN��J�¼�
�`��´N�?#Ü�
Ø �c��$Vq.��øq®�Ø
0.07 �7��`Lq�Ëi�C9��
P§¿��ùå+,tdqHj÷+
qHåK÷VÇNO�C9�`LË
��&ùXê9�qöÃK9:�»
q9:�12���qöD��Hq
ö9:�~L/�ÏÐ�gh}²�
9:ùåÏÐ�}²Ã�`LË��
�Qå0XÑb`LqH��ÜÝ�
iÜê(�#W�P§���yÓ
$¸9�*�9:�#ÓL�9��
P§°W�#Ó�P§�
Áä«i���ùå�9��
@P§X��¯G£%d@ø¶Ó�
VßbX�DE�y9�*�9:ñ
I�qHj÷ºnli�Ö×X�b
���NÃÄü°dSli@øó�
&ý�!�VÑbø��9:P�9
�*�9:�~L/�XXu�X
yÁÂP§�YøÌ4�Ö×�¤
dÇÃç���@P§µX�@u
ÂNOmÜ�ÖýVÑby 50% Ã|��Ðä9�*�9:��ÆØ
=>XHuÂy��sqj_µþ+
�P§aÜ~y`�Ø
�Ð[¯�3úç��Á$¿ÀÐ9
�$0P§�c�Ð�µÐLXÁ¸
�Ð�qö9�*�9:Hó�)Ø
¿��yj�µyJ§å/5gØ
ü@v~çy�Ö×�cd��ÐX
P#�4R£%�9�P§��Ð�
ÁäÔ«iµ0P§�c��Ð>
� 1 3�H¢#Ó�P§NO[Ó�âãXÄc)#NOyÓ$3áBØ
VÇÓ�âã�P§Xy¢§#Ó�
¯�áBX�Áä«i9:#[^�
�ÐPgD�jH«9�µ0�P
§�9:C�78�ø��Ð�?Ø
#Ü�Áä«i9:Ä$áBý �
sYqö��@dSHc)�rN�Ø
��[CÍÎ&!CD�ÄMÑç
��ç����#��Lð�9��
�sYqöP§��@�Q��H�
ø!ç�y`X,µ�vy12��
âã÷^P§�liqö¢s�sÖ
²lH`LË�1��?�=>�j
äj�s�/�Ã��ï56¡��
�ó�º»�78Ã�8Î�4£H
C���.���úû�Kæ�b�
.���ô/`aº» #Ó�e~
úûX¤?øVWL�µL�ygh
Ö×�X��!#�y��ϵ�
9�*�9:dSôç56¡XÃbc
�JNO�²L4ôç,���i�
Ö×��}X%��JVC�56¡
ZZ[�J^e��v�NúÜ~�Ø
�����VW�#ç�56¡
�:L¡vXP�ç��JÓ9�*
�9:��í·56¡��Ö�þ8
C����²LXyÙ+úÖ×�5
6¡[°í·�ôÓ�·�VÁä«
i� 5 �JX�k�ø56¡ôç¶$¸����i�ÖýX#lç��
Ü~þ8C����²L�X?ø
0�úqR¡���0�¡¢6Ü�
µ 2009 �æ�ëyþO�b�56¡e8µÔXu�@øëyþOê9�
*�9:�ôç�þ8ÏYKÜ~�
�²L�
´ 14.13
%
ef{Q
38 2011 �������
y©ÂCÍεX56¡NÃÃ
º?�ý�º»o9:NÄ+5
!9:éêÃ,y¹¡¢��µ�¬
@�í¼�P5�5N�ê�Jò
¡ý�%9�*�9:ôç56¡�
Ö×#ÓXú?ý�ôç56¡
�X9:"#�'k56¡:v��
@A/GX"Næ§@øÁ{í
¡�/�°VX9:�%ôç$
{P§�Ãéк?��CÐ�P§
�NO[bû9:�7ø´P@�#
Ó�Áä«i7ø´ XÓ}NO
CÐ�P§��Y�b�Nú»
º?X¤ç��56¡KLý��P
§�ìÃ���«iôÓ�°�b�
xGÖ×!ÆyX¤ç�xîµÒY
�$¸�
yBþgX$¸�Jëy 2010 �6 �li$¸ 140 §¨��qö¢sXcdò¡+ôÈ���ï${Ø
22662 Bþg��56¡X56¡�@yôÓÈ���NµÔ�P�J�
NÃ[ 14.05% �²ëyþOøÁ{í¡�ìí�Á�·kÆXy��
�ôÓ�µXj��²L� 10918 Bþg��þ8C���&Xb�DE
�Jà 1.75% ��þOø5N����\56¡X¤�����¡v
�� 1983 Bþg��Ø
d �/CÍÎéêqö¿À���
úûXiO{Øhttp://www.doingbusiness.org�
�����VW�®CÍÎ���
4£XÓ���4£[eÛÈ÷øH
eùÃ�å/�Ð�þM�2007 �Xk÷øùå¿À� G�4�
��XÃý@Á$�4ê0��å�
���Q9�5¬$=�y0��åØ
��� 188 09�µ�@ 4 0]������VW�®�ßào�c
÷ùô��Þæå/�eªÜ«��
Ðå/������VW���4ê
Á 409�9:$=�$¸CÍÎ@NOy÷øùåýþ´Á0¿À|é
ê!MPgÞô0��å���@
�Q�9�V8ÎK������Ø
��VW�®� 4 ¸ßàXXPgXb�#ÞôÁÂ9�XghCÍÎ>
#[êÈÒC�Mú�Ø
ÙÚ÷øùå¿À�Qßà�Ø
0��å��9�#�v,'t�²
À_XÇo]��Î��A���¯�
�²�¼��åÃ�ÓåÓ��{|
� 8 09��2009 �Xk÷øùå¿À�
G�4� �$���89X
kÀ_¾åß��� �ÕXjµ
u��%¸�ùå&ú� 60 &P� 201 &����,ÔXj�Ðå/HÞ«¯å/�°GM£%ïD��X
b�c)yø�uÂÄCÍ|K�c
d¢§/��ܼG�±²�r�¶
ÓX¿%Þ«¯�Ðå/+�Ðå/
�4%ª��¡M 4 øÜM�¶LXu¯G�G�� 8 Þ+ 8 ÞÃ�ªíg#º»��5½�CÍÎ#Oê
È!êM�JXkYåíÑO
�Ü~��� ¸�X<5uÂj
C��ö�K�kJ�Yåí��
�µ3 1.25 §�Ã��CÍÎ#[êÈ!M�Á$á�ê��k¶k%�
���k�$=�
v�Xyø} þ��Q�ø
}u�JXk|��4� �$
å�¸��@Qø}�K�*+7
8XiW������VW�tu (http://www.doingbusiness.org)���mËϯ$=Ó·/���Õb�o
yYåí�dM�qXb�CÍÎ
b�ü@i%Yåí�+î4Rp
Ѻ» kYåí�¡¢�GÄy
j�µê#È(�¯+î�@�%
���Yåí+Yåí�yø�
9�L�X¤¹CÍÎ#Oéê!
