rN'l'ltE ciltCtJr.t.(:olJN.t.\,

GI;AVA. I-I.C'

SKYI,IJI{ CASE

NO\\/ Ct)lvt Iis

addrcss 7-). I l: l.+ j.95

A\ lo\L.l-t"1. t.I.t).

lsstreti ro ('l i.r\ lt'i

('o\4MUNI('At-10N.S

tlru'iirllorr.'ing:

cotJRl'llEtrAlt'l

Nn l0 | l-L-

(la l*rdar \\,'[)c'lL'rrda rrt.s

l\'lovlnt ,lrrlrn l)trc 75.l.l:.1.1j 95 1,,N1pyirrrt,,i idc,trlied b-r II,

' bv a'cJ rirr.,uh it$ art()*L'\. 1.,^H'orrl.l('rrs or. .rr:r r.rar\, .lattti t)rtrr r'r rlris lr.rrtr'.trJu ( t'tr.t ttr (Jr*rsrr pJliirrrif'r-r s1r.,-,1r,..1111

l:lt ( o\1ivil. rNt( A I tONS lN(. .,\Nt)r0lt (.il,\tt I I i<Ll.(.(collcctii,cl_r, .'CllAR I-lll{.-) ancl jn sLrpp()11 rrl.u,hiclr srurcs

IIACN(JI{()t INI)

I'}hirrtrl'{'(iIlr\Vr\. l-l-('lilccl its cornpluirrr ugainsl l)u,lLnd;rnr SK\,] I.lt (.r\Sl: rrn'lrr,c lr)' l0 ll l'ltu corrrplltirrt illlegcs I)cllnclarrr p,rticiplrrud irr sr g1r111p11tcr rrlrcriirru"cttttslliritcr" anci tlt;rt r'rhuli clticsti.rtctl hr I'1,i,tirl-r irscllr.5. l)crulrril*rrt:rrlrriittui,r rlrlartitipatiorr. Curlpl.tirtt pat.s. 15. l6: l)cl.crrdarrr i\nsirct.to (.o111p13i11t plir.s. 15. l6

l)l;tirrlil'1-GtlAVA' l'l-( lncl l)cfc.danr sK\'l.r:ti cAsl. prcs*rrccr .rr.r cr..cr.scre\;tg'ccd r,ritiort,u.lLr rr -r(). l0, lirr thc er.rlr-\ (,i a, ()rcrcr.arrth.r.izir!: thc ri ircrtrsrrre trl.trrepcrsottall-v iduntillaLrlc jtllilrrtllttiott ol'eit['rlc ()pcrar()r srrr.rsr.:r.ibcr.s. irrcrrrtii,g c'lAIt r l:]{C()N1NlI'NI('\TIONS

INl'llOt) U(''t'r()N

[irorit ilre flcts allceed in tlre conrpiairrt. it i.s lirr li'rrnr clcar rh;rt vunrrc is propcr or.

.iLirisdictiorr over an), ol'tire par.t.ics ol'

;r) l'lairrrill' (lt r,\V 4. l.t.(' is an lllinoisu()Illorillt()n. b) thaf arrr,ol'thc ailr:urcl hackilre aclivitics occtrr.r.cd in thc Statr; ri[. lllinois.

c)t,at l)el'errcjarrt sKyLIrrt cASr: resircs i, thc starr--.t',ririois cl )rhirt rirr or'r)rir irrtit.l.s.corllprrters ()('pr()Pert)' lic.s irr lllirroi.s. or c) rhat t6e ll) udr.lrssscs ;rlleuccj $ithcr aru iltlllinois' itncl ltor'" tltcr at'c or ilt'e tt(rl ae curiltc. I his prcriucics pcr.s()r.)ill iLrrisrJicti.,bccause tlris paucir,r, r,iolates tlrc dLre proucss rcquircrtrurrrs ol.tlrc tJS (.tlrrsritrrliorr Lrrrtjcr

irtternalional Shoe. arrd thc hroailcr aiid lreie[rrcnud clLrc l]!.(]ce\\ l"lrotectiorrr ol.tlrc lllinois

