Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

download Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

of 13

Transcript of Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

  • 8/20/2019 Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

    1/13

     Antonetti, Alina Alia Antonetti Atttorney at Law817 Almeria AvenueREAR APTCora Gables F 33134

    Name: SOO-ENRIQUEZ GSTAVO

    US. Department of Justice

    Executive Oce Immigration Reew

    Board ofImmigration ApealsOce of th Crk

    5107 Lee sburg Pik, Sute 200Fals Chc Vgn 2204

    DHS/ICE Oice of hie Counse POP.OBox 2515Phoenix AZ 85002

     A 087274650

    Date o t h is notice / 5 /2015

    cosed is a copy of te Boad's decisi ad ode i the above-reeced case.

    Encosue

    Panel Membes:uly, RogrGrr A Co rici A.

    Sinceely,

    DO caDoa CaChie Cerk

    Uetea Dock

    For more unpublished BIA decisions, visitwww.irac.net/unpublished/index/

     I m m i  g r a n t & R e f u  g e e A  p  p e l l a t e C e

     n t e r , L L C| w w w . i r a c . n e t

    Cite as: Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

  • 8/20/2019 Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

    2/13

    Decision f e Bard Imtin Appls

    F Curh Vignia 2053

     Fe A087 274 650 Pox,A Dte: AUG 5 201

    e GUSTA VO SOTO IQUEZ

    MOVA PROCEEDS

    APPEA

    ON BHALF F ESPONDN: Ai Atonet, su

    RE:

     otic: ec 22()(6)(A)(), & Act [8 USC § 82()(6)(A)()]

    Pn wout beg ded o poed (wr)

    odged: S 237()()(B), & Act [8 USC § 22() ){ B) -n Uted Ste in oton of w

    APPLICAIO Adjsmt of Ss; w of nsb

    e esponden, d czen of Mexico, es e o udges M 9

    204, dcison, ndig eoe, dg s ppcton usen of sts deseon 245() of e Iion d Ntony Act, 8 USC § 1255(), d tngot de e D of Hoed Secty no onded eepoens ppe w be ssi, d e eod w be eded updted bckodd secy cecks

    e Bod ews ngs of fc d e cy oeou" sdd 8 CFR§00(d))i) Mater of S-H, 23 & Dec 462, 46465 (B 2002) Te Bo

     evew uesion of w, dson, d udn d o ssues n pes om dcsosof Ion Judges de novo 8 CF R § 10031(d)(3)(i) Becuse e con w e My , 2005, t s ujec to e visos of e A ID Ac of 2005

    esponden cocedes t e i emobe y e of s w pec in e Uted Stes (J t 2 T 20) e espondt equted te eef of duent of sto e e en Re le n hi e s dSes ctz ouse.

     Feby 2003, e espodet ws concted, prut o gty pe, 1991 oeof poseso of acotc gs (Ex 2, Tb D) Fo oe, te espondt was senced

     to 2 ys pbo o, e d fees (id.) In be 206, t Supio Co ofAzon, Mcop Coty, e aide e onden's 200 uden of gt psu oARIZON EVSD TTUES NOD § 3907 xh 3)

     I m m i  g r a n t & R e

     f u  g e e A  p  p e l l a t e C e

     n t e r , L L C| w w w . i r

     a c . n e t

    Cite as: Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

  • 8/20/2019 Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

    3/13

    087 274 65

    e Iiion Judg deeind h th resondent's 199 convton l win thFederl Frst Oender Act FFOA) proecing h rsonden gst the dvers mmgrtionconsequencs o onetie s drg ossesson. See Lujan-Armendariz IN, 222 F3d 728

    (9h r. 200) holdng t der drg convcons exunged nder th FOA, 18 US.C.§ 367, o b used fr ion uroses and no rtionl bsis exiss fr denyng reli oidncly siuted ins who u fr siilr een nder ste exungeen ws), overrule by unez-Reyes . Hoer 66 F.3d 684 69 9 r 20) (hoding ony lis rosectively)

