CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT...

62
F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris au cours de l’exploitation de l’enregistrement phonique (CVR). Cette transcription comprend les Øchanges entre les membres de l’Øquipage, les messages de radiotØlØphonie et des bruits divers correspondant par exemple des manuvres de sØlecteurs ou des alarmes. L’attention du lecteur est attirØe sur le fait que l’enregistrement et la transcription d’un CVR ne constituent qu’un reflet partiel des ØvØnements et de l’atmosphLre d’un poste de pilotage. En consØquence, l’interprØtation d’un tel document requiert la plus extrŒme prudence. Les voix des membres dØquipage sont entendues par lintermØdiaire du microphone dambiance. Elles sont placØes dans des colonnes sØparØes par souci de clartØ. Une colonne est dØdiØe aux autres voix, bruits et alarmes Øgalement entendus par lintermØdiaire du microphone dambiance. FOREWORD The following is the transcript of the elements which were understood from the work on the CVR recording. This transcript contains conversations between crew members, radiotelephonic messages and various noises corresponding, for example, to the movement of selectors or to alarms. The reader’s attention is drawn to the fact that the recording and transcript of a CVR are only a partial reflection of events and of the atmosphere in a cockpit. Consequently, the utmost care is required in the interpretation of this document. The voices of crew members are heard via the cockpit area microphone (CAM). They are placed in separate columns for reasons of clarity. Another column is reserved for the voices of others, the noises and alarms also heard via the CAM. GLOSSARY UTC Timings in the transcript in the Preliminary Report were expressed in 25ths of a second. So as to improve readability, the data is now presented in tenths of a second. FDR Generated time as recorded by the FDR in seconds and tenths of a second Ctl Air traffic control centre on the frequency in use Co Dispatcher Ground Ground Personnel FSL Fire Service Leader CC Cabin Crew SV Synthetic voice ! Communications with ATC, the ground and the CC by interphone ? Speaker not identified ( ) Word or group of words in parentheses are doubtful () Word or group of words with no bearing on the flight (*) Word or group of words not understood

Transcript of CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT...

Page 1: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript

page 1/1

C V R T R A N S C R I P T

Ce qui suit représente la transcription des éléments qui ont pu être compris au cours de l'exploitation de l'enregistrement phonique (CVR). Cette transcription comprend les échanges entre les membres de l'équipage, les messages de radiotéléphonie et des bruits divers correspondant par exemple à des man�uvres de sélecteurs ou à des alarmes. L'attention du lecteur est attirée sur le fait que l'enregistrement et la transcription d'un CVR ne constituent qu'un reflet partiel des événements et de l'atmosphère d'un poste de pilotage. En conséquence, l'interprétation d'un tel document requiert la plus extrême prudence. Les voix des membres d�équipage sont entendues par l�intermédiaire du microphone d�ambiance. Elles sont placées dans des colonnes séparées par souci de clarté. Une colonne est dédiée aux autres voix, bruits et alarmes également entendus par l�intermédiaire du microphone d�ambiance.

FOREWORD The following is the transcript of the elements which were understood from the work on the CVR recording. This transcript contains conversations between crew members, radiotelephonic messages and various noises corresponding, for example, to the movement of selectors or to alarms. The reader's attention is drawn to the fact that the recording and transcript of a CVR are only a partial reflection of events and of the atmosphere in a cockpit. Consequently, the utmost care is required in the interpretation of this document. The voices of crew members are heard via the cockpit area microphone (CAM). They are placed in separate columns for reasons of clarity. Another column is reserved for the voices of others, the noises and alarms also heard via the CAM.

GLOSSARY

UTC Timings in the transcript in the Preliminary Report were expressed in 25ths of a second. So as to improve readability, the data is now presented in tenths of a second.

FDR Generated time as recorded by the FDR in seconds and tenths of a second

Ctl Air traffic control centre on the frequency in use

Co Dispatcher

Ground Ground Personnel

FSL Fire Service Leader

CC Cabin Crew

SV Synthetic voice

! Communications with ATC, the ground and the CC by interphone

? Speaker not identified

( ) Word or group of words in parentheses are doubtful

(�) Word or group of words with no bearing on the flight

(*) Word or group of words not understood

Page 2: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

14 h

12

min

23

s BE

GIN

NING

OF

RECO

RDIN

G

12 m

in 2

4 s

(*

)

12 m

in 2

5 s

(*

)

12 m

in 2

6 s

(*) t

he IN

S is

ru

nnin

g

12 m

in 2

7 s

N

ot y

et

12 m

in 2

8 s

not y

et w

e ca

n m

aybe

nav

igat

e

12 m

in 3

6 s

one

hund

red

four

teen

12 m

in 3

9 s

one

hund

red

four

teen

12 m

in 4

5 s

one

hund

red

four

teen

12 m

in 4

7 s

(*

) sta

b fo

urte

en

four

teen

12 m

in 5

0 s

radi

o al

timet

er o

ne

thou

sand

eig

ht

conf

irmed

Page 3: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

12 m

in 5

4 s

O

ne th

ousa

nd

eigh

t tw

enty

-nin

e se

vent

y-ei

ght

thre

e hu

ndre

d an

d fif

ty fe

et

12 m

in 5

8 s

wat

ches

12 m

in 5

9 s

It�

s er

r fou

rteen

14 h

13

min

02

s

w

ell a

nd m

ine

isn�

t qu

ite fo

urte

en e

rr is

n�t y

our w

atch

rig

ht

13 m

in 0

5 s

I h

ave

one

thirt

een

err a

nd tw

enty

se

cond

s

13 m

in 0

9 s

I�m

a b

it fa

st

tota

l fue

l gau

ge

13 m

in 1

3 s

So

tota

l fue

l ga

uge

I hav

e ni

nety

-six

four

and

ni

nety

-six

thre

e fo

r ni

nety

-five

on

boar

d

13 m

in 1

9 s

N

inet

y-fiv

e on

bo

ard

13 m

in 2

1 s

gear

con

trol l

ight

s

13 m

in 2

3 s

do

wn

four

gre

ens

Page 4: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

13 m

in 2

5 s

I N S

13 m

in 2

6 s

So

the

depa

rture

po

sitio

n ha

s be

en

ente

red

and

chec

ked

13 m

in 3

0 s

man

thru

st th

rust

re

vers

er

13 m

in 3

1 s

it�

s ch

ecke

d id

le

13 m

in 3

2 s

radi

o

13 m

in 3

4 s

se

t

13 m

in 3

5 s

rada

r tra

nspo

nder

13 m

in 3

6 s

se

t sta

nd b

y pa

rdon

13 m

in 3

8 s

engi

ne d

ebow

13 m

in 3

9 s

Sw

itche

d on

not

de

bow

13 m

in 4

0 s

fire

dete

ctio

n

13 m

in 4

2 s

on

bot

h

13 m

in 4

3 s

fligh

t rec

orde

rs

with

two

hund

red

twen

ty

Page 5: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

13 m

in 4

4 s

tw

o hu

ndre

d tw

enty

inse

rted

off

13 m

in 4

6 s

fire

prot

ectio

n

13 m

in 4

7 s

te

sted

13 m

in 4

8 s

pres

suris

atio

n

13 m

in 4

9 s

si

x th

ousa

nd

13 m

in 5

0 s

engi

ne c

ontro

l sc

hedu

le

13 m

in 5

1 s

13 m

in 5

3 s

13 m

in 5

5 s

cent

ral v

entil

atio

n

batte

ries

fly o

ver a

uto

four

lo

w

test

ed

they

are

on

C

C: L

adie

s an

d ge

ntle

men

, goo

d D

ay m

y na

me

is

(...)

your

chi

ef

fligh

t atte

ndan

t in

the

nam

e of

the

cap�

13 m

in 5

7 s

I N S

13 m

in 5

8 s

I�v

e re

leas

ed th

em

14 h

14

min

00

s

So th

e pr

ogra

mm

e te

n el

even

is c

heck

ed

and

mod

e fo

ur is

on

nav

14 m

in 0

4 s

Z F

W Z

F C

G

Page 6: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

14 m

in 0

5 s

So

I ha

ve

nine

ty-o

ne n

ine

and

fifty

-two

two

14 m

in 0

9 s

airc

raft

wei

ght

tota

l fue

l

14 m

in 1

0 s

on

e hu

ndre

d ei

ghty

-six

ni

nety

-five

14 m

in 1

2 s

tota

lizer

s

14 m

in 1

4 s

At

zer

o

14 m

in 1

5 s

refe

renc

e sp

eeds

14 m

in 2

3 s

so

the

refe

renc

e sp

eeds

V1

one

hund

red

fifty

V R

on

e hu

ndre

d ni

nety

-eig

ht V

2

two

hund

red

twen

ty tw

o on

e hu

ndre

d fo

rty-tw

o

one

hund

red

eigh

ty it

�s

disp

laye

d on

the

left

CC

: (*)

