>'5' AVPURY - SeyLII 9 of 2014 Prohibition of... · *,, 2b>>:6;6>:6;6

12
%%0% )!(%)$) , L*0aU5]_VY*(),> 2B>>:6;6<AA=1779493: /3D6AA6 **+ DEC<=6=G=CB C: GE5::=7?=B; =B D9EFCBF 57G% *(), ".4A ' =7)'(*# 5EE5B;9A9BG C: F97G=CBF F97G=CBF D5EG =&DE9@=A=B5EK )' FU\_aaVaYR N[QP\ZZR[PRZR[a *' =[aR_]_RaNaV\[ D5EG ==&GE5::=7?=B; =B D9EFCBF +' G_NSSVPXV[T V[]R_`\[` ,' 7UVYQ a_NSSVPXV[T -' 5TT_NcNaV[T PV_PbZ`aN[PR` .' 6R[RSVaV[T S_\Z Re]Y\VaNaV\[ \S a_NSSVPXV[T V[]R_`\[` /' 5VQV[T% NORaaV[T \_ NaaRZ]aV[T V[P\ZZV``V\[ \S \SSR[PR \S a_NSSVPXV[T V[]R_`\[` & 0' D_\Z\aV\[ \Sa_NSSVPXV[T V[]R_`\[` 1' 7Y\`b_R\_QR_ D5EG ### F9EI=79F GC DE9FHA98 I=7G=AF C: GE5::=7?=B; 5B8 I=7G=A C: GE5::=7?=B; )(' ER]\_aV[TN[Q_RSR__NY ))' 8RPV`V\[\[ R[a_fV[a\FRfPURYYR` )*' JVa[R`` ]_\aRPaV\[ )+' D_\aRPaV\[ \S]_VcNPf\S ]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ` \Sa_NSSVPXV[T ),' IbY[R_NOYR dVa[R`` )-' 8R]\_aNaV\[\S ]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ` \S a_NSSVPXV[T ).' =``bN[PR\S]R_ZVa\ N]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ` \S a_NSSVPXV[T )/' B\[&YVNOVYVaf \S cVPaVZ` \S a_NSSVPXV[T )0' 7\Z]R[`NaV\[ )1' ERab_[\S a_NSSVPXRQ PVaVgR[` N[Q]R_ZN[R[a_R`VQR[a` \S FRfPURYYR`

Transcript of >'5' AVPURY - SeyLII 9 of 2014 Prohibition of... · *,, 2b>>:6;6>:6;6

Page 1: >'5' AVPURY - SeyLII 9 of 2014 Prohibition of... · *,, 2b>>:6;6>:6;6

%%0%)!(%)$) ,

L*0aU5]_VY*(),> 2B>>:6;6<AA=1779493:/3D6AA6 **+

DEC<=6=G=CB C: GE5::=7?=B; =B D9EFCBF 57G%*(),

".4A ' =7)'(*#

5EE5B;9A9BG C: F97G=CBF

F97G=CBFD5EG =&DE9@=A=B5EK

)' FU\_aaVaYRN[QP\ZZR[PRZR[a*' =[aR_]_RaNaV\[

D5EG ==&GE5::=7?=B; =B D9EFCBF

+' G_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`,' 7UVYQa_NSSVPXV[T-' 5TT_NcNaV[TPV_PbZ`aN[PR`.' 6R[RSVaV[TS_\Z Re]Y\VaNaV\[\S a_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`/' 5VQV[T%NORaaV[T\_ NaaRZ]aV[TV[P\ZZV``V\[ \S \SSR[PR\S a_NSSVPXV[T

V[]R_`\[` &0' D_\Z\aV\[ \Sa_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`1' 7Y\`b_R\_QR_

D5EG ### F9EI=79F GC DE9FHA98 I=7G=AF C:GE5::=7?=B; 5B8 I=7G=A C: GE5::=7?=B;

)(' ER]\_aV[TN[Q_RSR__NY))' 8RPV`V\[\[ R[a_fV[a\FRfPURYYR`)*' JVa[R`` ]_\aRPaV\[)+' D_\aRPaV\[\S ]_VcNPf\S ]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ\Sa_NSSVPXV[T),' IbY[R_NOYRdVa[R``)-' 8R]\_aNaV\[\S ]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ`\S a_NSSVPXV[T).' =``bN[PR\S ]R_ZVaa\ N]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[T)/' B\[&YVNOVYVaf\S cVPaVZ`\S a_NSSVPXV[T)0' 7\Z]R[`NaV\[)1' ERab_[\S a_NSSVPXRQPVaVgR[N[Q]R_ZN[R[a_R`VQR[a`\S FRfPURYYR`

Page 2: >'5' AVPURY - SeyLII 9 of 2014 Prohibition of... · *,, 2b>>:6;6>:6;6

, %

**, 2B>>:6;6<AA=1779493:/3D6AA6 L*0aU5]_VY*(),M

D5EG =I &B5G=CB5@ 7CCE8=B5G=B; 7CAA=GG99 CBGE5::=7?=B; =B D9EFCBF

*(' BNaV\[NY7\\_QV[NaV[T7\ZZVaaRR\[ G_NSSVPXV[TV[DR_`\[`*)' 7\Z]\`VaV\[ \S 7\ZZVaaRR**' :b[PaV\[` \S 7\ZZVaaRR*+' ARRaV[T`*,' FRP_RaN_VNa

D5EG I &GE5::=7?=B; =B D9EFCBF :HB8

*-' G_NSSVPXV[TV[DR_`\[` :b[Q*.' 5PP\b[a` N[QNbQVa*/' DYN[\S NPaVcVaVR`*0' 5[[bNY_R]\_a

D5EG I= &A=F79@@5B9CHF

*1' 8V_RPaV\[OfAV[V`aR_\[ ]\YVPf+(' 5]]YVPNaV\[\S ]_\cV`V\[` \S DR[NY7\QR+)' D_\aRPaV\[\S NPaQ\[R V[T\\Q SNVaU+*' ERTbYNaV\[`

%%%%.)%%(

L*0aU5]_VY*(),M 2B>>:6;6<AA=1779493:/3D6AA6 *,-

+(' GURZRZOR_`%\SSVPR_N[Q\aUR_RZ]Y\fRR` \S aUR7\ZZVaaRR `UNYYORQRRZRQa\ ORRZ]Y\fRQ V[ aUR]bOYVP`R_cVPRN[Q`RPaV\[`1) a\ 1. \S aURDR[NY7\QR `UNYYN]]Yfa\aURZ'

+)' 5[f PVcVY`bVa\_ \aUR_YRTNY]_\PRRQV[T`UNYY[\aYVRNTNV[`aaUR7\ZZVaaRR%ZRZOR_`%\SSVPR_N[Q \aUR_RZ]Y\fRR` \S aUR7\ZZVaaRR V[ _R`]RPa\S N[ NPaQ\[R \_V[aR[QRQa\ ORQ\[R V[T\\Q SNVaUV[]b_`bN[PR\S aUV5Pa'

5]]YVPNaV\[\S ]_\cV`V\[`\S DR[NY7\QR

D_\aRPaV\[\SNPa`Q\[R V[T\\Q SNVaU

+*' GUR AV[V`aR_ZNf% V[ P\[`bYaNaV\[ dVaU aUR ERTbYNaV\[`

7\ZZVaaRR%ZNXR_RTbYNaV\[`S\_&

#N$ N[f ZNaaR_dUVPUV _R^bV_RQ\_ [RPR``N_fa\OR]_R`P_VORQa\ TVcRRSSRPaa\ aUR]_\cV`V\[`\S aUV5Pa3

#O$ aUR]_\PRQb_RNaZRRaV[T\S aUR7\ZZVaaRR3

#P$ aUR7\QR \S 7\[QbPa S\_ ZRZOR_` \S aUR7\ZZVaaRRV[\_QR_a\ ]_RcR[a P\[SYVPa\SV[aR_R`aN[Q O_V[TV[TaUR7\ZZVaaRR V[a\QV`_R]baR'

= PR_aVSfaUNaaUVV`NP\__RPaP\]f \S aUR6VYYdUVPUdN`]N``RQOf aURBNaV\[NY5``RZOYf \[ )-aU 5]_VY%*(),'

#L$#5>Y)4S4&h@bV`NJNfR&<VcR8R]baf 7YR_X

!