     Uon or d novo rvw, w disee wt he Iigron Judgs denil o djustent oss r o dscron Befr djusen o stus y b grted n lict brs he buden o deonstrng th h ris rei s r o dscreion.  ee Maer of ra,13 I&N Dec 494 496 BIA 1970); Mater of Ba &N Dc. 626 BIA 974; A.. 1976).he extrordinry dscronr relie o djsen "c ony be nted n eioroscses t 630. Generlly, e existence o vorble cors such s mly tes hds,leng o residnce n the Unies Ses ec. will be considerd s coterviling corsmrting vorbl exercis o dnsrive discrton. Maer of ra supra 496.However whre dverse cors are resen, y be ncss r len to resent evdenceo unusul or even ostndng qties o ouweigh he negve ctors

    The Imigrtion Judg consdrd e resondn's vorble cors inclding hisrsidence in e Unted Ss snce 1988 d s ily tes incldng his Ued Stes cizenwi nd chid (I.J. 78). he Igrtion Judg so consider vorble ctor hresondents supo o hs whle she colees hcy school (I.J. ).

    he Iition Jdge sed is dn o djsent s ter o dscretion soey on hs

    concusion tht h rsondent ckd credbil becuse his sony conicd wih 203 re-senence nvestigon regarding s 1991 oens red by robtion ocer fr hes criinl co ndicting tht n 1991 d y 1992 he sod cocn o n ndrcover olc ocer  .J. t 7-8 r. t 39, 4550 E 2 b E). We nqr y e hd ino ecircumstcs srodg h coission o he crm n ordr to drn er vorbe exercse o discretion s wrranted it s iissibl to go ben rcord oconvcon to rssss n lien's ultte ut or nnocnc Matter of oberts 20 I&ND 294 31 BIA 99) Jus w wl not g hnd rcord o conviction o dene eguit or nocenc o en so we re hsin o gve substtil weght to resenenceinvsgon  reped more thn 1 yers er h even bsent convicion r the ceegd or coroborg vdence o he llegtion conined tren. See Mater of rregun

    21 &N Dc 38 42 (BIA 995) (dcnng o give sbsti weigt to an est reo, n ebsence o convicon or cooborting evdece, in consdering exrcise o discretion)Her e lic concded h he hd comtd cr d d restituton most 25 earsg e e e te, e ws nble to se Englsh d, rre w bl tocomncte th t polc ocr Tr. 41) Moreovr, even ssing he sold cocne sssred in e rsentence reo, s estiony is ndisud tht he h h no dverse contct

    2

     I m m i  g r a n t & R e f u  g e e A  p  p e l l a t e C e

     n t e r , L L C| w w w . i r a c . n e t

    Cite as: Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

  • 8/20/2019 Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

    4/13

    A087 274 650

    aw ercemet, to icude a rac ticket, sice that tme (Tr. at 50, 53) 1  Uder thesecircumsces, we cocude that the resoet mets adjustmet of status i discretio, ad wew remad he record r the reqred backgrou d securty updates

    ODER: T respodet's appea is sutaied

     FRTHER ORDER Pursuat to 8 CFR. § 1003l (d)(6), the record is remaded to theImmiatio Judge r the urpose of aowng the DHS the ooun to compete or udateidetiy, aw ercemet, or securty ivetigations or examiatios, d rer roceedngs, ifecesar, a r e ery of a order as provide by 8 CFR § 003 47(h)

     FR HE BOAD <

    I We observe hat e DHS did ot oose a at of reief (r. at 55).

    3

                 

         p  p         

           

          

          

    Cite as: Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

  • 8/20/2019 Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

    5/13

    SS R F SV F FR GR VW

    GR R  S R S

    X RZ

    R F

    S-QZ G

    R

    ))))))

    RV RS

     F --

    "A1 .

    RG eco 23)()B) o te gion d Noy Ac edsson s noniga ude ()) o Ac e spoeee he nd s e ong n eed n vioono Ac o y ot w o he ne s

    Adjusm o us u sco 245() of te Acoury Depe de secon 24B(b) o e Ac

    Ri C Buos sqBueos Lw Oces Ic686 No 27 AvenuePoex Ao 817

    G:C KppAssis Ce CounseDepen o Ho cuy23 No ent AvenuePoex Aon 84

    S RR F GR R

    I. PROCEDURAL HISTORY

    O nu 209 e Dep o Hoen cuy ("DH) ssued oce oApp (TA) gs e sponen cgg s ovbe pusun o secio22()6)(A)() o e io oly Ac (A o e Ac), s eded s pse i e U es ou eing e o po o wo s v h

     Und es y e o pce oe sg y oey ne. [Ex. .] suppo o is cg H ge spon ) s o c o no o e Ue ts; 2) s n ciz o Mexco () ned e U es o e Po exs o o ou ugus 2 188 (4) ws no e o po speco by gon Oce (Id]

    se cd poceedngs ed o Juy 22 29 e espode og cosee lgons (1) ough (3) n TA e egon (4) a ie te cg o

    4 .

