Psalm 25:21 May integrity and uprightness protect me, because my hope is in you. Le Carême.
Sciences et Société en mutationstorage.canalblog.com/10/32/381881/26314803.doc · Web...
24
Ministère de l'Enseignement supérieur et de la Recherche www.enseignementsup-recherche.gouv.fr BIBLIOGRAPHIE Sur l’intégrité scientifique provisoire Compilation de biblio1/120408/ sur thunderbird, à reclasser (rubriques et chrono) Et de documents écrits (dossier bureau) et complété avec documents de Biblio (fichier disque dur) Général Fraudes scientifiques et déontologie scientifique, Michel Wright, TC8 2005 Livres L’intégrité scientifique en zone grise, François Dumont, Les éditions Deslandes, Québec, 1997 La souris truquée, William Broad et Nicholas Wade, Seuil, Paris, 1987 et Simon and Schuster, new York, 1982 pour la version originale Articles de revues How to teach research ethics, C.Neal Stewart, J rand J.Lannett Edwards, The Scientist.com (http://www.the-scientist.com/article/display/54226/ ) Keeping plagiarism at bay, a salutary tale, martin B.R., Research Policy, 2007 The economics of scientific misconduct, Nicola Lacetera, Lorenzo Zirulia, mars 2008, Universita Commerciale Luigi Bocconi, Milano Quelques pistes pour un statut juridique du chercheur lanceur d’alerte, Dossier Engagement public des chercheurs, Christine Noiville et Marie-Angèle Hermitte, Natures, Sciences, Sociétés, 14, 2006 Normal misbehavior : Scientists talk about the ethics of research, R. de Vries, M.S. Anderson, B.C. Martinson, Journal of empirical research on human research ethics, 2006 Beyonf fraud – Stem cell research continues, Evan Y. Snyder MD PhD, Jeanne F. Loring PhD, The new England journal of medicine, janvier 2006 Scientists behaving badly, B.C. Martinson, Journal of empirical research on human research ethics, 2006, Nature, vol.435, 2005 La fraude scientifique, la réponse de la communauté, Girolamo Ramuni, La revue pour l’histoire du CNRS, n°9, novembre 2003 3, rue Michel Ange 75794 – Paris, Tél : +33(0)144 964 000 1
Transcript of Sciences et Société en mutationstorage.canalblog.com/10/32/381881/26314803.doc · Web...
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
BIBLIOGRAPHIE
Sur lrsquointeacutegriteacute scientifique
provisoire Compilation de biblio1120408 sur thunderbird agrave reclasser (rubriques et chrono) Et de documents eacutecrits (dossier bureau) et compleacuteteacute avec documents de Biblio (fichier disque dur)
Geacuteneacuteral Fraudes scientifiques et deacuteontologie scientifique Michel Wright TC8 2005
Livres Lrsquointeacutegriteacute scientifique en zone grise Franccedilois Dumont Les eacuteditions Deslandes
Queacutebec 1997 La souris truqueacutee William Broad et Nicholas Wade Seuil Paris 1987 et Simon and
Schuster new York 1982 pour la version originale
Articles de revues How to teach research ethics CNeal Stewart J rand JLannett Edwards The
Scientistcom (httpwwwthe-scientistcomarticledisplay54226) Keeping plagiarism at bay a salutary tale martin BR Research Policy 2007 The economics of scientific misconduct Nicola Lacetera Lorenzo Zirulia mars
2008 Universita Commerciale Luigi Bocconi Milano Quelques pistes pour un statut juridique du chercheur lanceur drsquoalerte Dossier
Engagement public des chercheurs Christine Noiville et Marie-Angegravele Hermitte Natures Sciences Socieacuteteacutes 14 2006
Normal misbehavior Scientists talk about the ethics of research R de Vries MS Anderson BC Martinson Journal of empirical research on human research ethics 2006
Beyonf fraud ndash Stem cell research continues Evan Y Snyder MD PhD Jeanne F Loring PhD The new England journal of medicine janvier 2006
Scientists behaving badly BC Martinson Journal of empirical research on human research ethics 2006 Nature vol435 2005
La fraude scientifique la reacuteponse de la communauteacute Girolamo Ramuni La revue pour lrsquohistoire du CNRS ndeg9 novembre 2003
Etudes Promoting research integrity ICSU survey among members 2008 Les usages de lrsquointernet agrave lrsquoUniversiteacute de Lyon laquo de la documentation au
plagiat raquo septembre 2007
Articles de journaux communications et sites internet Investigating international misconduct commentary by Nigel Lloyd and Christine
Boesz Nature April 2008 La France srsquoattaque agrave la fraude scientifique Pierre le Hir Le Monde 24 janvier
2008-04-12 La transparence la cleacute de la recherche et du deacuteveloppement Quotidien du peuple
Peacutekin 15 mars 2008 (httpfrenchpeoplecomcnSci-Edu6374076html)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 1
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
A tale of two citations Mounir Errami Harold Garner Nature Vol 451 (7177) janvier 2008
Deacutepasser les bornes par Alex Gillis University affairs Canada (httpwwwaffairesuniversitairescaFrancaisissues2008janvierdepasser_bornes_01html)
Scientific integrity recent developments Pieter JD Drenth ALLEAKNAW conference on emerging regional co-operations Southeast European academies of sciences and humanities 2007
Plus de 800 institutions ont souscrit agrave la charte europeacuteenne du chercheur drsquoapregraves la Commission europeacuteenne Agence AEF 23 aoucirct 2007
Dossier lrsquointeacutegriteacute scientifique existe-t-elle Sciences Frontiegraveres ndeg 44 1999 Lrsquointeacutegriteacute scientifique en zone grise
Newsletters Annonces 3e colloque sur lrsquointeacutegriteacute scientifique en recherche meacutedicale FRSQ Queacutebec Une formation sur le plagiat eacutelectronique dans les travaux scolaires hellipCa vous
inteacuteresse Avis de la CEST-Jeunesse Queacutebec Office of Research Integrity (ORI) newsletter (httporihhsgov )
Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations Integrity in research a rationale for community action expert group meeting
Brussels 2007 Recommended guidelines on research ethics Norwegian association of Higher
education institutions 2007 Summary of Australian guidance on international research misconduct Prepared by
TM Dyke Australian member ICCFFRMI 3 April 2008 Australian researchers are expected to comply with two over-arching documents The Australian Code for the Responsible Conduct of Research (2007) [the Code httpwwwnhmrcgovaupublicationssynopsesr39synhtm] and the National Statement on Ethical conduct in Human Research (2007) [the Statement httpwwwnhmrcgovaupublicationssynopsese72synhtm]
JRC guidelines for integrity in its support activities Robust science for policy making a guideline towards integrity and veracity in scientific support and advice October 2006
Research misconduct NSF La fraude scientifique Isabelle de Lamberterie CNRS-COMETS 2006 SLAC BaBar Publication Policy 199mdashmodifieacute 2005 (approval for public release of
results) Guidelines on scientific analysis in policy making HM Government GB October
2005 Charte europeacuteenne du chercheur code de conduite pour le recrutement des
chercheurs Commission europeacuteenne 2005 Inteacutegriteacute dans la recherche scientifique Universiteacute de Genegraveve 2005 Integrity in scientific research introductory paper advisory committee AAAS
2005 Le plagiat eacutelectronique dans les travaux scolaires une pratique qui soulegraveve des
questions eacutethiques Commission de lrsquoeacutethique de la science et de la technologie Queacutebec 2005
Guidelines on good research practice including statement on the handling of allegations of research misconduct Wellcome trust 2005 (updated) 2002
Code de deacuteontologie de lrsquoInstitut pasteur deacutecembre 2004 Memorandum on scientific integrity ALLEA 2003 Un code de conduite des chercheurs dans les sciences du comportement humain
Socieacuteteacute franccedilaise de psychologie 2003 Guide drsquoeacutethique de la recherche et drsquointeacutegriteacute scientifique Fonds de la recherche
en santeacute du Queacutebec 2003 Good scientific practice and procedures for handling misconduct and fraud in
science national advisory board on research ethics Finland 2002
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 2
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
EMBL rules of good scientific practice of procedure in cases of suspected scientific misconduct 2002
Proceacutedure concernant la creacuteation et le fonctionnement des commissions creacutees par la direction geacuteneacuterale CNRS 2000 (httpwwwcnrsfrfrorganismeethiquecometshistorique1994-2001chartehtm)
Comiteacute de deacuteontologie scientifique Universiteacute Claude Bernard creacuteation Lyon 2000
Preamble for research misconduct policy Executive office of the president (OSTP) USA 2000
Entente-cadre sur la proprieacuteteacute intellectuelle applicable agrave tous les chercheurs des deacutepartements de sciences fondamentales de la faculteacute de meacutedecine Universiteacute de Montreacuteal 1996
Recommandations on the status of scientific researchers UNESCO Records of the general conference 1974
Funding principles Volkswagen foundation
Recensements Academic Corruption Degree fraud The Boston College Center for international
higher education concerne 26 pays articles de presse (httpwwwbcedubc_orgavpsoecihehecmcmnews_03fakehtm)
Interim analysis of codes of conduct and codes of ethics UNESCO Division of ethics of science and technology septembre 2006
Regarding the Guidelines for Responses to Research Misconduct ndash Report of the special Committee on research misconduct Aug 8 2006 Council for Science and Technology Japan (httpwwwmextgojpenglishkagaku07053104htm)
Policy on relationship between Trust-funded researchers and commercial organizations Wellcome Trust (httpwwwwellcomeacukAbout-usPolicyPolicy-and-position-statementswtd039176htm)
Rapports Research Integrity global responsibility to foster common standards Office of
Research Integrity (USA) amp European Science Foundation - Science Policy Briefing UK 2008
Stewards of integrity institutional approaches to promote and safeguard good scientific practice in Europe ESF 2008 (to be published)
Handbook for Members of Audit Committees in Higher Education Institutions - Committee of University Chairmen This guide is aimed at members of audit committees of higher education institutions in the UK It shares current good practice and encourages its appropriate adoption across the higher education sector The advice was prepared in January 2008 (httpwwwhefceacukpubshefce200808_0608_06doc)
Working paper on conflict of interest for review and comment American council on education avril 2008
OECD report on best practices for ensuring scientific integrity and preventing misconduct 2007
Final report to ESF and ORI First world conference on research integrity fostering responsible research Tony Mayer and Nick Steneck Nov 2007
Inteacutegriteacute scientifique vers lrsquoeacutelaboration de politiques coheacuterentes Freacutedeacuteric Sgard et Steacutephane Michalowski Sciences 2007
What to do if you suspect plagiarism etc Committee on publication ethics flowchart COPE 2006
Scientific advice Risk and Evidence Based policy Making House of commons Science and technology committee 2006 Aug 8 2006 Special Committee on scientific misconduct Council for Science and Technology
Protecting patents preserving integrity advancing health accelerating the implementation of COI policies in human subjects research a report of the AAMC-AAU advisory committee on financial conflicts of interest in human subjects research AAMC (association of american medical college ) (httpwwwaaueduresearchRpt_AAU-AAMC_COI_208pdf
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 3
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
The Danish Committee on scientific dishonesty Danish Agency for science technology and innovation annual report 2006 november 2007 (httpfidksiteenglishpublicationspublications-2007annual-report-2006-the-danish-committees-on-scientific-dishoFIST_GB_wwwpdf)
Good scientific practice in research and scholarship European science foundation policy briefing 2000
Colloques et confeacuterences Lisbon first world conference on science integrity An action-oriented approach
Contributions from Pieter Drenth Stefan Michalowski Frederic Sgard Ovid Tzeng Drsquoune faccedilon geacuteneacuterale les contributions agrave la Confeacuterence de Lisbonne sur lrsquointeacutegriteacute
scientifique se trouvent agrave httpwwwesforgactivitiesesf-conferencesdetailsarchives2007confdetail242html
Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat logiciel Tetralogie Ce logiciel qui est un outil de veille (strateacutegique
concurrentielle) qui permet de faire des comparaisons afin de deacutetecter des plagiats (lthttpatlasiritfrgt)
Logiciel grenoble
Source site ESf
RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHReferences amp Background Reading
NATURE Volume 451 Number 7181 - 21 February 2008
- Pakistan needs a powerful ethics and integrity body (Nature 451 887 - Correspondence - Muhammad Mukhtar amp Zahida Parve)
Volume 451 Number 7179 - 7 February 2008- No conflict of interest in misconduct case says lab (Nature 451 618-619 - News)
Volume 451 Number 7177 - 24 January 2008- A tale of two citations (Nature 451 397-399 - Commentary - Mounir Errami amp Harold Garner)
Volume 450 Number 7170 - 29 November 2007- Loopholes in oversight rules revealed US energy department criticized over procedure for misconduct investigations (Nature 450 590 - News - Eugenie Samuel Reich)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 4
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
- Each co-author should sign to reduce risk of fraud (Nature 450 610 - Correspondence - Kevin Yager)
Volume 450 Number 7169 - 22 November 2007- Replicator Review Nature has implemented a peer-review policy for strong claims (Nature 450 457-458 - Editorial)- Stem-cell Researcher accused of Negligence (Nature 450 470- News)
Volume 450 Number 7166 - 1 November 2007- Who is accountable How the responsibilities of co-authors for a scientific papers integrity could be made more explicit (Nature 450 1 - Editorial)
Volume 449 Number 7161 - 27 September 2007- Stem-cell Fraudster is working in Thailand Woo Suk Hwang may be back in the cloning lab (Nature 449 387 - News - David Cyranoski)
Volume 448 Number 7154 - 9 August 2007- Academic Accused of Living on Borrowed Lines Allegations prompt Fears over Prevalence of Plagiarism (Nature 448 623-726 - News - Alison Abbott)
Volume 447 Number 7146 - 14 June 2007- Indian Scientists battle Journal Retraction (Nature 447 753-884 - News - KS Jayaraman)
Volume 447 Number 7142 - 17 May 2007- Purdue dogged by misconduct claims Third inquiry into bubble fusion is underway (Nature 447 238-239 - News - Eugenie Samuel Reich)- Recognition could support a science code of conduct (Nature 447 259 - Correspondence - Yan Ropert-Coudert)- Modellers seek reason for low attraction rate (Nature 447 236-237- News - Declan Butler amp Jenny Hogan)Volume 447 Number 7140 - 3 May 2007- Share your lab notes The use of electronic laboratory notebooks should be supported by all concerned (Nature 447 1 - Editorial)
Volume 446 Number 7135 - 29 March 2007- Confidentiality is essential in misconduct inquiries (Nature 446 492 - Correspondence - Sally Mason amp Charles Rutledge)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 5
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 446 Number 7133 - 15 March 2007- Geophysicist faces probe into use of research funds Co-founder of European Academy of Sciences comes under scrutiny (Nature 446 236 - News - Jim Giles)
Volume 445 Number 7129 - 15 February 2007- Methods in Full From now on Nature authors will be able to include more experimental details in their papers (Nature 445 684 - Editorials)
Volume 445 Number 7126 - 25 January 2007- Journals should set a new standard in transparency (Nature 445 364 - Correspondence - Robert P Dellavalle Kristy Lundahl Scott R Freeman and Lisa M Schilling)
Volume 445 Number 7125 - 18 January 2007- Leading by example The primary safeguard against scientific misconduct is the example set every day by thousands of senior researchers in the laboratory (Nature 445 229 - Editorials)- Misconduct Itrsquos all academic (Nature 445 240-241 - News - Geoff Brumfiel)- Breeding cheats (Nature 445 242-243 - News - Jim Giles)- Where are they now (Nature 445 244-245 - News - Lucy Odling-Smee Jim Giles Ichiko Fuyuno David Cyranoski and Emma Marris)
Volume 444 Number 7122 - 21 December 2006- Peer review and fraud Two assessments of the refereeing process highlight challenges for journals (Nature 444 971-972 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7121 - 14 December 2006- The elephant in the room A biotech trial that went awry (Nature 444 790 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7120 - 7 December 2006- Journal reveals plans to fight fraud Science to select papers for extra-secure review process (Nature 444 658-659 - News - Meredith Wadman)- Purdue attacked over fusion inquiry Physicists angry at apparent inertia in misconduct investigation (Nature 444 664-665 - News - Eugenie Samuel Reich)- A fair share The concept of sharing primary data is
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 6
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
generating unnecessary angst in the psychology community (Nature 444 653-654 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7116 -- 9 November 2006- Correction or retraction Errors reported in this issue by authors of a Nature paper pose a dilemma about trust (Nature 444 123-124 - Editorials)
Volume 443 Number 7108 - 14 September 2006- Whistleblowers in peril The US Congress should reverse a pernicious removal of protection of federal employees (Nature 443 121 - Editorials)
Volume 442 Number 7099 - 13 July 2006- Misconduct forum should not be used to settle sc ores (Nature 442 132 - Correspondence - Guosheng Wu)- Misconduct China needs university ethics courses (Nature 442 132 - Correspondence - Qizhi Wang)
Volume 441 Number 7096 - 22 June 2006- Misconduct lack of action provokes web accusations (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Shi-min Fang)- Misconduct exposure is not like Cultural Revolution (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Zheng Huang)- Misconduct Chinese funding body unmoved (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Ushma Savla Neill)
Volume 441 Number 7093 - 1 June 2006- Finding fraud in China As Chinese research expands who is looking out for faked results (Nature 441 549-550 - Editorials)
Volume 441 Number 7092 - 25 May 2006- Named and shamed As accusations of scientific misconduct in China become rife some fear persecution reminiscent of that used in the Cultural Revolution (Nature 441 392-393 - News - David Cyranoski)
Volume 435 Number 7043 - 9 June 2005- One in three scientists confesses to having sinned Misconduct ranges from faking results outright to dropping suspect data points (Nature 435 718-719 - News - Meredith Wadman)- Scientists behaving badly (Nature 435 737-738 - Commentary - Brian C Martinson Melissa S Anderson amp Raymond de Vries)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 7
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
NATURE In the Field
17 September 2007 Integrity - Zero Tolerance in Portugal (Sarah Tomlin)
NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY Volume 24 Number 2 - 2 February 2006
South Korean policy failure and the Hwang debacle (Nature Biotechnology 24 141-143 - Commentary - Herbert Gottweis amp Robert Triendl)
SCIENCE Volume 316 Issue 5832 - 22 June 2007
- Scientific Publishing Osaka University Researchers reject Demand to Retract Science Paper (p 1681 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 316 Issue 5827 - 18 May 2007- Research Integrity Sonofusion Back on the Firing Line as Misconduct Probe Reopens (p 964 - News of the Week - Robert F Service)
Volume 315 Issue 5819 - 23 March 2007- Open Government House OKs Whistleblower Bill (p 1649 - News of the Week - Eli Kintisch)
Volume 315 Issue 5814 - 16 February 2007- Research Integrity Bubble Fusion Researcher Cleared of Misconduct Charges but Doubts Linger (p 921 - News of the Week - Robert F Service)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 8
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 315 Issue 5810 - 19 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Former Hwang Colleague Faked Monkey Datas US Says (p 317 - News of the Week - Constance Holden)
Volume 315 Issue 5808 - 5 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Japanrsquos Universities Take Action (p 26 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 314 Issue 5806 - 15 December 2006- Scientific Misconduct Online Sleuths Challenge Cell Paper (p 1669 - News of the Week - Hao Xin)
Volume 314 Issue 5804 - 1 December 2006- Developmental Biology Fraud Investigation Clouds Paper on Early Cell Fate (pp 1367-1369 - News of the Week - Gretchen Vogel)- Scientific Misconduct Chinarsquos Fraud Buster Hit by Libel Judgments Defenders Rally Round (pp 1366-1367 - News of the Week - Jia Hepeng and Hao Xin)- Responding to Fraud (pp 1353 - Editorial - Donald Kennedy) (+ Supporting On-line Material)
Volume 312 Issue 5779 - 9 June 2006- Scientific Misconduct Scandals Shake Chinese Science (pp 1464-1466 - News Focus - Hao Xin)- Scientific Misconduct Crime Scene Investigation How to Handle Misconduct (p 1465 - News Focus - Eliot Marshall)
Volume 85 Issue 07 - 12 February 2007- Re search Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three Japanese cases conclude (pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
Volume 84 Issue 45 - 6 November 2006- Research Misconduct Federal agencies handle fabrication falsification and plagiarism allegations differently but all take claims seriously (pp 18-22 - Susan Morrissey)
BMJ
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 9
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 335 Ndeg 7619 - 15 September 2007Dealing with Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 524525 - Xavier Bosch)
Volume 334 Ndeg 7590 - 24 February 2007- Managing Suspected Research Misconduct (Editorials - pp 378-379 - Charles Young amp Fiona Godlee)- Research Ethics Doubts over Head Injury Studies (Feature - pp 392-394 - Ian Roberts Richard Smith amp Stephen Evans)
Volume 331 Ndeg 7511 - 30 July 2005Investigating Allegations of Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 245-246 - Jane Smith amp Fiona Godlee)
RESEARCH POLICY Volume 36 Issue 7 September 2007
Keeping Plagiarism at Bay A Salutary Tale (Editorial - p 905-311 - Ben R Martin amp Other Editors of Research Policy)
IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY Volume 25 Ndeg2 - MarchApril 2006
Spring Cleaning and Ethics in our Backyard (From the Editor - pp 4-5 - John Enderle)
THE LANCET
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 10
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 370 Ndeg9596 - 20 October 2007Research Integrity Collaboration and Research needed (Comment - p 1403-1404 - Erik von Elm)
CELL Volume 131 - 5 October 2007
Seeking an International Dialogue on Research Integrity (p 9-11 - Christie Aschwanden)
SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS 27 September 2007
A Qualitative Approach to Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR) Training Development Identification of Metacognitive Strategies (Vykinta Kligyte Richard T Marcy Sydney T Sevier Elaine S Godfrey and Michael D Mumford)
CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS Volume 85 Ndeg7 - 12 February 2007
Research Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 11
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Japanese cases conclude (Science amp Technology - pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
Vol 16 no 1 December 2007 issue PDF (52 KB)Among the articles in this issue are registration opens for the first biennial RCR conference RCR award given to the Council of Graduate Schools postdoc training funded at 12 institutions 2007 Annual Report due by March 1 2008 Global Science Forum develops steps to lessen research misconduct first World Conference report recommends actions to meet crucial needs innovative RCR resources to be available on-line in spring 2008
BOOKS Integrity in Scientific Research Creating an Environment that Promotes
Responsible ConductCommittee on Assessing Integrity in Research Environments National Research Council Institute of MedicineNational Academies Press 2002 - ISBN 0309084792
Introduction to the Responsible Conduct of ResearchNicholas Steneck US Office of Research IntegrityRevised edition 2004 - ISBN 0160722853
The Great Betrayal Fraud in ScienceHorace Freeland JudsonHarcourt 2004 - ISBN 0151008779
Scientific Integrity Text and Cases in responsible Conduct of ResearchFrancis MacrinaASM Press 2005 - ISBN 1555813186
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 12
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHInvited Papers amp BiographiesName Affiliation Lecture Biography
Prof Howard ALPER
University of Ottawa Department of Chemistry Canada
Research Integrity Best Practices for the Benefic of Society (PPT - 41 MB)
Word (37 KB)
Prof Melissa ANDERSON
University of Minnesota Department of Educational Policy and Administration Minneapolis USA
Educating Competent Responsible and Successful Researchers (PPT - 15 KB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Lida ANESTIDOU
The National Academies Institute for Laboratory Animal Research Washington USA
Current Policies and Policy Development (PDF - 393 KB)
Dr Guitelle BAGHDADI-SABETI
World Health Organisation (WHO) Geneva Switzerland
Good Governance for Medicines (PPT - 09 MB)
Word (113 KB)
Prof Ulrike BEISIEGEL
Universitaumltskrankenhaus Hamburg-Eppendorf Germany
Safeguarding Good Scientific Practice (PPT - 81 KB)
Dr Lawrence BELL
Museum of Science Boston USA
Who Do You Trust Science Museums as Forums for Conversations between Scientists and the Public (PDF - 23 MB)
PDF (302 KB)
Dr Christine BOESZ
US National Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Legal Aspects of Investigation amp International Cooperation (PPT - 79 KB)
Dr Philip CAMPBELL
Nature London UK Misconduct in Research Who is Responsible for What (PPT - 111 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Dr Paul CARO Acadeacutemie des Technologies Paris France
Science and the Show Society (PPT - 69 KB)
Dr Paul DAVID University of Oxford Empirical Realities of PDF (41
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 13
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
amp Dr Andrea POZZI
Oxford Internet Institute UK amp Stanford University Landau Economics Centre USA
Scientific Misconduct in Publicly Funded Research What Can We Learn from the ORIs Investigations in of US Cases in the Biomedical and Behavioral Sciences (PDF - 648 KB)
KB)
Dr Vladimir DE SEMIR
Universitat Pompeu Fabra Journalism and Audiovisual Communication Department Barcelona ES
Research Integrity amp Knowledge Society R+D+i is not enough (PDF - 243 MB)
Dr Amaboo DHAI
University of the Witwatersrand Medical School Steve Biko Centre for Bioethics Parktown South Africa
Preserving Protecting amp Improving Research Integrity in Africa Challenges and Recommendations (PPT - 6 MB)
Word (short biography) (29 KB) - Word (long version) (118 KB)
Dr Pieter DRENTH
All European Academies (ALLEA) Amsterdam The Netherlands
Strengths and Weaknesses of Currrent Policies and Practices (PPT - 116 KB)
Word (36 KB)
Prof Ayse ERZAN
Istanbul Technical University Faculty of Sciences and Letters Turkey
Developing and Applying Integrity Policies in a Global Context (PPT - 102 KB)
Word (KB)
Prof Michael FARTHING
University of London UK Institutional Perspectives on Integrity of Publication (PPT - 702 KB)
Prof Carlos FIOLHAIS
University of Coimbra Portugal
- Scientific Integrity and Scientific Culture Telling the Truth to the Public (PPT- 20 MB)- Extended Abstract (Word - 42 KB)
Word (26 KB)
Dr Peggy FISCHER
National Science Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Investigating Research Misconduct Across International Borders Principles and Practices (PPT - 233 KB)
Word (24 KB)
Ms Annette FLANAGIN amp Dr Muza
JAMA Journal of the American Medical Association Chicago USA
African Journal Partnership Project (PPT - 560 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 14
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
GONDWE amp University of Malawi College of Medicine Blantyre Malawi
Prof William GARDNER
The Ohio State University Columbus USA
Research Misconduct International Cooperation (PPT - 297 KB)
Prof Herbert GOTTWEIS
University of Vienna Institut fuumlr Politikwissenschaft Austria