Const it ut iorr

Sccortd' thc complaillt cittt attd shoir kJ hc ciisrnisse.l sul sp()nril h.r,t5is c(rr1.1 (,,*

to tllc P;ltlcrt-r Lrl 'spccificitv irr tlrc cc,r.rrplii inl as t() u) tlrr: iclcrl rtr (rl'tjrc 'rrr,lrr.rcti

c(lllll)trlcr liircnsics liInr l-r1 thc ircrrrll ntdth()J\ qscj tp icicrrtil\ fhc irllcsud ll) ltltlr.e:scr(r'r'ltlt rcc0grtiz.ed 'ccierltif ic solilvirre rvas rrsctl. il' ;rrr; ) c) tlrc qLralilic;iri.rs rrl' rheLttrttrtrllc'd coi)lptrtcr fi:rcrtsics ilrnt. unci cJ) rvlrat.sciunrillc or t:thc,rctl.)o(l()l()gical hlrsrsplaintiff'oI its lir.ulrsics Ii'rtr ltas lirl irsserrine rhlrr tlrc ll) liiidrcsse s. irrcltrtl irrr \4

l)ors l-48. No. ll-9061. l0l? \,V1. lt9(rL)-IJ. *j (N.l). lll .lLrnc tl. l00l) (,,Ccrrur.alli,.;rpartl'lacks stantlirlg to e;r'rash a sirbpt'rr:nl issur-rci lo il n()r'rpirrty Lrlress the p.rrt.\,5as l cluir,ol'privile'ge atrachcd t. tlr( irllirr.rinlitrir s,uirhr ()r unress it inrplic,rcs a pi*r \,s 1:r.irae 'irrtcrcsts.") (erlpltlsis aclijcd ). ('out1s lrin e lirtrpd .rtalclirru ip _siqrilar e.ases. evcp rr,5e retlte Movant's priVncy irrtercsr is "rriirrirnalal rresr.,,rrraribrr rr4eciia. Lr_(- v. r)oe.s

ll'.161. l0l2 Wl- 2i675.5.i. *l (S D. (-al, .lLrnc ll. l0ll). llceuusc l)oe lrrs

l-15. No

al lc;tst aItritlirtrit I prir'ac-v illtcrcst irt thc inlb.rrariolr

'cclLrestcri b.r.tLrlr,ocrr,. hc has starrcli.r rtr

ohjcct sce l-hird Dcgrec Irilnrs. lnc. r,. ljous l-lOii. No. ll-.1{)07. l()il wl- (r(rg055 *-)(l)" I\4d [:ctr 2ti' 2012) ("]torve'cl rninirnal or'cxccccJinglY srnall,tlru l)oe I)clcncJrrnrs,;ntt'resls hrt'c'are- paItics ttur:cl r.rrrl.r'huvc'sorrrc pcr.strnai r.irht or,r.ivilcgu irr rlrcinlbt'tnation stlLrslrl'lo have srirrrding ro clrailcngc a sLrbpocna to r rhircl ,arl)',).Il. l'l.AIN1'lFI.' r.tAS I,i\il,Ir)'fo Ar,r,F.(;r,. Irr\('.r.S sL,r,r,ort-r.rN(; .r.nrsc()urt'r"s ,,URISr)rC-r'roN Ovr..r{ Nr oVAN'r. OR ti\/r,.N or.. At Y r)i\ R.r.\,