Page 3: >'5' AVPURY - SeyLII 9 of 2014 Prohibition of... · *,, 2b>>:6;6>:6;6

*,, 2B>>:6;6<AA=1779493:/3D6AA6 L*0aU5]_VY*(),M 2B>>:6;6<AA=1779493:/3D6AA6L*0aU5]_VY*(),M **-

DYN[\SNPaVcVaVR`

5[[bNY_R]\_a

8V_RPaV\[OfAV[V`aR_\[]\YVPf

%%%0%.%(%%(

#+$ GURNPP\b[a \S aUR7\ZZVaaRR`UNYYORNbQVaRQOfaUR5bQVa\_;R[R_NYV[ NPP\_QN[PRdVaU5_aVPYR)-0 \S aUR7\[`aVabaV\['

#,$ JUR_R aURNPP\b[a` N[Q `aNaRZR[a\S NPP\b[a` \SaUR7\ZZVaaRRV[_R`]RPa\S NSV[N[PVNYfRN_UNcRORR[NbQVaRQ%aUR7\ZZVaaRR `UNYYSb_[V`UaURAV[V`aR_N P\]f \S aUR`aNaRZR[aa\TRaUR_dVaUNP\]f \S N[f _R]\_a Of aUR5bQVa\_;R[R_NY\[ aURaNaRZR[a\S NPP\b[a` \_ \[ aURNPP\b[a` \S aUR7\ZZVaaRR'

DEC<=6=G=CB C: GE5::=7?=B; =B D9EFCBF57G%*(),

".4A 1 =7)'(*#*/'#)$ GUR7\ZZVaaRR UNYY]_R]N_RN]YN[\S NPaVcVaVR`N[Q

`bOZVaVaNaYRN`a+( QNf`ORS\_RaURORTV[[V[T\S RNPUSV[N[PVNYfRN_a\ aURAV[V`aR_S\_UV\_ UR_N]]_\cNY'

0 3@@6<A

h'!#*$ GUR]YN[\S NPaVcVaVR`b[QR_ bO`RPaV\[#)$`UNYY&

>' 5' AVPURYD_R`VQR[a

#N$ V[PYbQRN`aNaRZR[a\S aURU\_aN[QZRQVbZaR_Z\OWRPaVcR`\S aUR7\ZZVaaRR3N[Q

#O$ \baYV[RaUR`a_NaRTVR`aUNaaUR7\ZZVaaRRV[aR[Qa\ VZ]YRZR[aV[\_QR_a\ NPUVRcRVa`\OWRPaVcR`b[QR_aUV5Pa'

)+A8.>?9:$)'(*

*0' GUR7\ZZVaaRR`UNYY%N``\\[ N`]\``VOYRNSaR_aURRe]V_NaV\[\S RNPUSV[N[PVNYfRN_N[QV[N[f RcR[a[\a YNaR_aUN[aUR+) `a QNf\S AN_PUV[N[f fRN_%bOZVaa\ aURAV[V`aR_N[N[[bNY_R]\_aQRNYV[TTR[R_NYYfdVaUaURNQZV[V`a_NaV\[N[QVa`NPaVcVaVR`Qb_V[TaUR]_RPRQV[TSV[N[PVNYfRN_N[QaURAV[V`aR_`UNYYPNb`RaUR_R]\_aa\ ORaNOYRQV[aURBNaV\[NY5``RZOYf'

5B 57G a\ ]_\cVQR S\_ aUR]_\UVOVaV\[%]_RcR[aV\[ N[QP\ZONaV[T \S a_NSSVPXV[TV[ ]R_`\[` N[Q ZRN`b_R` a\]_\aRPa N[Q N``V`acVPaVZ`\S a_NSSVPXV[TV[ ]R_`\[` a\b]QNaRN[Q Z\QR_[V`R YNd`\[ UbZN[ a_NSSVPXV[TN[Q a\TVcRRSSRPaa\ aUR]_\cV`V\[` \S aURD_\a\P\Y a\ D_RcR[a%Fb]]_R`` N[Q Db[V`U G_NSSVPXV[TV[ DR_`\[% 9`]RPVNYYfJ\ZR[ N[Q 7UVYQ_R[%`b]]YRZR[aV[T aURH[VaRQBNaV\[`7\[cR[aV\[ NTNV[`aG_N[`[NaV\[NYC_TN[V`RQ7_VZR N[QS\_ ZNaaR_ P\[[RPaRQaUR_RdVaU\_ V[PVQR[aNYaUR_Ra\'

D5EG I= &A=F79@@5B9CHF9B57G98 Of aURD_R`VQR[aN[QaURBNaV\[NY5``RZOYf'

*1' GURAV[V`aR_ZNf TVcRV[d_VaV[TaURQV_RPaV\[`\S]\YVPf a\ aUR7\ZZVaaRR V[ _RTN_Qa\ aURQV`PUN_TR\S Va`Sb[PaV\[`b[QR_aUV5Pa N[QaUR7\ZZVaaRR`UNYYP\Z]Yf dVaU`bPUQV_RPaV\[`'

D5EG =&DE9@=A=B5EK

)' GUV 5Pa ZNf OR PVaRQN` aUR D_\UVOVaV\[\SG_NSSVPXV[TV[DR_`\[` 5Pa%*(),3 N[Q`UNYYP\ZR V[a\\]R_NaV\[\[ `bPUNQNaRN`aURAV[V`aR_ZNf%Of B\aVPR]bOYV`URQV[aUR/3D6AA6$N]]\V[a'

FU\_a aVaYRN[QP\ZZR[PRZR[a

&%

Page 4: >'5' AVPURY - SeyLII 9 of 2014 Prohibition of... · *,, 2b>>:6;6>:6;6

**. 2B>>:6;6<A A=1779493:/3D6AA6 L*0aU5]_VY*(),M L*0aU5]_VY*(),M 2B>>:6;6<A A=1779493:/3D6AA6 *,+

=[aR_]_RaNaV\[ ! =[ aUV5Pa%b[YR`` aURP\[aRea \aUR_dV`R_R^bV_R`& D5EG I &GE5::=7?=B; =B D9EFCBF :HB8

%%0.(%%(

PUVYQ ZRN[` N]R_`\[ b[QR_aURNTR\S )03 *-'# )$ GUR_RV UR_ROfR`aNOYV`URQNG_NSSVPXV[TV[DR_`\[`:b[Q% dUVPU `UNYYOR ZN[NTRQ Of aUR 7\ZZVaaRR% V[NPP\_QN[PRdVaUaURDbOYVP:V[N[PR AN[NTRZR[a 5Pa%*()*' P\R_PV\[ ZRN[` b`R \S S\_PR\_ aU_RNaaUR_R\S%N[Q

`\ZR S\_Z` \S [\[&cV\YR[a \_ ]`fPU\Y\TVPNYb`R \SS\_PR\_ aU_RNaaUR_R\S%V[PYbQV[T& #*$ GUR:b[Q `UNYYP\[`V`a \S&

#N$ aURZ\[Rf` NYY\PNaRQS_\Z aUR7\[`\YVQNaRQ:b[Q3#N$ aU_RNa\S UN_Z \_ ]Uf`VPNY_R`a_NV[a\S N[f

]R_`\[3

#O$ N[f `PURZR%]YN[ \_ ]NaaR_[V[aR[QRQa\ PNb`RN]R_`\[ a\ ORYVRcRaUNaSNVYb_Ra\ ]R_S\_Z N[NPad\bYQ _R`bYaV[`R_V\b`UN_Za\ \_ ]Uf`VPNY_R`a_NV[aNTNV[`aN[f ]R_`\[3

#O$ Q\[NaV\[` _RPRVcRQS\_ aUR]b_]\`R` \S aUR:b[Q3 N[Q

#P$ N[f \aUR_`\b_PR N`ZNf ORQRaR_ZV[RQOf aURAV[V`aR_'