14 m

in 2

6 s

on th

e rig

ht

14 m

in 2

7 s

an

d on

bac

kup

Page 7: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

14 m

in 2

8 s

attit

ude

14 m

in 2

9 s

it�

s th

irtee

n de

gree

s

14 m

in 3

0 s

P se

ven

14 m

in 3

1 s

P

seve

n is

th

irty-

nine

poi

nt

one

14 m

in 3

2 s

I h

aven

�t do

ne it

14 m

in 3

3 s

th

irty-

nine

one

14 m

in 3

5 s

th

irty-

nine

one

14 m

in 3

6 s

th

irty-

nine

one

14 m

in 3

8 s

fuel

flow

an

d th

irty-

nine

five

14 m

in 4

1 s

fu

el fl

ow is

twen

ty

poin

t thr

ee

nine

teen

nin

e

14 m

in 4

3 s

nois

e re

duct

ion

14 m

in 4

5 s

th

e re

duct

ion

is o

n se

vent

y-th

ree

seco

nds

14 m

in 4

7 s

se

vent

y-th

ree

Page 8: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

14 m

in 4

8 s

G

illes

is th

at o

kay

for y

ou?

14 m

in 4

9 s

an

d m

inus

five

yes

14 m

in 5

3 s

th

en th

e th

rust

le

ver i

s at

four

teen

an

d yo

u w

ill ha

ve

N2

of

nine

ty-s

even

and

a

bit

14 m

in 5

8 s

ni

nety

-sev

en

14 m

in 5

9 s

park

ing

brak

e

14 h

15

min

00

s

It�s

on p

ark

fifte

en

hund

red

in fr

ont

15 m

in 0

3 s

th

ree

thou

sand

th

ree

behi

nd

cent

ral a

larm

sy

stem

15 m

in 0

5 s

re

call

15 m

in 0

6 s

canc

el

15 m

in 0

7 s

in

hibi

t

15 m

in 0

9 s

the

win

dow

15 m

in 1

1 s

It�

s cl

osed

lock

ed

on th

e le

ft

15 m

in 1

3 s

on th

e rig

ht

Page 9: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

15 m

in 1

4 s

door

ligh

t

15 m

in 1

6 s

So

I st

ill ha

ve a

ca

rgo

I hav

e th

e fo

rwar

d le

ft do

or

and

the

aft l

eft

door

15 m

in 2

6 s

seco

ndar

y ai

r do

ors

15 m

in 2

8 s

au

to

15 m

in 2

9 s

feed

er p

ump

for

thre

e

15 m

in 3

2 s

on

15 m

in 3

3 s

hydr

aulic

al

tern

ator

for t

hree

15 m

in 3

8 s

of

f and

off

15 m

in 4

0 s

anti

collis

ion

and

seat

bel

ts

15 m

in 4

3 s

th

e se

at b

elts

on

are

on o

n

15 m

in 4

4 s

that

�s it

(*)

15 m

in 4

5 s

Cab

in g

ong

15 m

in 5

0 s

C

C: y

es

Page 10: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

15 m

in 5

1 s

! y

es it

�s a

ft no

15 m

in 5

3 s

C

C: n

o fo

rwar

d

15 m

in 5

4 s

C

C: H

ervé

the

rear

15 m

in 5

5 s

! y

es H

ervé

th

ere�

s st

ill a

door

op

en a

ft

15 m

in 5

7 s

C

C: y

eh y

eh h

e�s

clos

ing

it rig

ht n

ow

15 m

in 5

9 s

! o

kay

14 h

16

min

03

s

!

gro

und

16 m

in 0

7 s

! h

ello

hel

lo

16 m

in 0

8 s

G

roun

d: y

es I�

m

liste

ning

16 m

in 1

0 s

! y

es th

at w

here

ar

e w

e do

wn

ther

e

Page 11: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

16 m

in 1

1 s

G

roun

d: w

ell t

he

mec

hani

cs h

ave

finis

hed

now

th

ey�re

just

get

ting

off t

he la

st �

the

last

tool

box

now

bu

t the

load

ing

isn�

t qui

te fi

nish

ed

yet

16 m

in 2

0 s

! th

e ho

ld th

ere

the

bagg

age?

16 m

in 2

2 s

G

roun

d:

affir

mat

ive

ther

e�s

still

a (*

) to

fill..

. to

com

plet

ely

empt

y th

e�

16 m

in 2

6 s

! w

ell i

t�s

fortu

nate

that

w

e�re

thre

e qu

arte

rs o

f an

hour

late

ot

herw

ise

wha

t w

ould

it h

ave

been

like

16 m

in 3

2 s

! th

at�s

wha

t ten

m

inut

es m

ore

at

leas

t

16 m

in 3

5 s

G

roun

d: e

rr ye

s

Page 12: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

16 m

in 3

9 s

ye

s I�m

goi

ng to

se

e it�

s be

caus

e�

ther

e w

as a

m

echa

nica

l pr

oble

m m

aybe

16 m

in 4

2 s

oh n

o

16 m

in 4

3 s

an

d if

if w

e ha

dn�t

been

late

(*) w

as

late

for t

he fi

ll-up

th

e ta

nker

s ar

rived

ha

lf an

hou

r be

fore

the

theo

retic

al

depa

rture

tim

e so

yo

u kn

ow (*

) so

met

imes

16 m

in 5

4 s

it�

s th

e en

gine

ch

ange

whi

ch

16 m

in 5

7 s

so

bef

ore

star

ing

up w

e�ll

do a

blu

e ch

eck

14 h

17

min

01

s

be

fore

sta

rting

up

17 m

in 0

2 s

ye

s I p

refe

r bef

ore

star

ting

up

17 m

in 0

4 s

ther

e ar

e so

me

serv

os w

hich

(*)

the

fligh

t con

trols

Page 13: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

17 m

in 0

7 s

no

it�s

bec

ause

w

e�re

ther

e�s

ther

e w

as a

leak

on

the

blue

and

I ha

d a

bloc

kage

with

a

low

leve

l blu

e w

e fil

led

it up

I�m

go

ing

to p

ress

the

blue

in�

the

Gro

und

blu

e pu

mps

are

on

let�s

firs

t clo

se th

e ai

r int

akes

that

are

bl

ocke

d

17 m

in 2

2 s

as s

oon

as th

ey�v

e fin

ishe

d w

ith th

eir

mes

s

17 m

in 2

3 s

ye

h

17 m

in 2

6 s

an

d th

en a

fter t

hat

we�

re g

oing

to

star

t up

17 m

in 2

7 s

G

roun

d: o

kay

in

any

case

for t

he

cont

rols

if y

ou li

ke

we

can

do it

17 m

in 3

4 s

!

oka

y I�m

... I�

m

appl

ying

hyd

raul

ic

pres

sure

Page 14: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

17 m

in 3

6 s

G

roun

d: o

kay

it�s

clea

r you

can

go

17 m

in 4

0 s

yo

u yo

u ha

ve th

e co

ntro

ls

17 m

in 4

2 s

I'v

e go

t the

m

17 m

in 4

4 s

ten

min

utes

17 m

in 4

5 s

CC

: how

long

17 m

in 4

6 s

ten

min

utes

17 m

in 4

7 s

CC

: ten

min

utes

...

wai

t her

e

17 m

in 4

8 s

yeh

yeh

yeh

17 m

in 4

9 s

it�s

not i

t�s n

ot th

e re

pair

to th

e ai

rcra

ft it�

s th

e ba

ggag

e w

hich

ar

e no

t loa

ded

17 m

in 5

3 s

CC

: ah

okay

17 m

in 5

4 s

bu

t I d

on�t

dare

tell

them

that

17 m

in 5

6 s

we

thin

k (*

)

Page 15: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

17 m

in 5

7 s

(*

) to

hel

p hi

m to

load

to

spe

ed th

ings

up

! o

kay

okay

I�m

cl

osin

g ai

r int

akes

th

ree

and

four

14 h

18

min

03

s

Gro

und:

oka

y it�

s do

ne

18 m

in 0

4 s

ho

w a

re th

ings

in

the

back

?