Phintil'1'(;LjAVA. l_1.( hus lailed to allesc, lilcts in rhe corirplajrrr ro r:srllrlish tiiartltis c0u11 ltas irrrisciiction over rhc panies. itsc-ll-or l)clcnclarrr sKyl.l:l{. (.AS[:. 0r oli\l(-)\illll' At l"rc'sr' t)lairitil'l'ltas tr.sscrtucJ a lcgirl corrclir.si.ir.l jrrr.isrjietirrrr i.r.lrrlu thu [r*refhcts llltged in tlrc cortrplairrl aru' s, r.lgv.irl ,f'rircrs cst;rblirhirrq c'c, rt prirrr, lircic cuseol'pcrsonal irrrisdiction that tlris case slroulcJ r)rLlvs no lirrthcr. l'5c l.ss .f'r.,.r.irrrr.spriVate' pers.rtall-i idcllrillahlc ittlirlrrration. is a bcil tlrlrt ci.ur!r()r he ,rr.rrrrq .rc, il'lutcr.irljnal order r.nlcrcd iri tlrts cotr:.t i,rirtrlcj latcr Lre lirLr ncJ lo hc voicJ. (.oerci,.r- cllirrrs;rre'rtractiltg scttlelllelll' thc' prtlspcct ttl- bcirrg narncr..i i, a iarr sLrit .sstre iutecl vr irhporll()graph-\'(lts plairrtilJ'corrrtscl's lau lirrrr ira.s buutrnrt: rrtrlrrri.rrs lilr.). ar.c,;igllr likL:lrIo occtll livcn tltc pa'\t c\pcr;ertce til-nranr ot]rcr.lclirr l)or:s in srrril,r lirig^ti.rr. (Scu.cg .

'ltrrrltrst Picrrrl.esV'Dtlesl-75. No. ll Cl 1546 Llrrirct1 Srlrcs I) jsrrict (.L.rrrn ljr. .l hc

NortherttDi'stIict()l'IJlin.isllastcr. l)i'isitm.i)irru: Arrerrst:7.201 l ...rrrti!lcsr,.ir hirrrhisdistrict ltavu lccogniz.cd rhat plairrtil-l s in thcsc types of.cuses rlighr r.rrrlirir l-r thr.cutcn lodisclose dct'endants,identitres irr ordcr to irn;.rropei.ll, lcvcraue seillclncnr ne{otiations.See l-lard D|iYe ProdLrcriorrs v, [)ocs l_.]ll. N() ll_9061. l0i2 \\,1.ll9(r0.tg. *6 (N.l) lll'fr-rrrr l'1 ' l0ll1 lrvarrting plarrtrill ttt s6liridcr Ilule ll beIbrc iriirrrirrs dcr,rrlarrr r'rr'drsprrtcd tlrat rrc rra

I']laintifl'alleges' r\nd' tltc [jirst AtrtertcJr,crt "r'ecluirc.s cor/11s [o (-r.riiurc c.i,rrlairrts likcthis ollc t'vorrld at lelrst sLtrvivL'it t,otiorr to di-srniss. bclirrc rlru c.r,-t lrurh.rizes c,rr_idiscovcr;'to iclc-ntilv artrrrIcl.r n.lhirrr,b,rrl lrirr' rhcsc ll)addrcsst,s ilrc supp()scdl-r rrncorr;r,cti "l lrr-,prosl)ecl ol.hrrrrcir.cr_ls rrr.tlrorislrncls rrl.irutrplehcillu colltacttd Lr-t'Plarlltil'1. rrltetltcr ltir scrtlerncnt ercrrarr

these persorrs (irtcluding nl()\rilnt)arc ri-,rhtlir ll-r tlrgetcd. arrr.i h) thrrt rhc,-sc clir irrrs hc[)n!lrr this'iLrriscjictior.i' fultrreo'cr. it is possihlc tt-r s1.r.r|il, ai-idr.ussc.s. [)isr-.vcr' ar thi., prrirrishould br. u itlt lhe partir,-s arrrJ f,huir cL)ntputcr.s\stL.nls lil.st. t]()l irurtrjr.r:LJs r)1.\tr.altgcl.s tr)lh is lir tgur ion.