#P$ NOb`R\_ N[f aU_RNaYV[XRQa\ aURYRTNY`aNab`\SN]R_`\[3 \_

#+$ GUR:b[Q ZNf ORN]]YVRQS\_&

#Q$ ]`fPU\Y\TVPNY]_R``b_R3#N$ aUR]NfZR[a \S Re]R[`R` _RYNaRQa\ ]_\cV`V\[

\S `R_cVPRa\ ]_R`bZRQ cVPaVZ \S a_NSSVPXV[TN[QcVPaVZ\Sa_NSSVPXV[T3

7\ZZVaaRR ZRN[` aUR BNaV\[NY 7\\_QV[NaV[T7\ZZVaaRR \[ G_NSSVPXV[TV[DR_`\[` R`aNOYV`URQV[`RPaV\[*(3

#O$ aUR]NfZR[a \S P\Z]R[`NaV\[ V[NPP\_QN[PRdVaU RPaV\[ )03 N[Q

QR`VT[NaRQURYaR_ ZRN[` N ]YNPRQR`VT[NaRQN``bPUOf aURAV[V`aR_V[aR_Z` \S `RPaV\[ )( #.$#O$3

#P$ N[f \aUR_]b_]\`R N` ZNf ORQRaR_ZV[RQOfaURAV[V`aR_[RPR``N_fS\_ aURVZ]YRZR[aNaV\[\S aUV5Pa'

Re]Y\VaNaV\[ V[PYbQR`&#,$ GUR5bQVa\_ ;R[R_NY`UNYYR[`b_R aUR]_R]N_NaV\[\S

]_\]R_ O\\X` \S NPP\b[a V[_RYNaV\[a\ aUR:b[Q'#N$ `RebNYRe]Y\VaNaV\[3

#O$ S\_PRQYNO\b_\_ `R_cVPR`3 *.'#)$ GURSV[N[PVNYfRN_ \S aUR7\ZZVaaRR `UNYYORaURPNYR[QN_fRN_'

#P$ `bOWRPaV[TN ]R_`\[ a\ ]_NPaVPR` VZVYN_a\`YNcR_f3 #*$ GUR7\ZZVaaRR `UNYYZNV[aNV[]_\]R_ NPP\b[a` N[Q

\aUR__RYRcN[a_RP\_Q`N[Q ]_R]N_RN`aNaRZR[a\S NPP\b[a` V[aURS\_Z N[QZN[[R_ N]]_\cRQ Of aUR5bQVa\_;R[R_NY'#Q$ V[c\Yb[aN_f `R_cVabQR3

G_NSSVPXV[TV[DR_`\[` :b[Q

5PP\b[a`N[Q NbQVa`

Page 5: >'5' AVPURY - SeyLII 9 of 2014 Prohibition of... · *,, 2b>>:6;6>:6;6

*,* 2B>>:6;6<AA=1779493:/3D6AA6 L*0aU5]_VY*(),M L*0aU5]_VY*(),M 2B>>:6;6<AA=1779493:/3D6AA6 **/

#-$ =[ N[f RcR[a\S N[RZR_TR[Pf& #R$ S_NbQbYR[ab`R \S N ]R_`\[ S\_ _RZ\cNY\SaURV_\_TN[` \_ O\Qf ]N_a`3\_

#N$ aURAV[V`aR_UNYYUNcR]\dR_` a\ PNYYN[Rea_N\_QV[N_fZRRaV[T\SaUR7\ZZVaaRR3 "-# S\_PRQZN__VNTR3

#O$ aUR7UNV_]R_`\[%V[ P\[`bYaNaV\[dVaUaURAV[V`aR_%`UNYYUNcR]\dR_` a\ PNYYN[Rea_N\_QV[N_fZRRaV[T\S aUR7\ZZVaaRRV[`bPUN[RcR[a'

:b[Q ZRN[` aURG_NSSVPXV[TV[ DR_`\[` :b[QR`aNOYV`URQV[ RPaV\[*-3

AV[V`aR_ ZRN[` aURAV[V`aR__R`]\[`VOYRS\_<\ZR 5SSNV_`3

#.$ FbOWRPaa\ aUR]_\cV`V\[` \SaUV5Pa%aUR7\ZZVaaRRZNf QRcRY\]_bYR_RYNaV[Ta\ aURP\[QbPa\S VaNSSNV_`' \_TN[V`RQP_VZV[NYT_\b] ZRN[` N `a_bPab_RQ

T_\b] \S aU_RR\_ Z\_R ]R_`\[`% ReV`aV[TS\_ N]R_V\Q\SaVZRN[QNPaV[TV[P\[PR_adVaUaURNVZ\SP\ZZVaaV[T \[R \_ Z\_R `R_V\b` \SSR[PR`%V[PYbQV[Ta_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`% V[\_QR_a\ \OaNV[QV_RPaYf\_ V[QV_RPaYfNSV[N[PVNY\_ \aUR_ZNaR_VNYOR[RSVa3

FRP_RaN_VNa *,'#)$ GURAV[V`aR_UNYY]_\cVQR bPU\SSVPR_N[Q\aUR_RZ]Y\fRR`N`ZNf OR[RPR``N_fS\_aURRSSVPVR[a]R_S\_ZN[PR\SaURSb[PaV\[` \S aUR7\ZZVaaRR b[QR_aUV5Pa%dUVPU UNYYSb[PaV\[N`aURFRP_RaN_VNa\S aUR7\ZZVaaRR'

#*$ GURFRP_RaN_VNa`UNYYOR_R`]\[`VOYRS\_&

#N$ \_TN[V`V[TZRRaV[T \S aUR7\ZZVaaRRN[QP\Z]VYV[TZV[baR`3

]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[T ZRN[` N]R_`\[ V[_R`]RPa\S dU\Z aUR_RN_R_RN`\[` a\ ORYVRcRaUNaUR\_ `URV NcVPaVZ\Sa_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`%dURaUR_\_ [\a aUR ]R_]Ra_Na\_ UN` ORR[ VQR[aVSVRQ%N]]_RUR[QRQ%]_\`RPbaRQ\_ P\[cVPaRQ3

#O$ N``V`aV[TaUR7\ZZVaaRRdVaUVZ]YRZR[aNaV\[\S VaNPaVcVaVR`3 ]_\aRPaV\[ ZRN[` aUR ]Uf`VPNY]_\aRPaV\[%

VQR[aVafN[Q]_VcNPf\S aURcVPaVZ\_ NdVa[R`` \Sa_NSSVPXV[TV[ ]R_`\[`% V[PYbQV[TZRN`b_R` a\]_\aRPaUVZ\_ UR_S_\Z V[aVZVQNaV\[N[Q_RaNYVNaV\[%Of XRR]V[TUVZ\_ UR_V[N`NSRN[Q`RPb_R]YNPR3

#P$ `R_cV[T N` N[ V[S\_ZNaV\[ PR[a_RdUVPUR[`b_R` Q\PbZR[aNaV\[%QNaNP\YYRPaV\[N[Qa_R[QN[NYf`V`\S aURa_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[` V[FRfPURYYR`3N[Q

#Q$ ,VNVV[ T dVa U [\[ &; &c R_[ ZR[ aN,\_TN[V`NaV\[S_\Z aURY\PNY%_RTV\[NYN[QV[aR_[NaV\[NY\_TN[V`NaV\[`'

D_\a\P\Y ZRN[` aURH[VaRQBNaV\[` D_\a\P\Ya\D_RcR[a%Fb]]_R`` N[Q Db[V`U G_NSSVPXV[TV[DR_`\[%9`]RPVNYYfJ\ZR[ N[Q7UVYQ_R[#NQ\]aRQOf aURH[VaRQBNaV\[` ;R[R_NY5``RZOYf \[ *.aU

8RPRZOR_%*((+$ `b]]YRZR[aV[T aUR H[VaRQBNaV\[` 7\[cR[aV\[ NTNV[`a G_N[`[NaV\[NYC_TN[V`RQ7_VZR#NQ\]aRQOf aURH[VaRQBNaV\[`;R[R_NY5``RZOYf \[ )-aUB\cRZOR_%*((($3

#+$ GUR7UNV_]R_`\[\S aUR7\ZZVaaRR`UNYYN]]\V[a NFRP_RaN_fS\_ aUR7\ZZVaaRRNZ\[T`a \SSVPR_`]_\cVQRQb[QR_`bO`RPaV\[#)$'

%%%0%.(%%(!

