Is˜¯Gtu 31 vå2014æ / Report of Tsunami Engineering Vol.31 ...€¦ · Is˜¯Gtu31 vå2014æ /...

Post on 24-May-2020

2 views 0 download

Transcript of Is˜¯Gtu 31 vå2014æ / Report of Tsunami Engineering Vol.31 ...€¦ · Is˜¯Gtu31 vå2014æ /...

379��IsÄÅGtu 31vå2014æ / Report of Tsunami Engineering Vol.31 å2014æ�379V 389

�34Á7�ûüýþ���8í-.P2

����� | qa8��Ì�ÕÖÌ��ô8����H��8�:;�

An Analysis of Reconstruction Grant Project on the 2011 Great East Japan Earthquake Disaster� Focus on the Projects of Coastal Municipalities in Iwate and Miyagi Prefectures

at the First 3 Years since the Disaster Occurred �

þ��no *1p(qr� **1:;�<= *

6ñ�7

Reconstruction Grant system on the 2011 Great East Japan Earthquake disaster is found for prompt recovery of the stricken area. It is more flexible than existing systems. It seems to be used when the next Great Nankai Trough Earthquakes disaster is occurred. This paper reports on basic analysis of actual recording data of the Recon�struction Grant applied affected coastal munici�palities in Iwate and Miyagi. The results are as follows 1æ the scale of reconstruction grant proj�ects and numbers of death and tsunami affected people have a high association. 2æ The tsunami affected municipalities are classified 2 clusters based on distribution the grant menu and amount. Municipalities of the first cluster mainly focus housing recovery, the other cluster focus fishery settlement recovery and disaster prevention rein�forcement. 3æ Mass media and persons concerned with government to 2011 Great East Japan Earth�quake disaster Reconstruction grants have a good opinion in 2014. 4æ However, it is estimated that Kochi prefecture of reconstruction from the next Great Nankai Trough Earthquakes disaster need more than twice the budget to Miyagi.

º0�09ÇÀZ[ ^�+�@ab+ab

cdef�+ÒUs�+���@+ab�

Keywords: the 2011 Great East Japan Earthquake disaster, disaster reconstruction, reconstruction grant project, physical recovery, tsunami disaster, Reconstruction Agency

�����

��`��

ÀZ[ ^�abcde ¡�+ó^�_

`ÆK?�ͺ��JÉh ab��Åo�

_+yo_ñRÈ�o ¡��K 1æ�ÀZ[

^��?�ͺ��ùúüG" aT

?@GãÆ+yo_g_vKÝ��� ­®

AU�`a��¸o¯�+ó ¡�R�

�ï±_�K�

ÀZ[ ^�abcde ¡�2a���

¯`���K�ÀZ[ ^�abþ%ű/

��+78¨ 2)�Ûg�+þMUk;Æ�þMÒ>�_¶n+�)�­M_v�®�È

�oabcdef�>¦_2Kabcdef

����U_aJKió_{bKo�+�

c��M�K¯ö_v�+ZÁ�å³�

�+cdeGcdJK¯��×Kè¯M�

baK�ÛþMUk;Æ�þMÒ>c�è̄ �+

ó/up¨u�)_`abÛÌ��]Æ��

]�ű�ÀZ[ ^�_©n�@*�/ å01�"�©/£u "évæ�lmÈ�

oó/u�¨_­MJKUk;�űåï�

�M�K��G-Û�æÆ��_°æKÅ

±¯nbï��M�K��è¯M�i�ba

K�2014© 3ª���U�JKBñvU1�� 11Ò>c� 227Uk;��K 1æ��Â

*À¬ s�@�sg©ÄÅE**�À¬ sIs]

380 ��IsÄÅGtu 31vå2014æ

�+¬E> 4k+Ï�� 4Uk+�j���Uk;+56���Uk;+\����Uk

;+ 6� 41Uk;+!j� 17Uk+�¨� 1U+}P� 29Uk+yo� 3Uk+Ý3� 2;��K�abcde ¡_vKf��ê�+<]�s�+µ��+�+W¥F\

