ˇ ˆ ˙ ˝ ˘ ˇ ˛ ˚˜ˇ ! ˇ #$ecoj.sbu.ac.ir/article_87137_71310065399a852a8105... · 1398 ˚...

of 31/31
1398 Quarterly Journal of Economics and Modelling Shahid Beheshti University : !" #$ % &’ () *+ %, - . / 012 - 27 / 09 / 1397 12 / 11 / 1397 34 & ( !"# $%& ’( ) *+,- !) + ./ +0 . .1! 2+2 34 51 ./ 67%4 ) 89 . ): $%& ;2 .*</ .’2 >92!9 ) %?9 ’@ >92!9 + ./ < .*2! +0 ) AB9 !"# $%& ’( & 2 ! C) !DE F ) G2 A)H 2!I< .+J F) - ! !7 9 2016 - 2005 N+0* )%"J C+O F?%2 +P% + Q) ) 2 .%J >!R I9+ SRT U%9 .2 F’J )@ 0%V+2 .% ’@ !) (9 >92!9 .# 2 .2 F’J 2 ! F) - C) !DE !"# $%& ’( >92!9 ;1! %?9 F)WE X"9 .# !1) ’!( !) (9 >92!9 Y A# ZE < .*2! ’ ! F) - $%& ’( >92!9 %?9 ’@ .2 F’J 2 * & (5 : ’( X2!9 0%V+2 .% N+0* )%"J !I< %?9 ’@ X2!9 < .*2! .$%& ".1 6$ JEL : C23 G20 O13 . X’9 FI"9 ) $%& \!7E F’O"9 $%& F)J %2 [email protected] ∗∗ X’9 FI"9 ) $%& \!7E F’O"9 $%& F)J %2 [email protected] ∗∗∗ 2(# ’( X’9 FI"9 ) $%& \!7E F’O"9 $%& [email protected]
  • date post

    23-Aug-2020
  • Category

    Documents

  • view

    0
  • download

    0

Embed Size (px)

Transcript of ˇ ˆ ˙ ˝ ˘ ˇ ˛ ˚˜ˇ ! ˇ #$ecoj.sbu.ac.ir/article_87137_71310065399a852a8105... · 1398 ˚...

  • �������� ����� �������

    �� ����������� �� � ����1398

    Quarterly Journal of Economics and Modelling Shahid Beheshti University

    :���� �� ������ ���� ������ ����� � ������ �� �����

    ���� ���� !"� ��#$

    �%��� �&'�∗(��) �*��+ �%�,� -∗∗ �. /���� �01�2 -∗∗∗

    ������ ���� ����� ���

    27/09/1397 12/11/1397

    34&(�

    ������� ������ ��� �� ��� �� �!"# �� ���$%&� '(� ) �*+,- ����� �!) �+� ./��� �+0 � .� .1!� ��

    �2�+2 3�4�� �51 ./��� ��� 67%4� ����)��� 89 .� ��): ���$%&� ;2��� �� .*�9�2!9 �+� ./��� �� ��!R

    � ��� I9�+� SR�T U��%9 .�2� F'��J ��)@� �0%V+2 .%�� �� '�@�� �!) �� �(�9 >�9�2!9 .# �2

    .�2� F'��J �2�� ��!� F�)� �- C�)� !DE �� �!"# �� ���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 ;1!� �%?9

    F)WE�� X�"9 .# ���� �!1) �' �!( ���� �!) �� �(�9 >�9�2!9 Y� A �# ZE�� ��9�2!9 � �%?9 �� '�@�� .�2� F'��J �2��

    *�&�(5����: '(� X�2!9 ��0%V+2 .%�� N+0*� �� �)�%"J �!I

  • 98 �,$ -7�� 8�0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    1 .���"�

    X& X�I" )H� ) X�9����$%&�F'�'� ^)_� �2� � �!"# [email protected] �- .# '9� F'( �� ��

