Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq...

65
1 Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials/Nurseries tested during 2018-19 cropping season in Pakistan Contributors: Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan, Abdul Jabbar Chandio, CIMMYT- Pakistan Dr. Muhammad Imtiaz, CIMMYT Pakistan

Transcript of Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq...

Page 1: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

1

Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials/Nurseries

tested during 2018-19 cropping season in Pakistan

Contributors: Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan, Abdul Jabbar Chandio, CIMMYT- Pakistan Dr. Muhammad Imtiaz, CIMMYT Pakistan

Page 2: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

2

Page 3: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

3

Trial Name and number of Test locations

1. 39th Elite Selection Wheat Yield Trial (39th ESWYT) --- 17 locations

2. 17th High Temperature Wheat Yield Trial (17th HTWYT) --- 7 locations

3. 9th Harvest Plus Yield Trial (9th HPYT) --- 7 locations

4. 26th Semi-Arid Wheat Yield Trial (26th SAWYT) --- 13 locations

5. 8th Stress Adaptive Trait Yield Nursery (8th SATYN) --- 7 locations

6. 6th Wheat Yield Consortium Yield Trial (6th WYCYT) --- 7 locations

7. 1st Collaborative Wheat Yield Trial (1st CWYT )--- 3 locations

Acknowledgement:

We are thankful to all national partners for evaluation, data collection and timely data sharing of these trials. We also express our

gratitude to Biometrics and Statistics Unit (BSU) CIMMYT, especially Juan Burgueño and Angela Pacheco for their continuous

guidance and support on data analysis.

Methodology for Data Analysis:

All the trials were analyzed using META-R software, which is based on R free version and is developed by CIMMYT BSU team. The

software can be downloaded free from CIMMYT website (https://data.cimmyt.org/dataset.xhtml?persistentId=hdl:11529/10201) and

should be cited (Gregorio Alvarado; Marco López; Mateo Vargas; Angela Pacheco; Francisco Rodríguez; Juan Burgueño; José Crossa,

2016/11/30, META-R (Multi Environment Trial Analysis whit R for Windows.) Version 6.0 http://hdl.handle.net/11529/10201

International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center) in technical reports and journal articles. BLUEs (Best Linear and Unbiased

Estimation) and BLUPs (Best Linear and Unbiased Prediction) were calculated for individual as well as combined over locations. BLUE

values are calculated when genotypes are considered fixed and these values (Estimated mean performance) are helpful in identifying

best genotypes for release as a variety. On the other hand, BLUPs (calculated when genotypes are considered as Random) are

prediction of performance and are helpful in selecting best genotypes for further evaluation and also using them in your breeding

Page 4: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

4

programs. Therefore, BLUP analysis could help breeders to selection of genotypes from these trials for further testing at individual

locations.

Coefficient of Variation (CV %) of some locations is high, which is due to large standard deviation (SD) in data and or low grand mean

yield. The large variation in data is due to environmental conditions and or incautious trial management and data collection.

In case of individual as well as combined over locations evaluations, genotypes were subjected to LSD test in comparison to local

check only. LSD values for both BLUP and BLUEs were calculate through META-R and significantly (P<0.05) yielding higher genotypes

than checks were starred manually using Excel formula i.e. IF(genotype mean-$check mean$>$LSD$,”*”,””)

Page 5: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

5

LIST OF TABLES

Table No. Title Page No.

Table 1. Detail of local checks used in various international trials .......................................................................................................... 7

Table 2. Detail of entries evaluated in 39th ESWYT .................................................................................................................................. 8

Table 3. Yield performance (kg/ha) of 39th ESWYT lines over local checks in KP .................................................................................. 12

Table 4. Yield performance (kg/ha) of 39th ESWYT lines over local checks in Punjab ...................................................................... 14-17

Table 5. Yield (kg/ha) performance of 39th ESWYT lines over local checks in Sindh, Baluchistan and across locations ....................... 18

Table 6. Detail of Entries evaluated in 17th HTWYT ............................................................................................................................... 20

Table 7. Yield (kg/ha) Performance of 17th HTWYT lines over local checks in Punjab ........................................................................... 24

Table 8. Yield (kg/ha) Performance of 17th HTWYT lines over local checks in KP, Sindh and across locations ..................................... 26

Table 9. Detail of entries evaluated in 9th HPYT ..................................................................................................................................... 28

Table 10. Yield (kg/ha) performance of 9th HPYT lines over local checks in Punjab .............................................................................. 33

Table 11. Yield (kg/ha) performance of 9th HPYT lines over local checks in KP, Sindh and across locations ......................................... 35

Table 12. Detail of entries evaluated in 26th SAWYT lines ..................................................................................................................... 37

Table 13. Yield (kg/ha) Performance of 26th SAWYT lines over local checks Punjab ........................................................................ 41-44

Table 14. Yield (kg/ha) Performance of 26th SAWYT lines over local checks in Baluchistan and Sindh................................................. 45

Table 15. Yield (kg/ha) Performance of 26th SAWYT lines over local checks in KP and combined over locations ................................ 47

Table 16. Detail of Entries evaluated in 8th SATYN ................................................................................................................................. 49

Table 17. Yield (kg/ha) performance of 8th SATYN lines over local checks in KP and Sindh ................................................................. 51

Table 18. Yield (kg/ha) performance of 8th SATYN lines over local checks in Punjab and combined over locations ........................... 53

Table 19. Detail of Entries evaluated in 6th WYCYT ................................................................................................................................ 54

Page 6: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

6

Table 20. Yield (kg/ha) performance of 6th WYCYT lines over local checks in Punjab ........................................................................... 56

Table 21. Yield (kg/ha) performance of 6th WYCYT lines over local checks in Baluchistan, Sindh, KP and across locations ................. 58

Table 22. Detail of Entries evaluated in 1st CWYT .................................................................................................................................. 59

Table 23. Yield (kg/ha) performance of 1st CWYT lines over local checks in individual and across locations ....................................... 63

Acronyms

ARI: Agricultural Research Institute

AZRI: Arid Zone Research Institute

AZRI: Arid Zone Research Institute

BARDC: Baluchistan Agricultural Research and Development Centre

BARI: Barani Agricultural Research Institute

BLUE: Best Linear and Unbiased Estimator

BLUP: Best Linear and Unbiased Predictor

BSU: Biometrics and Statistics Unit

CCRI: Cereal Crops Research Institute

KP: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Province

NARC: National Agricultural Research Centre

NIA: Nuclear Institute of Agriculture

NIFA: Nuclear Institute for Food and Agriculture

PARC: Pakistan Agricultural Research Council

QARI: Quaid-e-Awam Agricultural Research Institute, Larkana

RARI: Regional Agricultural Research Institute

WRI FSD: Wheat Research Institute, Faisalabad

WRI SKD: Wheat Research Institute, Sakrand

Page 7: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

7

Table 1. Detail of local checks used in various international trials Local Check Parentage Used in Location (s)

Wadan-17 YAV79//DACK/RABI/3/SNIPE/4/ AE. SQUARRO SA 39ESWYT ARS-Bafa

Khaista-17 KAUZ//ALTAR 84/AOS/3/MILAN/KAUZ/4/HUITES/7/ CAL/NH//H567.71/3/SERI/4/CAL/ NH//H567.71 /5/2*KAUZ/6/PASTOR

39ESWYT, 9HPYT CCRI-KP

Paseena-17 MTRWA92.161/PRINIA/5/SERI*3//RL6010/4*YR/3/PASTOR/4 39ESWYT, 9HPYT ARI-Tarnab, ARS-Swabi

Pirsabak-15 MILAN/S87230//BABAX 26SAWYT CCRI

NIFA-Aman PRL/2*PASTOR//PBW343*2/KUKUNA/3/ROLF 07 39ESWYT, 1CWYT NIFA-KP

NIFA-Lalma PASTOR/3/ALTAR 84/AEGILOPS SQUARROSA (TAUS)//OPATA 8SATYN NIFA-KP

Kohat-17 SOKOLL/WBLLI 26SAWYT, 8SATYN, 6WYCYT, 1CWYT

BARS-Kohat

Israr Shaheed-17 ESDA/ / ALTAR 84 / AE.AQUARROSA (211) /3/ ESDA/4/ 39ESWYT, 17HTWYT, ARI-D.I.K

Shahid-17 BYJ/COC/PRL/BOW/3/URES/JUN/KAUZ 26SAWYT ARI-D.I.K

Fateh jang-16 ERA F 2000/4/ FONCHAN #3 / TRT"S"//VEE#9/3/COOK/VEES//DOVE"S/SERI

39ESWYT, 26SAWYT BARS-FJ

Jauhar-16 KAUZ/PASTOR//V.3009 39ESWYT, 17HTWYT 9HPYT, 26SAWYT, 8SATYN, 6WYCYT

RARI-BWPR AZRI, BWPR

Fakhr-e-Bhakkar TTRS/SPA//WL711/3/CHI/4/CROWS/NAC//BOW,S 39ESWYT, 26SAWYT, 8SATYN, 6WCYT,17HTWYT

AZRI-Bhakkar

Faisalabad-08 PBW65/2*Pastor 39ESWYT, 26SAWYT, 8SATYN, 6WYCYT,17HTWYT

WRI-FSD

Galaxy-13 Punjab 96/V-87094//MH-97 9HPYT WRI-FSD

Ihsan-16 Pastor/3/Altar-84/Ae.Sq//Opata 39ESWYT, 26SAWYT 9HPYT

BARI-Chakwal

Kiran-95 WL-771/Crow “s” Mutant 1CWYT NIA-TJ

Benazir-13 CHEN/AEGILOPS SQUARROSA (TAUS)//BCN/3/VEE#7/BOW/4/PASTOR 39ESWYT, 26SAWYT 9HPYT, 8SATYN, 17HTWYT, 6WCYT

NIA-TJ, WRI-Sakrand

NIA Amber VEE//5 'S'/SARA//SOGHAT90 39ESWYT NIA-TJ

T.D-1 MAI'S' X NORTENO65 X H68 39ESWYT, 17HTWYT QARI-Larkana

Page 8: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

8

26SAWYT

Shalkot-14 TRACHA’S//CMH76-252/PVN’S 39ESWYT, 26SAWYT 6WYCYT

BARDC-Quetta

Zardana CNO/8156//TOB/3/CNO/4/NO/3/II12300//LR64/8156/5/PVM 39ESWYT, 26SAWYT ARI-Quetta

Borlaug-16 SOKOLL/3/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU

39ESWYT, 9HPYT, 26SAWYT, 6WYCYT

NARC-ISB

Pakistan-13 MEX94.27.1.20/3/SOKOLL//ATTILA/3*BCN

17HTWYT Wheat Wide Crosses-NARC

Gundom-2018 39WSWYT Ghazi Univ.

Table 2. Detail of entries evaluated in 39th ESWYT Entry No.

Cross Name Selection History

101 Local Check As given in Table 1

102 MUCUY CMSS07Y01083T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099Y-40M-0WGY

103

CROC_1/AE.SQUARROSA

(205)//BORL95/3/PRL/SARA//TSI/VEE#5/4/FRET2/5/CIRO16 CMSS10Y00023S-099Y-099M-099NJ-099NJ-4WGY-0B

104 KACHU/SAUAL/4/ATTILA*2/PBW65//PIHA/3/ATTILA/2*PASTOR CMSS10Y00374S-099Y-099M-1WGY-0B

105 NELOKI//SOKOLL/EXCALIBUR CMSA11Y00507S-099Y-099M-099NJ-099NJ-10WGY-0B

106 SUP152/QUAIU #2//BECARD/QUAIU #1 CMSS11B00405S-099M-099NJ-099NJ-26WGY-0M

107 BORL14//BECARD/QUAIU #1 CMSS12Y00070S-099Y-099M-0SY-9M-0WGY

108 KACHU//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING/3/KACHU/KIRITATI CMSS12Y00241S-099Y-099M-0SY-9M-0WGY

109 WBLL4/KUKUNA//WBLL1/3/WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING/4/BORL14 CMSS12Y00259S-099Y-099M-0SY-15M-0WGY

110 SUP152/AKURI//SUP152/3/MUCUY CMSS12Y00300S-099Y-099M-0SY-4M-0WGY

Page 9: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

9

111 PRL/2*PASTOR*2//MISR2, EGY/3/2*BECARD//ND643/2*WBLL1 CMSS12Y00645T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-9M-0WGY

112 SUP152/BLOUK #1/3/PRL/2*PASTOR*2//VORB/4/SUP152/BLOUK #1 CMSS12Y00707T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-26M-0WGY

113 BOKOTA//BECARD/QUAIU #1/3/BOKOTA CMSS12Y00713T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-5M-0WGY

114 SUP152/HUIRIVIS #1//2*BORL14 CMSS12Y00718T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-48M-0WGY

115

KSW/SAUAL//SAUAL/3/TRCH/HUIRIVIS

#1/5/UP2338*2/SHAMA/3/MILAN/KAUZ//CHIL/CHUM18/4/UP2338*2/S

HAMA CMSS12Y00730T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-42M-0WGY

116

BORL14*2/7/MUU/5/WBLL1*2/4/YACO/PBW65/3/KAUZ*2/TRAP//KAUZ/

6/WBLL1*2/SHAMA CMSS12Y00773T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-14M-0WGY

117 WBLL1/4/BOW/NKT//CBRD/3/CBRD/5/WBLL1*2/TUKURU/6/2*BORL14 CMSS12Y00823T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-5M-0WGY

118 NADI#2//TRCH/HUIRIVIS #1/3/NADI#1 CMSS12Y00880T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-17M-0WGY

119

KACHU//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING/3/BAJ

#1/AKURI/4/KACHU//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING CMSS12Y00915T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-8M-0WGY

120

SUP152/BAJ #1/4/BAJ #1/3/KIRITATI//ATTILA*2/PASTOR/5/SUP152/BAJ

#1 CMSS12Y00919T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-25M-0WGY

121 WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING/3/2*BORL14 CMSS12Y00929T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-20M-0WGY

122 KIRITATI/WBLL1//2*BLOUK #1*2/3/KACHU #1/KIRITATI//KACHU CMSS12Y00946T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-13M-0WGY

123

KACHU #1/3/T.DICOCCON PI94624/AE.SQUARROSA

(409)//BCN/4/2*KACHU/5/MUTUS*2/TECUE #1/6/MUTUS*2/TECUE #1 CMSS12Y01163T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-27M-0WGY

124 BAJ #1/3/SUP152//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING CMSS12B00004S-099M-0SY-9M-0WGY

125

TACUPETO

F2001/BRAMBLING//KACHU/8/REH/HARE//2*BCN/3/CROC_1/AE.SQUAR

ROSA (213)//PGO/4/HUITES/5/T.DICOCCON PI94624/AE.SQUARROSA

(409)//BCN/6/REH/HARE//2*BCN/3/CROC_1/AE.SQUARROSA

(213)//PGO/4/HUITES/7/MUTUS CMSS12B00035S-099M-0SY-34M-0WGY

Page 10: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

10

126 BORL14/4/BAJ #1/3/KIRITATI//ATTILA*2/PASTOR CMSS12B00044S-099M-0SY-12M-0WGY

127 MUTUS/ROLF07//MUCUY CMSS12B00083S-099M-0SY-1M-0WGY

128 MUTUS/AKURI//SUP152/BAJ #1 CMSS12B00100S-099M-0SY-22M-0WGY

129 BAJ #1/TECUE #1//MUTUS*2/TECUE #1 CMSS12B00104S-099M-0SY-1M-0WGY

130 KINGBIRD #1//INQALAB 91*2/TUKURU/3/BECARD/FRNCLN CMSS12B00105S-099M-0SY-27M-0WGY

131 SUP152/BAJ #1/3/KACHU//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING CMSS12B00147S-099M-0SY-39M-0WGY

132 WBLL4/KUKUNA//WBLL1/3/WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING/4/BECARD/FRNCLN CMSS12B00157S-099M-0SY-27M-0WGY

133 BECARD/QUAIU #1//ONIX/KBIRD CMSS12B00280S-099M-0SY-6M-0WGY

134 KACHU/BECARD//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING/3/FRNCLN*2/TECUE #1 CMSS12B00317S-099M-0SY-1M-0WGY