Page 6: >'5' AVPURY - SeyLII 9 of 2014 Prohibition of... · *,, 2b>>:6;6>:6;6

**0 2B>>:6;6<AA=1779493:/3D6AA6 L*0aU5]_VY*(),M L*0aU5]_VY*(),M 2B>>:6;6<AA=1779493:/3D6AA6 *,)

`RebNYRe]Y\VaNaV\[ ZRN[` & #Q$ YRTNYNQcVPRN[QN``V`aN[PR3

#R$ N``V`aN[PR\S N[ V[aR_]_RaR_\_ a_N[`YNa\_3

#S$ _R]Na_VNaV\[3

#T$ `\PVNY_RV[aRT_NaV\['

G_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`

%%0h2'2'

#N$ a\ R[P\b_NTR%V[QbPR%\_ S\_PRN]R_`\[ a\ ORb`RQS\_ aUR`RebNYT_NaVSVPNaV\[\S N[\aUR_]R_`\[3

#O$ a\ b`R N]R_`\[ V[\_ QRYVOR_NaRYfRe]\`V[T N]R_`\[ a\ `RebNYNPa \_ ]\_[\T_N]Uf V[cVRd\S P\ZZVaaV[TN[ NPa\S a_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[3\_

#,$ GUR]_R`bZRQ cVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[T\_ cVPaVZ\Sa_NSSVPXV[T`UNYYORV[S\_ZRQ\S aUR R_cVPRNcNVYNOYR%V[ NYN[TbNTRaURfb[QR_`aN[Q'

#P$ a\ ]_\Pb_R\_ NYY\dN]R_`\[ a\ OR]_\Pb_RQS\_P\ZZR_PVNYRebNYRe]Y\VaNaV\[\_ V[N[f dNf]N_aVPV]NaR\_ N``V`aV[aURP\ZZR_PVNYRebNYRe]Y\VaNaV\[\S N]R_`\[%

S\_ aUR]b_]\`R` \S \OaNV[V[TSV[N[PVNY\_ \aUR_OR[RSVa`3

#-$ GUR AV[V`aR_ZNf% V[ P\[`bYaNaV\[ dVaU aUR7\ZZVaaRR%N[QdVaUQbR_RTN_Qa\ `NSRafN[Q`RPb_Vaf\S aUR]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[TN[QcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[T%OfB\aVPR]bOYV`URQV[aUR/3D6AA6%

#N$ QR`VT[NaRN[ NQR^bNaR]YNPRN`NQR`VT[NaRQ`URYaR_S\_ aUR PN_RN[Q ]_\aRPaV\[ \S]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[TN[QcVPaVZ`\S a_NSSVPXV[T3N[Q

#O$ ZNXR_RTbYNaV\[`\[ aUR`aN[QN_Q\S PN_RN[Q ]_\aRPaV\[ \S ]_R`bZRQ cVPaVZ \Sa_NSSVPXV[TN[QcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[TN[Q\[aURNQZV[V`a_NaV\[\S QR`VT[NaRQ`URYaR_`'

a_NSSVPXV[TV[ ]R_`\[` UN`aURZRN[V[TN` V`V[`RPaV\[+#)$3

cVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[T ZRN[` N]R_`\[ dU\ UN ORR[`bOWRPaRQa\ a_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`3

cbY[R_NOYRdVa[R`` ZRN[`&

#N$ NPUVYQ3

#O$ N[f ]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ\Sa_NSSVPXV[T3\_

#P$ N]R_`\[ dU\ d\bYQ`bSSR_b[QbR`a_R` dUVYRTVcV[TRcVQR[PRORPNb`R\S N ZR[aNY\_]Uf`VPNYQV`NOVYVaf\_ ORPNb`R \S aUR]\``VOVYVaf\S ORV[TV[aVZVQNaRQOf aURNPPb`RQ'

*+'#)$ GUR7\ZZVaaRR UNYYZRRa[\a YR`aUN[S\b_aVZRN ARRaV[T`

fRN_V[aURSV_`afRN_\S aURP\ZZR[PRZR[a \S aUV5Pa%N[Q[\aYR`aUN[adVPRNfRN_aUR_RNSaR_'

#*$ GUR b\_bZ S\_ NZRRaV[T\S aUR7\ZZVaaRR`UNYYORSVcRZRZOR_`'

#+$ GUR7UNV_]R_`\[%\_ V[UV\_ UR_NO`R[PR%aURIVPR&7UNV_]R_`\[UNYY]_R`VQR\cR_ ZRRaV[T\S aUR7\ZZVaaRR'D5EG ==&GE5::=7?=B; %&D9EFCBF

+'#)$ 5 ]R_`\[ dU\ _RP_bVa`%a_N[`]\_a`%a_N[`SR_`%UN_O\b_\_ _RPRVcRN[\aUR_]R_`\[ Of N[f \S aURS\YY\dV[TZRN[`&

#,$ =[ aURNO`R[PR\S aUR7UNV_]R_`\[N[Q aURIVPR&7UNV_]R_`\[%ZRZOR_`\S aUR7\ZZVaaRRZNf RYRPaNZ\[T`aaURZ`RYcRN[f ]R_`\[ a\ ]_R`VQR\cR_NZRRaV[T'

%+%

Page 7: >'5' AVPURY - SeyLII 9 of 2014 Prohibition of... · *,, 2b>>:6;6>:6;6

*,( 2B>>:6;6<A A=1779493:/3D6AA6 L*0aU5]_VY*(),M L*0aU5]_VY*(),M 2B>>:6;6<A A=1779493:/3D6AA6 **1

V[ aUR]_\aRPaV\[ \S ]R_`\[` NTNV[`aa_NSSVPXV[T3

#N$ aU_RNa3

#O$ b`R\S S\_PR\_ \aUR_S\_Z` \S P\R_PV\[3

#P$ NOQbPaV\[3

#Q$ S_NbQ3

#R$ QRPR]aV\[3V[PYbQV[TN[f ZV`_R]_R`R[aNaV\[Of d\_Q` \_ P\[QbPaN`a\ SV[N[PVNYV[PR[aVcR\_ ]_\ZV`R \S _RdN_Q\_ TNV[N[Q \aUR_P\[QVaV\[ \S d\_X3

#O$ Z\[Va\_ N[Q ]_R]N_RN[ N[[bNY_R]\_a \[]_\T_R`` V[ aUR [NaV\[NY _R`]\[`R a\a_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[` a\ OR`bOZVaaRQa\ aURAV[V`aR_3

#P$ R[`b_RP\\_QV[NaV\[NZ\[T`a aURT\cR_[ZR[aNTR[PVR`\aUR_\_TN[V`NaV\[R[TNTRQV[aURVZ]YRZR[aNaV\[\SaUV`5PaOf&

"9# S\_ZV[TNaN`XS\_PR\[ N[ 35 8=4 ON`V`3N[Q

#S$ NOb`R \S ]\dR_ \_ \S N[\aUR_ ]R_`\["`]\`VaV\[ \S cbY[R_NOVYVaf3\_

#T$ TVcV[T\_ _RPRVcV[T\S ]NfZR[a` \_ OR[RSVa`%X[\dV[TYf \_ V[aR[aV\[NYYf%a\ NPUVRcRaURP\[`R[a \S N ]R_`\[ UNcV[TP\[a_\Y \cR_N[\aUR_]R_`\[%

""! R[`b_V[T aURVZ]YRZR[aNaV\[\S aUR[NaV\[NYNPaV\[]YN[ \[ a_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[` N[QVa`bO`R^bR[a_R]\_aV[T3

#Q$ ZNXR_RP\ZZR[QNaV\[a\ aURAV[V`aR_\[ N[fZNaaR_P\[PR_[V[TaURVZ]YRZR[aNaV\[\S aUV`5Pa3N[Q

S\_ aUR]b_]\`R` \S Re]Y\VaNaV\[%P\ZZVa` aUR\SSR[PR\Sa_NSSVPXV[TV[ ]R_`\[` N[Q `UNYY\[ P\[cVPaV\[ ORYVNOYRa\VZ]_V`\[ZR[a S\_ N aR_Z [\a RePRRQV[T), fRN_`%\_ `bPUVZ]_V`\[ZR[aN[QNSV[R[\a RePRRQV[TF7E-((%((('

#*$ JUR_R VaV ]_\cRQ a\ aURNaV`SNPaV\[\S aUR7\b_aaUNaN[f \S aURZRN[` _RSR__RQa\ V[ bO`RPaV\[#)$#N$a\ #T$UN`ORR[b`RQV[P\ZZVaaV[TaUR\SSR[PR\S a_NSSVPXV[T%VaUNYY[\aORNQRSR[PRaUNaaURa_NSSVPXRQ]R_`\[ P\[`R[aRQa\ `bPUNPa'