IV. il,r, r No r s' coNS',t't'r'U'r'r 0NA I. r) t,[,] r,ri oc riss CON C I! r{NS A It r.,IrVUN IIrcrrE*.'\Nr),rus'r'rFy nriivrissnr. r)rjE.r-0 r,n cK ()r.-PEITSONA I, .I TJITIS I)CI'I.I0N

Firlallr'' sirrce Plairltil'i'has clt,scrr t. f rlc tlri.s r,r,",srit i. srutc coLrrl r,ti.lr,r tharltbderal ctlurt' this cotll'{ lru'\l hc rrrirrdlrrlthal not o.l-v r,rst Ihe pcrs.rrrl.itrr.isri icti,rrarr,l,r'sis c0'ccflr it.su,rvitrr the ,S co.stitrrtitln's duc p*rccs-s u.,rlucfr)5 (ratC*i:tirlnarShot')' hrtl oitr illirrois ('tlllstiirrlirlrt's tiuc pr()ccss criiusc rcrlrrir.cs c'crr r).r()re he igltcncdscrutitt'v'tJta, lhe US ('onstitLtt j.n's rJrre. p.occ-ss cr.rsc. u.!,.r(iir-r tr:st trrirt [)riri,til-r-s

'cot.lllairlt clcirrll liril's' "lllirrois tlttt 1':t'.cuss pr.r'isitrrr slr.rr rtr bc c.rrstr.LrecJ rr.r.e L-rrrrirdrrthln thc tecjelaldue pr.ocess clarrsc. lnd thc Ijlirrois SLrpr.rrne (.()rr.t u,ill c()nstrLruindependcnll'v lht- sc.Jre of'rhe llliroi.s srate cor:stitrrtiorr's cJr.rc pt.ocess srilrilllIcc.--l.ciri:lr' r' Spsrn(l!e. rs6 ilr.2d r9,8. rr7 (r. r999). citirg r{ori.'r_r.1rrsd *r Ir. rcr r.'.37-r. 152 lll l)cc ,t*4. 5(r5 N.l:.:d il0l ( l9cl0)^ lhc lllin.is Suprcrne (-.Lrr.r lrasitlterPre tc

Movant ire-rcbv adopt.s and incorpor.alcs the nroIj()ns

qirn-sh arrd llrr p.otcctive .rder oI i!4ovarrt 66.J4.q r l

1060 Wc.sr

Ptto'rllcl'IvI, ()R t) rarr

ttr rli,i,nl*,t ol'arrcl ntotiot.ls t()

lJ() ,,\nd C'ltlr.tcr AucoLtnl Ilolcicr

IJere' il lhe court dou'-s tlr-rt cltursh I)laintifl's othcr*,ise i,rpr..per. srrtrp.err,. tircCotlrl. ill a nrinirnlrrn. shtlulcl clttcr a ptr)tcctivc orcler prolribitirrg thc prLr hlic r.lisclosrrrc ollrrt"t'inlirrtnltl ion rclatil)-u t() [)c1'cttdarrt.btairrccJ via the subpcrc-rra. Arrorc. r)tir*.thirru.s.llrc protcctive orcJu'l'sltorrld rtlarrdaIc rhar all coLrrt lllires i, this a\]tio, that c()rtair.r ()r.rel'ercttcc itrlirrnraticln relatirlg r. l)t'1";ncJartt oblairrctl 'i, trrc sulrpo.r,,.r-rsI cithcr hr:lcrlactcd trr lllcd trncler scal t() prcvenI tlre pLrblrc clisclosrrrc aucj crrsrrrc Ihc c,ntirrtrecjco'lldc'rialiL'o. rhirt ilrl.r'nrariorr. I'r.rrihirirrg puhlic discrrsLrrc or.Dcrcrdanr-sc.rtllderrtial irtfbr,ratiolt is necessarr\r lo prL'\,r-rl [)e-f.rndarrr ii.r.,, srr l'it.rirrg LrridL*.iinnoval.lce. r'ttibarrassntelit. tutcl oltpr.cssiorr tlrut r.v6rr lcJ restrlt ii. I)l1iptil.l, rvi(56rrisul'llcicnt eVidcttliar.t' stlllport. putrliclv accuscs I)etl.nclurrt ol'illcr:lr ll1 rirrrVrrltiirci irrspo'npgr'apll'1'' lrr lrdditiott. 'srrch pr(ltcctia, r.r'ill c()rrp(rl'r rr,ith tlris ('r)r.r.[ r.rr]s.s rrrritnpartiulad jrrilicaror.of'JcgaI