135

OASIS/SKAUZ//4*BCN*2/3/PASTOR/4/HEILO/5/PAURAQ/6/BECARD/QUA

IU #1 CMSS12B00378S-099M-0SY-5M-0WGY

136 CIRO16/2*BORL14 CMSS12B00569T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-53M-0WGY

137 BORL14*2/3/KBIRD//WBLL1*2/KURUKU CMSS12B00630T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-11M-0WGY

138 BORL14*2//KFA/2*KACHU CMSS12B00633T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-12M-0WGY

139 BORL14*2//KFA/2*KACHU CMSS12B00633T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-37M-0WGY

140 BORL14*2//BECARD/QUAIU #1 CMSS12B00634T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-19M-0WGY

141

CNO79//PF70354/MUS/3/PASTOR/4/BAV92*2/5/HAR311/6/BECARD/QU

AIU #1/7/BECARD/QUAIU #1 CMSS12B00640T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-14M-0WGY

142 FITIS*2/3/ATTILA*2/PBW65*2//MURGA CMSS12B00671T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-6M-0WGY

143 SUP152/BLOUK #1*2/4/TUKURU//BAV92/RAYON*2/3/KIRITATI CMSS12B00709T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-22M-0WGY

144 NADI#1*2/3/MUTUS/AKURI #1//MUTUS CMSS12B00767T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-46M-0WGY

145 KACHU//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING*2/3/KACHU/KIRITATI CMSS12B00801T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-36M-0WGY

Page 11: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

11

146 KACHU//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING*2/3/KACHU/KIRITATI CMSS12B00801T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-46M-0WGY

147 ONIX/KBIRD//BORL14/3/ONIX/KBIRD CMSS12B00825T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-17M-0WGY

148 STLN/MUNAL #1//2*BORL14 CMSS12B00828T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-42M-0WGY

149

WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING//CHYAK*2/3/KINGBIRD #1//INQALAB

91*2/TUKURU CMSS12B00929T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-13M-0WGY

150

FRET2*2/BRAMBLING//BECARD/3/WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING*2/4/BECARD/Q

UAIU #1 CMSS12B00944T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-33M-0WGY

Page 12: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

12

Table 3. Yield performance (kg/ha) of 39th ESWYT lines over local checks in KP

Entry CCRI

LC: Khaista-17 NIFA

LC: NIFA Aman

ARI-D.I Khan LC: Israr

Shaheed-17 ARI-Tarnab

LC: Paseena-17 ARS. Bafa

LC: Wadan-17 ARS-Swabi

LC: Paseena-17

BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 4124 4263 3673 2663 2576 1129 3076 3202 3799 3900 2068 2067

102 4386 4602 3937 4265* 3207 1129 1641 1472 2680 2641 4004* 4013*

103 4598 4976 3988 4627* 3016 3336* 1649 1481 2326 2252 4302* 4312*

104 4276 4459 3950 4334* 3269 2675 2793 2861 3959 4089 2185 2185

105 3819 3812 3947 4296* 3171 3443* 3277 3444 3072 3083 1759 1757

106 2979 2519 3870 3865 3154 3090* 2547 2564 3400 3450 1495 1491

107 4045 4156 3963 4477* 3341 3160* 2509 2518 4021 4156 1750 1747

108 3842 3815 3889 3967 3281 3746* 4291* 4666* 3206 3243 5639* 5657*

109 4006 4011 3920 4087* 3112 3483* 1918 1805 2202 2081 1484 1480

110 4036 4056 3850 3671 3051 3030* 3001 3111 2469 2381 1958 1957

111 4006 4000 3947 4252* 3155 2827* 2451 2448 4504* 4722* 5261* 5276*

112 4143 4232 3974 4398* 3241 3097* 1557 1370 2598 2570 1913 1911

113 4000 4032 3949 4330* 3057 3353* 2670 2712 2886 2902 5168* 5183*

114 3539 3260 3755 3040 3094 2837* 2801 2870 3130 3144 2037 2036

115 3496 3286 3823 3580 3389 3000* 1772 1630 3932 4077 1623 1619

116 3388 3037 3755 3040 3221 3933* 1926 1815 3419 3469 1337 1332

117 3860 3814 3851 3665 3034 3416* 2087 2009 3414 3487 1163 1157

118 4541 4773 4043 4834* 3350 2670 1979 1879 3207 3254 1899 1897

119 3821 3725 3861 3736 2912 3836* 2901 2991 3328 3401 2059 2058

120 3590 3365 3856 3717 3025 2296 2795 2863 3726 3837 1683 1680

121 3555 3290 4061 4910* 3151 2763 2909 3000 3290 3295 1699 1696

122 3839 3741 3927 4187* 3411 3120* 3155 3296 3471 3521 2080 2079

123 3949 3922 3912 4089* 2806 3973* 1703 1546 2509 2451 1852 1850

124 3118 2732 3799 3483 2840 1880 1903 1787 4337 4503 1387 1383

125 3910 3894 3780 3285 2936 2056 2498 2505 3301 3331 1359 1354

126 4109 4158 3856 3755 2965 2281 2471 2472 3285 3322 1699 1696

Page 13: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

13

127 4461 4721 3956 4416* 3656* 2403 1641 1472 3054 3061 5653* 5670*

128 3917 3904 3956 4335* 3246 4748* 2018 1926 3207 3225 4541* 4553*

129 3713 3524 3871 3776 3238 3303* 1695 1537 2726 2661 1278 1273

130 4054 4059 3874 3870 3259 3407* 2287 2250 2537 2471 1359 1354

131 3919 3966 3955 4365* 2816 3470* 1791 1652 2345 2230 1830 1828

132 3747 3670 3928 4138* 3130 2058 2333 2305 3047 3022 1103 1097

133 4758 5197 3947 4234* 3296 3030* 2993 3102 2346 2224 5252* 5268*

134 4183 4298 3881 3869 3303 3550* 1956 1852 2425 2311 1972 1971

135 3781 3673 3792 3258 3309 3697* 2210 2157 2633 2522 1501 1497

136 3436 3210 3822 3504 2955 3723* 2110 2037 3054 3030 1699 1696

137 4166 4321 3980 4434* 3222 2453 3039 3157 2457 2349 1727 1724

138 3717 3608 3848 3669 3034 3306* 2440 2435 3245 3233 1378 1374

139 4434 4728 3880 3915 2995 2810* 2448 2444 3116 3097 1834 1832

140 3985 3976 3842 3558 3048 2650 3093 3222 2039 1856 1960 1958

141 3871 3805 3882 3697 3421 2863* 2763 2824 3075 3045 1058 1051

142 4054 4164 3852 3654 3013 4200* 1710 1555 3143 3154 1790 1787

143 4109 4205 3917 3976 3026 2813* 2402 2389 2755 2719 1360 1355

144 4149 4265 3764 3060 3300 2793* 3009 3120 2681 2636 2526* 2527*

145 4116 4167 3937 4031* 3413 3696* 3177 3324 3097 3070 1885 1883

146 3741 3642 3798 3274 3302 4173* 3154 3296 3213 3222 1944 1942

147 4512 4842 3913 4021* 3608* 3800* 2463 2463 2910 2891 4432* 4443*

148 3328 3078 3754 2989 3046 4777* 2678 2722 2944 2922 1125 1119

149 4272 4477 3933 4056* 3300 2830* 2041 1953 3567 3622 3895* 3904*

150 3875 3840 3856 3624 3114 3666* 3600 3833 2726 2676 2888* 2891*

LSD 762.6 940.3 517.9 1349.7 894.3 3180.0 767.0 842.2 581.5 609.3 272.3 273.0

CV (%) 11.2 11.2 16.1 16.4 25.4 25.8 17.0 17.0 9.3 9.4 5.8 5.8

Genotype significance

** ** NS NS NS NS ** ** ** ** ** **

LC: Local check #: Entries Marked with * are significantly higher in yield than Local check *: P≤0.05 **: P≤0.01 NS: Non Significant

Page 14: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

14

Table 4. Yield performance (kg/ha) of 39th ESWYT lines over local checks in Punjab

Entry AZRI Bhakkar

LC: Fakhr-e-Bhakkar BARI Chakwal LC: Ihsan-16

BARS FT. Jhang LC: Ft.Jhang-16

Ghazi Univ. LC: Gundom-18

BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 3451 3518 2517 2352 5454 5482 2888 2768

102 3451 3857 6401* 6412* 5284 5301 2957 2828

103 3451 3850 7371* 7411* 4392 4386 3024 2890

104 3451 3674 6448* 6457* 4275 4267 6454* 6617*

105 3451 3331 5285* 5230* 5588 5621 6023* 6148*

106 3451 3273 4894* 4845* 6420* 6476* 4476* 4466*

107 3451 3246 6329* 6328* 5108 5127 6250* 6368*

108 3451 3779 7222* 7262* 5098 5119 6212* 6357*

109 3451 3694 4817* 4736* 4133 4106 5957* 6063*

110 3451 3277 5485* 5430* 5584 5606 2761 2618

111 3451 3991 5809* 5815* 6822* 6916* 4370* 4360*

112 3451 3502 6372* 6382* 5468 5511 2749 2608

113 3451 3500 5407* 5391* 6465* 6544* 5914* 5996*

114 3451 2948 4799* 4738* 5589 5625 2366 2181

115 3451 2937 6182* 6197* 5695 5748 3322 3201

116 3451 3136 5840* 5821* 5526 5561 2260 2067

117 3451 3460 6115* 6116* 5092 5122 4422* 4412*

118 3451 3881 8018* 8114* 5476 5514 6721* 6877*

119 3451 3324 6797* 6842* 5693 5749 6902* 7090*

120 3451 3923 6030* 6048* 5494 5533 3647 3562

121 3451 3596 4874* 4826* 4831 4823 7315* 7521*

122 3451 3446 6998* 7064* 6169* 6211* 6365* 6497*

123 3451 2930 6098* 6125* 6234* 6290* 2386 2225

124 3451 2814 4157* 4102* 5662 5695 3177 3048

125 3451 2838 5389* 5371* 4969 4977 4849* 4877*

126 3451 2993 6077* 6102* 4408 4401 3984 3948

Page 15: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

15

127 3451 3773 6215* 6241* 4024 4000 3960 3893

128 3451 3400 6987* 7032* 4379 4366 5573* 5657*

129 3451 3409 6199* 6204* 4831 4823 3728 3653

130 3451 3967 6837* 6897* 4942 4943 3170 3052

131 3451 3831 6200* 6219* 4089 4059 3931 3870

132 3451 3510 6259* 6286* 4267 4246 4286* 4282*

133 3451 3354 7363* 7416* 4766 4757 7292* 7519*

134 3451 3525 6335* 6369* 5187 5186 4618* 4621*

135 3451 3529 5387* 5354* 4592 4566 6201* 6328*

136 3451 3656 6056* 6075* 4966 4969 6517* 6687*

137 3451 3458 6026* 6026* 3701 3655 4097 4074*

138 3451 3213 5930* 5947* 4552 4529 4362* 4345*

139 3451 2852 6932* 6980* 4859 4855 2801 2652

140 3451 3487 8663* 8759* 5290 5288 3789 3728

141 3451 3523 5719* 5676* 4573 4523 5628* 5707*

142 3451 3929 6312* 6313* 4044 3988 2876 2729

143 3451 4379 6906* 6936* 4150 4101 6094* 6229*

144 3451 4400 5517* 5492* 3541 3471 5492* 5579*

145 3451 3502 5083* 5015* 4036 3967 4437* 4423*

146 3451 3457 5546* 5525* 2877 2773 3382 3285

147 3451 2859 5810* 5791* 5145 5126 3358 3249

148 3451 3222 4237* 4144* 3709 3640 4036 4005

149 3451 2910 6567* 6566* 4139 4084 7774* 8035*

150 3451 2706 7100* 7141* 4810 4772 4045 4000

LSD 0.0 1221.5 608.6 616.9 464.1 464.5 1243.9 1286.5

CV (%) 15.9 16.5 4.9 4.9 4.4 4.5 13.6 13.6

Genotype significance

NS NS ** * ** ** ** **

Page 16: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

16

Table 4. Yield performance (kg/ha) of 39th ESWYT lines over local checks in Punjab

Entry NARC

LC: Borlaug-16 RARI-BWP

LC: Jauhar-16 WRI-FSD

LC: Faisalabad-08

BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 4560 4588 3331 3342 4509 4481

102 5249 5403 1984 1919 4508 4483

103 5272 5443* 2140 2091 5397* 5478*

104 4170 4080 1961 1901 5198* 5255*

105 5419* 5604* 2936 2925 5845* 5978*

106 4024 3956 2378 2335 5405* 5489*

107 5082 5218 3719 3757 5733* 5854*

108 4939 4989 1984 1925 5042 5081

109 4155 4035 3525 3549 4649 4649

110 4081 3947 3683 3715 5553* 5661*

111 4992 5041 3540 3576 5546* 5642*

112 4735 4785 2755 2743 4570 4547

113 5066 5190 3775 3825 4743 4741

114 3711 3501 2633 2616 3107 2917

115 3680 3553 3340 3366 3426 3265

116 4340 4243 2555 2533 4789 4802

117 4803 4866 3940* 3993* 4858 4869

118 5374* 5541* 2553 2528 4937 4960

119 4034 3909 3303 3326 4832 4842

120 3792 3673 2553 2528 4539 4514

121 4663 4619 2806 2793 4129 4064

122 4831 4894 3949* 3997* 4972 5001

123 4586 4555 2331 2295 4667 4659

124 2893 2617 2053 2002 4495 4464

125 4394 4376 2217 2170 3881 3776

126 4334 4258 4005* 4062* 4005 3917

127 5309 5471* 4082* 4144* 4453 4417

128 4730 4774 1981 1920 4296 4240

129 3867 3678 2174 2126 4796 4811

Page 17: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

17

130 4078 4005 3436 3455 4606 4590

131 4261 4249 3656 3701 4762 4761

132 3788 3630 2632 2619 4094 4015

133 4968 5070 1847 1786 4318 4263

134 4241 4214 3697 3737 4911 4931

135 4603 4564 2515 2492 4615 4606

136 3749 3584 2789 2785 4555 4531

137 4025 3957 3900* 3952* 4753 4751

138 4542 4569 2513 2487 5130* 5176*

139 5027 5154 2314 2284 4265 4204

140 4697 4676 3896* 3951* 5216* 5280*

141 4216 4132 4059* 4123* 5729* 5861*

142 4740 4841 2642 2632 4599 4585

143 4488 4481 3671 3717 4309 4262

144 5338 5485* 4034* 4100* 4982 5016

145 4407 4359 2764 2757 4947 4985

146 4614 4679 2943 2943 4041 3962

147 5349* 5560* 2958 2965 5863* 6002*

148 2931 2691 2491 2467 4119 4047

149 5571* 5808* 2570 2550 3812 3702

150 5377* 5581* 3078 3086 5780* 5911*

LSD 785.9 836.9 484.6 495.5 603.2 638.2

CV (%) 9.0 8.7 8.0 8.1 6.7 6.7

Genotype significance

** ** ** ** ** **

Page 18: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

18

Table 5. Yield (kg/ha) performance of 39th ESWYT lines over local checks in Sindh, Baluchistan and across locations

Entry NIA

LC: Benazir-13 QARI-Larkana

LC: T.D-1 ARI-Q

LC: Zardana BARDC. Quetta LC: Shalkot-14

Combined over locations results

BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 5878 5166 3909 4380 1053 975 1920 1793 3497 3293