    ����� ������09 ;7�� �(.9�+��)�a �?9 .� .%V��) �� �!"# .701 ��) X�)� �*+,- '�9�!�

    ��c� �2� �O0� �%T ) '��# F��?%2� ���$%&� .*2!� ) F�� �51 �� ����� ��� ��

    \�!� '�%V �+*&�) ��� �++,� �!1) �V1 �� �[email protected] .'9!"� d+9 ���$%&� �!#� ) e�� ��

    N�� .� � �!"# �� �a� �c .# ��� S�',� .� ���& ��*+,- ����� ��%"+� �� �����!a�

    �B ) ���$%&� '(� �� ��+*� ;VT � ) F�!,9 �!a X�'9)5( ��� F�� .� �9�)�

    ���$%&� >�+��� �� .'9��� �*+,- ����� '&� �� �!"# .� �,V9 �� ^!7/��9 �O70E

    �*+,- ����� �9�)� f#)����� X�!�E �� F'�'� ���19) F'( .%a��( (�*+,- ����� ��?

    �2� �9��) ) f#�2)1999(2

    �� �� � �!"#�)� ��� ��J 89�� .,

  • � ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� ������ ���� ����� 99 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    .���2 A �# �� I�� g- �� ) '"4� A��d� �\�!� ) �I��'B9 A��d� ��O�d+ ���J

    ���&� A �# ._+%9 �� ) �7� h!� ���� A �# ��9�� ) ��V ��!��9 ) �7a�� ��$%&� ���

    A4� ����)�"# ) �*�R +89 ��$%&� �'+'�'�7� '(� '9�!�

    �9��) ) f#�2) '�#2001�J!m� ) X!2�?7+J �1 �2006n!7� ) �#��@ �2 �2011�#)� �3 �

    2010X���O0 ) o)�� �4 �2013 q! ) �I+� ��� )5 �2016.(

    �?�� ���+Y�� � ��,� o! ���!� .� .1!� �� *+,- ����� �9�)� �� ���$%&� '(� �

    �?�� �� '��+� ��� A �# �51 ;2��� ���O �� �%�� ������ ��� F'9��� �� �!"# ��

    �� 89 .� ��):f� ���' F!r9 ) ��'9� f� �+0 � ) AB9 .� ����E �� .'2�(�9 ��'9� �

    ��� '�@��# ) s+rR j+$4� ��*+,- ����� �) �� SR�T �� '�@�� ��dm�T ��+V� F!1)

    ./2�) .�2� �+0 ��� '�@��# �

    � +P%�!_9��9 ) l9!�) ' � A �# �� ���$%&� XW# �6 �2009 X!V9�1 ) !7�� N2�& )7 �

    2005 �� .# [email protected] �0: �!"# C� �

    1. Gylfason and Zoega

    2. Arezki and Van der Ploeg

    3. Brückner 4. Farooq et al.

    5. Moradbeigi and Siong HookLaw 6. Monge and Naranjo 7. Acemoglu and Johnson

  • 100 �,$ -7�� 8�0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    Fu)� .� �� �!"# �� '�@�� '9�!%� �!"# C� �� �

    .*2!� .1�� .� .%V� ��!"# C� ���$%&� '(� ) �*+,- ����� �!) �+� ./��� �� �������

    .%(�� ���$%&� '(� � �?7%4� >�Y� '9�!� �� [email protected] >�9�2!9 ) �*+,- ����� �9�)� ���*

  • � ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� ������ ���� ����� 101 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    ���0� )1.( F� ��� ���� � ������ �� G������ #$ ����� ������ �2�

    :�,�� �)@�J� !9�X�J'�V

    �!/9�0 � �� .#�� � F' �"� ���!09��!O�%2� 2012 .(�O�

    �� � �#��#� N5� 2+N%V

  • 102 �,$ -7�� 8�0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    V�+�� ����� ,- ����� y�4%2� .�+*� ����� .'9��� �[email protected] >����R ) X�)��� $%&�� ����

    z*� �� � �!"#>�9�2!9 (�9� & ��+�0 ,- �����+*� ) %9 ��+._ A �# h!� ����

    7�� �' ��� .���� ��& � �!"#.*2!�

  • � ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� ������ ���� ����� 103 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    7��H)1 .(�$ J. #� (�� K�'�� G����L� !��B� M�+��

    ���$%&� '(� ) ��*�� S&�'T �)�

    F'( vWR� W��#6

    )FMOLS(

    +P%� )� .*2!� ) �

  • 104 �,$ -7�� 8�0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    ) ���$E

    )X���O0 1387(

    2004-1990

    �%?9 �� �!"#

    ) C�)� !DE

    h�T�� �%?9+�

    .*2!�

    N+0*� �� �)�%"J

    ).%��GMM(

    .� \'E ) �%?9 �� '�@�� �!1) S+�*

    N+B%V� ) �,i� +Y�� �

  • � ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� ������ ���� ����� 105 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    )g)�'��� 2013(1

    2007-1970

    ;4%�� �� �!"#

    ����� �����

    �*+,-

    >�*�� S&�'T �)�

    ) �

    %0# �*+,- ����� �� ��� �� �!"#

    .%�� .*2!� ./��� C� �+�|0 .'9�

    ����� �9�)� ) ��*

    1. Hattendorff

    2. Sarmidi and et al

    3. Yuxiang and Chen 4 Gerelmaa and Kotani

  • 106 �,$ -7�� 8�0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    ����!a� �,2��� '(� �� N

    F'��J.'9�

    )�79��!�2016(1

    2010-1985

    28 ����� �!"#

    �%?9 �����

    C+�O�GMM

    S&�'T ) �0%V+2

    .7T� )� >�*��

    )��2SLS(

    +Y�� �*+,- ����� �� SR�T '�@��

    �� ���$%&� '(� � �����*� ) �?��

    ��� ) ���� �2�� ��!� �� �!"#

    �)� �%J 89 �� �� ._+%9 ��

    ,%*� �+04� 67%4� .�2�

    ) ���:�

    )X���O0 1394(

    1389-1352

    ;4%�� � �!"#

    �%?9

    >�*�� S&�'T �)�

    .7T� .2)��3SLS(

    (N+B%V� Y�) �%?9 �� '�@�� �!)

    +Y�� �'�'�7� ) >'�

    �+�|0 .�V+9 � �!"# ��� ���$%&�

    �� d+9 �9�V9� .���2 ) ���$%&� ����@

    F��!#�� u)9 ) X��� �!"# )� >'�

    '(� � �����*� ) �,i� Y� >'�'�7� )

    .'9���

    ) ��!,5�

    )X���O0 1391(

    2010-1996

    ;4%�� � �!"#

    �%?9

    >�*�� S&�'T �)�

    ).%�� N+0*�EGLS(

    �!) �2�� ��!� �9��� F�)� �-

    ) �?�� +Y�� ����� �*+,- �����

    Y� ����� ���59 �+?+# d+9 ) �����*�

    ��� ���$%&� '(� � �����*� ) �,i�

    \'E ��0:�� .�2� F�!� � �!"#

    � �!) �� �B/�� ) ;2��� ��!a���� �

    .� [email protected] �� SR�T �� '�@�� ) �*+,-

    ���59 �+?+# s/2 X'�@ �+���

    A �# ZE�� k�- ����� ) F'(_��

    F'( � �!"# ��� ���$%&� '(� %"+�

    .�2�

    ) ��)��

    )X���O0 1390(

    2008-1970

    8 !DE �%?9 �!"#

    C�)�

    �� X� �+04�

    N+0*� �� �)�%"J

    ) .%��GMM

    ) �*+,- ����� �!) X�+� �?�� ./���

    A��d�) ���$%&� '(�GDP (.9�2

    .���� �!1)

    1 Youmanli

  • � ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� ������ ���� ����� 107 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    ���$%&� '(� ) �*+,- ����� �!) �+� ./��� �� �

    G�2� � .���� �!1) �2�� ��!� F�)�

    ��� �� �"4� '9�!� �� � �!1) �[email protected] �+� >'�'�7� ) �,i� �I%V,0

    '(� ) .���2 ^�VT ���2���@ ) ����

    �!"# �� �!"# ��� ���$%&� DE!