�+g§cV�+¼3��EGJK�09f

� 40f�hi KÙ�f�¯+Ù�f�_N}JK�091pµ4f���Küe)Ç

f�� 2�õ��K�

��`89Õþ¿-¾�|%P¡¢��

Bñͺ���@ab_NJKU�ÄÅ�+

��v� ����K�

zæ+ab>¦_NJKU�ÄÅ���¯

`���K�R(i 2æ�+c®1�ò ^�+

�q�061¼4q03�@�ab>¦�0

Mù�G¶å¯nbI�1wOn+Ì��Û

G¹ih_no��i 3æ�U{�ab>¦

�>¦�ê�ÂÃ��>+�©�ab>¦_

`ÆK?@­®¯ab>¦��ê�wOhi+

��a¸o­®��@�_ab>¦�0MÈ

�b×o�h+0MÈ�o>¦���a¸o

�êG-¸bao�h+_Ëab¹ih_n

o�îki 4æ�®êUuXÅvjk���

G¶å_+z�_NJK_ÆtuG �¯

�+^�_v¸b��oz��W��É+Å

Æ�ab>¦G�����v�_7Ænba

Kh+:=�z��ab_Nnb��v�

_fG-¸baKhGtuno�þ�1:; 5æ

�ÀZ[ ^���j�156�¸¹?�Í

º��0MÈ�oab>¦��ê¯?�ͺ

�+�Õ�N9¯�N}G¹ih_no�

�_abf�_NJKU�ÄÅ�X»�¯

`���K�j;1º% 6æ��ô7ø)�

���@å1990©V 1995©æ� abf���¼¯nb�UÈ�o��Uî\��B�_

`ÆK�DÐf�G¶å¯n+����DÐ

f�_¶nb��v�_�� , ��v�__çæMno�hG�� , Ì�ù��\������s�G��v�_��o�hG¹ih

_no�\W 7æ�®êU_`ÆKc®1�

ò ^�hi�abf�_NJKf��ǯ

���_�ù�G�ï_»ÓnbaK�

¬D�v�_ab>¦_NJKÄÅ�LW

Û�i�K��ñ�+Ì�G�ÇJKabf

�_Ëab�+M%�f�]øz0G¶å_

no��É+����_��1_çæM_"

�G�bo��_¯�z�+?�B���a

bf�����G�d�_»Ó1wOnoü

��z�_ a�þ_�Ë��@��L�

?�B��UÈ�of���ê�+�z�

_¹ih_È�ba a�

��`��¤·

ÀZ[ ^�abcde ¡�+U{�c

de ¡G¨�oö÷ f� ¡���+¿

E4$µ< B^ �+:=_���Z+È

�K�±1 ­® ���@_`ab��U

È�Kccd�ºa�

[ÄÅ��+ÀZ[ ^�abcdef�

�þi1W�G¹ih_n+:=�?�B�

abf�G�&JKD��®�G �¯G

��¯nb+ÀZ[ ^��?�no�j�

¯56�_`ÆK¸¹Uk;G¶å_noa

bcdef���êwOG ¸o�

�T)�ûÇ

��`T)�Ë�%PÜ �

[Ñ��+[ÄÅ�wO¶å_ËabÓ,

K�

:û�wO��+�j�+56��¸¹

27Uk;G¶å¯no�\��G-ao*r�+\�u���â�oEf�_vK��

G�Çnoo���K�\���?�ͺ�

��+��_vK?@¯��f�_vK?@

�YÆnbaKo�+f��7f¯Ì��÷

¯ K?@_Ëab£¤G �¯�Ôna

o�+\��Uk;Gtu¶åhi-Ôno�

�j�¯56��Uk;��+2014© 3ªÅÆå� 7û[»wæ�abcde�[w�Ë��KUk;�+�j�� 33Uk;\14Uk;+56�� 35Uk;\ 22Uk;��K�2��¸¹Uk;��bcd�ËG¯nbaK�+�çUk;�cdGãÆoÍ

381ÀZ[ ^�abcdef�_NJKwO

g��hi 3©�_�j�156��¸¹Uk;_lmÈ�of�_Ëabg

º�����Xw¬X_¯�z¸baK�z

o+:=���+MÈ�K¿E4$µB^�

�+¸¹]��T ��?@��¨�Z+

È�K¯hi�+¸¹Uk;_`ÆKab

f�_NJK�)G �`a��K�¬Dh

i+ÄŶåG�j�+56��¸¹ 27Uk;¯no�

��`T)&�E

[±��+v&V×GmaoÛ�wO¯+

]7¶2tu`vA�6£8z0tuhi

K.�wO_v¸bÀZ[ ^�abcde

f�_NJKwOG ¸o�

Û�tu_mao70£�+�6£0½-

4D_v&È�baK�� 3Ë��KÇ1æÛabcdef�>¦èåðUk;�v&æ2æ���­®É?@_NJKFGåg§B*¤ 8æ+�¼�r>b�v&70£ 9ææ