102 6984* 6951* 3835 3403 894 757 2025 2022 3761 3733

103 6776 6532* 3913 4435 902 788 2052 2046 3836 3856*

104 7571* 7738* 3903 4301 1048 974 1869 1655 3952* 4050*

105 7307* 7276* 3910 4400 1233 1204 1963 1888 3996* 4118*

106 7327* 7458* 3911 4410 1362 1353 1919 1789 3754 3722

107 7713* 7915* 3826 3280 1413* 1440* 1907 1728 4063* 4231*

108 7264* 7285* 3832 3362 1153 1108 1870 1657 4117* 4323*

109 7046* 6937* 3956 5002 1083 1014 2038 1992 3716 3652

110 6628 6320 3759 2398 1070 997 2159 2259 3654 3550

111 7405* 7485* 3885 4063 977 924 2110 2257 4152* 4381*

112 7005* 6823* 3829 3329 1446* 1518* 2041 2131 3712 3649

113 6174 5636 3892 4157 1501* 1593* 1911 1807 4029* 4175*

114 6035 5437 4041 6131 1835* 2014* 1829 1605 3548 3375

115 6122 5559 3820 3202 1612* 1734* 1892 1765 3607 3477

116 7374* 7414* 3912 4419 1232 1244 2122 2250 3637 3522

117 7439* 7463* 3909 4383 1405 1464* 2112 2288 3847 3872*

118 7714* 8021* 3902 4294 1329 1353 2158 2384* 4150* 4376*

119 6942* 6802* 3903 4307 1388 1449* 2204 2464* 3967* 4076*

120 7657* 7938* 3909 4379 1106 1068 2046 2139 3754 3723

121 7538* 7696* 3906 4346 1222 1200 1842 1611 3883 3925*

122 7609* 7907* 3912 4422 1489* 1525* 1841 1666 4153* 4377*

123 7068* 7028* 3829 3318 1312 1320 1952 1888 3612 3485

124 7302* 7342* 3830 3339 1257 1250 2089 2178 3471 3250

125 6388 5953 3825 3268 1078 1016 2165 2383* 3590 3443

126 6154 5678 3920 4531 1652* 1753* 2231 2502* 3745 3705

127 7433* 7535* 3913 4437 1120 1075 2078 2153 4057* 4217*

128 6948* 6779* 3823 3239 1324 1329 2075 2185 3890 3940*

Page 19: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

19

129 7224* 7233* 3833 3378 996 912 1951 1852 3582 3427

130 7212* 7321* 3893 4177 1410 1424* 2016 2050 3752 3715

131 7638* 7924* 3881 4007 1069 1015 2008 1974 3696 3621

132 7025* 7050* 3904 4323 1323 1339 2108 2207 3682 3601

133 7349* 7458* 3753 2312 1273 1270 2101 2217 4076* 4247*

134 7462* 7777* 3773 2578 1726* 1833* 2116 2246 3833 3849*

135 7398* 7575* 3887 4087 1684* 1795* 2030 1999 3785 3765

136 7167* 7260* 3913 4432 1569* 1653* 1926 1806 3775 3755

137 6981* 6915* 3832 3362 1099 1049 1972 1933 3748 3705

138 7482* 7806* 3757 2364 1056 979 2028 2053 3678 3593

139 7293* 7414* 3834 3395 1024 958 1844 1613 3707 3640

140 7242* 7345* 3920 4531 1306 1313 1869 1646 3927* 3999*

141 7003* 6975* 3848 3571 1612* 1699* 2034 2039 3869 3903*

142 6850* 6744* 3913 4433 1619* 1713* 2276 2594* 3669 3578

143 7463* 7680* 3909 4390 1649* 1751* 2039 2084 3882 3933*

144 7483* 7710* 3888 4110 1170 1140 1821 1604 3880 3929*

145 7296* 7408* 3839 3453 1050 982 1902 1747 3748 3704

146 7415* 7689* 3833 3375 1354 1354 2066 2166 3640 3532

147 7728* 8040* 3841 3477 1283 1284 1957 1891 4014* 4148*

148 6941* 6838* 3833 3375 1191 1162 2013 2053 3392 3118

149 7483* 7638* 3836 3410 966 875 2038 2107 4011* 4141*

150 6984* 7053* 3884 4050 1357 1358 2123 2291 3957* 4055*

LSD 963.2 1192.4 541.5 1971.4 358.8 405.4 370.3 570.8 429.8 550.8

CV (%) 7.8 7.8 25.3 25.3 15.4 15.7 13.2 13.2 12.9 12.9

Genotype significance ** ** NS NS ** ** * * ** **

Page 20: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

20

Table 6. Detail of Entries evaluated in 17th HTWYT Entry No.

Cross Name Selection History

1 LOCAL CHECK As given in Table 1

2 NADI

CMSS06B00734T-099TOPY-099ZTM-099Y-099M-13WGY-

0B

3 QUAIU #1/SUP152 CMSS08Y00057S-099Y-099M-099NJ-13WGY-0B

4 WBLL1*2/SHAMA//KACHU/3/PRL/6/SAUAL/4/CROC_1/AE.SQUA

RROSA (205)//KAUZ/3/ATTILA/5/SAUAL

CMSS10B00973T-099TOPY-099M-099NJ-099NJ-5WGY-

0B

5 MUTUS*2/KINGBIRD #1/3/KSW/SAUAL//SAUAL CMSS11B00495S-099M-099NJ-099NJ-11WGY-0M

6 KACHU #1/3/T.DICOCCON PI94624/AE.SQUARROSA

(409)//BCN/4/2*KACHU/5/MUTUS*2/TECUE #1 CMSS11B00600S-099M-099NJ-099NJ-16WGY-0M

7 BORL14//KFA/2*KACHU CMSS12Y00069S-099Y-099M-0SY-1M-0WGY

8 SUP152/BAJ #1//KFA/2*KACHU CMSS12Y00244S-099Y-099M-0SY-14M-0WGY

9 GRACK/CHYAK/6/ROLF07*2/5/FCT/3/GOV/AZ//MUS/4/DOVE/BU

C CMSS12Y00335S-099Y-099M-0SY-19M-0WGY

10 SUP152/BLOUK #1/3/PRL/2*PASTOR*2//VORB/4/SUP152/BLOUK

#1 CMSS12Y00707T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-33M-0WGY

11

ALTAR 84/AE.SQUARROSA

(221)//3*BORL95/3/URES/JUN//KAUZ/4/WBLL1/5/MUTUS/6/2*

BAJ #1/AKURI CMSS12Y00716T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-44M-0WGY

12 KSW/SAUAL//SAUAL/3/2*BORL14 CMSS12Y00732T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-11M-0WGY

13 BORL14*2//KFA/2*KACHU CMSS12Y00770T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-48M-0WGY

14 ROLF07*2/DIAMONDBIRD//TRCH/HUIRIVIS #1/3/BORL14 CMSS12Y00783T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-1M-0WGY

15 WBLL1*2/CHAPIO*2//MURGA/3/2*MISR 1 CMSS12Y00804T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-20M-0WGY

Page 21: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

21

16 KUTZ*2/5/UP2338*2/VIVITSI/3/FRET2/TUKURU//FRET2/4/MISR

1 CMSS12Y00813T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-1M-0WGY

17 KUTZ*2//KFA/2*KACHU CMSS12Y00814T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-20M-0WGY

18 WBLL1/4/BOW/NKT//CBRD/3/CBRD/5/WBLL1*2/TUKURU/6/2*B

ORL14 CMSS12Y00823T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-21M-0WGY

19 WBLL1*2/SHAMA//BAJ #1*2/3/BORL14 CMSS12Y00854T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-13M-0WGY

20 NADI/3/WBLL1*2/SHAMA//BAJ #1/4/NADI CMSS12Y00881T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-6M-0WGY

21 UP2338*2/SHAMA//2*BAJ #1/3/2*BORL14 CMSS12Y00883T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-23M-0WGY

22 BAJ #1/3/KIRITATI//ATTILA*2/PASTOR*2/4/MUTUS*2/TECUE #1 CMSS12Y00928T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-4M-0WGY

23 FRANCOLIN #1*2/HAWFINCH #1//2*MUCUY CMSS12Y00950T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-10M-0WGY

24

VILLA JUAREZ

F2009/6/ATTILA/3*BCN//BAV92/3/PASTOR/4/TACUPETO

F2001*2/BRAMBLING/5/PAURAQ CMSS12B00006S-099M-0SY-6M-0WGY

25 WBLL1/KUKUNA//TACUPETO F2001/3/BAJ #1/4/KACHU

#1/KIRITATI//KACHU CMSS12B00009S-099M-0SY-20M-0WGY

26 BORL14/4/BAJ #1/3/KIRITATI//ATTILA*2/PASTOR CMSS12B00044S-099M-0SY-20M-0WGY

27 FRANCOLIN

#1//WBLL1*2/KURUKU/3/WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING//CHYAK CMSS12B00091S-099M-0SY-6M-0WGY

28 KINGBIRD #1//INQALAB 91*2/TUKURU/3/BECARD/FRNCLN CMSS12B00105S-099M-0SY-40M-0WGY

29 SUP152/BAJ #1//KFA/2*KACHU CMSS12B00146S-099M-0SY-26M-0WGY

30 SUP152/BAJ #1//KFA/2*KACHU CMSS12B00146S-099M-0SY-37M-0WGY

31

SUP152/BAJ #1/7/ALTAR 84/AE.SQUARROSA

(221)//3*BORL95/3/URES/JUN//KAUZ/4/WBLL1/5/KACHU/6/KIRI

TATI//PBW65/2*SERI.1B CMSS12B00148S-099M-0SY-6M-0WGY

Page 22: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

22

32 SUP152/BAJ

#1/5/ATTILA/3*BCN*2//BAV92/3/KIRITATI/WBLL1/4/DANPHE CMSS12B00149S-099M-0SY-17M-0WGY

33 KAUZ*2/MNV//KAUZ/3/MILAN/4/BAV92/5/AKURI/6/MUTUS/7/F

RET2/TUKURU//FRET2/3/MUNAL #1 CMSS12B00226S-099M-0SY-20M-0WGY

34 WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING//VORB/FISCAL/3/BECARD/5/ATTILA/3*BC

N*2//BAV92/3/KIRITATI/WBLL1/4/DANPHE CMSS12B00262S-099M-0SY-11M-0WGY

35 WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING//VORB/FISCAL/3/BECARD/5/ATTILA/3*BC

N*2//BAV92/3/KIRITATI/WBLL1/4/DANPHE CMSS12B00262S-099M-0SY-17M-0WGY

36 BECARD/FRNCLN//BORL14 CMSS12B00282S-099M-0SY-19M-0WGY

37 KACHU/BECARD//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING/4/FRET2/TUKURU//FRE

T2/3/MUNAL #1 CMSS12B00312S-099M-0SY-12M-0WGY

38 KACHU/BECARD//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING/3/KACHU/KINDE CMSS12B00318S-099M-0SY-32M-0WGY

39 CIRO16/2*BORL14 CMSS12B00569T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-38M-0WGY

40 PRL/2*PASTOR//PBW343*2/KUKUNA/3/ROLF07*2/4/KFA/2*KAC

HU CMSS12B00607T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-10M-0WGY

41 BORL14*2//MUNAL #1/FRANCOLIN #1 CMSS12B00629T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-2M-0WGY

42 BORL14*2//KFA/2*KACHU CMSS12B00633T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-11M-0WGY

43 BORL14*2//KFA/2*KACHU CMSS12B00633T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-26M-0WGY

44 BORL14*2//BECARD/QUAIU #1 CMSS12B00634T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-26M-0WGY

45 COPIO*2/MUCUY CMSS12B00644T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-1M-0WGY

46 KACHU #1/KIRITATI//KACHU*2/3/BECARD/FRNCLN CMSS12B00647T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-17M-0WGY

47 KACHU//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING*2/3/KACHU/KIRITATI CMSS12B00801T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-33M-0WGY

48 ONIX/KBIRD//BORL14/3/ONIX/KBIRD CMSS12B00825T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-21M-0WGY

49 SUP152*2/HAWFINCH #1/3/2*KACHU #1/KIRITATI//KACHU CMSS12B00855T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-71M-0WGY

Page 23: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

23

50 BAJ #1/PAURAQ/3/KACHU #1/KIRITATI//KACHU/4/BAJ

#1*2/WHEAR CMSS12B00899T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-26M-0WGY

Page 24: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

24

Table 7. Yield (kg/ha) Performance of 17th HTWYT lines over local checks in Punjab

Entry AZRI Bhakkar

LC: Fakhr-e-Bhakkar Wheat Wide crosses

LC=Pakistan-13 RARI-BWP

LC: Jauhar-16 WRI-FSD

LC: Faisalabad-08

BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 2428 2638 2445 2507 2056 2057 3864 3837

2 2428 2856 2445 3079 3040* 3057* 4323* 4324*

3 2428 2610 2445 2471 2437* 2443* 5480* 5518*

4 2428 1516 2445 2736 2551* 2560* 3647 3624

5 2428 2033 2445 2207 2548* 2557* 4444* 4440*

6 2428 2168 2445 2479 2658* 2668* 4802* 4822*

7 2428 2589 2445 1971 2929* 2943* 4437* 4435*

8 2428 2266 2445 3586 3152* 3172* 6031* 6098*

9 2428 2510 2445 3023 744 723 4612* 4622*

10 2428 1927 2445 2573 2821* 2834* 4963* 4986*

11 2428 2443 2445 3355 2470* 2478* 4867* 4888*

12 2428 2627 2445 2126 2876* 2890* 4067 4046

13 2428 2328 2445 1740 2328 2333 4607* 4610*

14 2428 3208 2445 3142 2931* 2946* 4073 4061

15 2428 2286 2445 1790 1563 1555 4098 4081

16 2428 2041 2445 3642 2220 2224 4173 4164

17 2428 3689 2445 2526 2877* 2891* 3640 3603

18 2428 3699 2445 2248 2330 2336 4278* 4276*

19 2428 2463 2445 3655 2442* 2450* 4615* 4626*

20 2428 2241 2445 1698 2221 2224 4437* 4440*

21 2428 2702 2445 1953 1558 1546 5675* 5717*

22 2428 2298 2445 2459 574 547 4271* 4263*

23 2428 1770 2445 3066 1670 1661 5473* 5511*

24 2428 1927 2445 2101 2321 2322 4033 4008

25 2428 2142 2445 2737 1285 1269 4024 3996

26 2428 2166 2445 1966 959 938 4324* 4318*

27 2428 2239 2445 1151 2540* 2544* 3451 3404

28 2428 2788 2445 1737 2541* 2546* 4168 4146

29 2428 2932 2445 2953 2924* 2935* 3742 3711

Page 25: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

25

30 2428 2381 2445 1859 2979* 2991* 4169 4157

31 2428 2810 2445 1827 1401 1388 4603* 4602*

32 2428 2445 2445 3042 1132 1116 4438* 4439*

33 2428 2484 2445 2862 746 723 4330* 4315*

34 2428 2639 2445 2735 856 834 4215* 4206*

35 2428 3002 2445 3528 1402 1390 3481 3442

36 2428 1987 2445 2442 585 560 5545* 5587*

37 2428 2296 2445 1312 856 834 4611* 4607*

38 2428 2264 2445 2185 965 946 3632 3601

39 2428 2206 2445 2277 1237 1221 4608* 4607*

40 2428 1898 2445 2228 1566 1556 5082* 5104*

41 2428 2122 2445 1200 1619 1612 6159* 6231*

42 2428 2368 2445 2098 2437* 2444* 4308* 4305*

43 2428 2190 2445 1563 2605* 2616* 4504* 4517*

44 2428 2295 2445 2213 2770* 2783* 5056* 5089*

45 2428 2289 2445 2100 2766* 2778* 4376* 4380*

46 2428 2947 2445 2906 2931* 2946* 3627 3605

47 2428 2222 2445 2748 2437* 2444* 4568* 4575*

48 2428 2271 2445 3433 2467* 2474* 4958* 4977*

49 2428 2479 2445 2633 2439* 2446* 4452* 4452*

50 2428 2718 2445 2356 2712* 2724* 3788 3773

LSD 0.0 1218.0 0.0 1945.4 287.3 289.1 348.9 354.7

CV (%) 23.4 23.4 36.7 38.1 6.8 6.8 3.9 3.9

Genotype significance NS NS NS NS ** ** ** **

Page 26: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

26

Table 8. Yield (kg/ha) Performance of 17th HTWYT lines over local checks in KP, Sindh and across locations