     I m m i  g r a n t & R e

     f u  g e e A  p  p e l l a t e C e

     n t e r , L L C| w w w . i r

     a c . n e t

  • 8/20/2019 Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

    6/13

    EQEZA087-27465

    rmovabi psa to scon 22a) 6))) of e c he rsponn, oh cosl,sna Mxico as te conr of rmoval h rsponen, oh consl, nca ta he

    lel ntre th Unid Sats n 1988 w a o I-94, rrvalDpe Record, bt hrsponn was avn ic locan t ocnt he rspondn, og consl, alsoinicat a wol b sekn he rlf of asten of sas ner scion 245(a) of ec pon obainin proof of leal entr Alteaivl, the responent, oh cosl, indicaetat wol b sekin rlif in th rm of ccellation of rmovl or volnry eprreTe Co rs proceins o allow rsponden im to locae s I-94

    On Marc 24, 2010, e rsponen, roh consel, indcae at h wishe oschel nivial har o monstra h responen's ligiili r cncellation ofrmovl, as h respondn was still havn ic locatn his 94 t s hering, DHS lsoinicat ta te respondent ad a crina hisory hat col ac his eliiilit r reli

    DHS sumite t respond's crin rcors on J 9, 2010 [x 2] respondn never smted an application r cncellation of rmoval Insa, at e

    nividal hrn on Novmr 4, 2013, th rsponden, trogh consel, sbmid a Form 485, pplicaion o Reister Prmanen Rsince or djst Stas, which ncl vnc ofa lg ntr no Unite Saes on Ocobr 1, 988 x 5] Basd on he videnc of a llen, DH sbmi a Form I-261, ditional Chres of Inamissiliyeporaili, in liof NT [x ] In Fo 1-26, DHS loge amend chge aainst ersponen, chrgin him as removal prsn o scion 237a) )B) of the c, as amend,in ha ar amsson as a nonnt nr sction 10(a)(5) of e c, te rspondnrmne in h Unte Ss r a tme lonr hn pei, in violaton of the c or n

    or law of he Unit Sas [Id] In sppor of is char, DHS llee ha th rspondent:) was amit o he Unit States a a o place on or ao ust 27, 988, as aorder crosser or noniign visior a a Mxic order po of en r a mporry prono o exced svn-wo hors to visi in th ra wiin et-ve ils of Unite Staesorder wi Mxico 2) was nconr on or aot Decemr 16, 2008, at Phoenix, Aizona, adistce or th wnve mils om h Unie Stas border with Mxico; nd 3) hs norecivd the peissio of iraion ocr to procd eod tha wentve mil lior sevnt-o-hor priod rsponn amite thse alleaions conceed he cg

     prsat o 237a)( )(B) of t ct.

    Th rspondn tesid n sppor of is a  plcations r rlief at nivil hing

    l on Novbr 4, 2013, bere hs Cor nur of ocnts relatin o hresponnts cse have een enered nto recor as lows the N, issed on Jay 5,2009 [x 1 ; a Fo I-261, ion hs of nadssl/Dporali, smit on Novmr 4, 2013 x ; DSs Sisson of vidnce, sbite on 9, 2010 x. 2,

    I The respondent teste thrugh an nerpreter n he Spaish language r he majrity of hs tesiony. However,e responent cose o nsh hs testmoy n he Engsh anguage as he as speaks Engis enty an washang cy wang r the intereter o copete her intepreatons bere he cu respond

    2

     I m m i  g r a n t & R e f u  g e e A  p  p e l l a t e C e n

     t e r , L L C| w w w . i r a

     c . n e t

  • 8/20/2019 Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

    7/13

    TNQZ·

    b AE]; Jmet o G St e bmte o 20 E ] eot'og omt e 5 20 [Ex 4] o -85 Aco to

    Regtr Pemet Reence jt St wth ng oet Form 60Acto r Wve of Gro o mb td on Ote 29 201 [x. 5b AE