Hwang-gate Lessons for Science Governance (PDF - 12 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Chris GRAF Wiley-Blackwell Oxford UK
What are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics (PPT - 13 MB)
Mr Angel GURRIA
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
Remarks
Prof Ian HALLIDAY
European Science Foundation Strasbourg France
Integrating Responsibility The Research Student Perspective (PPT - 170 KB)
Mr Joel HASSE FERREIRA
European Parliament Brussels Belgium
Public Policies and Strategies Fostering Research Integrity (Word - 28 KB)
Dr Elizabeth HEITMAN
Vanderbilt University Medical Center Nashville USA
The Need for Global Strategies for Training Students in RCR (PPT - 101 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Manuel HEITOR
Portuguese Ministry for Science Technology and Higher Education (MCTES) Lisbon Portugal
- Do We Need a Revisited Policy Agenda for Research IntegrityAn Institutional Perspective (PDF - 98 KB)- Concluding Remarks (PDF - 32 KB)
PDF (187 KB)
Prof Helena ILLNEROVA
Academy of Sciences Prague Czech Republic
Trust in Research and the Importance of Training (Word - 43 KB)
Word (28 KB)
Prof Matthias KAISER
The National Committee for Research Ethics in Science and Technology (NENT) Oslo Norway
International Cooperation to Foster Research Integrity Reflections on Actors and Instruments (PPT - 21 MB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 15
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Dr Katrina KELNER
Science Magazine Washington USA
Science s Efforts to Ensure Research Integrity (PPT - 250 KB)
Word (22 KB)
Dr Sabine KLEINERT
The Lancet London UK How Can Good Publication Standards Influence Research Integrity Part1 (PPT - 47 MB) amp Part2 (PPT - 73 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Anthony KOMAROFF
Harvard Medical School Boston USA
Problems Undermining Public Confidence in and Understanding Research (PPT - 81 KB)
Word (32 KB)
Dr Philip LANGLAIS
Old Dominion University Norfolk USA
Institutional and Societal Issues Educating for Responsible Research (PPT - 235 KB)
Dr Nigel LLOYD
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Canada (NSERC) Ottawa Canada
Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct (PPT - 36 KB)
Word (57 KB)
Dr Joao LOBO ANTUNES
Hospital de Santa Maria Serviccedilo de Neurocirurgia Lisboa Portugal
To Publish or Not To Publish Communicating Science in a New Global and Financial Environment (PPT - 60 MB)
Professor Fernando LOPES DA SILVA
University van Amsterdam The Netherlands
Integrity in Biomedical Research The Role of Education (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Brian MARTINSON
HealthPartners Research Foundation (HPRF) Minneapolis USA
Research Integrity and the Social and Psychological Environments of Science (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Ana MARUSIC
Zagreb University School of Medicine Croatia
Why are scientific journals small or large important in fostering research integrity (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Shamila NAIR-BEDOUELLE
UNESCO Paris France COMESTs Role in Fostering Integrity in Research (PPT - 531 KB)
Prof Paumlr Vetenskapsraringdet (Swedish Closing Remarks (PPT - 23
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 16
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
A tale of two citations Mounir Errami Harold Garner Nature Vol 451 (7177) janvier 2008
Deacutepasser les bornes par Alex Gillis University affairs Canada (httpwwwaffairesuniversitairescaFrancaisissues2008janvierdepasser_bornes_01html)
Scientific integrity recent developments Pieter JD Drenth ALLEAKNAW conference on emerging regional co-operations Southeast European academies of sciences and humanities 2007
Plus de 800 institutions ont souscrit agrave la charte europeacuteenne du chercheur drsquoapregraves la Commission europeacuteenne Agence AEF 23 aoucirct 2007
Dossier lrsquointeacutegriteacute scientifique existe-t-elle Sciences Frontiegraveres ndeg 44 1999 Lrsquointeacutegriteacute scientifique en zone grise
Newsletters Annonces 3e colloque sur lrsquointeacutegriteacute scientifique en recherche meacutedicale FRSQ Queacutebec Une formation sur le plagiat eacutelectronique dans les travaux scolaires hellipCa vous
inteacuteresse Avis de la CEST-Jeunesse Queacutebec Office of Research Integrity (ORI) newsletter (httporihhsgov )
Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations Integrity in research a rationale for community action expert group meeting
Brussels 2007 Recommended guidelines on research ethics Norwegian association of Higher
education institutions 2007 Summary of Australian guidance on international research misconduct Prepared by
TM Dyke Australian member ICCFFRMI 3 April 2008 Australian researchers are expected to comply with two over-arching documents The Australian Code for the Responsible Conduct of Research (2007) [the Code httpwwwnhmrcgovaupublicationssynopsesr39synhtm] and the National Statement on Ethical conduct in Human Research (2007) [the Statement httpwwwnhmrcgovaupublicationssynopsese72synhtm]
JRC guidelines for integrity in its support activities Robust science for policy making a guideline towards integrity and veracity in scientific support and advice October 2006
Research misconduct NSF La fraude scientifique Isabelle de Lamberterie CNRS-COMETS 2006 SLAC BaBar Publication Policy 199mdashmodifieacute 2005 (approval for public release of
results) Guidelines on scientific analysis in policy making HM Government GB October
2005 Charte europeacuteenne du chercheur code de conduite pour le recrutement des
chercheurs Commission europeacuteenne 2005 Inteacutegriteacute dans la recherche scientifique Universiteacute de Genegraveve 2005 Integrity in scientific research introductory paper advisory committee AAAS
2005 Le plagiat eacutelectronique dans les travaux scolaires une pratique qui soulegraveve des
questions eacutethiques Commission de lrsquoeacutethique de la science et de la technologie Queacutebec 2005
Guidelines on good research practice including statement on the handling of allegations of research misconduct Wellcome trust 2005 (updated) 2002
Code de deacuteontologie de lrsquoInstitut pasteur deacutecembre 2004 Memorandum on scientific integrity ALLEA 2003 Un code de conduite des chercheurs dans les sciences du comportement humain
Socieacuteteacute franccedilaise de psychologie 2003 Guide drsquoeacutethique de la recherche et drsquointeacutegriteacute scientifique Fonds de la recherche
en santeacute du Queacutebec 2003 Good scientific practice and procedures for handling misconduct and fraud in
science national advisory board on research ethics Finland 2002
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 2
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
EMBL rules of good scientific practice of procedure in cases of suspected scientific misconduct 2002
Proceacutedure concernant la creacuteation et le fonctionnement des commissions creacutees par la direction geacuteneacuterale CNRS 2000 (httpwwwcnrsfrfrorganismeethiquecometshistorique1994-2001chartehtm)
Comiteacute de deacuteontologie scientifique Universiteacute Claude Bernard creacuteation Lyon 2000
Preamble for research misconduct policy Executive office of the president (OSTP) USA 2000
Entente-cadre sur la proprieacuteteacute intellectuelle applicable agrave tous les chercheurs des deacutepartements de sciences fondamentales de la faculteacute de meacutedecine Universiteacute de Montreacuteal 1996
Recommandations on the status of scientific researchers UNESCO Records of the general conference 1974
Funding principles Volkswagen foundation
Recensements Academic Corruption Degree fraud The Boston College Center for international
higher education concerne 26 pays articles de presse (httpwwwbcedubc_orgavpsoecihehecmcmnews_03fakehtm)
Interim analysis of codes of conduct and codes of ethics UNESCO Division of ethics of science and technology septembre 2006
Regarding the Guidelines for Responses to Research Misconduct ndash Report of the special Committee on research misconduct Aug 8 2006 Council for Science and Technology Japan (httpwwwmextgojpenglishkagaku07053104htm)
Policy on relationship between Trust-funded researchers and commercial organizations Wellcome Trust (httpwwwwellcomeacukAbout-usPolicyPolicy-and-position-statementswtd039176htm)
Rapports Research Integrity global responsibility to foster common standards Office of
Research Integrity (USA) amp European Science Foundation - Science Policy Briefing UK 2008
Stewards of integrity institutional approaches to promote and safeguard good scientific practice in Europe ESF 2008 (to be published)
Handbook for Members of Audit Committees in Higher Education Institutions - Committee of University Chairmen This guide is aimed at members of audit committees of higher education institutions in the UK It shares current good practice and encourages its appropriate adoption across the higher education sector The advice was prepared in January 2008 (httpwwwhefceacukpubshefce200808_0608_06doc)
Working paper on conflict of interest for review and comment American council on education avril 2008
OECD report on best practices for ensuring scientific integrity and preventing misconduct 2007
Final report to ESF and ORI First world conference on research integrity fostering responsible research Tony Mayer and Nick Steneck Nov 2007
Inteacutegriteacute scientifique vers lrsquoeacutelaboration de politiques coheacuterentes Freacutedeacuteric Sgard et Steacutephane Michalowski Sciences 2007
What to do if you suspect plagiarism etc Committee on publication ethics flowchart COPE 2006
Scientific advice Risk and Evidence Based policy Making House of commons Science and technology committee 2006 Aug 8 2006 Special Committee on scientific misconduct Council for Science and Technology
Protecting patents preserving integrity advancing health accelerating the implementation of COI policies in human subjects research a report of the AAMC-AAU advisory committee on financial conflicts of interest in human subjects research AAMC (association of american medical college ) (httpwwwaaueduresearchRpt_AAU-AAMC_COI_208pdf
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 3
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
The Danish Committee on scientific dishonesty Danish Agency for science technology and innovation annual report 2006 november 2007 (httpfidksiteenglishpublicationspublications-2007annual-report-2006-the-danish-committees-on-scientific-dishoFIST_GB_wwwpdf)
Good scientific practice in research and scholarship European science foundation policy briefing 2000
Colloques et confeacuterences Lisbon first world conference on science integrity An action-oriented approach
Contributions from Pieter Drenth Stefan Michalowski Frederic Sgard Ovid Tzeng Drsquoune faccedilon geacuteneacuterale les contributions agrave la Confeacuterence de Lisbonne sur lrsquointeacutegriteacute
scientifique se trouvent agrave httpwwwesforgactivitiesesf-conferencesdetailsarchives2007confdetail242html
Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat logiciel Tetralogie Ce logiciel qui est un outil de veille (strateacutegique
concurrentielle) qui permet de faire des comparaisons afin de deacutetecter des plagiats (lthttpatlasiritfrgt)
Logiciel grenoble
Source site ESf
RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHReferences amp Background Reading
NATURE Volume 451 Number 7181 - 21 February 2008
- Pakistan needs a powerful ethics and integrity body (Nature 451 887 - Correspondence - Muhammad Mukhtar amp Zahida Parve)
Volume 451 Number 7179 - 7 February 2008- No conflict of interest in misconduct case says lab (Nature 451 618-619 - News)
Volume 451 Number 7177 - 24 January 2008- A tale of two citations (Nature 451 397-399 - Commentary - Mounir Errami amp Harold Garner)
Volume 450 Number 7170 - 29 November 2007- Loopholes in oversight rules revealed US energy department criticized over procedure for misconduct investigations (Nature 450 590 - News - Eugenie Samuel Reich)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 4
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
- Each co-author should sign to reduce risk of fraud (Nature 450 610 - Correspondence - Kevin Yager)
Volume 450 Number 7169 - 22 November 2007- Replicator Review Nature has implemented a peer-review policy for strong claims (Nature 450 457-458 - Editorial)- Stem-cell Researcher accused of Negligence (Nature 450 470- News)
Volume 450 Number 7166 - 1 November 2007- Who is accountable How the responsibilities of co-authors for a scientific papers integrity could be made more explicit (Nature 450 1 - Editorial)
Volume 449 Number 7161 - 27 September 2007- Stem-cell Fraudster is working in Thailand Woo Suk Hwang may be back in the cloning lab (Nature 449 387 - News - David Cyranoski)
Volume 448 Number 7154 - 9 August 2007- Academic Accused of Living on Borrowed Lines Allegations prompt Fears over Prevalence of Plagiarism (Nature 448 623-726 - News - Alison Abbott)
Volume 447 Number 7146 - 14 June 2007- Indian Scientists battle Journal Retraction (Nature 447 753-884 - News - KS Jayaraman)
Volume 447 Number 7142 - 17 May 2007- Purdue dogged by misconduct claims Third inquiry into bubble fusion is underway (Nature 447 238-239 - News - Eugenie Samuel Reich)- Recognition could support a science code of conduct (Nature 447 259 - Correspondence - Yan Ropert-Coudert)- Modellers seek reason for low attraction rate (Nature 447 236-237- News - Declan Butler amp Jenny Hogan)Volume 447 Number 7140 - 3 May 2007- Share your lab notes The use of electronic laboratory notebooks should be supported by all concerned (Nature 447 1 - Editorial)
Volume 446 Number 7135 - 29 March 2007- Confidentiality is essential in misconduct inquiries (Nature 446 492 - Correspondence - Sally Mason amp Charles Rutledge)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 5
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 446 Number 7133 - 15 March 2007- Geophysicist faces probe into use of research funds Co-founder of European Academy of Sciences comes under scrutiny (Nature 446 236 - News - Jim Giles)
Volume 445 Number 7129 - 15 February 2007- Methods in Full From now on Nature authors will be able to include more experimental details in their papers (Nature 445 684 - Editorials)
Volume 445 Number 7126 - 25 January 2007- Journals should set a new standard in transparency (Nature 445 364 - Correspondence - Robert P Dellavalle Kristy Lundahl Scott R Freeman and Lisa M Schilling)
Volume 445 Number 7125 - 18 January 2007- Leading by example The primary safeguard against scientific misconduct is the example set every day by thousands of senior researchers in the laboratory (Nature 445 229 - Editorials)- Misconduct Itrsquos all academic (Nature 445 240-241 - News - Geoff Brumfiel)- Breeding cheats (Nature 445 242-243 - News - Jim Giles)- Where are they now (Nature 445 244-245 - News - Lucy Odling-Smee Jim Giles Ichiko Fuyuno David Cyranoski and Emma Marris)
Volume 444 Number 7122 - 21 December 2006- Peer review and fraud Two assessments of the refereeing process highlight challenges for journals (Nature 444 971-972 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7121 - 14 December 2006- The elephant in the room A biotech trial that went awry (Nature 444 790 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7120 - 7 December 2006- Journal reveals plans to fight fraud Science to select papers for extra-secure review process (Nature 444 658-659 - News - Meredith Wadman)- Purdue attacked over fusion inquiry Physicists angry at apparent inertia in misconduct investigation (Nature 444 664-665 - News - Eugenie Samuel Reich)- A fair share The concept of sharing primary data is
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 6
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
generating unnecessary angst in the psychology community (Nature 444 653-654 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7116 -- 9 November 2006- Correction or retraction Errors reported in this issue by authors of a Nature paper pose a dilemma about trust (Nature 444 123-124 - Editorials)
Volume 443 Number 7108 - 14 September 2006- Whistleblowers in peril The US Congress should reverse a pernicious removal of protection of federal employees (Nature 443 121 - Editorials)
Volume 442 Number 7099 - 13 July 2006- Misconduct forum should not be used to settle sc ores (Nature 442 132 - Correspondence - Guosheng Wu)- Misconduct China needs university ethics courses (Nature 442 132 - Correspondence - Qizhi Wang)
Volume 441 Number 7096 - 22 June 2006- Misconduct lack of action provokes web accusations (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Shi-min Fang)- Misconduct exposure is not like Cultural Revolution (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Zheng Huang)- Misconduct Chinese funding body unmoved (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Ushma Savla Neill)
Volume 441 Number 7093 - 1 June 2006- Finding fraud in China As Chinese research expands who is looking out for faked results (Nature 441 549-550 - Editorials)
Volume 441 Number 7092 - 25 May 2006- Named and shamed As accusations of scientific misconduct in China become rife some fear persecution reminiscent of that used in the Cultural Revolution (Nature 441 392-393 - News - David Cyranoski)
Volume 435 Number 7043 - 9 June 2005- One in three scientists confesses to having sinned Misconduct ranges from faking results outright to dropping suspect data points (Nature 435 718-719 - News - Meredith Wadman)- Scientists behaving badly (Nature 435 737-738 - Commentary - Brian C Martinson Melissa S Anderson amp Raymond de Vries)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 7
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
NATURE In the Field
17 September 2007 Integrity - Zero Tolerance in Portugal (Sarah Tomlin)
NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY Volume 24 Number 2 - 2 February 2006
South Korean policy failure and the Hwang debacle (Nature Biotechnology 24 141-143 - Commentary - Herbert Gottweis amp Robert Triendl)
SCIENCE Volume 316 Issue 5832 - 22 June 2007
- Scientific Publishing Osaka University Researchers reject Demand to Retract Science Paper (p 1681 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 316 Issue 5827 - 18 May 2007- Research Integrity Sonofusion Back on the Firing Line as Misconduct Probe Reopens (p 964 - News of the Week - Robert F Service)
Volume 315 Issue 5819 - 23 March 2007- Open Government House OKs Whistleblower Bill (p 1649 - News of the Week - Eli Kintisch)
Volume 315 Issue 5814 - 16 February 2007- Research Integrity Bubble Fusion Researcher Cleared of Misconduct Charges but Doubts Linger (p 921 - News of the Week - Robert F Service)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 8
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 315 Issue 5810 - 19 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Former Hwang Colleague Faked Monkey Datas US Says (p 317 - News of the Week - Constance Holden)
Volume 315 Issue 5808 - 5 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Japanrsquos Universities Take Action (p 26 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 314 Issue 5806 - 15 December 2006- Scientific Misconduct Online Sleuths Challenge Cell Paper (p 1669 - News of the Week - Hao Xin)
Volume 314 Issue 5804 - 1 December 2006- Developmental Biology Fraud Investigation Clouds Paper on Early Cell Fate (pp 1367-1369 - News of the Week - Gretchen Vogel)- Scientific Misconduct Chinarsquos Fraud Buster Hit by Libel Judgments Defenders Rally Round (pp 1366-1367 - News of the Week - Jia Hepeng and Hao Xin)- Responding to Fraud (pp 1353 - Editorial - Donald Kennedy) (+ Supporting On-line Material)
Volume 312 Issue 5779 - 9 June 2006- Scientific Misconduct Scandals Shake Chinese Science (pp 1464-1466 - News Focus - Hao Xin)- Scientific Misconduct Crime Scene Investigation How to Handle Misconduct (p 1465 - News Focus - Eliot Marshall)
Volume 85 Issue 07 - 12 February 2007- Re search Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three Japanese cases conclude (pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
Volume 84 Issue 45 - 6 November 2006- Research Misconduct Federal agencies handle fabrication falsification and plagiarism allegations differently but all take claims seriously (pp 18-22 - Susan Morrissey)
BMJ
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 9
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 335 Ndeg 7619 - 15 September 2007Dealing with Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 524525 - Xavier Bosch)
Volume 334 Ndeg 7590 - 24 February 2007- Managing Suspected Research Misconduct (Editorials - pp 378-379 - Charles Young amp Fiona Godlee)- Research Ethics Doubts over Head Injury Studies (Feature - pp 392-394 - Ian Roberts Richard Smith amp Stephen Evans)
Volume 331 Ndeg 7511 - 30 July 2005Investigating Allegations of Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 245-246 - Jane Smith amp Fiona Godlee)
RESEARCH POLICY Volume 36 Issue 7 September 2007
Keeping Plagiarism at Bay A Salutary Tale (Editorial - p 905-311 - Ben R Martin amp Other Editors of Research Policy)
IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY Volume 25 Ndeg2 - MarchApril 2006
Spring Cleaning and Ethics in our Backyard (From the Editor - pp 4-5 - John Enderle)
THE LANCET
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 10
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 370 Ndeg9596 - 20 October 2007Research Integrity Collaboration and Research needed (Comment - p 1403-1404 - Erik von Elm)
CELL Volume 131 - 5 October 2007
Seeking an International Dialogue on Research Integrity (p 9-11 - Christie Aschwanden)
SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS 27 September 2007
A Qualitative Approach to Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR) Training Development Identification of Metacognitive Strategies (Vykinta Kligyte Richard T Marcy Sydney T Sevier Elaine S Godfrey and Michael D Mumford)
CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS Volume 85 Ndeg7 - 12 February 2007
Research Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 11
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Japanese cases conclude (Science amp Technology - pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
Vol 16 no 1 December 2007 issue PDF (52 KB)Among the articles in this issue are registration opens for the first biennial RCR conference RCR award given to the Council of Graduate Schools postdoc training funded at 12 institutions 2007 Annual Report due by March 1 2008 Global Science Forum develops steps to lessen research misconduct first World Conference report recommends actions to meet crucial needs innovative RCR resources to be available on-line in spring 2008
BOOKS Integrity in Scientific Research Creating an Environment that Promotes
Responsible ConductCommittee on Assessing Integrity in Research Environments National Research Council Institute of MedicineNational Academies Press 2002 - ISBN 0309084792
Introduction to the Responsible Conduct of ResearchNicholas Steneck US Office of Research IntegrityRevised edition 2004 - ISBN 0160722853
The Great Betrayal Fraud in ScienceHorace Freeland JudsonHarcourt 2004 - ISBN 0151008779
Scientific Integrity Text and Cases in responsible Conduct of ResearchFrancis MacrinaASM Press 2005 - ISBN 1555813186
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 12
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHInvited Papers amp BiographiesName Affiliation Lecture Biography
Prof Howard ALPER
University of Ottawa Department of Chemistry Canada
Research Integrity Best Practices for the Benefic of Society (PPT - 41 MB)
Word (37 KB)
Prof Melissa ANDERSON
University of Minnesota Department of Educational Policy and Administration Minneapolis USA
Educating Competent Responsible and Successful Researchers (PPT - 15 KB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Lida ANESTIDOU
The National Academies Institute for Laboratory Animal Research Washington USA
Current Policies and Policy Development (PDF - 393 KB)
Dr Guitelle BAGHDADI-SABETI
World Health Organisation (WHO) Geneva Switzerland
Good Governance for Medicines (PPT - 09 MB)
Word (113 KB)
Prof Ulrike BEISIEGEL
Universitaumltskrankenhaus Hamburg-Eppendorf Germany
Safeguarding Good Scientific Practice (PPT - 81 KB)
Dr Lawrence BELL
Museum of Science Boston USA
Who Do You Trust Science Museums as Forums for Conversations between Scientists and the Public (PDF - 23 MB)
PDF (302 KB)
Dr Christine BOESZ
US National Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Legal Aspects of Investigation amp International Cooperation (PPT - 79 KB)
Dr Philip CAMPBELL
Nature London UK Misconduct in Research Who is Responsible for What (PPT - 111 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Dr Paul CARO Acadeacutemie des Technologies Paris France
Science and the Show Society (PPT - 69 KB)
Dr Paul DAVID University of Oxford Empirical Realities of PDF (41
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 13
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
amp Dr Andrea POZZI
Oxford Internet Institute UK amp Stanford University Landau Economics Centre USA
Scientific Misconduct in Publicly Funded Research What Can We Learn from the ORIs Investigations in of US Cases in the Biomedical and Behavioral Sciences (PDF - 648 KB)
KB)
Dr Vladimir DE SEMIR
Universitat Pompeu Fabra Journalism and Audiovisual Communication Department Barcelona ES
Research Integrity amp Knowledge Society R+D+i is not enough (PDF - 243 MB)
Dr Amaboo DHAI
University of the Witwatersrand Medical School Steve Biko Centre for Bioethics Parktown South Africa
Preserving Protecting amp Improving Research Integrity in Africa Challenges and Recommendations (PPT - 6 MB)
Word (short biography) (29 KB) - Word (long version) (118 KB)
Dr Pieter DRENTH
All European Academies (ALLEA) Amsterdam The Netherlands
Strengths and Weaknesses of Currrent Policies and Practices (PPT - 116 KB)
Word (36 KB)
Prof Ayse ERZAN
Istanbul Technical University Faculty of Sciences and Letters Turkey
Developing and Applying Integrity Policies in a Global Context (PPT - 102 KB)
Word (KB)
Prof Michael FARTHING
University of London UK Institutional Perspectives on Integrity of Publication (PPT - 702 KB)
Prof Carlos FIOLHAIS
University of Coimbra Portugal
- Scientific Integrity and Scientific Culture Telling the Truth to the Public (PPT- 20 MB)- Extended Abstract (Word - 42 KB)
Word (26 KB)
Dr Peggy FISCHER
National Science Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Investigating Research Misconduct Across International Borders Principles and Practices (PPT - 233 KB)
Word (24 KB)
Ms Annette FLANAGIN amp Dr Muza
JAMA Journal of the American Medical Association Chicago USA
African Journal Partnership Project (PPT - 560 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 14
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
GONDWE amp University of Malawi College of Medicine Blantyre Malawi
Prof William GARDNER
The Ohio State University Columbus USA
Research Misconduct International Cooperation (PPT - 297 KB)
Prof Herbert GOTTWEIS
University of Vienna Institut fuumlr Politikwissenschaft Austria
Hwang-gate Lessons for Science Governance (PDF - 12 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Chris GRAF Wiley-Blackwell Oxford UK
What are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics (PPT - 13 MB)
Mr Angel GURRIA
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
Remarks
Prof Ian HALLIDAY
European Science Foundation Strasbourg France
Integrating Responsibility The Research Student Perspective (PPT - 170 KB)
Mr Joel HASSE FERREIRA
European Parliament Brussels Belgium
Public Policies and Strategies Fostering Research Integrity (Word - 28 KB)
Dr Elizabeth HEITMAN
Vanderbilt University Medical Center Nashville USA
The Need for Global Strategies for Training Students in RCR (PPT - 101 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Manuel HEITOR
Portuguese Ministry for Science Technology and Higher Education (MCTES) Lisbon Portugal
- Do We Need a Revisited Policy Agenda for Research IntegrityAn Institutional Perspective (PDF - 98 KB)- Concluding Remarks (PDF - 32 KB)
PDF (187 KB)
Prof Helena ILLNEROVA
Academy of Sciences Prague Czech Republic
Trust in Research and the Importance of Training (Word - 43 KB)
Word (28 KB)
Prof Matthias KAISER