Entry ARI.D.I Khan

LC: Israr Shaheed-17 WRI-SKD

LC: Benazir-13 QARI-Larkana

LC: T.D-1

Combined over locations results

BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 3093 2590 4244 3600 4379 4617 3473 3272

2 3224 3163 4244 3250 4402 4734 3564 3816

3 3280 3523 4244 4035 4405 4714 3600 4042

4 3212 3169 4244 2688 4299 4468 3499 3436

5 3183 3009 4244 3452 4359 4553 3534 3637

6 3405 4003* 4244 4273 4451 4888 3610 4092*

7 3390 4032* 4244 4374 4323 4458 3586 3959

8 3230 3252 4244 4331 4123 3919 3609 4091*

9 3232 3194 4244 4235 4345 4557 3473 3273

10 3326 3630 4244 4080 4381 4670 3599 4029

11 3191 3040 4244 4483 4349 4546 3549 3727

12 3180 2960 4244 3853 3993 3329 3481 3312

13 3303 3595 4244 3746 4243 4128 3538 3667

14 3191 2971 4244 3327 4287 4297 3524 3576

15 3217 3198 4244 4174 4396 4607 3487 3361

16 3151 2788 4244 4321 4333 4440 3497 3411

17 3390 3937* 4244 4633 4280 4227 3540 3670

18 3160 2834 4244 4264 4254 4196 3498 3415

19 3182 2997 4244 4090 4516 5070 3557 3775

20 3288 3431 4244 5109 4274 4258 3528 3593

21 3282 3378 4244 3908 4308 4381 3557 3767

22 3195 2984 4244 4804 4006 3437 3399 2816

23 3363 3823* 4244 4582 4303 4419 3570 3846

24 3223 3211 4244 5256 4076 3624 3477 3295

25 3095 2550 4244 3685 4318 4366 3439 3054

26 3161 2886 4244 3838 4505 5051 3477 3291

27 3345 3777* 4244 4432 4329 4417 3518 3540

28 3245 3247 4244 4338 4383 4567 3536 3635

Page 27: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

27

29 3257 3261 4244 4849 4192 4019 3511 3492

30 3198 2998 4244 4953 4356 4531 3543 3677

31 3204 3138 4244 4809 4219 4084 3481 3307

32 3328 3676* 4244 3492 4113 3839 3474 3260

33 3286 3457 4244 4030 3989 3347 3427 2969

34 3274 3368 4244 3250 4391 4654 3478 3274

35 3252 3258 4244 3884 4314 4413 3454 3137

36 3129 2753 4244 5004 4243 4247 3477 3279

37 3265 3358 4244 4732 3967 3279 3437 3028

38 3187 2961 4244 4809 4128 3831 3406 2843

39 3374 3928* 4244 4422 4297 4330 3518 3525

40 3272 3348 4244 4718 4189 4021 3518 3518

41 3082 2453 4244 4879 4321 4454 3543 3689

42 3098 2630 4244 3113 4179 3977 3483 3333

43 3138 2778 4244 4702 4219 4190 3512 3509

44 3406 4025* 4244 2607 4193 4107 3592 3984

45 3209 3040 4244 6016* 4343 4521 3542 3681

46 3244 3209 4244 3578 3970 3355 3475 3277

47 3383 3953* 4244 4941 4398 4664 3578 3903

48 3281 3416 4244 4596 4404 4664 3576 3882

49 3205 3062 4244 4899 4043 3535 3491 3373

50 3134 2699 4244 4781 4299 4384 3495 3393

LSD 477.7 1049.8 0.0 2393.3 577.0 1013.5 326.2 801.8

CV (%) 15.7 16.0 25.2 27.5 11.9 11.5 10.6 10.7

Genotype significance NS NS NS NS NS NS NS NS

Page 28: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

28

Table 9. Detail of entries evaluated in 9th HPYT Entry No.

Cross Name Selection History

401 LOCAL CHECK As given in Table 1

402 KACHU #1

CMSS97M03912T-040Y-020Y-030M-020Y-040M-4Y-2M-

0Y

403 MAYIL CMSS08Y01129T-099M-099Y-3M-0Y-5M-0Y

404 ZINCSHAKTHI CMSA06M00195T-099Y-099Y-9M-0Y-7B-0Y

405 DANPHE #1*2/SOLALA//BORL14 CMSS13B00868S-099M-099Y-18M-0WGY

406 DANPHE #1*2/SOLALA//BORL14 CMSS13B00868S-099M-099Y-25M-0WGY

407 VALI//KACHU/KIRITATI CMSS13B00880S-099M-099Y-5M-0WGY

408 MANKU//MUTUS*2/TECUE #1 CMSS13B00893S-099M-099Y-29M-0WGY

409

VILLA JUAREZ F2009/3/T.DICOCCON PI94625/AE.SQUARROSA

(372)//3*PASTOR/4/WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING/5/WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING//Q

UAIU CMSS13B00898S-099M-099Y-17M-0WGY

410

FRANCOLIN #1/3/IWA

8600211//2*PBW343*2/KUKUNA/7/TRAP#1/BOW/3/VEE/PJN//2*TUI/4/

BAV92/RAYON/5/KACHU #1/6/TOBA97/PASTOR/3/T.DICOCCON

PI94624/AE.SQUARROSA (409)//BCN/4/BL

1496/MILAN/3/CROC_1/AE.SQUARROSA (205)//KAUZ CMSS13B00948S-099M-099Y-22M-0WGY

411

C80.1/3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1/3/ATTILA/3*BCN*2//BAV92/4/WBLL1*2/K

URUKU/5/IWA

8600211//2*PBW343*2/KUKUNA/7/TRAP#1/BOW/3/VEE/PJN//2*TUI/4/

BAV92/RAYON/5/KACHU #1/6/TOBA97/PASTOR/3/T.DICOCCON

PI94624/AE.SQUARROSA (409)//BCN/4/BL

1496/MILAN/3/CROC_1/AE.SQUARRO CMSS13B00984S-099M-099Y-8M-0WGY

412 C80.1/3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1/3/ATTILA/3*BCN*2//BAV92/4/WBLL1*2/K

URUKU/5/IWA 8600211//2*PBW343*2/KUKUNA/6/MUCUY CMSS13B00989S-099M-099Y-13M-0WGY

Page 29: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

29

413 C80.1/3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1/3/ATTILA/3*BCN*2//BAV92/4/WBLL1*2/K

URUKU/5/IWA 8600211//2*PBW343*2/KUKUNA/6/MUCUY CMSS13B00989S-099M-099Y-17M-0WGY

414

TRAP#1/BOW/3/VEE/PJN//2*TUI/4/BAV92/RAYON/5/KACHU

#1/6/TOBA97/PASTOR/3/T.DICOCCON PI94624/AE.SQUARROSA

(409)//BCN/4/BL 1496/MILAN/3/CROC_1/AE.SQUARROSA

(205)//KAUZ/7/FRNCLN/3/ND643//2*PRL/2*PASTOR/4/FRANCOLIN #1 CMSS13B01010S-099M-099Y-26M-0WGY

415 ROLF07*2/KIRITATI/3/IWA 8600211//2*PBW343*2/KUKUNA/4/MANKU CMSS13B01018S-099M-099Y-22M-0WGY

416 SHAKTI/2*BORL14 CMSS13B01796T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-6M-0WGY

417 SHAKTI/2*BORL14 CMSS13B01796T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-16M-0WGY

418 SHAKTI/2*BORL14 CMSS13B01796T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-35M-0WGY

419 SHAKTI/2*MUCUY CMSS13B01802T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-17M-0WGY

420 SHAKTI/6/KAUZ//ALTAR 84/AOS/3/PASTOR/4/873.97/5/MUNAL

#1/7/FRET2*2/SHAMA//KIRITATI/2*TRCH/3/BAJ #1 CMSS13B01835T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-19M-0WGY

421 SHAKTI/7/SERI.1B*2/3/KAUZ*2/BOW//KAUZ/4/KRONSTAD

F2004/5/MUNAL/6/MUNAL #1/8/MP4010/MUNAL #1 CMSS13B01842T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-29M-0WGY

422 SHAKTI/5/WHEAR/KIRITATI/3/C80.1/3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1*2/4/KIRITATI

/2*TRCH/6/BECARD//KIRITATI/2*TRCH/3/BECARD CMSS13B01843T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-12M-0WGY

423

KATERE/MUCUY/7/TRAP#1/BOW/3/VEE/PJN//2*TUI/4/BAV92/RAYON/5

/KACHU #1/6/TOBA97/PASTOR/3/T.DICOCCON PI94624/AE.SQUARROSA

(409)//BCN/4/BL 1496/MILAN/3/CROC_1/AE.SQUARROSA (205)//KAUZ CMSS13B01852T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-4M-0WGY

424

KATERE/MUCUY/7/TRAP#1/BOW/3/VEE/PJN//2*TUI/4/BAV92/RAYON/5

/KACHU #1/6/TOBA97/PASTOR/3/T.DICOCCON PI94624/AE.SQUARROSA

(409)//BCN/4/BL 1496/MILAN/3/CROC_1/AE.SQUARROSA (205)//KAUZ CMSS13B01852T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-22M-0WGY

425

KATERE//ONIX/KBIRD/6/C80.1/3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1/3/ATTILA/3*BCN*

2//BAV92/4/WBLL1*2/KURUKU/5/IWA

8600211//2*PBW343*2/KUKUNA CMSS13B01854T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-8M-0WGY

Page 30: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

30

426

ZINCOL//BECARD/QUAIU #1/7/INQALAB

91*2/TUKURU//WHEAR/6/BAV92//IRENA/KAUZ/3/HUITES/4/T.SPELTA

PI348764/5/BAV92//IRENA/KAUZ/3/HUITES CMSS13B01862T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-17M-0WGY

427

DANPHE #1*2/3/T.DICOCCON PI94625/AE.SQUARROSA

(372)//SHA4/CHIL/4/PBW343*2/KUKUNA//PARUS/3/PBW343*2/KUKUN

A/5/MAYIL CMSS13B01878T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-8M-0WGY

428

HGO94.7.1.12//WBLL1*2/KUKUNA/3/WBLL1*2/KURUKU/4/PBW343*2/K

UKUNA*2//FRTL/PIFED/6/C80.1/3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1/3/ATTILA/3*BCN

*2//BAV92/4/WBLL1*2/KURUKU/5/IWA

8600211//2*PBW343*2/KUKUNA CMSS13B01895T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-3M-0WGY

429

VALI/3/MUTUS*2//ND643/2*WBLL1/6/C80.1/3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1/3/

ATTILA/3*BCN*2//BAV92/4/WBLL1*2/KURUKU/5/IWA

8600211//2*PBW343*2/KUKUNA CMSS13B01911T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-5M-0WGY

430

WHEAR/KUKUNA/3/C80.1/3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1/4/T.DICOCCON

PI94625/AE.SQUARROSA

(372)//SHA4/CHIL/5/WHEAR/KUKUNA/3/C80.1/3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1/6

/VILLA JUAREZ F2009/3/T.DICOCCON PI94625/AE.SQUARROSA

(372)//3*PASTOR/4/WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING/7/TRAP#1/BOW/3/VEE/PJN/

/2* CMSS13B01913T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-23M-0WGY

431 QUAIU #1/SOLALA//QUAIU #2/3/MANKU/4/KACHU #1/KIRITATI//KACHU CMSS13B01918T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-5M-0WGY

432

KOKILA/3/MUTUS*2//ND643/2*WBLL1/8/PSN/BOW//SERI/3/MILAN/4/A

TTILA/5/KAUZ*2/CHEN//BCN/3/MILAN/6/WBLL1*2/SHAMA/7/IWA

8600211//2*PBW343*2/KUKUNA CMSS13B01939T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-16M-0WGY

433

KIRITATI/4/2*SERI.1B*2/3/KAUZ*2/BOW//KAUZ/5/CMH81.530/6/WHEA

R/KIRITATI/3/C80.1/3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1/4/CMH75A.66/SERI/7/VILLA

JUAREZ F2009/3/T.DICOCCON PI94625/AE.SQUARROSA

(372)//3*PASTOR/4/WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING CMSS13B01941T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-4M-0WGY

434 WHEAR/KIRITATI/3/C80.1/3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1/4/CMH75A.66/SERI/5/

HUW234+LR34/PRINIA//PFAU/WEAVER/3/CMH83.30/6/KACHU/DANPHE CMSS13B01946T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-1M-0WGY

Page 31: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

31

435 DANPHE #1*2/3/T.DICOCCON PI94625/AE.SQUARROSA

(372)//SHA4/CHIL/4/MANKU CMSS13Y00823S-099Y-099M-099Y-36M-0WGY

436

WHEAR/KUKUNA/3/C80.1/3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1/4/T.DICOCCON

PI94625/AE.SQUARROSA

(372)//SHA4/CHIL/5/WHEAR/KUKUNA/3/C80.1/3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1/6

/MUU/FRNCLN//FRANCOLIN #1 CMSS13Y00867S-099Y-099M-099Y-13M-0WGY

437 MANKU/6/WHEAR/KUKUNA/3/C80.1/3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1/5/PRL/2*P

ASTOR/4/CHOIX/STAR/3/HE1/3*CNO79//2*SERI CMSS13Y00884S-099Y-099M-099Y-8M-0WGY

438

VILLA JUAREZ F2009/3/T.DICOCCON PI94625/AE.SQUARROSA

(372)//3*PASTOR/4/WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING/5/WHEAR/KIRITATI/3/C80.1/

3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1*2/4/KIRITATI/2*TRCH CMSS13Y00894S-099Y-099M-099Y-34M-0WGY

439 VALI/5/2*VILLA JUAREZ F2009/3/T.DICOCCON PI94625/AE.SQUARROSA

(372)//3*PASTOR/4/WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING

CMSS13Y01564T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099Y-18M-

0WGY

440 QUAIU #1/3/T.DICOCCON PI94625/AE.SQUARROSA

(372)//3*PASTOR/4/QUAIU #2*2/5/SUP152/BECARD

CMSS13Y01584T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099Y-16M-

0WGY

441 MAYIL/2*VALI

CMSS13Y01585T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099Y-8M-

0WGY

442 MAYIL/2*VALI

CMSS13Y01585T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099Y-13M-

0WGY

443 MAYIL*2//SUP152*2/TECUE #1

CMSS13Y01587T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099Y-54M-

0WGY

444

VILLA JUAREZ F2009/3/T.DICOCCON PI94625/AE.SQUARROSA

(372)//3*PASTOR/4/WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING*2/5/KVZ/PPR47.89C//TACUP

ETO F2001*2/BRAMBLING/3/2*TACUPETO F2001*2/BRAMBLING

CMSS13Y01615T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099Y-55M-

0WGY

445 KOKILA/2*VALI

CMSS13Y01619T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099Y-7M-

0WGY

Page 32: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

32

446 SHAKTI/2*KUTZ

CMSS13Y01627T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099Y-16M-

0WGY

447 ZINCOL/5/2*QUAIU #1/3/T.DICOCCON PI94625/AE.SQUARROSA

(372)//3*PASTOR/4/QUAIU #2

CMSS13Y01630T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099Y-13M-

0WGY

448

WHEAR/KIRITATI/3/C80.1/3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1/4/CMH75A.66/SERI/5/

2*VILLA JUAREZ F2009/3/T.DICOCCON PI94625/AE.SQUARROSA

(372)//3*PASTOR/4/WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING

CMSS13Y01643T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099Y-1M-

0WGY

449 PAURAQ//RL6043/4*NAC/3/2*QUAIU #1/SOLALA//QUAIU #2

CMSS13Y01652T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099Y-3M-

0WGY

450 PAURAQ//AG/5*NAC/3/2*QUAIU #1/SOLALA//QUAIU #2

CMSS13Y01654T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099Y-23M-

0WGY

Page 33: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

33

Table 10. Yield (kg/ha) performance of 9th HPYT lines over local checks in Punjab

Entry BARI Chakwal LC: Ihsan-16

NARC LC: Borlaug-16

RARI-BWP LC: Jauhar-16

WRI-FSD LC: Galaxy-13

BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 3267 3122 4459 4599 3131 3083 3888 3594