18 m

in 0

5 s

CC

: eve

ryth

ing�

s ok

ay

18 m

in 0

6 s

th

at�s

true

18 m

in 0

7 s

18 m

in 0

8 s

w

ell I

�ll sa

y so

met

hing

just

be

fore

sta

rt-up

so

as to

(*)

CC

: yes

yes

18 m

in 1

2 s

!

wel

l the

air

inta

kes

are

okay

w

e ca

n m

ove

the

fligh

t con

trols

CC

: (*)

18 m

in 1

6 s

(*

)

Gro

und:

oka

y ro

ger

it�s

clea

r yo

u ca

n go

ahe

ad

18 m

in 1

8 s

eh

18 m

in 1

9 s

CC

: (*)

Page 16: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

18 m

in 2

0 s

w

hat s

hall

I do

(*)

18 m

in 2

1 s

CC

: (*)

18 m

in 2

2 s

go

ahe

ad

18 m

in 2

3 s

sh

all I

do

a bi

t of

(*) a

nd I

(*)

18 m

in 2

6 s

w

e�re

goi

ng to

be

in m

echa

nica

l but

it�

s no

t ser

ious

but

(*

)

Gon

g

18 m

in 2

8 s

You

don�

t nee

d m

e eh

18 m

in 3

0 s

no

no

18 m

in 3

2 s

18 m

in 3

4 s

We�

ll ha

ve to

ask

th

e di

spat

cher

if

he h

as a

wei

ght

estim

ate�

at t

he

sam

e tim

e

G

ong

18 m

in 3

5 s

18 m

in 3

8 s

I �

m in

mec

hani

cal

may

be th

at�s

a

prob

lem

bec

ause

it

does

n�t r

espo

nd

like

(*)

no

no

it�s

not a

pr

oble

m

18 m

in 4

1 s

you�

re b

uggi

ng

me

(*)

Page 17: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

18 m

in 4

2 s

18 m

in 4

4 s

ye

s yo

u�re

bu

ggin

g m

e if

you�

re n

ot

read

y (*

)

Gon

g

Jo

king

tone

18 m

in 4

9 s

18 m

in 5

0 s

w

ell i

t�s m

akin

g so

me

jum

ps in

m

echa

nica

l eh

but

may

be th

at�s

no

rmal

ye

s ye

s no

no

but..

.

18 m

in 5

3 s

so

nex

t the

rudd

er

14 h

19

min

00

s

wel

l tha

t�s w

orki

ng

eh

19 m

in 0

1 s

ok

ay

19 m

in 0

5 s

Gon

g

19 m

in 0

6 s

!

oka

y so

the

leve

l has

falle

n sl

ight

ly th

at�s

no

rmal

and

it�s

st

abilis

ing

the

air

inta

kes

are

clos

ed

the

fligh

t con

trols

ar

e w

orki

ng

corre

ctly

I�m

cu

tting

hyd

raul

ic

pres

sure

19 m

in 1

5 s

G

roun

d: o

kay

than

ks

Page 18: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

19 m

in 2

0 s

It�

s go

ing

to fa

ll th

e th

e co

ntro

ls

are

goin

g to

go

forw

ard

19 m

in 2

3 s

ok

ay

19 m

in 2

5 s

ye

s in

mec

hani

cal

it�s

goin

g to

be

a bi

t har

d to

y fe

el it

fly

ing

on

mec

hani

cal i

t�s n

ot

(...)

Gon

g

La

ught

er

19 m

in 2

7 s

ye

s (*

)

19 m

in 3

1 s

w

ell I

rem

embe

r

La

ught

er

19 m

in 4

0 s

ok

ay it

�s d

ropp

ed

I�ll d

eal w

ith it

14 h

20

min

04

s

ther

e yo

u ar

e w

e�re

bac

k on

ye

llow

20 m

in 0

5 s

Co:

load

she

et s

ir

20 m

in 0

6 s

Co:

goo

d...

in

fact

... th

ere

wer

e so

me

bags

whi

ch

wer

e ad

ded

I hav

e tw

o to

ns tw

o of

ba

ggag

e

Page 19: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

20 m

in 1

4 s

Co:

for t

he B

RS

secu

rity

softw

are

20 m

in 1

8 s

ye

s

20 m

in 1

9 s

Co:

ther

e�s

a pr

oble

m w

e ha

ven�

t def

ined

w

hat I

cal

led

the

peop

le w

ho w

ere

in th

e BR

S se

ctio

n er

r the

bag

gage

w

as c

orre

ctly

la

belle

d as

four

fiv

e ni

ne z

ero

but

it di

dn�t

go th

roug

h

20 m

in 2

9 s

hu

m

Page 20: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

20 m

in 3

0 s

Co:

so

we

tried

to

do a

few

thin

gs to

ca

ll to

ring

a fe

w

bells

but

in th

e en

d w

e ha

ve tw

o to

ns tw

o of

bag

s th

ey a

re la

belle

d bu

t I c

an�t

read

all

the

bagg

age

to b

e lo

aded

so

I�ll h

ave

to s

ee w

ith th

e pe

ople

con

cern

ed

to d

o th

at I�

ll w

arn

the

DO

for m

e it�

s cl

ear f

or s

ecur

ity I

have

no

no-s

how

s an

d I h

ave

no

extra

bag

s

20 m

in 5

6 s

Co:

and

all

the

bags

hav

e be

en

thro

ugh

the

x-ra

y ac

cord

ing

to th

e re

quire

d ra

ndom

pr

oced

ure

14 h

21

min

03

s

okay

C

o: I

reck

on th

at

it�s

the

mon

itor

that

�s n

ot w

orki

ng

Page 21: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

21 m

in 0

8 s

ok

ay

Co:

I�ve

adj

uste

d th

e fu

el to

m

axim

um fo

r tax

i be

caus

e it�

s in

crea

sed

by tw

o hu

ndre

d ki

los

of

bagg

age

21 m

in 1

8 s

In

any

cas

e it�

s w

hat y

ou to

ld u

s eh

nin

ety-

one

nine

w

e w

ere

basi

ng

ours

elve

s on

that

21 m

in 2

1 s

Co:

oka

y

21 m

in 2

2 s

So

we�

re o

kay

eh

21 m

in 2

4 s

So

bec

ause

ther

e yo

u�ve

put

taxi

ing

a bi

t hig

h eh

21 m

in 2

8 s

Co:

I�ve

put

two

two

tons

21 m

in 2

9 s

W

e�ll

be ta

king

off

with

a b

it m

ore

than

that

in fa

ct e

h

21 m

in 3

1 s

Co:

yes

21 m

in 3

2 s

Bu

t tha

t�s o

kay

it�s

not i

mpo

rtant

Page 22: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

21 m

in 3

4 s

Co:

doe

s th

at s

uit

you?

21 m

in 3

5 s

So

zer

o fu

el is

fif

ty-tw

o th

ree

Gille

s eh

in fa

ct

21 m

in 3

7 s

ye

s I�v

e co

rrect

ed

it

21 m

in 3

8 s

Yo

u�ve

cor

rect

ed it

eh

(*)

21 m

in 4

1 s

Co:

oth

erw

ise

for

load

ing

we�

ll cl

ose

the

hold

and

we�

re

read

y

21 m

in 4

5 s

So

that

�s o

kay

21 m

in 4

7 s

So

her

e th

ere�

s si

x an

d si

x tw

elve

tw

elve

and

five

ten

seve

n

21 m

in 5

0 s

rig

ht

21 m

in 5

2 s

Fo

ur h

undr

ed w

ell

that

�s p

erfe

ct

Page 23: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

21 m

in 5

3 s

Fr

om th

e m

echa

nica

l vi

ewpo

int t

he

mec

hani

cal

view

poin

t it�s

ove

r si

nce

21 m

in 5

7 s

(*

)

Co:

yes

but

err

the

bagg

age

cam

e ca

me

cam

e an

d w

ell i

t res

et o

n th

e D

but

� p

robl

em

14 h

22

min

05

s

C

o: th

at�s

it

14 h

22

min

05

s

C

o: th

at�s

it

22 m

in 0

6 s

th

anks

22 m

in 0

7 s

W

ell s

ir til

l nex

t tim

e

22 m

in 0

8 s

Co:

goo

dbye

ge

ntle

men

22 m

in 0

9 s

go

odby

e go

odby

e

22 m

in 1

1 s

Co:

see

you

soo

n

22 m

in 1

2 s

Se

e yo

u so

on

See

you

soon

Page 24: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

22 m

in 1

4 s

Fi

fty-tw

o th

ree

wel

l tha

t�s w

hat h

e sa

id it

�s fo

rty k

ilos

over

but

any

way

22 m

in 1

7 s

22 m

in 1

9 s

(*

)