cJ i.sputcs and rrot ,.rnurc],r rools lirr cnca)rl.{rsirr{ arr.J uxriclinuscttlclncllts li0rn Dcfendltt.tts cor"ctl b,r ths potcntill e.Srs trl- lirisarirrn.rrrJ li:rbilitr "

l?i,qltthr^'an L/-( r //iii. ^-o.

r:r-cv-0{)r r iD" co}o. A1:r. 7" 10il)(.r. Kanc).\\/Ill:ltIl]oRF.. vr.van( .rrrrrr Doe 75. r.11. i.r_i.(]5 lrr arrcj r]rr.trLrrir irs ;rll.r.trrr.

l.A\\'91:1:11'lrs OF.llaIFl-{1.\,.t. AN'I'ONH_l_1. l..ll-1 I,,l{n yS.l illS il.rr.r..blc (..ur{ r,quash all srrbl'loena.s issucd h), lrlaintifl'arrcl its c()rrlscl relatiiiq t() ll) irejcir.css75.1.11.1,15.9-\. inciudiire br.rl nor ljruircrl ro (.Hr\R-l.l:R COI\1Ni(rhil(.A llO\S lN(,. trr.cll'\R1'Flt (:oN'lN/ltlNl('AfloNs l.l.c..;rirtl sLrch oihcr rclicl'rrs rrris ('rrrrrr dccrrrs lrsranrl cqir itah,le . inclucl ing {irt protcct ivc or.dcr.,

VI,

.lr:[[re],.].lirr Movrrr

Larv O|J'icc ol'.lcl1i.cy. .1. Anroncll ji0 Norrh LaSallc Sr.. Suirc i-100('hicago. IL 60601I'el. j l2ll0l -fli l0Fax I I 2/i3l-466iCook Countl No. 44221

I.rd.

EXHIBIT A

11

lll

19

2A

21

2.?-

2_\

L4

i!, )

26

'ta

itB

Ca 2:12-cv-001 36-DDp-SS Document I l Filed 05/01/12 page .t of 5 Page lD #:99

1

,

J

4

5

6

1

B

I

JS -o

uNI',fID S1A1'[.3 t]rsTRrC.t c0r.lili,CENTRAL DIS'IR I

'']' (]I CAL I I"-'ORI,JIA

:0

11

12

t3

4.,

r5

,1 C

CILESTIAL 1NC.,

PIainrifi.,Case I'Jo. (:V l"?-rj3l3i; DDI, itiS:

11

12:

t3

11

i5

i6

llt3

t9

20

2t

,:.?_

.1 :

.t ,1

)c

1t\

2'l

1J

Ca 2,12-cv-A0136-DDp,SS Documenr 1 1 Frled 05/01/12 page 2 ot S page tD 8...100

l

2

3

4

5

fU

I

t-l

9

t0

rn california"; and ?r plai-nLtf f'.s copyri.qht.eci.. I.,"lrn Lays .r-ir,lt-rcl'e of Lhe wc)rk, t-iie nanre of r-irc nrorj,ucr, rlr,)d l_ire,n,c_r,orjrarrrJHrl-s, California adr-lres-s of t_he prodLlcer.,, (Ordet.