The National Committee for Research Ethics in Science and Technology (NENT) Oslo Norway
International Cooperation to Foster Research Integrity Reflections on Actors and Instruments (PPT - 21 MB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 15
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Dr Katrina KELNER
Science Magazine Washington USA
Science s Efforts to Ensure Research Integrity (PPT - 250 KB)
Word (22 KB)
Dr Sabine KLEINERT
The Lancet London UK How Can Good Publication Standards Influence Research Integrity Part1 (PPT - 47 MB) amp Part2 (PPT - 73 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Anthony KOMAROFF
Harvard Medical School Boston USA
Problems Undermining Public Confidence in and Understanding Research (PPT - 81 KB)
Word (32 KB)
Dr Philip LANGLAIS
Old Dominion University Norfolk USA
Institutional and Societal Issues Educating for Responsible Research (PPT - 235 KB)
Dr Nigel LLOYD
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Canada (NSERC) Ottawa Canada
Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct (PPT - 36 KB)
Word (57 KB)
Dr Joao LOBO ANTUNES
Hospital de Santa Maria Serviccedilo de Neurocirurgia Lisboa Portugal
To Publish or Not To Publish Communicating Science in a New Global and Financial Environment (PPT - 60 MB)
Professor Fernando LOPES DA SILVA
University van Amsterdam The Netherlands
Integrity in Biomedical Research The Role of Education (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Brian MARTINSON
HealthPartners Research Foundation (HPRF) Minneapolis USA
Research Integrity and the Social and Psychological Environments of Science (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Ana MARUSIC
Zagreb University School of Medicine Croatia
Why are scientific journals small or large important in fostering research integrity (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Shamila NAIR-BEDOUELLE
UNESCO Paris France COMESTs Role in Fostering Integrity in Research (PPT - 531 KB)
Prof Paumlr Vetenskapsraringdet (Swedish Closing Remarks (PPT - 23
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 16
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
EMBL rules of good scientific practice of procedure in cases of suspected scientific misconduct 2002
Proceacutedure concernant la creacuteation et le fonctionnement des commissions creacutees par la direction geacuteneacuterale CNRS 2000 (httpwwwcnrsfrfrorganismeethiquecometshistorique1994-2001chartehtm)
Comiteacute de deacuteontologie scientifique Universiteacute Claude Bernard creacuteation Lyon 2000
Preamble for research misconduct policy Executive office of the president (OSTP) USA 2000
Entente-cadre sur la proprieacuteteacute intellectuelle applicable agrave tous les chercheurs des deacutepartements de sciences fondamentales de la faculteacute de meacutedecine Universiteacute de Montreacuteal 1996
Recommandations on the status of scientific researchers UNESCO Records of the general conference 1974
Funding principles Volkswagen foundation
Recensements Academic Corruption Degree fraud The Boston College Center for international
higher education concerne 26 pays articles de presse (httpwwwbcedubc_orgavpsoecihehecmcmnews_03fakehtm)
Interim analysis of codes of conduct and codes of ethics UNESCO Division of ethics of science and technology septembre 2006
Regarding the Guidelines for Responses to Research Misconduct ndash Report of the special Committee on research misconduct Aug 8 2006 Council for Science and Technology Japan (httpwwwmextgojpenglishkagaku07053104htm)
Policy on relationship between Trust-funded researchers and commercial organizations Wellcome Trust (httpwwwwellcomeacukAbout-usPolicyPolicy-and-position-statementswtd039176htm)
Rapports Research Integrity global responsibility to foster common standards Office of
Research Integrity (USA) amp European Science Foundation - Science Policy Briefing UK 2008
Stewards of integrity institutional approaches to promote and safeguard good scientific practice in Europe ESF 2008 (to be published)
Handbook for Members of Audit Committees in Higher Education Institutions - Committee of University Chairmen This guide is aimed at members of audit committees of higher education institutions in the UK It shares current good practice and encourages its appropriate adoption across the higher education sector The advice was prepared in January 2008 (httpwwwhefceacukpubshefce200808_0608_06doc)
Working paper on conflict of interest for review and comment American council on education avril 2008
OECD report on best practices for ensuring scientific integrity and preventing misconduct 2007
Final report to ESF and ORI First world conference on research integrity fostering responsible research Tony Mayer and Nick Steneck Nov 2007
Inteacutegriteacute scientifique vers lrsquoeacutelaboration de politiques coheacuterentes Freacutedeacuteric Sgard et Steacutephane Michalowski Sciences 2007
What to do if you suspect plagiarism etc Committee on publication ethics flowchart COPE 2006
Scientific advice Risk and Evidence Based policy Making House of commons Science and technology committee 2006 Aug 8 2006 Special Committee on scientific misconduct Council for Science and Technology
Protecting patents preserving integrity advancing health accelerating the implementation of COI policies in human subjects research a report of the AAMC-AAU advisory committee on financial conflicts of interest in human subjects research AAMC (association of american medical college ) (httpwwwaaueduresearchRpt_AAU-AAMC_COI_208pdf
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 3
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
The Danish Committee on scientific dishonesty Danish Agency for science technology and innovation annual report 2006 november 2007 (httpfidksiteenglishpublicationspublications-2007annual-report-2006-the-danish-committees-on-scientific-dishoFIST_GB_wwwpdf)
Good scientific practice in research and scholarship European science foundation policy briefing 2000
Colloques et confeacuterences Lisbon first world conference on science integrity An action-oriented approach
Contributions from Pieter Drenth Stefan Michalowski Frederic Sgard Ovid Tzeng Drsquoune faccedilon geacuteneacuterale les contributions agrave la Confeacuterence de Lisbonne sur lrsquointeacutegriteacute
scientifique se trouvent agrave httpwwwesforgactivitiesesf-conferencesdetailsarchives2007confdetail242html
Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat logiciel Tetralogie Ce logiciel qui est un outil de veille (strateacutegique
concurrentielle) qui permet de faire des comparaisons afin de deacutetecter des plagiats (lthttpatlasiritfrgt)
Logiciel grenoble
Source site ESf
RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHReferences amp Background Reading
NATURE Volume 451 Number 7181 - 21 February 2008
- Pakistan needs a powerful ethics and integrity body (Nature 451 887 - Correspondence - Muhammad Mukhtar amp Zahida Parve)
Volume 451 Number 7179 - 7 February 2008- No conflict of interest in misconduct case says lab (Nature 451 618-619 - News)
Volume 451 Number 7177 - 24 January 2008- A tale of two citations (Nature 451 397-399 - Commentary - Mounir Errami amp Harold Garner)
Volume 450 Number 7170 - 29 November 2007- Loopholes in oversight rules revealed US energy department criticized over procedure for misconduct investigations (Nature 450 590 - News - Eugenie Samuel Reich)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 4
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
- Each co-author should sign to reduce risk of fraud (Nature 450 610 - Correspondence - Kevin Yager)
Volume 450 Number 7169 - 22 November 2007- Replicator Review Nature has implemented a peer-review policy for strong claims (Nature 450 457-458 - Editorial)- Stem-cell Researcher accused of Negligence (Nature 450 470- News)
Volume 450 Number 7166 - 1 November 2007- Who is accountable How the responsibilities of co-authors for a scientific papers integrity could be made more explicit (Nature 450 1 - Editorial)
Volume 449 Number 7161 - 27 September 2007- Stem-cell Fraudster is working in Thailand Woo Suk Hwang may be back in the cloning lab (Nature 449 387 - News - David Cyranoski)
Volume 448 Number 7154 - 9 August 2007- Academic Accused of Living on Borrowed Lines Allegations prompt Fears over Prevalence of Plagiarism (Nature 448 623-726 - News - Alison Abbott)
Volume 447 Number 7146 - 14 June 2007- Indian Scientists battle Journal Retraction (Nature 447 753-884 - News - KS Jayaraman)
Volume 447 Number 7142 - 17 May 2007- Purdue dogged by misconduct claims Third inquiry into bubble fusion is underway (Nature 447 238-239 - News - Eugenie Samuel Reich)- Recognition could support a science code of conduct (Nature 447 259 - Correspondence - Yan Ropert-Coudert)- Modellers seek reason for low attraction rate (Nature 447 236-237- News - Declan Butler amp Jenny Hogan)Volume 447 Number 7140 - 3 May 2007- Share your lab notes The use of electronic laboratory notebooks should be supported by all concerned (Nature 447 1 - Editorial)
Volume 446 Number 7135 - 29 March 2007- Confidentiality is essential in misconduct inquiries (Nature 446 492 - Correspondence - Sally Mason amp Charles Rutledge)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 5
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 446 Number 7133 - 15 March 2007- Geophysicist faces probe into use of research funds Co-founder of European Academy of Sciences comes under scrutiny (Nature 446 236 - News - Jim Giles)
Volume 445 Number 7129 - 15 February 2007- Methods in Full From now on Nature authors will be able to include more experimental details in their papers (Nature 445 684 - Editorials)
Volume 445 Number 7126 - 25 January 2007- Journals should set a new standard in transparency (Nature 445 364 - Correspondence - Robert P Dellavalle Kristy Lundahl Scott R Freeman and Lisa M Schilling)
Volume 445 Number 7125 - 18 January 2007- Leading by example The primary safeguard against scientific misconduct is the example set every day by thousands of senior researchers in the laboratory (Nature 445 229 - Editorials)- Misconduct Itrsquos all academic (Nature 445 240-241 - News - Geoff Brumfiel)- Breeding cheats (Nature 445 242-243 - News - Jim Giles)- Where are they now (Nature 445 244-245 - News - Lucy Odling-Smee Jim Giles Ichiko Fuyuno David Cyranoski and Emma Marris)
Volume 444 Number 7122 - 21 December 2006- Peer review and fraud Two assessments of the refereeing process highlight challenges for journals (Nature 444 971-972 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7121 - 14 December 2006- The elephant in the room A biotech trial that went awry (Nature 444 790 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7120 - 7 December 2006- Journal reveals plans to fight fraud Science to select papers for extra-secure review process (Nature 444 658-659 - News - Meredith Wadman)- Purdue attacked over fusion inquiry Physicists angry at apparent inertia in misconduct investigation (Nature 444 664-665 - News - Eugenie Samuel Reich)- A fair share The concept of sharing primary data is
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 6
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
generating unnecessary angst in the psychology community (Nature 444 653-654 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7116 -- 9 November 2006- Correction or retraction Errors reported in this issue by authors of a Nature paper pose a dilemma about trust (Nature 444 123-124 - Editorials)
Volume 443 Number 7108 - 14 September 2006- Whistleblowers in peril The US Congress should reverse a pernicious removal of protection of federal employees (Nature 443 121 - Editorials)
Volume 442 Number 7099 - 13 July 2006- Misconduct forum should not be used to settle sc ores (Nature 442 132 - Correspondence - Guosheng Wu)- Misconduct China needs university ethics courses (Nature 442 132 - Correspondence - Qizhi Wang)
Volume 441 Number 7096 - 22 June 2006- Misconduct lack of action provokes web accusations (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Shi-min Fang)- Misconduct exposure is not like Cultural Revolution (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Zheng Huang)- Misconduct Chinese funding body unmoved (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Ushma Savla Neill)
Volume 441 Number 7093 - 1 June 2006- Finding fraud in China As Chinese research expands who is looking out for faked results (Nature 441 549-550 - Editorials)
Volume 441 Number 7092 - 25 May 2006- Named and shamed As accusations of scientific misconduct in China become rife some fear persecution reminiscent of that used in the Cultural Revolution (Nature 441 392-393 - News - David Cyranoski)
Volume 435 Number 7043 - 9 June 2005- One in three scientists confesses to having sinned Misconduct ranges from faking results outright to dropping suspect data points (Nature 435 718-719 - News - Meredith Wadman)- Scientists behaving badly (Nature 435 737-738 - Commentary - Brian C Martinson Melissa S Anderson amp Raymond de Vries)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 7
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
NATURE In the Field
17 September 2007 Integrity - Zero Tolerance in Portugal (Sarah Tomlin)
NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY Volume 24 Number 2 - 2 February 2006
South Korean policy failure and the Hwang debacle (Nature Biotechnology 24 141-143 - Commentary - Herbert Gottweis amp Robert Triendl)
SCIENCE Volume 316 Issue 5832 - 22 June 2007
- Scientific Publishing Osaka University Researchers reject Demand to Retract Science Paper (p 1681 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 316 Issue 5827 - 18 May 2007- Research Integrity Sonofusion Back on the Firing Line as Misconduct Probe Reopens (p 964 - News of the Week - Robert F Service)
Volume 315 Issue 5819 - 23 March 2007- Open Government House OKs Whistleblower Bill (p 1649 - News of the Week - Eli Kintisch)
Volume 315 Issue 5814 - 16 February 2007- Research Integrity Bubble Fusion Researcher Cleared of Misconduct Charges but Doubts Linger (p 921 - News of the Week - Robert F Service)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 8
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 315 Issue 5810 - 19 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Former Hwang Colleague Faked Monkey Datas US Says (p 317 - News of the Week - Constance Holden)
Volume 315 Issue 5808 - 5 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Japanrsquos Universities Take Action (p 26 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 314 Issue 5806 - 15 December 2006- Scientific Misconduct Online Sleuths Challenge Cell Paper (p 1669 - News of the Week - Hao Xin)
Volume 314 Issue 5804 - 1 December 2006- Developmental Biology Fraud Investigation Clouds Paper on Early Cell Fate (pp 1367-1369 - News of the Week - Gretchen Vogel)- Scientific Misconduct Chinarsquos Fraud Buster Hit by Libel Judgments Defenders Rally Round (pp 1366-1367 - News of the Week - Jia Hepeng and Hao Xin)- Responding to Fraud (pp 1353 - Editorial - Donald Kennedy) (+ Supporting On-line Material)
Volume 312 Issue 5779 - 9 June 2006- Scientific Misconduct Scandals Shake Chinese Science (pp 1464-1466 - News Focus - Hao Xin)- Scientific Misconduct Crime Scene Investigation How to Handle Misconduct (p 1465 - News Focus - Eliot Marshall)
Volume 85 Issue 07 - 12 February 2007- Re search Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three Japanese cases conclude (pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
Volume 84 Issue 45 - 6 November 2006- Research Misconduct Federal agencies handle fabrication falsification and plagiarism allegations differently but all take claims seriously (pp 18-22 - Susan Morrissey)
BMJ
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 9
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 335 Ndeg 7619 - 15 September 2007Dealing with Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 524525 - Xavier Bosch)
Volume 334 Ndeg 7590 - 24 February 2007- Managing Suspected Research Misconduct (Editorials - pp 378-379 - Charles Young amp Fiona Godlee)- Research Ethics Doubts over Head Injury Studies (Feature - pp 392-394 - Ian Roberts Richard Smith amp Stephen Evans)
Volume 331 Ndeg 7511 - 30 July 2005Investigating Allegations of Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 245-246 - Jane Smith amp Fiona Godlee)
RESEARCH POLICY Volume 36 Issue 7 September 2007
Keeping Plagiarism at Bay A Salutary Tale (Editorial - p 905-311 - Ben R Martin amp Other Editors of Research Policy)
IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY Volume 25 Ndeg2 - MarchApril 2006
Spring Cleaning and Ethics in our Backyard (From the Editor - pp 4-5 - John Enderle)
THE LANCET
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 10
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 370 Ndeg9596 - 20 October 2007Research Integrity Collaboration and Research needed (Comment - p 1403-1404 - Erik von Elm)
CELL Volume 131 - 5 October 2007
Seeking an International Dialogue on Research Integrity (p 9-11 - Christie Aschwanden)
SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS 27 September 2007
A Qualitative Approach to Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR) Training Development Identification of Metacognitive Strategies (Vykinta Kligyte Richard T Marcy Sydney T Sevier Elaine S Godfrey and Michael D Mumford)
CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS Volume 85 Ndeg7 - 12 February 2007
Research Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 11
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Japanese cases conclude (Science amp Technology - pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
Vol 16 no 1 December 2007 issue PDF (52 KB)Among the articles in this issue are registration opens for the first biennial RCR conference RCR award given to the Council of Graduate Schools postdoc training funded at 12 institutions 2007 Annual Report due by March 1 2008 Global Science Forum develops steps to lessen research misconduct first World Conference report recommends actions to meet crucial needs innovative RCR resources to be available on-line in spring 2008
BOOKS Integrity in Scientific Research Creating an Environment that Promotes
Responsible ConductCommittee on Assessing Integrity in Research Environments National Research Council Institute of MedicineNational Academies Press 2002 - ISBN 0309084792
Introduction to the Responsible Conduct of ResearchNicholas Steneck US Office of Research IntegrityRevised edition 2004 - ISBN 0160722853
The Great Betrayal Fraud in ScienceHorace Freeland JudsonHarcourt 2004 - ISBN 0151008779
Scientific Integrity Text and Cases in responsible Conduct of ResearchFrancis MacrinaASM Press 2005 - ISBN 1555813186
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 12
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHInvited Papers amp BiographiesName Affiliation Lecture Biography
Prof Howard ALPER
University of Ottawa Department of Chemistry Canada
Research Integrity Best Practices for the Benefic of Society (PPT - 41 MB)
Word (37 KB)
Prof Melissa ANDERSON
University of Minnesota Department of Educational Policy and Administration Minneapolis USA
Educating Competent Responsible and Successful Researchers (PPT - 15 KB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Lida ANESTIDOU
The National Academies Institute for Laboratory Animal Research Washington USA
Current Policies and Policy Development (PDF - 393 KB)
Dr Guitelle BAGHDADI-SABETI
World Health Organisation (WHO) Geneva Switzerland
Good Governance for Medicines (PPT - 09 MB)
Word (113 KB)
Prof Ulrike BEISIEGEL
Universitaumltskrankenhaus Hamburg-Eppendorf Germany
Safeguarding Good Scientific Practice (PPT - 81 KB)
Dr Lawrence BELL
Museum of Science Boston USA
Who Do You Trust Science Museums as Forums for Conversations between Scientists and the Public (PDF - 23 MB)
PDF (302 KB)
Dr Christine BOESZ
US National Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Legal Aspects of Investigation amp International Cooperation (PPT - 79 KB)
Dr Philip CAMPBELL
Nature London UK Misconduct in Research Who is Responsible for What (PPT - 111 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Dr Paul CARO Acadeacutemie des Technologies Paris France
Science and the Show Society (PPT - 69 KB)
Dr Paul DAVID University of Oxford Empirical Realities of PDF (41
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 13
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
amp Dr Andrea POZZI
Oxford Internet Institute UK amp Stanford University Landau Economics Centre USA
Scientific Misconduct in Publicly Funded Research What Can We Learn from the ORIs Investigations in of US Cases in the Biomedical and Behavioral Sciences (PDF - 648 KB)
KB)
Dr Vladimir DE SEMIR
Universitat Pompeu Fabra Journalism and Audiovisual Communication Department Barcelona ES
Research Integrity amp Knowledge Society R+D+i is not enough (PDF - 243 MB)
Dr Amaboo DHAI
University of the Witwatersrand Medical School Steve Biko Centre for Bioethics Parktown South Africa
Preserving Protecting amp Improving Research Integrity in Africa Challenges and Recommendations (PPT - 6 MB)
Word (short biography) (29 KB) - Word (long version) (118 KB)
Dr Pieter DRENTH
All European Academies (ALLEA) Amsterdam The Netherlands
Strengths and Weaknesses of Currrent Policies and Practices (PPT - 116 KB)
Word (36 KB)
Prof Ayse ERZAN
Istanbul Technical University Faculty of Sciences and Letters Turkey
Developing and Applying Integrity Policies in a Global Context (PPT - 102 KB)
Word (KB)
Prof Michael FARTHING
University of London UK Institutional Perspectives on Integrity of Publication (PPT - 702 KB)
Prof Carlos FIOLHAIS
University of Coimbra Portugal
- Scientific Integrity and Scientific Culture Telling the Truth to the Public (PPT- 20 MB)- Extended Abstract (Word - 42 KB)
Word (26 KB)
Dr Peggy FISCHER
National Science Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Investigating Research Misconduct Across International Borders Principles and Practices (PPT - 233 KB)
Word (24 KB)
Ms Annette FLANAGIN amp Dr Muza
JAMA Journal of the American Medical Association Chicago USA
African Journal Partnership Project (PPT - 560 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 14
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
GONDWE amp University of Malawi College of Medicine Blantyre Malawi
Prof William GARDNER
The Ohio State University Columbus USA
Research Misconduct International Cooperation (PPT - 297 KB)
Prof Herbert GOTTWEIS
University of Vienna Institut fuumlr Politikwissenschaft Austria
Hwang-gate Lessons for Science Governance (PDF - 12 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Chris GRAF Wiley-Blackwell Oxford UK
What are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics (PPT - 13 MB)
Mr Angel GURRIA
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
Remarks
Prof Ian HALLIDAY
European Science Foundation Strasbourg France
Integrating Responsibility The Research Student Perspective (PPT - 170 KB)
Mr Joel HASSE FERREIRA
European Parliament Brussels Belgium
Public Policies and Strategies Fostering Research Integrity (Word - 28 KB)
Dr Elizabeth HEITMAN
Vanderbilt University Medical Center Nashville USA
The Need for Global Strategies for Training Students in RCR (PPT - 101 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Manuel HEITOR
Portuguese Ministry for Science Technology and Higher Education (MCTES) Lisbon Portugal
- Do We Need a Revisited Policy Agenda for Research IntegrityAn Institutional Perspective (PDF - 98 KB)- Concluding Remarks (PDF - 32 KB)
PDF (187 KB)
Prof Helena ILLNEROVA
Academy of Sciences Prague Czech Republic
Trust in Research and the Importance of Training (Word - 43 KB)
Word (28 KB)
Prof Matthias KAISER
The National Committee for Research Ethics in Science and Technology (NENT) Oslo Norway
International Cooperation to Foster Research Integrity Reflections on Actors and Instruments (PPT - 21 MB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 15
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Dr Katrina KELNER
Science Magazine Washington USA
Science s Efforts to Ensure Research Integrity (PPT - 250 KB)
Word (22 KB)
Dr Sabine KLEINERT
The Lancet London UK How Can Good Publication Standards Influence Research Integrity Part1 (PPT - 47 MB) amp Part2 (PPT - 73 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Anthony KOMAROFF
Harvard Medical School Boston USA
Problems Undermining Public Confidence in and Understanding Research (PPT - 81 KB)
Word (32 KB)
Dr Philip LANGLAIS
Old Dominion University Norfolk USA
Institutional and Societal Issues Educating for Responsible Research (PPT - 235 KB)
Dr Nigel LLOYD
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Canada (NSERC) Ottawa Canada
Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct (PPT - 36 KB)
Word (57 KB)
Dr Joao LOBO ANTUNES
Hospital de Santa Maria Serviccedilo de Neurocirurgia Lisboa Portugal
To Publish or Not To Publish Communicating Science in a New Global and Financial Environment (PPT - 60 MB)
Professor Fernando LOPES DA SILVA
University van Amsterdam The Netherlands
Integrity in Biomedical Research The Role of Education (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Brian MARTINSON
HealthPartners Research Foundation (HPRF) Minneapolis USA
Research Integrity and the Social and Psychological Environments of Science (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Ana MARUSIC
Zagreb University School of Medicine Croatia
Why are scientific journals small or large important in fostering research integrity (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Shamila NAIR-BEDOUELLE
UNESCO Paris France COMESTs Role in Fostering Integrity in Research (PPT - 531 KB)
Prof Paumlr Vetenskapsraringdet (Swedish Closing Remarks (PPT - 23
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 16
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
The Danish Committee on scientific dishonesty Danish Agency for science technology and innovation annual report 2006 november 2007 (httpfidksiteenglishpublicationspublications-2007annual-report-2006-the-danish-committees-on-scientific-dishoFIST_GB_wwwpdf)
Good scientific practice in research and scholarship European science foundation policy briefing 2000
Colloques et confeacuterences Lisbon first world conference on science integrity An action-oriented approach
Contributions from Pieter Drenth Stefan Michalowski Frederic Sgard Ovid Tzeng Drsquoune faccedilon geacuteneacuterale les contributions agrave la Confeacuterence de Lisbonne sur lrsquointeacutegriteacute
scientifique se trouvent agrave httpwwwesforgactivitiesesf-conferencesdetailsarchives2007confdetail242html
Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat logiciel Tetralogie Ce logiciel qui est un outil de veille (strateacutegique
concurrentielle) qui permet de faire des comparaisons afin de deacutetecter des plagiats (lthttpatlasiritfrgt)
Logiciel grenoble
Source site ESf
RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHReferences amp Background Reading
NATURE Volume 451 Number 7181 - 21 February 2008
- Pakistan needs a powerful ethics and integrity body (Nature 451 887 - Correspondence - Muhammad Mukhtar amp Zahida Parve)
Volume 451 Number 7179 - 7 February 2008- No conflict of interest in misconduct case says lab (Nature 451 618-619 - News)
Volume 451 Number 7177 - 24 January 2008- A tale of two citations (Nature 451 397-399 - Commentary - Mounir Errami amp Harold Garner)
Volume 450 Number 7170 - 29 November 2007- Loopholes in oversight rules revealed US energy department criticized over procedure for misconduct investigations (Nature 450 590 - News - Eugenie Samuel Reich)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 4
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
- Each co-author should sign to reduce risk of fraud (Nature 450 610 - Correspondence - Kevin Yager)
Volume 450 Number 7169 - 22 November 2007- Replicator Review Nature has implemented a peer-review policy for strong claims (Nature 450 457-458 - Editorial)- Stem-cell Researcher accused of Negligence (Nature 450 470- News)
Volume 450 Number 7166 - 1 November 2007- Who is accountable How the responsibilities of co-authors for a scientific papers integrity could be made more explicit (Nature 450 1 - Editorial)
Volume 449 Number 7161 - 27 September 2007- Stem-cell Fraudster is working in Thailand Woo Suk Hwang may be back in the cloning lab (Nature 449 387 - News - David Cyranoski)