    ) ���O0 X����2 .*2!� �,V9 ���$%&�

    +� �� �!"# .�!DE���O0 X����2 )

    �� A��d� %"+� ���$%&� .*2!��.'��

    ) �9�9�5

  • 108 �,$ -7�� 8�0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    )��!12015(1 2011-1991

    �%?9 �� �!"#

    >�*�� S&�'T �)�

    )�

    k�- �� '(� � �?�� +Y�� ����� �9�)�

    ��# ) ��2 +Y�� .# ��Y�

    '(�� %J�d�

    X�J'�V�!9 ��)@�J : �,��

    X�0 �� F' �"� e�� h)'1 �� .# �!- �� �!"# �� �?7%4� ��_� >�*�9�2!9 �!"# Sa�� �� �� .*�9�2!9 �+� ./��� N .*

  • � ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� ������ ���� ����� 109 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    : e�� .�*

  • 110 �,$ -7�� 8�0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    ) ��� ���9�!�) ���89 �� X�!� �� ��

    .+

  • � ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� ������ ���� ����� 111 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    _�� '9�!� �� �'(�� ��!0E�!( ���$%&� '(� ��!B� .� �X���O0 ) �9�VT�)1395 .(

    A�E!:!� �� �O� X�!�E .� d+9 ���$%&� '(� ) ���_� X�!���� .1�� �+� ./���

    ��� �� �'�'1 ^!c��c �� X)�� '(� ��!� .�2� v/� ���$%&� >�*

    �9�51 N � �� ._+%9 �� .��J >��_� X���%( ;,2 X'( '(� ���$%&� �� G�+B�

    �9�51 �� X�!���� �� �+�|0 .��J �>����) k�- �� ) ���_� ��8%9� �� �)� �� k�-

    >����) �e�# .���2 �� �� � ��)@ �.%"+� h�B%9� � ��)@ Sa�� .� A��d� � �!"#

    .1!� �� d+9 >�*

    .��!I��_� X�!� ��� +Y�� �G�#!< �9�V9� .���2

    ����$%&� .'� � �� ��& S+7r� ) .�d_� ��!� '(� '9'B%*� C+2W#!9 ) C+2W# X�9

    ;1!� ) �2� ���$%&� .*2!� ) '(� .#r� �!�!� ���_� X�!���� .1�� A��d� .#

    ��) F5� ) ���J j$4� s/2 A��d� k�- �� � �!"# ��$%&� ���I0 A��d�

    �� ���$%&� '(� ) ��$%&� X�!���� .1�� �+� ./��� �!1) ��� �� .�!( �� � �!"#

    � �� �!"# X�VO� SO( .� '+)�?� �7E .� 67%4

    �O+9��)�2� .%(�� ���$%&� '(� � �?�� +Y�� � �!"# �� �a� �� �� ) F�!,91 �2003 .(

    ŋ� )�� ) (X��� ���_� +P%�) X��� >�Y� ) �*/B� ���Y >�Y� I9�+� ;+�� .�(� !I�9�2!9 � ��JY� �+J

    1. Yanikkaya

  • 112 �,$ -7�� 8�0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    �2� F+� ) �u!

    ) .

  • � ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� ������ ���� ����� 113 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    �?%2� ��!� �� ��d�� {!9 S+�*�� S&�'T �)� �� F� �2� �O0� ���

    .'�@ �2'� ���J��2�9 U��%9 ) '9!( ��)@� %J�d� ��+04� ;��: f9����).� ./��� S+

  • 114 �,$ -7�� 8�0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    �� .# ���� �I%V� � ��d�� ) �/a >W01 �

  • � ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� ������ ���� ����� 115 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    �2� �*/B� �I%V��) �!1) �2�� '����+9 ��1�%�!R �� .�2� F'( F��

    F��� �� �*/B� �I%V��)�)� �� F��?%2� ��,+#� �� F��� 'T�) ."�� \!2� �� ��

    !c ) �+< ���!< X!��@ +89 �,+#�1)LIC�+( ) X�V� �N�� �(2)IPS {!&) h�0%T� �(

    X!��@ SO"� ��� �� ��� .��� ' �!a A��d� �� ^3�# 'T�) ."�� U��%9 ."�� �� 'T�)