    I. STAEMEN OF THE LAW

    A. Credibilt

    A t m tem wee l met t tttry te ry t r o re h or he m rqt th C t h eeto

    regarg t rey eve u b te t' emy. A §20()()(B). n er ton r re emo o r e heMy 1 2005 ee o he AL ID At o 2005 PL. 109-3, 9 Stt. 23("EAL ID At th ety detmon go by te AL D t rvoregrg rely e A vde th te rby we ee theowg mer:

    Cerg e tty o e te d reet tor temmgrto g my be crebty det te emor coror reoe o th p or t th t y o thecn' r we cont e cncy ee te ct' orwn wre or tem (evr me wehr r ot deroth oerg he ct r wh e emen wee me)the te cotecy o h ch sttemet t coneny of httmet wh othr vee rcor (cg et o h Dmto St o cotry ot) y cure r ho eme wht rgard o eter eny, ic or ehoogoe o the ear o h ct' c r y tr reen

    A § 20(c)((C).

    Reevt tor a to t' er ne r r ex wy wt t or t roue otn min r o eeh. SeeArulampaam v. Ashcof, 33 F 67 8 ( Cr 2003) n to wng torm or n vere re nng ' b t ctyete teoy Unakhaul v Gnzaes F 3 93 9 Cr 205 hog t to roy core t "mgr ncc" etmo) evavetetmy Wang v INS 352 .3 1250 25 (9 Cr 2003) ttmony tt is meDon . Gnale, 416 F3 8 7 9th C 200)

     Unr te REAL D Ac v r ctene re crty3

     

     

      

  • 8/20/2019 Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

    8/13

    �/

    OOENRQUEZ·A087-274-650

    '(

    dig Jibril v. Goales, 423 F3d 1129, 1138 1 (9 Cir 200) For puoses of a adversecredibiy deemiaio he appica ms be given an oppouiy o expain or dey y

    discrepancies or iosiseies, ad e Cou ms cosidr he applicas rasoable adplausible expaaios Chen v Ashcro, 362 F.3d 611, 618 9h Cir. 2004); Sing v Gonzales,439 F.3d 1100 10 9h Cir 2006); Kar v Ashcro 379 F.3d 876, 887 (9h Cir. 2004).

    e appia's esmo aoe ma be suiet o susa is or her burde of proofwho corroboratio "f i is demostaby redib prsuasiv, ad probave of ssucien o support he applias laim Maer f-Y--, 24 & Dec. 260 263 BA 2007)f h applica's esimoy is und o be credible he Co il eigh e esimoy h oervde i he reord A § 240(c )( 4){B) Hoever if e Cou deeres ha oroboraiveevidee should be produd, i "ms be provided uless he applic does o have hevidce d cao reasoabl obai he evidee Id ;  see as Sing v Hoder 649 F3d

    1161 1173 (9h Cir. 2011) oig ha e ilure o produe readily availabe evidee maysuppo a advers credibiliy deemaio uder he AL D Ac credibili lagagesupersedig previous ih Crcui ase a) Unuakhauu, 416 F.3d a 938 odig ha aapplica may be d o credible "here h J has reaso o quesio he applicsredibiliy ad e applia ils o produce o-dupicaiv, maeral easy availableooboraig evidece ad provides o credible explaaio r suc lue) (ineaquoaios omd) Ths, a appic r reif should provide videiary suppo r"maeria cs whic ae cera o his or er m ad easil subje o vericaio Mater o-Y--, 24 & Dec. a 263 quog Maer -, 21 I& Dec. 722 7226 BA 1997))he ilre o produce su reasoabl avaabe ooboratg evidece c lead o a digha he appia has ied to mee his or her brde of proo d

    B. Adjustment o Status uer Sectio 245(a) o the Act

    Sio 24a) of the A provides r he adjusmet of sas of ie who asispected ad admid or paoled io he ied Saes o a disriory basis, i: 1) h aliemakes appicaio r adjusmen 2) a imigran visa is iediae avaabe o th aiea he ime his or her appiaio is led; ad 3) he aie is eigibe o reive an iigra visaad is admssible r perme residee. A § 24(a). f he aie has no bee "ispeed adadmied or paroed ito e ed Saes, h alie is o egibe r adjusme of saus uder24(a) ess he or se qies r he special provisios uder he Viole Agais WomAc ("A WA. Id

    deeiig heer a vorabe exercise of discreo is wed i ganngadjse of sas, cours ill ook o a mber of qiabl cos. Such ors "icl ba o limid o e existece of mily ies i he id Staes; h g of he respodnsresidee i he ied Saes; he dship of avelig abroad ad he respodesiigraio hisory, cludig any preoeived ie o imme a he ime of eerg as aommi Maer of Hasm 24 & Dec. 785 793 (BIA 2009) ieal ciaiosomied). Addiioa a crima hisor lak hreois relevan o he exercise of