Volume 448 Number 7154 - 9 August 2007- Academic Accused of Living on Borrowed Lines Allegations prompt Fears over Prevalence of Plagiarism (Nature 448 623-726 - News - Alison Abbott)
Volume 447 Number 7146 - 14 June 2007- Indian Scientists battle Journal Retraction (Nature 447 753-884 - News - KS Jayaraman)
Volume 447 Number 7142 - 17 May 2007- Purdue dogged by misconduct claims Third inquiry into bubble fusion is underway (Nature 447 238-239 - News - Eugenie Samuel Reich)- Recognition could support a science code of conduct (Nature 447 259 - Correspondence - Yan Ropert-Coudert)- Modellers seek reason for low attraction rate (Nature 447 236-237- News - Declan Butler amp Jenny Hogan)Volume 447 Number 7140 - 3 May 2007- Share your lab notes The use of electronic laboratory notebooks should be supported by all concerned (Nature 447 1 - Editorial)
Volume 446 Number 7135 - 29 March 2007- Confidentiality is essential in misconduct inquiries (Nature 446 492 - Correspondence - Sally Mason amp Charles Rutledge)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 5
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 446 Number 7133 - 15 March 2007- Geophysicist faces probe into use of research funds Co-founder of European Academy of Sciences comes under scrutiny (Nature 446 236 - News - Jim Giles)
Volume 445 Number 7129 - 15 February 2007- Methods in Full From now on Nature authors will be able to include more experimental details in their papers (Nature 445 684 - Editorials)
Volume 445 Number 7126 - 25 January 2007- Journals should set a new standard in transparency (Nature 445 364 - Correspondence - Robert P Dellavalle Kristy Lundahl Scott R Freeman and Lisa M Schilling)
Volume 445 Number 7125 - 18 January 2007- Leading by example The primary safeguard against scientific misconduct is the example set every day by thousands of senior researchers in the laboratory (Nature 445 229 - Editorials)- Misconduct Itrsquos all academic (Nature 445 240-241 - News - Geoff Brumfiel)- Breeding cheats (Nature 445 242-243 - News - Jim Giles)- Where are they now (Nature 445 244-245 - News - Lucy Odling-Smee Jim Giles Ichiko Fuyuno David Cyranoski and Emma Marris)
Volume 444 Number 7122 - 21 December 2006- Peer review and fraud Two assessments of the refereeing process highlight challenges for journals (Nature 444 971-972 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7121 - 14 December 2006- The elephant in the room A biotech trial that went awry (Nature 444 790 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7120 - 7 December 2006- Journal reveals plans to fight fraud Science to select papers for extra-secure review process (Nature 444 658-659 - News - Meredith Wadman)- Purdue attacked over fusion inquiry Physicists angry at apparent inertia in misconduct investigation (Nature 444 664-665 - News - Eugenie Samuel Reich)- A fair share The concept of sharing primary data is
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 6
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
generating unnecessary angst in the psychology community (Nature 444 653-654 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7116 -- 9 November 2006- Correction or retraction Errors reported in this issue by authors of a Nature paper pose a dilemma about trust (Nature 444 123-124 - Editorials)
Volume 443 Number 7108 - 14 September 2006- Whistleblowers in peril The US Congress should reverse a pernicious removal of protection of federal employees (Nature 443 121 - Editorials)
Volume 442 Number 7099 - 13 July 2006- Misconduct forum should not be used to settle sc ores (Nature 442 132 - Correspondence - Guosheng Wu)- Misconduct China needs university ethics courses (Nature 442 132 - Correspondence - Qizhi Wang)
Volume 441 Number 7096 - 22 June 2006- Misconduct lack of action provokes web accusations (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Shi-min Fang)- Misconduct exposure is not like Cultural Revolution (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Zheng Huang)- Misconduct Chinese funding body unmoved (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Ushma Savla Neill)
Volume 441 Number 7093 - 1 June 2006- Finding fraud in China As Chinese research expands who is looking out for faked results (Nature 441 549-550 - Editorials)
Volume 441 Number 7092 - 25 May 2006- Named and shamed As accusations of scientific misconduct in China become rife some fear persecution reminiscent of that used in the Cultural Revolution (Nature 441 392-393 - News - David Cyranoski)
Volume 435 Number 7043 - 9 June 2005- One in three scientists confesses to having sinned Misconduct ranges from faking results outright to dropping suspect data points (Nature 435 718-719 - News - Meredith Wadman)- Scientists behaving badly (Nature 435 737-738 - Commentary - Brian C Martinson Melissa S Anderson amp Raymond de Vries)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 7
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
NATURE In the Field
17 September 2007 Integrity - Zero Tolerance in Portugal (Sarah Tomlin)
NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY Volume 24 Number 2 - 2 February 2006
South Korean policy failure and the Hwang debacle (Nature Biotechnology 24 141-143 - Commentary - Herbert Gottweis amp Robert Triendl)
SCIENCE Volume 316 Issue 5832 - 22 June 2007
- Scientific Publishing Osaka University Researchers reject Demand to Retract Science Paper (p 1681 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 316 Issue 5827 - 18 May 2007- Research Integrity Sonofusion Back on the Firing Line as Misconduct Probe Reopens (p 964 - News of the Week - Robert F Service)
Volume 315 Issue 5819 - 23 March 2007- Open Government House OKs Whistleblower Bill (p 1649 - News of the Week - Eli Kintisch)
Volume 315 Issue 5814 - 16 February 2007- Research Integrity Bubble Fusion Researcher Cleared of Misconduct Charges but Doubts Linger (p 921 - News of the Week - Robert F Service)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 8
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 315 Issue 5810 - 19 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Former Hwang Colleague Faked Monkey Datas US Says (p 317 - News of the Week - Constance Holden)
Volume 315 Issue 5808 - 5 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Japanrsquos Universities Take Action (p 26 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 314 Issue 5806 - 15 December 2006- Scientific Misconduct Online Sleuths Challenge Cell Paper (p 1669 - News of the Week - Hao Xin)
Volume 314 Issue 5804 - 1 December 2006- Developmental Biology Fraud Investigation Clouds Paper on Early Cell Fate (pp 1367-1369 - News of the Week - Gretchen Vogel)- Scientific Misconduct Chinarsquos Fraud Buster Hit by Libel Judgments Defenders Rally Round (pp 1366-1367 - News of the Week - Jia Hepeng and Hao Xin)- Responding to Fraud (pp 1353 - Editorial - Donald Kennedy) (+ Supporting On-line Material)
Volume 312 Issue 5779 - 9 June 2006- Scientific Misconduct Scandals Shake Chinese Science (pp 1464-1466 - News Focus - Hao Xin)- Scientific Misconduct Crime Scene Investigation How to Handle Misconduct (p 1465 - News Focus - Eliot Marshall)
Volume 85 Issue 07 - 12 February 2007- Re search Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three Japanese cases conclude (pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
Volume 84 Issue 45 - 6 November 2006- Research Misconduct Federal agencies handle fabrication falsification and plagiarism allegations differently but all take claims seriously (pp 18-22 - Susan Morrissey)
BMJ
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 9
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 335 Ndeg 7619 - 15 September 2007Dealing with Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 524525 - Xavier Bosch)
Volume 334 Ndeg 7590 - 24 February 2007- Managing Suspected Research Misconduct (Editorials - pp 378-379 - Charles Young amp Fiona Godlee)- Research Ethics Doubts over Head Injury Studies (Feature - pp 392-394 - Ian Roberts Richard Smith amp Stephen Evans)
Volume 331 Ndeg 7511 - 30 July 2005Investigating Allegations of Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 245-246 - Jane Smith amp Fiona Godlee)
RESEARCH POLICY Volume 36 Issue 7 September 2007
Keeping Plagiarism at Bay A Salutary Tale (Editorial - p 905-311 - Ben R Martin amp Other Editors of Research Policy)
IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY Volume 25 Ndeg2 - MarchApril 2006
Spring Cleaning and Ethics in our Backyard (From the Editor - pp 4-5 - John Enderle)
THE LANCET
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 10
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 370 Ndeg9596 - 20 October 2007Research Integrity Collaboration and Research needed (Comment - p 1403-1404 - Erik von Elm)
CELL Volume 131 - 5 October 2007
Seeking an International Dialogue on Research Integrity (p 9-11 - Christie Aschwanden)
SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS 27 September 2007
A Qualitative Approach to Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR) Training Development Identification of Metacognitive Strategies (Vykinta Kligyte Richard T Marcy Sydney T Sevier Elaine S Godfrey and Michael D Mumford)
CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS Volume 85 Ndeg7 - 12 February 2007
Research Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 11
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Japanese cases conclude (Science amp Technology - pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
Vol 16 no 1 December 2007 issue PDF (52 KB)Among the articles in this issue are registration opens for the first biennial RCR conference RCR award given to the Council of Graduate Schools postdoc training funded at 12 institutions 2007 Annual Report due by March 1 2008 Global Science Forum develops steps to lessen research misconduct first World Conference report recommends actions to meet crucial needs innovative RCR resources to be available on-line in spring 2008
BOOKS Integrity in Scientific Research Creating an Environment that Promotes
Responsible ConductCommittee on Assessing Integrity in Research Environments National Research Council Institute of MedicineNational Academies Press 2002 - ISBN 0309084792
Introduction to the Responsible Conduct of ResearchNicholas Steneck US Office of Research IntegrityRevised edition 2004 - ISBN 0160722853
The Great Betrayal Fraud in ScienceHorace Freeland JudsonHarcourt 2004 - ISBN 0151008779
Scientific Integrity Text and Cases in responsible Conduct of ResearchFrancis MacrinaASM Press 2005 - ISBN 1555813186
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 12
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHInvited Papers amp BiographiesName Affiliation Lecture Biography
Prof Howard ALPER
University of Ottawa Department of Chemistry Canada
Research Integrity Best Practices for the Benefic of Society (PPT - 41 MB)
Word (37 KB)
Prof Melissa ANDERSON
University of Minnesota Department of Educational Policy and Administration Minneapolis USA
Educating Competent Responsible and Successful Researchers (PPT - 15 KB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Lida ANESTIDOU
The National Academies Institute for Laboratory Animal Research Washington USA
Current Policies and Policy Development (PDF - 393 KB)
Dr Guitelle BAGHDADI-SABETI
World Health Organisation (WHO) Geneva Switzerland
Good Governance for Medicines (PPT - 09 MB)
Word (113 KB)
Prof Ulrike BEISIEGEL
Universitaumltskrankenhaus Hamburg-Eppendorf Germany
Safeguarding Good Scientific Practice (PPT - 81 KB)
Dr Lawrence BELL
Museum of Science Boston USA
Who Do You Trust Science Museums as Forums for Conversations between Scientists and the Public (PDF - 23 MB)
PDF (302 KB)
Dr Christine BOESZ
US National Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Legal Aspects of Investigation amp International Cooperation (PPT - 79 KB)
Dr Philip CAMPBELL
Nature London UK Misconduct in Research Who is Responsible for What (PPT - 111 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Dr Paul CARO Acadeacutemie des Technologies Paris France
Science and the Show Society (PPT - 69 KB)
Dr Paul DAVID University of Oxford Empirical Realities of PDF (41
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 13
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
amp Dr Andrea POZZI
Oxford Internet Institute UK amp Stanford University Landau Economics Centre USA
Scientific Misconduct in Publicly Funded Research What Can We Learn from the ORIs Investigations in of US Cases in the Biomedical and Behavioral Sciences (PDF - 648 KB)
KB)
Dr Vladimir DE SEMIR
Universitat Pompeu Fabra Journalism and Audiovisual Communication Department Barcelona ES
Research Integrity amp Knowledge Society R+D+i is not enough (PDF - 243 MB)
Dr Amaboo DHAI
University of the Witwatersrand Medical School Steve Biko Centre for Bioethics Parktown South Africa
Preserving Protecting amp Improving Research Integrity in Africa Challenges and Recommendations (PPT - 6 MB)
Word (short biography) (29 KB) - Word (long version) (118 KB)
Dr Pieter DRENTH
All European Academies (ALLEA) Amsterdam The Netherlands
Strengths and Weaknesses of Currrent Policies and Practices (PPT - 116 KB)
Word (36 KB)
Prof Ayse ERZAN
Istanbul Technical University Faculty of Sciences and Letters Turkey
Developing and Applying Integrity Policies in a Global Context (PPT - 102 KB)
Word (KB)
Prof Michael FARTHING
University of London UK Institutional Perspectives on Integrity of Publication (PPT - 702 KB)
Prof Carlos FIOLHAIS
University of Coimbra Portugal
- Scientific Integrity and Scientific Culture Telling the Truth to the Public (PPT- 20 MB)- Extended Abstract (Word - 42 KB)
Word (26 KB)
Dr Peggy FISCHER
National Science Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Investigating Research Misconduct Across International Borders Principles and Practices (PPT - 233 KB)
Word (24 KB)
Ms Annette FLANAGIN amp Dr Muza
JAMA Journal of the American Medical Association Chicago USA
African Journal Partnership Project (PPT - 560 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 14
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
GONDWE amp University of Malawi College of Medicine Blantyre Malawi
Prof William GARDNER
The Ohio State University Columbus USA
Research Misconduct International Cooperation (PPT - 297 KB)
Prof Herbert GOTTWEIS
University of Vienna Institut fuumlr Politikwissenschaft Austria
Hwang-gate Lessons for Science Governance (PDF - 12 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Chris GRAF Wiley-Blackwell Oxford UK
What are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics (PPT - 13 MB)
Mr Angel GURRIA
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
Remarks
Prof Ian HALLIDAY
European Science Foundation Strasbourg France
Integrating Responsibility The Research Student Perspective (PPT - 170 KB)
Mr Joel HASSE FERREIRA
European Parliament Brussels Belgium
Public Policies and Strategies Fostering Research Integrity (Word - 28 KB)
Dr Elizabeth HEITMAN
Vanderbilt University Medical Center Nashville USA
The Need for Global Strategies for Training Students in RCR (PPT - 101 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Manuel HEITOR
Portuguese Ministry for Science Technology and Higher Education (MCTES) Lisbon Portugal
- Do We Need a Revisited Policy Agenda for Research IntegrityAn Institutional Perspective (PDF - 98 KB)- Concluding Remarks (PDF - 32 KB)
PDF (187 KB)
Prof Helena ILLNEROVA
Academy of Sciences Prague Czech Republic
Trust in Research and the Importance of Training (Word - 43 KB)
Word (28 KB)
Prof Matthias KAISER
The National Committee for Research Ethics in Science and Technology (NENT) Oslo Norway
International Cooperation to Foster Research Integrity Reflections on Actors and Instruments (PPT - 21 MB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 15
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Dr Katrina KELNER
Science Magazine Washington USA
Science s Efforts to Ensure Research Integrity (PPT - 250 KB)
Word (22 KB)
Dr Sabine KLEINERT
The Lancet London UK How Can Good Publication Standards Influence Research Integrity Part1 (PPT - 47 MB) amp Part2 (PPT - 73 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Anthony KOMAROFF
Harvard Medical School Boston USA
Problems Undermining Public Confidence in and Understanding Research (PPT - 81 KB)
Word (32 KB)
Dr Philip LANGLAIS
Old Dominion University Norfolk USA
Institutional and Societal Issues Educating for Responsible Research (PPT - 235 KB)
Dr Nigel LLOYD
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Canada (NSERC) Ottawa Canada
Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct (PPT - 36 KB)
Word (57 KB)
Dr Joao LOBO ANTUNES
Hospital de Santa Maria Serviccedilo de Neurocirurgia Lisboa Portugal
To Publish or Not To Publish Communicating Science in a New Global and Financial Environment (PPT - 60 MB)
Professor Fernando LOPES DA SILVA
University van Amsterdam The Netherlands
Integrity in Biomedical Research The Role of Education (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Brian MARTINSON
HealthPartners Research Foundation (HPRF) Minneapolis USA
Research Integrity and the Social and Psychological Environments of Science (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Ana MARUSIC
Zagreb University School of Medicine Croatia
Why are scientific journals small or large important in fostering research integrity (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Shamila NAIR-BEDOUELLE
UNESCO Paris France COMESTs Role in Fostering Integrity in Research (PPT - 531 KB)
Prof Paumlr Vetenskapsraringdet (Swedish Closing Remarks (PPT - 23
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 16
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
- Each co-author should sign to reduce risk of fraud (Nature 450 610 - Correspondence - Kevin Yager)
Volume 450 Number 7169 - 22 November 2007- Replicator Review Nature has implemented a peer-review policy for strong claims (Nature 450 457-458 - Editorial)- Stem-cell Researcher accused of Negligence (Nature 450 470- News)
Volume 450 Number 7166 - 1 November 2007- Who is accountable How the responsibilities of co-authors for a scientific papers integrity could be made more explicit (Nature 450 1 - Editorial)
Volume 449 Number 7161 - 27 September 2007- Stem-cell Fraudster is working in Thailand Woo Suk Hwang may be back in the cloning lab (Nature 449 387 - News - David Cyranoski)
Volume 448 Number 7154 - 9 August 2007- Academic Accused of Living on Borrowed Lines Allegations prompt Fears over Prevalence of Plagiarism (Nature 448 623-726 - News - Alison Abbott)
Volume 447 Number 7146 - 14 June 2007- Indian Scientists battle Journal Retraction (Nature 447 753-884 - News - KS Jayaraman)
Volume 447 Number 7142 - 17 May 2007- Purdue dogged by misconduct claims Third inquiry into bubble fusion is underway (Nature 447 238-239 - News - Eugenie Samuel Reich)- Recognition could support a science code of conduct (Nature 447 259 - Correspondence - Yan Ropert-Coudert)- Modellers seek reason for low attraction rate (Nature 447 236-237- News - Declan Butler amp Jenny Hogan)Volume 447 Number 7140 - 3 May 2007- Share your lab notes The use of electronic laboratory notebooks should be supported by all concerned (Nature 447 1 - Editorial)
Volume 446 Number 7135 - 29 March 2007- Confidentiality is essential in misconduct inquiries (Nature 446 492 - Correspondence - Sally Mason amp Charles Rutledge)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 5
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 446 Number 7133 - 15 March 2007- Geophysicist faces probe into use of research funds Co-founder of European Academy of Sciences comes under scrutiny (Nature 446 236 - News - Jim Giles)
Volume 445 Number 7129 - 15 February 2007- Methods in Full From now on Nature authors will be able to include more experimental details in their papers (Nature 445 684 - Editorials)
Volume 445 Number 7126 - 25 January 2007- Journals should set a new standard in transparency (Nature 445 364 - Correspondence - Robert P Dellavalle Kristy Lundahl Scott R Freeman and Lisa M Schilling)
Volume 445 Number 7125 - 18 January 2007- Leading by example The primary safeguard against scientific misconduct is the example set every day by thousands of senior researchers in the laboratory (Nature 445 229 - Editorials)- Misconduct Itrsquos all academic (Nature 445 240-241 - News - Geoff Brumfiel)- Breeding cheats (Nature 445 242-243 - News - Jim Giles)- Where are they now (Nature 445 244-245 - News - Lucy Odling-Smee Jim Giles Ichiko Fuyuno David Cyranoski and Emma Marris)
Volume 444 Number 7122 - 21 December 2006- Peer review and fraud Two assessments of the refereeing process highlight challenges for journals (Nature 444 971-972 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7121 - 14 December 2006- The elephant in the room A biotech trial that went awry (Nature 444 790 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7120 - 7 December 2006- Journal reveals plans to fight fraud Science to select papers for extra-secure review process (Nature 444 658-659 - News - Meredith Wadman)- Purdue attacked over fusion inquiry Physicists angry at apparent inertia in misconduct investigation (Nature 444 664-665 - News - Eugenie Samuel Reich)- A fair share The concept of sharing primary data is
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 6
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
generating unnecessary angst in the psychology community (Nature 444 653-654 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7116 -- 9 November 2006- Correction or retraction Errors reported in this issue by authors of a Nature paper pose a dilemma about trust (Nature 444 123-124 - Editorials)
Volume 443 Number 7108 - 14 September 2006- Whistleblowers in peril The US Congress should reverse a pernicious removal of protection of federal employees (Nature 443 121 - Editorials)
Volume 442 Number 7099 - 13 July 2006- Misconduct forum should not be used to settle sc ores (Nature 442 132 - Correspondence - Guosheng Wu)- Misconduct China needs university ethics courses (Nature 442 132 - Correspondence - Qizhi Wang)
Volume 441 Number 7096 - 22 June 2006- Misconduct lack of action provokes web accusations (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Shi-min Fang)- Misconduct exposure is not like Cultural Revolution (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Zheng Huang)- Misconduct Chinese funding body unmoved (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Ushma Savla Neill)
Volume 441 Number 7093 - 1 June 2006- Finding fraud in China As Chinese research expands who is looking out for faked results (Nature 441 549-550 - Editorials)
Volume 441 Number 7092 - 25 May 2006- Named and shamed As accusations of scientific misconduct in China become rife some fear persecution reminiscent of that used in the Cultural Revolution (Nature 441 392-393 - News - David Cyranoski)
Volume 435 Number 7043 - 9 June 2005- One in three scientists confesses to having sinned Misconduct ranges from faking results outright to dropping suspect data points (Nature 435 718-719 - News - Meredith Wadman)- Scientists behaving badly (Nature 435 737-738 - Commentary - Brian C Martinson Melissa S Anderson amp Raymond de Vries)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 7
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
NATURE In the Field
17 September 2007 Integrity - Zero Tolerance in Portugal (Sarah Tomlin)
NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY Volume 24 Number 2 - 2 February 2006
South Korean policy failure and the Hwang debacle (Nature Biotechnology 24 141-143 - Commentary - Herbert Gottweis amp Robert Triendl)
SCIENCE Volume 316 Issue 5832 - 22 June 2007
- Scientific Publishing Osaka University Researchers reject Demand to Retract Science Paper (p 1681 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 316 Issue 5827 - 18 May 2007- Research Integrity Sonofusion Back on the Firing Line as Misconduct Probe Reopens (p 964 - News of the Week - Robert F Service)
Volume 315 Issue 5819 - 23 March 2007- Open Government House OKs Whistleblower Bill (p 1649 - News of the Week - Eli Kintisch)
Volume 315 Issue 5814 - 16 February 2007- Research Integrity Bubble Fusion Researcher Cleared of Misconduct Charges but Doubts Linger (p 921 - News of the Week - Robert F Service)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 8
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 315 Issue 5810 - 19 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Former Hwang Colleague Faked Monkey Datas US Says (p 317 - News of the Week - Constance Holden)
Volume 315 Issue 5808 - 5 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Japanrsquos Universities Take Action (p 26 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 314 Issue 5806 - 15 December 2006- Scientific Misconduct Online Sleuths Challenge Cell Paper (p 1669 - News of the Week - Hao Xin)
Volume 314 Issue 5804 - 1 December 2006- Developmental Biology Fraud Investigation Clouds Paper on Early Cell Fate (pp 1367-1369 - News of the Week - Gretchen Vogel)- Scientific Misconduct Chinarsquos Fraud Buster Hit by Libel Judgments Defenders Rally Round (pp 1366-1367 - News of the Week - Jia Hepeng and Hao Xin)- Responding to Fraud (pp 1353 - Editorial - Donald Kennedy) (+ Supporting On-line Material)
Volume 312 Issue 5779 - 9 June 2006- Scientific Misconduct Scandals Shake Chinese Science (pp 1464-1466 - News Focus - Hao Xin)- Scientific Misconduct Crime Scene Investigation How to Handle Misconduct (p 1465 - News Focus - Eliot Marshall)
Volume 85 Issue 07 - 12 February 2007- Re search Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three Japanese cases conclude (pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
Volume 84 Issue 45 - 6 November 2006- Research Misconduct Federal agencies handle fabrication falsification and plagiarism allegations differently but all take claims seriously (pp 18-22 - Susan Morrissey)
BMJ
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 9
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 335 Ndeg 7619 - 15 September 2007Dealing with Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 524525 - Xavier Bosch)
Volume 334 Ndeg 7590 - 24 February 2007- Managing Suspected Research Misconduct (Editorials - pp 378-379 - Charles Young amp Fiona Godlee)- Research Ethics Doubts over Head Injury Studies (Feature - pp 392-394 - Ian Roberts Richard Smith amp Stephen Evans)
Volume 331 Ndeg 7511 - 30 July 2005Investigating Allegations of Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 245-246 - Jane Smith amp Fiona Godlee)
RESEARCH POLICY Volume 36 Issue 7 September 2007
Keeping Plagiarism at Bay A Salutary Tale (Editorial - p 905-311 - Ben R Martin amp Other Editors of Research Policy)
IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY Volume 25 Ndeg2 - MarchApril 2006
Spring Cleaning and Ethics in our Backyard (From the Editor - pp 4-5 - John Enderle)
THE LANCET
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 10
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 370 Ndeg9596 - 20 October 2007Research Integrity Collaboration and Research needed (Comment - p 1403-1404 - Erik von Elm)
CELL Volume 131 - 5 October 2007
Seeking an International Dialogue on Research Integrity (p 9-11 - Christie Aschwanden)
SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS 27 September 2007
A Qualitative Approach to Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR) Training Development Identification of Metacognitive Strategies (Vykinta Kligyte Richard T Marcy Sydney T Sevier Elaine S Godfrey and Michael D Mumford)
CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS Volume 85 Ndeg7 - 12 February 2007
Research Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 11
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Japanese cases conclude (Science amp Technology - pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
Vol 16 no 1 December 2007 issue PDF (52 KB)Among the articles in this issue are registration opens for the first biennial RCR conference RCR award given to the Council of Graduate Schools postdoc training funded at 12 institutions 2007 Annual Report due by March 1 2008 Global Science Forum develops steps to lessen research misconduct first World Conference report recommends actions to meet crucial needs innovative RCR resources to be available on-line in spring 2008
BOOKS Integrity in Scientific Research Creating an Environment that Promotes
