0HUHQM HEU]L Q H]YX N D 'RSOHUR YH IHNDW X]SRP R` … · 2021. 1. 4. · wh odn rm h rvfloxm h vx...

7
ν= ±υ μ υ ν ν υ υ = (ω + α29 υ=υ ⋅ (ω + α29 υυ ω α

Transcript of 0HUHQM HEU]L Q H]YX N D 'RSOHUR YH IHNDW X]SRP R` … · 2021. 1. 4. · wh odn rm h rvfloxm h vx...

Page 1: 0HUHQM HEU]L Q H]YX N D 'RSOHUR YH IHNDW X]SRP R` … · 2021. 1. 4. · wh odn rm h rvfloxm h vx ydnr pwu hqxwnx 3rwuheq mr mh r^ rguhglw sul rmhnflm ex u]lq h plnurirq d w em u]l

3HWUD�6WRMVDYOMHYL`

0HUHQMH�EU]LQH�]YXND�X]�SRPR`�'RSOHURYRJHIHNWD

%U]LQD� ]YXND� RGUH_HQD� MH� MHGQRVWDYQRP�� QHVWDQ�GDUGQRP�PHWRGRP��X]�SRPR`�NODWQD�VD�PLNURIRQRPNRML�GHWHNWXMH�SURPHQH�IUHNYHQFLMH�]YXND��RGQRVQR'RSOHURYRJ�HIHNWD�NRML� VH� MDYOMD�X�RYRP�VLVWHPX�&LOM�UDGD�MH�ELOR�LVSLWLYDQMH�HILNDVQRVWL�L�WHVWLUDQMHPHWRGH��NDR�L�LVSLWLYDQMH�XVORYD�SRG�NRMLPD�DSDUD�WXUD�GDMH�QDMEROMH�UH]XOWDWH��.ODWQR�VD�PDOLP�PLNUR�IRQRP� QD� VORERGQRP� NUDMX� VH� OMXOMDOR� L]QDG�PDORJ]YXaQLND��NRML�MH�HPLWRYDR�WRQ�RGUH_HQH�IUHNYHQFLMH�8VOHG�NUHWDQMD��PLNURIRQD�X�RGQRVX�QD�]YXaQLN��GROD]LGR�SRMDYH�'RSOHURYRJ�HIHNWD��7DGD�IUHNYHQFLMD�WRQDNRMX�UHJLVWUXMHPR�SUHNR�PLNURIRQD�WDNR_H�KDUPRQLMVNLRVFLOXMH��'D�EL�XWYUGLOL�QD�NRML�VH�QDaLQ�IUHNYHQFLMDWRQD� PHQMD� VD� YUHPHQRP� QHRSKRGQR� MH� L]DaXQDWLEU]LQX� PLNURIRQD�� RGQRVR� SURMHNFLMX� WH� EU]LQH� QDSUDYDF�QHSRNUHWQL�]YXaQLN�¬�SRNUHWQL�PLNURIRQ�L�QD�RV�QRYX�WH�EU]LQH�X]�SRPR`�'RSOHURYRJ�HIHNWD�L]UDaXQDWLSURPHQX� IUHNYHQFLMH�� 2YDM� MHGQRVWDYDQ� PRGHO� QDPRPRJX`DYD�GD�VLPXOLUDPR�FHR�HNVSHULPHQW�L�GD�RQGDWDNR� GRELMHQL� VLJQDO� XSRUHGLPR� VD� RQLP� NRML� VPRVQLPLOL��^WR�QDP�RQGD�RPRJX`DYD�GD�L]UDaXQDPR�MHG�LQX�QHSR]QDWX�YHOLaLQX�¬�EU]LQX�]YXND��*ODYQD�SUHG�QRVW�RYH�PHWRGH�MH�MHIWLQ�L�ODNR�L]YRGOMLY�HNVSHULPHQWNRML�VD�VWDQGDUG�QRP�̂ NROVNRP�UDaXQDUVNRP�RSUHPRPGDMH�YUHGQRVW�EU]LQH�]YXND�VD�WDaQR^`X�RG����P�V��WM�SULEOLCQR����

8YRG%U]LQD� ]YXND� X� YD]GXKX� VH� GDQDV�PRCH

RGUHGLWL�YUOR�SUHFL]QR��0H_XWLP��PHWRGH�]D�QMHQRPHUHQMH�NRULVWH�XJODYQRP�GYD�VYRMVWYD�WDODVD��HKR�LUH]RQDQFLMX��,GHMD�RYRJ�UDGD�MH�SRNX^DWL�RGUHGLWLEU]LQX�]YXND�X]�SRPR`�MHGQH�GUXJH�SRMDYH�YH]DQH

]D�WDODVH��'RSOHURYRJ�HIHNWD��2VQRYQL�FLOM�PHWRGH�MHELR�LVSLWLYDQMH�QMHQH�SRX]GDQRVWL�L�WDaQRVWL�

'RSOHURY�HIHNDW3RMDYD�SURPHQH�IUHNYHQFLMH�NRMX�UHJLVWUXMH�SUL�

MHPQLN�SUL�UHODWLYQRP�NUHWDQMX�SULMHPQLND�L�L]YRUDWDODVD�QD]LYD�VH�'RSOHURY�HIHNDW��)UHNYHQFLMD�NRMXUHJLVWUXMH�SULMHPQLN�PHQMD�VH�SR�VOHGH`RM�]DYLVQRVWL�

ν�=�F�±�υSF�µ�υL

�⋅�YR ���

JGH�MH�νR�IUHNYHQFLMD�NRMX�HPLWXMH�L]YRU��ν�IUHNYHQ�FLMD�NRMX�UHJLVWUXMH�SULMHPQLN��υR��υS�EU]LQH�L]YRUDRGQRVQR�SULMHPQLND��WM��NRPSRQHQDWD�X�SUDYFX�SUL�MHPQLN�L]YRU��L�F�EU]LQD�]YXND��=QDN�SOXV�X�JRUQMRMIRUPXOL�VH�RGQRVL�QD�VOXaDM�NDGD�VH�SULMHPQLN�L�L]YRUSULEOLCDYDMX��D�PLQXV�QD�VOXaDM�NDGD�VH�RQL�PH_XVREQRXGDOMDYDMX�

.DGD�SUHWSRVWDYLPR�GD�L]YRU�PLUXMH��D�SULMHPQLNL]QDG�QMHJD�KDUPRQLMVNL�RVFLOXMH�OHYR�GHVQR�PRCHPRGDWL�MHGQRVWDYDQ�PDWHPDWLaNL�PRGHO�RQRJD�^WR�VHGH^DYD�X�HNVSHULPHQWX��VOLND����

.UHWDQMH�PDWHPDWLaNRJ�NODWQD�RSLVXMX�VOHGH`HMHGQDaLQH��.DGHOEXUJ��5DSDML`�������

[�=�[R�⋅�FRV(ωW�+�α) ���υ�=�υR�⋅�VLQ(ωW�+�α) ���

JGH� VX� [�� [R�XGDOMHQRVW��RGQRVQR�PDNVLPDOQDXGDOMHQRVW�RG�UDYQRWHCQRJ�SRORCDMD��υ��υR��EU]LQD�RGQRVQR�PDNVLPDOQD�EU]LQD��ω�XJDRQD�EU]LQD�L�αSRaHWQD�ID]D�RVFLORYDQMD�

,]�����PRCHPR�RGUHGLWL�SRORCDM��D�L]�����EU]LQXWHOD�NRMH�RVFLOXMH�X�VYDNRP�WUHQXWNX��3RWUHEQR�MH�MR^RGUHGLWL�SURMHNFLMX�EU]LQH�PLNURIRQD��WM��EU]LQX�X�RG�QRVX�QD�]YXaQLN��MHU�RQD�ILJXUL^H�X�MHGQDaLQL�����

3HWUD�6WRMVDYOMHYL`���������6RPERU��6ODYL^H9DMQHUD�ALaH�(���,�����XaHQLFD����UD]UHGD0DWHPDWLaNH�JLPQD]LMH�X�%HRJUDGX0(1725��6U_DQ�9HUEL`��,63

=%251,.�5$'29$����� ),=,.$��• ����

Page 2: 0HUHQM HEU]L Q H]YX N D 'RSOHUR YH IHNDW X]SRP R` … · 2021. 1. 4. · wh odn rm h rvfloxm h vx ydnr pwu hqxwnx 3rwuheq mr mh r^ rguhglw sul rmhnflm ex u]lq h plnurirq d w em u]l

,PDMX`L�X�YLGX��VOLND����2=� �K��20� �Oθ�=�∠ �20=ϕ�=�∠ �02=VLQϕ�=�[���O0RCHPR�SULPHWLWL�

X�=�υ�FRV�π��−�θ

$NR�SULPHQLPR�VLQXVQX�L�NRVLQXVQX�WHRUHPX�QD∆02=�LPDPR�

0=�=�√ �O��+�K��−���O�K�FRVϕK���0=� �VLQ�θ���VLQ�ϕ

SD�MH�

X�=�υ�K�VLQϕ0=

D�NDNR�MH�VLQϕ�=�[�O�=�[R�FRV�(ω�W�+�α)���O

PRCHPR�RGUHGLWL�X�X�VYDNRP�WUHQXWNX�8NROLNR�X�����]DPHQLPR�υL�=���L�υS�=�X��GR�

ELMDPR�ν�=�

XF�+��

�⋅�νR

'DNOH�IUHNYHQFLMD�NRMX�`H�UHJLVWURYDWL�PLNURIRQPHQMD`H�VH�SR�VOHGH`RM�]DYLVQRVWL�

ν�=�[��+�[R�ω�VLQ(ω�W�+�α)]�⋅K�VLQ�ϕ(O��+�K��−��OK�FRVϕ)���

�⋅νR���

JGH�MH�VLQ�ϕ�=�[R�FRV�(ω�W�+�α)���O

ω�=�√ �J���OJ�MH�JUDYLWDFLRQR�XEU]DQMH��D�O�GXCLQD�NODWQD���20��

(NVSHULPHQW$SDUDWXUX�aLQH�UDaXQDU��IXQNFLMVNL�JHQHUDWRU�

SLH]R�]YXaQLN�L�NODWQR�VD�NRQGHQ]DWRUVNLP�PLNUR�IRQRP��7RQ�MH�VQLPDQ�X�:LQGRZV�SURJUDPX�6RXQG5HFRUGHU��2EUDGD�VQLPDND�YU^HQD�MH�X�SURJUDPVNRPRNUXCHQMX�0$7/$%�

6LJQDO�JHQHUDWRU�HPLWXMH�WRQ�RGUH_HQH�IUHNYHQ�FLMH�SUHNR�PDORJ�]YXaQLND�L�PLNURIRQRP�JD�VQLPD�PR�QD�UDaXQDUX��=YXaQLN�MH�ILNVLUDQ�LVSRG�NDEOD�VDPLNURIRQRP�NRML�VH�QDOD]L�QHNROLNR�FHQWLPHWDUDL]QDG�QMHJD��8NROLNR�PLNURIRQ�PLUXMH�UDaXQDU�EHOHCLMHGQX�LVWX�YUHGQRVW�WRNRP�YUHPHQD��VOLND��D���0H_X�WLP��XNROLNR�PLNURIRQ�L]YHGHPR�L]�UDYQRWHCQRJ�SR�ORCDMD�L�SXVWLPR�GD�RVFLOXMH�L]QDG�]YXaQLND�MDYOMD�VH'RSOHURY�HIHNDW��MHU�VH�VDGD�PLNURIRQ��SULMHPQLN�NUH`H�X�RGQRVX�QD�]YXaQLN��L]YRU���7DGD�IUHNYHQFLMDVQLPOMHQRJ�VLJQDOD�SUDYLOQR�RVFLOXMH�RNR�RGDEUDQHYUHGQRVWL��VOLND��E��

3R^WR�NDEO�PLNURIRQD�QLMH�QHLVWHJOMLYD�QLW�]DQH�PDUOMLYH�PDVH��NDNR�WR�]DKWHYD�PRGHO�PDWHPDWLaNRJNODWQD��NDEO�VD�PLNURIRQRP�MH�GRGDWQR�RSWHUH`HQPDOLP�WHJRP�GD�EL�VRSVWYHQH�RVFLODFLMH�®QLWL¯�ELOH^WR�PDQMH�L]UDCHQH��8SRUH_LYDQ�MH�SHULRG�RYDNR�NRQ�VWUXLVDQRJ�NODWQD�VD�YUHGQR^`X�NRMX�GDMH�PRGHO��=DNODWQR�GXCLQH��¬��P��NRMH�VX�NRUL^`HQH�X�RYRP�HN�VSHULPHQWX��RGVWXSDQMH�VH�MDYOMD�WHN�QD�GUXJRM�GHFL�PDOL��∆7� ������V���^WR�MH�VDVYLP�]DGRYROMDYDMX`H�

6OLND����0RGHO�NODWQD�NRUL^`HQRJ�X�HNVSHULPHQWX0�¬�PLNURIRQ��=�¬�]YXaQLN

)LJXUH����3HQGXOXP�PRGHO�XVHG�LQ�H[SHULPHQW0�¬�PLFURSKRQH��=�¬�VSHDNHU

����• ��3(71,A.(�69(6.(��� '(2��,

Page 3: 0HUHQM HEU]L Q H]YX N D 'RSOHUR YH IHNDW X]SRP R` … · 2021. 1. 4. · wh odn rm h rvfloxm h vx ydnr pwu hqxwnx 3rwuheq mr mh r^ rguhglw sul rmhnflm ex u]lq h plnurirq d w em u]l

3UH�SRaHWND�HNVSHULPHQWD�ELOR�MH�SRWUHEQR�RGUH�GLWL�XVORYH��IUHNYHQFLMX��X�NRMLPD�MH�XRS^WH�PRJX`HL]GYRMLWL�]YXN�PLNURIRQD�RG�RVWDOLK�^XPRYD�X�ODER�UDWRULML��]DWLP�L�GXCLQX�L�DPSOLWXGX�RVFLORYDQMD�®PLN�URIRQVNRJ�NODWQD¯�NRMH�QH�RGVWXSDMX��SUHYL^H��RGWHRULMVNRJ�PRGHOD��NDR�L�RSWLPDOQX�GXCLQX�WUDMDQMDVQLPND�NRML�EL�SUXCLR�GRYROMQR�LQIRUPDFLMD��D�RSHWQH�EL� ®XRaLR¯�SULJX^HQRVW�RVFLORYDQMD��.RQWUROQLPVQLPFLPD�VD�UD]OLaLWLP�SRaHWQLP�XVORYLPD�QD^OL�VPRQDMSRYROMQLMH�XVORYH�

3UYR�MH�VQLPOMHQ�WRQ��WM��VLJQDO�JHQHUDWRUD�NDGDPLNURIRQ�PLUXMH��VOLND��D��GD�ELVPR�SURYHULOLIUHNYHQFLMX�NRMX�HPLWXMH�]YXaQLN�L�QD�WDM�QDaLQ�NDOL�EULVDOL�DSDUDWXUX��=DWLP�MH�VQLPDQ�VLJQDO�VD�PLNUR�IRQRP�NRML�RVFLOXMH�SRG�XVORYLPD�NRMH�NRQWUROL^HPR�VOLND��E��

6YD�PHUHQMD�VX�YU^HQD�X�ODERUDWRULML�JGH�MH�WHP�SHUDWXUD�L]QRVLOD�PDQMH�YL^H�NRQVWDQWQLK����&��9UHG�QRVW�EU]LQH�]YXND��.DGHOEXUJ��5DSDML`�������X�GDWLPXVORYLPD�MH�����P�V�

2EUDGD�SRGDWDND�QD�UDaXQDUX3URJUDPL�]D�XaLWDYDQMH�SRGDWDND��VLPXODFLMX�L�IL�

WRYDQMH�SLVDQL�VX�X�SURJUDPVNRP�RNUXCHQMX�0$7�/$%��2YGH�MH�GDW�VDPR�NUDWDN�RSLV�2aLWDYDQMH�VQLPOMHQH�IUHNYHQFLMH�VDVSHNWURJUDPD

(NVSHULPHQW�VH�]DYU^DYD�VQLPDQMHP�]YXND��WM�RVFLODFLMD�JHQHULVDQRJ�WRQD�X��ZDY�IRUPDWX��6LJQDONRML�VH�UHJLVWUXMH�SUHNR�PLNURIRQD�X�0$7/$%�MHSULND]DQ�NDR�QXPHULaNL�QL]�XUH_HQLK�GYRMNL��1DPDMH�SRWUHEDQ�VDPR�LQWHQ]LWHW�]YXND�NRML�SULPD�PLNUR�IRQ��7DM�QL]�LQWHQ]LWHWD�SRVPDWUDPR�X�IUHNYHQWQRPGRPHQX�L�WDNR�YLGLPR�NDUDNWHULVWLaQH�IUHNYHQFLMH�LQMLKRYH�RVFLODFLMH��(IHNDW�RVFLODFLMD�VH�QDMEROMH�YLGLL]�SURPHQH�)XULMHRYRJ�WUDQVIRUPD�X�]DYLVQRVWL�RGYUHPHQD��VSHNWURJUDPD�

6SHFJUDP�MH�MHGQD�RG�0DWODERYLK�XJUD_HQLK�IXQ�NFLMD�DODWD�]D�REUDGX�VLJQDOD�L�SUHGVWDYOMD��0$7�/$%�8VHU±V�*XLGH��0DWKZRUNV��)XULMHRY�WUDQVIRUP�HQJ��WLPH�GHSHQGHQW�)RXULHU�WUDQVIRUP��VLJQDOD�V�X]DYLVQRVWL�RG�YUHPHQD��1D�RYDM�QDaLQ�VLJQDO�GHOLPRQD�NUDWNH�YUHPHQVNH�LQWHUYDOH��UHGD�����V��L�QDOD]LPRDPSOLWXGH�QMLKRYLK�)XULMHRYLK�WUDQVIRUPD��D�]D�VYDNLRG�RYLK�LQWHUYDOD�L]GYDMDPR�IUHNYHQFLMX�QDMYH`HJ�LQ�WHQ]LWHWD��WM��IUHNYHQFLMX�NRMD�RGJRYDUD�WRQX�NRML�SRWLaHRG�]YXaQLND�

3RaHWQD�ID]D��1D�JUDILNX�$��VOLND����MH�SULND]DQLQWHQ]LWHW�VLJQDOD�X�]DYLVQRVWL�RG�YUHPHQD�V� �I�W��0DNVLPDOQL�LQWHQ]LWHW�VLJQDOD�RGJRYDUD�WUHQXFLPDNDGD�MH�PLNURIRQ�QDMEOLCH�]YXaQLNX��RGQRVQR�NDGD�MHNODWQR�X�QDMQLCHP�SRORCDMX�

'D�ELVPR�SUHFL]QR�L]GYRMLOL�PDNVLPXPH�SRVPD�WUD`HPR�YUKRYH��V�!�������RGQRVQR�QMLKRYH�NYDGUDWH�V�!������� �I�W���GD�ELVPR�LK�UD]GYRMLOL�RG�RVWDOLKORNDOQLK�PDNVLPXPD��

1D�JUDILNX�%��VOLND����XRaDYD�VH�GD�MH�YUHPHQVNLWUHQXWDN�∆W�RG�SRaHWND�PHUHQMD�GR�SUYRJ�PDNVLPX�PD�GUXJDaLML�RG�UD]PDND�L]PH_X�RVWDOLK�PDNVLPXPD�NRML�L]QRVL�7����7�¬�SHULRG�RVFLORYDQMD�NODWQD���3R�aHWQD�ID]D�RGUH_HQD�MH�NDR�α�=�ω�⋅�

7��−�∆�W

��

6OLND����$�¬�,QWHQ]LWHW�VLJQDOD�X�]DYLVQRVWL�RG�YUHPHQD�%�¬�.YDGUDW�LQWHQ]LWHWD�VLJQDOD��YH`HJ�RG������X]DYLVQRVWL�RG�YUHPHQD�)LJXUH����$�¬�6LJQDO�LQWHQVLW\�GHSHQGLQJ�RQ�WLPH�%�¬�6TXDUH�RI�VLJQDO�LQWHQVLW\��ODUJHU�WKDQ�����GHSHQGLQJ�RQ�WLPH��

=%251,.�5$'29$����� ),=,.$��• ����

Page 4: 0HUHQM HEU]L Q H]YX N D 'RSOHUR YH IHNDW X]SRP R` … · 2021. 1. 4. · wh odn rm h rvfloxm h vx ydnr pwu hqxwnx 3rwuheq mr mh r^ rguhglw sul rmhnflm ex u]lq h plnurirq d w em u]l