dM�þkeª�«�°�µÞ+
å/¯�q¦±M�!�{|X�i
% °v�}~X�ê�å/�Ðþ
M¿úPk�«�°�dM�XÃ
��ê�eù��PkYm�°H�
G��dM�X@ø 1 ��5 �H 10 �åÅùå��!LXPü@@ø 20 �åÅùå�eù���@Q÷øùå�úûÃ��R÷
H9�L��üùk��4£��
������û�� 56úû�_
<MXk��4RH4£Ã�¶mP
úûKæ� ÷��� @#ÓC
ÍÎ�úû8@NÑMXÁäþkå
&H��/� .0«i�
¹ùåo
Ø ��Å 42 1�:���M�1÷ù�Ø y,k¸���Ð�ª�Ç�þê
CÍÎ��!åí���
Ø BÖ,�yCÍÎùåZ��Ø
åíôç��
Ø ��yCÍÎ�ô49QgGOê
�Ñ7�ê¹CÍÎ+ú&'�Ó�
Ø ïRy¹CÍÎÙ���\k�
Ø #�å[[ùX��¯G£%��
ÇDå[�
¹��o
Ø �@°&g9:�
Ø y¹CÍÎÙ���\kû��
Ø � 100% `í���Ø C���G���
Ø @ùå 60 &�
ef�� 39
Ø b��yCÍÎj�Îïë�
G´�G����y$UÃ|Xg
Á$G´ª�yø�uÂ#òª}
«��9:X¤jÁ$G´�
Ø þú�4XÄ�#%ù庻Ò�
4R�4£+îVb�yø�rX
�Îïë�£%��þ�
÷>þM¿ú� 3 0~¿ú��!Lo÷>�´¿ú�å/�ÐþM¿
úÃ�eù�´¿úV. 14.14X��@ÁÂ~¿ú!�.¸LM��X,
ÐL��!� 0 � 100XúLz!��£¸G´zrs�
÷>�´¿ú®�� (i) �rycn��Må/g�òªo%�°Ø
ôÓp(ii) o%�°ôÓ��FÜ�°pÃ� (iii) j�Ü+��ùåYåíêùå�!wÇLÏÑ�b�
CÍÎyck��Må/g�òªo
%�°ôÓX¤,êM� 1pb�kghå/g�!òªo%�°ôÓX
¤êM�¤�b�o%�°ôÓ�
ÙFÜ�°5� 3 �X¤êM� 1pb��°� 3 �+ 3 �Ã|Ä5� 5 �X¤êM� 0.5pb�o%�°ôÓ�°�Ø 5 �+ 5 �Ã|X¤êM� 0�JXb�Yåíêùå�!wÇLÏÑ� 0.75 +Ã|XêM� 1pb�ÑL� 0.50 + 0.50 Ã|XÄY� 0.75XêM� 0.67pÑL� 0.25 + 0.25 Ã|XÄY� 0.50XêM� 0.33pÑLY� 0.25XêM� 0�b�Yåí?ø�Îïë����
i%X�Îïë�yø�#È$U
�G���+î#yø�Bòª}«
��9:X+îXYåíp�4Ø
i%Ä#yø�Dy§���å&X
¤êM� 0�yÃ� 4 GÖý�[�²Mà 0.251 �ÑLVêM��f� 0.33XoBi%Yåíp4R£% Yåí¡¢�GXÄj_µB
(p4RBi%YåíXÄ��
%���j©$åív/�Yåí
@øp��L�ü@�4i%�Y
åíXÄ9�L�@4%�Yåí
À_�
Ã��ßXÁ¸0�#yck
��Må/òªo%�°ôÓVê
M� 0XX}«ôÓ+N@ø 4 �VêM� 0 . 5X�4%Yåíêùå&!wÇLÏÑ� 0 .58VêM� 0.67X�S�Á 3 ¸úL��!LX"j¿úøÄMG.´X¤�
�êM� 39 M�å/�ÐþM¿ú@ 5 ¸��
LMo(i) �rk�Ðå/@°Gp( i i ) �rkÞ«¯å/@°Gp(iii) Þå/�Ð� 5.5 3Ô� 6 3Ã|p(iv) $��µ�r@ 2 ¸���ÐÓ�ܼg����M�ÇPjÞå/
�Ða�� 50 u�+*�V�vÇ��ÐXpÃ� (v) åÅ� 1 ��5 �H 10 ��ùå��!eª�«�Ð��� 26 ¸å/¯Ô�5� 15 ¸å/¯�k�{| (i) H (ii)Xb���¡~Ô@N�°GX¤êM� 1�b�Ý$�°G�m��Ð+Þ«¯å
/�¡X¤bû¹CÍÎm���¡
yLMòúµ�D�òÄMNnl 0�0.33�0.66 + 1 �êM�b�Lgh°GX¤CÍÎ�êM� 0�k�{| (iii)Xb�4RDE�Þå/�Ð5� 5.5 3++� 6 3X¤êM� 1Xr¤êM� 0�k�{| (iv)Xb�±å�7r?X¤êM� 1X�7�?¤êM� 0�k�{| (v)Xb�eª�«� 15 �21 ¸å/¯X¤êM� 0pb�eª�«� 22 � 26 ¸å/¯X¤êM� 0 .5pb�#¥ 15 ¸å/¯+Ò� 26 ¸å/¯X¤êM� 1�
Ã�>¼+�ßXÁ¸0�kØ
�Ðå/ÇðGVêM� 1XXÄ�#°GÞ«¯å/VêM� 0XXDEµÞå/ 6 3VêM� 0XXDE 2 ¸�`@ 50 u�å/ÞVêM
´ 14.14
(0–100)
(0–100)
(0–100)
(0–100)
ef{Q
40 2011 �������
� 0XXdSj 16.7 ¸å/¯��!eª�«VêM� 0X�S�ÁÂêM��!LX"gj��øÄMG
.´Xê��>¼+J�¿ú� 20�eù�´¿ú@ 8 ¸��LMo
(i) �r#DEje��ù/���å&��ûp(ii) ÷t�� 1 ���ùå�rcdWm¶Ó�VÑb12Ø
��Xp(iii) ÷t$ÔM�� 9 ��ù�rcdWm¶Ó�p(iv) ÷t�� 1 ��ù�rcdêȶÓ�^_p(v) ÷t$ÔM�� 9 ��ù�rcdêȶÓ�^_p(vi) 4R�r£%÷tyj©$ùå%��ùc
dk,�ØMÃ+Ø Òp(vii) k��ùå�rj!9£¤p(viii) Ø���rj!9£¤�k�{| (i)Xb�k�ghCDá��ùå±å!