Responsible ConductCommittee on Assessing Integrity in Research Environments National Research Council Institute of MedicineNational Academies Press 2002 - ISBN 0309084792
Introduction to the Responsible Conduct of ResearchNicholas Steneck US Office of Research IntegrityRevised edition 2004 - ISBN 0160722853
The Great Betrayal Fraud in ScienceHorace Freeland JudsonHarcourt 2004 - ISBN 0151008779
Scientific Integrity Text and Cases in responsible Conduct of ResearchFrancis MacrinaASM Press 2005 - ISBN 1555813186
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 12
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHInvited Papers amp BiographiesName Affiliation Lecture Biography
Prof Howard ALPER
University of Ottawa Department of Chemistry Canada
Research Integrity Best Practices for the Benefic of Society (PPT - 41 MB)
Word (37 KB)
Prof Melissa ANDERSON
University of Minnesota Department of Educational Policy and Administration Minneapolis USA
Educating Competent Responsible and Successful Researchers (PPT - 15 KB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Lida ANESTIDOU
The National Academies Institute for Laboratory Animal Research Washington USA
Current Policies and Policy Development (PDF - 393 KB)
Dr Guitelle BAGHDADI-SABETI
World Health Organisation (WHO) Geneva Switzerland
Good Governance for Medicines (PPT - 09 MB)
Word (113 KB)
Prof Ulrike BEISIEGEL
Universitaumltskrankenhaus Hamburg-Eppendorf Germany
Safeguarding Good Scientific Practice (PPT - 81 KB)
Dr Lawrence BELL
Museum of Science Boston USA
Who Do You Trust Science Museums as Forums for Conversations between Scientists and the Public (PDF - 23 MB)
PDF (302 KB)
Dr Christine BOESZ
US National Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Legal Aspects of Investigation amp International Cooperation (PPT - 79 KB)
Dr Philip CAMPBELL
Nature London UK Misconduct in Research Who is Responsible for What (PPT - 111 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Dr Paul CARO Acadeacutemie des Technologies Paris France
Science and the Show Society (PPT - 69 KB)
Dr Paul DAVID University of Oxford Empirical Realities of PDF (41
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 13
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
amp Dr Andrea POZZI
Oxford Internet Institute UK amp Stanford University Landau Economics Centre USA
Scientific Misconduct in Publicly Funded Research What Can We Learn from the ORIs Investigations in of US Cases in the Biomedical and Behavioral Sciences (PDF - 648 KB)
KB)
Dr Vladimir DE SEMIR
Universitat Pompeu Fabra Journalism and Audiovisual Communication Department Barcelona ES
Research Integrity amp Knowledge Society R+D+i is not enough (PDF - 243 MB)
Dr Amaboo DHAI
University of the Witwatersrand Medical School Steve Biko Centre for Bioethics Parktown South Africa
Preserving Protecting amp Improving Research Integrity in Africa Challenges and Recommendations (PPT - 6 MB)
Word (short biography) (29 KB) - Word (long version) (118 KB)
Dr Pieter DRENTH
All European Academies (ALLEA) Amsterdam The Netherlands
Strengths and Weaknesses of Currrent Policies and Practices (PPT - 116 KB)
Word (36 KB)
Prof Ayse ERZAN
Istanbul Technical University Faculty of Sciences and Letters Turkey
Developing and Applying Integrity Policies in a Global Context (PPT - 102 KB)
Word (KB)
Prof Michael FARTHING
University of London UK Institutional Perspectives on Integrity of Publication (PPT - 702 KB)
Prof Carlos FIOLHAIS
University of Coimbra Portugal
- Scientific Integrity and Scientific Culture Telling the Truth to the Public (PPT- 20 MB)- Extended Abstract (Word - 42 KB)
Word (26 KB)
Dr Peggy FISCHER
National Science Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Investigating Research Misconduct Across International Borders Principles and Practices (PPT - 233 KB)
Word (24 KB)
Ms Annette FLANAGIN amp Dr Muza
JAMA Journal of the American Medical Association Chicago USA
African Journal Partnership Project (PPT - 560 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 14
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
GONDWE amp University of Malawi College of Medicine Blantyre Malawi
Prof William GARDNER
The Ohio State University Columbus USA
Research Misconduct International Cooperation (PPT - 297 KB)
Prof Herbert GOTTWEIS
University of Vienna Institut fuumlr Politikwissenschaft Austria
Hwang-gate Lessons for Science Governance (PDF - 12 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Chris GRAF Wiley-Blackwell Oxford UK
What are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics (PPT - 13 MB)
Mr Angel GURRIA
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
Remarks
Prof Ian HALLIDAY
European Science Foundation Strasbourg France
Integrating Responsibility The Research Student Perspective (PPT - 170 KB)
Mr Joel HASSE FERREIRA
European Parliament Brussels Belgium
Public Policies and Strategies Fostering Research Integrity (Word - 28 KB)
Dr Elizabeth HEITMAN
Vanderbilt University Medical Center Nashville USA
The Need for Global Strategies for Training Students in RCR (PPT - 101 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Manuel HEITOR
Portuguese Ministry for Science Technology and Higher Education (MCTES) Lisbon Portugal
- Do We Need a Revisited Policy Agenda for Research IntegrityAn Institutional Perspective (PDF - 98 KB)- Concluding Remarks (PDF - 32 KB)
PDF (187 KB)
Prof Helena ILLNEROVA
Academy of Sciences Prague Czech Republic
Trust in Research and the Importance of Training (Word - 43 KB)
Word (28 KB)
Prof Matthias KAISER
The National Committee for Research Ethics in Science and Technology (NENT) Oslo Norway
International Cooperation to Foster Research Integrity Reflections on Actors and Instruments (PPT - 21 MB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 15
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Dr Katrina KELNER
Science Magazine Washington USA
Science s Efforts to Ensure Research Integrity (PPT - 250 KB)
Word (22 KB)
Dr Sabine KLEINERT
The Lancet London UK How Can Good Publication Standards Influence Research Integrity Part1 (PPT - 47 MB) amp Part2 (PPT - 73 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Anthony KOMAROFF
Harvard Medical School Boston USA
Problems Undermining Public Confidence in and Understanding Research (PPT - 81 KB)
Word (32 KB)
Dr Philip LANGLAIS
Old Dominion University Norfolk USA
Institutional and Societal Issues Educating for Responsible Research (PPT - 235 KB)
Dr Nigel LLOYD
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Canada (NSERC) Ottawa Canada
Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct (PPT - 36 KB)
Word (57 KB)
Dr Joao LOBO ANTUNES
Hospital de Santa Maria Serviccedilo de Neurocirurgia Lisboa Portugal
To Publish or Not To Publish Communicating Science in a New Global and Financial Environment (PPT - 60 MB)
Professor Fernando LOPES DA SILVA
University van Amsterdam The Netherlands
Integrity in Biomedical Research The Role of Education (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Brian MARTINSON
HealthPartners Research Foundation (HPRF) Minneapolis USA
Research Integrity and the Social and Psychological Environments of Science (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Ana MARUSIC
Zagreb University School of Medicine Croatia
Why are scientific journals small or large important in fostering research integrity (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Shamila NAIR-BEDOUELLE
UNESCO Paris France COMESTs Role in Fostering Integrity in Research (PPT - 531 KB)
Prof Paumlr Vetenskapsraringdet (Swedish Closing Remarks (PPT - 23
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 16
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 446 Number 7133 - 15 March 2007- Geophysicist faces probe into use of research funds Co-founder of European Academy of Sciences comes under scrutiny (Nature 446 236 - News - Jim Giles)
Volume 445 Number 7129 - 15 February 2007- Methods in Full From now on Nature authors will be able to include more experimental details in their papers (Nature 445 684 - Editorials)
Volume 445 Number 7126 - 25 January 2007- Journals should set a new standard in transparency (Nature 445 364 - Correspondence - Robert P Dellavalle Kristy Lundahl Scott R Freeman and Lisa M Schilling)
Volume 445 Number 7125 - 18 January 2007- Leading by example The primary safeguard against scientific misconduct is the example set every day by thousands of senior researchers in the laboratory (Nature 445 229 - Editorials)- Misconduct Itrsquos all academic (Nature 445 240-241 - News - Geoff Brumfiel)- Breeding cheats (Nature 445 242-243 - News - Jim Giles)- Where are they now (Nature 445 244-245 - News - Lucy Odling-Smee Jim Giles Ichiko Fuyuno David Cyranoski and Emma Marris)
Volume 444 Number 7122 - 21 December 2006- Peer review and fraud Two assessments of the refereeing process highlight challenges for journals (Nature 444 971-972 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7121 - 14 December 2006- The elephant in the room A biotech trial that went awry (Nature 444 790 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7120 - 7 December 2006- Journal reveals plans to fight fraud Science to select papers for extra-secure review process (Nature 444 658-659 - News - Meredith Wadman)- Purdue attacked over fusion inquiry Physicists angry at apparent inertia in misconduct investigation (Nature 444 664-665 - News - Eugenie Samuel Reich)- A fair share The concept of sharing primary data is
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 6
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
generating unnecessary angst in the psychology community (Nature 444 653-654 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7116 -- 9 November 2006- Correction or retraction Errors reported in this issue by authors of a Nature paper pose a dilemma about trust (Nature 444 123-124 - Editorials)
Volume 443 Number 7108 - 14 September 2006- Whistleblowers in peril The US Congress should reverse a pernicious removal of protection of federal employees (Nature 443 121 - Editorials)
Volume 442 Number 7099 - 13 July 2006- Misconduct forum should not be used to settle sc ores (Nature 442 132 - Correspondence - Guosheng Wu)- Misconduct China needs university ethics courses (Nature 442 132 - Correspondence - Qizhi Wang)
Volume 441 Number 7096 - 22 June 2006- Misconduct lack of action provokes web accusations (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Shi-min Fang)- Misconduct exposure is not like Cultural Revolution (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Zheng Huang)- Misconduct Chinese funding body unmoved (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Ushma Savla Neill)
Volume 441 Number 7093 - 1 June 2006- Finding fraud in China As Chinese research expands who is looking out for faked results (Nature 441 549-550 - Editorials)
Volume 441 Number 7092 - 25 May 2006- Named and shamed As accusations of scientific misconduct in China become rife some fear persecution reminiscent of that used in the Cultural Revolution (Nature 441 392-393 - News - David Cyranoski)
Volume 435 Number 7043 - 9 June 2005- One in three scientists confesses to having sinned Misconduct ranges from faking results outright to dropping suspect data points (Nature 435 718-719 - News - Meredith Wadman)- Scientists behaving badly (Nature 435 737-738 - Commentary - Brian C Martinson Melissa S Anderson amp Raymond de Vries)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 7
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
NATURE In the Field
17 September 2007 Integrity - Zero Tolerance in Portugal (Sarah Tomlin)
NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY Volume 24 Number 2 - 2 February 2006
South Korean policy failure and the Hwang debacle (Nature Biotechnology 24 141-143 - Commentary - Herbert Gottweis amp Robert Triendl)
SCIENCE Volume 316 Issue 5832 - 22 June 2007
- Scientific Publishing Osaka University Researchers reject Demand to Retract Science Paper (p 1681 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 316 Issue 5827 - 18 May 2007- Research Integrity Sonofusion Back on the Firing Line as Misconduct Probe Reopens (p 964 - News of the Week - Robert F Service)
Volume 315 Issue 5819 - 23 March 2007- Open Government House OKs Whistleblower Bill (p 1649 - News of the Week - Eli Kintisch)
Volume 315 Issue 5814 - 16 February 2007- Research Integrity Bubble Fusion Researcher Cleared of Misconduct Charges but Doubts Linger (p 921 - News of the Week - Robert F Service)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 8
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 315 Issue 5810 - 19 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Former Hwang Colleague Faked Monkey Datas US Says (p 317 - News of the Week - Constance Holden)
Volume 315 Issue 5808 - 5 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Japanrsquos Universities Take Action (p 26 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 314 Issue 5806 - 15 December 2006- Scientific Misconduct Online Sleuths Challenge Cell Paper (p 1669 - News of the Week - Hao Xin)
Volume 314 Issue 5804 - 1 December 2006- Developmental Biology Fraud Investigation Clouds Paper on Early Cell Fate (pp 1367-1369 - News of the Week - Gretchen Vogel)- Scientific Misconduct Chinarsquos Fraud Buster Hit by Libel Judgments Defenders Rally Round (pp 1366-1367 - News of the Week - Jia Hepeng and Hao Xin)- Responding to Fraud (pp 1353 - Editorial - Donald Kennedy) (+ Supporting On-line Material)
Volume 312 Issue 5779 - 9 June 2006- Scientific Misconduct Scandals Shake Chinese Science (pp 1464-1466 - News Focus - Hao Xin)- Scientific Misconduct Crime Scene Investigation How to Handle Misconduct (p 1465 - News Focus - Eliot Marshall)
Volume 85 Issue 07 - 12 February 2007- Re search Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three Japanese cases conclude (pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
Volume 84 Issue 45 - 6 November 2006- Research Misconduct Federal agencies handle fabrication falsification and plagiarism allegations differently but all take claims seriously (pp 18-22 - Susan Morrissey)
BMJ
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 9
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 335 Ndeg 7619 - 15 September 2007Dealing with Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 524525 - Xavier Bosch)
Volume 334 Ndeg 7590 - 24 February 2007- Managing Suspected Research Misconduct (Editorials - pp 378-379 - Charles Young amp Fiona Godlee)- Research Ethics Doubts over Head Injury Studies (Feature - pp 392-394 - Ian Roberts Richard Smith amp Stephen Evans)
Volume 331 Ndeg 7511 - 30 July 2005Investigating Allegations of Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 245-246 - Jane Smith amp Fiona Godlee)
RESEARCH POLICY Volume 36 Issue 7 September 2007
Keeping Plagiarism at Bay A Salutary Tale (Editorial - p 905-311 - Ben R Martin amp Other Editors of Research Policy)
IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY Volume 25 Ndeg2 - MarchApril 2006
Spring Cleaning and Ethics in our Backyard (From the Editor - pp 4-5 - John Enderle)
THE LANCET
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 10
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 370 Ndeg9596 - 20 October 2007Research Integrity Collaboration and Research needed (Comment - p 1403-1404 - Erik von Elm)
CELL Volume 131 - 5 October 2007
Seeking an International Dialogue on Research Integrity (p 9-11 - Christie Aschwanden)
SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS 27 September 2007
A Qualitative Approach to Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR) Training Development Identification of Metacognitive Strategies (Vykinta Kligyte Richard T Marcy Sydney T Sevier Elaine S Godfrey and Michael D Mumford)
CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS Volume 85 Ndeg7 - 12 February 2007
Research Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 11
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Japanese cases conclude (Science amp Technology - pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
Vol 16 no 1 December 2007 issue PDF (52 KB)Among the articles in this issue are registration opens for the first biennial RCR conference RCR award given to the Council of Graduate Schools postdoc training funded at 12 institutions 2007 Annual Report due by March 1 2008 Global Science Forum develops steps to lessen research misconduct first World Conference report recommends actions to meet crucial needs innovative RCR resources to be available on-line in spring 2008
BOOKS Integrity in Scientific Research Creating an Environment that Promotes
Responsible ConductCommittee on Assessing Integrity in Research Environments National Research Council Institute of MedicineNational Academies Press 2002 - ISBN 0309084792
Introduction to the Responsible Conduct of ResearchNicholas Steneck US Office of Research IntegrityRevised edition 2004 - ISBN 0160722853
The Great Betrayal Fraud in ScienceHorace Freeland JudsonHarcourt 2004 - ISBN 0151008779
Scientific Integrity Text and Cases in responsible Conduct of ResearchFrancis MacrinaASM Press 2005 - ISBN 1555813186
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 12
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHInvited Papers amp BiographiesName Affiliation Lecture Biography
Prof Howard ALPER
University of Ottawa Department of Chemistry Canada
Research Integrity Best Practices for the Benefic of Society (PPT - 41 MB)
Word (37 KB)
Prof Melissa ANDERSON
University of Minnesota Department of Educational Policy and Administration Minneapolis USA
Educating Competent Responsible and Successful Researchers (PPT - 15 KB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Lida ANESTIDOU
The National Academies Institute for Laboratory Animal Research Washington USA
Current Policies and Policy Development (PDF - 393 KB)
Dr Guitelle BAGHDADI-SABETI
World Health Organisation (WHO) Geneva Switzerland
Good Governance for Medicines (PPT - 09 MB)
Word (113 KB)
Prof Ulrike BEISIEGEL
Universitaumltskrankenhaus Hamburg-Eppendorf Germany
Safeguarding Good Scientific Practice (PPT - 81 KB)
Dr Lawrence BELL
Museum of Science Boston USA
Who Do You Trust Science Museums as Forums for Conversations between Scientists and the Public (PDF - 23 MB)
PDF (302 KB)
Dr Christine BOESZ
US National Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Legal Aspects of Investigation amp International Cooperation (PPT - 79 KB)
Dr Philip CAMPBELL
Nature London UK Misconduct in Research Who is Responsible for What (PPT - 111 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Dr Paul CARO Acadeacutemie des Technologies Paris France
Science and the Show Society (PPT - 69 KB)
Dr Paul DAVID University of Oxford Empirical Realities of PDF (41
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 13
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
amp Dr Andrea POZZI
Oxford Internet Institute UK amp Stanford University Landau Economics Centre USA
Scientific Misconduct in Publicly Funded Research What Can We Learn from the ORIs Investigations in of US Cases in the Biomedical and Behavioral Sciences (PDF - 648 KB)
KB)
Dr Vladimir DE SEMIR
Universitat Pompeu Fabra Journalism and Audiovisual Communication Department Barcelona ES
Research Integrity amp Knowledge Society R+D+i is not enough (PDF - 243 MB)
Dr Amaboo DHAI
University of the Witwatersrand Medical School Steve Biko Centre for Bioethics Parktown South Africa
Preserving Protecting amp Improving Research Integrity in Africa Challenges and Recommendations (PPT - 6 MB)
Word (short biography) (29 KB) - Word (long version) (118 KB)
Dr Pieter DRENTH
All European Academies (ALLEA) Amsterdam The Netherlands
Strengths and Weaknesses of Currrent Policies and Practices (PPT - 116 KB)
Word (36 KB)
Prof Ayse ERZAN
Istanbul Technical University Faculty of Sciences and Letters Turkey
Developing and Applying Integrity Policies in a Global Context (PPT - 102 KB)
Word (KB)
Prof Michael FARTHING
University of London UK Institutional Perspectives on Integrity of Publication (PPT - 702 KB)
Prof Carlos FIOLHAIS
University of Coimbra Portugal
- Scientific Integrity and Scientific Culture Telling the Truth to the Public (PPT- 20 MB)- Extended Abstract (Word - 42 KB)
Word (26 KB)
Dr Peggy FISCHER
National Science Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Investigating Research Misconduct Across International Borders Principles and Practices (PPT - 233 KB)
Word (24 KB)
Ms Annette FLANAGIN amp Dr Muza
JAMA Journal of the American Medical Association Chicago USA
African Journal Partnership Project (PPT - 560 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 14
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
GONDWE amp University of Malawi College of Medicine Blantyre Malawi
Prof William GARDNER
The Ohio State University Columbus USA
Research Misconduct International Cooperation (PPT - 297 KB)
Prof Herbert GOTTWEIS
University of Vienna Institut fuumlr Politikwissenschaft Austria
Hwang-gate Lessons for Science Governance (PDF - 12 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Chris GRAF Wiley-Blackwell Oxford UK
What are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics (PPT - 13 MB)
Mr Angel GURRIA
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
Remarks
Prof Ian HALLIDAY
European Science Foundation Strasbourg France
Integrating Responsibility The Research Student Perspective (PPT - 170 KB)
Mr Joel HASSE FERREIRA
European Parliament Brussels Belgium
Public Policies and Strategies Fostering Research Integrity (Word - 28 KB)
Dr Elizabeth HEITMAN
Vanderbilt University Medical Center Nashville USA
The Need for Global Strategies for Training Students in RCR (PPT - 101 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Manuel HEITOR
Portuguese Ministry for Science Technology and Higher Education (MCTES) Lisbon Portugal
- Do We Need a Revisited Policy Agenda for Research IntegrityAn Institutional Perspective (PDF - 98 KB)- Concluding Remarks (PDF - 32 KB)
PDF (187 KB)
Prof Helena ILLNEROVA
Academy of Sciences Prague Czech Republic
Trust in Research and the Importance of Training (Word - 43 KB)
Word (28 KB)
Prof Matthias KAISER
The National Committee for Research Ethics in Science and Technology (NENT) Oslo Norway
International Cooperation to Foster Research Integrity Reflections on Actors and Instruments (PPT - 21 MB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 15
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Dr Katrina KELNER
Science Magazine Washington USA
Science s Efforts to Ensure Research Integrity (PPT - 250 KB)
Word (22 KB)
Dr Sabine KLEINERT
The Lancet London UK How Can Good Publication Standards Influence Research Integrity Part1 (PPT - 47 MB) amp Part2 (PPT - 73 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Anthony KOMAROFF
Harvard Medical School Boston USA
Problems Undermining Public Confidence in and Understanding Research (PPT - 81 KB)
Word (32 KB)
Dr Philip LANGLAIS
Old Dominion University Norfolk USA
Institutional and Societal Issues Educating for Responsible Research (PPT - 235 KB)
Dr Nigel LLOYD
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Canada (NSERC) Ottawa Canada
Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct (PPT - 36 KB)
Word (57 KB)
Dr Joao LOBO ANTUNES
Hospital de Santa Maria Serviccedilo de Neurocirurgia Lisboa Portugal
To Publish or Not To Publish Communicating Science in a New Global and Financial Environment (PPT - 60 MB)
Professor Fernando LOPES DA SILVA
University van Amsterdam The Netherlands
Integrity in Biomedical Research The Role of Education (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Brian MARTINSON
HealthPartners Research Foundation (HPRF) Minneapolis USA
Research Integrity and the Social and Psychological Environments of Science (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Ana MARUSIC
Zagreb University School of Medicine Croatia
Why are scientific journals small or large important in fostering research integrity (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Shamila NAIR-BEDOUELLE
UNESCO Paris France COMESTs Role in Fostering Integrity in Research (PPT - 531 KB)
Prof Paumlr Vetenskapsraringdet (Swedish Closing Remarks (PPT - 23
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 16
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
generating unnecessary angst in the psychology community (Nature 444 653-654 - Editorials)
Volume 444 Number 7116 -- 9 November 2006- Correction or retraction Errors reported in this issue by authors of a Nature paper pose a dilemma about trust (Nature 444 123-124 - Editorials)
Volume 443 Number 7108 - 14 September 2006- Whistleblowers in peril The US Congress should reverse a pernicious removal of protection of federal employees (Nature 443 121 - Editorials)
Volume 442 Number 7099 - 13 July 2006- Misconduct forum should not be used to settle sc ores (Nature 442 132 - Correspondence - Guosheng Wu)- Misconduct China needs university ethics courses (Nature 442 132 - Correspondence - Qizhi Wang)
Volume 441 Number 7096 - 22 June 2006- Misconduct lack of action provokes web accusations (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Shi-min Fang)- Misconduct exposure is not like Cultural Revolution (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Zheng Huang)- Misconduct Chinese funding body unmoved (Nature 441 932 - Correspondence - Ushma Savla Neill)
Volume 441 Number 7093 - 1 June 2006- Finding fraud in China As Chinese research expands who is looking out for faked results (Nature 441 549-550 - Editorials)
Volume 441 Number 7092 - 25 May 2006- Named and shamed As accusations of scientific misconduct in China become rife some fear persecution reminiscent of that used in the Cultural Revolution (Nature 441 392-393 - News - David Cyranoski)
Volume 435 Number 7043 - 9 June 2005- One in three scientists confesses to having sinned Misconduct ranges from faking results outright to dropping suspect data points (Nature 435 718-719 - News - Meredith Wadman)- Scientists behaving badly (Nature 435 737-738 - Commentary - Brian C Martinson Melissa S Anderson amp Raymond de Vries)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 7
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
NATURE In the Field
17 September 2007 Integrity - Zero Tolerance in Portugal (Sarah Tomlin)
NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY Volume 24 Number 2 - 2 February 2006
South Korean policy failure and the Hwang debacle (Nature Biotechnology 24 141-143 - Commentary - Herbert Gottweis amp Robert Triendl)
SCIENCE Volume 316 Issue 5832 - 22 June 2007
- Scientific Publishing Osaka University Researchers reject Demand to Retract Science Paper (p 1681 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 316 Issue 5827 - 18 May 2007- Research Integrity Sonofusion Back on the Firing Line as Misconduct Probe Reopens (p 964 - News of the Week - Robert F Service)
Volume 315 Issue 5819 - 23 March 2007- Open Government House OKs Whistleblower Bill (p 1649 - News of the Week - Eli Kintisch)
Volume 315 Issue 5814 - 16 February 2007- Research Integrity Bubble Fusion Researcher Cleared of Misconduct Charges but Doubts Linger (p 921 - News of the Week - Robert F Service)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 8
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 315 Issue 5810 - 19 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Former Hwang Colleague Faked Monkey Datas US Says (p 317 - News of the Week - Constance Holden)
Volume 315 Issue 5808 - 5 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Japanrsquos Universities Take Action (p 26 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 314 Issue 5806 - 15 December 2006- Scientific Misconduct Online Sleuths Challenge Cell Paper (p 1669 - News of the Week - Hao Xin)
Volume 314 Issue 5804 - 1 December 2006- Developmental Biology Fraud Investigation Clouds Paper on Early Cell Fate (pp 1367-1369 - News of the Week - Gretchen Vogel)- Scientific Misconduct Chinarsquos Fraud Buster Hit by Libel Judgments Defenders Rally Round (pp 1366-1367 - News of the Week - Jia Hepeng and Hao Xin)- Responding to Fraud (pp 1353 - Editorial - Donald Kennedy) (+ Supporting On-line Material)
Volume 312 Issue 5779 - 9 June 2006- Scientific Misconduct Scandals Shake Chinese Science (pp 1464-1466 - News Focus - Hao Xin)- Scientific Misconduct Crime Scene Investigation How to Handle Misconduct (p 1465 - News Focus - Eliot Marshall)