    4

     I   i  g  a   &  e  u  g e e A  p  p e   a  e C e 

      e  ,   C

         i  a

        e 

  • 8/20/2019 Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

    9/13

    OO-QUZ·A087-274-650.

    dscreo Id Geerlly, who he presece of relev dverse cors, screo wllordrly vor r duse o ss ater of Mendez-orlez, 2 I&N Dec 296, 3

    B 996)

    C. Vounta Departure

    ecio 24B o he c provdes h, t e coclso o reovl proceedgs, cory pet ie o volrly depr he ed Ses, the lie's own expese, ele: ) hs ee physclly prese e ed Ses r period of t les oe yermedely precedg serce o e oce o ppe (2) s d hs een person of goodorl chcer r t les ve yers (3) s o deporle uner § 237()(2))) (s nggrved lo) or 237()(4) (on secriy or reled onds); nd (4) hs eslishe y clerd covcg evdece he or she h e es o dep e ied Ses d neds o

    do so der 8 CFR § 24026c)(2), cler nd covcg evdece o he es o depshl clde ll cses preseo y he lie o psspor or oer rvel docueosce o ssre lwl ey o he co o whch he le s deprg lenpeed o dep volly s pos volry depe od o ecessry oese h he lie wl depr" § 24B(b)3)

    ANL VSIS

    Credibility

    Te respoe ed s djse of sts pplcon o Noveer 4, 2 3; herere,hs c s goveed y he REL D c See REAL D c sg h he D cppes o reqess r rele led on or er e My 1, 205 de o ece)

    der he RE D c credlity sdrd, he Cour ds h e respode hs oprovided credile esoy The respode prvde cosse esony regrdng hspcpo he sle o drus Dug drec exto, te respode repeedly sedh he never sold dgs d, ore speccally, th he ever sold drs o polce ocer Therespoe lso ly cled h oly hs ed Jose oBel Beltr) sold dgsHowever, dr crossexio e respode ded h he ced s te ddle ewee Bel d dercover polce ocer who ws cg s uyer. lhogh e

    respode s lly evsve whe qesoed rerdg he eves dscssed hsPreseece vesgo, he lely ded h he hd, c sold coce o dercover ocer o Noveer 27, 99 Deceer 3, 1, d uy 7, 992

    Moreover, he or ds plsle te respoet ever receved y oeyr helpg Belr sell dgs, s he cls rherore, sch cls re drecly cordcey e record The respoe esed h e ever eeed or expeced o ee oelyo helpg Belr; rer, e respode cls h he only ced s ddle drn

    5

     I m m i  g r a n t & R e f u  g e e A  p  p e l l a t e C e n

     t e r , L L C| w w w . i r a

     c . n e t

  • 8/20/2019 Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

    10/13

    QUZ 77

    ers ug tsacios ecause h id er a ed o hp hi ou. e resodehr ese a e ever o anoe a he raso he as hepg era as o eexra ico ecaus as org a Paa xprss so chai, a ha do e e exa o. Hoer, he Presec vesgo coacs he rsoe's eso [ee x 2, a . The Presec Ivesigaio saes ha upo qusoig, heresponde o a poce ocer th h goig o receiv $00 o oe of e drug

     rsacos ha he ws hepig Bea s he ugs o ae ex one. [Id] Fuere respode aer ese ha he as o eg uh oe a Pn xpess, ch is he cou o rd o pay a aoe o onu orkg o s cina case i 19 Theo ds he irio coae i e reseece Ivesigo o e ore redie a

     e respoe s sseo ha s a eee-y-od ma w opig ob heexpeed ohg n r r helg Bera s drugs or Beras edship.  See

    Chebcoub v. IN 25 Fd 103 044 9 200) hoig ha eso s"ipausie n igt of bakoud evece ca suppo a aderse rei g)arogae by saue o other n a tated hresha v Holde, 50 d 104 046 ir 2010  ee also Jibr v. Gonzale, 42 3d 2 135 ( ir. 2005 "houghsecuaio ad oeure oe co sus a adverse ed dg J beaoed o exercse coo sese rejecg a peiioers eso eve i he o

     poi o specc coar eiee he record o ree .

    he o s he respoes eso acke he requis g o u o idu o he inconsise pause smo discussed above ee Kar v Goae 83 06, 06 (h r 200) (iea uoaios oie cordig he ou d a

     he respode has ot povied redibe sion , erere eers a averse creidig.

