The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf &...
Transcript of The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf &...
![Page 1: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
The discussion about the
identity of
Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten,
2006
versus
Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten,
2006
![Page 2: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
History: Bernard, Rolán & Ryall
Bernard, P.A.,1984. Coquillages du Gabon, pl.49, fig. 184
Clavatula sp.
Clavatula mourei Bernard, 1984 mss. Rolán & Ryall, 1999
in Checklist of Angolese Marine Molluscs
![Page 3: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
History: Bernard
‘’Clavatula pfefferi (Stredel, 1912)’
Coquillages du Gabon, pl.49, fig. 186
‘solid fusiform shell with double sutural cord
identical to that of Clavatula sp. (p.184)’
![Page 4: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
the real Clavatula pfefferi (Strebel, 1912)
E Nigeria
06°06’ N/ 04°29’ E
‘Atlantide’ Expedition’
ZMC
![Page 5: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
History: Abbott & Dance in their
Compendium
Abbott & Dance, 1982.
Compendium of Seashells, p.241
‘Clavatula bimarginata
(Lamarck, 1822)’
![Page 6: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten 2006
Paratype 1 Paratype 1 Paratype 2 Paratype 2
Gabon
![Page 7: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006
Paratype 3 Paratype 4 Paratype 5 Paratype 6
Gabon
![Page 8: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006
Gabon
Paratype 7 Paratype 8
Gabon N Angola
Paratype 9 Holotype
![Page 9: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Clavatula quinteni
Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006
Paratype 10 Paratype 11 Paratype 11
Gabon N Angola
![Page 10: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Clavatula quinteni
Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006
N Angola
Paratype 12 Paratype 12 Paratype 13 Paratype 13
![Page 11: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Clavatula xanteni
Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006
Holotype
North Angola
Paratype 4
![Page 12: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Clavatula xanteni
Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006
Paratype 8 Paratype 8 Paratype 7 Paratype 7
N Angola
![Page 13: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Clavatula xanteni
Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006
Paratype 9 Paratype 9
N Angola
![Page 14: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Comparison of the protoconch and
the teleoconch
Clavatula quinteni Clavatula xanteni
![Page 15: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Comparison of the characteristics
fusiform elongated shell
granulose spiral cord
sharp subsutural
ridge
spiral cord
making the suture
undulate
well developed
nodulose axial
ribs
white zone at base
of whorls and at shoulder
of last whorl flattened
subsutural
cord
with very
narrow
subsutural
groove
broader shell
wide
subangular
oval mouth
wide and short siphonal canal
![Page 16: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Comparison of the radula
Clavatula xanteni
Clavatula quinteni
rounded barbe
sharp pointed barbe
![Page 17: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
History: Rolán & Ryall, 2006 mss.
‘Clavatula bernardi’
![Page 18: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
radula of ‘C. bernardi’
History: Rolán & Ryall, 2006 mss.
![Page 19: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Clavatula quinteni: Gabon
![Page 20: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Clavatula quinteni: Gabon
![Page 21: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Clavatula quinteni:
off Luanda, Angola
![Page 22: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Clavatula quinteni:
Benguela, Prov. Namibe, Angola
![Page 23: The discussion about the identity ofThe discussion about the identity of Clavatula quinteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006 versus Clavatula xanteni Nolf & Verstraeten, 2006](https://reader033.fdocuments.fr/reader033/viewer/2022060815/6094952d9760c249ab24069f/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Clavatula xanteni
North Angola off Luanda, Angola
juvenile specimen
Clavatula sp.
Clavatula quinteni