Volume 85 Issue 07 - 12 February 2007- Re search Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three Japanese cases conclude (pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
Volume 84 Issue 45 - 6 November 2006- Research Misconduct Federal agencies handle fabrication falsification and plagiarism allegations differently but all take claims seriously (pp 18-22 - Susan Morrissey)
BMJ
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 9
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 335 Ndeg 7619 - 15 September 2007Dealing with Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 524525 - Xavier Bosch)
Volume 334 Ndeg 7590 - 24 February 2007- Managing Suspected Research Misconduct (Editorials - pp 378-379 - Charles Young amp Fiona Godlee)- Research Ethics Doubts over Head Injury Studies (Feature - pp 392-394 - Ian Roberts Richard Smith amp Stephen Evans)
Volume 331 Ndeg 7511 - 30 July 2005Investigating Allegations of Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 245-246 - Jane Smith amp Fiona Godlee)
RESEARCH POLICY Volume 36 Issue 7 September 2007
Keeping Plagiarism at Bay A Salutary Tale (Editorial - p 905-311 - Ben R Martin amp Other Editors of Research Policy)
IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY Volume 25 Ndeg2 - MarchApril 2006
Spring Cleaning and Ethics in our Backyard (From the Editor - pp 4-5 - John Enderle)
THE LANCET
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 10
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 370 Ndeg9596 - 20 October 2007Research Integrity Collaboration and Research needed (Comment - p 1403-1404 - Erik von Elm)
CELL Volume 131 - 5 October 2007
Seeking an International Dialogue on Research Integrity (p 9-11 - Christie Aschwanden)
SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS 27 September 2007
A Qualitative Approach to Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR) Training Development Identification of Metacognitive Strategies (Vykinta Kligyte Richard T Marcy Sydney T Sevier Elaine S Godfrey and Michael D Mumford)
CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS Volume 85 Ndeg7 - 12 February 2007
Research Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 11
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Japanese cases conclude (Science amp Technology - pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
Vol 16 no 1 December 2007 issue PDF (52 KB)Among the articles in this issue are registration opens for the first biennial RCR conference RCR award given to the Council of Graduate Schools postdoc training funded at 12 institutions 2007 Annual Report due by March 1 2008 Global Science Forum develops steps to lessen research misconduct first World Conference report recommends actions to meet crucial needs innovative RCR resources to be available on-line in spring 2008
BOOKS Integrity in Scientific Research Creating an Environment that Promotes
Responsible ConductCommittee on Assessing Integrity in Research Environments National Research Council Institute of MedicineNational Academies Press 2002 - ISBN 0309084792
Introduction to the Responsible Conduct of ResearchNicholas Steneck US Office of Research IntegrityRevised edition 2004 - ISBN 0160722853
The Great Betrayal Fraud in ScienceHorace Freeland JudsonHarcourt 2004 - ISBN 0151008779
Scientific Integrity Text and Cases in responsible Conduct of ResearchFrancis MacrinaASM Press 2005 - ISBN 1555813186
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 12
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHInvited Papers amp BiographiesName Affiliation Lecture Biography
Prof Howard ALPER
University of Ottawa Department of Chemistry Canada
Research Integrity Best Practices for the Benefic of Society (PPT - 41 MB)
Word (37 KB)
Prof Melissa ANDERSON
University of Minnesota Department of Educational Policy and Administration Minneapolis USA
Educating Competent Responsible and Successful Researchers (PPT - 15 KB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Lida ANESTIDOU
The National Academies Institute for Laboratory Animal Research Washington USA
Current Policies and Policy Development (PDF - 393 KB)
Dr Guitelle BAGHDADI-SABETI
World Health Organisation (WHO) Geneva Switzerland
Good Governance for Medicines (PPT - 09 MB)
Word (113 KB)
Prof Ulrike BEISIEGEL
Universitaumltskrankenhaus Hamburg-Eppendorf Germany
Safeguarding Good Scientific Practice (PPT - 81 KB)
Dr Lawrence BELL
Museum of Science Boston USA
Who Do You Trust Science Museums as Forums for Conversations between Scientists and the Public (PDF - 23 MB)
PDF (302 KB)
Dr Christine BOESZ
US National Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Legal Aspects of Investigation amp International Cooperation (PPT - 79 KB)
Dr Philip CAMPBELL
Nature London UK Misconduct in Research Who is Responsible for What (PPT - 111 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Dr Paul CARO Acadeacutemie des Technologies Paris France
Science and the Show Society (PPT - 69 KB)
Dr Paul DAVID University of Oxford Empirical Realities of PDF (41
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 13
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
amp Dr Andrea POZZI
Oxford Internet Institute UK amp Stanford University Landau Economics Centre USA
Scientific Misconduct in Publicly Funded Research What Can We Learn from the ORIs Investigations in of US Cases in the Biomedical and Behavioral Sciences (PDF - 648 KB)
KB)
Dr Vladimir DE SEMIR
Universitat Pompeu Fabra Journalism and Audiovisual Communication Department Barcelona ES
Research Integrity amp Knowledge Society R+D+i is not enough (PDF - 243 MB)
Dr Amaboo DHAI
University of the Witwatersrand Medical School Steve Biko Centre for Bioethics Parktown South Africa
Preserving Protecting amp Improving Research Integrity in Africa Challenges and Recommendations (PPT - 6 MB)
Word (short biography) (29 KB) - Word (long version) (118 KB)
Dr Pieter DRENTH
All European Academies (ALLEA) Amsterdam The Netherlands
Strengths and Weaknesses of Currrent Policies and Practices (PPT - 116 KB)
Word (36 KB)
Prof Ayse ERZAN
Istanbul Technical University Faculty of Sciences and Letters Turkey
Developing and Applying Integrity Policies in a Global Context (PPT - 102 KB)
Word (KB)
Prof Michael FARTHING
University of London UK Institutional Perspectives on Integrity of Publication (PPT - 702 KB)
Prof Carlos FIOLHAIS
University of Coimbra Portugal
- Scientific Integrity and Scientific Culture Telling the Truth to the Public (PPT- 20 MB)- Extended Abstract (Word - 42 KB)
Word (26 KB)
Dr Peggy FISCHER
National Science Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Investigating Research Misconduct Across International Borders Principles and Practices (PPT - 233 KB)
Word (24 KB)
Ms Annette FLANAGIN amp Dr Muza
JAMA Journal of the American Medical Association Chicago USA
African Journal Partnership Project (PPT - 560 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 14
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
GONDWE amp University of Malawi College of Medicine Blantyre Malawi
Prof William GARDNER
The Ohio State University Columbus USA
Research Misconduct International Cooperation (PPT - 297 KB)
Prof Herbert GOTTWEIS
University of Vienna Institut fuumlr Politikwissenschaft Austria
Hwang-gate Lessons for Science Governance (PDF - 12 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Chris GRAF Wiley-Blackwell Oxford UK
What are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics (PPT - 13 MB)
Mr Angel GURRIA
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
Remarks
Prof Ian HALLIDAY
European Science Foundation Strasbourg France
Integrating Responsibility The Research Student Perspective (PPT - 170 KB)
Mr Joel HASSE FERREIRA
European Parliament Brussels Belgium
Public Policies and Strategies Fostering Research Integrity (Word - 28 KB)
Dr Elizabeth HEITMAN
Vanderbilt University Medical Center Nashville USA
The Need for Global Strategies for Training Students in RCR (PPT - 101 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Manuel HEITOR
Portuguese Ministry for Science Technology and Higher Education (MCTES) Lisbon Portugal
- Do We Need a Revisited Policy Agenda for Research IntegrityAn Institutional Perspective (PDF - 98 KB)- Concluding Remarks (PDF - 32 KB)
PDF (187 KB)
Prof Helena ILLNEROVA
Academy of Sciences Prague Czech Republic
Trust in Research and the Importance of Training (Word - 43 KB)
Word (28 KB)
Prof Matthias KAISER
The National Committee for Research Ethics in Science and Technology (NENT) Oslo Norway
International Cooperation to Foster Research Integrity Reflections on Actors and Instruments (PPT - 21 MB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 15
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Dr Katrina KELNER
Science Magazine Washington USA
Science s Efforts to Ensure Research Integrity (PPT - 250 KB)
Word (22 KB)
Dr Sabine KLEINERT
The Lancet London UK How Can Good Publication Standards Influence Research Integrity Part1 (PPT - 47 MB) amp Part2 (PPT - 73 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Anthony KOMAROFF
Harvard Medical School Boston USA
Problems Undermining Public Confidence in and Understanding Research (PPT - 81 KB)
Word (32 KB)
Dr Philip LANGLAIS
Old Dominion University Norfolk USA
Institutional and Societal Issues Educating for Responsible Research (PPT - 235 KB)
Dr Nigel LLOYD
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Canada (NSERC) Ottawa Canada
Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct (PPT - 36 KB)
Word (57 KB)
Dr Joao LOBO ANTUNES
Hospital de Santa Maria Serviccedilo de Neurocirurgia Lisboa Portugal
To Publish or Not To Publish Communicating Science in a New Global and Financial Environment (PPT - 60 MB)
Professor Fernando LOPES DA SILVA
University van Amsterdam The Netherlands
Integrity in Biomedical Research The Role of Education (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Brian MARTINSON
HealthPartners Research Foundation (HPRF) Minneapolis USA
Research Integrity and the Social and Psychological Environments of Science (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Ana MARUSIC
Zagreb University School of Medicine Croatia
Why are scientific journals small or large important in fostering research integrity (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Shamila NAIR-BEDOUELLE
UNESCO Paris France COMESTs Role in Fostering Integrity in Research (PPT - 531 KB)
Prof Paumlr Vetenskapsraringdet (Swedish Closing Remarks (PPT - 23
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 16
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
NATURE In the Field
17 September 2007 Integrity - Zero Tolerance in Portugal (Sarah Tomlin)
NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY Volume 24 Number 2 - 2 February 2006
South Korean policy failure and the Hwang debacle (Nature Biotechnology 24 141-143 - Commentary - Herbert Gottweis amp Robert Triendl)
SCIENCE Volume 316 Issue 5832 - 22 June 2007
- Scientific Publishing Osaka University Researchers reject Demand to Retract Science Paper (p 1681 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 316 Issue 5827 - 18 May 2007- Research Integrity Sonofusion Back on the Firing Line as Misconduct Probe Reopens (p 964 - News of the Week - Robert F Service)
Volume 315 Issue 5819 - 23 March 2007- Open Government House OKs Whistleblower Bill (p 1649 - News of the Week - Eli Kintisch)
Volume 315 Issue 5814 - 16 February 2007- Research Integrity Bubble Fusion Researcher Cleared of Misconduct Charges but Doubts Linger (p 921 - News of the Week - Robert F Service)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 8
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 315 Issue 5810 - 19 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Former Hwang Colleague Faked Monkey Datas US Says (p 317 - News of the Week - Constance Holden)
Volume 315 Issue 5808 - 5 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Japanrsquos Universities Take Action (p 26 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 314 Issue 5806 - 15 December 2006- Scientific Misconduct Online Sleuths Challenge Cell Paper (p 1669 - News of the Week - Hao Xin)
Volume 314 Issue 5804 - 1 December 2006- Developmental Biology Fraud Investigation Clouds Paper on Early Cell Fate (pp 1367-1369 - News of the Week - Gretchen Vogel)- Scientific Misconduct Chinarsquos Fraud Buster Hit by Libel Judgments Defenders Rally Round (pp 1366-1367 - News of the Week - Jia Hepeng and Hao Xin)- Responding to Fraud (pp 1353 - Editorial - Donald Kennedy) (+ Supporting On-line Material)
Volume 312 Issue 5779 - 9 June 2006- Scientific Misconduct Scandals Shake Chinese Science (pp 1464-1466 - News Focus - Hao Xin)- Scientific Misconduct Crime Scene Investigation How to Handle Misconduct (p 1465 - News Focus - Eliot Marshall)
Volume 85 Issue 07 - 12 February 2007- Re search Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three Japanese cases conclude (pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
Volume 84 Issue 45 - 6 November 2006- Research Misconduct Federal agencies handle fabrication falsification and plagiarism allegations differently but all take claims seriously (pp 18-22 - Susan Morrissey)
BMJ
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 9
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 335 Ndeg 7619 - 15 September 2007Dealing with Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 524525 - Xavier Bosch)
Volume 334 Ndeg 7590 - 24 February 2007- Managing Suspected Research Misconduct (Editorials - pp 378-379 - Charles Young amp Fiona Godlee)- Research Ethics Doubts over Head Injury Studies (Feature - pp 392-394 - Ian Roberts Richard Smith amp Stephen Evans)
Volume 331 Ndeg 7511 - 30 July 2005Investigating Allegations of Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 245-246 - Jane Smith amp Fiona Godlee)
RESEARCH POLICY Volume 36 Issue 7 September 2007
Keeping Plagiarism at Bay A Salutary Tale (Editorial - p 905-311 - Ben R Martin amp Other Editors of Research Policy)
IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY Volume 25 Ndeg2 - MarchApril 2006
Spring Cleaning and Ethics in our Backyard (From the Editor - pp 4-5 - John Enderle)
THE LANCET
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 10
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 370 Ndeg9596 - 20 October 2007Research Integrity Collaboration and Research needed (Comment - p 1403-1404 - Erik von Elm)
CELL Volume 131 - 5 October 2007
Seeking an International Dialogue on Research Integrity (p 9-11 - Christie Aschwanden)
SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS 27 September 2007
A Qualitative Approach to Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR) Training Development Identification of Metacognitive Strategies (Vykinta Kligyte Richard T Marcy Sydney T Sevier Elaine S Godfrey and Michael D Mumford)
CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS Volume 85 Ndeg7 - 12 February 2007
Research Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 11
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Japanese cases conclude (Science amp Technology - pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
Vol 16 no 1 December 2007 issue PDF (52 KB)Among the articles in this issue are registration opens for the first biennial RCR conference RCR award given to the Council of Graduate Schools postdoc training funded at 12 institutions 2007 Annual Report due by March 1 2008 Global Science Forum develops steps to lessen research misconduct first World Conference report recommends actions to meet crucial needs innovative RCR resources to be available on-line in spring 2008
BOOKS Integrity in Scientific Research Creating an Environment that Promotes
Responsible ConductCommittee on Assessing Integrity in Research Environments National Research Council Institute of MedicineNational Academies Press 2002 - ISBN 0309084792
Introduction to the Responsible Conduct of ResearchNicholas Steneck US Office of Research IntegrityRevised edition 2004 - ISBN 0160722853
The Great Betrayal Fraud in ScienceHorace Freeland JudsonHarcourt 2004 - ISBN 0151008779
Scientific Integrity Text and Cases in responsible Conduct of ResearchFrancis MacrinaASM Press 2005 - ISBN 1555813186
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 12
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHInvited Papers amp BiographiesName Affiliation Lecture Biography
Prof Howard ALPER
University of Ottawa Department of Chemistry Canada
Research Integrity Best Practices for the Benefic of Society (PPT - 41 MB)
Word (37 KB)
Prof Melissa ANDERSON
University of Minnesota Department of Educational Policy and Administration Minneapolis USA
Educating Competent Responsible and Successful Researchers (PPT - 15 KB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Lida ANESTIDOU
The National Academies Institute for Laboratory Animal Research Washington USA
Current Policies and Policy Development (PDF - 393 KB)
Dr Guitelle BAGHDADI-SABETI
World Health Organisation (WHO) Geneva Switzerland
Good Governance for Medicines (PPT - 09 MB)
Word (113 KB)
Prof Ulrike BEISIEGEL
Universitaumltskrankenhaus Hamburg-Eppendorf Germany
Safeguarding Good Scientific Practice (PPT - 81 KB)
Dr Lawrence BELL
Museum of Science Boston USA
Who Do You Trust Science Museums as Forums for Conversations between Scientists and the Public (PDF - 23 MB)
PDF (302 KB)
Dr Christine BOESZ
US National Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Legal Aspects of Investigation amp International Cooperation (PPT - 79 KB)
Dr Philip CAMPBELL
Nature London UK Misconduct in Research Who is Responsible for What (PPT - 111 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Dr Paul CARO Acadeacutemie des Technologies Paris France
Science and the Show Society (PPT - 69 KB)
Dr Paul DAVID University of Oxford Empirical Realities of PDF (41
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 13
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
amp Dr Andrea POZZI
Oxford Internet Institute UK amp Stanford University Landau Economics Centre USA
Scientific Misconduct in Publicly Funded Research What Can We Learn from the ORIs Investigations in of US Cases in the Biomedical and Behavioral Sciences (PDF - 648 KB)
KB)
Dr Vladimir DE SEMIR
Universitat Pompeu Fabra Journalism and Audiovisual Communication Department Barcelona ES
Research Integrity amp Knowledge Society R+D+i is not enough (PDF - 243 MB)
Dr Amaboo DHAI
University of the Witwatersrand Medical School Steve Biko Centre for Bioethics Parktown South Africa
Preserving Protecting amp Improving Research Integrity in Africa Challenges and Recommendations (PPT - 6 MB)
Word (short biography) (29 KB) - Word (long version) (118 KB)
Dr Pieter DRENTH
All European Academies (ALLEA) Amsterdam The Netherlands
Strengths and Weaknesses of Currrent Policies and Practices (PPT - 116 KB)
Word (36 KB)
Prof Ayse ERZAN
Istanbul Technical University Faculty of Sciences and Letters Turkey
Developing and Applying Integrity Policies in a Global Context (PPT - 102 KB)
Word (KB)
Prof Michael FARTHING
University of London UK Institutional Perspectives on Integrity of Publication (PPT - 702 KB)
Prof Carlos FIOLHAIS
University of Coimbra Portugal
- Scientific Integrity and Scientific Culture Telling the Truth to the Public (PPT- 20 MB)- Extended Abstract (Word - 42 KB)
Word (26 KB)
Dr Peggy FISCHER
National Science Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Investigating Research Misconduct Across International Borders Principles and Practices (PPT - 233 KB)
Word (24 KB)
Ms Annette FLANAGIN amp Dr Muza
JAMA Journal of the American Medical Association Chicago USA
African Journal Partnership Project (PPT - 560 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 14
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
GONDWE amp University of Malawi College of Medicine Blantyre Malawi
Prof William GARDNER
The Ohio State University Columbus USA
Research Misconduct International Cooperation (PPT - 297 KB)
Prof Herbert GOTTWEIS
University of Vienna Institut fuumlr Politikwissenschaft Austria
Hwang-gate Lessons for Science Governance (PDF - 12 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Chris GRAF Wiley-Blackwell Oxford UK
What are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics (PPT - 13 MB)
Mr Angel GURRIA
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
Remarks
Prof Ian HALLIDAY
European Science Foundation Strasbourg France
Integrating Responsibility The Research Student Perspective (PPT - 170 KB)
Mr Joel HASSE FERREIRA
European Parliament Brussels Belgium
Public Policies and Strategies Fostering Research Integrity (Word - 28 KB)
Dr Elizabeth HEITMAN
Vanderbilt University Medical Center Nashville USA
The Need for Global Strategies for Training Students in RCR (PPT - 101 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Manuel HEITOR
Portuguese Ministry for Science Technology and Higher Education (MCTES) Lisbon Portugal
- Do We Need a Revisited Policy Agenda for Research IntegrityAn Institutional Perspective (PDF - 98 KB)- Concluding Remarks (PDF - 32 KB)
PDF (187 KB)
Prof Helena ILLNEROVA
Academy of Sciences Prague Czech Republic
Trust in Research and the Importance of Training (Word - 43 KB)
Word (28 KB)
Prof Matthias KAISER
The National Committee for Research Ethics in Science and Technology (NENT) Oslo Norway
International Cooperation to Foster Research Integrity Reflections on Actors and Instruments (PPT - 21 MB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 15
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Dr Katrina KELNER
Science Magazine Washington USA
Science s Efforts to Ensure Research Integrity (PPT - 250 KB)
Word (22 KB)
Dr Sabine KLEINERT
The Lancet London UK How Can Good Publication Standards Influence Research Integrity Part1 (PPT - 47 MB) amp Part2 (PPT - 73 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Anthony KOMAROFF
Harvard Medical School Boston USA
Problems Undermining Public Confidence in and Understanding Research (PPT - 81 KB)
Word (32 KB)
Dr Philip LANGLAIS
Old Dominion University Norfolk USA
Institutional and Societal Issues Educating for Responsible Research (PPT - 235 KB)
Dr Nigel LLOYD
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Canada (NSERC) Ottawa Canada
Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct (PPT - 36 KB)
Word (57 KB)
Dr Joao LOBO ANTUNES
Hospital de Santa Maria Serviccedilo de Neurocirurgia Lisboa Portugal
To Publish or Not To Publish Communicating Science in a New Global and Financial Environment (PPT - 60 MB)
Professor Fernando LOPES DA SILVA
University van Amsterdam The Netherlands
Integrity in Biomedical Research The Role of Education (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Brian MARTINSON
HealthPartners Research Foundation (HPRF) Minneapolis USA
Research Integrity and the Social and Psychological Environments of Science (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Ana MARUSIC
Zagreb University School of Medicine Croatia
Why are scientific journals small or large important in fostering research integrity (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Shamila NAIR-BEDOUELLE
UNESCO Paris France COMESTs Role in Fostering Integrity in Research (PPT - 531 KB)
Prof Paumlr Vetenskapsraringdet (Swedish Closing Remarks (PPT - 23
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 16
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 315 Issue 5810 - 19 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Former Hwang Colleague Faked Monkey Datas US Says (p 317 - News of the Week - Constance Holden)
Volume 315 Issue 5808 - 5 January 2007- Scientific Misconduct Japanrsquos Universities Take Action (p 26 - News of the Week - Dennis Normile)
Volume 314 Issue 5806 - 15 December 2006- Scientific Misconduct Online Sleuths Challenge Cell Paper (p 1669 - News of the Week - Hao Xin)
Volume 314 Issue 5804 - 1 December 2006- Developmental Biology Fraud Investigation Clouds Paper on Early Cell Fate (pp 1367-1369 - News of the Week - Gretchen Vogel)- Scientific Misconduct Chinarsquos Fraud Buster Hit by Libel Judgments Defenders Rally Round (pp 1366-1367 - News of the Week - Jia Hepeng and Hao Xin)- Responding to Fraud (pp 1353 - Editorial - Donald Kennedy) (+ Supporting On-line Material)
Volume 312 Issue 5779 - 9 June 2006- Scientific Misconduct Scandals Shake Chinese Science (pp 1464-1466 - News Focus - Hao Xin)- Scientific Misconduct Crime Scene Investigation How to Handle Misconduct (p 1465 - News Focus - Eliot Marshall)
Volume 85 Issue 07 - 12 February 2007- Re search Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three Japanese cases conclude (pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
Volume 84 Issue 45 - 6 November 2006- Research Misconduct Federal agencies handle fabrication falsification and plagiarism allegations differently but all take claims seriously (pp 18-22 - Susan Morrissey)
BMJ
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 9
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 335 Ndeg 7619 - 15 September 2007Dealing with Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 524525 - Xavier Bosch)
Volume 334 Ndeg 7590 - 24 February 2007- Managing Suspected Research Misconduct (Editorials - pp 378-379 - Charles Young amp Fiona Godlee)- Research Ethics Doubts over Head Injury Studies (Feature - pp 392-394 - Ian Roberts Richard Smith amp Stephen Evans)
Volume 331 Ndeg 7511 - 30 July 2005Investigating Allegations of Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 245-246 - Jane Smith amp Fiona Godlee)
RESEARCH POLICY Volume 36 Issue 7 September 2007
Keeping Plagiarism at Bay A Salutary Tale (Editorial - p 905-311 - Ben R Martin amp Other Editors of Research Policy)
IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY Volume 25 Ndeg2 - MarchApril 2006
Spring Cleaning and Ethics in our Backyard (From the Editor - pp 4-5 - John Enderle)
THE LANCET
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 10
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 370 Ndeg9596 - 20 October 2007Research Integrity Collaboration and Research needed (Comment - p 1403-1404 - Erik von Elm)
CELL Volume 131 - 5 October 2007
Seeking an International Dialogue on Research Integrity (p 9-11 - Christie Aschwanden)
SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS 27 September 2007
A Qualitative Approach to Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR) Training Development Identification of Metacognitive Strategies (Vykinta Kligyte Richard T Marcy Sydney T Sevier Elaine S Godfrey and Michael D Mumford)
CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS Volume 85 Ndeg7 - 12 February 2007
Research Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 11
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Japanese cases conclude (Science amp Technology - pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
Vol 16 no 1 December 2007 issue PDF (52 KB)Among the articles in this issue are registration opens for the first biennial RCR conference RCR award given to the Council of Graduate Schools postdoc training funded at 12 institutions 2007 Annual Report due by March 1 2008 Global Science Forum develops steps to lessen research misconduct first World Conference report recommends actions to meet crucial needs innovative RCR resources to be available on-line in spring 2008
BOOKS Integrity in Scientific Research Creating an Environment that Promotes
Responsible ConductCommittee on Assessing Integrity in Research Environments National Research Council Institute of MedicineNational Academies Press 2002 - ISBN 0309084792
Introduction to the Responsible Conduct of ResearchNicholas Steneck US Office of Research IntegrityRevised edition 2004 - ISBN 0160722853
The Great Betrayal Fraud in ScienceHorace Freeland JudsonHarcourt 2004 - ISBN 0151008779
Scientific Integrity Text and Cases in responsible Conduct of ResearchFrancis MacrinaASM Press 2005 - ISBN 1555813186
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 12
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHInvited Papers amp BiographiesName Affiliation Lecture Biography
Prof Howard ALPER
University of Ottawa Department of Chemistry Canada
Research Integrity Best Practices for the Benefic of Society (PPT - 41 MB)
Word (37 KB)
Prof Melissa ANDERSON
University of Minnesota Department of Educational Policy and Administration Minneapolis USA
Educating Competent Responsible and Successful Researchers (PPT - 15 KB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Lida ANESTIDOU
The National Academies Institute for Laboratory Animal Research Washington USA