#R$ ]R_S\_Z N[f \aUR_ Sb[PaV\[ [RPR``N_f a\VZ]YRZR[aaUR]_\cV`V\[ \S aUV5Pa \_ aURD_\a\P\Y'

#*$ GUR7\ZZVaaRR`UNYYQRcRY\]N[Q]_\]\`R a\ aURAV[V`aR__bYR_RYNaV[Ta\ cNPN[Pf%ZRRaV[TN[Q]_\PRQb_R`'

#+$ GUR7\ZZVaaRR%UNYYQRcRY\]N `a_NaRTfS\_ aUR]_\cV`V\[ \S `R_cVPRa\ aUR]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ`\S a_NSSVPXV[TN[QcVPaVZ`\S a_NSSVPXV[T%V[PYbQV[T&

#N$ ZRQVPNY`R_cVPR`3

#O$ NQR^bNaR`URYaR_N[QON`VP[RRQ`3

#P$ P\b[`RYYV[TN[Q\aUR_]`fPU\Y\TVPNY`b]]\_a3

,'# )$ 5 ]R_`\[ dU\ _RP_bVa`%UN_O\b_`%a_N[`SR_`%_RPRVcR` 7UVYQ'

NPUVYQ%X[\dV[TYf \_ _RPXYR``YfQV`_RTN_QV[TaUNaaUR]R_`\[ V` a_NSSVPXV[T

NPUVYQ%S\_]b_]\`R` \S Re]Y\VaNaV\[%dURaUR_\_ [\a Of b`R \SN[f ZRN[` _RSR__RQa\ V[`RPaV\[+#Y$#N$a\ #T$%P\ZZVa` aUR\SSR[PR\S PUVYQa_NSSVPXV[TN[Q`UNYY\[ P\[cVPaV\[ORYVNOYRa\VZ]_V`\[ZR[a S\_ N aR_Z [\a RePRRQV[T*- fRN_`%\_ `bPUVZ]_V`\[ZR[aN[QNSV[R[\a RePRRQV[TF7E0((%((('

#*$ 5 ]R_`\[ dU\ NQ\]a`%S\`aR_` \_ \OaNV[` aURTbN_QVN[`UV]\S N PUVYQdVaUaURV[aR[aV\[\S Re]Y\VaNaV\[%

.(%%( *$

Page 8: >'5' AVPURY - SeyLII 9 of 2014 Prohibition of... · *,, 2b>>:6;6>:6;6

*+( 2B>>:6;6<A A=1779493:/3D6AA6 L*0aU5]_VY*(),M L*0aU5]_VY*(),M 2B>>:6;6<A A=1779493:/3D6AA6 *+1

5TT_NcNaV[TPV_PbZ`aN[PR`

%%0/(''3

P\ZZVa` N[ \SSR[PR N[Q `UNYY\[ P\[cVPaV\[ OR YVNOYRa\VZ]_V`\[ZR[a S\_ N aR_Z [\a RePRRQV[T*- fRN_`%\_ `bPUVZ]_V`\[ZR[a N[QNSV[R[\a RePRRQV[TF7E0((%((('

#T$ NFaNaR7\b[`RY S_\Z aUR5aa\_[Rf ;R[R_NY"`7UNZOR_`3

#+$ JUR_R aURcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[ V`NPUVYQ%aUR]R_`\[ P\[cVPaRQ S\_ P\ZZVaaV[T N[ \SSR[PR b[QR_ aUV``RPaV\[`UNYY[\a d\_X V[N[f PN]NPVafdVaUPUVYQ_R['

#U$ N `R[V\_ \SSVPVNYS_\Z aUR :V[N[PVNY=[aRYYVTR[PRN[Q 5``Ra` ERP\cR_f H[VaR`aNOYV`URQ b[QR_ aUR 5[aV A\[Rf@Nb[QR_V[T5Pa3

-'#)$ 5[ \SSR[PR\S a_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[ V`QRRZRQa\ ORNTT_NcNaRQ VS P\ZZVaaRQ V[ N[f \S aUR S\YY\dV[TPV_PbZ`aN[PR` &

#V$ ad\ _R]_R`R[aNaVcR\S aUR@VNV`\[H[Va S\_B\[&;\cR_[ZR[aNY C_TN[V`NaV\[` V[FRfPURYYR` UNcV[T Re]R_VR[PR N[QX[\dYRQTRV[V``bR`_RYNaV[Ta\ a_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[` \_ UbZN[ _VTUa`'

#N$ VSaURcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[T`bSSR_` `R[\b`V[Wb_f\_ QVR`3

#*$ GUR 7\ZZVaaRR ZNf V[cVaRa\ Va` ZRRaV[T`_R]_R`R[aNaVcR\S [NaV\[NYN[Q V[aR_[NaV\[NYV[`aVabaV\[ N[Q\aUR_\_TN[V`NaV\[`a\ ]_\cVQR aRPU[VPNYNQcVPRN[Q N``V`aN[PRN`aURP\ZZVaaRRZNf P\[`VQR_[RPR``N_f'

#O$ aUR\SSR[PR V`P\ZZVaaRQ NTNV[`aZ\_R aUN[\[R cVPaVZ`3

#P$ aURcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[TV` \S N[ b[`\b[QZV[Q3

#+$ GURaR_Z \S \SSVPR\S N ZRZOR_ \S aUR7\ZZVaaRR`UNYYORaU_RRfRN_`'

#Q$ aUR NPPb`RQ ]R_`\[ V` V[ N ]\`VaV\[ \S_R`]\[`VOVYVaf\_ a_b`a dVaU _RSR_R[PRa\ aURcVPaVZ\Sa_NSSVPXV[T3

**'#)$ GURSb[PaV\[` \S aUR7\ZZVaaRR `UNYYORa\& :b[PaV\[`\S7\ZZVaaRR

#N$ S\_ZbYNaR ]\YVPf%`a_NaRTVR`%TbVQRYV[R`%]_\T_NZZR` N[Q \aUR_ ZRN`b_R` _RYNaV[Ta\&

#R$ aURNPPb`RQ]R_`\[ b`R` Q_bT`%ZRQVPNaV\[\_dRN]\[` V[aURP\ZZV``V\[ \S aUR\SSR[PR3

"-# aURNPPb`RQ]R_`\[ b`R` cV\YR[PR\_ aU_RNa\ScV\YR[PRNTNV[`a_RYNaVcR\_ N[f ZRZOR_ \SSNZVYf\S aURcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[T3

"9# VQR[aVSVPNaV\[N[Q_RSR__NY\S cVPaVZ\Sa_NSSVPXV[T%N[Q ]_\cV`V\[ \S `R_cVPR`N[Q]_\aRPaV\[ \S ]_R`bZRQ cVPaVZ \Sa_NSSVPXV[TN[QcVPaVZ \S a_NSSVPXV[T3

""! `aN[QN_Q\]R_NaV[T]_\PRQb_R` S\_ aUR_RSR__NY\S ]_R`bZRQ cVPaVZ` \Sa_NSSVPXV[T3N[Q

#T$ aUR \SSR[PR V` P\ZZVaaRQ Of N[ \_TN[V`RQP_VZV[NYT_\b]3

#U$ aUR\SSR[PR V`P\ZZVaaRQ Of N]bOYVPR_cN[a\_ N[f ]R_`\[ NPaV[TV[N[ \SSVPVNYPN]NPVafV[aURReR_PV`R\S QbaVR`3\_

"""! PN]NPVaf ObVYQV[T\S T\cR_[ZR[aNTR[PVR\aUR_\_TN[V`NaV\[` R[TNTRQ

(+%

Page 9: >'5' AVPURY - SeyLII 9 of 2014 Prohibition of... · *,, 2b>>:6;6>:6;6

*+0 2B>>:6;6<A A=1779493:/3D6AA6 L*0aU5]_VY*(),M

BNaV\[NY7\\_QV[NaV[T7\ZZVaaRR \[G_NSSVPXV[TV[DR_`\[`

7\Z]\`VaV\[\S 7\ZZVaaRR

%%%0.(%%)

#O$ ]_\cV`V\[ \S aUR_RYRcN[aa_NcRYQ\PbZR[a`N[Q NbaU\_V`NaV\[[RPR``N_f a\ a_NcRYN[Q_R&R[aR_FRfPURYYR`3N[Q