6LPXODFLMD�HNVSHULPHQWD0DWHPDWLaNL�PRGHO�RYRJ�HNVSHULPHQWD�RSLVDQ�MH

X�XYRGX��3DUDPHWUL�NRML�RGUH_XMX�IXQNFLMX�����[R��O�LK�RaLWDYDMX�VH�GLUHNWQR��D�α� L�νR�X]�SRPR`�SUH�WKRGQR�RSLVDQRJ�DOJRULWPD��

=D�VYDNL�]YXN�NRML�UHJLVWUXMH�PLNURIRQ�EHOHCL�VHX�SULEOLCQR���������YUHGQRVWL�LQWHQ]LWHWD�]YXND��EU]LQDX]RUNRYDQMD��RGQRVQR�EURM�X]RUDND�X�MHGQRM�VHNXQGLNRML�X�RYRP�VOXaDMX�L]QRVL������N+]��SXWD����V�NROL�NR�RWSULOLNH�WUDMH�VQLPDN���2EUDGD�UH]XOWDWD�XSRUH_LYDQMHPVLPXODFLMH�L�HNVSHULPHQWD�

,PDPR�HNVSHULPHQWDOQX�IUHNYHQFLMX�L�IUHNYHQ�FLMX�NRMX�GDMH�VLPXODFLMD�]D�LVWH�SRaHWQH�XVORYH��XRGUH_HQLP�WUHQXFLPD��NUDWNLP�YUHPHQVNLP�LQWHU�YDOLPD���1DV�LQWHUHVXMH�VXPD�NYDGUDWD�UD]OLND�RYLKGYHMX�IUHNYHQFLMD�]D�VYH�LQWHUYDOH�YUHPHQD��6��9UHG�QRVW�VLPXOLUDQH�IUHNYHQFLMH��IXQNFLMH������]DYLVL�RGSDUDPHWUD�F��SUHWSRVWDYOMHQH�EU]LQH�]YXND���9DULUDQ�MHP�RYRJ�SDUDPHWUD�GRELMDMX�VH�UD]OLaLWH�YUHGQRVWL�6�3RVPDWUDMPR�JUDILN�6 I�F���=D�F�L]�SUHWSRVWDYOMHQRJLQWHUYDOD�YUHGQRVWL�]D�EU]LQX�]YXND�X�YD]GXKX����������P�V��JUDILN�LPD�REOLN�SDUDEROH��NRMD�GRVWLCHPLQLPXP�QD�WRP�LQWHUYDOX��0LQLPXP�IXQNFLMHRGJRYDUD�EU]LQL�]YXND�X�QD^HP�HNVSHULPHQWX��7DMPLQLPXP�PRCHPR�RGUHGLWL�ILWRYDQMHP�GRELMHQLKYUHGQRVWL�QD�NYDGUDWQX�IXQNFLMX�*UH^ND�PHWRGH

.DNR�ELVPR�SURFHQLOL�XNXSQX�JUH^NX�RYDNR�L]PH�UHQH�YUHGQRVWL�]D�EU]LQX�]YXND��JUH^ND�PHUHQMD�MHSURFHQMLYDQD�QD�YL^H�QDaLQD��

����.DR�XNXSQL�HIHNDW�SRMHGLQDaQLK�JUH^DND�PHU�HQMD�YHOLaLQD�NRMH�RSLVXMX�SRaHWQH�XVORYH��O�G��[R��νR�L�α��¬�JUH^ND�∆�F���2QD�QDP�SRND�]XMH�NROLNR�JUH^ND�PHUHQMD�QHNRJ�RG�SRaHWQLKXVORYD�GRSULQRVL�NRQDaQRM�JUH^FL�UH]XOWDWD�

����.DR�JUH^ND�RGUH_LYDQMD�PLQLPXPD�IXQNFLMH6� �I�F��¬�JUH^ND�∆�F��

����.DR�SURVHaQD�YUHGQRVW�RGVWXSDQMD�IUHNYHQ�FLMH�RaLWDQH�VD�VSHNWURJUDPD�RG�RQH�NRMD�MH]DGDWD�JHQHUDWRURP�VLJQDOD�¬�∆�F���2YR�QDPJRYRUL�NROLNR�JUH^LPR�SUL�VDPRP�RaLWDYDQMXIUHNYHQFLMH�WRQD�VD�VSHNWURJUDPD��3RND]DORVH�GD�VH�RGUH_HQL�SRaHWQL�XVORYL��SUH�VYHJD�QL�VND�IUHNYHQFLMD��D�]DWLP�L�VXYL^H�NUDWNR�NODWQR�]QDWQR�XYH`DYDMX��

5H]XOWDWL�L�GLVNXVLMD(NVSHULPHQW�MH��X�RSWLPDOQLP�XVORYLPD��NRMH

VPR�SUHWKRGQR�XWYUGLOL��SRQRYOMHQ�YL^H�SXWD��=D�LOXV�WUDFLMX�MH�L]GYRMHQ�VDPR�MHGDQ��6���VQLPDN�L�VYL�UH]XO�WDWL�RGQRVH�VH�QD�QMHJD��3RGDFL�R�RVWDOLP�VQLPFLPDQDOD]H�VH�X�WDEHOL���

7DEHOD����3RGDFL�R�VQLPFLPD�X�RSWLPDOQLP�XVORYLPD1R νR

[+]]O[FP]

α[UDG]

�F[P�V]