An

d w

e ha

ve

I�ve�

I�ve

take

n th

e ta

keof

f wei

ght

as o

ne h

undr

ed

and

eigh

ty-fi

ve

tons

22 m

in 2

2 s

22 m

in 2

4 s

W

ell w

e�ll

take

one

hu

ndre

d ei

ghty

-five

one

hu

ndre

d th

at�s

to

say

we�

ll be

at t

he

stru

ctur

al �

lim

its

W

ith fi

fty-tw

o tw

o

22 m

in 2

9 s

St

ruct

ural

err

fifty

-four

for o

ne

hund

red

CG

(*)

see

22 m

in 3

8 s

An

d w

e�re

real

ly a

t th

e m

inim

um

22 m

in 4

2 s

fu

el

22 m

in 4

3 s

fu

el y

es

22 m

in 4

4 s

go

od

22 m

in 4

5 s

go

Page 25: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

22 m

in 5

0 s

D

id y

ou h

ave

time

to d

o th

e ce

rtific

ates

, C

hris

tian

22 m

in 5

3 s

pa

rtial

ly

22 m

in 5

4 s

Tw

o th

irds

22 m

in 5

5 s

I �

eac

h tim

e th

at

I hav

e so

me

spar

e tim

e I d

o so

me

I ha

ve s

ome

now

I�ll

go o

n

22 m

in 5

9 s

I�m

not

far f

rom

th

e en

d I t

hink

yes,

I'll

leav

e it

to

you

14 h

23

min

00

s

I�ll l

eave

it to

you

23 m

in 0

1 s

Bu

t any

way

I�ll

only

pas

s ov

er

whe

n w

e�ve

pa

ssed

the

soun

d ba

rrier

eh

beca

use

23 m

in 0

7 s

(�

)

(*)

23 m

in 1

0 s à

23 m

in 3

2 s

(�

)

Page 26: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

23 m

in 3

4 s

pard

on

23 m

in 3

5 s

I�m

bot

herin

g yo

u

23 m

in 3

6 s

no n

o (*

)

23 m

in 4

1 s

so

23 m

in 4

2 s

I j

ust h

ave

the

carg

o op

en

23 m

in 4

6 s

They

�re c

losi

ng it

14 h

24

min

02

s

To te

ll yo

u th

e tru

th w

e ha

ve

corre

cted

the

CG

to

fifty

-two

thre

e in

stea

d of

fifty

-two

two

24 m

in 0

6 s

fine

24 m

in 0

7 s

H

e m

ade

a m

ista

ke in

the

CG

24 m

in 1

0 s

Unl

ess

it is

n�t h

im

Jo

key

tone

24 m

in 1

2 s

(*

)

24 m

in 3

1 s

G

roun

d: G

roun

d st

atio

n ar

e yo

u re

ceiv

ing

24 m

in 3

5 s

!

yes

Page 27: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

24 m

in 3

7 s

G

roun

d: W

ell

we�

ve ju

st lo

cked

th

e re

ar h

old

load

ing

door

the

hand

le is

in it

s re

cess

24 m

in 4

4 s

!

Wel

l gre

at s

o er

r if I

und

erst

and

the

airc

raft

is c

lear

th

ere

24 m

in 4

9 s

G

roun

d: th

e ai

rcra

ft cl

eare

d w

e�re

read

y fo

r st

art-u

p

24 m

in 5

2 s

Go

ahea

d pu

ll

24 m

in 5

5 s

!

Fin

e so

we�

ll st

art i

n no

rmal

se

quen

ce a

nd

then

we

will

be

pulle

d ba

ck e

rr fo

rwar

ds s

o w

e�ll

star

t up

the

thre

e fir

st s

o ot

herw

ise

the

choc

ks �

no

se g

ear a

re in

po

sitio

n eh

14 h

25

min

04

s

Gro

und:

the

nose

ge

ar c

hock

s ar

e no

t in

posi

tion

Page 28: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

25 m

in 0

8 s

!

Oka

y an

d yo

u co

nfirm

that

all

door

s ar

e ch

ecke

d eh

25 m

in 1

2 s

G

roun

d: th

e do

ors

are

chec

ked

yes

25 m

in 1

3 s

Is th

ere

a tra

ctor

?

25 m

in 1

4 s

!

Oka

y so

err.

.. ye

s go

od q

uest

ion

is th

ere

an

extin

guis

her i

n th

e co

rner

ther

e?

25 m

in 2

0 s

A tra

ctor

25 m

in 2

1 s

!

A tr

acto

r I

mea

n is

it th

ere?

25 m

in 2

3 s

25 m

in 2

7 s

I hav

en�t

seen

it

no

Gro

und:

the

tract

or is

in

posi

tion

with

the

bar l

ocke

d ye

s th

e lo

ckpi

n is

on

the

nose

gea

r

25 m

in 2

9 s

!

Wel

l err

so w

e I�m

rem

indi

ng y

ou

abou

t sta

rt-up

on

thre

e

Page 29: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

25 m

in 3

4 s

Th

e pr

e-st

artu

p ch

eck-

list h

as

been

don

e ha

s be

en d

one

G

roun

d: o

kay

roge

r

25 m

in 3

6 s

yes

yes

we�

re

read

y

25 m

in 3

7 s

!

Is a

ir pr

essu

re

esta

blis

hed?

25 m

in 3

9 s

G

roun

d: n

o no

t yet

bu

t it w

on�t

be

long

25 m

in 4

1 s

!

So

call

me

back

w

hen

air p

ress

ure

is e

stab

lishe

d

25 m

in 4

5 s

!

Lad

ies

and

gent

lem

en a

ll is

in

orde

r and

we

are

star

ting

up o

ur

engi

nes

25 m

in 5

1 s

G

roun

d: a

ir pr

essu

re

esta

blis

hed

25 m

in 5

4 s

!

Per

fect

sta

rt up

th

ree

25 m

in 5

7 s

Th

e th

ree

Page 30: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

25 m

in 5

8 s

(...)

Hel

d

So

ng

14 h

26

min

00

s

Ope

n

26 m

in 0

1 s

st

art p

ump

26 m

in 0

6 s

I�m

pas

sing

ove

r th

e le

ver J

ean

26 m

in 0

7 s

top

ten

for o

ne

hund

red

26 m

in 0

8 s

to

p

26 m

in 1

1 s

igni

tion

26 m

in 1

2 s

ig

nitio

n

26 m

in 1

4 s

N

1

26 m

in 2

5 s

Tw

enty

-five

pe

rcen

t

26 m

in 2

7 s

re

turn

ed

26 m

in 2

8 s

cl

osed

26 m

in 2

9 s

C

lose

d ok

ay

26 m

in 3

0 s

Shal

l I ta

ke th

e le

ver?

Page 31: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

26 m

in 3

2 s

If

you

like

okay

th

anks

fine

26 m

in 3

5 s

st

abilis

ed d

ebow

26 m

in 3

7 s

N

orm

al o

n th

ree

26 m

in 3

8 s

no

rmal

26 m

in 3

9 s

R

elea

sed

at

sixt

y-se

ven

26 m

in 5

3 s

Tw

o hu

ndre

d an

d ni

nety

it�s

dr

oppi

ng

26 m

in 5

8 s

O

kay

rota

ting

stal

l

(*)

14 h

27

min

01

s

Rea

dy h

ydra

ulic

s

27 m

in 0

2 s

Hel

d R

eady

hyd

raul

ics?

27 m

in 0

3 s

hy

drau

lics

27 m

in 0

5 s

! C

onco

rde

four

fiv

e ni

ne z

ero

good

eve

ning

on

Echo

twen

ty-s

ix

we

will

be re

ady

to

pull

in tw

o m

inut

es

27 m

in 1

4 s

!

Rea

dy fo

r tw

o?

Page 32: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

27 m

in 1

5 s

27 m

in 2

1 s

27 m

in 2

3 s

Tw

o

C

tl: A

ir Fr

ance

Fo

ur fi

ve n

ine

zero

go

od d

ay e

rr yo

u�re

pus

hing

ba

ck fa

cing

the

wes

t wel

l are

you

re

ady

to p

ush

back

?