3æ*òÉ\�¦³ ��Õ� FGå�¼�r>b�v&70£ 9ææ

1æ_Ëab�+2014© 3ª���ðUk;�vTnbaK�y�_ÙÚ×+abcd

ef�70£�0«G-�no�70£�0

«��d�+f��v+<¯f�Ê+ab�

wõ_vKf�Ê+BÅÊ1URÊ+cd1

�+f��UÃ�+�cd¶åf�ó+ð©

¡�cd¶åf�ó+��f�ó¯no�{

\09L+�a`��±�UÈ�baK�f

�� 2,235s¯ ¸o�2æ3æ_Nnb+f��ê¯N}��Ka�G£¤JKo�+���­®É?@_NJ

KFG+*òÉ\�¦³ ��Õ� FGG

mab+r>� wOG ��

]7¶2tu_Ëab�+�j�¯56�

�Ì�A������â�ºa�jZG¯x

¬yG_�n+abcde_N}JKG>

�FGG��n+Ì��êwOG ��

�6£8z0tu�+2014© 2ª_ïcN2�G¶å_nb+DÓnoÛ�tu°e

G<�1�T���ÔPìno��G®�n+

�ê�67G �¦³ì�6£8z0_v¸

b ¸o�

�89:CG-¾�|%P;·T)

��`F-¾�È3

[Ñ��+abcdef�70£�0«G

mab+�UÈ�baKf���õ�¯��

>G ��T 1_�j�+56�¸¹ 27Uk;_`ab�UÈ�oðf���>f�s

L¯cdeb��bG�no�T 1�+f�sL�¿���,baK�

f�sL�+�, 2,235s���+1Uk;�o�+82.8s�Uno¯_ K��i 39f����+sL�WaDB 11f���>��f�sL�� 8]Ga�baoå81.0Væ�DB 11f���Â�+�@vÉ��HØf�+>òf�+Å��1öÊ)Ç

f�+ÒUs�ŦH*f�+ÒUÅ���

�Çf�+v��mÅ�ÖcÜìf�+XF

>f�+WWv;B±abÙp��HØf�+

F\�Uó3mURabHØf�+¾�<ì

A��tuf�+veURÖcÜìf��

�¸o�cdeb_�JK¯+f�sL¯

óô+cdeb��Å��1öÊf�¯ÒU

Ùp�HØf����WÛ+�a�\�_N

}JKf��Wa�DB 80%Ga�K 7f���Â�+Å��1öÊf�+�@vÉ�

�HØf�+>òf�+UËBabüe)Ç

f�+ÒUs�ŦH*f�+F\�Uó3

mURabHØf�+WWv;B±abÙp

��HØf���¸o�

D»_�Ðo+�UsL�nÛ�cdeb

�Waf����v�_z¯�i�KÇ

1æ�za�ab_NJKf�ÇÅ��1öÊ)Çf�+�@vÉ��HØf�+

UËBabüe)Çf�

2æ�ÕÙp�ab_NJKf�Ç>òf�+ÒUÅ����Çf�+XF>f�+

ÒUs�ŦH*f�+v��mÅ�

ÖcÜìf�+veURÖcÜìf�

3æ\��ab_NJKf�ÇF\�Uó3mURabHØf�+WWv;B±

abÙp��HØf�

¬D�+f�sL1cdeb¯�+1æ�za�ab_NJKf�­®���WÛ+�

382 ��IsÄÅGtu 31vå2014æ

a� 2æ�ÕÙp�ab_NJKf�+3æ\��ab_NJKf�¯ËÚÛ�Å��1

öÊ)Çf�_��WÛ�f�ó�[wÈ�

b`�+��� 24.1VGa�bao���É�ÕÙp���� ?@��Gﱯnb+

UËBÉ�m�s�_hhKf�­®� ×

a¯���þ�K�¾�<ìA��tuf

��+ ­® &�f����UZMB�

{�K¾�<ìA�¯Ò �_Ëab�tu

f���K�&�f�_�+��X�

� Ûf��tuf��s¹� ×a¯�

whK�F\�Uó3mURabHØf�+

WWv;B±abÙp��HØf�¯a¸o

f��Wa¯a�¯_+¸¹?�B�ab

f��þÚ�T�baK�

��`�Å���-¾�®�|}

?@�¡¯f�­®�N}G67JKo�

_+µN2L�>ÁG ¸o�?@�¡¯n

bmaoS��+ðUk;� 1æ �1 ñû¹�L+2æ��#�*ò+3æ� ��ºÈ+4æ��òFh�+5æ����L+6æ*ò� 6S���K�� 1_?@�¡¯f�sL�"»�G+� 2_?@�¡¯cdeb�"»�G�no� T 2_+f�sL+cdeb¯ðB±S�¯�µN2LG�no�rñ