∆�F�[P�V]

∆�F�[P�V]

∆�F�[P�V]

U

6� ������ �� ���� ��� �� �� � ����6� ������ �� ��� ��� �� �� � ����6� ������ �� ���� ��� � � � ����6� ������ �� ���� ��� �� � � ����6� ������ �� ���� ��� �� � � ����6� ������ �� ���� ��� �� � � ����6� ������ �� ���� ��� � �� � ����6� ������ �� ���� ��� �� �� � ����6� ������ �� ���� ��� � �� � ����6�� ������ �� ���� ��� �� �� � ����1R�¬�UHGQL�EURM�VQLPNDνR�¬�RVQRYQD�IUHNYHQFLMDO�¬�DPSOLWXGDα�¬�SRaHWQD�ID]DF�¬�EU]LQD�]YXND∆�F��¬�XNXSQL�HIHNDW�SRMHGLQDaQLK�JUH^DND�������PHUHQMD�YHOLaLQD�NRMH�RSLVXMX�SRaHWQH�XVORYH∆�F��¬�JUH^ND�GRELMHQD�ILWRYDQMHP∆�F��¬�SURVHaQD�YUHGQRVW�VWDQGDUGQH�GHYLMDFLMHU�¬�NRHILFLMHQW�NRUHODFLMH

,]PHUHQD�GXCLQD�NODWQD�L]QRVL�O� �����±���FP��DYLVLQD�]YXaQLND�X�RGQRVX�QD�QDMQLCL�SRORCDM�PLNURIRQDG� �����±�����FP��D�DPSOLWXGH�RVFLORYDQMD�[R� ����±��FP��2VQRYQD�IUHNYHQFLMD�JHQHUDWRUD�νR� ��������+]�LSRaHWQD�ID]D�α� ������UDG�

=D�GDWL�VQLPDN�VPR�GRELOL�GD�EU]LQD�]YXND�L]�QRVL�F� �����P�V�

*UH^ND�MH�SURFHQMHQD�QD�YL^H�QDaLQD��∆F�� ����P�V∆F�� ���P�V∆F�� ���P�V3ULPHQMHQD�PHWRGD�GDMH�YUHGQRVW�EU]LQH�]YXND

NRMD�VH�VD�WDEOLaQLP�YUHGQRVWLPD�VODCH�GR�QD�����

�����• ��3(71,A.(�69(6.(��� '(2��,

Page 5: 0HUHQM HEU]L Q H]YX N D 'RSOHUR YH IHNDW X]SRP R` … · 2021. 1. 4. · wh odn rm h rvfloxm h vx ydnr pwu hqxwnx 3rwuheq mr mh r^ rguhglw sul rmhnflm ex u]lq h plnurirq d w em u]l

1D�JUH^NH�VX�X�QDMYH`RM�PHUL�XWLFDOL�JUH^ND�DSUR�NVLPDFLMH��RGQRVQR�RGVWXSDQMH�UHDOQRJ�RG�WHRULMVNRJPRGHOD��PDVD�NDEOD�QLMH�]DQHPDUOMLYD�X�RGQRVX�QDPDVX�WHJRYD��WDNR_H��RVFLODFLMH�NODWQD�QLVX�PDOHNDNR�WR�DSURNVLPDFLMD�]DKWHYD���RWSRU�YD]GXKD��NRGQH^WR�GXCLK�VQLPDND�MDVQR�VH�XRaDYD�VPDQMHQMH�DP�SOLWXGH�WRNRP�YUHPHQD��L�SURSUDWQH�RVFLODFLMH�NODWQD�RQH�X�KRUL]RQWDOQRM�UDYQL���NDR�^XPL�XVOHG�QH�VDYU^HQRVWL�LQVWUXPHQDWD�L�UH]RQDQFLMH��

6LPXODFLMRP�HNVSHULPHQWD�QD�UDaXQDUX�WHVWLUDQDMH�RVHWOMLYRVW�UH]XOWDWD�QD�WDaQRVW�VD�NRMRP�VPRRGUH_LYDOL�SRMHGLQDaQH�SDUDPHWDUH��3RND]DOR�VH�GDQD�JUH^NX�X�QDMYH`RM�PHUL�XWLaX�YLVLQD�PLNURIRQD��XRGQRVX�QD�]YXaQLN�X�QDMQLCHP�SRORCDMX��L�DPSOLWXGH�SD�MH�QMLK�SRWUHEQR�PHULWL�VD�^WR�YH`RP�WDaQR^`X�

2SWLPDOQL�XVORYL�WDNR_H�VX�WHVWLUDQL�QD�UDaXQDUX�0RCH�VH�]DNOMXaLWL�VOHGH`H�

.ODWQR�YH`H�GXCLQH�®UD]YODaL¯�IXQNFLMX�����SR�[�RVL��D�YH`D�IUHNYHQFLMD�L�DPSOLWXGD�RVFLORYDQMD�NODWQDSR�\�RVL�L�VDPLP�WLP�RPRJX`DYDMX�EROMH�UH]XOWDWH��

8]�WR��YL^D�IUHNYHQFLMD�RPRJX`XMH�SUHFL]QLMHL]GYDMDQMH�ELWQLK�WRQRYD�VD�VSHNWURJUDPD��QD�VOLFL��XSRUH_HQL�VX�VQLPFL�VLJQDOD�RG���N+]�L����N+]���8]QDMYH`X�EU]LQX�X]RUNRYDQMD�RG�������X]RUDND�X�VH�

6OLND����6SHNWURJUDPL�VQLPOMHQRJ�VLJQDOD�NDGDPLNURIRQ�PLUXMH��$��L�NDGD�RVFLOXMH��%��)LJXUH����6SHFWURJUDPV�RI�VLJQDO�UHFRUGHG�ZKLOH�WKHPLFURSKRQH�ZDV�LGOH��$��DQG�GXULQJ�RVFLOODWLRQV��%��

6OLND����6QLPOMHQD�L�RaHNLYDQD�IUHNYHQFLMD�

)LJXUH����5HFRUGHG�DQG�H[SHFWHG�IUHTXHQF\�

6OLND����=DYLVQRVW�NYDGUDWD�VWDQGDUGQH�GHYLMDFLMH�6�RGEU]LQH�]YXND�)LJXUH����'HSHQGDQFH�RI�WKH�VTXDUH�RI�VWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ�6�IURP�WKH�VSHHG�RI�VRXQG�

=%251,.�5$'29$����� ),=,.$��• �����

Page 6: 0HUHQM HEU]L Q H]YX N D 'RSOHUR YH IHNDW X]SRP R` … · 2021. 1. 4. · wh odn rm h rvfloxm h vx ydnr pwu hqxwnx 3rwuheq mr mh r^ rguhglw sul rmhnflm ex u]lq h plnurirq d w em u]l

NXQGL�QLMH�ELOR�PRJX`H�SUHFL]QR�REUDGLWL�VQLPNHIUHNYHQFLMH�YH`H�RG����N+]��

9UHPHQVNL�LQWHUYDOL�NRMH�NRULVWLPR�]D�SUDYOMHQMHVSHNWRJUDPD�EL�WUHEDOR�GD�EXGX�^WR�NUD`L�MHU�WDNRLPDPR�EROMX�YUHPHQVNX�UH]ROXFLMX��1DCDORVW��NUDWNLLQWUHYDOL�LPDMX�NUDWDN�QL]�LQWHQ]LWHWD�NRMH�EL�WUHEDORSUHWYRULWL�X�)XULMHRY�WUDQVIRUP��SD�WDNR�GRELMDPROR^X�IUHNYHQWQX�UH]ROXFLMX��2YGH�EL�WUHEDOR�QD`LNRPSURPLV�]D�UH]ROXFLMX�SR�YUHPHQVNRM�L�IUHNYHQW�QRM�RVL�

9HOLaLQD�G��YLVLQD�PLNURIRQD��VDPR�®LVNRVL¯�IXQ�NFLMX��VPDQMHQMHP�RYH�YHOLaLQH�PRJOR�EL�VH�GRELWL�QDSUHFL]QRVWL��DOL�WDGD�GROD]H�GR�L]UDCDMD�KRUL]RQWDOQHRVFLODFLMH�NODWQD�

3URGXCDYDQMHP�WUDMDQMD�VQLPDND�GROD]L�GR�L]UD�CDMD�SULJX^HQMH�NRMH�X�VLPXODFLML�QLVPR�X]HOL�X�RE]LU�

.RQWUROQL�VQLPFL�VD�GXCLQDPD�NODWQD�RG��¬��P�IUHNYHQFLMDPD����¬������+]��YLVLQDPD�PLNURIRQD�¬���FP�L�VQLPFLPD��¬���V�SRWYU_XMX�RYH�SUHWSR�VWDYNH�

=DNOMXaDN�*ODYQD�SUHGQRVW�RYH�PHWRGH�MH�^WR�QH�]DKWHYD

VNXS�L�NRPSOLNRYDQ�HNVSHULPHQW��,DNR�QH^WR�VORCHQL�MD�DQDOL]D��PRCH�VH�XUDGLWL�QD�ELOR�NRP�3&�UDaXQDUX�

.DNR�MH�HNVSHULPHQWDOQL�GHR�RYRJ�PHWRGD�YUORMHGQRVWDYDQ��ELOR�EL�LQWHUHVDQWQR�LVSLWDWL�NROLNR�EL�VHSRYH`DQMHP�GXCLQH�NODWQD��DPSOLWXGH��IUHNYHQFLMH��DVPDQMHQMHP�WUDMDQMD�VQLPND�PRJOD�SREROM^DWL�QMH�JRYD�HILNDVQRVW�

=DKYDOQRVW��#HOHOD�ELK�GD�VH�]DKYDOLP�PHQWRUX6U_DQX�9HUEL`X�QD�LGHML�L�NRULVQLP�SUHGOR]LPD��NDRL�,VWUDCLYDaNRM�VWDQLFL�3HWQLFD��=DKYDOQRVW�GXJXMHP�L'UDJDQX�$`LPRYL`X�L�%UDQLPLUX�$FNRYL`X�EH]�NRMLKEL�HNVSHULPHQWDOQL�GHR�RYRG�UDGD�ELR�QHL]YRGOMLY�

/LWHUDWXUD.DGHOEXUJ�1���5DSDML`�9��������)L]LND���%HRJUDG��.UXJ.RML`�0���0L`XQRYL`�0��������7HRULMD�RVFLODFLMD�%HRJUDG��1DXaQD�NQMLJD0$7/$%�8VHU±V�*XLGH0DWKZRUNV��'RVWXSQR�QD�KWWS���ZZZ�PDWKZRUNV�FRP�DFFHVV�KHOSGHVN�KHOS�SGIBGRF�VLJQDO�VLJQDOBWE�SGI