#P$ NPPR]aN[PRN[Q _Rab_[ dVaU\ba b[_RN`\[NOYRQRYNfN[QdVaUQbR_RTN_Qa\ `NSRaf'

D5EG =I &B5G=CB5@ 7CCE8=B5G=B;7CAA=GG99 CB GE5::=7?=B; =B D9EFCBF

*(' GUR_RV` UR_ROfR`aNOYV`URQ%N P\ZZVaaRR a\ ORX[\d[ N`aURBNaV\[NY7\\_QV[NaV[T 7\ZZVaaRR \[ G_NSSVPXV[TV[DR_`\[`'

*)'#)$ GUR 7\ZZVaaRR `UNYYP\[`V`a \S aUR S\YY\dV[TZRZOR_`%a\ ORN]]\V[aRQ Of aURD_R`VQR[a%Of [\aVPR]bOYV`URQV[ aUR/3D6AA6$\[ `bPU aR_Z` N[Q P\[QVaV\[` N` aURD_R`VQR[aZNf QRaR_ZV[R&

#N$ D_V[PV]NYFRP_RaN_fV[aURAV[V`a_f \S F\PVNY5SSNV_`%dU\ `UNYYORaUR7UNV_]R_`\[3

#O$ D_V[PV]NYFRP_RaN_fV[ aUR 8R]N_aZR[a \S=ZZVT_NaV\[N[Q 7VcVYFaNab`%dU\ `UNYYORaURIVPR&7UNV_]R_`\[3

#P$ D_V[PV]NYFRP_RaN_fV[aURAV[V`a_f\S @NO\b_%N[Q <bZN[ ER`\b_PR 8RcRY\]ZR[a \_ UV \_UR__R]_R`R[aNaVcR3

#Q$ 8V_RPa\_ ;R[R_NY \S 7\[`bYN_ 5SSNV_NaaURAV[V`a_f \S :\_RVT[ 5SSNV_`\_ UV` \_ UR__R]_R`R[aNaVcR3

#R$ 7\ZZV``V\[R_ \S D\YVPR\_ N[ \SSVPR_NaaUR_N[X[\a ORY\daURFb]R_V[aR[QN[a3

8R]baf 7\ZZV``V\[R_ \S 7b`a\Z` \_ UV \_UR__R]_R`R[aNaVcR`3

"-#

%-

L*0aU5]_VY*(),M 2B>>:6;6<A A=1779493:/3D6AA6 *+)

#V$ dUR_RaURcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[T&

"! QRcRY\]` NZR[aNYVYY[R``RN` N_R`bYa\S `RebNYRe]Y\VaNaV\[\_ b`R \S S\_PR3

""! ORP\ZR` ]_RT[N[a \_ V` S\_PRQ a\aR_ZV[NaRaUR]_RT[N[Pf N` N_R`bYa\S`RebNYRe]Y\VaNaV\[3

"999# `bSSR_` ZbaVYNaV\[%QV`SVTb_RZR[a\_]R_ZN[R[a O\QVYfV[Wb_fN` N_R`bYa\S`RebNYRe]Y\VaNaV\[\_ b`R \SS\_PR3\_

"9C# V`Re]\`RQ a\ YVSR&aU_RNaR[V[TQV`RN`R`%V[PYbQV[TUbZN[ VZZb[\QRSVPVR[PfcV_b` \_ 5P^bV_RQ=ZZb[R 8RSVPVR[PfFf[Q_\ZR \_ \aUR_ `RebNYYfa_N[`ZVaaRQQV`RN`R%N` N _R`bYa \S`RebNYRe]Y\VaNaV\[\_ b`R \S S\_PR'

#*$ 5 ]R_`\[ dU\ P\ZZVa` aUR\SSR[PR\S a_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[` b[QR_ NTT_NcNaV[TPV_PbZ`aN[PR``UNYY\[ P\[cVPaV\[ORYVNOYRa\ VZ]_V`\[ZR[a S\_ NaR_Z[\a RePRRQV[T*- fRN_`%\_`bPU VZ]_V`\[ZR[a N[QNSV[R[\a RePRRQV[TF7E0((%((('

.' 5 ]R_`\[ dU\% V[aR[aV\[NYYf%OR[RSVa S_\Z aURRe]Y\VaNaV\[\S a_NSSVPXV[TV[ ]R_`\[` \_ PNb`R` \_ R[NOYR`N[\aUR_]R_`\[ a\ OR[RSVaS_\Z a_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`% P\ZZVa`N[ \SSR[PR N[Q `UNYY\[ P\[cVPaV\[ ORYVNOYRa\ VZ]_V`\[ZR[aS\_ NaR_Z [\a RePRRQV[T*- fRN_`%\_ `bPU VZ]_V`\[ZR[a N[Q NSV[R[\a RePRRQV[TF7E0((%((('

/' 5 ]R_`\[ dU\ NVQ\_ NORa \_ NaaRZ]a` \_ P\b[`RY` N]R_`\[ V[ aUR P\ZZV``V\[ \S aUR\SSR[PR \S a_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[` P\ZZVa` N[ \SSR[PRN[Q`UNYY\[ P\[cVPaV\[ ORYVNOYRa\VZ]_V`\[ZR[a S\_ N aR_Z [\a RePRRQV[T)- fRN_`%\_ `bPUVZ]_V`\[ZR[a N[QNSV[R[\a RePRRQV[TF7E-((%((('

0' 5 ]R_`\[ dU\ S\_ aUR]b_]\`R \S aUR ]_\Z\aV\[ \Sa_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`% V[aR[aV\[NYYf&

*$

6R[RSVaV[TS_\ZRe]Y\VaNaV\[\Sa_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`

5VQV[T%NORaaV[T%\_NaaRZ]aV[TV[P\ZZV``V\[ \S\SSR[PR\Sa_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`

D_\Z\aV\[ \Sa_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`

Page 10: >'5' AVPURY - SeyLII 9 of 2014 Prohibition of... · *,, 2b>>:6;6>:6;6

*+* 2B>>:6;6<AA=1779493:/3D6AA6 L*0aU5]_VY*(),M

%%0%"! !

7Y\`b_R\_QR_

#N$ YRN`R\_ `bOYRN`R`%b`R` \_ NYY\d`aURb`R \SN[f U\b`R%ObVYQV[T\_ R`aNOYV`UZR[a3

#O$ ]_\QbPR`%]_V[a`%O_\NQPN`a \_ QV`a_VObaR`OfN[f ZRN[`% V[PYbQV[TaURb`R \S V[S\_ZNaV\[aRPU[\Y\Tf \_ aURV[aR_[Ra%N[f P\ZZb[VPNaV\[ZNaR_VNYdUVPU ]_\Z\aR` a_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`3

N``V`a`V[ ZV`_R]_R`R[aNaV\[\_ S_NbQS\_ aUR]b_]\`R` \S ]_\Pb_V[T \_ SNPVYVaNaV[TaURNP^bV`VaV\[\S [RPR``N_f ReVaQ\PbZR[a S_\ZaUR 8R]N_aZR[a \S =ZZVT_NaV\[ S\_ aUR]b_]\`R` \S a_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`3

SNPVYVaNaR`ReVaS_\Z \_ R[a_f V[a\ FRfPURYYR`\S NcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[TdU\ V`V[]\``R``V\[\S NcNYVQa_NcRYQ\PbZR[a%aNZ]R_RQdVaU\_S_NbQbYR[aa_NcRYQ\PbZR[a` S\_ aUR]b_]\`R\S a_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`3

#R$ P\[SV`PNaR`% dVaUU\YQ` \_ QR`a_\f` aURa_NcRYYV[TQ\PbZR[a` \_ ]R_`\[NY Q\PbZR[a`dUVPUORY\[Ta\ NcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[TS\_ aUR]b_]\`R` \S Sb_aUR_V[Ta_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`3\_

#P$

#Q$

#S$ ]_RcR[a` NcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[TS_\Z R[aR_V[T\_ YRNcV[TFRfPURYYR`\_ `RRXV[TN``V`aN[PRS_\Z N]]_\]_VNaR YNd R[S\_PRZR[aNbaU\_VaVR`%