Current Policies and Policy Development (PDF - 393 KB)
Dr Guitelle BAGHDADI-SABETI
World Health Organisation (WHO) Geneva Switzerland
Good Governance for Medicines (PPT - 09 MB)
Word (113 KB)
Prof Ulrike BEISIEGEL
Universitaumltskrankenhaus Hamburg-Eppendorf Germany
Safeguarding Good Scientific Practice (PPT - 81 KB)
Dr Lawrence BELL
Museum of Science Boston USA
Who Do You Trust Science Museums as Forums for Conversations between Scientists and the Public (PDF - 23 MB)
PDF (302 KB)
Dr Christine BOESZ
US National Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Legal Aspects of Investigation amp International Cooperation (PPT - 79 KB)
Dr Philip CAMPBELL
Nature London UK Misconduct in Research Who is Responsible for What (PPT - 111 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Dr Paul CARO Acadeacutemie des Technologies Paris France
Science and the Show Society (PPT - 69 KB)
Dr Paul DAVID University of Oxford Empirical Realities of PDF (41
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 13
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
amp Dr Andrea POZZI
Oxford Internet Institute UK amp Stanford University Landau Economics Centre USA
Scientific Misconduct in Publicly Funded Research What Can We Learn from the ORIs Investigations in of US Cases in the Biomedical and Behavioral Sciences (PDF - 648 KB)
KB)
Dr Vladimir DE SEMIR
Universitat Pompeu Fabra Journalism and Audiovisual Communication Department Barcelona ES
Research Integrity amp Knowledge Society R+D+i is not enough (PDF - 243 MB)
Dr Amaboo DHAI
University of the Witwatersrand Medical School Steve Biko Centre for Bioethics Parktown South Africa
Preserving Protecting amp Improving Research Integrity in Africa Challenges and Recommendations (PPT - 6 MB)
Word (short biography) (29 KB) - Word (long version) (118 KB)
Dr Pieter DRENTH
All European Academies (ALLEA) Amsterdam The Netherlands
Strengths and Weaknesses of Currrent Policies and Practices (PPT - 116 KB)
Word (36 KB)
Prof Ayse ERZAN
Istanbul Technical University Faculty of Sciences and Letters Turkey
Developing and Applying Integrity Policies in a Global Context (PPT - 102 KB)
Word (KB)
Prof Michael FARTHING
University of London UK Institutional Perspectives on Integrity of Publication (PPT - 702 KB)
Prof Carlos FIOLHAIS
University of Coimbra Portugal
- Scientific Integrity and Scientific Culture Telling the Truth to the Public (PPT- 20 MB)- Extended Abstract (Word - 42 KB)
Word (26 KB)
Dr Peggy FISCHER
National Science Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Investigating Research Misconduct Across International Borders Principles and Practices (PPT - 233 KB)
Word (24 KB)
Ms Annette FLANAGIN amp Dr Muza
JAMA Journal of the American Medical Association Chicago USA
African Journal Partnership Project (PPT - 560 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 14
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
GONDWE amp University of Malawi College of Medicine Blantyre Malawi
Prof William GARDNER
The Ohio State University Columbus USA
Research Misconduct International Cooperation (PPT - 297 KB)
Prof Herbert GOTTWEIS
University of Vienna Institut fuumlr Politikwissenschaft Austria
Hwang-gate Lessons for Science Governance (PDF - 12 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Chris GRAF Wiley-Blackwell Oxford UK
What are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics (PPT - 13 MB)
Mr Angel GURRIA
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
Remarks
Prof Ian HALLIDAY
European Science Foundation Strasbourg France
Integrating Responsibility The Research Student Perspective (PPT - 170 KB)
Mr Joel HASSE FERREIRA
European Parliament Brussels Belgium
Public Policies and Strategies Fostering Research Integrity (Word - 28 KB)
Dr Elizabeth HEITMAN
Vanderbilt University Medical Center Nashville USA
The Need for Global Strategies for Training Students in RCR (PPT - 101 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Manuel HEITOR
Portuguese Ministry for Science Technology and Higher Education (MCTES) Lisbon Portugal
- Do We Need a Revisited Policy Agenda for Research IntegrityAn Institutional Perspective (PDF - 98 KB)- Concluding Remarks (PDF - 32 KB)
PDF (187 KB)
Prof Helena ILLNEROVA
Academy of Sciences Prague Czech Republic
Trust in Research and the Importance of Training (Word - 43 KB)
Word (28 KB)
Prof Matthias KAISER
The National Committee for Research Ethics in Science and Technology (NENT) Oslo Norway
International Cooperation to Foster Research Integrity Reflections on Actors and Instruments (PPT - 21 MB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 15
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Dr Katrina KELNER
Science Magazine Washington USA
Science s Efforts to Ensure Research Integrity (PPT - 250 KB)
Word (22 KB)
Dr Sabine KLEINERT
The Lancet London UK How Can Good Publication Standards Influence Research Integrity Part1 (PPT - 47 MB) amp Part2 (PPT - 73 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Anthony KOMAROFF
Harvard Medical School Boston USA
Problems Undermining Public Confidence in and Understanding Research (PPT - 81 KB)
Word (32 KB)
Dr Philip LANGLAIS
Old Dominion University Norfolk USA
Institutional and Societal Issues Educating for Responsible Research (PPT - 235 KB)
Dr Nigel LLOYD
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Canada (NSERC) Ottawa Canada
Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct (PPT - 36 KB)
Word (57 KB)
Dr Joao LOBO ANTUNES
Hospital de Santa Maria Serviccedilo de Neurocirurgia Lisboa Portugal
To Publish or Not To Publish Communicating Science in a New Global and Financial Environment (PPT - 60 MB)
Professor Fernando LOPES DA SILVA
University van Amsterdam The Netherlands
Integrity in Biomedical Research The Role of Education (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Brian MARTINSON
HealthPartners Research Foundation (HPRF) Minneapolis USA
Research Integrity and the Social and Psychological Environments of Science (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Ana MARUSIC
Zagreb University School of Medicine Croatia
Why are scientific journals small or large important in fostering research integrity (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Shamila NAIR-BEDOUELLE
UNESCO Paris France COMESTs Role in Fostering Integrity in Research (PPT - 531 KB)
Prof Paumlr Vetenskapsraringdet (Swedish Closing Remarks (PPT - 23
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 16
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 335 Ndeg 7619 - 15 September 2007Dealing with Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 524525 - Xavier Bosch)
Volume 334 Ndeg 7590 - 24 February 2007- Managing Suspected Research Misconduct (Editorials - pp 378-379 - Charles Young amp Fiona Godlee)- Research Ethics Doubts over Head Injury Studies (Feature - pp 392-394 - Ian Roberts Richard Smith amp Stephen Evans)
Volume 331 Ndeg 7511 - 30 July 2005Investigating Allegations of Scientific Misconduct (Editorials - pp 245-246 - Jane Smith amp Fiona Godlee)
RESEARCH POLICY Volume 36 Issue 7 September 2007
Keeping Plagiarism at Bay A Salutary Tale (Editorial - p 905-311 - Ben R Martin amp Other Editors of Research Policy)
IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY Volume 25 Ndeg2 - MarchApril 2006
Spring Cleaning and Ethics in our Backyard (From the Editor - pp 4-5 - John Enderle)
THE LANCET
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 10
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 370 Ndeg9596 - 20 October 2007Research Integrity Collaboration and Research needed (Comment - p 1403-1404 - Erik von Elm)
CELL Volume 131 - 5 October 2007
Seeking an International Dialogue on Research Integrity (p 9-11 - Christie Aschwanden)
SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS 27 September 2007
A Qualitative Approach to Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR) Training Development Identification of Metacognitive Strategies (Vykinta Kligyte Richard T Marcy Sydney T Sevier Elaine S Godfrey and Michael D Mumford)
CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS Volume 85 Ndeg7 - 12 February 2007
Research Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 11
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Japanese cases conclude (Science amp Technology - pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
Vol 16 no 1 December 2007 issue PDF (52 KB)Among the articles in this issue are registration opens for the first biennial RCR conference RCR award given to the Council of Graduate Schools postdoc training funded at 12 institutions 2007 Annual Report due by March 1 2008 Global Science Forum develops steps to lessen research misconduct first World Conference report recommends actions to meet crucial needs innovative RCR resources to be available on-line in spring 2008
BOOKS Integrity in Scientific Research Creating an Environment that Promotes
Responsible ConductCommittee on Assessing Integrity in Research Environments National Research Council Institute of MedicineNational Academies Press 2002 - ISBN 0309084792
Introduction to the Responsible Conduct of ResearchNicholas Steneck US Office of Research IntegrityRevised edition 2004 - ISBN 0160722853
The Great Betrayal Fraud in ScienceHorace Freeland JudsonHarcourt 2004 - ISBN 0151008779
Scientific Integrity Text and Cases in responsible Conduct of ResearchFrancis MacrinaASM Press 2005 - ISBN 1555813186
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 12
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHInvited Papers amp BiographiesName Affiliation Lecture Biography
Prof Howard ALPER
University of Ottawa Department of Chemistry Canada
Research Integrity Best Practices for the Benefic of Society (PPT - 41 MB)
Word (37 KB)
Prof Melissa ANDERSON
University of Minnesota Department of Educational Policy and Administration Minneapolis USA
Educating Competent Responsible and Successful Researchers (PPT - 15 KB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Lida ANESTIDOU
The National Academies Institute for Laboratory Animal Research Washington USA
Current Policies and Policy Development (PDF - 393 KB)
Dr Guitelle BAGHDADI-SABETI
World Health Organisation (WHO) Geneva Switzerland
Good Governance for Medicines (PPT - 09 MB)
Word (113 KB)
Prof Ulrike BEISIEGEL
Universitaumltskrankenhaus Hamburg-Eppendorf Germany
Safeguarding Good Scientific Practice (PPT - 81 KB)
Dr Lawrence BELL
Museum of Science Boston USA
Who Do You Trust Science Museums as Forums for Conversations between Scientists and the Public (PDF - 23 MB)
PDF (302 KB)
Dr Christine BOESZ
US National Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Legal Aspects of Investigation amp International Cooperation (PPT - 79 KB)
Dr Philip CAMPBELL
Nature London UK Misconduct in Research Who is Responsible for What (PPT - 111 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Dr Paul CARO Acadeacutemie des Technologies Paris France
Science and the Show Society (PPT - 69 KB)
Dr Paul DAVID University of Oxford Empirical Realities of PDF (41
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 13
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
amp Dr Andrea POZZI
Oxford Internet Institute UK amp Stanford University Landau Economics Centre USA
Scientific Misconduct in Publicly Funded Research What Can We Learn from the ORIs Investigations in of US Cases in the Biomedical and Behavioral Sciences (PDF - 648 KB)
KB)
Dr Vladimir DE SEMIR
Universitat Pompeu Fabra Journalism and Audiovisual Communication Department Barcelona ES
Research Integrity amp Knowledge Society R+D+i is not enough (PDF - 243 MB)
Dr Amaboo DHAI
University of the Witwatersrand Medical School Steve Biko Centre for Bioethics Parktown South Africa
Preserving Protecting amp Improving Research Integrity in Africa Challenges and Recommendations (PPT - 6 MB)
Word (short biography) (29 KB) - Word (long version) (118 KB)
Dr Pieter DRENTH
All European Academies (ALLEA) Amsterdam The Netherlands
Strengths and Weaknesses of Currrent Policies and Practices (PPT - 116 KB)
Word (36 KB)
Prof Ayse ERZAN
Istanbul Technical University Faculty of Sciences and Letters Turkey
Developing and Applying Integrity Policies in a Global Context (PPT - 102 KB)
Word (KB)
Prof Michael FARTHING
University of London UK Institutional Perspectives on Integrity of Publication (PPT - 702 KB)
Prof Carlos FIOLHAIS
University of Coimbra Portugal
- Scientific Integrity and Scientific Culture Telling the Truth to the Public (PPT- 20 MB)- Extended Abstract (Word - 42 KB)
Word (26 KB)
Dr Peggy FISCHER
National Science Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Investigating Research Misconduct Across International Borders Principles and Practices (PPT - 233 KB)
Word (24 KB)
Ms Annette FLANAGIN amp Dr Muza
JAMA Journal of the American Medical Association Chicago USA
African Journal Partnership Project (PPT - 560 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 14
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
GONDWE amp University of Malawi College of Medicine Blantyre Malawi
Prof William GARDNER
The Ohio State University Columbus USA
Research Misconduct International Cooperation (PPT - 297 KB)
Prof Herbert GOTTWEIS
University of Vienna Institut fuumlr Politikwissenschaft Austria
Hwang-gate Lessons for Science Governance (PDF - 12 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Chris GRAF Wiley-Blackwell Oxford UK
What are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics (PPT - 13 MB)
Mr Angel GURRIA
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
Remarks
Prof Ian HALLIDAY
European Science Foundation Strasbourg France
Integrating Responsibility The Research Student Perspective (PPT - 170 KB)
Mr Joel HASSE FERREIRA
European Parliament Brussels Belgium
Public Policies and Strategies Fostering Research Integrity (Word - 28 KB)
Dr Elizabeth HEITMAN
Vanderbilt University Medical Center Nashville USA
The Need for Global Strategies for Training Students in RCR (PPT - 101 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Manuel HEITOR
Portuguese Ministry for Science Technology and Higher Education (MCTES) Lisbon Portugal
- Do We Need a Revisited Policy Agenda for Research IntegrityAn Institutional Perspective (PDF - 98 KB)- Concluding Remarks (PDF - 32 KB)
PDF (187 KB)
Prof Helena ILLNEROVA
Academy of Sciences Prague Czech Republic
Trust in Research and the Importance of Training (Word - 43 KB)
Word (28 KB)
Prof Matthias KAISER
The National Committee for Research Ethics in Science and Technology (NENT) Oslo Norway
International Cooperation to Foster Research Integrity Reflections on Actors and Instruments (PPT - 21 MB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 15
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Dr Katrina KELNER
Science Magazine Washington USA
Science s Efforts to Ensure Research Integrity (PPT - 250 KB)
Word (22 KB)
Dr Sabine KLEINERT
The Lancet London UK How Can Good Publication Standards Influence Research Integrity Part1 (PPT - 47 MB) amp Part2 (PPT - 73 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Anthony KOMAROFF
Harvard Medical School Boston USA
Problems Undermining Public Confidence in and Understanding Research (PPT - 81 KB)
Word (32 KB)
Dr Philip LANGLAIS
Old Dominion University Norfolk USA
Institutional and Societal Issues Educating for Responsible Research (PPT - 235 KB)
Dr Nigel LLOYD
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Canada (NSERC) Ottawa Canada
Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct (PPT - 36 KB)
Word (57 KB)
Dr Joao LOBO ANTUNES
Hospital de Santa Maria Serviccedilo de Neurocirurgia Lisboa Portugal
To Publish or Not To Publish Communicating Science in a New Global and Financial Environment (PPT - 60 MB)
Professor Fernando LOPES DA SILVA
University van Amsterdam The Netherlands
Integrity in Biomedical Research The Role of Education (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Brian MARTINSON
HealthPartners Research Foundation (HPRF) Minneapolis USA
Research Integrity and the Social and Psychological Environments of Science (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Ana MARUSIC
Zagreb University School of Medicine Croatia
Why are scientific journals small or large important in fostering research integrity (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Shamila NAIR-BEDOUELLE
UNESCO Paris France COMESTs Role in Fostering Integrity in Research (PPT - 531 KB)
Prof Paumlr Vetenskapsraringdet (Swedish Closing Remarks (PPT - 23
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 16
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Volume 370 Ndeg9596 - 20 October 2007Research Integrity Collaboration and Research needed (Comment - p 1403-1404 - Erik von Elm)
CELL Volume 131 - 5 October 2007
Seeking an International Dialogue on Research Integrity (p 9-11 - Christie Aschwanden)
SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS 27 September 2007
A Qualitative Approach to Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR) Training Development Identification of Metacognitive Strategies (Vykinta Kligyte Richard T Marcy Sydney T Sevier Elaine S Godfrey and Michael D Mumford)
CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS Volume 85 Ndeg7 - 12 February 2007
Research Ethics Experts ponder how best to prevent and respond to scientific misconduct as three
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 11
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Japanese cases conclude (Science amp Technology - pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
Vol 16 no 1 December 2007 issue PDF (52 KB)Among the articles in this issue are registration opens for the first biennial RCR conference RCR award given to the Council of Graduate Schools postdoc training funded at 12 institutions 2007 Annual Report due by March 1 2008 Global Science Forum develops steps to lessen research misconduct first World Conference report recommends actions to meet crucial needs innovative RCR resources to be available on-line in spring 2008
BOOKS Integrity in Scientific Research Creating an Environment that Promotes
Responsible ConductCommittee on Assessing Integrity in Research Environments National Research Council Institute of MedicineNational Academies Press 2002 - ISBN 0309084792
Introduction to the Responsible Conduct of ResearchNicholas Steneck US Office of Research IntegrityRevised edition 2004 - ISBN 0160722853
The Great Betrayal Fraud in ScienceHorace Freeland JudsonHarcourt 2004 - ISBN 0151008779
Scientific Integrity Text and Cases in responsible Conduct of ResearchFrancis MacrinaASM Press 2005 - ISBN 1555813186
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 12
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHInvited Papers amp BiographiesName Affiliation Lecture Biography
Prof Howard ALPER
University of Ottawa Department of Chemistry Canada
Research Integrity Best Practices for the Benefic of Society (PPT - 41 MB)
Word (37 KB)
Prof Melissa ANDERSON
University of Minnesota Department of Educational Policy and Administration Minneapolis USA
Educating Competent Responsible and Successful Researchers (PPT - 15 KB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Lida ANESTIDOU
The National Academies Institute for Laboratory Animal Research Washington USA
Current Policies and Policy Development (PDF - 393 KB)
Dr Guitelle BAGHDADI-SABETI
World Health Organisation (WHO) Geneva Switzerland
Good Governance for Medicines (PPT - 09 MB)
Word (113 KB)
Prof Ulrike BEISIEGEL
Universitaumltskrankenhaus Hamburg-Eppendorf Germany
Safeguarding Good Scientific Practice (PPT - 81 KB)
Dr Lawrence BELL
Museum of Science Boston USA
Who Do You Trust Science Museums as Forums for Conversations between Scientists and the Public (PDF - 23 MB)
PDF (302 KB)
Dr Christine BOESZ
US National Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Legal Aspects of Investigation amp International Cooperation (PPT - 79 KB)
Dr Philip CAMPBELL
Nature London UK Misconduct in Research Who is Responsible for What (PPT - 111 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Dr Paul CARO Acadeacutemie des Technologies Paris France
Science and the Show Society (PPT - 69 KB)
Dr Paul DAVID University of Oxford Empirical Realities of PDF (41
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 13
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
amp Dr Andrea POZZI
Oxford Internet Institute UK amp Stanford University Landau Economics Centre USA
Scientific Misconduct in Publicly Funded Research What Can We Learn from the ORIs Investigations in of US Cases in the Biomedical and Behavioral Sciences (PDF - 648 KB)
KB)
Dr Vladimir DE SEMIR
Universitat Pompeu Fabra Journalism and Audiovisual Communication Department Barcelona ES
Research Integrity amp Knowledge Society R+D+i is not enough (PDF - 243 MB)
Dr Amaboo DHAI
University of the Witwatersrand Medical School Steve Biko Centre for Bioethics Parktown South Africa
Preserving Protecting amp Improving Research Integrity in Africa Challenges and Recommendations (PPT - 6 MB)
Word (short biography) (29 KB) - Word (long version) (118 KB)
Dr Pieter DRENTH
All European Academies (ALLEA) Amsterdam The Netherlands
Strengths and Weaknesses of Currrent Policies and Practices (PPT - 116 KB)
Word (36 KB)
Prof Ayse ERZAN
Istanbul Technical University Faculty of Sciences and Letters Turkey
Developing and Applying Integrity Policies in a Global Context (PPT - 102 KB)
Word (KB)
Prof Michael FARTHING
University of London UK Institutional Perspectives on Integrity of Publication (PPT - 702 KB)
Prof Carlos FIOLHAIS
University of Coimbra Portugal
- Scientific Integrity and Scientific Culture Telling the Truth to the Public (PPT- 20 MB)- Extended Abstract (Word - 42 KB)
Word (26 KB)
Dr Peggy FISCHER
National Science Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Investigating Research Misconduct Across International Borders Principles and Practices (PPT - 233 KB)
Word (24 KB)
Ms Annette FLANAGIN amp Dr Muza
JAMA Journal of the American Medical Association Chicago USA
African Journal Partnership Project (PPT - 560 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 14
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
GONDWE amp University of Malawi College of Medicine Blantyre Malawi
Prof William GARDNER
The Ohio State University Columbus USA
Research Misconduct International Cooperation (PPT - 297 KB)
Prof Herbert GOTTWEIS
University of Vienna Institut fuumlr Politikwissenschaft Austria
Hwang-gate Lessons for Science Governance (PDF - 12 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Chris GRAF Wiley-Blackwell Oxford UK
What are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics (PPT - 13 MB)
Mr Angel GURRIA
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
Remarks
Prof Ian HALLIDAY
European Science Foundation Strasbourg France
Integrating Responsibility The Research Student Perspective (PPT - 170 KB)
Mr Joel HASSE FERREIRA
European Parliament Brussels Belgium
Public Policies and Strategies Fostering Research Integrity (Word - 28 KB)
Dr Elizabeth HEITMAN
Vanderbilt University Medical Center Nashville USA
The Need for Global Strategies for Training Students in RCR (PPT - 101 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Manuel HEITOR
Portuguese Ministry for Science Technology and Higher Education (MCTES) Lisbon Portugal
- Do We Need a Revisited Policy Agenda for Research IntegrityAn Institutional Perspective (PDF - 98 KB)- Concluding Remarks (PDF - 32 KB)
PDF (187 KB)
Prof Helena ILLNEROVA
Academy of Sciences Prague Czech Republic
Trust in Research and the Importance of Training (Word - 43 KB)
Word (28 KB)
Prof Matthias KAISER
The National Committee for Research Ethics in Science and Technology (NENT) Oslo Norway
International Cooperation to Foster Research Integrity Reflections on Actors and Instruments (PPT - 21 MB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 15
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Dr Katrina KELNER
Science Magazine Washington USA
Science s Efforts to Ensure Research Integrity (PPT - 250 KB)
Word (22 KB)
Dr Sabine KLEINERT
The Lancet London UK How Can Good Publication Standards Influence Research Integrity Part1 (PPT - 47 MB) amp Part2 (PPT - 73 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Anthony KOMAROFF
Harvard Medical School Boston USA
Problems Undermining Public Confidence in and Understanding Research (PPT - 81 KB)
Word (32 KB)
Dr Philip LANGLAIS
Old Dominion University Norfolk USA
Institutional and Societal Issues Educating for Responsible Research (PPT - 235 KB)
Dr Nigel LLOYD
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Canada (NSERC) Ottawa Canada
Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct (PPT - 36 KB)
Word (57 KB)
Dr Joao LOBO ANTUNES
Hospital de Santa Maria Serviccedilo de Neurocirurgia Lisboa Portugal
To Publish or Not To Publish Communicating Science in a New Global and Financial Environment (PPT - 60 MB)
Professor Fernando LOPES DA SILVA
University van Amsterdam The Netherlands
Integrity in Biomedical Research The Role of Education (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Brian MARTINSON
HealthPartners Research Foundation (HPRF) Minneapolis USA
Research Integrity and the Social and Psychological Environments of Science (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Ana MARUSIC
Zagreb University School of Medicine Croatia
Why are scientific journals small or large important in fostering research integrity (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Shamila NAIR-BEDOUELLE
UNESCO Paris France COMESTs Role in Fostering Integrity in Research (PPT - 531 KB)
Prof Paumlr Vetenskapsraringdet (Swedish Closing Remarks (PPT - 23
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 16
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Japanese cases conclude (Science amp Technology - pp 76-79 - Sophie L Rovner)
OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
Vol 16 no 1 December 2007 issue PDF (52 KB)Among the articles in this issue are registration opens for the first biennial RCR conference RCR award given to the Council of Graduate Schools postdoc training funded at 12 institutions 2007 Annual Report due by March 1 2008 Global Science Forum develops steps to lessen research misconduct first World Conference report recommends actions to meet crucial needs innovative RCR resources to be available on-line in spring 2008
BOOKS Integrity in Scientific Research Creating an Environment that Promotes
Responsible ConductCommittee on Assessing Integrity in Research Environments National Research Council Institute of MedicineNational Academies Press 2002 - ISBN 0309084792
Introduction to the Responsible Conduct of ResearchNicholas Steneck US Office of Research IntegrityRevised edition 2004 - ISBN 0160722853
The Great Betrayal Fraud in ScienceHorace Freeland JudsonHarcourt 2004 - ISBN 0151008779
Scientific Integrity Text and Cases in responsible Conduct of ResearchFrancis MacrinaASM Press 2005 - ISBN 1555813186
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 12
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHInvited Papers amp BiographiesName Affiliation Lecture Biography
Prof Howard ALPER
University of Ottawa Department of Chemistry Canada
Research Integrity Best Practices for the Benefic of Society (PPT - 41 MB)
Word (37 KB)
Prof Melissa ANDERSON
University of Minnesota Department of Educational Policy and Administration Minneapolis USA
Educating Competent Responsible and Successful Researchers (PPT - 15 KB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Lida ANESTIDOU
The National Academies Institute for Laboratory Animal Research Washington USA
Current Policies and Policy Development (PDF - 393 KB)
Dr Guitelle BAGHDADI-SABETI
World Health Organisation (WHO) Geneva Switzerland
Good Governance for Medicines (PPT - 09 MB)
Word (113 KB)
Prof Ulrike BEISIEGEL
Universitaumltskrankenhaus Hamburg-Eppendorf Germany
Safeguarding Good Scientific Practice (PPT - 81 KB)
Dr Lawrence BELL
Museum of Science Boston USA
Who Do You Trust Science Museums as Forums for Conversations between Scientists and the Public (PDF - 23 MB)
PDF (302 KB)
Dr Christine BOESZ
US National Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Legal Aspects of Investigation amp International Cooperation (PPT - 79 KB)
Dr Philip CAMPBELL
Nature London UK Misconduct in Research Who is Responsible for What (PPT - 111 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Dr Paul CARO Acadeacutemie des Technologies Paris France
Science and the Show Society (PPT - 69 KB)