Gro

und:

no

no n

ot fo

r the

m

omen

t

Gro

und:

oka

y re

ady

for t

wo

27 m

in 2

5 s

27 m

in 2

6 s

27 m

in 2

7 s

27 m

in 2

8 s

27 m

in 2

9 s

!

oka

y s

tart

up

two

N2

! y

eh in

two

min

utes

or e

rr no

no

t pus

hed

back

bu

t pul

led

faci

ng

wes

t

Hel

d op

en

star

t pum

p

27 m

in 3

1 s

C

tl: T

o be

pul

led

back

faci

ng w

est

so y

ou g

et p

ulle

d ba

ck fa

cing

wes

t an

d ca

ll ba

ck to

ta

xi

27 m

in 3

5 s

te

n pe

rcen

t

27 m

in 3

6 s

fu

el

! ro

ger

27 m

in 3

7 s

to

p

27 m

in 4

1 s

N

1

27 m

in 4

2 s

An

d ig

nitio

n

Page 33: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

27 m

in 4

8 s

cabi

n go

ng

27 m

in 5

3 s

Tw

enty

-five

pe

rcen

t

27 m

in 5

5 s

re

turn

ed

27 m

in 5

6 s

cl

osed

27 m

in 5

7 s

cl

osed

14 h

28

min

02

s

stab

ilised

deb

ow

norm

al o

n tw

o

28 m

in 0

5 s

no

rmal

28 m

in 2

1 s

Noi

se

In

crea

se in

eng

ine

RPM

28 m

in 2

2 s

Tw

o si

xty-

eigh

t

28 m

in 2

5 s

fa

lling

and

rota

ting

stal

l

28 m

in 2

8 s

!

Fin

e tw

o is

ru

nnin

g so

we

can

disc

onne

ct th

e un

its a

nd c

all m

e ba

ck w

hen

the

airc

raft

is a

way

W

e ca

n di

scon

nect

the

units

28 m

in 3

5 s

G

roun

d: o

kay

roge

r

Page 34: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

28 m

in 4

0 s

We

are

clea

red

to

pull

14 h

29

min

11

s

N

oise

Sim

ilar t

o se

at m

ovem

ent

29 m

in 1

5 s

Noi

se

Si

mila

r to

seat

mov

emen

t

29 m

in 4

5 s

G

roun

d: G

roun

d st

atio

n

29 m

in 4

7 s

They

�re c

allin

g us

29 m

in 4

9 s

!

yes

?

29 m

in 5

0 s

G

roun

d: S

o fo

r the

de

partu

re

dire

ctio

n w

e ha

ven�

t got

muc

h ch

oice

it�s

goi

ng to

be

wes

twar

ds

29 m

in 5

3 s

(..

.)

La

ught

er

29 m

in 5

4 s

no y

ou s

ay e

ast

In

a jo

key

man

ner

29 m

in 5

6 s

!

yes

that

yes

in

fact

I th

ink

that

I do

n�t s

ee a

ny

othe

r sol

utio

n er

r �

I do

n�t s

ee a

ny

othe

r sol

utio

n ye

s

Page 35: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

14 h

30

min

02

s

Gro

und:

oka

y ai

rcra

ft cl

eare

d re

ady

to ta

xi

30 m

in 0

5 s

!

So

we

have

cl

eara

nce

the

brak

e is

rele

ased

w

e ca

n go

bac

k �

30 m

in 1

1 s

!

And

we

can

put

a bl

ock

on �

so

rry w

e ca

n go

on

yes

a b

lock

on

thirt

y on

e

Go

on g

o on

30 m

in 1

3 s

G

roun

d: th

irty

one

okay

roge

r

30 m

in 3

0 s

(the

barri

er d

idn�

t se

e)

30 m

in 5

4 s

Cab

in g

ong

14 h

31

min

27

s

Gro

und:

you

can

st

art

the

othe

r en

gine

s

31 m

in 3

1 s

!

oka

y so

read

y fo

r fou

r?

31 m

in 3

3 s

G

roun

d: re

ady

all

four

31 m

in 3

5 s

!

sta

rt-up

four

Page 36: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

31 m

in 3

6 s

he

ld

31 m

in 3

9 s

op

en

31 m

in 4

0 s

N

2

31 m

in 4

1 s

st

art p

ump

31 m

in 4

8 s

te

n pe

rcen

t

31 m

in 4

9 s

fu

el

31 m

in 5

0 s

to

p

31 m

in 5

1 s

N

1

31 m

in 5

4 s

ig

nitio

n

14 h

32

min

04

s

Twen

ty-fi

ve

perc

ent

32 m

in 0

5 s

re

turn

ed

32 m

in 0

6 s

cl

osed

32 m

in 0

7 s

G

roun

d: p

ush

com

plet

e c

an y

ou

put o

n th

e pa

rkin

g br

ake

plea

se

32 m

in 0

8 s

!

Yes

par

king

br

ake

on c

an w

e di

scon

nect

the

yoke

read

y fo

r on

e?

Page 37: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

32 m

in 1

1 s

G

roun

d: re

ady

for

one

32 m

in 1

7 s

!

sta

rt-up

one

32 m

in 1

8 s

so

sta

bilis

ed

debo

w th

anks

32 m

in 1

9 s

he

ld

32 m

in 2

3 s

op

en

32 m

in 2

5 s

st

art p

ump

32 m

in 2

6 s

N

2

32 m

in 3

7 s

te

n pe

rcen

t

32 m

in 3

8 s

fu

el

32 m

in 4

0 s

to

p N

1

32 m

in 4

2 s

ig

nitio

n

32 m

in 5

5 s

tw

enty

-five

pe

rcen

t

32 m

in 5

7 s

re

turn

ed

32 m

in 5

8 s

cl

osed

32 m

in 5

9 s

Va

lves

clo

sed

14 h

33

min

02

s

stab

ilised

deb

ow

Page 38: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

33 m

in 0

4 s

no

rmal

on

four

33 m

in 0

5 s

no

rmal

four

33 m

in 1

7 s

So

thre

e hu

ndre

d an

d te

n it�

s dr

oppi

ng

33 m

in 2

2 s

an

d ro

tatin

g st

all

norm

al o

n on

e

33 m

in 2

5 s

no

rmal

on

one

33 m

in 3

7 s

33 m

in 4

0 s

Th

ree

hund

red

and

four

! C

onco

rde

four

fiv

e ni

ne z

ero

we

will

be re

ady

to

taxi

in o

ne m

inut

e

33 m

in 4

2 s

33 m

in 4

4 s

It�

s fa

lling

Rot

atin

g st

all

C

tl: ro

ger f

our f

ive

nine

zer

o fo

r tax

i co

ntac

t Gro

und

one

twen

ty o

ne

nine

ty s

even

go

odby

e

33 m

in 4

7 s

! g

oodb

ye

Page 39: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

33 m

in 4

8 s

!

fine

sta

rt-up

co

mpl

ete

so e

rr yo

u ca

n st

op

liste

ning

in a

nd

mak

e a

sign

on

the

left

show

ing

the

hydr

aulic

pin

go

odby

e th

anks

fo

r eve

ryth

ing

have

a g

ood

day

33 m

in 5

5 s

G

roun

d: I�

ll m

ake

a si

gn to

the

right

33 m

in 5

6 s

Two

gong

s

33 m

in 5

7 s

!

mak

e a

sign

to

the

right

oka

y go

odby

e

33 m

in 5

9 s

Gon

g

14 h

34

min

00

s

Gro

und:

goo

dbye

34 m

in 0

1 s

T

C U

test

G

ong

34 m

in 0

3 s

ye

s

Gon

g

34 m

in 0

5 s

Gon

g

34 m

in 0

8 s

th

ey�v

e ch

ange

d G

ong

34 m

in 1

0 s

yes

Page 40: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

34 m

in 1

7 s

Gon

g

34 m

in 2

3 s

so

34 m

in 2

4 s

(*

) dep

artu

re o

n

34 m

in 3

3 s

! C

onco

rde

four

fiv

e ni

ne z

ero

to

taxi

nex

t to

five

sout

h w

e ar

e

34 m

in 3

8 s

34 m

in 3

9 s

stab

feel

and

tri

m (*

)

Ctl:

Air

Fran

ce

four

five

nin

e ze

ro

good

day

taxi

to

hold

ing

poin

t tw

enty

-six

righ

t via

R

omeo

34 m

in 4

4 s

! v

ia R

omeo

tw

enty

-six

righ

t

34 m

in 4

5 s

po

st s

tart-

up

chec

k-lis

t

34 m

in 4

6 s

stab

feel

and

trim

is

eng

aged

34 m

in 4

8 s

en

gage

d

34 m

in 4

9 s

fligh

t con

trols

I�ve

ch

ecke

d

34 m

in 5

0 s

cl

ear o

n th

e rig

ht

clea

r on

the

right

it�

s cl

ear

Page 41: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

34 m

in 5

1 s

he�s

indi

catin

g yo

u ca

n ta

xi to

Rom

eo

it�s

the�

it�s

the

34 m

in 5

5 s

fir

st le

ft

34 m

in 5

6 s

first

left

14 h

35

min

03

s

T

C U

35 m

in 0

4 s

te

sted

35 m

in 0

5 s

Te

sted

35 m

in 0

6 s

engi

ne d

e-ic

ing

35 m

in 0

7 s

of

f

35 m

in 0

8 s

door

ligh

ts

35 m

in 0

9 s

Li

ghts

off

35 m

in 1

0 s

cent

ral s

yste

m

reca

lled

35 m

in 1

2 s

ram

p an

d sp

ill

35 m

in 1

3 s

Th

ey a

re o

n au

to

and

at z

ero

35 m

in 1

5 s

seco

ndar

y no

zzle

35 m

in 1

7 s

(*

)

G

ap in

the

reco

rdin

g du

e to

ta

pe s

plic

e

Page 42: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

35 m

in 1

8 s

Engi

ne id

le

35 m

in 2

0 s

lo

w

35 m

in 2

1 s

Feed

er p

umps

35 m

in 2

2 s

Al

l on

on

35 m

in 3

2 s

C

tl: A

ir Fr

ance

fo

ur fi

ve n

ine

zero

D

o yo

u w

ant

Whi

sky

ten

or e

rr R

omeo

taxi

way

?

35 m

in 3

7 s

! e

rr I n

eed

all

the

runw

ay e

h

35 m

in 3

8 s

C

tl: o

kay

So y

ou

taxi

for R

omeo

Air

Fran

ce fo

ur fi

ve

nine

zer

o

35 m

in 4

1 s

! fi

ne ro

ger f

our

five

nine

zer

o vi

a R

omeo

35 m

in 4

6 s

feed

er p

umps

35 m

in 4

8 s

Al

l on

on

35 m

in 4

9 s

hydr

aulic

s el

ectri

cs

35 m

in 5

0 s

ch

ecke

d

Page 43: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

35 m

in 5

3 s

Back

up a

ltern

ator

35 m

in 5

4 s

ch

ecke

d

35 m

in 5

5 s

engi

ne o

verh

eat

35 m

in 5

7 s

te

sted

35 m

in 5

8 s

Fron

t whe

el

stee

ring

appa

rent

ly th

ere

isn�

t any

14 h

36

min

00

s

wel

l...

36 m

in 0

1 s

It�

s w

orki

ng

36 m

in 0

3 s

I�m

man

agin

g to

co

ntro

l the

airc

raft

36 m

in 0

5 s

taxi

turn

are

on

"on"

36 m

in 0

7 s

Airc

raft

clea

r si

gnal

rece

ived

36 m

in 1

0 s

ye

s

36 m

in 1

1 s

Nos

e dr

oop

at fi

ve

36 m

in 2

7 s

I�l

l get

up

a bi

t of

spee

d be

fore

try

ing

the

brak

es

Page 44: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

36 m

in 2

9 s

Be c

aref

ul it

�s

goin

g fa

st

36 m

in 3

1 s

I m

ean

that

...

36 m

in 3

2 s

yes

(*)

36 m

in 3

3 s

I�l

l let

it g

o eh

36 m

in 3

4 s

yes

yes

let i

t go

on

the

cont

rary

36 m

in 3

6 s

Th

at�s

wha

t I

mea

nt

36 m

in 4

3 s

So w

e ha

ve to

co

ntin

ue o

n th

e ta

xiw

ay to

get

to

the

end

eh

36 m

in 4

7 s

Ye

s fin

e ok

ay

36 m

in 4

9 s

(sho

uldn

�t) ta

ke

Tang

o Ta

ngo

we

don�

t go

to th

e en

d

36 m

in 5

3 s

Em

erge

ncy

brak

e te

st

36 m

in 5

7 s

not g

ood

14 h

37

min

03

s

Nor

mal

bra

king

Page 45: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

37 m

in 0

7 s

N

o pr

essu

re, n

o ju

mpi

ng, n

o re

leas

e

37 m

in 1

0 s

Ta

xiin

g ch

eck-

list

37 m

in 1

1 s

ye

s

37 m

in 1

8 s

(*)

So th

e br

ake

fan

light

is o

n on

37 m

in 1

9 s

eh

?

37 m

in 2

0 s

au

to ig

nitio

n...

37 m

in 2

1 s

(*) a

s lo

ng a

s po

ssib

le

37 m

in 2

2 s

on

37 m

in 2

3 s

R

ehea

t A D

S

drai

n st

atic

and

ic

e

37 m

in 2

5 s

Fo

ur o

n tw

o lo

w

two

(*)

37 m

in 2

7 s

An

d on

and

tota

l in

hibi

t

37 m

in 2

8 s

Gon

g

37 m

in 2

9 s

P

F C

Page 46: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

37 m

in 3

2 s

37 m

in 3

8 s

Ah y

ou�v

e go

t the

ru

dder

s go

ing

to

gree

n al

l the

tim

e I

thin

k th

at w

e�ll

leav

e it

that

�s th

e se

cond

tim

e it�

s do

ne it

dur

ing

the

test

s

G

ong

37 m

in 3

9 s

Shal

l I re

set o

r no

t?

37 m

in 4

3 s

I don

�t se

e w

hich

on

e (*

)

37 m

in 4

5 s

R

eset

- w

e�ll

see

37 m

in 4

6 s

no n

o

37 m

in 4

7 s

If

it so

unds

dur

ing

take

off w

e to

uch

noth

ing

whi

le w

e (s

tart)

it

37 m

in 5

1 s

It�s

alre

ady

done

it

to m

e tw

ice

37 m

in 5

4 s

tw

ice.

.. so

the

brak

es

Page 47: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

37 m

in 5

6 s

em

erg

test

ed

norm

al n

o pr

essu

re n

o ju

mpi

ng n

o re

leas

e

14 h

38

min

00

s

the

trim

s fo

r fif

ty-fo

ur p

erce

nt

38 m

in 0

2 s

Ac

tual

ly z

ero

zero

fo

r fift

y-fo

ur I

see

two

and

a ha

lf ch

ecke

d ic

o fli

ght

38 m

in 0

8 s

Pr

essu

risat

ion

and

air c

ondi

tioni

ng

chec

ked

38 m

in 1

4 s

Fu

el tr

ansf

er is

un

der w

ay p

ipe

safe

ties

38 m

in 2

1 s

Fi

ne o

n ar

rival

38 m

in 2

2 s

yes

38 m

in 2

6 s

ye

s

38 m

in 2

7 s

38 m

in 2

9 s

of

f atta

ched

Se

ats

and

harn

ess

over

-pul

l of

f and

ant

i-ski

d of

f and

de-

icin

g an

d ta

keof

f br

iefin

g

Page 48: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

38 m

in 3

3 s

re

...

Gon

g

38 m

in 3

4 s

Ah

it�s

dro

pped

ag

ain

38 m

in 3

5 s

That

�s it

it�s

dr

oppe

d

38 m

in 3

6 s

Yo

u�re

righ

t let

�s

stay

in y

ell i

n gr

een

38 m

in 4

0 s

We�

re s

tayi

ng in

gr

een

eh

38 m

in 4

3 s

Bo

th ru

dder

s or

th

e up

per

38 m

in 4

4 s

ye

s bo

th y

es

38 m

in 4

5 s

Bo

th e

h

38 m

in 4

6 s

(*

)

oh y

es y

es y

es o

h w

ell y

ou h

ave

to...

th

ey�re

alw

ays

toge

ther

are

n�t

they

?

Page 49: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

38 m

in 4

9 s

Ye

s no

but

whe

n yo

u pr

ess

you

switc

h to

the

gree

n sy

stem

but

th

e th

e �

was

the

drop

on

both

of

them

�or

on

just

on

e?

38 m

in 5

6 s

On

both

of c

ours

e no

? no

?

38 m

in 5

9 s

I d

on�t

thin

k no

yo

u ca

n on

ly h

ave

one

may

be

14 h

39

min

00

s

ah

I do

n�t k

now

w

ell e

rr...