    Secio 245() of he provdes r e ause of ss of an respoe speeda aie or paold o he ie Sas i e espode: 1) has ae apiio raduse 2) ia visa is iee vae o the respoe (3 e respodehas deosraed egiil o receiv ha visa d aiss r peae resde; (4 he respoe a vorae xercse of isreio

    he rsoe ha ade appio duse of sats, a gran vsas meiae aae o i as h sos o a d es ciz. Ex , as AB. herespoe h aso proi proof o a ega er 8 Ex , a C

    ough he respod pe gu o Possesso o Noic Dugs 2003 [Ex 2], sudge of gu as se aside o Sepeer 22, 200 [x. . Trere, he Fedra FrsOeder A appies proecn he respoe agais averse igao cosequeces

    ;a c

     I m m i  g r a n t & R e

     f u  g e e A  p  p e l l a t e C e

     n t e r , L L C| w w w . i r

     a c . n e t

  • 8/20/2019 Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

    11/13

    SOTO-ENRQUZ·A087274-650

    becse is s-e sple possessio rg oese ws exped See LujanArmendariz v.INS 222 d 72 (9 2000, overuled by unezReyes v. Hoer 646 F3d 684 (9t r.

    2011 (holig eql poeco d o requre reig expged se cocios of dgcies e me s eel g cocos t d ee expuge ue e Feel FrsOede ) log e Nih Cci hel i uez-Rees eel Fis Oeder Acpoecos o o eed o s-ie sple ug possesso oeses expged ude steeblv stue, rule pples oly pospecely NuneRee 646 F.3 690-94Theee becuse he rspode's se expgee occe 2006, ve yes ee eNuez-Re oli s Possesso o Ncoc rgs oese oes no cout gs hi s coico r dssbily prposes

    Tus e esoe s soly elgile jsmen of sus e seo 45(of e Ac e oly reig issue is whee e wats voble execse of dsceo

     2. Discretion

    Adte o sus er seco 245( o e Ac s discetiory r of eleatte ofaah 5 Dec 127, 34 (BIA 00. I king seoy eeios, eCor weh e vole an dese sceoy cos to ee wether, o blce, eol o th eece dices e respode ts vorle exercise o dscetoMate oJe, 3 & Dec 3, 383 (AG 2002.

    Cosdetios t y sppo orle eercse o discreo by e Cou icle,u e not le o, eiece o log-e esdece, youg ge e, ohe aly es

    he Ue te, serce e ed tes rme rces, evdee of vle d sece o heco eidece of ny geie poscoico eblto, ad so ofeploye, popey, o sess es wih e ite es. C-V-T, 22 &N Dec 11 Negie coserios iclude evece of respode s ccer o esibty s pee esden o e Ue Stes, cludn the e uderlyig crcusces ofhe os of issility o eoblty e sse, e pesece of tolsc igo oltios, e e, ececy, ad seiosness o respoe'scl recod Id

     Fs, e lookig e ege cors pese the resoes case he Co hs t e espoe d o povie credible esoy e espode as ot eeig w e Cou regdig is iolvee i e sle of coce Alog herespodes es ocue oe wey yes go, 1991, te espode coes o eyclpblit his cos Te respoe eses o i e expece o eceie oey nechage r epig is ie sell ugs, d e plces ll of e ble is skes oBela

    e posiie cos i e espode s cse ncle he espode s log-ie resece is con d s lil es o he Ue es, cld e Ses cize wife

     I m m i  g r a n t & R e f u  g e e A  p  p e l l a t e C e n

     t e r , L L C| w w w . i r a

     c . n e t

  • 8/20/2019 Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

    12/13

    SOTOENRQUEZA7-274650

    nd hild. The Cou an so asse h he responden provides suppor o is wfe wheher ie eoional or anil whle she is opleing phray sool.