402 5241* 5194* 4350 4415 4185* 4250* 4027 3704

403 7311* 7367* 4757 5116 3507 3500 4760* 4963*

404 6088* 6083* 3702 3479 3206 3166 3880 3569

405 5786* 5766* 4356 4449 3582 3583 4360 4329

406 6104* 6100* 3701 3472 3432 3416 4448 4361

407 6919* 6955* 4338 4508 2152 2000 4270 4200

408 6305* 6311* 3396 3035 2829 2750 3851 3524

409 6612* 6633* 4776 5053 3507 3500 4517 4609*

410 5887* 5872* 4153 4148 3055 3000 4446 4498*

411 4971* 4911* 4228 4233 3808 3833 4162 4071

412 6512* 6528* 4096 4062 4034* 4083* 4599* 4763*

413 7072* 7116* 4107 4161 4561* 4666* 4394 4454*

414 6612* 6633* 4372 4456 2829 2750 4376 4451*

415 5791* 5772* 4065 4100 2848 2771 4198 4149

416 7067* 7111* 4077 4027 4335* 4416* 4661* 4895*

417 4177* 4078* 3517 3220 3206 3166 4339 4359

418 4272* 4177* 4028 3937 2829 2750 3973 3682

419 5966* 5955* 4862 5154 1850 1666 4756* 4996*

420 7036* 7078* 4011 3912 4335* 4416* 4382 4320

421 5818* 5800* 3429 3060 2001 1833 4303 4292

422 6406* 6417* 3133 2611 5390* 5583* 4048 3754

423 5939* 5927* 4096 4015 2076 1916 4398 4392

424 6183* 6183* 4475 4671 2980 2916 4379 4385

425 6512* 6528* 4268 4286 3883 3916 4186 4074

426 7713* 7789* 4282 4286 2679 2583 3687 3285

427 7316* 7372* 4626 4890 4862* 5000* 4642* 4795*

428 6908* 6944* 3579 3284 3657 3666 4162 4037

Page 34: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

34

429 6728* 6755* 4117 4059 3507 3500 4176 4094

430 5982* 5972* 4224 4196 4335* 4416* 4383 4275

431 6236* 6238* 4551 4791 3131 3083 4510 4630*

432 7025* 7066* 4099 4030 2152 2000 4529 4637*

433 6395* 6405* 3898 3758 4411* 4500* 4511 4621*

434 7030* 7072* 4234 4221 5013* 5166* 4155 3960

435 5908* 5894* 4111 4061 2754 2666 4383 4456*

436 5728* 5706* 3735 3502 3357 3333 4266 4227

437 5342* 5300* 3714 3491 2980 2916 4188 4117

438 5501* 5467* 4079 3996 5164* 5333* 3948 3638

439 6210* 6211* 4520 4746 2867 2792 4329 4347

440 6564* 6583* 4041 3959 3357 3333 4567* 4744*

441 5760* 5739* 4216 4274 4486* 4583* 4808* 5196*

442 5998* 5989* 4327 4526 3281 3250 4796* 5153*

443 5971* 5961* 4302 4385 2829 2750 5137* 5663*

444 6162* 6161* 4483 4648 2980 2916 4070 4001

445 5432* 5394* 4053 4036 5916* 6166* 4181 4220

446 7449* 7511* 4696 4952 3657 3666 4623* 4769*

447 7120* 7167* 4484 4754 4636* 4750* 4245 4295

448 6993* 7033* 4885 5253 4486* 4583* 4790* 5134*

449 6839* 6872* 3913 3840 5164* 5333* 4176 4177

450 5400* 5361* 3704 3510 3657 3666 4368 4371

LSD 547.2 560.6 777.2 932.7 873.1 918.5 643.1 817.6

CV (%) 4.5 4.5 10.8 10.6 12.8 12.8 8.9 9.1

Genotype significance ** ** ** ** ** ** ** **

Page 35: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

35

Table 11. Yield (kg/ha) performance of 9th HPYT lines over local checks in KP, Sindh and across locations

CCRI

LC: Khaista-17 ARS-Swabi

LC: Paseena-17 WRI-Sakrand

LC: Benazir-13

Combined over locations results

Entry BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 4137 4062 2276 2279 4637 4784 3924 3636

402 3329 2842 1553 1543 4547 4470 3983 3771

403 4052 4044 4742* 4791* 4579 4591 4483* 4914*

404 3717 3500 1326 1311 4369 3744 3897 3578

405 3522 3125 1384 1371 4238 3356 3953 3701

406 3752 3485 2584 2593 4545 4464 4076 3981

407 3914 3834 1933 1929 4553 4496 4076 3993

408 3377 2982 1886 1882 4465 4089 3880 3539

409 4660 4877 4506* 4551* 4558 4546 4457 4850*

410 4241 4239 1669 1661 4255 3463 4022 3866

411 4324 4522 1825 1819 4417 4016 4053 3931

412 4183 4230 1219 1202 4661 4973 4191 4240

413 3952 3991 1143 1125 4477 4327 4191 4255

414 3823 3701 1371 1357 4511 4479 4076 3989

415 4631 5024 1900 1896 4572 4667 4099 4046

416 4003 3975 1977 1975 4601 4801 4289 4471*

417 3874 3760 1264 1248 4547 4562 3847 3462

418 4549 4797 1264 1248 4826 5569 3961 3722

419 4127 4223 2311 2315 4616 4730 4156 4165

420 4294 4408 1973 1971 4325 3778 4196 4254

421 3028 2428 989 968 4901 5912 3851 3482

422 3510 3151 1382 1368 4488 4401 4030 3880

423 4040 4026 1131 1112 4317 3699 3904 3598

424 4192 4292 2125 2125 4532 4564 4144 4151

425 3956 3821 1853 1848 4736 5281 4184 4226

426 5016* 5511* 3602* 3630* 4458 4205 4296 4484*

427 4077 4116 1470 1458 4855 5719 4411 4753*

428 3942 3799 1973 1971 4642 4942 4113 4067

429 3993 3897 1958 1955 4298 3758 4086 4014

430 4004 3903 1996 1994 4295 3711 4104 4049

Page 36: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

36

431 4838 5346* 3931* 3965* 4143 3143 4271 4443*

432 4499 4795 5822* 5891* 4639 4826 4416 4761*

433 3928 3849 1355 1340 4648 4937 4159 4174

434 3752 3591 1127 1108 4598 4766 4190 4249

435 4333 4485 1586 1576 4929 5986 4153 4170

436 4154 4271 1373 1359 4292 3582 3957 3723

437 3552 3277 1996 1994 4578 4687 3930 3656

438 4241 4335 1552 1541 4407 4082 4096 4036

439 4518 4860 4575* 4621* 4517 4482 4326 4567*

440 4143 4195 4765* 4815* 4568 4694 4355 4627*

441 3549 3270 1181 1164 4602 4885 4156 4184

442 4395 4650 2153 2154 4483 4429 4210 4309

443 4302 4475 3399* 3423* 4502 4404 4283 4464*

444 4424 4660 2184 2186 4562 4618 4164 4197

445 4258 4348 2171 2172 4900 5951 4357 4637*

446 4335 4457 2461 2468 4689 5160 4391 4707*

447 4457 4744 1735 1728 4653 5037 4356 4641*

448 4432 4595 2004 2002 4436 4248 4380 4681*

449 3560 3267 1095 1076 4454 4313 4129 4113

450 3818 3670 1357 1343 4542 4636 3985 3789

LSD 862.2 1061.8 436.7 440.8 808.8 1572.4 533.7 804.6

CV (%) 12.5 12.4 10.3 10.3 16.6 16.9 11.3 11.3

Genotype significance ** ** ** ** NS NS ** **

Page 37: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

37

Table 12. Detail of entries evaluated in 26th SAWYT lines Entry No. Cross Name Selection History

301 LOCAL CHECK As given in Table 1

302 FITIS

CMSS06Y00878T-099TOPM-099Y-099ZTM-099Y-

099M-18WGY-0B

303 SHORTENED SR26 TRANSLOCATION//2*WBLL1*2/KKTS/3/BECARD

CMSS08Y01115T-099M-099Y-099M-099NJ-14WGY-

0B

304 SOKOLL/3/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU*2/6/OASIS/5*BORL95/5/CNDO/

R143//ENTE/MEXI75/3/AE.SQ/4/2*OCI

CMSA10M00159T-050Y-099ZTM-099NJ-099NJ-

5WGY-0B

305 WHEAR/KUKUNA/3/C80.1/3*BATAVIA//2*WBLL1/4/QUAIU/5/BORL14 CMSS11B00520S-099M-099NJ-099NJ-31WGY-0M

306 BORL14/FITIS CMSS12Y00064S-099Y-099M-0SY-27M-0WGY

307 FITIS/3/KACHU #1/KIRITATI//KACHU CMSS12Y00107S-099Y-099M-0SY-58M-0WGY

308

FRANCOLIN

#1//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING/6/WBLL1*2/KURUKU*2/5/REH/HARE//2*B

CN/3/CROC_1/AE.SQUARROSA (213)//PGO/4/HUITES/7/FRANCOLIN

#1/WBLL1

CMSS12Y00710T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-40M-

0WGY

309 BORL14*2//MUNAL #1/FRANCOLIN #1

CMSS12Y00771T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-3M-

0WGY

310

PF74354//LD/ALD/4/2*BR12*2/3/JUP//PAR214*6/FB6631/5/NL750/6

/PVN/7/TOBA97/PASTOR/8/CNO79//PF70354/MUS/3/PASTOR/4/BAV

92*2/5/HAR311/9/CNO79//PF70354/MUS/3/PASTOR/4/BAV92*2/5/H

AR311

CMSS12Y00791T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-48M-

0WGY

311

WBLL1/FRET2//PASTOR*2/3/MURGA/6/KSW/5/2*ALTAR

84/AE.SQUARROSA

(221)//3*BORL95/3/URES/JUN//KAUZ/4/WBLL1/7/KFA/2*KACHU

CMSS12Y00808T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-15M-

0WGY

312

KSW/5/2*ALTAR 84/AE.SQUARROSA

(221)//3*BORL95/3/URES/JUN//KAUZ/4/WBLL1/6/KACHU

#1/KIRITATI//KACHU/7/KUTZ

CMSS12Y00902T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-7M-

0WGY

Page 38: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

38

313 SUP152/BAJ #1//TRCH/HUIRIVIS #1/3/SUP152/BAJ #1

CMSS12Y00918T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-8M-

0WGY

314 SUP152/BAJ #1/4/BAJ

#1/3/KIRITATI//ATTILA*2/PASTOR/5/SUP152/BAJ #1

CMSS12Y00919T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-13M-

0WGY

315 WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING/3/2*BORL14

CMSS12Y00929T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-14M-

0WGY

316 INIA CHURRINCHE/KIRITATI*2//KFA/2*KACHU

CMSS12Y01129T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-0SY-25M-

0WGY

317 PRL/2*PASTOR//PBW343*2/KUKUNA/3/ROLF07/4/MUTUS*2/TECUE

#1 CMSS12B00028S-099M-0SY-23M-0WGY

318 MUTUS/AKURI//SUP152/BAJ #1 CMSS12B00100S-099M-0SY-33M-0WGY

319 SUP152/BAJ #1//KFA/2*KACHU CMSS12B00146S-099M-0SY-10M-0WGY

320 SUP152*2/TECUE #1//SUP152/BAJ #1 CMSS12B00235S-099M-0SY-9M-0WGY

321 BECARD/FRNCLN//BORL14 CMSS12B00282S-099M-0SY-20M-0WGY

322 KACHU/BECARD//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING/3/KACHU/KINDE CMSS12B00318S-099M-0SY-9M-0WGY

323 WORRAKATTA/2*PASTOR/6/KAUZ/5/PAT10/ALD//PAT72300/3/PVN/4

/BOW/7/BAJ #1/3/KIRITATI//ATTILA*2/PASTOR CMSS12B00481S-099M-0SY-18M-0WGY

324 CIRO16/2*BORL14 CMSS12B00569T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-26M-0WGY

325 BORL14*2//MUNAL #1/FRANCOLIN #1 CMSS12B00629T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-15M-0WGY

326 BORL14*2//MUNAL #1/FRANCOLIN #1 CMSS12B00629T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-29M-0WGY

327 BORL14*2/3/KBIRD//WBLL1*2/KURUKU CMSS12B00630T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-24M-0WGY

328 BORL14*2/3/WBLL1*2/TUKURU//CROSBILL #1 CMSS12B00631T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-4M-0WGY

329 BORL14*2//KFA/2*KACHU CMSS12B00633T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-3M-0WGY

330 BORL14*2//KFA/2*KACHU CMSS12B00633T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-5M-0WGY

Page 39: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

39

331 BORL14*2//KFA/2*KACHU CMSS12B00633T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-29M-0WGY

332 BORL14*2//BECARD/QUAIU #1 CMSS12B00634T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-25M-0WGY

333 BORL14*2/6/BABAX/LR42//BABAX*2/3/KUKUNA/4/CROSBILL

#1/5/BECARD CMSS12B00635T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-16M-0WGY

334 KACHU #1/KIRITATI//KACHU*2/3/GRACK/CHYAK CMSS12B00646T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-10M-0WGY

335 WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING/4/BABAX/LR42//BABAX*2/3/SHAMA*2/5/BEC

ARD/QUAIU #1 CMSS12B00714T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-18M-0WGY

336 WBLL1*2/SHAMA//BAJ #1*2/3/KACHU #1/KIRITATI//KACHU CMSS12B00720T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-11M-0WGY

337 MUTUS/AKURI*2//KFA/2*KACHU CMSS12B00746T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-9M-0WGY

338 NADI*2/3/MUTUS/AKURI #1//MUTUS CMSS12B00767T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-74M-0WGY

339

ALTAR 84/AE.SQUARROSA

(221)//3*BORL95/3/URES/JUN//KAUZ/4/WBLL1*2/5/REH/HARE//2*B

CN/3/CROC_1/AE.SQUARROSA (213)//PGO/4/HUITES*2/6/NADI CMSS12B00768T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-14M-0WGY

340 KACHU//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING*2/6/ROLF07*2/5/REH/HARE//2*BCN/

3/CROC_1/AE.SQUARROSA (213)//PGO/4/HUITES CMSS12B00800T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-32M-0WGY

341 KACHU//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING*2/3/KACHU/KIRITATI CMSS12B00801T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-59M-0WGY

342 ONIX/KBIRD//BORL14/3/ONIX/KBIRD CMSS12B00825T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-27M-0WGY

343

ATTILA/3*BCN//BAV92/3/TILHI/4/SUP152/5/SUP152/6/KFA/2*KACHU

/7/ATTILA/3*BCN//BAV92/3/PASTOR/4/TACUPETO

F2001*2/BRAMBLING/5/PAURAQ CMSS12B00841T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-29M-0WGY

344 KIRITATI/WBLL1//2*BLOUK #1*2/3/BECARD/QUAIU #1 CMSS12B00848T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-36M-0WGY

345 SUP152/AKURI//SUP152/3/MUCUY/4/MUTUS//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING

/3/WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING CMSS12B00860T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-46M-0WGY

346 KACHU/KINDE//NELOKI/3/BORL14 CMSS12B00887T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-14M-0WGY

Page 40: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

40

347 FRET2*2/BRAMBLING//BECARD/3/WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING*2/4/KACHU

/KINDE CMSS12B00943T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-17M-0WGY

348 BABAX/LR42//BABAX*2/3/KUKUNA/4/CROSBILL

#1/5/BECARD*2/6/KACHU/KIRITATI CMSS12B00995T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-19M-0WGY

349 BABAX/LR42//BABAX/3/ER2000*2/4/COPIO CMSS12B01042T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-14M-0WGY

350 MERCATO//JNRB.5/PIFED*2/3/SAUAL/YANAC//SAUAL CMSS12B01150T-099TOPY-099M-0SY-13M-0WGY

Page 41: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

41

Table 13. Yield (kg/ha) Performance of 26th SAWYT lines over local checks Punjab

AZRI Bhakkar

LC: Fakhr-e-Bhakkar BARI Chakwal LC: Ihsan-16

BARS FT. Jhang LC: Ft. Jhang-16

NARC LC: Borlaug-16

Entry BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 3570 2773 2543 2529 4983 4985 3987 3800