f_5�µN�ºaÈ���Q?_DB 3Ëz�Ú$�nbaK�%aÚ�ñ�µN2L

�M�DB��K¯G�nbaK�µN2

L�+ �1 ñû¹�L¯f�­®�µN

2L�+f�sL� 0.856+cdeb� 0.865

T 1�ÀZ[ ^�abcde ¡��U��å� 7ûw�>æ

383ÀZ[ ^�abcdef�_NJKwO

g��hi 3©�_�j�156��¸¹Uk;_lmÈ�of�_Ëabg

� 1�ÀZ[ ^�abcde ¡��Uf�sL¯ðS��N2

� 2�ÀZ[ ^�abcde ¡��Uf�ó¯ðS��N2

384 ��IsÄÅGtu 31vå2014æ

¯��ºÛ+�_��#�*ò¯�µN2L

�+f�sL� 0.851+cdeb� 0.847¯ËÚÛ�B±�­®É�� ?@ÉB±�­

®v��+^����GãÆo*ò�WÈ_

B�nbf�­®���K7f�"i�o�

�v� 7f�+^����GãÆo*ò

�+abf��­®Ì���¯IünbaK

¯��)È�K� ¬D�\�+abcdef��eb¯�

�µN�ºa �1 ñû¹�L_�

n+Uk;G�0«¯nb+x¹�L XG �1 ñû¹�L+���L YGabcdef��cdebå*BÇ1,000�Ñæ_noû®wOG �¯+Y=6.45X+2466.3åR2=0.787 æ��¸o��û®Ô_�¯Úab++M¿E4$µ< B^_v¸b�

�JKccd��Kabcdef��­®�

�MÚ�G ¸o�ºP�� �L�� ¯

Kk��� c70£ 10æ_�¯Ú×+¬

D�û®Ô�abcde��>G �¯+�

�= 3©���abcdecdeb�� 3-1,860*ѯ K�56�_`ÆKÀZ[ ^���= 3©���abcdecdeb�1- 2,339*Ñ��Khi+¿E4$µ< B^�@��ÀZ[ ^�� 2¬D�abcde�`a¯ �+v�d Aïs¹�

��JK¯�Z+È�K�

��`-¾È3� PÜ ����

���+�U�baKf��7f_

ÙÚÛͺ��wõ¯+Ì�wõ_�Ka÷

�wOGþ�K�f��7f¯+Ì�a÷¯

Ka��¹ih_ K¯+:=�?�B_

`ÆKabf��7f���v���Kh+

zh ZDG �¯��×Kccd��

K�

Uk;�wõ_`ab�+Uk;G�0«

¯nb+ðabcdef��lmebG�L

¯JK70£Q-4G-�no�¢$«£0

ì�ñ/_�Ward/+õX¡_�²0¢q-9ÌõG$mno�ðcdeb�+Uk;�

¯_�°ìåZ'�ìæG ¸o�� 3_�no769"#$%åg��æ�+ðUk;�¢$«£0å�1æ_wh�ba

Ûô�GTnbaK�wO�°e+2Ë�¢$«£0�f�È�o�ð¢$«£0�þi

�+��¯`���K�

� 3�+ð¢$«£0�ÌõåõX¡æG10�15���wõno�D:�W(kVW�kGu 1¢$«£0å20Uk;æ¯n+X

T 2�ÀZ[ ^�abcde ¡��UsL1f�ó¯ðS��µN2L

� 3�ÀZ[ ^�abcde_vK�Uf�_�¯ÚÛ�j�156�¸¹Uk;�¢$«£0wOåWard/æ

385ÀZ[ ^�abcdef�_NJKwO

g��hi 3©�_�j�156��¸¹Uk;_lmÈ�of�_Ëabg

:��5UV¢3kGu 2¢$«£0å7Uk;æ¯no�X»_Ì�A��¢$«£0

�þiGÓ,K���+Uk;�¯_+

�cdeb� h�«_�abcdef��

a�K]�G`�+ð¢$«£0�ó]��

]´M_�¯Úab�)JK�[Ñ�+ó]