    F��� ."�� X!��@ .# �2� F'( ��5�"+� �*/B� �I%V��) �!1) �� ��'*%� �,+#� ��

    )X�V� 'T�)CIPSU��%9 .�2� .701 [email protected] �� (3 ��� X�V� �*/B� �I%V��) X!��@

    F��� �� �-�B� �+� �I%V��) �!,9 � ��,� ?R .+: .# ��� X�"9 .*)�+( ) X�V�IPS,2003 F���@ �9�r� ���B� .�2� (t-bar )X�V� .�2� F'( .,2�r� X�V� Q2!�2007 �� (

    X!��@ S�',� �� IPS )ADF X�'B �� �!1) �2�� ��� �9!��@ F���@ C���*/B� �I%V��) �%J 89 �� )

    X!��@ .� .# �2� F��� ��5�"+� �-�B� �+� �I%V��) �%J 89 �� .� ) 'T�) ."��CIPS .�2� g)*� X�V�

    :�2� �� >�!R .� X!��@ ��� F���@

  • 116 �,$ -7�� 8�0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    .'�'�7� �� �,+#� �� X��!%��9 d+9�� � !m�# X!��@ .�2� F'( F��?%2� !m�# X!��@ �� �'�(

    SI9� �)� G�2�-.7T� )� _9JF��� ��d1� ��I0 ) �2� �� �� �I%(�,9� N X!��@ \�_9� �� �� ��!7��� ��

    �� 89 X!��@ �� F��?%2� �� ��I%(�,9� N ./��� �!1) \'E �� �V���,E .# X!��@ ��� �� ?R .+: .�+JADF

    ���� �2�!(

  • � ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� ������ ���� ����� 117 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    7��H)2.( ���)�9���0H (����P�� �%�*$� ��

    X!��@ F���@ !I

  • 118 �,$ -7�� 8�0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    7��H)3.( � ���� ������ �2� ����� �L$� � ���� ���� !"� � #&F� ��#$

    ������ �� �����

    +P%� !I

  • � ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� ������ ���� ����� 119 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    )01/0( )030/0( )02/0(

    AR(2) 18/3-

    )58/0(

    88/2-

    )67/0(

    91/2-

    )97/0(

    � �!"# ��'*� 11 11 11

    >�' �"� S# ��'*� 100 92 92

    h�0%T� .�2� F'( .m��� d%9�� �� d+9 ;��: .� !�� h�0%T� ���B� ) �#�� Sa�� �� �+04� ��/a ��+*� g�r9�

    F���@ .� !��.�2� F'( .m��� d%9�� �� d+9 �I%V,0 �!a X!��@ ) X�J��2 �'

  • 120 �,$ -7�� 8�0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    F�)� �� ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 .# �,i� +Y�� +P%� ��� ���1 F�)� >�9�2!9 � S,& ��

    ��� .�

    X�2!9 � �?9 .�9�2!9 ��� �� � �!"# ��� �� �2� A�#�) (� �!"# ��� �� �%?9 �� '�

    ;[email protected] S�e� ��%05� �� �O� .'�(�� .%(�'9 �,2��� >�9�2!9 �� � �!"# ��� ���

    ��� �!"# .�2� � �!"# ��� ��9�2!9 +Y�� ) �'�7 ���0+� F'�'�� � �� �

    �� F'�@ �2� .� ._+%9 ��� S�e� I�� �*+,- ����� �� '�@�� X�2!9 .�# X�!�E X�!�

    �0+& ��!0E s/2 >�9�2!9 �� �!"# ��� �� X'�@ �!1!� ) �(�� ' �!a F�0 .� �� �

    �� SR�T �9��+0-�9 �0+& ��!0E s/2 � �!"# ��� �� ���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 ZE�� �

    ���)'r� ���V ) �9�� �!1) X!|0 �7��!E .'( ' �!a ���1 ^�VT �� �!1!� ��

    �� F'�@ �2� .� ._+%9 ��� � Y!� S��!E I�� �� �� � �!"# ��� �� .���2 �� )� X�!