302 3570 3291 4154* 4145* 5633* 5659* 3894 3691

303 3570 3574 7066* 7069* 6271* 6304* 4876* 5431*

304 3570 3522 7704* 7709* 4850 4863 4552 4905

305 3570 3669 5852* 5851* 5895* 5920* 4293 4329

306 3570 3562 5670* 5667* 4432 4428 4275 4350

307 3570 3949 6103* 6102* 4520 4507 4321 4471

308 3570 3502 4743* 4737* 5789* 5826* 3939 3845

309 3570 4391* 6104* 6105* 3916 3897 4465 4785

310 3570 3621 4859* 4855* 6561* 6610* 4202 4330

311 3570 4178* 6163* 6164* 4561 4582 4709 5183*

312 3570 4242* 6547* 6551* 4947 4965 4010 3848

313 3570 3585 5924* 5925* 5657* 5691* 4155 4190

314 3570 3422 7397* 7405* 4918 4941 4598 5021*

315 3570 3585 6162* 6163* 6578* 6635* 4306 4452

316 3570 3318 7253* 7260* 6363* 6423* 4489 4833

317 3570 4117* 7155* 7162* 6021* 6066* 4365 4460

318 3570 4134* 7057* 7062* 6996* 7073* 4370 4521

319 3570 3178 5710* 5709* 6331* 6397* 4334 4534

320 3570 3489 5940* 5940* 7646* 7740* 3723 3403

321 3570 3656 6246* 6247* 6254* 6287* 4208 4089

322 3570 3785 6382* 6382* 5561* 5576* 3869 3397

323 3570 3225 2333 2318 7315* 7382* 3356 2583

324 3570 2985 6521* 6522* 7598* 7656* 4088 3814

325 3570 3663 4560* 4554* 6328* 6356* 4140 3812

326 3570 3434 5952* 5951* 5924* 5955* 4347 4299

327 3570 3444 5923* 5922* 5531* 5536* 3957 3589

328 3570 3663 5252* 5248* 4098 4069 3942 3470

329 3570 3677 5593* 5592* 4070 4046 4440 4489

Page 42: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

42

330 3570 3327 5447* 5443* 4406 4391 3777 3238

331 3570 3330 5103* 5102* 3970 3909 3355 2725

332 3570 3466 6155* 6159* 4030 3987 4494 4729

333 3570 3758 6904* 6911* 4307 4257 4324 4308

334 3570 3755 6314* 6317* 3748 3691 3822 3493

335 3570 3439 6925* 6933* 4441 4401 4537 4834

336 3570 4195* 5856* 5859* 4364 4330 4104 4055

337 3570 3633 6738* 6745* 4100 4044 4389 4420

338 3570 4005* 5539* 5539* 4018 3968 4429 4543

339 3570 3684 6364* 6368* 3753 3687 4660 4981*

340 3570 3980 6338* 6344* 4928 4901 4252 4342

341 3570 2889 7437* 7443* 4833 4806 4203 4302

342 3570 3405 4381* 4373* 5067 5036 4795 5259*

343 3570 3333 5632* 5630* 5000 4984 4190 4248

344 3570 3687 4620* 4614* 4495 4465 3616 3255

345 3570 3493 5057* 5054* 4066 4019 4766 5275*

346 3570 3309 6543* 6544* 5477 5466 4337 4428

347 3570 3509 6096* 6095* 4092 4036 4285 4378

348 3570 2833 6708* 6710* 5079 5051 4341 4382

349 3570 3750 5220* 5216* 4808 4773 4166 4079

350 3570 3101 6051* 6050* 4204 4160 4019 3878

LSD 0.0 1231.0 199.7 198.5 507.2 497.8 839.8 1110.8

CV (%) 14.7 16.0 1.6 1.6 4.7 4.6 12.7 13.1 Genotype significance NS NS ** ** ** ** ** **

Page 43: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

43

Table 13. Yield (kg/ha) Performance of 26th SAWYT lines over local checks Punjab

RARI-BWP

LC: Jauhar-16 WRI-FSD

LC: Faisalabad-08 AZRI-BWP

LC: Jauhar-16

Entry BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 2142 2091 4170 4067 4067 3446

302 3178* 3291* 3924 3791 3791 3680*

303 3454* 3625* 4461 4453 4453 3858*

304 2395 2375 5547* 5792* 5792* 3119

305 2838* 2891* 4275 4191 4191 4716*

306 3440* 3592* 5534* 5681* 5681* 2779

307 3578* 3766* 4086 4012 4012 3979*

308 3135* 3225* 5450* 5678* 5678* 3717*

309 3289* 3416* 5255* 5398* 5398* 3428

310 3564* 3733* 4503 4515 4515 4289*

311 2067 1958 4291 4310 4310 2893

312 2060 1958 4085 3961 3961 4134*

313 2633 2642 4915* 4979* 4979* 2964

314 2402 2358 4397 4384 4384 4439*

315 2125 2058 3991 3893 3893 4323*

316 2018 1917 4800 4857* 4857* 3137

317 2002 1891 4118 4000 4000 3493

318 2045 1950 4205 4114 4114 3272

319 3771* 3916* 4766 4868* 4868* 3645*

320 2248 2183 4200 4109 4109 3297

321 2084 2008 4185 4081 4081 3764*

322 3475* 3608* 3768 3547 3547 4312*

323 1937 1825 3745 3616 3616 2093

324 3135* 3233* 4758 4741 4741 3287

325 3504* 3633* 4851* 4806* 4806* 3883*

326 2234 2166 5443* 5609* 5609* 3103

327 2939* 3008* 3991 3841 3841 4124*

328 2003 1908 4092 3916 3916 3414

329 1823 1708 4588 4554 4554 4168*

Page 44: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

44

330 2858* 2900* 4684 4623 4623 3512

331 2849* 2916* 5087* 5195* 5195* 2634

332 2443 2416 4799 4921* 4921* 3073

333 3481* 3617* 4565 4539 4539 4302*

334 2102 2041 4167 4084 4084 4150*

335 3322* 3441* 4121 4074 4074 3669*

336 3277* 3375* 5473* 5713* 5713* 3837*

337 2044 1966 4412 4358 4358 3490

338 2523 2525 4537 4518 4518 3737*

339 2987* 3075* 4441 4436 4436 4017*

340 2125 2066 5083* 5203* 5203* 4225*

341 2217 2133 5208* 5337* 5337* 3069

342 1991 1892 5732* 5939* 5939* 3668*

343 2331 2250 4235 4245 4245 3432

344 1874 1725 4550 4615 4615 3567

345 2058 1950 5013* 5108* 5108* 4194*

346 1969 1850 4137 4035 4035 2920

347 2484 2458 4494 4485 4485 3186

348 2724 2708 4856* 4867* 4867* 4196*

349 3072* 3108* 3963 3818 3818 3769*

350 2208 2125 5201* 5284* 5284* 4309*

LSD 657.4 698.2 639.4 689.5 187.0 188.4

CV (%) 13.2 13.3 7.3 7.5 2.6 2.6

Genotype significance

** ** ** ** ** **

Page 45: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

45

Table 14. Yield (kg/ha) Performance of 26th SAWYT lines over local checks in Baluchistan and Sindh

ARI-Quetta LC: Zardana

BARDC-Quetta LC: Shalkot-14

QARI-Larkana LC: T.D-1

Entry BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 1496 1528 1932 1766 4513 4329

302 594 504 1951 1877 4556 4416

303 875 824 1929 1806 4862 5045

304 944 901 1979 1905 4915 5164

305 1044 1015 1956 1841 4863 5066

306 678 600 1911 1752 4580 4465

307 1001 966 1935 1826 4866 5053

308 1185 1175 1979 1905 4538 4369

309 1134 1117 1841 1572 4874 5091

310 1144 1129 2129 2467* 4606 4527

311 1042 1012 1891 1746 4460 4180

312 1301 1307 1995 2075 4589 4462

313 1312 1319 1978 2071 4566 4396

314 1340 1351 2021 2243* 4577 4440

315 1373 1388 2008 2163 4032 3270

316 1168 1156 2087 2447* 4987 5303

317 1355 1368 2031 2187 4571 4426

318 671 591 2075 2373* 4514 4302

319 1688 1746 2036 2194 4518 4301

320 1928* 2017* 2019 2199 4819 4946

321 1256 1256 2015 2130 4847 5047

322 1792 1864 1974 1966 4862 5073

323 1880* 1964* 1907 1702 4508 4319

324 1240 1238 1930 1829 5270 5916*

325 1193 1184 2008 2022 4912 5182

326 1262 1262 1950 1834 4544 4393

327 890 841 2041 2174 4463 4214

328 1629 1678 1926 1766 5030 5430

329 1132 1115 1916 1822 4577 4476

Page 46: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

46

330 1077 1052 1980 1986 5415* 6239*

331 1140 1124 2010 2091 5519* 6411*

332 1655 1709 1926 1774 4558 4393

333 1740 1805 1910 1729 4550 4387

334 1013 980 1990 2029 4554 4392

335 1759 1826 1903 1795 4575 4441

336 1892* 1977* 1879 1626 4846 4999

337 1648 1701 1929 1788 5015 5367

338 1318 1326 2042 2190 4513 4307

339 1069 1043 2026 2140 4079 3375

340 796 734 2089 2374* 4587 4466

341 1094 1072 2077 2336* 5082 5520

342 1245 1243 2001 2060 4560 4399

343 1288 1292 2004 2015 4589 4468

344 1763 1831 1966 1897 4504 4288

345 1237 1234 1956 1961 4852 5036

346 1275 1278 1961 1939 4555 4405

347 1216 1211 1954 1916 4458 4184

348 1236 1233 1988 1971 4885 5104

349 973 935 1886 1654 4581 4462

350 950 909 1924 1822 4571 4438

LSD 343.1 365.5 265.3 473.7 845.2 1227.2

CV (%) 14.4 14.4 11.5 11.1 12.9 13.0

Genotype significance ** ** NS NS * **

Page 47: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

47

Table 15. Yield (kg/ha) Performance of 26th SAWYT lines over local checks in KP and combined over locations

CCRI

LC: Pirsabak-15 BARS-Kohat LC: Kohat-17

ARI-D.I Khan LC: Shahid-17

Combined over locations results

Entry BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 5009 4985 3648 3182 2225 1874 3543 3230

302 4832 4733 3648 2786 2264 1997 3630 3425

303 6073* 6320* 3648 4799 2551 2887 4030* 4334*

304 6005* 6128* 3648 4218 2493 2721 3942* 4127*

305 6027* 6246* 3648 4369 2514 2801 3924* 4091*

306 5429 5472 3648 3880 2383 2379 3766 3732

307 5779 5955 3648 4072 2658 3227* 3879 3993*

308 4059 3718 3648 3478 2448 2576 3748 3689

309 4980 4967 3648 4144 2538 2870 3825 3874*

310 4808 4755 3648 3944 2267 2005 3848 3926*

311 4726 4560 3648 4347 2460 2614 3680 3539

312 5269 5323 3648 3518 2380 2371 3761 3727

313 4650 4573 3648 3355 2365 2290 3761 3728

314 5556 5697 3648 3754 2408 2453 3904 4055*

315 5714 5891 3648 4494 2420 2466 3828 3879*

316 6436* 6787* 3648 3313 2400 2428 3977* 4220*

317 6404* 6730* 3648 4678 2449 2591 3899 4038*

318 6305* 6573* 3648 3649 2618 3130* 3914* 4069*

319 5308 5281 3648 3681 2593 3040* 3939* 4123*

320 4610 4473 3648 2982 2262 1990 3807 3826*

321 5599 5629 3648 3838 2482 2563 3850 3923*

322 5026 4867 3648 3533 2266 1875 3825 3858*

323 3682 3146 3648 1685 2179 1587 3424 2948

324 5268 5217 3648 3325 2278 1882 3945* 4134*

325 4623 4401 3648 3009 2210 1699 3796 3796*

326 5022 4805 3648 3319 2454 2465 3798 3795*

327 5209 5144 3648 4019 2322 2025 3748 3687

328 4710 4509 3648 3749 2343 2124 3636 3432

329 5293 5250 3648 3818 2407 2323 3707 3599

Page 48: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

48

330 4868 4672 3648 3066 2360 2175 3736 3655

331 4144 3884 3648 3027 2248 1914 3640 3448

332 5604 5586 3648 4280 2556 2918* 3785 3767

333 6109* 6302* 3648 3665 2652 3239* 3945* 4136*

334 4430 4188 3648 2975 2505 2765 3645 3452

335 5465 5523 3648 3340 2430 2523 3858 3944*

336 5029 4873 3648 2613 2186 1735 3813 3832*

337 5318 5322 3648 4071 2584 3022* 3818 3847*

338 5153 5084 3648 3088 2318 2168 3716 3614

339 5642 5740 3648 4081 2365 2286 3770 3743

340 5138 5117 3648 3540 2492 2720 3819 3856*

341 5471 5593 3648 4054 2404 2393 3888 4014*

342 5631 5789 3648 3661 2282 1976 3799 3807*

343 5448 5456 3648 3868 2394 2355 3742 3670

344 4185 3891 3648 2235 2283 1999 3572 3286

345 6243* 6549* 3648 3781 2247 1890 3819 3856*

346 5733 5867 3648 3949 2502 2708 3786 3773

347 5979* 6221* 3648 4342 2409 2381 3755 3708

348 5441 5538 3648 3979 2319 2126 3893 4018*

349 4893 4859 3648 3225 2452 2553 3706 3595

350 5777 5921 3648 4623 2647 3173* 3812 3830*

LSD 943.8 1052.2 0.0 1841.5 558.8 1035.2 368.0 555.2

CV (%) 9.3 9.3 23.8 24.4 20.4 20.5 10.0 10.0

Genotype significance ** ** NS NS NS NS ** **

Page 49: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

49

Table 16. Detail of Entries evaluated in 8th SATYN Entry No. Cross Name Selection History

9401 LOCAL CHECK As given in Table 1

9402 SOKOLL/WBLL1/5/W15.92/4/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1 PTSS11Y00209S-099B-099Y-099B-39Y-020Y-0B

9403 SOKOLL/4/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1

PTSS11Y00094S-0SHB-099B-099Y-099B-1Y-020Y-

0B

9404 SOKOLL/WBLL1/4/2*PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1 PTSS13Y00176T-099B-21Y-020Y-0B

9405 CIT71/CPT//AE.SQUARROSA (629)/4/2*PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1 PTSS13Y00197T-099B-7Y-020Y-0B

9406 CIT71/CPT//AE.SQUARROSA (629)/4/2*PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1 PTSS13Y00197T-099B-27Y-020Y-0B

9407 IWA8611532/4/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1/5/BABAX/LR42//BABAX/

3/ER2000

PTSS12SHB00022T-099TOPB-099Y-099B-11Y-

020Y-0B

9408 IWA8611532/4/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1/5/BABAX/LR42//BABAX/

3/ER2000 PTSS12SHB00022T-099TOPB-099Y-099B-15Y-0Y

9409 W15.92/4/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1/5/IWA8612414/6/BABAX/LR4

2//BABAX/3/ER2000

PTSS12GHB00012T-0TOPB-099Y-099B-4Y-020Y-

0B

9410 W15.92/4/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1/5/OAX92.2.5/6/BABAX/LR42//

BABAX/3/ER2000

PTSS12GHB00017T-0TOPB-099Y-099B-2Y-020Y-

0B

9411 BAV92/SERI

CMSS96Y04084S-0Y-1B-93TLA-0B-0Y-106B-0Y-0Y-

0Y-0Y

9412 PBL94.14.30/4/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1/5/BABAX/LR42//BABAX/3

/ER2000 PTSS12SHB00003T-0TOPB-099Y-099B-6Y-020Y-0B

9413 PBL94.14.30/4/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1/5/BABAX/LR42//BABAX/3

/ER2000 PTSS12SHB00003T-0TOPB-099Y-099B-7Y-020Y-0B

9414 MEX94.15.34/4/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1/5/BABAX/LR42//BABAX/

3/ER2000

PTSS12SHB00004T-0TOPB-099Y-099B-10Y-020Y-

0B

Page 50: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

50

9415 SOKOLL/4/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1/5/SOKOLL/3/PASTOR//HXL757

3/2*BAU PTSS12SHB00016T-0TOPB-099Y-099B-2Y-020Y-0B

9416 SOKOLL/5/W15.92/4/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1/6/SOKOLL/3/PASTO

R//HXL7573/2*BAU PTSS12SHB00020T-0TOPB-099Y-099B-6Y-020Y-0B

9417 SOKOLL/5/W15.92/4/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1/6/SOKOLL/3/PASTO

R//HXL7573/2*BAU

PTSS12SHB00020T-0TOPB-099Y-099B-25Y-020Y-

0B

9418

ALTAR 84/AE.SQUARROSA

(895)/4/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1/5/BABAX/LR42//BABAX/3/ER200