14 h

39

min

04

s

So th

e ta

keof

f is

� a

t max

imum

ta

keof

f wei

ght o

ne

hund

red

eigh

ty

tons

one

hun

dred

w

hich

mea

ns fo

ur

rehe

ats

with

a

min

imum

failu

re

N2

of n

inet

y ei

ght

Page 50: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

39 m

in 2

1 s

39 m

in 2

5 s

be

twee

n ze

ro a

nd

one

hund

red

knot

s I s

top

for

any

aura

l war

ning

th

e ty

re fl

ash

(C

tl) A

ir Fr

ance

fo

ur fi

ve n

ine

zero

co

ntac

t the

Tow

er

on o

ne h

undr

ed

twen

ty d

ecim

al

nine

39 m

in 2

9 s

! o

ne h

undr

ed

twen

ty-n

ine

four

fiv

e ni

ne z

ero

good

afte

rnoo

n

39 m

in 3

5 s

ty

re fl

ash

and

failu

re c

allo

ut fr

om

you

right

39 m

in 3

8 s

be

twee

n on

e hu

ndre

d kn

ots

and

V1 I

igno

re

the

gong

I st

op fo

r an

eng

ine

fire

a ty

re fl

ash

and

the

failu

re c

allo

ut

39 m

in 4

5 s

ye

s

39 m

in 4

6 s

af

ter V

1 w

e co

ntin

ue o

n th

e SI

D w

e ju

st ta

lked

ab

out w

e la

nd

back

on

runw

ay

twen

ty-s

ix ri

ght

Page 51: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

39 m

in 5

1 s

an

d th

e qu

ick

refe

renc

e ha

ndbo

ok is

read

y fo

r an

over

wei

ght

land

ing

39 m

in 5

6 s

(C

tl) A

ir Fr

ance

fo

ur fi

ve n

ine

zero

he

llo

39 m

in 5

8 s

! h

ello

thre

shol

d tw

enty

-six

righ

t fo

ur fi

ve n

ine

zero

14 h

40

min

01

s

(Ctl)

(*) f

our f

ive

nine

zer

o lin

e up

on

runw

ay

twen

ty-s

ix ri

ght

40 m

in 0

4 s

! w

e lin

e up

and

ho

ld o

n tw

enty

-six

rig

ht fo

ur fi

ve n

ine

zero

40 m

in 0

7 s

R

eady

in th

e ba

ck?

40 m

in 1

0 s

Let�s

go

40 m

in 1

1 s

!

CC

prep

are

for t

akeo

ff

40 m

in 1

6 s

pr

e-ta

keof

f ch

eck-

list

Page 52: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

40 m

in 1

9 s

H

ow m

uch

fuel

ha

ve w

e us

ed?

40 m

in 2

3 s

W

e�ve

got

eig

ht

hund

red

kilo

s th

ere

40 m

in 2

4 s

ei

ght h

undr

ed

kilo

s?

40 m

in 2

8 s

rig

ht

No

diffe

renc

e on

th

e se

cond

se

gmen

t

40 m

in 3

1 s

W

e ha

ven�

t lef

t ye

t, ha

ve w

e (*

)

40 m

in 3

5 s

Er

r bra

kes

one

hund

red

degr

ees

40 m

in 3

7 s

Be

fore

take

off

Take

off m

onito

r

40 m

in 3

9 s

arm

ed

40 m

in 4

0 s

ar

med

40 m

in 4

1 s

40 m

in 4

3 s

40 m

in 4

4 s

Th

e pa

ram

eter

s fo

r tak

e...

Take

off

para

met

ers

(CC

) cab

in re

ady

Page 53: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

40 m

in 4

5 s

W

ell t

hey�

re

conf

irmed

, not

hing

ha

s ch

ange

d

40 m

in 4

7 s

N

oise

redu

ctio

n pa

ram

eter

s co

nfirm

ed e

ngin

e ra

ting

light

on

take

-off

40 m

in 5

5 s

N

1 lim

iter f

our

nine

ty e

ight

ei

ghty

idle

on

high

14 h

41

min

00

s

Cen

tral a

larm

sy

stem

41 m

in 0

1 s

41 m

in 0

2 s

41 m

in 0

3 s

re

call

inhi

bit

(C

tl) A

ir Fr

ance

fo

ur fi

ve n

ine

zero

so

I w

ill ca

ll yo

u ba

ck a

s so

on a

s it�

s fre

e in

fron

t

41 m

in 0

4 s

! h

oldi

ng p

ositi

on

four

five

nin

e ze

ro

41 m

in 0

5 s

Th

e tra

nspo

nder

41 m

in 0

8 s

I�m

put

ting

it on

Page 54: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

41 m

in 0

9 s

Br

ake

tem

pera

ture

s ch

ecke

d on

e hu

ndre

d fif

ty th

e C

G is

at f

ifty

�.

Four

two

41 m

in 1

7 s

R

ehea

t fou

r w

hite

s de

-icin

g

41 m

in 1

9 s

ok

ay

41 m

in 2

0 s

Is

it h

otte

r on

the

left

or th

e rig

ht

ther

e?

41 m

in 2

8 s

It�

s ab

out t

he

sam

e yo

u kn

ow

41 m

in 3

0 s

Wha

t�s th

e m

ax ?

41 m

in 3

2 s

Th

ere

we�

re a

t on

e hu

ndre

d fif

ty

41 m

in 3

3 s

Yeah

it g

oes

up

fast

on

this

ta

xiw

ay w

e�ll

have

to

wat

ch o

ut

41 m

in 4

5 s

41 m

in 4

7 s

So

um

dep

art o

n th

e ce

ntre

line

to

one

hund

red

On

the

cent

relin

e le

vel o

ne h

undr

ed

41 m

in 5

5 s

C

G fi

fty fo

ur

Page 55: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

14 h

42

min

08

s

(*)

42 m

in 1

7.0

s 97

547.

5

(C

tl) A

ir Fr

ance

fo

ur fi

ve n

ine

zero

ru

nway

twen

ty-s

ix

right

win

d ze

ro

nine

ty e

ight

kno

ts

clea

red

for t

akeo

ff

42 m

in 2

1.6

s

42 m

in 2

3.3

s

9755

2.1

9755

3.7

Fou

r fiv

e ni

ne

zero

take

off

twen

ty-s

ix ri

ght

N

oise

of s

elec

tor

42 m

in 2

4.8

s 97

555.

3 Is

eve

rybo

dy

read

y

42 m

in 2

5.8

s 97

556.

3

yes

42 m

in 2

6 s

9755

6.5

yes

42 m

in 2

6.6

s 97

557.

1 To

one

hun

dred

V1

one

hun

dred

fif

ty

42 m

in 2

8.8

s 97

559.

3 (*

)

42 m

in 3

0.4

s 97

560.

9

Noi

se o

f sel

ecto

r

Clic

king

of t

hrus

t lev

ers

42 m

in 3

1 s

9756

1.5

top

42 m

in 3

1.3

s 97

561.

8

Cha

nge

in

back

grou

nd n

oise

Incr

ease

in th

e ai

rflow

in th

e ai

r con

ditio

ning

and

an

incr

ease

in e

ngin

e sp

eed

Page 56: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

42 m

in 3

5.3

s 97

565.

8

(?

) go

Chr

istia

n

42 m

in 3

7.4

s 97

567.

9

Tw

o tra

nsm

issi

on

clic

ks

42 m

in 4

3.3

s 97

573.

8

W

e ha

ve fo

ur

rehe

ats

42 m

in 4

7.5

s 97

578

N

oise

of s

elec

tor

M

ovem

ent o

f aut

omat

ic

sele

ctor

on

pass

ing

60 k

t

42 m

in 5

4.6

s 97

585.

1

one

hund

red

knot

s

42 m

in 5

5.1

s 97

585.

5

Noi

se

42 m

in 5

5.5

s 97

586

chec

ked

42 m

in 5

7 s

97

587.

5

Fo

ur g

reen

s

14 h

43

min

03.

7 s

9759

4.2

V

1

43 m

in 1

0.1

s 97

600.