    2� .� ._+%9 ��� .�# ��'07& U��%9 �� F'�@ � .*

  • � ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� ������ ���� ����� 121 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    .1�!� �I%V��) ) C�)� !DE �� ) �%?9 �� '�@�� .� �[email protected] y��4� ._+%9 �� ) � �!"# ���

    .� .1!�.# ��� �� ^!Vr� ��$%&� S# ��:�B� �d1� ��� N5� �� �O� ��9�2!9 �+� ./��� �?J X�!� �� ������ �

    ��� �� �

    �� �2�� ��!� F�)� �- ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 � ��$%&� X�!� ��� .1�� +P%� +Y��

    F'�@ �2'� ._+%9 ��� .�2� �����*� d+9 ����@ �r< .� ) �,i� C�)� !DE �� �!"#

    ��!� F�)� �- C�)� !DE �� �!"# �� ��$%&� ���� .1�� A��d� .# �2� ��� I9�+�

    >�9�2!9 .� �2���� .�2� F�� ���� � �!"# ��� �� ���$%&� '(� G�2� � �?J X�!�

    F��59 �+?+# �!,5� ) {!�� ��_�� k�- �� ��$%&� X�!� ��� ��d9)�� '(� �� !I�Y� �!,5� ��u!

    �� >�V2!� ) � ��59 %"+� .c .*2!� .# N%V+2 ��@��# A��d� �7# �!- .� ) �<

    �� �

  • 122 �,$ -7�� 8�0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    X!|0 �7��!E k�-

    J��#+� ;2��� f� � ��'9� ��'9�!� P%� >�9�2!9 A �# ��+� � ��$%&� XW#� �� )

    %9+._ ��$%&� '(�� .'(�� Y!�

    :�; P%�+ 7��*�� � X�2!9 ,� ./����?9 .

  • � ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� ������ ���� ����� 123 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    !DE �� �!"# �� ./��� ��� �� ��9�2!9 � A )H�2016-2005

    ��� ) �2� �����*� ) �,i��+2) X�2!9 �%?9 ����� ����� �� �!"# .# �� .+: �� ��

    ���$%&� '(� 9 ���� .�_� X�(�� '+mt� �'��#�_� U��%9 .� .1!� �� �+�|0 .'�# ��

    '(� X�2!9 � ����� �!) �� �(�9 X�2!9 A �# � ��EW-� ��)@

    ��/E� ) X�J'9+J \�) ��!� ��Fu)� G�2� � >W+5V�j+$4� ��'+���

    .���2 .� �O9�����J X���J F�2 �� �9!9�& ���0T A��d� ��� h�P%(� ) ������� ��

    �� ��V2!� ) � C9�� �� ���J F�2 .� �[email protected] k�!"� ) �+?+# A��d� �� '9�!�

  • 124 �,$ -7�� 8�0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    .# C�)� !DE �� �!"# �� ��V2!� ) � C9���� N%V+2 �� �08E� A4�[email protected] �< �

    C9�� ���� S+O"� � .'(�� Y!� �'� �

    X$�6�

    - Acemoglu, D., Johnson, S. (2005). Unbundling institutions. Journal of

    Political Economy.113(5), 949–995.

    - Adeniy, O., Abimbola, O., Omisakin, O. & Egwaikhide, F. (2015). Financial

    development and economic growth in Nigeria: Evidence from threshold

    modelling. Economic Analysis and Policy, 47, 11–21

    - Arellano, M., Bond, S. (1991). Some tests of specification for panel data:

    Monte Carlo evidence and an application to employment equations. Review of Economic Study, 58(2), 277–297.

    - Arellano, M., Bover, O. (1995). Another look at the instrumental variable

    estimation of error-components models. Journal of Economics, 68(1), 29–51.

    - Arezki, R., vander Ploeg, F. (2011). Do natural resources depress income

    per-capita? Review Development Economics, 15, 504–521.