Ca 2:12-cv-00130-DDp-SS Docurnent 11 Filed 05/01112 Page 3 of 5 Page tD #:101

DecIaranL "qerrera) iy concr.rr Is ]reads:

I ul 1, Lirt webs i t_r: rliisf:s-sil.rt,rr

Det-ei:nr inrng l.he n,ttion of anher IP aclcl ress t sj rr:lal lvc:iyperr:ertl, ) k>er.:ai.iSg ij r:_oui)t. rVwhen a n 1 i, ra nqr.; I s ,:l : .l cca t-i.,cjInlormart.on f or I r,_=.e.

ir)[-Crn,::l l-iS(?f ha_sei On hi.:; t>l-s i rnr:,i i.: :tn,J alaa:tratl r.t tgii -ctct..,

IriirI,ir : s 1-,..;,.;g.. 1,3ii .i;r foriii._i l. l (.):,rllr(j . I. rCJIS'..r"r.1: s ..j..op-), I l,i.t.

,.t..i."1 i) I -r ,...r:i L" S r: r s(; .) '.1 :j .-..t ;; i l ,J .) { r. rhaopen.s ber-ausr:r'F(er +ra"i-a ir-.\. ]

' . . l ' t j

ir ar I r a.r

I

2

3

4

5

o

-l

I

9

1U

11

1',)

13

-q

r5

-o

i'i

i9la

21

22

2.3

24

25

?. (,

?l

Cas 2:12-cv-00'l 36-DDP-SS Documenr 1 1 Filed 05/01i 12 Page 4 of 5 Page tD tt..1OZ

Furt-her, given ::"re i)oe llef enrjani s, r nanr , r iru. r,r (-()nr .rs:L'.Larnt.tf.f ':j lut-rsdrr,Ljorta j. cla.i llrs, r,iti: (;ollrt. f lrrr.rs f.ilr: ei.ll(li...rI::ur:rjand conclusor:y nat.utre of i-he allegations particu)arly colr:erninc;.Aga:'n, having previously cleclined Eo nralie any -r'eDresenr.atlcns asr LcrLhe acct-ii:aCy oI g.=o.]itr.-al.torr Lr>,_,i.s, i,,la::,ti:.til sr._. iJ,.)i._,s i.,r.) it,i-,_:rr:.rihan t.c "gener;llly corrcur,, wit.h onc websiLe,s qerrcl.r.lgeolocatr.,:n t-ooIs, which il_self cir.es ro anot:her f irmaccuracy ral_es prov-r,de,J. f,qua11y, r_iit.: inv,::st,tqdLjnqscn:enc{t ac(:u l-..}cy s:.. a: cltel i. i .:; r,:():1,.: i .-:;., r\./ '.;

B

o

l1

12

11

lr

16

1/

ti

t9

2.A

?)

22

,, -t

/:.1

2',-:

?€

?1

:)8

Cas

I,)

3

4

5

o

-l

2.12"cv-001 36-DDp-SS Documenr .l l Filed 05/01i 12 Page 5 of 5 Page lD #.103

also ha,;e usecl more re-li.rb-[e lecirno_lr:gy. i,jowever, i)\..*r.r ii l.iir-:,rr,r..;advar)r:e'l qer:)ocat-:on t.ools wet:e sr:np)v roo r:nreliarlle l a r.rjeilt:.-rrc..esfablisit'1 itriscii.ct.iorr, Lhs (:oL.,l rt- (_-(tulri rr,..rl, seL.rslJ*const-iturional concern-s it-t l-avar of l)l.iiirr-rf ('s rie.sire Lo suL)iJOen.lt-ne Doe Defenclants, rdenLifyrn_c i:I.cr:rnarFt ]:slt- Amrtnr:lrrrr.:r)L t_l.t.Jf. requ t r(,rs cour.t.., t()Cne ',vou-ltl ar_ leasr survive e moL jCI L()aur-horrzes ear:1y cJisc_-cvery to triertr f ,"_