0 PT11SHB00008T-0TOPB-099Y-099B-1Y-020Y-0B

9419 MEX94.27.1.20/3/SOKOLL//ATTILA/3*BCN/4/PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1 PTSS09GHB00029S-0SHB-099Y-4Y-020Y-0MXI

9420

SHAG_22/AE.SQUARROSA (721)//WHEAR/KRONSTAD

F2004/7/SHA7/VEE#5/5/VEE#8//JUP/BJY/3/F3.71/TRM/4/2*WEAVER/6/SKAU

Z/PARUS//PARUS SDSS12B00981T-0Y-0B-0B-26Y-0M-0Y

9421 CROC_1/AE.SQUARROSA (517)//KACHU/3/BAJ #1 SDSS12B00833T-0Y-0B-0B-54Y-0M-0Y

9422 68.111/RGB-U//WARD/3/AE.SQUARROSA

(452)/4/2*OASIS/SKAUZ//4*BCN/5/NAVJ07/6/KACHU SDSS12B01185T-0Y-0B-0B-133Y-0M-0Y

9423 W15.92/4/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1

PTSS02B00102T-0TOPY-0B-0Y-0B-11Y-0M-0SY-

0B-0Y

9424 SOKOLL/WBLL1

PTSS02Y00021S-099B-099Y-030ZTM-040SY-

040M-31Y-0M-0SY-0B-0Y

9425 SCOOP_1/AE.SQUARROSA (634)//KACHU/3/BAJ #1 SDSS12B00821T-0Y-0B-0B-32Y-0M-0Y

9426 SOKOLL/3/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/4/PARUS/PASTOR

PTSA08M00046S-050ZTM-050Y-50ZTM-010Y-0B-

020Y-0MXI

9427 PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1 PTSS02Y00027S-011Y-0B-0Y-0B-7Y-0M-0SY-0Y-0Y

9428 BAJ #1 CGSS01Y00134S-099Y-099M-099M-13Y-0B

Page 51: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

51

9429 BORLAUG100 F2014

CMSS06Y00605T-099TOPM-099Y-099ZTM-099Y-

099M-11WGY-0B-0MEX

9430 SOKOLL CMSS97M00316S-0P20M-0P20Y-43M-010Y

9431 FRANCOLIN #1

CGSS01B00056T-099Y-099M-099M-099Y-099M-

14Y-0B

9432 SOKOLL/WBLL1 PTSS02Y00021S-099B-099Y-099B-099Y-213B-0Y

9433 JNRB.5/PIFED/5/BJY/COC//PRL/BOW/3/SARA/THB//VEE/4/PIFED

PTSS08GHB00011S-0SH-099SHB-099SHB-099SHB-

52Y-0Y

Table 17. Yield (kg/ha) performance of 8th SATYN lines over local checks in KP and Sindh

BARS-Kohat LC: Kohat-17

NIFA LC: NIFA Lalma

NIA LC: Benazir-13

WRI Sakrand LC: Benazir-13

Entry BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 4220 4542 3966 4333 6823 6442 4159 3767

9402 3409 3315 3823 4000 6863 6515 4159 4269

9403 3090 3022 3416 3333 6695 6107 4159 3581

9404 2892 2743 3046 2667 6951 7010 4159 4252

9405 3104 2977 3073 2666 7072 7283 4159 4480

9406 3430 3443 3594 3666 7013 6855 4159 3290

9407 2348 1962 2850 2333 6317 4776 4159 4368

9408 3267 3267 3439 3333 6842 6444 4159 4220

9409 2724 2645 3044 2667 6941 6569 4159 3769

9410 3693 3876 3068 2667 6932 6534 4159 4688

9411 3545 3580 3038 2667 6787 6056 4159 4114

9412 3139 3242 3606 3666 7145 7317 4159 3875

9413 2883 2705 3026 2667 7214 7884 4159 4226

9414 2538 2296 3460 3333 7182 7937 4159 4275

Page 52: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

52

9415 2911 2773 4560 5333 7385 7972 4159 3923

9416 3411 3459 2930 2666 7100 7326 4159 3925

9417 3029 2810 3392 3333 6897 6929 4159 4253

9418 3164 3013 4549 5333 6782 6265 4159 4689

9419 2853 2745 3407 3333 6485 5792 4159 4115

9420 2938 2953 3972 4333 7207 7876 4159 4555

9421 4172 4674 5297 6666* 7238 7861 4159 4846*

9422 5149 6013* 3972 4333 7141 7420 4159 4339

9423 3346 3467 4166 4666 6869 6690 4159 4030

9424 3183 3166 3791 4000 6744 6529 4159 4296

9425 2852 2525 3630 3666 6774 6675 4159 4454

9426 3077 2931 3625 3666 7074 7448 4159 4226

9427 3865 4011 3067 2667 7000 7017 4159 4405

9428 2453 2211 3096 2667 7169 7867 4159 4279

9429 4091 4479 3822 4000 7191 7906 4159 4216

9430 4427 4990 3437 3333 6939 7177 4159 4236

9431 3098 3037 3453 3333 7032 7138 4159 3804

9432 2822 2511 3126 2667 7078 7476 4159 3657

9433 2618 2359 3245 3000 6660 6452 4159 3810

LSD 1095.7 1220.1 1395.3 1858.7 929.8 1678.7 0.0 935.6

CV (%) 18.2 15.7 24.5 25.3 9.6 11.1 10.1 8.7

Genotype significance ** ** ** * NS NS NS NS

Page 53: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

53

Table 18. Yield (kg/ha) performance of 8th SATYN lines over local checks in Punjab and combined over locations

AZRI Bhakkar

LC: Fakhr-e-Bhakkar RARI-BWP

LC: Jauhar-16 WRI-FSD

LC: Faisalabad-08

Combined over locations results

Entry BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 2085 2293 3406 3408 4224 4207 4425 4603

9402 2085 1967 4309* 4329* 4050 4091 4364 4484

9403 2085 2013 2188 2164 3937 3933 3946 3718

9404 2085 2095 2877 2866 3618 3532 3981 3762

9405 2085 2055 3411 3413 4509 4532 4215 4199

9406 2085 2033 2100 2073 3542 3486 4053 3901

9407 2085 2209 2917 2911 3233 3130 3578 3026

9408 2085 2200 4319* 4341* 3744 3739 4226 4214

9409 2085 2045 3740 3749 2882 2725 3923 3659

9410 2085 2185 2106 2083 4354 4404 4063 3932

9411 2085 1834 5367* 5408* 3663 3616 4258 4272

9412 2085 2017 3013 3005 4124 4136 4236 4238

9413 2085 1923 2026 2000 3815 3774 3997 3807

9414 2085 2100 4887* 4919* 4234 4251 4409 4563

9415 2085 2018 3360 3362 4047 4011 4481 4683

9416 2085 2061 3421 3422 4001 3933 4163 4124

9417 2085 2034 2810 2798 3519 3433 4027 3851

9418 2085 2201 3095 3090 4306 4319 4327 4411

9419 2085 2161 643 587 4230 4277 3742 3354

9420 2085 1817 2693 2676 5077* 5192* 4420 4588

9421 2085 2313 4239* 4254* 3677 3618 4859 5396

9422 2085 2136 2799 2791 4173 4180 4597 4914

9423 2085 2235 5464* 5503* 5424* 5603* 4735 5162

9424 2085 2099 3097 3091 3936 3963 4174 4139

9425 2085 2190 3011 3004 3811 3797 4078 3958

9426 2085 2195 3661 3670 5523* 5694* 4472 4685

9427 2085 2158 4804* 4834* 4794* 4887* 4489 4712

Page 54: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

54

9428 2085 2172 4560* 4583* 2789 2678 4113 4014

9429 2085 2223 3135 3130 4755 4842* 4571 4858

9430 2085 1962 2563 2547 3932 3931 4305 4370

9431 2085 1965 4052* 4067* 3610 3577 4237 4238

9432 2085 2002 4307* 4328* 3693 3729 4208 4187

9433 2085 1907 2020 1993 3466 3481 3800 3449

LSD 0.0 367.1 454.5 457.9 563.9 586.6 725.4 983.6

CV (%) 8.4 8.1 6.3 6.3 6.6 7.1 13.7 13.7

Genotype significance NS NS ** ** ** ** ** **

Table 19. Detail of Entries evaluated in 6th WYCYT Entry No. Cross Name Selection History

1 LOCAL CHECK As given in Table 1

2 SERI/BAV92//PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1/3/MUCUY PTSS14Y00324S-0B-099Y-099B-15Y-0B

3 SUP152//PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1/3/MUCUY PTSS14Y00330S-0B-099Y-099B-9Y-0B

4 SUP152//PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1/3/MUCUY PTSS14Y00330S-0B-099Y-099B-44Y-0B

5 WBLL1//PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1/3/MUCUY PTSS14Y00345S-0B-099Y-099B-12Y-0B

6 WBLL1//PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1/3/MUCUY PTSS14Y00345S-0B-099Y-099B-29Y-0B

7 WBLL1//PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1/3/MUCUY PTSS14Y00345S-0B-099Y-099B-37Y-0B

8 WBLL1//YANGLING SHAANXI/ESDA/3/ROLF07/4/TACUPETO

F2001/SAUAL//BLOUK #1 PTSS13B00143S-099Y-099B-099Y-20Y-020Y

9 PAVLOVKA/V15.89C//NAVJ07/3/ROLF07/4/MUCUY PTSS14Y00314S-0B-099Y-099B-23Y-020Y

10 PAVLOVKA/V15.89C//NAVJ07/3/ROLF07/4/MUCUY PTSS14Y00314S-0B-099Y-099B-25Y-020Y

Page 55: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

55

11 MEX94.27.1.20/3/SOKOLL//ATTILA/3*BCN/4/PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1/5

/MUCUY PTSS14Y00328S-0B-099Y-099B-3Y-020Y

12 MEX94.27.1.20/3/SOKOLL//ATTILA/3*BCN/4/PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1/5

/MUCUY PTSS14Y00328S-0B-099Y-099B-19Y-020Y

13 MEX94.27.1.20/3/SOKOLL//ATTILA/3*BCN/4/PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1/5

/MUCUY PTSS14Y00328S-0B-099Y-099B-29Y-020Y

14 MEX94.27.1.20/3/SOKOLL//ATTILA/3*BCN/4/PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1/5

/MUCUY PTSS14Y00328S-0B-099Y-099B-34Y-020Y

15 MEX94.27.1.20/3/SOKOLL//ATTILA/3*BCN/4/PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1/5

/MUCUY PTSS14Y00329S-0B-099Y-099B-23Y-020Y

16 BABAX/LR42//BABAX/3/VORB/4/COPIO PTSS14Y00475S-0B-099Y-099B-11Y-020Y

17 D67.2/PARANA 66.270//AE.SQUARROSA (465)/3/2*MUCUY PTSS14B00002T-099Y-099B-5Y-020Y

18 D67.2/PARANA 66.270//AE.SQUARROSA (465)/3/2*MUCUY PTSS14B00002T-099Y-099B-6Y-020Y

19 D67.2/PARANA 66.270//AE.SQUARROSA (465)/3/2*MUCUY PTSS14B00002T-099Y-099B-11Y-020Y

20 68.111/RGB-U//WARD/3/FGO/4/RABI/5/AE.SQUARROSA

(784)/6/2*MUCUY PTSS14B00005T-099Y-099B-10Y-020Y

21 68.111/RGB-U//WARD/3/FGO/4/RABI/5/AE.SQUARROSA

(784)/6/2*MUCUY PTSS14B00005T-099Y-099B-19Y-020Y

22 68.111/RGB-U//WARD/3/FGO/4/RABI/5/AE.SQUARROSA

(784)/6/2*MUCUY PTSS14B00005T-099Y-099B-24Y-020Y

23 GAN/AE.SQUARROSA (897)//KACHU/3/BAJ #1 SDSS12B00826T-0Y-0B-0Y-0M-2Y-0B-0Y

24 SCOOP_1/AE.SQUARROSA (634)//KACHU/3/BAJ #1 SDSS12B00821T-0Y-0B-0B-32Y-0M-0Y

25 ARLIN_1/AE.SQUARROSA (1017)//KACHU/3/BAJ #1 SDSS12B00837T-0Y-0B-0B-41Y-0M-0Y

26 ARLIN_1/AE.SQUARROSA (1017)//KACHU/3/BAJ #1 SDSS12B00837T-0Y-0B-0B-49Y-0M-0Y

Page 56: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

56

27 SERI/BAV92//PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1 PTSS09GHB00019S-0SHB-099Y-099B-14Y-0Y

28 MEX94.27.1.20/3/SOKOLL//ATTILA/3*BCN/4/PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1 PTSS09GHB00029S-0SHB-099Y-4Y-020Y-0MXI

29 BAJ #1 CGSS01Y00134S-099Y-099M-099M-13Y-0B

30 BORLAUG100 F2014

CMSS06Y00605T-099TOPM-099Y-099ZTM-099Y-

099M-11WGY-0B-0MEX

31 SOKOLL CMSS97M00316S-0P20M-0P20Y-43M-010Y

32 BCN/WBLL1//ROLF07/5/UP2338*2/SHAMA/3/MILAN/KAUZ//CHIL/CH

UM18/4/UP2338*2/SHAMA

PTSS11Y00029S-0SHB-099B-099Y-8B-099Y-099B-

020Y-0B

Table 20. Yield (kg/ha) performance of 6th WYCYT lines over local checks in Punjab

AZRI Bhakkar

LC: Fakhr-e-Bhakkar NARC

LC: Borlaug-16 RARI-BWP

LC: Jauar-16 WRI-FSD

LC: Faisalabad-08

Entry BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 2663 2521 3378 3253 3271 3333 4886 4906

2 2735 2687 4627* 4731* 2499 2500 5117 5131

3 2684 2562 4299 4367* 1634 1583 4033 4016

4 2677 2562 4065 4068 3682 3750 4896 4922

5 2708 2625 4203 4196 3304 3375 4828 4816

6 3236 3875* 5154* 5327* 1440 1383 5910* 5955*

7 2648 2479 3814 3748 2562 2583 5208 5233

8 2484 2083 3430 3384 2653 2666 4846 4853

9 2995 3312 4689* 4838* 3281 3325 5299* 5326*

10 2741 2708 4717* 4828* 2206 2208 4402 4378

11 2700 2604 4745* 4914* 3049 3083 5300* 5318*

12 2569 2291 5263* 5508* 2263 2250 4166 4151

13 2699 2604 4477* 4589* 2650 2666 5069 5090

14 2584 2333 5015* 5176* 1574 1517 5308* 5341*

Page 57: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

57

15 2933 3166 4661* 4797* 3667 3750 5102 5132

16 2826 2916 3797 3807 2262 2250 4934 4958

17 3119 3604* 5097* 5299* 1624 1583 5487* 5516*

18 2656 2500 4200 4261 2186 2166 4448 4432

19 2701 2604 4345* 4456* 2178 2167 5254 5277

20 2854 2979 4934* 5089* 1712 1667 5018 5043

21 3239 3896* 4537* 4598* 1982 1958 5229 5236

22 2957 3229 4391* 4420* 2570 2583 4644 4640

23 2767 2770 3765 3713 2102 2083 4432 4403

24 2774 2792 2935 2742 2156 2166 3468 3391

25 2716 2646 2619 2365 1448 1383 4963 4990

26 2727 2667 3714 3568 3111 3167 4977 4999

27 2681 2562 2425 2170 1785 1750 4008 3984

28 2733 2687 3592 3481 1542 1483 4737 4743

29 2700 2604 2266 1935 3230 3291 2585 2474

30 2692 2583 3479 3301 3666 3750 4465 4449

31 2685 2562 3668 3578 1417 1350 4261 4222

32 2685 2562 2970 2764 1723 1667 4019 3974

LSD 600.0 921.1 962.7 1018.7 529.4 544.8 394.7 396.2

CV (%) 16.1 16.2 11.1 11.1 10.9 11.1 3.9 3.8

Genotype significance NS NS ** ** ** ** ** **

Page 58: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

58

Table 21. Yield (kg/ha) performance of 6th WYCYT lines over local checks in Baluchistan, Sindh, KP and across locations