P\ZZVa` N[ \SSR[PR N[Q `UNYY\[ P\[cVPaV\[ OR YVNOYRa\VZ]_V`\[ZR[a S\_ N aR_Z [\a RePRRQV[T- fRN_`%\_ `bPUVZ]_V`\[ZR[a N[QNSV[R[\a RePRRQV[TF7E-((%((('

$ GUR7\b_a ZNf%b]\[ P\[cVPaV\[ \S N]R_`\[ b[QR_aUV5Pa%\_QR_ aURPY\`b_R \S aUR]_\]R_af \_ ]N_a aUR_R\S\_S\_SRVab_R\S N[f N``Ra`%b`RQV[aURP\ZZV``V\[ \SaUR\SSR[PR'

L*0aU5]_VY*(),M 2B>>:6;6<AA=1779493:/3D6AA6 *+/

#N$ V``bRN[ N]]_\]_VNaR]R_ZVaS\_ N]R_V\Qb[aVYaUR P\Z]YRaV\[ \S N[f _RYRcN[a YRTNY]_\PRRQV[T` V[ NPP\_QN[PR dVaU aUR=ZZVT_NaV\[8RP_RR3\_

#O$ aNXRQRPV`V\[a\ _Rab_[N]_R`bZRQ cVPaVZ\Sa_NSSVPXV[TdU\ V [\a NPVaVgR[\S FRfPURYYR`a\ UV\_ UR_P\b[a_f \S \_VTV[%

`bOWRPaa\ UbZN[VaN_VN[N[Q P\Z]N``V\[NaR P\[`VQR_NaV\[`%aNXV[TV[a\ NPP\b[a aUR R_V\b` YVXRYVU\\Q\S UN_Z%ORV[TXVYYRQ\_ ORV[T_R&a_NSSVPXRQ'

#*$ JUR[ QRPVQV[TdURaUR_a\ _Rab_[N]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[TdU\ V`N PUVYQ%aUROR`a V[aR_R`a\S aURPUVYQUNYYOR]N_NZ\b[a N[QSV_`aP\[`VQR_NaV\[ORV[TTVcR[a\aUR[RRQa\ `NSRTbN_QN[Q]_\Z\aR aURdRYSN_R\S aURPUVYQ'

!" 5 cVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[T`UNYY[\a OR QRaNV[RQ%PUN_TRQ\_ ]_\`RPbaRQ S\_ aURVYYRTNYR[a_f V[a\ FRfPURYYR`'

!# GUR7\b_a ZNf%\[ P\[cVPaV\[ \SaUR NPPb`RQ%\_QR_aUR]NfZR[a \S P\Z]R[`NaV\[ S\_ aURcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[T%a\OR]NVQ&

#N$ \ba \SaURSV[RVZ]\`RQ \[ aURNPPb`RQ3

#O$ V[NQQVaV\[a\ N[f ]R[NYaf3\_

#P$ S_\Z aURG_NSSVPXV[TV[DR_`\[` :b[Q%

S\_ aURUN_Z `bSSR_RQN` N _R`bYa\S aURP\ZZV``V\[ \S aUR\SSR[PR\Sa_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`'

!$ GUR AV[V`aR__R`]\[`VOYRS\_ :\_RVT[ 5SSNV_`%V[P\[`bYaNaV\[ dVaUaURAV[V`aR_S\_ <\ZR 5SSNV_`UNYYQRcRY\]NZRPUN[V`Z S\_ cVPaVZ \S a_NSSVPXV[T%dU\ V`N PVaVgR[N[Q]R_ZN[R[a _R`VQR[a\S FRfPURYYR`%S\_&

,#N$ cR_VSVPNaV\[\S [NaV\[NYVafNaP\[`bYN_ YRcRY3

F%

B\[&YVNOVYVaf\S cVPaVZ \Sa_NSSVPXV[T

7\Z]R[`NaV\[

ERab_[ \Sa_NSSVPXRQPVaVgR[N[Q]R_ZN[R[a_R`VQR[a\SFRfPURYYR`

Page 11: >'5' AVPURY - SeyLII 9 of 2014 Prohibition of... · *,, 2b>>:6;6>:6;6

*+. 2B>>:6;6<AA=1779493:/3D6AA6 L*0aU5]_VY*(),M

8R]\_aNaV\[\S ]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ \Sa_NSSVPXV[T

=``bN[PR \S]R_ZVaa\ N]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ \Sa_NSSVPXV[T

%%0!9-,&-

#N$ N cbY[R_NOYRdVa[R`` ZNf TVcRRcVQR[PRV[N[f ]YNPRV[`VQR\_ \ba`VQRaUR7\b_a&

"9# dUVPUV V[S\_ZNYYfN__N[TRQa\ `RaaURdVa[R``NaRN`R3\_

"99# a\ SNPVYVaNaRaURP\[QbPa \S ]_\PRRQV[T`Of PY\`RQPV_PbVaaRYRcV`V\[\_ N[f`VZVYN_ZRQVN3

#O$ aURSb_[Vab_RV[ N 7\b_a _\\Z ZNf OR_R&N__N[TRQa\ `RaaURdVa[R``NaRN`R3\_

#P$ N`b]]\_a ]R_`\[ \_ V[aR_ZRQVN_fZNf `Va\_`aN[Q[RN_N cbY[R_NOYRdVa[R`` Qb_V[TaURTVcV[T\S RcVQR[PRa\ ]_\cVQR ]Uf`VPNYP\ZS\_a N[Q NYR_aaUR7\b_a \S N[f b[QbRQV`a_R` N` [RPR``N_f%]_\cVQRQ aUNaaUR`b]]\_a ]R_`\[ \_ V[aR_ZRQVN_f`UNYY[\aN``V`a aUR dVa[R`` dVaU N[`dR_V[T N[f^bR`aV\[ \_ V[`a_bPaaURdVa[R`` V[ TVcV[TRcVQR[PR'

)-'#)$ B\adVaU`aN[QV[TN[f \aUR_d_VaaR[YNd%aURAV[V`aR_ZNf QRaR_ZV[RdURaUR_a\ NYY\dN ]_R`bZRQ cVPaVZ\Sa_NSSVPXV[TdU\ V`[\a N PVaVgR[\S FRfPURYYR`%a\ _RZNV[V[FRfPURYYR`S\_ N]R_V\Q\S +( QNf` S\_ ]b_]\`R` \S _RP\cR_f%dVaU\ba]_RWbQVPRa\ aURVZZVT_NaV\[`aNab \S aURa_NSSVPXRQ]R_`\['

#*$ 5[f ]_\PRRQV[TV[VaVNaRQV[_R`]RPa\S QR]\_aNaV\[\S aUR]_R`bZRQ cVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[T`UNYYOR`aNfRQ%b[aVYNQRPV`V\[V aNXR[b[QR_ RPaV\[)1 N[QaUR]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ\Sa_NSSVPXV[T`UNYYOR]_\cVQRQdVaU]_\aRPaV\[N[Q`R_cVPRb[QR_aUV5Pa'

).'#)$ =SN ]R_`\[ dU\ V`[\a N PVaVgR[\S FRfPURYYR`V`VQR[aVSVRQN`N]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[T%aURAV[V`aR_%\[aUR_RP\ZZR[QNaV\[\S aUR7\ZZVaaRR%ZNf&

L*0aU5]_VY*(),M 2B>>:6;6<AA=1779493:/3D6AA6 *++

D5EG ### F9EI=79F GC DE9FHA98 I=7G=A C:GE5::=7?=B; 5B8 I=7G=A C: GE5::=7?=B;

)('#)$ 5[ VZZVT_NaV\[\SSVPR_%Pb`a\Z` \SSVPR_%YNO\b_V[`]RPa\_%P\N`a TbN_Q%\SSVPVNY\S aUR BNaV\[NY8_bT9[S\_PRZR[a 5TR[Pf%`\PVNYd\_XR_ \_ ZRQVPNY]_NPaVaV\[R_dU\ \[ _RN`\[NOYRT_\b[Q` ORYVRcR`aUNaN ]R_`\[ V`ORV[Ta_NSSVPXRQ`UNYY_R]\_a`bPUZNaaR_a\ N]\YVPR\SSVPR_'

ER]\_aV[TN[Q _RSR__NY

#*$ 5[f ]R_`\[ dU\ \[ _RN`\[NOYRT_\b[Q` ORYVRcR`aUNaN[\aUR_]R_`\[ V ORV[Ta_NSSVPXRQ`UNYY_R]\_aa\ N]\YVPR\SSVPR_'