!-or a-il the.rea-sons CiscLrsqort rh+

f St,i

PlaLnL.i it.'s aorlplaInt. ,;r..,i.1 iii 11 g,il.:cx of lur:.sdrcf_t():l . ljrtca,.r..1 r,.make an adectruaLe .l ur.isclic_-i,t.ona L0rder Lo Shcw Car-:se, i-he 1:ourt-over :.]'t.r.S aCL:O:l an() rjisrr-,i:;sc-.s

rT IS SO OItL)L]tIiI]

Lrated: M,ry 7, ?.0"',).

Aqain, rt

r'olrr>lrtr

r.s Lrtc,

:s I iil .t 1',.

LlSe-fs.

I h;r t.

)s I r.-t:

l'. ,trl,-]c:,:

rr)[_ernel.

j I i'.: ncl s

5 :-t () !.J .i

I r ncls

'I i 'urrl I

n.J i

t- h,r L.

so l.a:Ii:,:l l.)

[-Cr t,, l-)€, r..Oi-t r : ' s

i L..r r" i .sil I c r. i .tr)

r)tiAt,l i) .(.ln i t. ed

:1r;(it,iisoi,rat-es lis'_r;

I

SI

trXHIBIT B

IilLlil (r woIio l.atse p0rn acct]saltons unL.lCrscore \v:-l:i privac;.dan Itttp:,','o.scatllclrrne s.rtri.sr>[rrcs.ctrrr],irtnrl ,])ati(llw(]l.lJ l() l.lg(i.7,lSr \! il

Originallv pubtished April :r1, eo)l aL g:53

False porn accusations udangers

l)N1 | l,agc nrodiiicd i\prrl e5, 2()l I it I 6::Jg ,\M

nderscore Wi -Iri privfl c1z

it's trnknorvn ltorv olterr u n,st:ctrr.eci rou tcrsc.titrrinitl irrvssliulliens, thc Intct.n.t i, i-iiil legallv dor,,nl r.radi n g r"n us ir or rn or.i e-s,

lir, Ci\l{O i.}'N'l't-t 0 Ni I)SON

'fhe fusociated press

havt: brought lr:gal rr.orrble lirr strt:.sroI lccorrnl.s ol ltcr.rplc who,r,c h;rc] tr>

ribcls. llesides t,heIrghl .r

itttt & l\iorld I l:alse portt acc,satrol.ts rrrrcierscore Wi-lji privacr,darr lrttp. r'o.scafi ler i rlcs n,,r strrrrce corn' hrrrrl rrari orrrvrrr'l d .lr) l J sl) 7 i N l tr,rl

Experts 'say'tl-re nlofe sa\\'Y I:rckers can go bc.r'ond.jusI crinnecting to ti:r: lnl.ernct on tlrc lrost,sdinrc; thcl'can ntonit'r Inicr,et actirlry in.i srcal prssr'.rr.ls

I child porn rard a strong argunrent fbr locking clorvrr WiFi rrerrt,urks Itttp: '/arsreclrnie a,ccrrnrrech-p. ricr,rr0 r.04/rb i-chird-1rorn-i"aici-u-srron

rlorr rr \\/iFi nrf rr o l.ksTh'rl{ VuU re CjO[]g tilg 11111_,1 : A l.tv(:f l)!