    - Asadi, Z., Bahrami, J. & Taleblo, R. (2013). Effect of resource curse on financial development and economic growth in the form of dynamic panel

    data model. Quarterly Journal of Economic Growth and Development,3(10)

    (In Persian). - Asari, A., Naseri, A. & Aghaei, M. (2008). Financial development and

    economic growth: comparing OPEC and non-OPEC developing countries.

    Quarterly Journal of Economic Research, 43 (82), 141-161 (In Persian). - Baltagi, B. (2005). Econometric Analysis of Panel Data, Third edition, John

    Wiley & Sons Ltd, London.

    - Beck, T. (2011). Finance and oil: is there a resource curse in financial

    development? European Banking Center Discussion Paper, 2011–004.

    - Beck, T., Lundberg, M. & Majnoni, G. (2006). Financial intermediary

    development tends growth volatility: do intermediaries dampen or magnify

    shocks? Journal of international money & finance, 25(7), 1146–1167.

    - Behbodi, D. & Asgharpor, H. & Mahalgo, N. (2012). The Role of

    institutional quality on the relationship between natural resources and economic growth in petroleum economies. Quarterly Journal of Economic

    Research and Policy, 62, 95-116 (In Persian).

    - Brückner, M. (2010). Natural resource dependence, non-tradable, and economic growth. Journal of Comparative Economics, 38(4),461–471.

    - Bittencourt, M. (2012). Financial development and economic growth in

    Latin America: is Schumpeter, right? Journal of Policy Modeling, 34, 341–355.

    - Blundell, R., Bond, S. (1998). Initial conditions and moment restrictions in

  • � ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� ������ ���� ����� 125 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    dynamic panel data models. Journal of Economics, 87(1), 115–143.

    - Bongini, P., Trivellato, P. & Zenga, M., (2016). Financial Literacy and Undergraduates. Application of Latent Regression Rasch Model. Journal of

    Financial Management, Markets and Institutions, 3(1), 13-30

    - Bound, J., Jaeger, D.A., Baker, R.M. (1995). Problems with instrumental

    variables estimation when the correlation between the instruments and the

    endogenous explanatory variable is weak. Journal of the American Statistical

    Association, 90(430),443–450.

    - Chudika, A., Pesaran, M. (2015). Common correlated effects estimation of

    heterogeneous dynamic panel data models with weakly exogenous repressors.

    Journal of Econometrics, 188(2), 393-420. - Durusu-Ciftci. D, Ispir, M. & Serdar, Yetkiner. H. (2016). Financial

    development and economic growth: Some theory and more evidence. Journal

    of Policy Modeling, In Press, Corrected Proof. - Ehsani, M., Karimi, S. & Jafarisamimi, A. (2016). The Impact of Public

    Expenditures Reallocation on Long-Run Economic Growth in Iran. Journal

    of Economics and Modeling, 28(7), 55-84

    - Elhannani, F., Boussalem, A. & Benbouziane, M. (2016). Financial

    development and the oil curse: Evidence from Algeria. Topics in Middle

    Eastern and North African Economies, 18(1).

    - Farooq, A., Shahbaz, M., Arouri, M. & Teulon, F. (2013). Does corruption

    impede economic growth in Pakistan? Economic Modeling, 35(0), 622–633.

    - Gerelmaa, L., Kotani, K. (2016). Further investigation of natural resources

    and economic growth: Do natural resources depress economic growth? Resources Policy, 50, 312–321.

    - Gylfason, T., Zoega, G. (2006). Natural resources and economic growth: the

    role of investment. World Economy, 29, 1091–1115.

    - Hassan, M.K., Sanchez, B. & Yu, J.S. (2011). Financial development and

    economic growth: new evidence from panel data. The Quarterly Review of

    Economics and Finance, 51 (1), 88–104.

    - Hattendorff, C. (2013). The Natural Resource Curse Revisited: Is There a

    Financial Channel? Economic Development and Technological Change, D10-

    V3. - Hsiao, C. (1986). Panel Data Analysis - Advantages and Challenges.