#+$ GURVQR[aVaf\SaUR]R_`\[ dU\ ZNXR N_R]\_ab[QR_aUV`RPaV\[ UNYYORXR]aP\[SVQR[aVNY'

#,$ GUR]\YVPR\SSVPR_`UNYYNPPR]aN[\[fZ\b` _R]\_a'

#-$ GUR]\YVPR\SSVPR_a\ dU\Z N_R]\_aV ZNQRb[QR_aUV``RPaV\[ `UNYYdVaU\ba QRYNf_RSR_aURZNaaR_a\ aURV[cR`aVTNaV[T\SSVPR_S\_ N[ V[VaVNYN``R``ZR[a N[QV[cR`aVTNaV\['

#.$ JUR_R aUR `NSRaf\S aUR]_R`bZRQ cVPaVZ\Sa_NSSVPXV[TV Na_V`X%aUR]\YVPR\SSVPR_`UNYY%VZZRQVNaRYf%aNXRZRN`b_R`a\ R[`b_R aUR`NSRaf\S aUR]_R`bZRQ cVPaVZ\Sa_NSSVPXV[T%N[Q&

#N$ dUR_RaUR]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[TV NPUVYQ%a_RNabPU PUVYQN` NPUVYQV[[RRQ\SP\Z]bY`\_f ZRN`b_R \S PN_RV[NPP\_QN[PRdVaU`RPaV\[/1 \S aUR7UVYQ_R["`5Pa N[Q_RZ\cR aURPUVYQa\ N`NSRN[Q`RPb_R]YNPRV[NPP\_QN[PRdVaURPaV\[0( \S aUR7UVYQ_R["`5Pa3\_

#O$ dUR_RaUR]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ\Sa_NSSVPXV[T\_NcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[TV`N[ NQbYa%dVaUaURP\[`R[a \S aURa_NSSVPXRQ]R_`\[% _RSR_bPU

F%

Page 12: >'5' AVPURY - SeyLII 9 of 2014 Prohibition of... · *,, 2b>>:6;6>:6;6

*+, 2B>>:6;6<AA=1779493:/3D6AA6 L*0aU5]_VY*(),M L*0aU5]_VY*(),M 2B>>:6;6<AA=1779493:/3D6AA6 *+-

/

8RPV`V\[ \[R[a_f V[a\FRfPURYYR`

JVa[R``]_\aRPaV\[

%%09$,&,

]R_`\[ a\ N `NSRN[Q `RPb_R QR`VT[NaRQ`URYaR_'

]_\aRPaV\[\S dVa[R``%aUR5aa\_[Rf ;R[R_NYUNYYQV_RPaaUNaaURdVa[R``ORVZZRQVNaRYf]YNPRQb[QR_]_\aRPaV\[%N[QdVaUV[/*U\b_` \S `bPUQV_RPaV\[%N]]Yf a\ aUR7\b_a S\_ N[ N]]_\]_VNaR\_QR_'""! GUR AV[V`aR_%V[ P\[`bYaNaV\[ dVaU aUR

7\ZZV``V\[R_ \S D\YVPR%`UNYYaNXRQRPV`V\[\[ dURaUR_a\NYY\daURR[a_f\S N[f `b`]RPa\_ ]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[TV[a\FRfPURYYR`'

)+'#)$ JUR_R Va N]]RN_` a\ N 7\b_a aUNaaUR_RV` NYVXRYVU\\Q\S UN_Za\ N]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ\Sa_NSSVPXV[T\_ a\ N[f\aUR_dVa[R``V[aURa_VNY%aUR7\b_a ZNf \_QR_aUNa&

)*'#)$ JUR_RVaN]]RN_ a\ aUR5aa\_[Rf ;R[R_NYaUNa&#N$ N]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[T\_ NdVa[R``

aR`aVSVR`V[ PY\`RQ7\b_a N[Q aUNa[\ \aUR_]R_`\[ `UNYYOR]_R`R[adUR[ aURRcVQR[PRV`TVcR[%b[YR``aUR]_R`R[PR\S aUR]R_`\[ V`[RPR``N_f S\_ aUR ]_\PRRQV[T` \_ V`NbaU\_V`RQOf aUR7\b_a3

#N$ aUR]R_`\[NY NSRaf\S NdVa[R``V V[QN[TR_3

#O$ N dVa[R`` ZNf OR ]_RcR[aRQS_\Z TVcV[TRcVQR[PR3

#P$ N dVa[R`` ZNf ORV[aVZVQNaRQ\_ `bOWRPaa\_RaNYVNaV\[3\_ #O$ aUR VQR[aVaf\S aUR ]_R`bZRQ cVPaVZ\S

a_NSSVPXV[T\_ aURdVa[R`` UNYY[\a OR_RcRNYRQS\_N]R_V\Q]RPVSVRQOfaUR7\b_a3N[Q#Q$ Va d\bYQ OR V[ aUR V[aR_R`a` \S aUR

NQZV[V`a_NaV\[\S Wb`aVPRaUNaN dVa[R`` OR]YNPRQb[QR_]_\aRPaV\[%

#P$ [\ V[S\_ZNaV\[\[ ]_\PRRQV[TURYQV[PY\`RQ7\b_a `UNYYOR ]bOYV`URQ\_ \[Yf `bPUV[S\_ZNaV\[dU\`R ]bOYVPNaV\[V P\[`VQR_RQOf aUR7\b_a a\ ORWb`aN[QR^bVaNOYRZNf OR]bOYV`URQ'

aUR5aa\_[Rf ;R[R_NYZNf N]]Yf a\ aUR7\b_a S\_ N[ \_QR_a\]YNPRaURdVa[R``b[QR_]_\aRPaV\['

#*$ GUR7\b_a ZNf%\[ N]]YVPNaV\[b[QR_ bO`RPaV\[#)$%\_QR_aUNaaURdVa[R`` OR]YNPRQb[QR_]_\aRPaV\[%b[aVYaURP\Z]YRaV\[ \S aUR]_\PRRQV[TV[ _R`]RPa\S aUR\SSR[PR\Sa_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[`%b[YR``&

#*$ 5[f ]R_`\[ dU\ QV`PY\`R`%dVaU\ba YNdSbYNbaU\_Vaf%a\ N[\aUR_]R_`\[ N[f V[S\_ZNaV\[NP^bV_RQV[aURP\b_`R \S UV\_ UR_\SSVPVNYQbaf aUNaR[NOYR`\_ YRNQ`a\ aURVQR[aVSVPNaV\[\S aUR]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ\S a_NSSVPXV[T\_ dVa[R``\S aUR\SSR[PRa_NSSVPXV[TV[]R_`\[` P\ZZVa` N[ \SSR[PRN[Q`UNYY\[ P\[cVPaV\[%ORYVNOYRa\ VZ]_V`\[ZR[a S\_ NaR_Z[\aRePRRQV[T)- fRN_`%\_ `bPU VZ]_V`\[ZR[a N[Q N SV[R[\aRePRRQV[TF7E-((%((('

#N$ aUR 5aa\_[Rf ;R[R_NY \OaNV[` N[ \_QR_QV`P\[aV[bV[TaUR]_\aRPaV\[NaN[RN_YVR_QNaR3\_

#O$ aUR]_\PRRQV[TUNcR[\a P\ZZR[PRQ dVaUV[`VeZ\[aU` \S `bPU\_QR_' ),'#)$ 5 7\b_a ZNf%V[_RYNaV\[a\ aURTVcV[T\S RcVQR[PR

Of NcbY[R_NOYRdVa[R``%\[ Va\d[ Z\aV\[%\_ \[ N]]YVPNaV\[Of aUR5aa\_[Rf ;R[R_NY%aURNPPb`RQ\_ NcbY[R_NOYRdVa[R``%\_QR_aUNa&

#+$ JUR_R VaN]]RN_ a\ aUR5aa\_[Rf ;R[R_NYaUNaN[fQRYNfd\bYQ QRSRNaaUR]b_]\`R \S \OaNV[V[TaUR\_QR_S\_ aUR

F%

D_\aRPaV\[\S]_VcNPf \SN]_R`bZRQcVPaVZ\Sa_NSSVPXV[T

IbY[R_NOYRdVa[R``