Dr Paul DAVID University of Oxford Empirical Realities of PDF (41
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 13
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
amp Dr Andrea POZZI
Oxford Internet Institute UK amp Stanford University Landau Economics Centre USA
Scientific Misconduct in Publicly Funded Research What Can We Learn from the ORIs Investigations in of US Cases in the Biomedical and Behavioral Sciences (PDF - 648 KB)
KB)
Dr Vladimir DE SEMIR
Universitat Pompeu Fabra Journalism and Audiovisual Communication Department Barcelona ES
Research Integrity amp Knowledge Society R+D+i is not enough (PDF - 243 MB)
Dr Amaboo DHAI
University of the Witwatersrand Medical School Steve Biko Centre for Bioethics Parktown South Africa
Preserving Protecting amp Improving Research Integrity in Africa Challenges and Recommendations (PPT - 6 MB)
Word (short biography) (29 KB) - Word (long version) (118 KB)
Dr Pieter DRENTH
All European Academies (ALLEA) Amsterdam The Netherlands
Strengths and Weaknesses of Currrent Policies and Practices (PPT - 116 KB)
Word (36 KB)
Prof Ayse ERZAN
Istanbul Technical University Faculty of Sciences and Letters Turkey
Developing and Applying Integrity Policies in a Global Context (PPT - 102 KB)
Word (KB)
Prof Michael FARTHING
University of London UK Institutional Perspectives on Integrity of Publication (PPT - 702 KB)
Prof Carlos FIOLHAIS
University of Coimbra Portugal
- Scientific Integrity and Scientific Culture Telling the Truth to the Public (PPT- 20 MB)- Extended Abstract (Word - 42 KB)
Word (26 KB)
Dr Peggy FISCHER
National Science Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Investigating Research Misconduct Across International Borders Principles and Practices (PPT - 233 KB)
Word (24 KB)
Ms Annette FLANAGIN amp Dr Muza
JAMA Journal of the American Medical Association Chicago USA
African Journal Partnership Project (PPT - 560 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 14
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
GONDWE amp University of Malawi College of Medicine Blantyre Malawi
Prof William GARDNER
The Ohio State University Columbus USA
Research Misconduct International Cooperation (PPT - 297 KB)
Prof Herbert GOTTWEIS
University of Vienna Institut fuumlr Politikwissenschaft Austria
Hwang-gate Lessons for Science Governance (PDF - 12 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Chris GRAF Wiley-Blackwell Oxford UK
What are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics (PPT - 13 MB)
Mr Angel GURRIA
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
Remarks
Prof Ian HALLIDAY
European Science Foundation Strasbourg France
Integrating Responsibility The Research Student Perspective (PPT - 170 KB)
Mr Joel HASSE FERREIRA
European Parliament Brussels Belgium
Public Policies and Strategies Fostering Research Integrity (Word - 28 KB)
Dr Elizabeth HEITMAN
Vanderbilt University Medical Center Nashville USA
The Need for Global Strategies for Training Students in RCR (PPT - 101 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Manuel HEITOR
Portuguese Ministry for Science Technology and Higher Education (MCTES) Lisbon Portugal
- Do We Need a Revisited Policy Agenda for Research IntegrityAn Institutional Perspective (PDF - 98 KB)- Concluding Remarks (PDF - 32 KB)
PDF (187 KB)
Prof Helena ILLNEROVA
Academy of Sciences Prague Czech Republic
Trust in Research and the Importance of Training (Word - 43 KB)
Word (28 KB)
Prof Matthias KAISER
The National Committee for Research Ethics in Science and Technology (NENT) Oslo Norway
International Cooperation to Foster Research Integrity Reflections on Actors and Instruments (PPT - 21 MB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 15
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Dr Katrina KELNER
Science Magazine Washington USA
Science s Efforts to Ensure Research Integrity (PPT - 250 KB)
Word (22 KB)
Dr Sabine KLEINERT
The Lancet London UK How Can Good Publication Standards Influence Research Integrity Part1 (PPT - 47 MB) amp Part2 (PPT - 73 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Anthony KOMAROFF
Harvard Medical School Boston USA
Problems Undermining Public Confidence in and Understanding Research (PPT - 81 KB)
Word (32 KB)
Dr Philip LANGLAIS
Old Dominion University Norfolk USA
Institutional and Societal Issues Educating for Responsible Research (PPT - 235 KB)
Dr Nigel LLOYD
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Canada (NSERC) Ottawa Canada
Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct (PPT - 36 KB)
Word (57 KB)
Dr Joao LOBO ANTUNES
Hospital de Santa Maria Serviccedilo de Neurocirurgia Lisboa Portugal
To Publish or Not To Publish Communicating Science in a New Global and Financial Environment (PPT - 60 MB)
Professor Fernando LOPES DA SILVA
University van Amsterdam The Netherlands
Integrity in Biomedical Research The Role of Education (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Brian MARTINSON
HealthPartners Research Foundation (HPRF) Minneapolis USA
Research Integrity and the Social and Psychological Environments of Science (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Ana MARUSIC
Zagreb University School of Medicine Croatia
Why are scientific journals small or large important in fostering research integrity (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Shamila NAIR-BEDOUELLE
UNESCO Paris France COMESTs Role in Fostering Integrity in Research (PPT - 531 KB)
Prof Paumlr Vetenskapsraringdet (Swedish Closing Remarks (PPT - 23
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 16
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHInvited Papers amp BiographiesName Affiliation Lecture Biography
Prof Howard ALPER
University of Ottawa Department of Chemistry Canada
Research Integrity Best Practices for the Benefic of Society (PPT - 41 MB)
Word (37 KB)
Prof Melissa ANDERSON
University of Minnesota Department of Educational Policy and Administration Minneapolis USA
Educating Competent Responsible and Successful Researchers (PPT - 15 KB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Lida ANESTIDOU
The National Academies Institute for Laboratory Animal Research Washington USA
Current Policies and Policy Development (PDF - 393 KB)
Dr Guitelle BAGHDADI-SABETI
World Health Organisation (WHO) Geneva Switzerland
Good Governance for Medicines (PPT - 09 MB)
Word (113 KB)
Prof Ulrike BEISIEGEL
Universitaumltskrankenhaus Hamburg-Eppendorf Germany
Safeguarding Good Scientific Practice (PPT - 81 KB)
Dr Lawrence BELL
Museum of Science Boston USA
Who Do You Trust Science Museums as Forums for Conversations between Scientists and the Public (PDF - 23 MB)
PDF (302 KB)
Dr Christine BOESZ
US National Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Legal Aspects of Investigation amp International Cooperation (PPT - 79 KB)
Dr Philip CAMPBELL
Nature London UK Misconduct in Research Who is Responsible for What (PPT - 111 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Dr Paul CARO Acadeacutemie des Technologies Paris France
Science and the Show Society (PPT - 69 KB)
Dr Paul DAVID University of Oxford Empirical Realities of PDF (41
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 13
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
amp Dr Andrea POZZI
Oxford Internet Institute UK amp Stanford University Landau Economics Centre USA
Scientific Misconduct in Publicly Funded Research What Can We Learn from the ORIs Investigations in of US Cases in the Biomedical and Behavioral Sciences (PDF - 648 KB)
KB)
Dr Vladimir DE SEMIR
Universitat Pompeu Fabra Journalism and Audiovisual Communication Department Barcelona ES
Research Integrity amp Knowledge Society R+D+i is not enough (PDF - 243 MB)
Dr Amaboo DHAI
University of the Witwatersrand Medical School Steve Biko Centre for Bioethics Parktown South Africa
Preserving Protecting amp Improving Research Integrity in Africa Challenges and Recommendations (PPT - 6 MB)
Word (short biography) (29 KB) - Word (long version) (118 KB)
Dr Pieter DRENTH
All European Academies (ALLEA) Amsterdam The Netherlands
Strengths and Weaknesses of Currrent Policies and Practices (PPT - 116 KB)
Word (36 KB)
Prof Ayse ERZAN
Istanbul Technical University Faculty of Sciences and Letters Turkey
Developing and Applying Integrity Policies in a Global Context (PPT - 102 KB)
Word (KB)
Prof Michael FARTHING
University of London UK Institutional Perspectives on Integrity of Publication (PPT - 702 KB)
Prof Carlos FIOLHAIS
University of Coimbra Portugal
- Scientific Integrity and Scientific Culture Telling the Truth to the Public (PPT- 20 MB)- Extended Abstract (Word - 42 KB)
Word (26 KB)
Dr Peggy FISCHER
National Science Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Investigating Research Misconduct Across International Borders Principles and Practices (PPT - 233 KB)
Word (24 KB)
Ms Annette FLANAGIN amp Dr Muza
JAMA Journal of the American Medical Association Chicago USA
African Journal Partnership Project (PPT - 560 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 14
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
GONDWE amp University of Malawi College of Medicine Blantyre Malawi
Prof William GARDNER
The Ohio State University Columbus USA
Research Misconduct International Cooperation (PPT - 297 KB)
Prof Herbert GOTTWEIS
University of Vienna Institut fuumlr Politikwissenschaft Austria
Hwang-gate Lessons for Science Governance (PDF - 12 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Chris GRAF Wiley-Blackwell Oxford UK
What are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics (PPT - 13 MB)
Mr Angel GURRIA
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
Remarks
Prof Ian HALLIDAY
European Science Foundation Strasbourg France
Integrating Responsibility The Research Student Perspective (PPT - 170 KB)
Mr Joel HASSE FERREIRA
European Parliament Brussels Belgium
Public Policies and Strategies Fostering Research Integrity (Word - 28 KB)
Dr Elizabeth HEITMAN
Vanderbilt University Medical Center Nashville USA
The Need for Global Strategies for Training Students in RCR (PPT - 101 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Manuel HEITOR
Portuguese Ministry for Science Technology and Higher Education (MCTES) Lisbon Portugal
- Do We Need a Revisited Policy Agenda for Research IntegrityAn Institutional Perspective (PDF - 98 KB)- Concluding Remarks (PDF - 32 KB)
PDF (187 KB)
Prof Helena ILLNEROVA
Academy of Sciences Prague Czech Republic
Trust in Research and the Importance of Training (Word - 43 KB)
Word (28 KB)
Prof Matthias KAISER
The National Committee for Research Ethics in Science and Technology (NENT) Oslo Norway
International Cooperation to Foster Research Integrity Reflections on Actors and Instruments (PPT - 21 MB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 15
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Dr Katrina KELNER
Science Magazine Washington USA
Science s Efforts to Ensure Research Integrity (PPT - 250 KB)
Word (22 KB)
Dr Sabine KLEINERT
The Lancet London UK How Can Good Publication Standards Influence Research Integrity Part1 (PPT - 47 MB) amp Part2 (PPT - 73 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Anthony KOMAROFF
Harvard Medical School Boston USA
Problems Undermining Public Confidence in and Understanding Research (PPT - 81 KB)
Word (32 KB)
Dr Philip LANGLAIS
Old Dominion University Norfolk USA
Institutional and Societal Issues Educating for Responsible Research (PPT - 235 KB)
Dr Nigel LLOYD
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Canada (NSERC) Ottawa Canada
Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct (PPT - 36 KB)
Word (57 KB)
Dr Joao LOBO ANTUNES
Hospital de Santa Maria Serviccedilo de Neurocirurgia Lisboa Portugal
To Publish or Not To Publish Communicating Science in a New Global and Financial Environment (PPT - 60 MB)
Professor Fernando LOPES DA SILVA
University van Amsterdam The Netherlands
Integrity in Biomedical Research The Role of Education (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Brian MARTINSON
HealthPartners Research Foundation (HPRF) Minneapolis USA
Research Integrity and the Social and Psychological Environments of Science (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Ana MARUSIC
Zagreb University School of Medicine Croatia
Why are scientific journals small or large important in fostering research integrity (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Shamila NAIR-BEDOUELLE
UNESCO Paris France COMESTs Role in Fostering Integrity in Research (PPT - 531 KB)
Prof Paumlr Vetenskapsraringdet (Swedish Closing Remarks (PPT - 23
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 16
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
amp Dr Andrea POZZI
Oxford Internet Institute UK amp Stanford University Landau Economics Centre USA
Scientific Misconduct in Publicly Funded Research What Can We Learn from the ORIs Investigations in of US Cases in the Biomedical and Behavioral Sciences (PDF - 648 KB)
KB)
Dr Vladimir DE SEMIR
Universitat Pompeu Fabra Journalism and Audiovisual Communication Department Barcelona ES
Research Integrity amp Knowledge Society R+D+i is not enough (PDF - 243 MB)
Dr Amaboo DHAI
University of the Witwatersrand Medical School Steve Biko Centre for Bioethics Parktown South Africa
Preserving Protecting amp Improving Research Integrity in Africa Challenges and Recommendations (PPT - 6 MB)
Word (short biography) (29 KB) - Word (long version) (118 KB)
Dr Pieter DRENTH
All European Academies (ALLEA) Amsterdam The Netherlands
Strengths and Weaknesses of Currrent Policies and Practices (PPT - 116 KB)
Word (36 KB)
Prof Ayse ERZAN
Istanbul Technical University Faculty of Sciences and Letters Turkey
Developing and Applying Integrity Policies in a Global Context (PPT - 102 KB)
Word (KB)
Prof Michael FARTHING
University of London UK Institutional Perspectives on Integrity of Publication (PPT - 702 KB)
Prof Carlos FIOLHAIS
University of Coimbra Portugal
- Scientific Integrity and Scientific Culture Telling the Truth to the Public (PPT- 20 MB)- Extended Abstract (Word - 42 KB)
Word (26 KB)
Dr Peggy FISCHER
National Science Foundation (NSF) Arlington USA
Investigating Research Misconduct Across International Borders Principles and Practices (PPT - 233 KB)
Word (24 KB)
Ms Annette FLANAGIN amp Dr Muza
JAMA Journal of the American Medical Association Chicago USA
African Journal Partnership Project (PPT - 560 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 14
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
GONDWE amp University of Malawi College of Medicine Blantyre Malawi
Prof William GARDNER
The Ohio State University Columbus USA
Research Misconduct International Cooperation (PPT - 297 KB)
Prof Herbert GOTTWEIS
University of Vienna Institut fuumlr Politikwissenschaft Austria
Hwang-gate Lessons for Science Governance (PDF - 12 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Chris GRAF Wiley-Blackwell Oxford UK
What are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics (PPT - 13 MB)
Mr Angel GURRIA
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
Remarks
Prof Ian HALLIDAY
European Science Foundation Strasbourg France
Integrating Responsibility The Research Student Perspective (PPT - 170 KB)
Mr Joel HASSE FERREIRA
European Parliament Brussels Belgium
Public Policies and Strategies Fostering Research Integrity (Word - 28 KB)
Dr Elizabeth HEITMAN
Vanderbilt University Medical Center Nashville USA
The Need for Global Strategies for Training Students in RCR (PPT - 101 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Manuel HEITOR
Portuguese Ministry for Science Technology and Higher Education (MCTES) Lisbon Portugal
- Do We Need a Revisited Policy Agenda for Research IntegrityAn Institutional Perspective (PDF - 98 KB)- Concluding Remarks (PDF - 32 KB)
PDF (187 KB)
Prof Helena ILLNEROVA
Academy of Sciences Prague Czech Republic
Trust in Research and the Importance of Training (Word - 43 KB)
Word (28 KB)
Prof Matthias KAISER
The National Committee for Research Ethics in Science and Technology (NENT) Oslo Norway
International Cooperation to Foster Research Integrity Reflections on Actors and Instruments (PPT - 21 MB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 15
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Dr Katrina KELNER
Science Magazine Washington USA
Science s Efforts to Ensure Research Integrity (PPT - 250 KB)
Word (22 KB)
Dr Sabine KLEINERT
The Lancet London UK How Can Good Publication Standards Influence Research Integrity Part1 (PPT - 47 MB) amp Part2 (PPT - 73 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Anthony KOMAROFF
Harvard Medical School Boston USA
Problems Undermining Public Confidence in and Understanding Research (PPT - 81 KB)
Word (32 KB)
Dr Philip LANGLAIS
Old Dominion University Norfolk USA
Institutional and Societal Issues Educating for Responsible Research (PPT - 235 KB)
Dr Nigel LLOYD
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Canada (NSERC) Ottawa Canada
Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct (PPT - 36 KB)
Word (57 KB)
Dr Joao LOBO ANTUNES
Hospital de Santa Maria Serviccedilo de Neurocirurgia Lisboa Portugal
To Publish or Not To Publish Communicating Science in a New Global and Financial Environment (PPT - 60 MB)
Professor Fernando LOPES DA SILVA
University van Amsterdam The Netherlands
Integrity in Biomedical Research The Role of Education (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Brian MARTINSON
HealthPartners Research Foundation (HPRF) Minneapolis USA
Research Integrity and the Social and Psychological Environments of Science (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Ana MARUSIC
Zagreb University School of Medicine Croatia
Why are scientific journals small or large important in fostering research integrity (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Shamila NAIR-BEDOUELLE
UNESCO Paris France COMESTs Role in Fostering Integrity in Research (PPT - 531 KB)
Prof Paumlr Vetenskapsraringdet (Swedish Closing Remarks (PPT - 23
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 16
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
GONDWE amp University of Malawi College of Medicine Blantyre Malawi
Prof William GARDNER
The Ohio State University Columbus USA
Research Misconduct International Cooperation (PPT - 297 KB)
Prof Herbert GOTTWEIS
University of Vienna Institut fuumlr Politikwissenschaft Austria
Hwang-gate Lessons for Science Governance (PDF - 12 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Chris GRAF Wiley-Blackwell Oxford UK
What are Publishers Doing About Publication Ethics (PPT - 13 MB)
Mr Angel GURRIA
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
Remarks
Prof Ian HALLIDAY
European Science Foundation Strasbourg France
Integrating Responsibility The Research Student Perspective (PPT - 170 KB)
Mr Joel HASSE FERREIRA
European Parliament Brussels Belgium
Public Policies and Strategies Fostering Research Integrity (Word - 28 KB)
Dr Elizabeth HEITMAN
Vanderbilt University Medical Center Nashville USA
The Need for Global Strategies for Training Students in RCR (PPT - 101 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Manuel HEITOR
Portuguese Ministry for Science Technology and Higher Education (MCTES) Lisbon Portugal
- Do We Need a Revisited Policy Agenda for Research IntegrityAn Institutional Perspective (PDF - 98 KB)- Concluding Remarks (PDF - 32 KB)
PDF (187 KB)
Prof Helena ILLNEROVA
Academy of Sciences Prague Czech Republic
Trust in Research and the Importance of Training (Word - 43 KB)
Word (28 KB)
Prof Matthias KAISER
The National Committee for Research Ethics in Science and Technology (NENT) Oslo Norway
International Cooperation to Foster Research Integrity Reflections on Actors and Instruments (PPT - 21 MB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 15
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Dr Katrina KELNER
Science Magazine Washington USA
Science s Efforts to Ensure Research Integrity (PPT - 250 KB)
Word (22 KB)
Dr Sabine KLEINERT
The Lancet London UK How Can Good Publication Standards Influence Research Integrity Part1 (PPT - 47 MB) amp Part2 (PPT - 73 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Anthony KOMAROFF
Harvard Medical School Boston USA
Problems Undermining Public Confidence in and Understanding Research (PPT - 81 KB)
Word (32 KB)
Dr Philip LANGLAIS
Old Dominion University Norfolk USA
Institutional and Societal Issues Educating for Responsible Research (PPT - 235 KB)
Dr Nigel LLOYD
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Canada (NSERC) Ottawa Canada
Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct (PPT - 36 KB)
Word (57 KB)
Dr Joao LOBO ANTUNES
Hospital de Santa Maria Serviccedilo de Neurocirurgia Lisboa Portugal
To Publish or Not To Publish Communicating Science in a New Global and Financial Environment (PPT - 60 MB)
Professor Fernando LOPES DA SILVA
University van Amsterdam The Netherlands
Integrity in Biomedical Research The Role of Education (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Brian MARTINSON
HealthPartners Research Foundation (HPRF) Minneapolis USA
Research Integrity and the Social and Psychological Environments of Science (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Ana MARUSIC
Zagreb University School of Medicine Croatia
Why are scientific journals small or large important in fostering research integrity (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Shamila NAIR-BEDOUELLE
UNESCO Paris France COMESTs Role in Fostering Integrity in Research (PPT - 531 KB)
Prof Paumlr Vetenskapsraringdet (Swedish Closing Remarks (PPT - 23
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 16
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Dr Katrina KELNER
Science Magazine Washington USA
Science s Efforts to Ensure Research Integrity (PPT - 250 KB)
Word (22 KB)
Dr Sabine KLEINERT
The Lancet London UK How Can Good Publication Standards Influence Research Integrity Part1 (PPT - 47 MB) amp Part2 (PPT - 73 MB)
Word (30 KB)
Dr Anthony KOMAROFF
Harvard Medical School Boston USA
Problems Undermining Public Confidence in and Understanding Research (PPT - 81 KB)
Word (32 KB)
Dr Philip LANGLAIS
Old Dominion University Norfolk USA
Institutional and Societal Issues Educating for Responsible Research (PPT - 235 KB)
Dr Nigel LLOYD
Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council Canada (NSERC) Ottawa Canada
Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct (PPT - 36 KB)
Word (57 KB)
Dr Joao LOBO ANTUNES
Hospital de Santa Maria Serviccedilo de Neurocirurgia Lisboa Portugal
To Publish or Not To Publish Communicating Science in a New Global and Financial Environment (PPT - 60 MB)
Professor Fernando LOPES DA SILVA
University van Amsterdam The Netherlands
Integrity in Biomedical Research The Role of Education (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Brian MARTINSON
HealthPartners Research Foundation (HPRF) Minneapolis USA
Research Integrity and the Social and Psychological Environments of Science (PPT - 166 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Ana MARUSIC
Zagreb University School of Medicine Croatia
Why are scientific journals small or large important in fostering research integrity (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (25 KB)
Dr Shamila NAIR-BEDOUELLE
UNESCO Paris France COMESTs Role in Fostering Integrity in Research (PPT - 531 KB)
Prof Paumlr Vetenskapsraringdet (Swedish Closing Remarks (PPT - 23
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 16
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
OMLING Research Council Stockholm Sweden
MB)
Prof Motoyuki ONO
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) Tokyo Japan
The Development of Codes Standards and Guidelines in Japan (PPT - 344 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Dr Chris PASCAL
Director Office of Research Integrity (ORI) US Department of Health and Human Services Rockville USA
Managing Cases of Research Misconduct The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Experience (PPT - 77 KB)
Word (33 KB)
Prof Janez POTOCNIK
European Commission Brussels BE
European Research Towards the Highest Standards of Integrity
Prof Ren-Zong QIU
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) Bioethics Programme Beijing China
Research Integrity Issues in China-Mainland (PTT - 204 KB)
Word (27 KB)
Prof Alexandre QUINTANILHA
Institute for Molecular and Cell Biology (IBMC) Porto Portugal
Individual Integrity and Institutional Trust (Word - 38 KB)
Dr Sally J ROCKEY
National Institutes of Health (NIH) Bethesda USA
Integrating Integrity into the Research Process through Training (PPT - 40 MB)
Word (33 KB)
Dr Mike ROSSNER
The Journal of Cell Biology New York USA
The Role of the Journal Editor in Assuring the Integrity of Research Data (PTT - 57 MB)
Word (24 KB)
Prof Guumln R SEMIN
Free University of Amsterdam The Netherlands
Enhancing the Self-Monitoring Function of Science and its Contribution to Integrity in Research (PTT - 440 KB)
Dr Andrew STAINTHORPE
UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO) London UK
Approaches to Case Handling (PPT - 46 KB)
Dr Herbert STEGEMANN
Asociacioacuten de Editores de Revistas Biomeacutedicas
The Potential of Local Editors Associations in
Word (25 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 17
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Venezolanas (ASEREME) Caracas Venezuela
Promoting Ethics in Publication (PTT - 393 KB)
Prof Nicholas STENECK
Office of Research Integrity (ORI) Rockville USA
What Do We Know Two Decades of Research on Research Integrity (PPT - 22 KB)
Dr Peter TINDEMANS
Euroscience Strasbroug Francehttpwwwess-europede
Conference Summary An Action-Oriented Approach (PPT - 125 KB)
Word (29 KB)
Prof Ovid JL TZENG
Academia Sinica National Yang Ming University Taipei Taiwan
Excellence with a Soul Fostering Research Integrity in a Changing Society (PPT - 34 MB)
Dr Liz WAGER Committee on Publications Ethics (COPE) London UK
Publication - the Role of Editors and Journals Current Best Practices (PPT - 11 MB)
Word (40 KB)
Dr Peteris ZILGALVIS
European Commission Directorate L - Science Economy and Society Brussels Belgium
Role of Funders in Publication Ethics (PPT - 853 KB)
Word (33 KB)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 18
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
Ministegravere de lEnseignement supeacuterieur et de la Recherche wwwenseignementsup-recherchegouvfr
Le cas Hwang Lessons for Science GovenanceHerbert Gottweis [Department of Political ScienceLife Science Governance ResearchInstitute University of Vienna]Presentation at the ESF-ORI First World Conference onRESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCHLisboa September 16-19 2007I am grateful to Byoungsoo Kim for research support
Lessons for Research IntegrityGovernance from ldquoHwang Gaterdquo1048726 Hyping science can lead to fraudulent science (1)1048726 Peer-review is no substitute for good science governance (2)1048726 Research integrity is increasingly a matter of network integrity(3)1048726 The globalization of science leads to a globalization of the ideaof research integrity (4)1048726 When dealing with cases of the scientific fraud act quickly anddecisively ndash and have the right institutions in place (5)
3 rue Michel Ange 75794 ndash Paris Teacutel +33(0)144 964 000 19
- Geacuteneacuteral
- Livres
- Articles de revues
- Etudes
- Articles de journaux communications et sites internet
- Newsletters Annonces
- Codes et textes en vigueur avis recommandations
- Recensements
- Rapports
- Colloques et confeacuterences
- Logiciels de lutte contre le plagiat
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- References amp Background Reading
- NATURE
- NATURE In the Field
- NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY
- SCIENCE
- BMJ
- RESEARCH POLICY
- IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY
- THE LANCET
- CELL
- SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS
- CHEMICAL amp ENGINEERING NEWS
- OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (ORI) NEWSLETTER
- BOOKS
- ESF-ORI First World Conference on
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY FOSTERING RESPONSIBLE RESEARCH
- Invited Papers amp Biographies
-
![Mutations in the Pectin Methyltransferase QUASIMODO2 ...Mutations in the Pectin Methyltransferase QUASIMODO2 Influence Cellulose Biosynthesis and Wall Integrity in Arabidopsis[OPEN]](https://static.fdocuments.fr/doc/165x107/609d35a4bb8ab77aa43faa7a/mutations-in-the-pectin-methyltransferase-quasimodo2-mutations-in-the-pectin.jpg)