�7�?X¤êM� 10X·kÆ,��{|!#yø�k{| (iv)Xb�±å�7�?X¤êM� 2�k�,zµ¸{|Xb�±å�7�?XØ
¤êM� 1Xr¤� 0�{| (i) H (iv)X/�8@�·M�£%Xy�¿ú���µ�@*Ù�A��
ßbXy4ã+XDEje��ù
/�����ûVêM� 0X�÷t��$��ù���Wm¶Ó�Ø
VêM� 1X"déê,^_VêM� 1XX$ÔM�� 9 ��ù���Wm¶Ó�VêM� 1X"déê,^_VêM� 1X�4R£%X����k��ùå�Ø Ò+º
»Ny�òVêM� 1X�4ã+þk��VêM� 1XHØ��VêM� 1X@!9£%�jÁÂMLÇùKXøÄMG.´Xê��¿úØ
� 80�
eù��¿À®����$���
ùå�Ó^9WmdS��G�Hf
çÔ¡������X[mªÞúÜ
~�[\åÅ� 1 ��5 �H 10 ��ùå�WmdSH�G��!L�
�M�b�eù��ôÜ5È 8 Þ+ 8 ÞÃ��ª�PgùåOBÖ��5½�þX¤êM� 0XÄ[9ËÜ����j�mªÞú�b�eù�
�ôÜ5È 8 Þ+ 8 ÞÃ��ª�Pgùå#BÖgh«v���5½�
þXpÑ[9Ëj�mªÞúXÄ�
[ 8.1 ÞÜM�b���ôÜÒ� 8 Þª�XÜM��j�Þú�$¸�[
L¯ÓMÏ$Þç��Ø
ßbXy#ä8ã¿XdS÷
ty���ùc�!º 1 ¸�WmXPgXåÅ� 1 ��5 �H 10 ��ùå��!�G�� 1.42 ¸��ª��#CÔ¡�÷t��$�ùå¹
�côç��� 10.5 Þ�ª��
d �/CÍÎ÷øùå¿À���
úûXiO{ http://www.doingbusiness.orgX"Ä�¼�iµyz�QCÍÎ�Á$¿À��4y Botero �,z&ô(���V2004 �Xµº�Xy}?ø"@��²�
1.Ø d �/CÍÎ÷øùå¿À���úûXiO{Øhttp://www.doingbusiness.orgX"Ä�¼�iµyz�QCÍÎ�Á$¿À��4y Botero �,z&ô(���V2004 �Xµº�Xy}?ø"@��²�Ø
2.�� http://www.doingbusiness.org/Subnational/�
3.Ø �����VW�t¥ (http://www.doingbusiness.org) º»$¸NÑ�г����úû»��ÏøX$¸úû�
�"~³_�XÃyf�4�Õ¾H�
;Øù�úû¸ª�Ø
Ø @ø��Ã�ø}u����X�
���7����VW÷øù
å¿Àø}u�?ÆqXhttp://www.doingbusiness.org�
4.Ø �����VW�µ/G¿À�Õ¾YZAÙ�Ñbo$¸CÍÎy5½Ø
ìíî¿À|NOêÈ�Mú���Ä 0 È 10XPáâ���c�P§��ÐH���ÊyêM��NO�Ä 1 ÈL,Ù�
Ø Ó�djêM£�¾�d?ø$¸�k
MÓ]X�Ãyz $¸NjÁ¸Ó]
u¾�£�¾�4oY�ĵ¸Lµ
2'u�Õ¾XØj�ê����Ã
!HYg_LÏYXÄPjêM£
�È 0–1 ���`�7$¸�4�ĵ¸Läq2'µ¸¿ÀMËÏ`�µÐ
LXØj�ê���ÃÓ$¸MËäq
�À_sYXê��6Üúû����
Þm� Z êM (Z–score)�Á¸�À_yø�£�¾�4H#êM�4ÏÐ�
tdYNI��®CÍÎ��K´�
R_W�I�¶$¸�4X��©¸C
ÍÎy©¸¿À|���K´ÌR_êØ
Á¸¿À� HY.²�ÑÒ�
¶m¸�4X®$¸CÍÎ.²�R
_W�I��t"ä,z 182 ¸CÍÎ.²��!L�Á·kÆX$¸CÍÎ
��ö��êM��k��@,z
CÍÎP���Ó��À_�e���
�è��ýþ´����kMXÃó
ñ�/CÍÎ`�¶k��X�Ãyz
¶$¸�4�
Ø è�Ô@,zN»yz��åXÓ}Ø
�Ì $¸,�´M X3$3b�Ø
yz ØZ– ØêM�4X��[@+Ù#Ó�þø�2009Ø�����VW�H�2010Ø�����VW��úûXk�ø�td�4HØZ–ØêM�4ê����ÏÐ��QM³ú� Ü~X
��Á´xG�4ÏÐ@A¯��QMØ
V�QM³ú� 0.81X�Ø
5.ØW� Djankov �&�(/V2005 �X�
6.Ø Á¸{|YZÖMÈnó�+6?4�/G��@y,�d�nó�@Ø10ظÃ||k9:�uÂCÍÎa@êM�
ef�� 41
7.Ø ydK9:)*k#þ�Qm�nó�4R&g�G´�X�����VW�
«i}nó*9C�y��opH^
_������VW�#®)*)�
ÏÐ4R&g�
8.Ø �«i�q�¢s�´ÄØ10Ø=�ÇÈØ150Ø=X��kÖ��Jî*éôj�Ö×�Á$Õ¾y©GÖ×��¾�
*!�¢s��+*�����ÐV+
mî$P@ÏX�
9.Ø ùå&�!wÇL�$¸CÍÎ�&!ØGNIØêåÅ&'y¹&'µ��ÑßÏÑ�
42 2011 �������
20 09 � 6 �� 2010 � 5 ���Ð`�(�������ØeÛ $Â�¿Àú
ûXv����ý»´��;�β ÁØ
$I�
�Øj�������Ø@��*Çýþ�
� j�������Ø@��*Ç���
✔
Y�¸ª4R�XY����[5!�
�ïÑßH?øq~ºnêôçXÅ4
Êã¿@��ïðÕê*�ýX��Ø
*Y�
��
ÅmàY���&7ë���û�EF
4R¬X"dS¡¢���B7ø7
8XFÙ 7ë ��Ø
��
Åmàyòó�qh¾ cd_ ��
�X�%¾Q?ø ��zô¾Q³6Ø
MIRSAL 2X�> òócd��Ð�
�
Å1%&EF $¸t|�VXDEØ
¡¢��'}%9�7øæçL�º»
78�ĵ1*78XÄP�� 7ë
��
�
Å1%&ð4�¸;@ê�vþuðy
`�.¸ðG�ðO@�XYX"gh
¾ ���êðH�Lð��ïKN�
��
+�25 áâ������
��
+�Y�ØDºn��'���q~Ø
³6X@êòó*Çý»�
��
+1DÑ¿Y��\`LüwY��{
|X@òó*Çaó�
��
���Ç Äk1��ÐêiÜÀ_�
�ÐXyóAã¿âãäåEN6Õê
*�F|�
��
óAã¿Y�¸ª�(KN4�XD
EP5ºA&k¶·��T~(X
ÄP�� 7ë ��
��
óA㿺! ��5!�OX"jÀ
_�Lð�ðOÄ 18% |�� 20%�Ø
��
óAã¿�æË�M¼4¸;åY�
kKN���XÃ��ÕkM¼¢ã�
��íGdSXÄP�Ù ��yM¼
�KµÆ±�K�NOM�
✔
�à¼Y�y³'R{iäH³'¢ã
�q�ìí�> ñ0òó��Ð�
✗
�º3HÊË5edSè¼�I��
�8É1�ù^_Ãíî(·lV�A
�
Y�£%�@�è¼�Iæçli>y
t|ºnX)�þº! è¼�I�ý
þ´�
��
��$¸����V7�ìDû�XØ
ÊË¿�.`¿�7ë78³6êÈ
���
��
Y�jí�KLð�Ç$x� 4%XÊR+Ù�Ç æçè¼����
��
Y�y¿*+kEF��1�Ã�
*C�^�³6XyʼiâãäåE
N6Õê*Çaó�
�
��º! _®H��æçL��C�X
ÊßÇ� ��æçè¼��P�
�
ÊßY�E�²-¾³'X��q~ú
ûn,³6Ã�Ø�R� !�1�X
@òó*Çý»�
��
Ê��Y�ºÈæçù�å/�O@ê
áâ��*Çaó�
2009 2010
����ÕÖ23 43
��
Y�dSyæç���ôç���è¼
KL 3% ��øXÊ��ÙÙº! è¼�I����
��
Ê��XY ���êððOX¸�
+¸ðGX"ái ð�|R4L�
��
��º! mXHÏð��Qq~³6
�ÓåMXÊ/�áâ���� *ý
þ����
�
CD"+Y��j¶·øÌP5º»ý
þh�X"y�²P��Ö×�º»T
~(XFÙ éê7ë�} �Ø
�
��ð��[5!��ïÑßÃ�è¼
ððR���XÇ|#ìST?øq~
lV³6�öXCD"+���ïð
Õê*ÇýþX���@�XY�
�
CD"+Y�ØDq~��'VQ³6X
25 òó�c��Ð�Ø
�
CD"+¸� �·M¼¢ã&ù�
�@Q£%X"ǯ M¼�kºA&
Aþ�5½@ä�
��
Y�jYj�í�dSÄ 5000 �éVô 3250 §�XX� 2 �éVô 1.30 §�XXáâ��Õê*aó�
��
5Çþ¿XY �[5!�÷t��Ø
Ñß�
�
�iF $¸��k13ù[Ãh¾ä
åEN6�âã&KXÓ�iF$¸UN
3ù[ó�DãEN6li��¦�
�
Ñþ�8>Ë�14áBdSè¼�I
��º»p-�.6©XÁÇÙ è¼
�I��´�
�
Ñþ�G% $L�4RXÍÎuÂS
Èè����@Oö��êÃÜÆ�
��
��º! iÜé^Ã�1���øX
y��âãäåEN6���@��Ç�
��
������êððOÄ 15% º!ÈØ18%XÓ�X��c�ï��[5!H��5!ÑO�@�º!�Ø
��
½+k/y�Y����êðÏ~X¯
kfïðvÇV 5% �UNwÇðX@���ð��PÇ��
��
½Vy*¼/0��æçL�æçè¼
�²aE�Ö×�@�25�
��
½Vh¾ ��ð&KXXY �[5
!�÷t��ÑßX"Ð� ªíð�
��
��æç�Ü~�¾@½��è¼æç
*Çaó�
��
ËRï4*Y�j��_®��ø2U
Ã�jDãäåENli��Ц�Ó
MÏ$X@âãäåEN6Õê*aó
��
ËRï4*XY 4%ðOX25 ð
GX"ØD *hi�6$ïð&K�
��
ËRï4*25k�'�H�'��Ø
��ç�dSX@êòó*Çý»�
��
ËRï4*Y�iF$¸ó����4
THÐ�æç:4e\��øX(ô
ÓÕê*Çaó�
��
Ë1�ø�LðÐ-nóðX@ïð*
Çhi�
��
j@°&g9:�Yj�í�dS
Ä 125,000 ñ�� $22,850 XYÈØ80,000 ñ�� $14,620Xyñ�áâ��Õê*Çaó�
��
$0Y�º!96L�H��ñIL�
ÏÐ�ÀY�OXg#ØdSyV£|
mË-�X@áâ��*Çaó�
44 2011 �������
��
½lm' ÒHgÝ ��4ü"Y�
��Q*RS4Xº! 4L�O�
��
+=ãÇ�H0���9:«vV@°
&g9:XiÄ�Yj�í�dS�Ø
100,000 +=ãÇÑ* $2,855Xáâ��*Ç���
��
yD"+@Q��@ø�q��@P§
>NÃy$¸ý'9�X@âãäåE
N6*Çaó�
��
2009 �D"+?Ð $³�F4@äX¯¾ ëy&�AþX�� M¼ÎG�
��
23+4ØD�[5!t|æç³6X
áâ��Õê*Çaó�
��
ùRúyk$øá( $u�!�X@á
â��*Çaó�
��
ùRúyøq�ø�kJÇÙ âãä
åEN6��´�
��
ùRúY���q~¾Q³6X�Ç
q~çyHt|VQ�ÇOXÄP@ò
ó�c��ÐH��@�25�
��
2ÍY�áâ�J!�µtH��¾Q
û�@òó*Çaó�
��
��¿% $�ó��&è¼æç�æ
çùXsßï5�è¼�I�c�Ð.