´MG+�Ucde�a�K]´]�¯Bí

¯_JK�

u 1¢$«£0�+��WÛ[wÈ�K7f_�Kf���@vÉ��HØf���¸

o�u 1¢$«£0_`ÆK�@vÉ��HØf��cde�a�K]´]�� 29.6%���+��ºa�u 1¢$«£0��+�a�+Å��1öÊ)Çf��cde�a�

K]´]�� 18.2%+>òf��cde�a�K]´]�� 9.8%���Wa��v�_�zaÉ�ÕÙp�HØ_NJKf��]

��WÛ ¸baK¯hi+u 1¢$«£0GÛ�za�ab\9�è¯Bí¯_

no�

u 2¢$«£0å7Ukæ�+��WÛ[wÈ�K7f_�Kf��+v��mÅ�Ö

cÜìf��+u 2¢$«£0_`ÆKÌ�cde�a�K]´]�� 15.2%��¸o�u 2¢$«£0_`ab�+abcde�a�K]´]��+>òf�� 18.8%+ÒUÅ����Çf�å��/yz{0/|6��

>¦0M�æ� 15.2V��¯ ¸bao��v�_+v��m�¨h+B±�Å�Öc

GÜì1�Çnv�¯JKf��]��WÛ

¸baK¯hi+u 2¢$«£0GÛv��m1Å�URab\9�è¯Bí¯_

no� �+f�7f_v¸bwõÈ�oð¢

$«£0_B¡ÚÆi�oUk;�?@�¡

�7fG×ØJK�?@�¡G�KS�¯n

b+1æ��#�*ò_a�K �1 ñû¹�L�a�K]�¯+2æ��òFh��Uk;�h�_a�K]�+3æ����L��K�Ì�A��ðUk;�'i�KS�

G¢$«£0��]´no�ðUk;��+

�¯�¯�*òÉh��å K¯hi+Ì

�zzI�no�+]´JK¯��× a

o�+¬D�v�_Ù°ìå]�G>ÁæJ

K¯_no���?@���GTJ���

�L�+1æ2æ¯óô_Ù°ìJK,×��K�+2014© 3ª����+��òF±_hhK«�L�70£�v&È�baK��

�+óô���L70£�v&È�ba a

o�+¢$«£0������LÌ����

]´MGÖ�M¯nb�J¯_no�

1æ2æ3æÌ�A��S��+u 1¢$«£0� 4.87V+17.5V+� 4,955Î+u 2¢$«£0� 0.49V+1.14V+� 108Î���+aæ��S�_`ab�u 1¢$«£0�?@�¡� ×a¯�wh¸o�u 1¢$«£0�+�Ó�Û�zaab\9�è��Kv�

_+�@vÉ��HØf�+>òf�+ÒU

s�ŦH*f��+ÒUHØ_NJKf�

�Wa��¨h+��/yz{0/|6�

°e_ÙÚ×+��G YÈ�oBÅ�WÛ

{ÆJK�Å��1öÊ)Çf�_vKZ+

òFå³Ôñ�öÊÉ+ÒUs�ŦH*f

�_vK§B��DÐ�� {�K7f��

K�u 2¢$«£0�+u 1¢$«£0�Uk;¯I�nb?@�I��YÈa¯hi+

Ûv��m1Å�URab\9�è��Kv

�_+ÅB����ÓÔG\9¯noz�Ú

Û�G �7f��K¯���þ�K�z

o+�¨h+W�Év� �\�ab_N

JKf��DB_B¡nb`�+�za�a

bhi\��ab_Y9�¡h�baK¯

���þ�K�

¬Dhi+?�ͺ��abf��ê�+

?@�¡_v¸b ×Û 2�õ�7fG�J¯�{h¸o�

�89:CG-¾�|%P<·T)