BARDC Quetta LC: Shalkot-14

BARS Kohat LC: Kohat-17

WRI Sakrand LC: Benazir-13

Combined over locations results

Entry BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 2354 2525 3406 2433 4047 3332 3478 3476

2 2354 2530 3406 3333 4047 3777 3607 3750

3 2354 2439 3406 2900 4047 4861* 3316 3134

4 2354 2539 3406 3167 4047 3527 3639 3816

5 2354 2137 3406 3000 4047 4472* 3616 3763

6 2354 2172 3406 2733 4047 4291 3805 4173

7 2354 2070 3406 3300 4047 3944 3495 3515

8 2354 2074 3406 3200 4047 4167 3384 3280

9 2354 2382 3406 3733 4047 4194 3824 4214

10 2354 2243 3406 2633 4047 4444 3499 3518

11 2354 2589 3406 3633 4047 3972 3712 3977

12 2354 2643 3406 3567 4047 3917 3516 3561

13 2354 2261 3406 3433 4047 4083 3589 3718

14 2354 2477 3406 3367 4047 4611* 3539 3604

15 2354 2384 3406 3800 4047 3986 3822 4210

16 2354 2400 3406 4966* 4047 4000 3476 3480

17 2354 2215 3406 4167 4047 3528 3725 4004

18 2354 2420 3406 2467 4047 3194 3422 3356

19 2354 2382 3406 1800 4047 4180 3547 3624

20 2354 2541 3406 3400 4047 4472* 3574 3682

21 2354 2074 3406 4200 4047 3777 3680 3903

22 2354 2020 3406 3833 4047 3722 3579 3685

23 2354 2193 3406 4500 4047 3847 3369 3238

24 2354 2121 3406 2333 4047 3750 3128 2727

25 2354 2611 3406 3333 4047 4028 3181 2840

26 2354 2290 3406 3966 4047 4333 3530 3577

27 2354 2267 3406 3400 4047 3930 3077 2627

28 2354 2621 3406 5333* 4047 4055 3305 3107

Page 59: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

59

29 2354 2204 3406 2433 4047 4541* 3063 2581

30 2354 2409 3406 3900 4047 4305 3505 3521

31 2354 2472 3406 2633 4047 3833 3229 2943

32 2354 2619 3406 4100 4047 4444 3160 2789

LSD 0.0 467.3 0.0 2388.3 0.0 1119.9 634.0 922.6

CV (%) 8.6 7.9 33.2 34.0 13.3 13.4 10.4 10.4

Genotype significance NS NS NS NS NS NS * **

Table 22. Detail of Entries evaluated in 1st CWYT Entry No. Cross Name Selection History 601 LOCAL CHECK As given in Table 1

602 MISR 1 CMSS00Y01881T-050M-030Y-030M-030WGY-33M-0Y-16Y-079B

603 CHIPAK CMSS07Y00066S-0B-099Y-099M-099Y-38M-0WGY

604 NADI CMSS06B00734T-099TOPY-099ZTM-099Y-099M-13WGY-0B

605 MUCUY CMSS07Y01083T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099Y-40M-0WGY

606 FITIS

CMSS06Y00878T-099TOPM-099Y-099ZTM-099Y-099M-18WGY-

0B

607 ZINCOL2016 CMSS07Y01302T-099Y-19M-0Y-2B-0Y

608 MAYIL CMSS08Y01129T-099M-099Y-3M-0Y-5M-0Y

609 KACHU/SOLALA CMSS09Y00580S-099Y-38M-0WGY-4B-0Y

610 MUNAL*2/WESTONIA

CMSS08Y00833T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099NJ-099NJ-14WGY-

0B

Page 60: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

60

611

SHORTENED SR26

TRANSLOCATION//2*WBLL1*2/KKTS/3/BECARD CMSS08Y01115T-099M-099Y-099M-099NJ-14WGY-0B

612 QUAIU #1/SUP152 CMSS08Y00057S-099Y-099M-099NJ-13WGY-0B

613 SUP152/BLOUK #1 CMSS06B00033S-0Y-099ZTM-099NJ-099NJ-4WGY-0B

614 KINGBIRD #1//INQALAB 91*2/TUKURU CMSS06B00485S-0Y-099ZTM-099Y-099M-7WGY-0B

615 BECARD/QUAIU #1 CMSS07B00230S-099M-099NJ-099NJ-23WGY-0B

616 BECARD/FRNCLN CMSS07B00235S-099M-099Y-099M-25WGY-0B

617 KACHU/BECARD//WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING CMSS07B00580T-099TOPY-099M-099Y-099M-10WGY-0B

618 QUAIU #1/BECARD CMSS08B00181S-099M-099NJ-099NJ-34WGY-0B

619 WBLL1*2/BRAMBLING/4/BABAX/LR42//BABAX*2/3/SHAMA CMSS08B00196S-099M-099NJ-099NJ-1WGY-0B

620 KACHU*2/BECARD

CMSS09Y00815T-099TOPM-099Y-099ZTM-099NJ-099NJ-5WGY-

0B

621

SOKOLL/WBLL1/4/D67.2/PARANA 66.270//AE.SQUARROSA

(320)/3/CUNNINGHAM CMSA09M00466S-050ZTM-050Y-3WGY-0B

622

ROLF07/SAUAL/5/SERI.1B//KAUZ/HEVO/3/AMAD*2/4/KIRIT

ATI CMSS10Y00359S-099Y-099M-3WGY-0B

623

KACHU/SAUAL/4/ATTILA*2/PBW65//PIHA/3/ATTILA/2*PAST

OR CMSS10Y00374S-099Y-099M-1WGY-0B

624

NS-

732/HER/3/PRL/SARA//TSI/VEE#5/4/FRET2/5/WHEAR/SOKO

LL CMSA09Y00712S-050Y-050ZTM-0NJ-099NJ-4WGY-0B

625

SOKOLL/3/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/4/PASTOR//MILAN/KA

UZ/3/BAV92 CMSA09Y00798S-050Y-050ZTM-0NJ-099NJ-1WGY-0B

626 HUW234+LR34/PRINIA*2//SNLG/3/KINGBIRD #1/4/BAJ #1

CMSS10Y00903T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099NJ-099NJ-10WGY-

0B

Page 61: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

61

627

KACHU/SAUAL/4/VARIS/MISR

2/3/FRET2/KUKUNA//FRET2/5/KACHU/SAUAL CMSS10B01033T-099TOPY-099M-099NJ-099NJ-20WGY-0B

628

WAXWING//INQALAB

91*2/KUKUNA/3/WBLL1*2/TUKURU/8/2*NG8201/KAUZ/4/

SHA7//PRL/VEE#6/3/FASAN/5/MILAN/KAUZ/6/ACHYUTA/7/

PBW343*2/KUKUNA CMSS10Y01311T-099TOPM-099Y-099M-099NJ-099NJ-7WGY-0B

629

ATTILA*2/PBW65//PIHA/3/ATTILA/2*PASTOR*2/5/SERI.1B//

KAUZ/HEVO/3/AMAD*2/4/KIRITATI CMSS10B01154T-099TOPY-099M-099NJ-099NJ-9WGY-0B

630 VENDA CMSS08B00178S-099M-099Y-15M-0RGY

631 BONSU CMSS08B00259S-099M-099NJ-30RGY-0B

632 BECARD//ND643/2*WBLL1 CMSS08B00422S-099M-099NJ-5RGY-0B

633

FRET2*2/SHAMA//PARUS/3/FRET2*2/KUKUNA/4/WBLL1/K

UKUNA//TACUPETO F2001/3/UP2338*2/VIVITSI CMSS10Y00436S-099Y-099M-099NJ-099NJ-11RGY-0B

634 NGL//2*WHEAR/SOKOLL CMSA10M00366T-050Y-050ZTM-099Y-27M-0RGY

635 BAJ #1/PREMIO CMSA10B00017S-050ZTM-099Y-21M-0RGY

636 SOKOLL/WBLL1

PTSS02Y00021S-099B-099Y-030ZTM-040SY-040M-18Y-0M-0SY-

0B-0Y

637 PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1 PTSS02Y00027S-011Y-0B-0Y-0B-7Y-0M-0SY-0Y-0Y

638 SOKOLL/WBLL1

PTSS02Y00021S-099B-099Y-030ZTM-040SY-040M-31Y-0M-0SY-

0B-0Y

639 SERI/BAV92//PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1 PTSS09GHB00019S-0SHB-099Y-099B-14Y-0Y

640

C80.1/3*QT4118//KAUZ/RAYON/3/2*TRCH/4/BERKUT/KRIC

HAUFF PTSS09GHB00057S-0SHB-099Y-099B-10Y-0Y

641 BAV92/SERI CMSS96Y04084S-0Y-1B-93TLA-0B-0Y-106B-0Y-0Y-0Y-0Y

642 W15.92/4/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/3/WBLL1 PTSS02B00102T-0TOPY-0B-0Y-0B-11Y-0M-0SY-0B-0Y

Page 62: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

62

643 SOKOLL/3/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/4/PARUS/PASTOR PTSA08M00046S-050ZTM-050Y-50ZTM-010Y-0B-020Y-0MXI

644

MEX94.27.1.20/3/SOKOLL//ATTILA/3*BCN/4/PUB94.15.1.12

/WBLL1 PTSS09GHB00029S-0SHB-099Y-4Y-020Y-0MXI

645 SOKOLL/WBLL1 PTSS02Y00021S-099B-099Y-099B-099Y-207B-0Y

646

KS940935.7.1.2/2*PASTOR/4/FRAME//MILAN/KAUZ/3/PAST

OR PTSS08GHB00009S-099SH-099Y-099B-099Y-136Y-0Y

647

JNRB.5/PIFED/5/BJY/COC//PRL/BOW/3/SARA/THB//VEE/4/P

IFED PTSS08GHB00011S-0SH-099SHB-099SHB-099SHB-52Y-0Y

648 SERI/BAV92//PUB94.15.1.12/WBLL1 PTSS09GHB00019S-0SHB-099Y-099B-9Y-0Y-020Y-0MXI

649

SOKOLL/3/PASTOR//HXL7573/2*BAU/4/MEX94.27.1.20/3/S

OKOLL//ATTILA/3*BCN PTSS11SHB00014S-099B-099Y-099B-53Y-099Y-0MXI

650

BCN/WBLL1//ROLF07/5/UP2338*2/SHAMA/3/MILAN/KAUZ/

/CHIL/CHUM18/4/UP2338*2/SHAMA PTSS11Y00029S-0SHB-099B-099Y-8B-099Y-099B-020Y-0B

Page 63: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

63

Table 23. Yield (kg/ha) performance of 1st CWYT lines over local checks in individual and across locations

BARS Kohat LC: Kohat-17

NIFA LC: NIFA Aman

NIA LC: Kiran-95

Combined over locations results

Entry BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE BLUP BLUE

Local Check 2964 2145 2845 2514 6493 6044 3943 3433

602 2545 1059 2769 2445 7250 7555* 4033 3605

603 4151 4989* 3757* 3721* 7042 7100 5056* 5189*

604 3986 4679* 3874* 3963* 7100 7179 5069* 5218*

605 3917 4515 4629* 4881* 6837 6703 5100* 5232*

606 3288 2906 3723* 3712* 7120 7305 4647 4559*

607 3837 4208 3556* 3454* 6607 6267 4653 4562*

608 4086 4926* 4477* 4763* 6984 6955 5245* 5492*

609 3165 2623 3551* 3459* 7277 7591* 4572 4408

610 3267 2877 3802* 3792* 6885 6840 4537 4353

611 3369 3105 4131* 4365* 7077 7113 4852* 4956*

612 3362 3098 3429 3350* 7061 7112 4604 4535*

613 3071 2268 3939* 4023* 6996 6992 4563 4497*

614 3419 3217 4411* 4661* 7143 7316 4946* 5065*

615 3270 2762 3939* 4023* 7049 7092 4690 4695*

616 3765 4077 3431 3361* 7387 7782* 4952* 5074*

617 4132 5012* 4258* 4450* 7221 7419* 5316* 5643*

618 3930 4465 3629* 3648* 6603 6297 4799* 4872*

619 3436 3272 3402 3398* 6990 6947 4644 4634*

620 3893 4372 4106* 4281* 7082 7214 5112* 5358*

621 4373 5721* 3866* 3966* 7029 7176 5280* 5600*

622 3589 3749 3863* 3985* 6924 6990 4843* 4955*

623 4464 5960* 4290* 4603* 7423 7857* 5651* 6213*

624 4018 4752* 3670* 3695* 7410 7863* 5188* 5484*

625 4268 5483* 3738* 3788* 7334 7715* 5315* 5656*

626 3467 3483 4063* 4303* 6832 6724 4812* 4910*

627 3481 3419 4047* 4195* 7435* 7912* 5020* 5223*

628 3265 2989 3587* 3588* 7205 7468* 4684 4676*

629 3553 3681 3715* 3765* 6733 6609 4678 4664*

Page 64: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

64

630 3962 4676* 4215* 4452* 7477* 8050* 5369* 5773*

631 3460 3191 3877* 3870* 7435* 7840* 4911* 4989*

632 3111 2422 3491 3445* 6881 6748 4431 4253

633 4220 5188* 3819* 3797* 7503* 7966* 5332* 5619*

634 3581 3554 3919* 3961* 7192 7432* 4916* 5004*

635 3458 3273 4047* 4108* 7381 7780* 4940* 5007*

636 3288 2862 3868* 3945* 6881 6748 4633 4566*

637 3442 3255 3367 3197 7083 7163 4617 4507*

638 2763 1521 3768* 3761* 6669 6431 4223 3926

639 2795 1538 3048 2770 6549 6143 3957 3506

640 3421 3180 3268 3074 7028 7103 4554 4406

641 3471 3357 3868* 3829* 7381 7594* 4883* 4897*

642 3060 2251 3497 3324* 6862 6557 4342 4083

643 3339 3042 3789* 3799* 6716 6246 4556 4427

644 3384 3155 3563* 3499* 6672 6162 4499 4337

645 3383 3139 3240 2996 6051 5047 4112 3698

646 4200 5148* 3413 3249 7456* 7752* 5198* 5422*

647 3419 3144 3371 3158 6601 6057 4390 4159

648 2919 2008 3413 3218 6439 5743 4074 3642

649 3418 3248 3715* 3618* 6396 5660 4408 4161

650 3873 4335 3388 3216 6939 6762 4804* 4810*

LSD 1558.2 2473.6 670.7 788.7 934.3 1280.9 842.7 1047.5

CV (%) 34.1 33.8 9.7 10.0 9.0 8.6 17.2 17.5

Genotype significance NS * ** ** ** ** ** **

Page 65: Analysis of Multi Location CIMMYT Wheat Yield Trials ... · Ghulam Ullah CIMMYT Pakistan, Dr. Attiq Ur Rehman Rattu, PARC, Ansaar Ahmad, CIMMYT-Pakistan Monsif Ur Rehman, CIMMYT-Pakistan,

65

International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center (CIMMYT)

Dr. Md. Imtiaz | CIMMYT Country Representative for Pakistan ([email protected])

CIMMYT-Pakistan office, CSI Building, NARC, Park Road, Islamabad