b�> $U�
��
Y�h¾KN�251����ùå
Ò��¯øJÀYXsßï5�¾Q¢
ãL�@òóÕê*«»�
��
s�9¿��?Ðq~úû�yt|á
�Xj² ¶·�æç��µ¾¢ãX
ÄPFÙ éê7ë�} �
��
Y��$åÇÙ��78y÷ã�Ð�
á�K´Xs�9¿Ç¯ kìíî�
5½�
��
Y�h¾9á�²KN�ØD�&(4ü
�Z[�\³6²-¾Xs�9¿@ô
Ó�(*Çaó�
��
s�9¿Y�h¾�²£¤X�� M¼
RSKN�
��
��ç��ú�¾Ç« ¹*���ç
H^%�ç��KXi¿uÓ}�áâ
���� *ýþ����Ø
��
i¿uY�EF¡¢¬XDE%�&
7ë��æm(\XrlYy&1��
�í>�AþXÄPFÙ 7ë ��
��
.`¿ !^_³6���@¾QØ
25 kú��j�1�XÄPÇ«
òó�
��
7ê�Ð� �����kø1�X
"kkø(\�ìK³6Ü~�¾XØ
@áâ��Õê*Çaó�
��
7ê�¼�[è¼KLÄMÑC���
�X�P?ø*Y�o%�OXæçè
¼Õê*Çaó�
��
7ê�Ð� ¶¥HÈû�f ð�Ø
��
2010 �þ��H0j���êððOÄØ38% X� 36%�
��
þ�Qt�H0Y�Ð�$ÂKNXØ
�v9:f¸X@áâ��*Çaó�Ø
��
��âãEüEN���Ä�äå��
� 1% X�� 0.6%XÓ�km�äåEN��Ðj °GXÓ}yþ�Qt
�H0âãäåEN6Õê*Çaó�À
��
þ�Qt�H0jè¼�Ið2525
$UXX��è¼KL� 3%�
��
àáÑ¿Y���äå6©�q~Ø
�6X@âãäåEN6*Çaó�
��
sßï5j��ñI��&�4L�³
ÈQ1¢ãL�X@áâ��*Çaó�
����ÕÖ23 45
��
Ü*+ÙjYj�í�dSXY�
100 ²3 $0.70X"#ØdSk��Ù4H9:¸K�96XÄP@áâ
��*Çaó�
��
Ü*+ÙY�jê9ø*�jâh
��Q�$u�!�X@âãäåEN
6*Çaó�
��
Ü*+ÙdSy9:�´VWµop
*+78Xǯ kìíî�5½�
��
Y�?ø$G !¢ã³6Hº!¾
Q��²¾�$³�ǯ¾Q²-¾�Ø
öXÜ*+Ù@êñ0òóÕê*
«»�
��
¾�Ð� �¹6+¹ãâ9�kºn
�ñI9:li�÷��£%XÄP
@áâ��Õê*aó�
��
y,0XDãM¼{|Õê*aó X
Ó�áBDE��yº�M¼liJØ
�¢íX"gnl������!
9éêëy�Aþ�
��
Ü��[�lVH�ï�Lð��[
�´lVH�ïXXY lVH�ïÝ
O�Ó�DEuvjÎyÜ~���ê
ð�@ø�´V./��û�
��
VY?øi$æç.sºnnð�¢ãØ
L�XÐ� áâ���c�ëØGØ
P§�
��
949+�H0#ØdSk9:�B&
�ò��96X@áâ��*Çaó�
��
949+�H0h¾ M¼RSKNX
"¸� k¢ã&ù�dSXÄ�bc
RSKNdøP���P§@Qõ��
*���
��
.`¿º! âãäåEN6��ø�
��
.`¿Ñ¯iF ó����4TXÇ«
ôÓ�(�
��
Ç�Ù�Ù?�HmX@ø 6$�ï
ðlViX"XY ��Hùå�ðO�
��
Ç�ÙY�F(q~��ºn���h
¾&KXº! 4L�O�Ø
��
ÇïY�EF�µ�¶·æçµtX"
%�&7ë��V2010 � 4 �áB��Xæm��(\XÄPFÙ 7ë ��
��
567Ð� �û1�X25 ��
'�c���"�> ��
��
»h¾ ��ðâð&KX"XY
�[5!�÷t��Ñß�Ø
��
»DãM¼{|Õê*ÇaóXqÓ
�k�Q4R� ¸�X@M¼åß
µ�¶��ÖÈ°GX7~X8�î
� ©ÂM¼º�&º�M¼li�Ø
¸��
��
ñ���æç:L��Ü~��Xj
æçè¼cd�P§25 $U�
��
ÉÊËÌXY ñI�øXÇ« �ç
¹*�9:ñIHð�æç�&KXÄ
P@áâ��*Çaó�
��
ÉÊËÌ���êððOÄ 30% X� 25%Xí�C�ððOÄ 20% X� 5%X"h¾ ���êð��ïP§XDE
µ¸�´È����ï�
��
9�1Y�á($u�!�XÐ���
l��'j��Q�øX@áâ��*
Çaó�
��
Å84�Ç $¸ð�æçHÐê9:
f¸�KNX@áâ��*Ç���
46 2011 �������
��
W*Xø7è1��?Ð-Ãcd�Ø
ð���X@áâ��*Ç��XÓ�Ø
7è1��?�æmcd*��ÐXPg
cdð�¢ãL�891���l��
��
WU�7Ð� å^_XâãäåEN
6Ó}Õê*Çaó�
��
DE@°&g9:Y�96&Ãq~�
�y4L�æç³6º�æçliXÄ
P@áâ��Õê*aó�
��
Y�øi$(\Ð-y¥EN6H0e
iÜ^_X"�¿@êâãäåEN
6Õê*ý»�
��
âã¿Y��>��Ù4H9:¸K
�Ú¸�ÐXô"ðH�Lð�æçK
NXyæçùDjç�ú�¾�@äX
@áâ��*Çaó�
��
âã¿dS[�´lVªíðXÇ�
ïð�¢ã�P�
��
âã¿Y�jäq~ú�^�³6X"
j¹³6êâã¿CD¢ã��q~ú
ûn,³6¢sÃø�pQXÄPÇ«
òó]´�
��
¼è�¿Y�ØDq~VQiºn³6X
�> ��'��
��
¼è�¿ØD $GM¼å��T~H
��GX2: 4L�¦öX"C�
©ÂKN�J�°�
��
�;ø$G���LðÐ- ��ð�
��
kÊ<áâ������@��Ç�
��
kÊ<DEt|O{9�7øæç
L��VWXÄP�� 7ø78³6�
��
FéêC�k9���ñI�c�Ð�
°G�
��
Féê��&7ë��e�C�H
mË@QYy&�;q78�
��
Féê=2 ���ïð�P�
��
Féêbû¾�4RX?ø q~³6º
nVQiXÄP25 �'�c��Ð�
��
FéêG% @QM¼¢ã&ù�4£X
�<£% P4&g�
��
3+>Ç« ��(\�nç]´X@á
â��*Çaó�
��
345� 2010 � 4 �æY� ��Eü4£X"�/GEN6�æmi%
���°XÁ@êâãäåEN6*Ç
aó�
��
345Y�IYy&@A1�z)�
��7øVWXÓ�/Gv´�ëy>Ø
cd|Vn��9�7ëæç��X
ÄPFÙ 7ë ��
��
34525 �c�òó��ú®XÓ�
ǯ ê×Ø5�,z00�môÖ�
¢ãKNXòó�&��êÈ ���
��
"�ã¿kêäåEN6�Q�£%�
¸�XXY �c��øX25
�c���
��
"�ã¿kêäåEN6�Q�£%�
¸�XXY �c��øX25
�c���
��
"�ã¿k,M¼4� Ù@´�¸
�XØD T~�\KN�E+�`aX
Á@êDãM¼{|Õê*Çaó�
��
�5Ç+Çy¬§XY9:ððO�
��
yòó±²µX�5Ç+Ç@øi$³
6ǯ ¾Qê�¦û��ÏÐ�ÀY
ê��XÄPXY ��'���XØ
25 ��'���
����ÕÖ23 47
��
�d9:M=:L��4-?&¬@X
�4-?²yDEñI�9:?@���
��
Y�j�t^_Hæç4R�©��Ð
25 $UX�¼�@êè¼�³Õê
*aó �
��
�¼�Y�º!NÃ%4Lº����
*Ä|°Xh¾ ôÓ�(�
��
�K/¿Y�³�*+t|!�@áâ
��*Çaó�
��
�K/¿Y�ØDt|^_X�>
è¼�I��ÐX25 è¼�I�Ø
���
��
�äh¾ k#F|���Eü��
�eÛde�&KX@âãäåEN6
*Çaó�
��
�äY�j9:�è¼�Ið��è¼
KL� 15% X�� 7%Xè¼�IÕê*aó�
��
�äÐ� k�'ú�+��1�X�>
ñ0òó��Ð�
��
Y��$å��,$u�ý'!�@á
â��Õê*aó�
��
Y�£%���cd��MÃþu�ï
���êðX�,-XY ���ð�
���
��
�¯4ö�Y�$L@Q²¼P5nó
��4X�� éê7ë� ��¹4
dSEF¶·æçµtX@æNø�¶
·�í¼��XDEkº�Hø/¶·
���$\M]�X"�@P5
ºA&yM¼KNÏ~EF�<�!9
A£¤�
��
#äS+�Ç $G���[&gð�
��
Y��i*+�4üH�Ç4T�ú®X
#äS+Ç« ��ßà��\�
��
§0���ªíðXÇ� yA�kØ
Ù>[YBnYÀàû��9:�ð�
�P�
�
òǼ0Ð� ��C f ðÈ�Ø
dSX"�$å�¯ t|ñI³6X
ÄP@áâ��*Çaó�
�
òǼ0jè¼�IðXY�è¼KL
� 6.7%�Ø
��
6�Y�h¾��(\�dS�º»$
u�t|��ñI!�X@áâ��*
Çaó�
��
6�Y�¢ã�q���h¾ âãä
åEN6�P§�
��
6�y��æçµØD «ë KNX
ÄP@è¼æç��Ð�> $U�
��
6�Y�jä��R�t%�q~úû
n,³6� !1�H�� !b��
a�çyX@òó*Çaó�
��
54+7XY �[5!�÷t��Ø
Ñß�
��
VY¸� ,���êð4XÐ� º
ôç�¸�HEiø�C��
��
VY¾Q¢ãL�#ØdSº»��'
�¦�ûCûXÄPh¾ òó�
��
5õàdSy9:�´VWµop*+
78Xǯ kìíî�5½�
��
DÚÑY�Ø�h¾�(\æm&
KX@áâ��*Çaó�
��
./àj $u�t|��ñI!��
��
./àY�ô"Hh¾êMÀ£ÝH9
ø*��Q�KNX�� âãäåE
N6�&K�
48 2011 �������
��
./àº! ëØðGX�v���ê
ð�ðOÃ�²¡ÆyþOX�Ç 9
:�ð��P�ÄÓ�XY��t|ô
çH?ø[ÜE�º»*+yzX�$
å25 1�P�
��
ãǼ3Y�º!�[5!��ÑßX
kÆy�fÜþ8¹vÇV 10% �-í�êðX�Ç 9:�ð��P�Ó
�X¹0�Y����� ðy�
q~ôç�Ø
��
ãǼ3Y�@ø��¾Qq~úû
n,³6XiF$u�jÎÍ!���
'XÃ�yWßÔ³ìí���i X
Ç« òó]´�
��
ã¯4XY ���êð�ðO�
��
ÊR+ÙY���żͳ���ê�
��¦ÏÐ�q~ÀYX�'cd��
Ð@��>�
��
012á( $u�è¼æç!��
��
012j $0���[5!4X"
XY ���êððO�Ø
��
¯�Y��F��jÎ7��ØÜô�
��?XÍÎuÂ�º��Ä¢ãûM
ó��9:éê�ÜXý�DãM¼�
��
#öjk@°&g9:�Yj�í�
dS25 $UXÄP@êáâ��Õ
ê*aó�
��
#ö#ØdSÄk12Ðê9�AFîX
@è¼æç*Çaó�
��
#ödS9:�*+�78opX
"kþ��Q�ÏÐ�nó÷^Ì�£
%Xǯ ìíî5½�
��
*5¿Ä��æç�O�G�%�A
GX"9:j²��æç�Ü~�¾X
jæçè¼��Ð�> 4 ¸��Ø
��
14�¿Y� ��M¼4X,µØD
T~�\H6$���KN�
��
1¼þ�h¾ äå�I÷�HäåE
N6�æm&KX@äåEN6�âã
*Çaó�
��
1¼þ�Ð� k�&�@è¼�²�
a�GA�
��
1¼þ�ø¼©H!�ðÐ- ��H
!�ð�
��
1H4Ð� îð�I°GX"XY
���êððO�
��
Y�ØDh¾��&KXAUżB
¢§¶m�@äåEN6�âã*ÇØ
aó�
��
AUżBk,��²ÄA4� Ø
¸ªXÇÙ@P5ëy�¦±MX"D
Ey�²P��Ö×��T~(X
ÄPFÙ éê7ë�} �
��
AUżBy95³�E� $¸��
ô�¦X�> �'cd��Ð�
��
AUżBY�9�JC�\�
kM¼p~j��аGST ëy
&�WêXÇ« M¼KN�
��
ó+§H�ß/Ñ�@°&g9:��
F£% Yj�í�dSX@áâ�
�*���
��
ó+§H�ß/Ñj���êððOX
�À_� 25%�
��
Y���$u�!�X@*+!�Nt
|9�Xy+õ�ã¿áâ��Õê*