.\ ltclrinrl-t lt(,-s(,(.rlrs look llll.i rr ltr'rl I tr'r 1;11y lyi;,. t. rr1 i rrct. l.ing

IL',Ir., I ,,.,.i-,_ r.r

ST,^.\, II.,] THE

?e

h.l'jrju/ y,/t il1

LA] ESI NE',4/S

\r\r(li\lt \\1lr lrrrrl l,l{1.) rrtrlrrr lirllr,r,irr-!il\ (,r nilttIl f :li(l

\td I lir.t to ilrl.,llt(.r I (, l)pliirrrrr (, rlrilrr I r

\\itJt ln(.rt{-r. l}rtrtrrlrr lLlr.l.rrrllin:tllr lt:rr r rllrlr plrrr llr I rII iiIl\ (.1

\'rlr ltlrr lirr:illr ol'ltr.r r r)rliutiu!lill( u,ttfltlll) rrltlirirl lrr.r(.r\r

l(rrttrrlJrrlr ltrlrr liglttr rlr, trot.ltr.\l;rrllrl rr irt lr., rr rllr I r-l r

\ lorilrrr,,l, lrr.,, rr:r( tl,r, lrjr\''(trrrLJr,tl r,\l'f(l:ttioil\. l,r \ltllrrrl \r,r t rillrr,.

AR.S .lOF:lS

OC.&snmaron Pos{.orr R,(n u.d,s DGv6LoDc,l'rmgr&lE Lo(ilru. Esn,^qton oc s(itv5

LAW & DISORDER I CIVIL IZATICN &DISCONTENTSFBI chiltl por-n r.aicl a

?57i^/ ll I l.?le berrg nacilged ot oo$,lloodrnq c)r,tc p61,,,ooruo,,, li, ael pe[rpe 1o lLrct, duwfl tnerr n/,F]rie1";'^)rl5 cncL' ;ln,J t,3r atl? A[hcueh lt]alS r]ol lhe only ,easou 1.. heep yotrr ,ret1^,crri se{rr'e l€ri)apssLlnE Lrse.S 'ilrti i*r sc.tred rrllc (o/nq so Blter res0 rrg i! rt,otLBf ot ho.r(:rr 3lcrles co lSCt?.1 t\\, thp

Dvrir the ,rde\pry-) .l he ijlr0e4,,foq tessOil hcep /oui tVrt r nelr"frL.s rtic!r1l Jo,vn(r)l ,,,.rLr trrd tij!\,entDr.ier)re,ri k,:!irrq /Juan )r)rtr COO, ,n flre rn,L-Jalte ()t lt F nl.ltiTXr ttrrF.. \lOlpSr .iil ftr I Jt.Jnrl i,!:, iilLl itre,tre a glriritiO jr).tn Si)ras-!ra rr\i-,. itnq S,, i;1CUS(. r€i ..1lL1r,/lal rlt,rilerves be rnq r.11696 L,y lhe FBt o; prc,irc6.ail;r the, r v,/ete5s ,E1!vor\s weri dlteeEory ls'(l :/ldolrrlioAd Chrlo porn0qr-flrv yi{;,e a.-,+eL) JuSt idrnrt rl r{le FBI dgerr: s,,is qtOteo Say nq la th..,1..C!sed lia.1,y ir aI lhraF i;aSts\e.(d n,drc Ar l \r . i1rrs ,",u ,,,,,,'];t,;:-;TJ"::Ii:I,::::il;:; ::il,'::::]T::]r:: ::;, ,.et40 I I s

f. l';lil4; r),tfr i ih,,. , l

dr'tj'al fr,1rrri r,r,,t I

.ttt t .-.I rA[rance ]r;trte: rg

FIEAL)FR COi'/Mtt,l t:j t57

ffi ,ono,.,^.,. *;;:;:",:,:l'4'(t'reJ'r''|''J r'( rei'", u^.,- -,

ff' Fcllow{!eh'qst t6it'r'! orL*rc! irrdo"r

n;5ii'nlFe:r\1 tcw' 'P!'s$'rr'r .tvlrt

sf x)llg arglnlent lbr locliing

itav,'rr rar,,'!J[,I]pjtcr. :,:rr.f I lr.r .T Ot:) Ir I:.1iT tJ i,t i STOR /

J

It). l l() la 7 ri pv