    However when weiging he vorle d adverse ors in e responden's se eCor anno nd h he warrans a vorable exerise o disreion The a e responedid no provide redie esiony is lge or weighing gins exerise of disreion inhis or Moreover he responden's inbiliy o e responsiili r his ps mises eshi ndesirble s peanen esiden o e Uned Ses. Ths he Cour nds eresponden has iled o eslish h he es relief in e Cour s disreion. Mater of C-VT,22 I&N e. 2. The Cour wll herere deny he responden s ppliion r djsmeno sus der seio 245() of e s aer o disreion.

    C. Volunta Departure

    e Cou nds e responden is eligile r he relief o volny depe underseion 240B of e . He ws pysilly presen in he Uied Ses r over oe yeapreeding serie o his noie o ppear on Jnu 5 200 e is nd as een person o goodmorl rer r e ps ve yers he is not deporle under seions 237(a)(2)()(iii) or237()(4) o he , d he has esalished by lear nd ovining evidene h he has heeans o dep he Unied aes d inends o do so To ep volun depure heresponden mus le $750 ond wi H's ICE Field Oe Direor wihin ve 5) siessdys o he dae of hs orer nd s dep e Uned Ses wihin sixy (60) dys ohe de o is order.

    NOTICE The respondens ilure o pos e required voluny depre ond wihn he iereqired does no erinae he responden's oligion o dep ihin he peod llowed ordoes i exemp he responden o e onsequenes of iling o depr voluarly ding eperiod loe 8 C.FR. § 240.26()(4). If e responen ils o dep he Uned Ses inordane w hese odiions he responden wll e suje o ivil penly o 5000 andshall be ineligile r peiod of en (0) yers o reeive ny her relief under seions20 240B 245 28 nd 249 o e . See INA § 240B(d); 8 C.F.R. § 120.26). Theresponen y choose o deline he Cours gran of voluny depure if he responden isnwilling o aep he oun of he bond or he oher ondiions. 8 C.FR. § 120.26()(3).

    WAIG ol e responden oose o e an ppel of his Co's order wih he Bord

    o Imigraion Appels e responden ms wihin hiy (30) days of ling n ppel wih heBoard sumi suien proo o hving posed he reqired voluary depe bond 8 CF.R.§ 1240.26()(3)(i If e responden does no provide imely proo o he Bor ha he reuirevouny depre od as een posed wih DHS he Bod ill no reinse e perod ovolnay depre in is nl order. Id.

    WG: If he responden es wih his Cour pos-deision oion o reopen orreonsider durg e period lowed r volnry deparue e gr of volunry depe

    8

                 

         p  p         

        ,   

          

          

  • 8/20/2019 Gustavo Soto Enriquez, A087 274 650 (BIA Aug. 5, 2015)

    13/13

    ,

    SOTOENRIQUEZ�77-6

    wll be automatically terminated, and e alteate order of remova w ll take eect immedately.8 C. § 12402((3(i) e penates r ilure to depar vountari under seco

    240(d) of the Act will not appy if te respondent has ed a postdecsion motio to reopen orreconsider drng the perod allowd r voluntary deparure. Id

    IV CONLUSIO

    he Court ds hat te respondent s not egible r adjusment of satus der secon245(a o te Act as a mater of discreton. he Court addtonaly nds tht te respondent seigble r volunar depaure under secton 240 of e Act and concudes ta e metsvounary deparure as a matter of discretion

    Accordingly te llowing orders shall be entered:ORDERS IT IS OED TT te responden' s appicatio r Adutment of

    tatus pursuan o section 245(a) of the Act s DENIED

    Date

    T IS FNLLY ORDERED TT he respondent be ante theprvilege to vontary depar the nted tates wn sxy (0 dasom the date of this order. e resondnt s requred to le a $50 bondwith the pamen of Homeld ecrt win ve (5) business daysom the dae of this order hould the responde l to leave andwen ordered ths order sall auomatcal bcome a order of removl

    om e nted tates to Meco upon the charge contaned n te Aurtermore, e respondent will be suect o cvl pena of $5000and shall be igble, r a period of te ( 0) ears to receve an rrelief under sectons 240A 240 245 248 and 249 of te Act

    Wen

    US. Immigrtion JudgeERTIFITE OF SEVIE _/SEE BY Mail sona erice (P)TO H [ ] A 1 ·,:D-. Aliens oeDTE (Court a

    9

          g           g     p  p         

        ,