aó�
��
+õ�ã¿y��æçµ*+�?øÜ
~�Xjè¼æç�²aE�Ö×25
75%�
��
+õ�ã¿Ð� ªíðX"�� �
��êððO�
����ÕÖ23 49
��
+�ý�dS9:�*+�78o
pX�$åǯ9:)*{&GXDE
5úMAìíîO{*+�9:78X
ÄPǯ ìíî�5½�
��
+�ý�Y�y,Ö1ujø�pQ
�q~úûn,³6XÄP25 �'
���
��
�"�ö�Y�$L@Q²¼P5nó
��4X�� 7ë ��¹4@æ
Nø�¶·�í¼��XDEk¶·P
5�º��$\M]�X_ET~(
X"iF ¶·æçµt�
��
��ái $u�!�ý'Xjy0�
�QHð��Q�æçå/kôùKX
89+Ù�áâ���� *ýþ�
���
��
89+ÙdS9:y�´VWµop
*+9:78X"DE5úMAìíî
O{*+�9:78XÄPǯ kì
íî�5½�
��
89+ÙXY ���êððO�
��
�0��� jx��XY�
Ið���â4Xæçè¼���@�
��
��
�0XYó�ð 12 ¸�X8�2: ���ð��P�
��
ôÇø0`~9:6$� 25% ���êððOÐ- xøðGXØ�R{Ú
Û�í�É G´��ðC!�Ð-ð
C!��H,zðC!�XÄPh¾ Ø
ïð&K�Ø
��
4ã+����êðH�Lð��ïØ
D q~ôç³6�
��
4ã+ãø ��'q~úûn,³6X
ǫ �'���2��
��
3`#¼��yñI���q?ø $
G�KNXáâ��Õê*���
��
3`#¼Ð� ¡¢nóð�
��
Y�º!9:æçù��O�jäq~
�ç¹*³6Xy�;áâ��Õê*
Çaó�
��
�;j���êðÄ 23.5% X� 22%XÓ��u��j *Y�ðOX®�Ø
5.5% È 11%�
��
q~¾Q³6�?ø�ý �;�òó�
��
×Ø5º! òó(\�C�X@áâ
��*���
��
×Ø5Y��E$¸��V7�FÙ
éê7ë�} �
��
×Ø54L³6��O¬§º!XÙÙ
�> liH÷ã*Ä�c��Ð�
��
×���Ù@´XY Yj�í�
dSX@êáâ��Õê*aó�
��
×�Y�(:0H��4£Xh¾
&KX@âãäåEN6*Çaó�
��
×�Y�Ø�"#ì�¯�Lðq~
lV³6X@ïð*Çaó�
��
��#ØdSÐê¯G�9�AFîX
y×¼iKê��¿kæçè¼*ÇØ
aó�
��
×gN+Ùº! êäåEN6�Q
KN��@C��
��
/pHÇA�Ç 9:�n�R÷�X
@áâ��*Ç���
��
/p¾QKN��OÙÙº!X�òó
�� *ýþ����
50 2011 �������
��
Y�jêð0@Q�78ïD,i$�
1��X/�2h¾ �'���
åP§�
��
/�2k@QM¼KN�£%� Ø
¸�X25 �c��ÐXXY ���
�4£Ó�ØD T~�\�
��
��j�IðÄ�è¼KL� 1% |�� 10%X;׺! è¼�I����
��
�/�G% ��Àà4L£¤X@ô
Ó(�KkøJ*ÇJC�
��
¼2þkäåEN6�æmiÄ �°�
��
¼2þkè¼æç�ø�=2@´5È
è¼KL� 6%�
��
¼2þðGHðR�@�25�
��
¼2þC�¸ª�M¼4STM¼��
��êºA&5�T~�ÃíîM¼�
��
Y�j@°&g9:�Yj�í�d
S=2ÓMÏmX6þ¿º! áâ�
��ýþ´�cÓ�j9:¸K�÷^
MG¾�
��
6þ¿��Ð� kN�Dúû��ë
y�Y�I°GXk¸&H9:7ë
78�QÚqFÙ����&'� 2.2%XÙÙ�Ç 7ë78�a®�
��
2�ÇXY è¼�³ðH�³�øX
Ç« æç&KXDEt|O{9:æ
çùº»�78Xý�è¼�³�
�
��y¾QH��iÄ �ÎVQVX
Ó�Y�ìí�� �i º! Ö�
Q'�û�OX7~ÔØD $G
!¢ã³6X¿§ã¿º! ñ0òó
�ýþ´�
��
~�³�}mt�JXDE9:�â&
¹*"^%Ý$�9:�çX@áâ�
�*Çaó�
��
��F��&7ë��X�� éê7
ø78� ��
��
~�Y�k©Â��?ø q~ºn�
�XÓ�ØD >7YmHq~å�¢
ã³6X(ôÓÕê*Çý»�
��
ÃL�;yF(,q~úûn,³6"
ámi$ý'¬X@2�/¸���c
���*ÇaóX��> òó�Ð�
��
Y���,t|ñI³6X·Ùþ�á
â���� *ýþ����
��
Y���LðæçEFt|æç³6X
Ã�øq~¨¸Ð-q9�j�¨¸X
f´�áâ��º» *ýþ����
��
f´Y�Ð�we�þð���q~ô
ç³625 ïð�1�P�
��
Y�XYé^H^²9:�ç�c��
�Ã��>^²9:�çH^_��¸
K�c��ÐXf´ã/¿º! áâ
���ýþ´�
��
f´ã/¿XY ���êð�ðO�
��
f´ã/¿³�i$ý'!�X�>
�'�c���
��
Y���4LµQ*KN�²-¾X�0
�� ôÓ(�&K�
��
�0kM¼£¤�¸�jh¾M¼K
NX@þ�9:�kÎ�¥X"��k
¢ã�ø�Ü~�
��
�n��&7ë����FG%¡¢¬
XXYcd%9�7øæçL�VW�
ëy�IXÄP�� 7ø78³6�
����ÕÖ23 51
��
�nÐ� ©ÂðGX"DEÃq~�
�ºnCDðH¶¥ð�lV.�
��
z�á( $u�!�X��(\Hð
�(\Ny$DâãXÓ�y9:EN
µ#ØdSf¸XÄP@áâ��*Ç
aó�
��
z����9åEü�æç���X 50%XÇ|æçEü�AöÄ��¢ã���D0�íæê��LXâãäå
EN6Õê*aó�
��
z�Y�@Yy&@A1�z)���
7øVWX"k�EÇÃß;XÄP�
� 7ø78³6�
��
:Ñ¿Ð� Yj�í�dSX@á
â��*Çaó�
��
:Ñ¿Y�yêÉÊËÌ�Ö�j$
u�Ö1X³�VQ�y�ºn!�X
Ã�yÖ1uØDM]©XÙÙº!