��`�&Î�ÜÝ

�Ñ��+]7¶2_G>È�oabc

deN}�»fG�¯_+ÀZ[ ^�ab

cde ¡_¶JK�Õ�Ú�_ËabwO

JK� tu_�+�j�¯56��Ì�A���

���â�ºa�jZG¯x¬yG�»fG

386 ��IsÄÅGtu 31vå2014æ

¶å_no�2012© 1ªhi 2014© 3ªz���jZG¯x¬yG�»fGÖ7n+£

�4?å"�næ¯[<_+Ûabcdeè

¯»~��K»f�70£�0«G-�no�

Èi_hi+�jZG i�j��¬Ô

�abcdef�_Ëab+x¬yG i5

6��¬Ô�abcdef�_Ëab»~È

�baK»f_Ëab-Ôno¯ö+�j

ZG� 40s+x¬yG� 92s¯ ¸o�»f��êhiÀZ[ ^�abcde 

¡_¶JKÚ�G×ØJKo�_+¶å»f

��êG��6�+ÛÂ8¯¶Qå&M�

»ÓæèÛ½$¯¶Qå�M� »ÓæèÛ£Ú

�å&M�1�M� »Ó�£ñ¯��Kæè

Û��i�� aå&M����M���

aæè� 4�õGLÁn+Ì�LÁ°eGð»f_d�no��i 4�õ�Ú���ÅûLG+ª�¯_�>n+ª�ìG� 4_�no� `+�jZG_�Û£Ú�è� h¸o�

� 4G"K¯+u 1�[w��T1æMÈ�o 2012© 2V 4ª�½$¯¶Q »f�

Wa�����»f�£�4?�ÛûGf

��$ªã���]3abµ�abcde�

Ütå�jZG+2012© 2ª 20Zæè+Ûabcde+u 1û[wæMS56�a`� 6]â ?�UkÈÖx�÷wÆËûªS:a�j�~È_9L�åx¬yG+2012© 3ª 3Zæè+Ûabcde+u 1û[wæMS56�a`� 6]âS;ÖPf¯��i{�Èab��� ÛuM�Ëèå2012© 3ª 3Zæè�v�_+$ª�ã�È�o¯ÉÕ

u�ênÈ_¶JK9L�\9���K�

u 2�[w°e��TÈ�o 2012© 5ªhi�+Ê�b&M� »f��Cnba

o�Ûabcdeu 2û[w�[�� 798*5}�Ñ��hn+a[� 1.4å�jZG+2012© 5ª 26Zæè+Ûabcde+u 2�[wæMS56���ͺ��ß'1Ú��

È�?s�ÇÎËåx¬yG+2012© 5ª 26Zæè+Ûabcdeu 2�[wSab��BµGu�DÐvS;Ö56�Pf�ÈuM�Ë

Å�È)Ï�Ë_åx¬yG+2012© 5ª

� 4�BñQ_"KÀZ[ ^�abcde ¡_¶JKÚ��iª�ì

387ÀZ[ ^�abcdef�_NJKwO

g��hi 3©�_�j�156��¸¹Uk;_lmÈ�of�_Ëabg

29Zæè¯ó ¡_¶nb&M� �P�"i�Kv�_ ¸o�

2013© 3ª_�½$¯¶Q »f�"i�K��i�+Ûabcde+tH_��

S;Ö56�Pf+Bñ�¿YÜì(�S�

ªÕåx¬yG+2013© 3ª 1Zæè+Ûa{b^� 2©�ab£���abcde�:a�j_ûª��å�jZG+2013© 3ª 6Zæè�v�_+µmhi 1©GF�­¸b+tH_aJK��É:a�j��µmhñ�9L

�T�baK�

Ì�=+�]�½$¯¶Q »f�"i�

K���+Û��i�� aè»f�ËÚÛ�

�i�+Ù[�_�cdä51æM_NJ

K»f��¸o�B�ü¯nb�+Û[�_

218*Ñ[w�abcdeå�jZG+2013© 6ª 26Zæè+Û2014©¡ZÁ2Áa`Sabcde 5,000*Ñ£-åx¬yG+2013© 8ª 31Zæè ���Ði�K�

2014© 3ª�+Ûabcde�ãÝñ�ïc�5©?+ÜÈ�"Én�å�jZG+2014© 3ª 10ZæèÛÀZ[ ^�SabcdeãÝñSïc+5©�¡?_tHåx¬yG+2014© 3ª 10Zæè�v�_+ó ¡�ãÝ"Vn_NJK»f���+Â8