    Sociedad de Estadistica e Investigaci on Operativa, 00(0), 1–63.

    - Morad beige, M., Hook Law, S. (2016). Growth volatility and resource curse: Does financial development dampen the oil shocks. Journal of resources

    policy, 48, 97-103.

    - Islam, M. (1995). Growth Empirics: A Panel Data Approach. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 110(4), 1127–1170.

    - Kaouther Gazdar., Kabir, H,. (2016). Oil price volatility, Islamic, and

    Economic Growth in GCC countries, Public Policy Discussion Paper, Federal

    Reserve bank of Boston. 04-6

  • 126 �,$ -7�� 8�0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    - Kurronen, S. (2015). Natural resources and capital structure. BOFIT

    Discussion Papers 10/2016. - Makian, S. N. A., Ezadi, M. (2015). The investigation the relationship

    between financial development and economic growth. Quarterly Journal of

    Iranian Economic Research, 20(62) (In Persian).

    - Ouoba, Y. (2016). Natural resources: Funds and economic performance of

    resource-rich countries, Resources Policy, 50, 108–116

    - Pesaran, M. (2004). General diagnostic tests for cross section dependence in

    panels. Discussion Paper No. 1240.

    - Rachdia, H., Saidib, H. (2016). Democracy and Economic Growth: Evidence

    in MENA countries. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 191, 616 – 621.

    - Raghuram, G., Rajan, Zingales, L. (2003). The great reversals: the politics

    of financial development in the twentieth centur. Journal of Financial Economics, 69 (11) 5–50.

    - Ramez, A. Lean, H. Smythb, R. (2016). Oil curse and finance–growth nexus

    in Malaysia: The role of investment. Energy Economics 57, 154–165.

    - Rezai, M., Yavari, K., Ezati, M. & Etesami, M. (2015). The investigation of

    Frequency of natural resources (oil and gas) on financial repression and

    economic growth from channel affecting income distribution. Quarterly

    Journal of Iranian Economic Energy. 4(14), 89-122 (In Persian).

    - Sachs, J.D., Warner, A.M. (1999). The big push, natural resource booms and

    growth. Journal of Development Economics, 59 (1), 43–76.

    - Sachs, J.D., Warner, A.M., (2001). The curse of natural resources. European Economic Review, 45, 827–838.

    - Sarmidi, T., Hook, L.S., Jafari, J. (2013). Resource Curse: New Evidence on

    the Role of Institutions. International Economic Journal, MPRA Paper, 37206,

    posted 9.

    - Shahabadi, A., Sadghi, H. (2013). Comparison of the effect of Frequency of

    natural resources on economic growth in Iran and Norway. Quarterly Journal

    of Economic Modeling. 7(2), 21-43 (In Persian).

    - Soltani, B., Amiri, B. (2009). Financial development and economic growth

    in case of developing countries. Quarterly Journal of Quantitative Economy (former Economic Investigations). 6(4) (In Persian).

    - Spatafora, N., Tytell, I., (2009). Commodity Terms of Trade: The History of

    Booms and Busts. IMF Working Paper No. 09/205. - Van der Ploeg, F., &Poelhekke, S. (2010). The pungent smell of "red

    herrings": Subsoil assets, rents, volatility and the resource curse. Journal of

    Environmental Economics and Management, 60(1), 44-55. - Vander Ploeg, F., Poelhekke, S. (2009). Volatility and the Natural Resource

    Curse. Oxford Economic Papers, 61(4), 727–760.

    - Yanikkaya, Halit,. (2003). Trade openness and economic growth: a cross-

    country empirical investigation, Journal of Development Economics, 7257– 9.

  • � ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� ������ ���� ����� 127 _____________________________________________________________________________________

    - Yavari, K., Rezagholizadeh, M. & Aghaei, M. (2011). The investigation of

    economic growth in countries related to natural resources (with emphasis on oil resources). Quarterly Journal of Economic Modeling. 3(5), 25-64 (In

    Persian).

    - Yuxiang, K., Chen, Z. (2011), Resource abundance and financial

    development: Evidence from China, Resources Policy, 36, 72–79.