òó�ýþ´�
��
:Ñ¿Y�ØDq~å�¢ã³6��
ôÓ(Ö×XÁ¸³6NÃÃq~
�ý�º»åßW��4Rúû�Hj
��T÷�(VWXÔO@9��34
L�
��
NêY�¸�����[5!��ÑßX
�Ç ���ð��P�Ø
��
�þ?ø t|ñI³6�t|/�m
ËiSXáâ��Õê*Çaó�
��
�þ¸ª 6?4XdS9:�*+
�78opX"kþ��Q�ÏÐ�n
ó÷^Ì� £%XÄPǯ ìíî
5½�Ø
��
µ0��V����êð46$ 0`
~���ðGX"Tp Ü~���ê
ð�fïð�êv�Ü~�4�
��
µ0V4Y��>1�9:�ç�ñI
{ÜÜÝ�li×����H�²5!
�c��ÐX@áâ��*Çaó�
��
µ0V4XY ���êððOXh¾
ïðlV.s����êð�VC£
¤��µ�êð�Ü~�4�
��
µ0ð³UN1ÀÐ� Oê�éØ
êð�
��
µ0ð³yQ*÷ëγjä���º
! �\��ßà��OH�����
Ø
12 2011 �������
2011 �����VW��y Janamitra Devan �¹Î¿��X� Sylvia Solf�Penelope BrookVg�Ï� 2010 � 5 �XH Neil GregoryVÄ 2010 �6 �ùáBg�Xß���� �����ù�voSvetlana Bagaudinova�Jose Becerra�Karim O. Belayachi�Frederic Bustelo�César Chaparro Ye d ro�Maya C h ou e i r i�S a nt i a go Croci Downes�Karen Sarah Cuttaree�Marie Del ion�Allen Dennis� Jacqueline den Otter�Raian Divanbeig i�Alejandro Espinosa-Wang�Antonio Garcia Cueto�Carolin G e g i n at�C e m i l e Ha c i b e yo g l u�Betina Hennig�Sabine Hertveldt�Mikiko Imai Ollison�Ludmila Januan�P� Nan Jiang�Palarp Jumpasut�Dahlia K hali fa�Eugenia Levine�Jean Michel Lobet�Valerie Marechal�Andres Martinez�Frederic Meunier�Alexandra Mincu�Robert Murillo�Joanna Nasr�Titilayo Oke�Oleksandr Olshanskyy�Dana Omran�Caroline Otonglo�Yara Salem�Pilar Salgado-Otónel�Jayashree Srinivasan�Susanne Szymanski�Tea Trumbic�Marina Turlakova H Lior Ziv�Koichi Ito�QFÏ Lizhi Liu�Junko Miyazaki�Janet Morris�R� Di Wang H Bryan Welsh ����_ å/º» ÍÎ�Ø
�����VW�úû��y�!�Ø
� Ramin Aliyev�Preeti Endlaw�Felipe Iturralde Escudero�Graeme L i t t l e r�Ku n a l H . P a t e l�Vi n o d Thottikkatu H Hashim Zia �&¢ã�
Nadine Ghannam �&�2011 �����VW��SÎH�¶�?�±²
H�E�?¤� Jamile Ramadan �&��@�m�¢ãÃ�~m±²>
�y Suzanne Smith �¿��9���
�����VW���k���
��Ó*)º»�ÐÑ·�Ã���Ø
��)*)nl�¿�.´�t
����
Oliver Hart H Andrei Shleifer �Á¸0eº» §âE�ïð�q��
��ê��� ô/��XÁ0å
/� Robert Morris ß�� Géêqö¿À�c�í¡�ò�7ÔR¡Ø
(Norwegian Trust Fund) º»�
Alison Strong �&VW��� Tå/�Gerry Quinn �&VWH¨.��qiÜ�
b�ü@K� 183 ¸CÍÎ� 8200 +�R÷�[Ü÷�4ü���tHØ
9�L�üù�õöU�1XÁ=VW
�#NO G9���y: H/¸
�À�:)º»`a��uÂMNy
c)ò���/��â9�9� +
¸���9:�Ø
��UN¿�Xr¤�VWµ�Ø�!
K������VW����ô/`a�
;<êȸN=��&��i����
���m³��������VW�Ø
tuohttp://www.doingbusiness.org�
1.Ø �����VW���k�'��� �ô/`a Courtney Fowler j�VWXX�Ø2010 �'���ïð¿À� 2006 ��D�����VW�ÃKXFowler �ý$ÏyÁ�q@�U�X7~XXÔ�&k.¸µ¿CÍÎ����
http://www.doingbusiness.org