6

Noi

se

43 m

in 1

1 s

43 m

in 1

1.9

s

9760

1.5

9760

2.4

Cha

nge

in

back

grou

nd n

oise

(*)

U

nint

ellig

ible

noi

se

43 m

in 1

3 s

9760

3.5

w

atch

out

Page 57: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

43 m

in 1

3.4

s

43 m

in 1

3.8

s

43 m

in 1

6.1

s

43 m

in 1

6.4

s

9760

3.9

9760

4.3

9760

6.6

9760

6.9

(sto

p)

End

of c

hang

e in

ba

ckgr

ound

noi

se

Noi

se o

f sel

ecto

r

(Ctl)

Con

cord

e ze

ro...

four

five

ni

ne z

ero

you

have

flam

es (*

) yo

u ha

ve fl

ames

be

hind

you

(?) (

*) ri

ght S

IMU

LTAN

EOU

S BR

OAD

CAS

TS

43 m

in 1

8.8

s 97

609.

3

! ro

ger

43 m

in 2

0.4

s 97

610.

9

Fa

ilure

eng

failu

re e

ngin

e tw

o

43 m

in 2

1.3

s 97

611.

8

2 se

lect

or n

oise

s

TCU

mov

emen

t pas

sing

from

m

ain

to a

ltern

ate

43 m

in 2

2.8

s 97

613.

3

Bell

Fi

re a

larm

(?) i

t�s re

ally

bu

rnin

g eh

43 m

in 2

3.5

s 97

614

G

ong

43 m

in 2

4.8

s 97

615.

3

Sh

ut d

own

engi

ne

two

43 m

in 2

5.8

s 97

616.

3 En

gine

fire

pr

oced

ure

43 m

in 2

6.2

s 97

616.

7

Noi

se o

f sel

ecto

r

Thru

st le

ver r

educ

tion

or H

P sh

utof

f

43 m

in 2

6.8

s 97

617.

3

End

of b

ell

Page 58: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

43 m

in 2

7.2

s

43 m

in 2

7.5

s

43 m

in 2

8.2

s

9761

7.7

9761

7.9

9761

8.7

W

atch

the

airs

peed

the

airs

peed

the

airs

peed

N

oise

of s

elec

tor

Gon

g

Au

tom

atic

trim

sel

ecto

r

43 m

in 2

8.7

s

43 m

in 2

9.3

s

43 m

in 3

0 s

9761

9.2

9761

9.8

9762

0.5

Gea

r on

retra

ct

Noi

se o

f sel

ecto

r

(?) i

t�s re

ally

bu

rnin

g an

d I�m

no

t sur

e it�

s co

min

g fro

m th

e en

gine

s

Fire

han

dle

bein

g pu

lled

43 m

in 3

1.6

s

43 m

in 3

2 s

43 m

in 3

2.6

s

9762

2.1

9762

2.5

9762

3.1

The

gear

Toile

t sm

oke

dete

ctio

n al

arm

(Ctl)

four

five

nin

e ze

ro y

ou h

ave

stro

ng fl

ames

be

hind

you

43 m

in 3

4.5

s 97

624.

5

Be

ginn

ing

of

rece

ptio

n of

a

Mid

dle

Mar

ker

43 m

in 3

4.7

s 97

625.

2

! y

es ro

ger

43 m

in 3

5.5

s 97

626

The

gear

(Jea

n)

43 m

in 3

7 s

9762

7.5

G

ong

43 m

in 3

7.3

s

43 m

in 3

7.7

s

43 m

in 3

8.4

s

9762

7.8

9762

8.2

9762

8.9

no

gear

Noi

se

Noi

se

(Ctl)

so

do a

s yo

u w

ish

you

have

pr

iorit

y fo

r a re

turn

to

the

field

43 m

in 3

9 s

9762

9.5

(gea

r) re

tract

Page 59: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

43 m

in 4

1.2

s 97

631.

7

! ro

ger

43 m

in 4

2.3

s 97

632.

8

Bell

Fi

re a

larm

43 m

in 4

3 s

9763

3.5

G

ong

43 m

in 4

4.7

s 97

635.

2

3 se

lect

or n

oise

s

Fire

ext

ingu

ishe

r fire

d w

ith fi

rst

shot

43 m

in 4

5.6

s 97

636.

1

(I�m

tryi

ng)

I�m fi

ring

it

43 m

in 4

6.3

s 97

636.

8 (a

re y

ou) s

hutti

ng

dow

n en

gine

two

ther

e

End

of to

ilet

smok

e de

tect

ion

alar

m

43 m

in 4

.28

s 97

638.

7

I�v

e sh

ut it

dow

n

43 m

in 4

9.3

s 97

639.

8

En

d of

rece

ptio

n of

Mid

dle

Mar

ker

43 m

in 4

9.9

s 97

640.

4

The

airs

peed

43 m

in 5

3 s

9764

3.5

N

oise

43 m

in 5

4.8

s 97

645.

3

End

of b

ell

43 m

in 5

6.7

s 97

647.

2

The

gear

isn�

t re

tract

ing

43 m

in 5

8.6

s 97

649.

1

Bell

Fi

re a

larm

43 m

in 5

9.1

s 97

649.

6

(SV)

who

op

who

op p

ull u

p

GPW

S w

arni

ng

43 m

in 5

9.4

s 97

649.

9

Gon

g

Page 60: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

14 h

44

min

00.

6 s

9765

1.1

(S

V) w

hoop

w

hoop

pul

l up

G

PWS

war

ning

44 m

in 0

0.7

s 97

651.

2

The

airs

peed

44 m

in 0

2 s

9765

2.5

(V

S) w

hoop

w

hoop

pul

l up

G

PWS

war

ning

44 m

in 0

3 s

9765

3.5

(FSL

) De

Gau

lle

tow

er fr

om fi

re

serv

ice

lead

er

44 m

in 0

5.2

s 97

655.

7

(C

tl) fi

re s

ervi

ce

lead

er e

rr...

the

Con

cord

e I d

on�t

know

his

in

tent

ions

get

into

po

sitio

n ne

ar th

e so

uthe

rn d

oubl

e ru

nway

44 m

in 1

0.5

s 97

661

N

oise

of s

elec

tor

44 m

in 1

2 s

9766

2.5

(*)

44 m

in 1

3.2

s

44 m

in 1

4.6

s

44 m

in 1

6.5

s

9766

3.7

9766

5.1

9766

6.7

(too

late

)

Le B

ourg

et L

e Bo

urge

t

(FSL

) De

Gau

lle

tow

er fr

om fi

re

serv

ice

lead

er

auth

oris

atio

n to

en

ter t

wen

ty-s

ix

right

Page 61: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

44 m

in 1

8.1

s

44 m

in 1

9.8

s

9766

8.6

9767

0.3

(no

time

no)

(C

tl) F

ire s

ervi

ce

lead

er c

orre

ctio

n th

e C

onco

rde

is

retu

rnin

g on

ru

nway

zer

o ni

ne

in th

e op

posi

te

dire

ctio

n

44 m

in 2

2.8

s 97

673.

2

! n

egat

ive

we�

re

tryin

g fo

r Le

Bour

get

44 m

in 2

4.7

s 97

675.

2

Noi

se o

f sel

ecto

r

44 m

in 2

5.1

s 97

675.

6

Noi

se o

f sel

ecto

r

44 m

in 2

5.4

s 97

675.

9

Noi

se o

f sel

ecto

r

44 m

in 2

6.2

s 97

676.

7

Noi

se o

f sel

ecto

r

44 m

in 2

6.4

s

44 m

in 2

6.6

s

44 m

in 2

7 s

9767

6.9

9767

7.1

9767

7.5

(n

o)

G

ong

Gon

g an

d no

ise

of

sele

ctor

(FSL

) De

Gau

lle

tow

er fr

om fi

re

serv

ice

lead

er c

an

you

give

me

the

situ

atio

n of

the

Con

cord

e no

w

44 m

in 2

7.5

s 97

678

N

oise

of s

elec

tor

and

begi

nnin

g of

m

ovem

ent o

f ob

ject

s in

coc

kpit

44 m

in 2

9 s

9767

9.5

(*)

Noi

ses

of e

ffort

Page 62: CVR TRANSCRIPT - BEA · F-BTSC appendix 2 Translation of the CVR transcript page 1/1 CVR TRANSCRIPT Ce qui suit reprØsente la transcription des ØlØments qui ont pu Œtre compris

CVR

UTC

FDR

TIM

E CA

PTAI

N FI

RST

OFF

ICER

FL

IGHT

EN

GIN

EER

COCK

PIT

AREA

M

ICRO

PHO

NE

VHF,

IN

TERP

HONE

, PA

O

BSER

VATI

ONS

44 m

in 3

0 s

9768

0.5

(*)

44 m

in 3

0.7

s 97

681.

2 (*

)

14 h

44

min

31.

6 s

9768

2.1

END

OF

REC

OR

DIN

G