3HWUD�6WRMVDYOMHYL`$�0HWKRG�IRU�0HDVXULQJ�WKH�6SHHGRI�6RXQG

7KH�VSHHG�RI�VRXQG�ZDV�PHDVXUHG�E\�XVLQJ�DVLPSOH��EXW�QRQVWDQGDUG�PHWKRG��$OO�PHWKRGV�IRUPHDVXULQJ�WKH�VSHHG�RI�VRXQG�DUH�EDVHG�HLWKHU�RQHFKR�RU�UHVRQDQFH��WKLV�PHWKRG�XVHV�DQRWKHU�FKDUDF�WHULVWLF�RI�DFRXVWLF�ZDYHV��WKH�'RSSOHU�HIIHFW��7KHDGYDQWDJH�RI�WKLV�PHWKRG�LV�D�YHU\�VLPSOH�DQG�FKHDS

6OLND����6SHNWURJUDPL�VQLPDND�VD�UD]OLaLWRPIUHNYHQFLMRP��$�¬���N+]��%�¬����N+]�)LJXUH����6SHFWURJUDPV�RI�UHFRUGLQJV�ZLWK�GLIIHUHQWIUHTXHQFLHV��$�¬���N+]��%�¬����N+]�

�����• ��3(71,A.(�69(6.(��� '(2��,

Page 7: 0HUHQM HEU]L Q H]YX N D 'RSOHUR YH IHNDW X]SRP R` … · 2021. 1. 4. · wh odn rm h rvfloxm h vx ydnr pwu hqxwnx 3rwuheq mr mh r^ rguhglw sul rmhnflm ex u]lq h plnurirq d w em u]l

H[SHULPHQW�WKDW�FDQ�EH�SHUIRUPHG�LQ�HYHU\�VFKRROODERUDWRU\��7KH�GDWD�DQDO\VLV�LV�PRUH�FRPSOH[��EXWUHTXLUHV�RQO\�D�PRGHUQ�3&��7KH�DLP�RI�WKLV�SDSHU�LVWR�ILQG�RSWLPDO�FRQGLWLRQV�IRU�WKH�H[SHULPHQW�DQG�WRWHVW�WKLV�PHWKRG�

7KH�SDSHU�FRQVLVWV�RI�WZR�SDUWV��ILQGLQJ�RSWLPDOFRQGLWLRQV�IRU�WKH�H[SHULPHQW�DQG�WKH�H[SHULPHQW�LWVHOIDQG�±FRPSXWHU�ZRUN±��WKDW�LV�UHDGLQJ�GDWD�IURP�VSHFWUR�JUDPV�DQG�QXPHULFDO�VLPXODWLRQ�

$�SHQQGXOXP�ZLWK�D�PLFURSKRQH�RQ�LWV�IUHH�HQGZDV�RVFLODWLQJ�DERYH�D�VPDOO�VSHDNHU��ZKLOH�WKH�VSHDNHUHPLWWHG�VRXQGV�RI�FHUWDLQ�IUHTXHQF\��%HFDXVH�RI�WKH�UHOD�WLYH�PRYLQJ�EHWZHHQ�VSHDNHU�DQG�PLFURSKRQH��WKH'RSSOHU�HIIHFW�RFFXUHG��7KXV�WKH�IUHTXHQF\�WKDW�ZDVUHJLVWHUHG�E\�WKH�PLFURSKRQH�DOVR�RVFLODWHG�

:H�PDGH�D�QXPHULFDO�VLPXODWLRQ�RI�WKH�H[SHUL�PHQW��7KH�SHQQGXOXP�LQ�WKH�H[SHULPHQW�ZDV�DSUR[L�PDWHG�WR�WKH�PDWKHPDWLFDO�RQH��7KH�RVFLODWLRQV�RIIUHTXHQF\��UHJLVWHUHG�E\�WKH�PLFURSKRQH��DUH�D�IXQF�WLRQ�RI�SHQQGXOXP�OHQJWK��SHULRG�DQG�WKH�DPSOLWXGHRI�RVFLODWLRQV��WKH�GLVWDQFH�EHWZHHQ�PLFURSKRQH�DQGSHQQGXOXP��VRXQG�IUHTXHQF\�E\�VSHDNHU�DQG��RI�FRXUVH��WKH�VSHHG�RI�VRXQG��)RU�GLIIHUHQW�VSHHGV�RIVRXQG�LQ�WKH�VLPXODWLRQ��ZH�FRPSDUHG�WKH�H[SHUL�PHQWDO�RVFLODWLRQV�ZLWK�WKH�RQHV�LQ�WKH�VLPXODWLRQ�7KH�PLQLPDO�GHYLDWLRQ�EHWZHHQ�WKRVH�WZR�LV�RE�WDLQHG�ZKHQ�WKH�VXSSRVHG�VSHHG�LV�FORVHVW�WR�WKH�UHDOVSHHG�RI�VRXQG�LQ�WKH�ODERUDWRU\�

7KH�DFFXUDF\�RI����ZDV�DFKLHYHG�

=%251,.�5$'29$����� ),=,.$��• �����