¯¶Q Ú�_ ¸baK�

¬Dv�+ÀZ[ ^�abcde ¡�+

���$ªÙ°Éµmh�9L��¸o��

�+R�hi 2©�Û�iùn+2u�M�Ú�G'b×baK¯�wh¸o�

��`�TE=Y�ÜÝ

3�� ¸oÛ�tu�°e�O�d�67¯+.� FGG��JKo�_+ïcN

2�ñ��6£8z0tu¯nb+56ab

bTñ�ññ|G�¸o�56abb�ab

��f���K¯ó�_+g¯Bñͺ��

tH+��K¯hi+g¯Bñ£h�=�

hi�FGG'K¯��¾�×K¯��o�

zo+�Ñ�]7¶2tu_`ab�+56

���� × ª��"ãÆi�o¯Gã

Æb+56abbñ��6£8z0tuG�

Uno�

�6£8z0tu�+2014© 2ª+DÓnoÛ�tu°eG<�1�T���ÔPì

no��G®�n+�ê�67G ¸o��

6£8z0_ano��� 2���¡��K�¹��v�+�6£8z0tu_Ó,i�o

ÀZ[ ^�abcdef�_NJKÅ�1

W��G�ÐKÇ

1æWb�abcde_¶n+ͺ�Tñ�L�Yi�baKÇÀZ[ ^��

?�B��+*�V°�ûn�W�¯

¸bao 11æ�þ_+Aï­®�Y

Èaͺ�ñ+Wb�cde�`�K

k�+ͺ�Tññ�s¹�G�JK�

ü�±+W�k�^���Aï­®¯+

abf�ñ�cdebGI�JK¯+

]� 22©¡ZÁ�� 51*Ñ��¸o�_¶n+abcde�]� 24© 6ª�u��[whi 2013©© 6ª�u 6û[wz���>�� 658*ѯ� 13¯ ¸baK�f��Ñ�ÉTñ�

s¹��C ��×ïÈ�Ko�+a

bcdef�G�ÇJKo�_�+ó

�_*�6'�U0GY=JK`a�

�K�

2æ2014© 2ªÅÆ��+Å��1öÊf�É�@vÉ��HØf��abcd

ef�� × ]�Ga�baKå3.1Ñ��wO�V�æ�:=�WF�f�

��\�ab_N}nof����

baÛ¯Z+È�K�ÀZ[ ^�a

bcde�µm&������+Y=

JKU0�ÒUab��K¯nb+\

�ab_NJKf����A6��K

¯nbûìc_ ¸ofü��¸o�

3æÀZ[ ^�abcde ¡�+?�ͺ�¹��hi�2ufÚ��K�

 ¡_Ëab × W�� Û+În

ö*jûnÉB±���_���W�

����K¯�abaK�ÅÆ��+

abcde�3�d�ºa ¡¯nb

�M�Ú�G'baK¯7ÆnbaK�

:=� ­® �@_`ab�óô�

 ¡�R��Z+È�K�

388 ��IsÄÅGtu 31vå2014æ

¬Dhi+ÀZ[ ^�abcde ¡É

�U��_Ëab+*�6' �W���K

���+ ¡Í�_Ëab�ºaÚ�G��

baK¯�{h¸o��°e�+�Ñ�

]7¶2tu_`ÆK 2014© 3ªÅÆ�Ú�°e¯øvnbaK�

&îï|�

[±��+ÀZ[ ^��yo_ñRÈ�

oÀZ[ ^�abcde ¡_�n+�

j�¯56��¸¹Uk;�lmÈ�baK

f���êÉ­®_NJKÛ�wO�¨h+

Bñ]7¶2��êwOÉf�¹��ñ��

6£8z0tu_vK.�wOG a+^�

��hi 3©��ó ¡�Å��×ØG a+:=�abcdef�_NJKP"1×Ø�

"�Gþ�o���tu1wOGVnb

'i�o°e���v�_z¯�i�KÇ

1æÀZ[ ^���hi 3©�iùno8½_`ÆKabcdef��+�z

a�ab_NJKf�­®��� ×

Û+�a��ÕÙp�HØ_NJKf

�+\��ab_NJKf��­®�

×a�

2æÀZ[ ^�abcdef��sLÉf�ó�­®�+ �1 ñû¹�L

É��#�*ò¯a¸o+^�_��

GãÆo*ò­®¯ºaµN�7�i

�o� 3æ2æ_�¯Úab+ �1 ñû¹�L¯abcdef��[webG�¯

_-�noû®ÔåijÔæ_v¸b+

+M¿E4$µ< B^_`ÆKºP

��cdef��­®��MG ¸

o¯ö+� 3- 1,860*ѯ ¸o���+56�_`ÆKÀZ[ ^�

��= 3©��[wÈ�oabcdecdeb� 1- 2,339*Ñ� 2¬D���+v�g�AïGFWJK¯

�Z+È�K� 4æ^���hi 3©��cd1�UnbaK�j�¯56��¸¹Uk;

�+Ã_ 2Ë�¢$«£0_wõÈ�K�u 1¢$«£0�Û�za�ab\9�è���+�@vÉ��HØf

�+Å��1öÊ)Çf�+>òf�

��Ã_lmÈ�baKUk;�U

�JK�u 2¢$«£0�+Ûv��m1Å�URab\9�è���+Ã_v

��mÅ�ÖcÜìf�+>òf�+

ÒUÅ����Çf��lmÈ�ba

KUk;�U�JK�u 1¢$«£0�Uk;�+I��+?@�¡� ×

Uk;���ÒUab�Ãa �U

f�¯ ¸bao�u 2¢$«£0�+u 1¢$«£0_I,bI��+?@�¡�YÈÛ+\�abÉÅ�Öc�

Üì_Ã��¡h�bao�

5æÀZ[ ^�abcde_¶JKB�G>GmaowO_vK¯+��_`

ab�Õu�ênÈÉ+µmh�9L

�a��Wh¸o���+Ì�=�Å

�GãÆb+&M� Ú�¯ ¸b

a¸o�

6æ 56abb¹��_¶JK�6£8z0tuG ¸o�Ì�°e+ab

cdef��ä51cdæM�_`a

b3�d�ºÛ+ÀZ[ ^�abc

de ¡_¶JKUk;¹��hi�

Ú��2ufÚ��K¯�wh¸o�

5æ6æ�v�_ÀZ[ ^�abcde ¡Ì����+ïc1ͺ�N2�hiïf

Ú�GãÆbaK�ñ�+Ì��Uf�G

�UJK*��ûnnbaK¯++M¿E

4$µ< B^_`ab�ÅÆ�L¬D�

ZÁ�`a_ K¯a�W��¹ih_ ¸

o�

[±��+^��� 3©�¯a��j�+56�¯�a7G�0«_no+[�� a

bG�ÝJK��G¶å_notu1wO_

¯�z¸baK�:=�+D»�W��£¤

¯¯�_+ÀZ[ ^�abcde ¡�µ

m(Y�Z+È�baK 2015©¡�z��iùG¶å_wO1�)Gä¤noa�

389ÀZ[ ^�abcdef�_NJKwO

g��hi 3©�_�j�156��¸¹Uk;_lmÈ�of�_Ëabg

#$ñò

1æab�ÇÀZ[ ^�abcde ¡2a+http://www.reconstruction.go.jp/topics/main�cat1/sub�cat1�14/20131206_kofukin�gaiyou.pdf

2æR(Þ�+Laurie Johnson+�ªz+¥îzÇ �@=��@ab>¦0Mù�g®ê

U¯øz0®0q6#�>¦0Mù��

I�G\9¯nbg+B±î�sÕ3<

�+No.13+pp.335�345+2010.3æ�ªz+R(Þ�+¥îzÇ��XÆ�­®��@_"æ{�oiab>¦�0

MÈ�K�h ? : ab>¦�0MÈ�K�@­®¯>¦�êg+B±î�sÕ3

<�+No.9+pp.20�36+2007.4æîk��S+3�ï1+§ú)*Çc®�ò ^�=�®êUuXÅ_`ÆKa

b>¦_NJK���_Ætu+Z[³

wsÕ×+pp.253�256+1996.5æþ�no+:;<=ÇÀZ[ ^�_`ÆKab>¦�<=�wO��j�15

6��¸¹Uk;G¶å¯nb�+Í

à�@�s+Vol. 31, No.4+pp.305�315+2013.�

6æj;S+º%1öÇ��Uî\��B��DÐf�_NJK����_��ù

�_NJKtuÄÅ+§jsÕ3<�+

No.786+pp.145�155+2005.7æ\W�bÇ®ê�^�abf��28½ÒU>¦¯z�ÚÛ�®�+s���+

2011.8æg§B*¤Ç��òFå³�§B3m%h�_Ëab +http://www.gsi.go.jp/chirijoho/chirijoho40025.html

9æ�¼�r>bÇÀZ[R]¢¹B±�70£@A?�N270£gÛ�Õ1*

òr>�dår>��KÒ>c�1UÅ

k;æèv�g ,http://www.stat.go.jp/info/shinsai/

10æ� cÇ¿E4$µ< B^¶0£¤�0º6##?0!åu��Gtæ ïCV ×+http://www.bousai.go.jp/jishin/nan�kai/nankaitrough_info.html

11æþ�no+:;<=+¥îzÇÀZ[ ^�_`ÆK?�ͺ��*�V°µm

_NJKwOg56��ýUG¶å_n

bg+B±î�sÕ3<�+No. 21+pp. 169�177, 2013.11.